These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Suggestion: Purchase skill points with PLEX

Author
Meisje
#41 - 2012-09-06 00:01:00 UTC
Awhile ago, CCP was toying with the idea of allowing a neural remap for plex, and the negative blowback from the player base was unprecedented. It was simply too close to what you're suggesting, which the bulk of the fan base clearly (and rightfully, imo) believes is a P2Win type scenario.

Thankfully, it's never going to happen. You're wasting your time.
Spr09
Abyssal Echoes
Invidia Gloriae Comes
#42 - 2012-09-06 00:14:14 UTC
oh HHHEEELLLLLLLLLLLLL no.

You obviously didn't think things through or use the search function.
Omnathious Deninard
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#43 - 2012-09-06 00:39:12 UTC
Benjamin Dixon wrote:
The fear of Infinite SP is reasonable. One way to address it would be to limit SP purchases to some reasonable number, perhaps 20 or 25 million.

You seriously expect that it would be "OK" to be able to purchase a years worth of skill points and there be no negative affects?
Let me guess you think 1 plex should by 5 mill skill points also huh. This is a very bad idea, and would hurt noobs a lot, it would never benefit them, and even if you thought that 2mill per plex (which is about how many skill points you get per month with implants and a good remap) would be OK NO one is going to pay $240 within there first month of playing just to get some extra skill points.
TL:DR no plex for sp, ever and yes I know I am like the 10th person to say this

If you don't follow the rules, neither will I.

Lucious Shazih
Doomheim
#44 - 2012-09-06 01:23:11 UTC
To the owner of this thread, I hate beating a dead horse but this one is just asking for it... NO! STFU! Play the game or buy another toon in the character Bazaar, then go lose expensive stuff with it in lowsec.

PS: When you redeem the PLEX to purchase your new character, make sure to do so in a random station far away from jita, then autopilot your way to jita in a shuttle so you can sell your plex and buy your toon using the newly acquired isk.
Alaekessa
Matari Combat Research and Manufacture Inc.
#45 - 2012-09-06 01:26:10 UTC
IDK if this has already been stated but:

GB2W
Zan Shiro
Doomheim
#46 - 2012-09-06 02:46:05 UTC
Omnathious Deninard wrote:
Benjamin Dixon wrote:
The fear of Infinite SP is reasonable. One way to address it would be to limit SP purchases to some reasonable number, perhaps 20 or 25 million.

You seriously expect that it would be "OK" to be able to purchase a years worth of skill points and there be no negative affects?



either he is trolling or not being jaded he does not know how how many aspects fo the game work. If a new player (i cba to e-stalk his char info) 14 billion isk sounds like alot of isk. To the multitude of bitter vets in the major alliance in titans and mommies....they had this isk laying around to say screw it, lets buy this. to those bitter vets who have not bought the big rigs, they may have this isk jsut sitting around most times, at least for the mommie anyway.

Sure as hell does not know hte 0.0 blobls wuold use this to crap out uber alts jsut like that. Dislodge the rich crews like goons or the russians with this in place....went from damn near impossible to forget about it. Tuesday they see they need 100 more BS after a battle, wednesday there they are all nice and dual boxing shiny.



OP...jsut do the grind. You get to where you need to be in time. And once there...you may find all those stepping stone ships you blew through will be the ships you like more later in life.

I know for me the" trash" frigates I left asap are now the ships I go to to make the game fun. If your goal is the uber BS to run in fleets....a good week or even month of almost pure pos bash will have you wishing for a BC or cruiser op to break up the living hell that is. Been there op.....also the reason why I am dragging ass on cap trains. POS rep ops don't get anymore exciting repping the pos than being the support fleet watching the carriers rep the pos. Either way....you are still there, watching a pos get repped. Dreads...its press f1 jsut likea bs. Stront powered siege mode not an omfg this is so much better change to me.
ugh zug
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#47 - 2012-09-06 03:52:55 UTC
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.

Want me to shut up? Remove content from my post,1B. Remove my content from a thread I have started 2B.

Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#48 - 2012-09-06 04:38:57 UTC
ugh zug wrote:
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.


Isk only gets you so far in this game... you can have the highest skillpoints in game, with the most pimped out ship fittings, and you'll still die to a bloodthirsty gang the same as a two week old newb.....

ugh zug
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#49 - 2012-09-06 04:47:34 UTC  |  Edited by: ugh zug
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:
ugh zug wrote:
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.


Isk only gets you so far in this game... you can have the highest skillpoints in game, with the most pimped out ship fittings, and you'll still die to a bloodthirsty gang the same as a two week old newb.....




and your point is? he or she still paid for it with rl cash, the fact that he or she died in a fire after the fact is IRRELEVANT.

