These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

A Hamrite Journey (formerly: Amarr for the Glory of God)

Author
Edaine Numenor
Numenor Benevolent Holdings
#241 - 2012-03-16 16:32:16 UTC
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Edaine Numenor wrote:
Your arguments are only statements with no weight, Mr. Tibs.


Better a statement with no weight than entire individual and their organization, you twit.



I'll probably regret asking this question, but here goes anyway:
Silas, do you enjoy being unkind?

Liberating slaves wherever, whenever, and however I can.

Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#242 - 2012-03-16 16:32:41 UTC
Stitcher wrote:
I should remind you that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. I


Interesting, that's one of the most common arguments for a belief in God. Have you become a believer?

The Jove are long-gone. You'll recall during Sansha's capture of one of their stations a year or so back, images showed the Jove station to be a derelict. Abandoned, empty, and undefended.

Sansha knocked on their front door quite loudly, but no one was home.

Sabik now, Sabik forever

Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#243 - 2012-03-16 16:36:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Astrid Stjerna
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Edaine Numenor wrote:
Your arguments are only statements with no weight, Mr. Tibs.


Better a statement with no weight than entire individual and their organization, you twit.



'Twit'? That's the best response you could come up with?

I can't discuss my involvement in all of this, but I will say this: Theobar Cresthill has my support, because he is one of a handful of Amarrians I know that isn't willfully blind to the propaganda that his government spews on an almost-daily basis.

You call those that serve you 'slaves', Ms. Vitalia, but your own people are just slaves of a different kind.

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#244 - 2012-03-16 16:43:56 UTC
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Stitcher wrote:
I should remind you that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. I


Interesting, that's one of the most common arguments for a belief in God. Have you become a believer?


Not in Amarr, no.

Another common component for a belief in God would be confirmation bias - selecting only that evidence and those explanations which can be made to fit, or indeed rely on, the presence of the deity, conspiracy and/or scenario which the individual has already chosen to believe in.

I require scientific rigour, thanks. There are other explanations for that station being abandoned, and while "They're all dead and gone" is indeed one option, another and rather simpler one would be that they simply didn't need it any longer. Or that their population has declined and they've abandoned some structure but continue to use others. Or that Sansha has something they're actually afraid of.

If I remember correctly, the Angel Cartel took over an abandoned Jovian station? There have definitely been Jove sightings since then. You can't assume extinction on the evidence of no contact for a few years, and one abandoned station. You can't assume anything.

We are talking about an extraordinarily reclusive culture here, after all. They wouldn't be reclusive if we knew what they were up to.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#245 - 2012-03-16 17:02:54 UTC
Edaine Numenor wrote:
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
I could start my own corporation, set my tax rate at 99%, and be just as vulnerable to war declarations as your group is.
You really have nothing to offer here, Mr. Numenor, as I tried to tell you when you started your corporation.


War decs? Perhaps, but I doubt it. Why the hostility Tibs? I am trying to give this guy an option that your corp certainly isn't giving.
Answer a couple questions:
Your corp tax rate is 6%. On a 1 million ISK mission award, 60,000 goes where? How do your members know where that 60,000 goes? What mechanisms do they have to see where it goes?
Actually, we do have something to offer that other taxing Corps do not offer. We offer several levels of financial transparency. We are non-profit. I receive nothing from the Corp.

To show my sincerity in the matter, Mr. Cresthill, I will personally donate 1 million ISK to the anti-slavery organization of your choice if you join us. Stay or leave, the donation will be made. Your arguments are only statements with no weight, Mr. Tibs.


First, you will refer to me as Mr. Thessalonia, if you would like to show even the basic respect I've shown you.

Second, I know exactly where that money goes. It goes towards furthering TS-F's quest of helping Nation, which in turn will help all of humanity.

None of this matters, because even if I were to form my own corporation tomorrow, I would know exactly where the money goes. I would be running it. I would know with 100% certainty where every kredit went.

If I join your corporation, I have your word, unless you gave me Jr. Accountant rights. Even then, I would only see when the money left.
Edaine Numenor
Numenor Benevolent Holdings
#246 - 2012-03-16 17:27:39 UTC
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:

None of this matters, because even if I were to form my own corporation tomorrow, I would know exactly where the money goes. I would be running it. I would know with 100% certainty where every kredit went.
If I join your corporation, I have your word, unless you gave me Jr. Accountant rights. Even then, I would only see when the money left.


