These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page123Next page
 

Corvidae Club Social Night!

Author
Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#21 - 2012-11-09 21:10:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Tiberious Thessalonia
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
I'm not sure you know what Vitoc is.


Maybe I don't. I thought it was something that required both regular doses and a regular antidote, which is named Vitoc. I don't know if the poison has a name outside of Amarr space. Apparently it's a single injection, or at least that's what GalNet says. Theories about a hemorrhagic virus? I doubt you'll tell me anything useful.


Actually I will. Vitoc is a treatment for a virus called Vitoxin. The Vitoxin method is one of many slave-control methods employed by certain holders in the Amarr Empire. In it, they expose the slave to Vitoxin which immediately begins rewriting the genetic code of the exposed, so that it becomes a permanent part of their lives.

Vitoc is administered at whatever required dosage is needed. It happens, as a side effect, to contribute to feelings of contentment, a general lowering of intelligence while under the effects, and other such things which are useful to the slave holder. In essence, in contains both the carrot, and the stick, of the slave control equation.

More technical details are available on GalNet, and mostly I tell you this because I see a lot of people who think that Vitoc is the problem, and there is a major problem that comes up where erstwhile freedom fighters, occasionally, will come on IGS and crow about how they destroyed a shipment of Vitoc...

...and therefore condemned the people they are trying to save to a horrible, agonizing death.


And is the use of Vitoxin to enslave people written in the Amarr Bible?


The what?

Edit: If you're referring to scripture, the use of Vitoxin is usually justified through the scriptural doctrine that God gave the Amarr all the stars and stewardship over everyone in them, to bring them to God, coupled with the proscription that it is through suffering that one is freed from their chains, along with the generally accepted idea that salvation is multigenerational.

I don't agree with it; I'm not really an Amarrian anymore. However, you'll do better for yourself if you actually make an effort to think like Amarrians when dealing with Amarrians, rather than just trying to dismiss them as Evil Slavers.
Leopold Caine
Stillwater Corporation
#22 - 2012-11-09 22:22:46 UTC
I think both of you should shut up if you are not planning to attend the actual event.
If you do plan to, that will make the discussion much more enjoyable. Just saying.
  • Leopold Caine, Domination Malakim

Angels are never far...

Stillwater Corporation Recruitment Open - Angel Cartel Bloc

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#23 - 2012-11-09 22:26:04 UTC
I rather thought I was helping the lady Meiyi by taking the responsibility of explaining things to Mr. En Welle, but point taken.
Leopold Caine
Stillwater Corporation
#24 - 2012-11-09 22:32:55 UTC
Thank you.
  • Leopold Caine, Domination Malakim

Angels are never far...

Stillwater Corporation Recruitment Open - Angel Cartel Bloc

Lia Suchong
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#25 - 2012-11-10 12:27:24 UTC
Due to unforseen circumstances, the Social Night and auction is postponed.

Please excuse any inconvenience caused.

Fly safe. Big smile
Gussarde en Welle
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#26 - 2012-11-10 14:07:20 UTC
Lia Suchong wrote:
Due to unforseen circumstances, the Social Night and auction is postponed.

Please excuse any inconvenience caused.

Fly safe. Big smile



And here I was all ready to start bidding at 50M!
Natalcya Katla
Astropolitan Front
#27 - 2012-11-10 18:36:39 UTC
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
"Our" "internment camps"? Clearly you have never set foot on Intaki or any of our home systems.


I, on the other hand, have been to Intaki V (against my will, I might add), and I find "internment camp" to be a quite fitting description of the place.
Gussarde en Welle
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#28 - 2012-11-10 20:10:54 UTC
Natalcya Katla wrote:
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
"Our" "internment camps"? Clearly you have never set foot on Intaki or any of our home systems.


I, on the other hand, have been to Intaki V (against my will, I might add), and I find "internment camp" to be a quite fitting description of the place.


You're a former TSF member and were also apparently taken into custody? You were probably in an open-air work-detention compound constructed for offworlders. They are not meant to be pleasant, and the Intaki people do not look kindly on members or supporters of Sansha's Nation.
We do not run humane and comfortable imprisonment facilities like the Gallente do. Nor are they the barren, functional cells of the Amarr or Caldari. Our prisons are filthy and dangerous, and are meant to be.
Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#29 - 2012-11-10 20:29:34 UTC
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
You're a former TSF member and were also apparently taken into custody? You were probably in an open-air work-detention compound constructed for offworlders. They are not meant to be pleasant, and the Intaki people do not look kindly on members or supporters of Sansha's Nation.
We do not run humane and comfortable imprisonment facilities like the Gallente do. Nor are they the barren, functional cells of the Amarr or Caldari. Our prisons are filthy and dangerous, and are meant to be.