Want me to shut up? Remove content from my post,1B. Remove my content from a thread I have started 2B.

Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#50 - 2012-09-06 04:52:10 UTC
ugh zug wrote:
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:
ugh zug wrote:
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.


Isk only gets you so far in this game... you can have the highest skillpoints in game, with the most pimped out ship fittings, and you'll still die to a bloodthirsty gang the same as a two week old newb.....




and your point is? he or she still paid for it with rl cash, the fact that he or she died in a fire after the fact is IRRELEVANT.


The fact that you can purchase a character off another player is IRRELEVANT to the op's proposal...

No characters get skillpoints for isk.... all characters earns sp at potentially the same rate... in real time...
Zan Shiro
Doomheim
#51 - 2012-09-06 05:08:43 UTC
ugh zug wrote:
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.



not really, I have know poeple better off in rl, massive gtc to plex conversions for a nice char already set to skip the grind undock and go boom.....several times. Can't fly a rfiter(t2 variant as well) worth a damn because you skipped them, vaga's are jsut a more expensive kill mail jsut as easy to claim.

Bitter vets....cahr bazaar no real edge either. they already have thier skills in place. Dead horse but its doing this game over time doing your grinds that makes you better at this game. If you roll with bitter vets you will see may times their edge is jsut experience. Give them a vanilla fits, vanilla tactics (which is what a noob will do usually) and chances are reall good they have seen this 100's of times before.

Fits and such....go full bore O fit for the win. At some point an instalock and/or bubble gate camp will claim that number. Many times in voice chat the silence was broken with a fuuuuuuuuuuuuu...... Dude wahts up? Just lost my hg crystal or some ungodly priced item in gate camp. Way it goes in eve. MOney can get you 10's of easy kills in a row. But at somepoint, you will be the loss and not the kill mail.
ugh zug
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#52 - 2012-09-06 05:29:12 UTC
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:
ugh zug wrote:
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:
ugh zug wrote:
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.


Isk only gets you so far in this game... you can have the highest skillpoints in game, with the most pimped out ship fittings, and you'll still die to a bloodthirsty gang the same as a two week old newb.....




and your point is? he or she still paid for it with rl cash, the fact that he or she died in a fire after the fact is IRRELEVANT.


The fact that you can purchase a character off another player is IRRELEVANT to the op's proposal...

No characters get skillpoints for isk.... all characters earns sp at potentially the same rate... in real time...


Okay, but it's still pay to win regardless how you paint it. there will always be characters for sale as long as there are people willing to fork out isk for them, saying they train at the same rate at everyone else is IRRELEVANT to the fact that you're still paying RL cash to get a WIN character.

if you don't like pay to win, then you should be protesting the character bazaar, and plex as a whole, because supporting either plex or character trading means you support pay to win by logic, or you're contradicting yourself.

So back to the op's suggestion if you support plex and character trading then you should not, by logic, have any argument against his suggestion, if you don't like pay to win then not only should you be against plex as a whole, but character trading as well, because supporting either plex or character trading would mean you'd be contradicting yourself.

Want me to shut up? Remove content from my post,1B. Remove my content from a thread I have started 2B.

ugh zug
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#53 - 2012-09-06 05:41:09 UTC  |  Edited by: ugh zug
Zan Shiro wrote:
ugh zug wrote:
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.



not really, I have know poeple better off in rl, massive gtc to plex conversions for a nice char already set to skip the grind undock and go boom.....several times. Can't fly a rfiter(t2 variant as well) worth a damn because you skipped them, vaga's are jsut a more expensive kill mail jsut as easy to claim.

Bitter vets....cahr bazaar no real edge either. they already have thier skills in place. Dead horse but its doing this game over time doing your grinds that makes you better at this game. If you roll with bitter vets you will see may times their edge is jsut experience. Give them a vanilla fits, vanilla tactics (which is what a noob will do usually) and chances are reall good they have seen this 100's of times before.

Fits and such....go full bore O fit for the win. At some point an instalock and/or bubble gate camp will claim that number. Many times in voice chat the silence was broken with a fuuuuuuuuuuuuu...... Dude wahts up? Just lost my hg crystal or some ungodly priced item in gate camp. Way it goes in eve. MOney can get you 10's of easy kills in a row. But at somepoint, you will be the loss and not the kill mail.



regardless of if they lost a shiny ship or not they paid for the ship with RL cash, they paid for the character with RL cash via gtc's. they paid for an advantage even if it didn't net them much or get them very far after undocking; it's still pay to win.

