These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

Hulk not worth the investment?

Author
Zhilia Mann
Tide Way Out Productions
#21 - 2012-03-21 16:12:42 UTC
Alua Oresson wrote:
When the hulk was introduced you could make 100+mil/hr in null-sec mining in a battleship.


Yeah, but the damn things also ran half a billion ISK before invention. If you think they're expensive now, you should have seen it....
Alua Oresson
Aegis Ascending
Solyaris Chtonium
#22 - 2012-03-21 16:27:49 UTC
I did see it. I was there. It was so real. My hands were..... Oh wait.


I was there at the time though. I remember watching the 2 guys in my corp that had one in lust for one. They were clearing a **** load of isk while tanking spawns.

http://pvpwannabe.blogspot.com/

astara989
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#23 - 2012-03-21 16:41:35 UTC
Not hard to make 15mill/hour in highsec with an hulk. Also theie prices are just going up and up, meaning not only do you make money on your investment from higher yield, but also being able to sell it later on for more then you bought it for.

Also if you do it right, gank risk is fairly low.
Alavaria Fera
GoonWaffe
#24 - 2012-03-21 18:04:42 UTC
astara989 wrote:
Also if you do it right, gank risk is fairly low.

Heh, well that's a fairly big assumption to make sometimes, given people's mining habits.

Triggered by: Wars of Sovless Agression, Bending the Knee, Twisting the Knife, Eating Sov Wheaties, Bombless Bombers, Fizzlesov, Interceptor Fleets, Running Away, GhostTime Vuln, Renters, Bombs, Bubbles ?

MadMuppet
Critical Mass Inc
#25 - 2012-03-21 18:14:46 UTC
If you are soloing there is one minor miner difference. The cargo hold of a Covetor is 4000m3 and a Hulk is 8000m3 which even when you account for the 3 rigs vs 2 rigs is still over 4000m3 difference (assuming the lows are to be used for MLUs or DCs, if you use expanders the difference is even more). That means more time mining and less travelling.

This message brought to you by Experience(tm). When common sense fails you, experience will come to the rescue. Experience(tm) from the makers of CONCORD.

"If you are part of the problem, you will be nerfed." -MadMuppet

IGNATIUS HOOD
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#26 - 2012-03-21 20:19:09 UTC
T'Pawhl wrote:
Hey guys,

I finally finished training up for Hulk on my main and went out and bought one. It cost 220 million ISK. As I was mining with it, I was thinking about Hulkageddon. 220 million ISK is a pretty steep investment, so I decided to pick up a Covetor instead.

Well here's the funny thing, in my Covetor my yield is only a slight bit less. I put the numbers into EFit and even with max skills, I simply don't see a Hulk justifying the investment unless you're mining in blue SOV. I think with T2 crystals the differences was like 8500m3/hour. Which if you're mining Veldspar is only 1.3 million.

The difference is: A Covetor can pay for itself in a couple of days simply via mineral value. A Hulk would take a few weeks.

Unless I'm missing something. Thoughts?


I never saw the need for one nor the need to T2 my mining lasers. I use Covetors with the very real expectation they will go boom eventually. I do mine ABC in WH gravs though. Might think different if I was melting veld in a backwater with an Orca alt and a couple additonal mining alts to tag along.
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."   --H.L. Mencken
Joyelle
SludgeSlingers
#27 - 2012-03-21 21:44:34 UTC
20mil an hr is just sad. I won't even login for such activity tbh but hey, it has to be done.
Tanya Powers
Doomheim
#28 - 2012-03-21 23:16:25 UTC
Darthewok wrote:
Yes, Hulks are ridiculously overpriced for their profit making potential.
200mil hull cost to make 2-5mil ISK/hr in hisec or 10-20mil ISK/hr in null?
Compare that to 60-120mil for a level 4 mission BS that can easily make 10-30mil ISK/hr in hi-sec...



Hulks salvage is worth for much more than you can mine with.
Thing is that if you're still mining you are doing it wrong, ganking is much more profitable right now and this is good to raise minerals price, but if you still mine don't sell your minerals idiots !! -stock

Every time you are selling whatever amount of minerals right now you are just giving to those alliances, that already profit from your hulk salvage, the necessary minerals/ships at low cost so they can keep gank you and build Titas/supers for cheap.
The meanwhile you wine on forums that gank is not fair.

Open you eyes a little bit ^^
drdxie
#29 - 2012-03-21 23:33:41 UTC
If you not using T2 crystals on a Hulk, you be wasting time and isk....