That you go out of your way to be inhumane to prisoners, and appear to be proud of the fact, is deeply troubling. I wonder what your Ida says about such practices.
Gussarde en Welle
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#30 - 2012-11-10 22:35:30 UTC  |  Edited by: Gussarde en Welle
Scherezad wrote:
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
You're a former TSF member and were also apparently taken into custody? You were probably in an open-air work-detention compound constructed for offworlders. They are not meant to be pleasant, and the Intaki people do not look kindly on members or supporters of Sansha's Nation.
We do not run humane and comfortable imprisonment facilities like the Gallente do. Nor are they the barren, functional cells of the Amarr or Caldari. Our prisons are filthy and dangerous, and are meant to be.


That you go out of your way to be inhumane to prisoners, and appear to be proud of the fact, is deeply troubling. I wonder what your Ida says about such practices.



Scherezad, please. We do not actively seek for offworld prisoners to be miserable. It is their choice to do with the prison grounds as they wish. We simply provide four walls, food and water, tools, and bedding to each prisoner. It is up to them to choose to use these gifts in the best way possible by working with each other. If all offworld prisoners practiced Ida, they could live quite content lives within the prison. We do not guard the interior of the prison because it is considered to be a danger to the guards, morally and physically. Therefore we leave prisoners to do as they wish within the prison, to themselves and others.

We know that this arrangement will make prison life hard because offworlders are rarely gentle with each other, but those that leave the prison have terrible tales to tell others and thereby will help us minimize suffering by stopping crimes before they start.

The few times I personally have had to detain someone, I was very humane, but I do not run the offworld prison system back home.
Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#31 - 2012-11-11 00:43:38 UTC
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
Scherezad wrote:
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
You're a former TSF member and were also apparently taken into custody? You were probably in an open-air work-detention compound constructed for offworlders. They are not meant to be pleasant, and the Intaki people do not look kindly on members or supporters of Sansha's Nation.
We do not run humane and comfortable imprisonment facilities like the Gallente do. Nor are they the barren, functional cells of the Amarr or Caldari. Our prisons are filthy and dangerous, and are meant to be.


That you go out of your way to be inhumane to prisoners, and appear to be proud of the fact, is deeply troubling. I wonder what your Ida says about such practices.

Scherezad, please. We do not actively seek for offworld prisoners to be miserable. It is their choice to do with the prison grounds as they wish. We simply provide four walls, food and water, tools, and bedding to each prisoner. It is up to them to choose to use these gifts in the best way possible by working with each other. If all offworld prisoners practiced Ida, they could live quite content lives within the prison. We do not guard the interior of the prison because it is considered to be a danger to the guards, morally and physically. Therefore we leave prisoners to do as they wish within the prison, to themselves and others.

We know that this arrangement will make prison life hard because offworlders are rarely gentle with each other, but those that leave the prison have terrible tales to tell others and thereby will help us minimize suffering by stopping crimes before they start.

The few times I personally have had to detain someone, I was very humane, but I do not run the offworld prison system back home.

I'm afraid you've confused me, sir. So in saying that your prisons are meant to be filthy and dangerous, you meant that your prisons were not meant to be filthy and dangerous - these conditions are the prisoners' fault, and you have nothing to do with it? It sounds much more like you provide the simple necessities that we Caldari do, and then allow the prisoners do what they will with them. All I can say to this idea is that, as your people have taken away the freedoms of these prisoners, that makes your government their guardian, and their living conditions reflect very poorly upon the guardian indeed.

Why you would be proud of such an arrangement - of using horrible living conditions as a deterrent instead of doing something to help these people - is beyond me, sir. Perhaps I have misunderstood. If so, I apologize.
Gussarde en Welle
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#32 - 2012-11-11 02:56:31 UTC
Scherezad wrote:
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
Scherezad wrote:
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
You're a former TSF member and were also apparently taken into custody? You were probably in an open-air work-detention compound constructed for offworlders. They are not meant to be pleasant, and the Intaki people do not look kindly on members or supporters of Sansha's Nation.
We do not run humane and comfortable imprisonment facilities like the Gallente do. Nor are they the barren, functional cells of the Amarr or Caldari. Our prisons are filthy and dangerous, and are meant to be.


That you go out of your way to be inhumane to prisoners, and appear to be proud of the fact, is deeply troubling. I wonder what your Ida says about such practices.