Want me to shut up? Remove content from my post,1B. Remove my content from a thread I have started 2B.

Tchulen
Trumpets and Bookmarks
#54 - 2012-09-06 09:36:20 UTC
ugh zug wrote:
Zan Shiro wrote:
ugh zug wrote:
we already have pay to win; plex will get you anything you want already, and people who say otherwise are simply fooling themselves.



not really, I have know poeple better off in rl, massive gtc to plex conversions for a nice char already set to skip the grind undock and go boom.....several times. Can't fly a rfiter(t2 variant as well) worth a damn because you skipped them, vaga's are jsut a more expensive kill mail jsut as easy to claim.

Bitter vets....cahr bazaar no real edge either. they already have thier skills in place. Dead horse but its doing this game over time doing your grinds that makes you better at this game. If you roll with bitter vets you will see may times their edge is jsut experience. Give them a vanilla fits, vanilla tactics (which is what a noob will do usually) and chances are reall good they have seen this 100's of times before.

Fits and such....go full bore O fit for the win. At some point an instalock and/or bubble gate camp will claim that number. Many times in voice chat the silence was broken with a fuuuuuuuuuuuuu...... Dude wahts up? Just lost my hg crystal or some ungodly priced item in gate camp. Way it goes in eve. MOney can get you 10's of easy kills in a row. But at somepoint, you will be the loss and not the kill mail.



regardless of if they lost a shiny ship or not they paid for the ship with RL cash, they paid for the character with RL cash via gtc's. they paid for an advantage even if it didn't net them much or get them very far after undocking; it's still pay to win.


By strict definition it isn't pay to win but then again neither is buying skill points. It's pay with cash. Nothing says that this will make you win. Usually it's actually the opposite as several people have pointed out.

Everything that you can currently buy with real money (or rather, plex) you can buy with isk.

You can't buy SP with isk at the moment. You shouldn't, therefore, be able to buy them with RL money (or plex).

Simples.

There are so many reasons to not allow buying SP with RL money or isk that it simply won't happen no matter how much you scream and whine. The reasons have been adequately documented in all the other "I want to not play the game because I'm rich and just want everything everywhere handed to me without effort" threads so I'm not going to reiterate here.
ugh zug
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#55 - 2012-09-06 10:54:00 UTC
Tchulen wrote:


By strict definition it isn't pay to win but then again neither is buying skill points. It's pay with cash. Nothing says that this will make you win. Usually it's actually the opposite as several people have pointed out.

Everything that you can currently buy with real money (or rather, plex) you can buy with isk.

You can't buy SP with isk at the moment. You shouldn't, therefore, be able to buy them with RL money (or plex).

Simples.

There are so many reasons to not allow buying SP with RL money or isk that it simply won't happen no matter how much you scream and whine. The reasons have been adequately documented in all the other "I want to not play the game because I'm rich and just want everything everywhere handed to me without effort" threads so I'm not going to reiterate here.



Tchulen, and many of the other players where are skewing the definition of paying 2 win to suit your argument. When you pay to win you're paying with real money for an advantage of any sort over other players, whether that be a new shiny ship, or a new character to skip training time. Buying a character with more SP then you currently have using GTC's is paying to win, buying a ship with GTCs, is paying to win. you're taking a shortcut and your paying RL money to do it.

Why do you say you cannot buy SP with ISK when it's already available through the character bazaar forum? gtc to plex to isk to new character with ton's of SP, pay to win. Furthermore, If you like plex, you like character trading, then logic would dictate that you would not have any valid arguments against the op's suggestion because you would be contradicting yourself.

I'm nether for or against the OP's suggestion, I'm simply making the point that EVE already has a pay 2 win system, and that anyone who says otherwise is woefully ignorant... The smell of the hypocritical wafting up in this thread is
stifling.

Want me to shut up? Remove content from my post,1B. Remove my content from a thread I have started 2B.

Tchulen
Trumpets and Bookmarks
#56 - 2012-09-06 11:09:59 UTC  |  Edited by: Tchulen
ugh zug wrote:

Tchulen, and many of the other players where are skewing the definition of paying 2 win to suit your argument. When you pay to win you're paying with real money for an advantage of any sort over other players, whether that be a new shiny ship, or a new character to skip training time. Buying a character with more SP then you currently have using GTC's is paying to win, buying a ship with GTCs, is paying to win. you're taking a shortcut and your paying RL money to do it.