My apologies, Mr. Thessalonia. I intended no disrespect. Having a touch of dyslexia, "Thessalonia" slows my communication down a bit, but I will use your full name in future references if "tibs" is offensive to you. You may call me Mr. N. You could help me by granting me permission to call you Mr. T.

Anyone who joins NUVOS has more than my word. First, they do have account query access so they can see the taxed amount both in their own personal wallet and the division wallet that is assigned to their organization of choice. That's one level of transparency. The second level is from the receiving organization. Whatever organization Mr. Cresthill chose would receive monthly amount of ISK from NUVOS. All he has to do is ask, "Did you receive such and such an amount from NUVOS?" That sure is easy enough to verify. If at any point, funds were mishandled, it would be immediately seen.

You've answered the questions I asked evasively. Your corp uses taxed ISK as it sees fit. There is a contradiction in your answer. "Towards furthering..." is not knowing "exactly" where your ISK goes. You have not answered the question. That is fine so long as your goals are trusted by all your members. NUVOS simply puts that in the hands of the members. Mr. Cresthill would choose, not me.

Let me ask it again: How can a member of your corp see exactly where that 6% goes? Into whose wallet does that 6% finally end up? How can a member of your corp find out? I've answered that from my Corp perspective. Now lets hear a real answer from you, Mr. Tiberious Thessalonia.

Liberating slaves wherever, whenever, and however I can.

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#247 - 2012-03-16 17:40:11 UTC
Simple, in that I do trust my organization and its goals. It's not like we have any reason to lie, and unlike most places I can be absolutely assured of my Overseers loyalty. Any examination of what Nation is will tell you that.


I'm sure if I cared enough to audit the corporation, I could talk the Overseer into allowing me the same permissions you allow your members.

As it stands, though, the biggest weakness of your organization is that it is criminally vulnerable to war-declarations. You have two members, and your primary means of income generation (and hence the 10% that will go to your chosen charities) essentially dries up in the face of any determined opposition. A corporation would pay only a pittance a week towards keeping you out of the skies. An alliance like mine pays a slightly higher pittance, but it would also take up comparitively fewer of our resources.

In short, your corporation does not offer security. It does not offer any guarantees that a lone capsuleer cannot seize for themselves. It is a foolish endeavor, and will ultimately be ground under the boot of either an opposing philosophy, or general capsuleer boredom and cruelty.
Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#248 - 2012-03-16 17:44:25 UTC
Stitcher wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:
Even though Vak'Atioth saw the defeat of a single Amarrian fleet, it was enough to dissuade the Jove from overt interference in Amarrian affairs.


I've seen some flimsy arguments in my time, but this one's about as thin as a graphene ribbon.

The Jove have never seemed at all inclined to interfere overtly in anybody's affairs.


Of course they haven't. Because they know the consequences.

Quote:

About the most they have ever done in terms of interacting with the rest of New Eden was when they gave us the capsule. We hardly ever hear from them, when we do they're doing something utterly perplexing like exploding on live holo, they never take their seat at the CONCORD assembly, and their borders are shut tight.


They also gave the Republic its head of state.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#249 - 2012-03-16 17:55:17 UTC  |  Edited by: Stitcher
Rodj Blake wrote:
Stitcher wrote:
The Jove have never seemed at all inclined to interfere overtly in anybody's affairs.


Of course they haven't. Because they know the consequences.


...what consequences, precisely? It's not like they came off worse last time.

I mean, this may seem like a radical interpretation but if I were to kick a wall and break my foot, I don't think I could then realistically claim to have taught the wall not to mess with me.

"You'd better not hurt me or else I'll be in pain!"? Threatening to cry would be a more effective deterrent.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#250 - 2012-03-16 18:13:44 UTC
Edaine Numenor wrote:

Silas, do you enjoy being unkind


I'm doing you a kindness for even acknowledging your existence.

You spoke ill towards Thessalonia, whom I happen to like. I do of course disagree with the eventual goals of Nation but I'm all about their methods and respect them for taking control of their own destiny to try and make that happen, cluster-wide.

I'll contrast that with people like you who spend your time dealing with the detridus of others. Worrying about a few human castaways and trying to quiz a capsuleer about where some insignificant pocket-change ends up.

Respect yourself first if you want respect from others.