Scherezad, please. We do not actively seek for offworld prisoners to be miserable. It is their choice to do with the prison grounds as they wish. We simply provide four walls, food and water, tools, and bedding to each prisoner. It is up to them to choose to use these gifts in the best way possible by working with each other. If all offworld prisoners practiced Ida, they could live quite content lives within the prison. We do not guard the interior of the prison because it is considered to be a danger to the guards, morally and physically. Therefore we leave prisoners to do as they wish within the prison, to themselves and others.

We know that this arrangement will make prison life hard because offworlders are rarely gentle with each other, but those that leave the prison have terrible tales to tell others and thereby will help us minimize suffering by stopping crimes before they start.

The few times I personally have had to detain someone, I was very humane, but I do not run the offworld prison system back home.

I'm afraid you've confused me, sir. So in saying that your prisons are meant to be filthy and dangerous, you meant that your prisons were not meant to be filthy and dangerous - these conditions are the prisoners' fault, and you have nothing to do with it? It sounds much more like you provide the simple necessities that we Caldari do, and then allow the prisoners do what they will with them. All I can say to this idea is that, as your people have taken away the freedoms of these prisoners, that makes your government their guardian, and their living conditions reflect very poorly upon the guardian indeed.

Why you would be proud of such an arrangement - of using horrible living conditions as a deterrent instead of doing something to help these people - is beyond me, sir. Perhaps I have misunderstood. If so, I apologize.


Again, allow me to clarify: I am explaining an aspect of Intaki culture; I am not a Prelator or Chair of the High Council. I have no power to change these things. But I was raised Intaki and, as a people, we dislike the interference of alien criminals.

Remember, these offworlders are almost always Sabik terrorists, Blood Raiders, Serpentis Thugs, Drug-Runners, Slavers or Sansha sympathizers. To even wind up in a detention camp, they had to commit a crime against the Intaki people within our borders. Tourists and visitors to Intaki would virtually never wind up in such a place unless they had bombed a marketplace or murdered a child or the like, so don't go thinking that these people are undeserving of punishment.

This level of gentle concern for humanitarian issues seems odd to me coming from a Caldari military pilot, Scherezad. The Caldari Commonlaw has provisions for expedited execution procedures of foreign capital offenders with no hope of a retrial. Most of the Megacorporations practice Trial without Jury and the Death Sentence for capital crimes. Do you seriously think that if I flew into Jita or Kigaso and exploded a bomb planetside or raided a passenger transport for slaves and then got arrested doing so, that the Caldari people wouldn't try and execute me in short order?

The Intaki do not practice the death sentence, and thus we give foreign prisoners a chance to survive and reform.
Natalcya Katla
Astropolitan Front
#33 - 2012-11-11 03:19:58 UTC
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
You're a former TSF member and were also apparently taken into custody? You were probably in an open-air work-detention compound constructed for offworlders. They are not meant to be pleasant, and the Intaki people do not look kindly on members or supporters of Sansha's Nation.


I am not and have never been a member of TSF. I am, however, affiliated with Naqam, who is in an alliance with TSF.

That's neither here nor there, though. My planetary experience on Intaki V was well before my acquaintance with Sansha's Nation. I was a child, dragged down onto the surface of that asphyxiating rock by a parent who insisted, against my protests, that it was time for me to familiarize myself with "my people", as she erroneously called them. I had never even been to a planet before, and had no desire to go to one, but there was nothing I could do.

The facility I was kept in was called a village. A cluster of primitive and shoddily constructed habitation modules with barely any life support systems installed, and with doors you had to physically push or pull to open. The air was unfiltered and stank of vegetation and animal droppings, and the habitation modules weren't even airtight, so you smelled it at night, too. There were animals walking around freely, rolling in mud, defecating on the ground, spreading filth everywhere, and other children playing with them as they did. How the whole place hadn't died from pestilence a long time ago was a mystery to me.

The air was filled with tiny, flying horrors I had never encountered before, but which I learned were called insects. They got everywhere, and at times I hardly dared to breathe for fear of inadvertently inhaling one. Some of them even sucked blood.

The worst part of it all was that constant, bone-grinding gravity. This was before I had any implants at all, not even synthetic muscle grafts, so I was completely defenceless against it. Only a day after I arrived, every muscle in my body was aching. I felt I was carrying aroud an extra person with me everywhere I walked. Every night, I woke up several times gasping for air, as my lungs struggled against that crushing force to pull that putrid air into them. There was no way at all to turn down the gravity setting and ease the discomfort. Only one way was down, only one way was up, and up was impossible to go. Until the day, weeks later, when I was finally able to board the shuttle and go back home to the station and a place fit for human life.