I believe you're mistaken. A generally accepted definition of pay to win is "Games that let you buy better gear or allow you to make better items then everyone else at a faster rate and then makes the game largely unbalanced even for people who have skill in the game without paying."

CCP don't allow you to buy better anything with cash. All they allow you to do is exchange RL money for plex. Plex have various uses, one of which is to sell them for isk so someone else gets to carry on playing whilst you get isk which you can use to only buy things you could have bought with isk you'd made in game.

Therefore you're skewing the definition of pay 2 win to suit your argument.


ugh zug wrote:
Why do you say you cannot buy SP with ISK when it's already available through the character bazaar forum? gtc to plex to isk to new character with ton's of SP, pay to win. Furthermore, If you like plex, you like character trading, then logic would dictate that you would not have any valid arguments against the op's suggestion because you would be contradicting yourself.


I say you can't buy SP because you can't. You can buy a toon with all that entails but you simply cannot buy skill points. Again, you're skewing the definition to suit your argument.


ugh zug wrote:
I'm nether for or against the OP's suggestion, I'm simply making the point that EVE already has a pay 2 win system, and that anyone who says otherwise is woefully ignorant... The smell of the hypocritical wafting up in this thread is
stifling.


Yet again your skewing definitions to suit your argument. As I've explained already there is no pay to win system in EvE. CCP have been careful to avoid it, at least partially due to the players reaction when they merely thought it might happen.

Your sig says it all really. I'm sure you do neither agree nor disagree. You're just being contentious because you enjoy trolling people.
Higgs Maken
The Metal Box Company
#57 - 2012-09-06 13:08:30 UTC
Before coming to EVE I play wow. Wow is a game with a constant cycle of buff and nerf, there's always a FOTM class, there aren't shortage of players lvling the current OP class, sad to say most of them are one trick pony. Once you learn how to counter them, they are free flag. They are free flag because they didn't spend enough time learning the class.

If eve were to allow SP purchase, you would be just like those wow FOTM players. Yes you are flying your dream ship will all related skills at lvl 5 faster, but you won't beat those players who spend real time learning how to fly their ship.
Verminus
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#58 - 2012-09-13 18:42:37 UTC
Tchulen wrote:


I believe you're mistaken. A generally accepted definition of pay to win is "Games that let you buy better gear or allow you to make better items then everyone else at a faster rate and then makes the game largely unbalanced even for people who have skill in the game without paying."

CCP don't allow you to buy better anything with cash. All they allow you to do is exchange RL money for plex. Plex have various uses, one of which is to sell them for isk so someone else gets to carry on playing whilst you get isk which you can use to only buy things you could have bought with isk you'd made in game.

Therefore you're skewing the definition of pay 2 win to suit your argument.



Kinda sorta(btw urban dictionary is not a great reference) the real definition would be something along the lines of the ability to acquire any benefit in game with the use of real world currency. Be it XP gains/boosts, items, items that boost abilitys, pre leveled toons or in eve's case pre trained toons, etc.

With that in mind you may want to rethink your view on the character bazaar because it is a p2w avenue it is just limited.

I personally do not see an issue with plex = sp if the amount of sp that is gained per plex is limited as well as the total amount of sp gained via plex being limited. Say something like 6 plex = 5 million sp head start package can only be purchased one time per toon/account.

That way it is limited to not breaking the game but instead giving a little head start bump to new players if they desire and the same package would be available to vets to provide a little sp bump if they so choose just rename it.
Eve Austrene
SKYE Corporation
#59 - 2012-09-13 19:21:39 UTC
Most of people in this topic miss the point.

It is not about what you can do. It is about what you can't do.
Even with years of training, and buying characters you still will not be able to do everything in the game on your own. You have 20m skill point and can fly Minnie marauder - great. Can you fly caldarli logistics? Or ammar carrier? Or refine ore at max proficiency? Have perfect exploration skills? No you can't. Even if you excel at 2-3 fields you can't cover it all. You need help of others. That's just how world works. Ant this is what fosters relationship between players - mutual goals, needs and necessity to rely on each other. This is what makes EVE great.

By proposing buying SP for ISK you are breaking this system. This is why I say no.

Tbh you need only a couple of million sp to be a good frigate pilot, and you can contribute a lot to any combat, and fulfill important roles in fleet. You can get that easily in month or 2 of training. What you will not get is player experience which is much more important. So I say get into decent training corp, learn the ropes, and the we'll talk.
Akrasjel Lanate
Immemorial Coalescence Administration
Immemorial Coalescence
#60 - 2012-09-13 19:34:09 UTC
No

CEO of Lanate Industries

Citizen of Solitude