Caldari Loving needed.. https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1608277&#post1608277

Tikera Tissant
#30 - 2012-03-22 06:29:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Tikera Tissant
Oh man I love the numbers in this thread
People don't know anything about mining and comparing it to missions.... geez Ugh

A covetor with T1 strip miners and no crystals, will do at best 8mil / hour, without having to warp to station to unload
If you have to go to station, you are looking at 6mil/hour at best

A hulk with T1 strip miners and no crystals, will only do about 500K / hour more than a covetor. So no freakin wonder the OP doesn't see the reason to use a hulk.... ("no s**t" meme fits right here)

A tanking hulk which can survive a single person gank, using T2 strip miners and crystals, will do about 2mil / hour more than a covetor
A non-tanking hulk which will not survive a gank, will do another 2mil / hour more to about 12mil / hour, even with having to jump to station, which is about twice as much as a covetor

A non-tanking hulk with good orca support, will do 20mil / hour (in practice, not theory numbers), 3 times the covetor the OP is most likely using. A tanking hulk will do 17mil / hour, also almost 3 times the covetor

So hulk not worth the hull? Please... use some brain cells with the 3rd grade math skills you used to know but now let them die slowly.
After a month of mining (about 1 hour a day), you can do the covetor income plus the cost of the hulk hull back, solo, compared to what the OP is using.

Its like using a nightmare to do the starter missions and complaining its not worth the money...

All of these numbers are in high-sec.
In low sec, the same setup can perform twice as much income an hour if you know what you are doing, even though with current prices of high-sec ores, you can do close to 30mil / hour mining in high-sec per hulk.

And comparint to missions? How many times people will keep doing that
Mining is a semi afk no-brain no-gaming skills profession
You don't shoot anything except astroids, you don't need to use your brain at all nor really pay attention to details (except ganker warning once in awhile)
Add mining with an indy alt, and its just as much of an income as missioning or even better

And unlike missiners, a miner doesn't need as many skills, and be almost max mining in about 45-50 days (excluding exhumer 5), while missioners will need to spend more time to skill for the right ship, for the best weapons, spend a few billions to get really geared up to steam roll missions enough to make those 30mil / hour.
Darthewok
Perkone
Caldari State
#31 - 2012-03-22 10:43:09 UTC
Tikera Tissant wrote:

And comparint to missions? How many times people will keep doing that
Mining is a semi afk no-brain no-gaming skills profession
You don't shoot anything except astroids, you don't need to use your brain at all nor really pay attention to details (except ganker warning once in awhile)
Add mining with an indy alt, and its just as much of an income as missioning or even better

And unlike missiners, a miner doesn't need as many skills, and be almost max mining in about 45-50 days (excluding exhumer 5), while missioners will need to spend more time to skill for the right ship, for the best weapons, spend a few billions to get really geared up to steam roll missions enough to make those 30mil / hour.


Your numbers seem about right.
Sure mining is good for semi-AFK-online.
Haha so many people playing EVE are not actually playing EVE actively but using it as some sort of semi-AFK activity.
Add this to the people just staying subscribed purely to skill train and ship-spin and EVE is like some sort of zombie trance online weirdland.

The amazing thing though is people training multiple accounts for Orca and Hulk, when if they just had 1 account and spent the money for the extra accounts to buy PLEX instead for ISK, in many cases they would make more ISK and not have to work as hard! Unless they lurve mining.
Also, it is true you can get decent mining faster than good level 4 missions skills. However, the problem is that after you get good level 4 missions skills, you can use those skills for PVP and in many other areas such as Incursions, WH, nullsec ratting.
Whereas mining skills are not very useful beyond mining.

Just some observations. Mine, don't mine, do whatever you like.

CAVEAT RICHARDUS VOLVERE - YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHg5SJYRHA0

Tikera Tissant
#32 - 2012-03-22 12:03:49 UTC
Darthewok wrote:

The amazing thing though is people training multiple accounts for Orca and Hulk, when if they just had 1 account and spent the money for the extra accounts to buy PLEX instead for ISK, in many cases they would make more ISK and not have to work as hard! Unless they lurve mining.


I'm not sure about that.

I'm making about 1.5bil a week from spending 9 hours in that week on mining with 6 accounts (4 hulks, orca, hauler) while I watch TV, and the rest of the few hours I have to play, I'm doing missions with some of my toons, exploration in WH/high sec. And I'm considering doing incursions as well with a toon or two. I'm also ganking once in awhile a hauler when I'm seriously bored from mining.
I also have two accounts doing PI (soon 3) and one doing research and menufacturing.

That pays off for all the accounts plus tons of spare for ships, modules, whatever.

I lost an orca in a WH a couple of months ago. It had a few sleeper salvage items, an extra ship.
I didn't tear up. Even talked to my killer in the WH for an hour, and even recieved an exit pass and a farewell.
I made that isk back within 2 days, and I still ended up ahead with profit at the end of the month.