Even today, after having been through space battles, losing ships, losing bodies, waking up in new ones, those few weeks on the surface of Intaki V are still the most terrifying and unpleasant experience I have ever had.
Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#34 - 2012-11-11 05:04:26 UTC
Gussarde en Welle wrote:
Scherezad wrote:
I'm afraid you've confused me, sir. So in saying that your prisons are meant to be filthy and dangerous, you meant that your prisons were not meant to be filthy and dangerous - these conditions are the prisoners' fault, and you have nothing to do with it? It sounds much more like you provide the simple necessities that we Caldari do, and then allow the prisoners do what they will with them. All I can say to this idea is that, as your people have taken away the freedoms of these prisoners, that makes your government their guardian, and their living conditions reflect very poorly upon the guardian indeed.

Why you would be proud of such an arrangement - of using horrible living conditions as a deterrent instead of doing something to help these people - is beyond me, sir. Perhaps I have misunderstood. If so, I apologize.


Again, allow me to clarify: I am explaining an aspect of Intaki culture; I am not a Prelator or Chair of the High Council. I have no power to change these things. But I was raised Intaki and, as a people, we dislike the interference of alien criminals.

Remember, these offworlders are almost always Sabik terrorists, Blood Raiders, Serpentis Thugs, Drug-Runners, Slavers or Sansha sympathizers. To even wind up in a detention camp, they had to commit a crime against the Intaki people within our borders. Tourists and visitors to Intaki would virtually never wind up in such a place unless they had bombed a marketplace or murdered a child or the like, so don't go thinking that these people are undeserving of punishment.

This level of gentle concern for humanitarian issues seems odd to me coming from a Caldari military pilot, Scherezad. The Caldari Commonlaw has provisions for expedited execution procedures of foreign capital offenders with no hope of a retrial. Most of the Megacorporations practice Trial without Jury and the Death Sentence for capital crimes. Do you seriously think that if I flew into Jita or Kigaso and exploded a bomb planetside or raided a passenger transport for slaves and then got arrested doing so, that the Caldari people wouldn't try and execute me in short order?

The Intaki do not practice the death sentence, and thus we give foreign prisoners a chance to survive and reform.


I do not question any of the things you have stated above, sir. You are not a Prelate, and are not in a position to change these things. I'm sure you, personally, would be a humane and just warden. You misplace my concern, however - I'm sorry, I communicate poorly. Let me try to summarize the placement of my confusion.

You opened this discussion by saying that the prisons of your people are meant to be dangerous. You then stated that they weren't meant to be dangerous, but are instead meant to be civil, and it's only the prisoners who choose to be dirty and dangerous. Your third statement was to reinforce the criminality of these individuals to justify less-gentle treatment. Which of these positions is true, sir? Are your prisons meant to be dangerous and nasty, or is that a byproduct of the inmates' actions, in which you do not intervene? If the goal is survival and reform, why place them in danger? Why not simply reform them?

As for my own peoples' treatment of criminals. Execution is a sane option for those who wish to visit mass murder or enslavement on innocents, but is not the only option, and not he only one that the State pursues. This being said, we are selective on the punishment and rehabilitation we use. We would never drop them into a facility rife with disease and filled with violence, and we would never inject them with thermokinetic chemicals so that they burst into flames under the deluge of a crowd's roar. This is wasteful, inflammatory, and needlessly cruel.

I do not imply here that the Intaki would do these things. As I have said above, I'm not really clear on what your position is. I apologize if that construal was made.

As for the fact that I seem concerned with humanitarian issues whilst being a Caldari pilot. I am deeply concerned with humanitarian issues across the Cluster, and this is not at odds with my willingness to fight for the State. It is very, very possible to be compassionate while also being a soldier. There is no truer compassion than that shown to an enemy.
Gussarde en Welle
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#35 - 2012-11-11 08:13:40 UTC
Scherezad wrote:


You opened this discussion by saying that the prisons of your people are meant to be dangerous. You then stated that they weren't meant to be dangerous, but are instead meant to be civil, and it's only the prisoners who choose to be dirty and dangerous.



I was being glib. Also: Prisons built for offworlders are what I describe. We do not have what you would call "prison" for native Intaki. Offworlder prisons are meant to be punishment. The nature of the punishment is left to the prisoners themselves. We give them tools to make a tolerable life if they so choose. Few ever do. That is what I meant.

Scherezad wrote:


Your third statement was to reinforce the criminality of these individuals to justify less-gentle treatment. Which of these positions is true, sir? Are your prisons meant to be dangerous and nasty, or is that a byproduct of the inmates' actions, in which you do not intervene?



We provide all things necessary for survival but do not intervene in day-to-day affairs. That is left to the prisoners. In most but not all cases, the criminals make their lives and the lives of others awful.