I even lost a 900mil tengu in a mission once for being stupid (was more interested in the TV than remembering activating the shield module). That isk also returned and still more to spare.

Having several accounts defenitly doesn't mean having to spend your time making ISK just to pay them off.
You can easily make a lot more if you play it smart.
Darthewok
Perkone
Caldari State
#33 - 2012-03-22 14:17:23 UTC
Tikera Tissant wrote:
Darthewok wrote:

The amazing thing though is people training multiple accounts for Orca and Hulk, when if they just had 1 account and spent the money for the extra accounts to buy PLEX instead for ISK, in many cases they would make more ISK and not have to work as hard! Unless they lurve mining.


I'm not sure about that.

I'm making about 1.5bil a week from spending 9 hours in that week on mining with 6 accounts (4 hulks, orca, hauler) while I watch TV, and the rest of the few hours I have to play, I'm doing missions with some of my toons, exploration in WH/high sec. And I'm considering doing incursions as well with a toon or two. I'm also ganking once in awhile a hauler when I'm seriously bored from mining.
I also have two accounts doing PI (soon 3) and one doing research and menufacturing.

That pays off for all the accounts plus tons of spare for ships, modules, whatever.

I lost an orca in a WH a couple of months ago. It had a few sleeper salvage items, an extra ship.
I didn't tear up. Even talked to my killer in the WH for an hour, and even recieved an exit pass and a farewell.
I made that isk back within 2 days, and I still ended up ahead with profit at the end of the month.

I even lost a 900mil tengu in a mission once for being stupid (was more interested in the TV than remembering activating the shield module). That isk also returned and still more to spare.

Having several accounts defenitly doesn't mean having to spend your time making ISK just to pay them off.
You can easily make a lot more if you play it smart.


Haha 6 accounting while watching TV, EVE is indeed a strange game.
Sounds like you are the miner's version of winning EVE so more power to you!
I have no objections to more multi-account mining fleet players anyway.
Someone has got to mine and keep those pew pew ships affordable.

CAVEAT RICHARDUS VOLVERE - YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHg5SJYRHA0

T'Pawhl
Doomheim
#34 - 2012-03-22 15:06:00 UTC
Tikera Tissant wrote:
Oh man I love the numbers in this thread
People don't know anything about mining and comparing it to missions.... geez Ugh

A covetor with T1 strip miners and no crystals, will do at best 8mil / hour, without having to warp to station to unload
If you have to go to station, you are looking at 6mil/hour at best

A hulk with T1 strip miners and no crystals, will only do about 500K / hour more than a covetor. So no freakin wonder the OP doesn't see the reason to use a hulk.... ("no s**t" meme fits right here)

A tanking hulk which can survive a single person gank, using T2 strip miners and crystals, will do about 2mil / hour more than a covetor
A non-tanking hulk which will not survive a gank, will do another 2mil / hour more to about 12mil / hour, even with having to jump to station, which is about twice as much as a covetor

A non-tanking hulk with good orca support, will do 20mil / hour (in practice, not theory numbers), 3 times the covetor the OP is most likely using. A tanking hulk will do 17mil / hour, also almost 3 times the covetor

So hulk not worth the hull? Please... use some brain cells with the 3rd grade math skills you used to know but now let them die slowly.
After a month of mining (about 1 hour a day), you can do the covetor income plus the cost of the hulk hull back, solo, compared to what the OP is using.

Its like using a nightmare to do the starter missions and complaining its not worth the money...

All of these numbers are in high-sec.
In low sec, the same setup can perform twice as much income an hour if you know what you are doing, even though with current prices of high-sec ores, you can do close to 30mil / hour mining in high-sec per hulk.

And comparint to missions? How many times people will keep doing that
Mining is a semi afk no-brain no-gaming skills profession
You don't shoot anything except astroids, you don't need to use your brain at all nor really pay attention to details (except ganker warning once in awhile)
Add mining with an indy alt, and its just as much of an income as missioning or even better

And unlike missiners, a miner doesn't need as many skills, and be almost max mining in about 45-50 days (excluding exhumer 5), while missioners will need to spend more time to skill for the right ship, for the best weapons, spend a few billions to get really geared up to steam roll missions enough to make those 30mil / hour.


Hey you seem to know what you're talking about!

What if I used a Covetor with T2 Crystals, Mining Upgrade I, and an Orca supporting me?

My logic is: "Don't fly what you can't afford. Assume everyship will be exploded eventually. Assume that the more expensive the ship, the more likely it will be exploded before it pays itself off." so please keep that in mind. I'm just a simple 1 person, 2 alt operation right now.
Tikera Tissant
#35 - 2012-03-22 16:26:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Tikera Tissant
T'Pawhl wrote:

Hey you seem to know what you're talking about!