Scherezad wrote:

If the goal is survival and reform, why place them in danger? Why not simply reform them?


We consider it an affront to the victims of crime that they and their countrymen be subjected to taxation so that offworlder criminals can be rehabilitated. This is considered to be increasing the overall suffering resulting from the original crime.

All prisoners have access on request to a priest, a physician and a paper copy of the 5 Golden Suthras.

Scherezad wrote:

As for my own peoples' treatment of criminals. Execution is a sane option for those who wish to visit mass murder or enslavement on innocents, but is not the only option, and not he only one that the State pursues.


...But it does pursue it and pursues it regularly for its own people, and even more so for foreigners. The Caldari reputation for punishment is somewhat more reknowned than the Amarrians for its severity and swiftness when it comes to offworld criminals.
Natalcya Katla
Astropolitan Front
#36 - 2012-11-11 10:41:34 UTC  |  Edited by: Natalcya Katla
Well, I had committed no crime at all, and I was still dragged down there. In fact, I have only committed one single crime in my life, and it was not against Intaki law. At least your "5 Golden Suthras" seem to be optional reading for your prisoners - they were not so for me. It was forced on me, along with the entire cultural label of "Intaki" itself.

In fact, through the Federal census system and CONCORD's standardized registration procedures for capsuleers, I am still considered to be Intaki by law, just because my original genetic makeup is one hundred percent Intaki. All my attempts to scrub that tacked-on identity off - even through genetic engineering - have proven to be utterly futile as far as the law is concerned. Since this ethnic label is freely available for anyone who wishes to look it up, I still on occasion have to defend myself against accusations that I belong to the culture.
Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#37 - 2012-11-11 16:56:23 UTC
Thank you for indulging my questions, sir.

Gussarde en Welle wrote:
I was being glib. Also: Prisons built for offworlders are what I describe. We do not have what you would call "prison" for native Intaki. Offworlder prisons are meant to be punishment. The nature of the punishment is left to the prisoners themselves. We give them tools to make a tolerable life if they so choose. Few ever do. That is what I meant.


I understand, sir. Thank you for your honesty.

Gussarde en Welle wrote:
...But it does pursue it and pursues it regularly for its own people, and even more so for foreigners. The Caldari reputation for punishment is somewhat more reknowned than the Amarrians for its severity and swiftness when it comes to offworld criminals.


We rarely distinguish greatly between foreigners and locals in our punishment of criminals. If anything, we are more variable in the punishments to our comrades when they betray us, but this is because we know more deeply the extent of their crimes and have more options for reply. A strict legal system is important, and should be applied uniformly. what it should not be is needlessly cruel.

I'm curious. Why do the Intaki treat offworlders so differently in their punishments?
Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#38 - 2012-11-11 16:57:28 UTC
Natalcya Katla wrote:
Well, I had committed no crime at all, and I was still dragged down there. In fact, I have only committed one single crime in my life, and it was not against Intaki law. At least your "5 Golden Suthras" seem to be optional reading for your prisoners - they were not so for me. It was forced on me, along with the entire cultural label of "Intaki" itself.

In fact, through the Federal census system and CONCORD's standardized registration procedures for capsuleers, I am still considered to be Intaki by law, just because my original genetic makeup is one hundred percent Intaki. All my attempts to scrub that tacked-on identity off - even through genetic engineering - have proven to be utterly futile as far as the law is concerned. Since this ethnic label is freely available for anyone who wishes to look it up, I still on occasion have to defend myself against accusations that I belong to the culture.


I'm very sorry for the unfortunate events of your past, ma'am. I hope that time and distance have eased those pains, and that your future will carry you further away from them.
Lia Suchong
Garoun Investment Bank
Gallente Federation
#39 - 2012-11-11 17:34:19 UTC
Okay why has this thread degenerated into yet another political argument?

I respectfully request you people take this elsewhere.

This is supposed to be a thread to promote a social night.

How in Gods Almighty Name did you manage to turn this into an argument?

Please, please, please, argue elsewhere.

Fly safe.
Gussarde en Welle
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#40 - 2012-11-11 18:37:49 UTC  |  Edited by: Gussarde en Welle
Natalcya Katla wrote:
Well, I had committed no crime at all, and I was still dragged down there. In fact, I have only committed one single crime in my life, and it was not against Intaki law. At least your "5 Golden Suthras" seem to be optional reading for your prisoners - they were not so for me. It was forced on me, along with the entire cultural label of "Intaki" itself.


I'm sorry you were made uncomfortable by your parent. We do have villages, but I have never been to a village that was as filthy or backward as you describe.
Previous page123Next page