What if I used a Covetor with T2 Crystals, Mining Upgrade I, and an Orca supporting me?

My logic is: "Don't fly what you can't afford. Assume everyship will be exploded eventually. Assume that the more expensive the ship, the more likely it will be exploded before it pays itself off." so please keep that in mind. I'm just a simple 1 person, 2 alt operation right now.


Practice numbers will be 15-15.5mil / hour average, depends on what you are mining (which is just as important).
That is with the best orca booster pilot.
Without the orca pilot you are looking at around 9mil / hour. So as you skill up an alt, it will go up and up.
Skill training the alt starts with mining foreman skill to 5 first, and later mining director skill to 5 once you can enter the orca to get the most from the links.
Adding 3% mining implant (relatively cheap) will get you another 500K isk / hour.

Don't forget that the covetor can die by the hands of a T2 catalyst if you don't fit it to basic tank.
So fitting it right to close to 10K EHP will discourage most ganks (BC gank won't be worth it at all).
A ship like that will cost about 40-42 mil isk (before buying crystals).

If you stick to T1 strip miners, you are doing 2.5mil less per hour, and the ship will cost you only 6 mil less (give or take the market).


Also pointing out, that to use the orca hanger, you will have to be in the same corp as your alt, a non-npc corp. Make a note of that.
T'Pawhl
Doomheim
#36 - 2012-03-22 17:19:04 UTC
Tikera Tissant wrote:

Practice numbers will be 15-15.5mil / hour average, depends on what you are mining (which is just as important).
That is with the best orca booster pilot.
Without the orca pilot you are looking at around 9mil / hour. So as you skill up an alt, it will go up and up.
Skill training the alt starts with mining foreman skill to 5 first, and later mining director skill to 5 once you can enter the orca to get the most from the links.
Adding 3% mining implant (relatively cheap) will get you another 500K isk / hour.

Don't forget that the covetor can die by the hands of a T2 catalyst if you don't fit it to basic tank.
So fitting it right to close to 10K EHP will discourage most ganks (BC gank won't be worth it at all).
A ship like that will cost about 40-42 mil isk (before buying crystals).

If you stick to T1 strip miners, you are doing 2.5mil less per hour, and the ship will cost you only 6 mil less (give or take the market).


Also pointing out, that to use the orca hanger, you will have to be in the same corp as your alt, a non-npc corp. Make a note of that.


Thank you very much, I appreciate all the help and advice you've given me. I think I will be pretty much safe from most ganks if I fly the tanked Covetor. In about 13 days my alt will be able to fly the Orca and start using the booster modules.

Do you have an idea what the Covetor tank fit would look like?
Tikera Tissant
#37 - 2012-03-22 17:34:20 UTC
There are several options.

A basic option is this:

[Covetor, T2 Tank Armor]
Mining Laser Upgrade I
Damage Control I

[empty med slot]

Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal II
Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal II
Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal II

Medium Trimark Armor Pump I
Medium Trimark Armor Pump I
Medium Trimark Armor Pump I


Another option is to plug holes like anti-em/thermal/explosive rigs, or shield rigs, mix and match.
Armor rigs will give a bit more EHP at the cost of speed, while shield ones will make the sig larger, so its easier to hit.

The orca you can go either tank one, or a hauler one (max cargo). Difference is very big (240K EHP on tanked vs 90 EHP on hauler).
I would suggest a middle ground around the 150K EHP give or take to balance it out. A single covetor will not speed fill it anyway.
T'Pawhl
Doomheim
#38 - 2012-03-22 17:40:17 UTC
Tikera Tissant wrote:
There are several options.

A basic option is this:

[Covetor, T2 Tank Armor]
Mining Laser Upgrade I
Damage Control I

[empty med slot]

Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal II
Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal II
Modulated Strip Miner II, Veldspar Mining Crystal II

Medium Trimark Armor Pump I
Medium Trimark Armor Pump I
Medium Trimark Armor Pump I


Another option is to plug holes like anti-em/thermal/explosive rigs, or shield rigs, mix and match.
Armor rigs will give a bit more EHP at the cost of speed, while shield ones will make the sig larger, so its easier to hit.

The orca you can go either tank one, or a hauler one (max cargo). Difference is very big (240K EHP on tanked vs 90 EHP on hauler).
I would suggest a middle ground around the 150K EHP give or take to balance it out. A single covetor will not speed fill it anyway.


Thank you so much! I really appreciate it.
Tikera Tissant
#39 - 2012-03-22 18:02:23 UTC
No problem.
You can mail me if you have any issues or questions.
Previous page12