Sabik now, Sabik forever

Silas Vitalia
Doomheim
#251 - 2012-03-16 18:20:09 UTC
Stitcher wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:
Stitcher wrote:
The Jove have never seemed at all inclined to interfere overtly in anybody's affairs.


Of course they haven't. Because they know the consequences.


...what consequences, precisely? It's not like they came off worse last time.

I mean, this may seem like a radical interpretation but if I were to kick a wall and break my foot, I don't think I could then realistically claim to have taught the wall not to mess with me.

"You'd better not hurt me or else I'll be in pain!"? Threatening to cry would be a more effective deterrent.


Kicking the wall may have hurt, but it did collapse afterall

Sabik now, Sabik forever

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#252 - 2012-03-16 18:24:30 UTC
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Stitcher wrote:
Rodj Blake wrote:
Stitcher wrote:
The Jove have never seemed at all inclined to interfere overtly in anybody's affairs.


Of course they haven't. Because they know the consequences.


...what consequences, precisely? It's not like they came off worse last time.

I mean, this may seem like a radical interpretation but if I were to kick a wall and break my foot, I don't think I could then realistically claim to have taught the wall not to mess with me.

"You'd better not hurt me or else I'll be in pain!"? Threatening to cry would be a more effective deterrent.


Kicking the wall may have hurt, but it did collapse afterall


One was probably not the cause of the other.

More likely, the wall was rotting from the inside previous to the kicking.

In that case, the empire should really be more embarassed about losing.
Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#253 - 2012-03-16 18:26:33 UTC  |  Edited by: Stitcher
No, let me tell you what's happened.

The wall in question is built atop the tallest mountain in New Eden. The summit is basically in vacuum. Getting up there involves climbing for a week while wearing a space suit. The last time anybody tried, nearly everyone on the expedition was killed because they'd all kicked it and then tried to climb back down with a broken foot. Because of the absurd difficulty involved in reaching it, nobody has seen the wall in years, or at least not anybody you talk to.

Then you, walking through a field near the base of said mountain, have found a brick and drawn the conclusion that the wall must have collapsed, rather than considering all the other possible ways a brick could wind up in a field.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Edaine Numenor
Numenor Benevolent Holdings
#254 - 2012-03-16 18:40:26 UTC
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Simple, in that I do trust my organization and its goals. It's not like we have any reason to lie, and unlike most places I can be absolutely assured of my Overseers loyalty. Any examination of what Nation is will tell you that.


I'm sure if I cared enough to audit the corporation, I could talk the Overseer into allowing me the same permissions you allow your members.

As it stands, though, the biggest weakness of your organization is that it is criminally vulnerable to war-declarations. You have two members, and your primary means of income generation (and hence the 10% that will go to your chosen charities) essentially dries up in the face of any determined opposition. A corporation would pay only a pittance a week towards keeping you out of the skies. An alliance like mine pays a slightly higher pittance, but it would also take up comparitively fewer of our resources.

In short, your corporation does not offer security. It does not offer any guarantees that a lone capsuleer cannot seize for themselves. It is a foolish endeavor, and will ultimately be ground under the boot of either an opposing philosophy, or general capsuleer boredom and cruelty.


Now here is a criticism that I can respect. Thanks for getting past the accountability issue. OK. Mr. Cresthill, Mr. Thessalonia is correct. If you want security, join a big corp in a big alliance or stay in Viziam. If someone war dec'd us, we would be limited in what we could accomplish. But, of course, were that to happen I would encourage you to leave the corp for your own safety. Heck, I might even kick you out. There you have it. Give it a try or don't. Sooner or later, you are going to start paying taxes to Viziam if you stay with them.

Liberating slaves wherever, whenever, and however I can.

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#255 - 2012-03-16 18:42:36 UTC
Edaine Numenor wrote:
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Simple, in that I do trust my organization and its goals. It's not like we have any reason to lie, and unlike most places I can be absolutely assured of my Overseers loyalty. Any examination of what Nation is will tell you that.


I'm sure if I cared enough to audit the corporation, I could talk the Overseer into allowing me the same permissions you allow your members.

As it stands, though, the biggest weakness of your organization is that it is criminally vulnerable to war-declarations. You have two members, and your primary means of income generation (and hence the 10% that will go to your chosen charities) essentially dries up in the face of any determined opposition. A corporation would pay only a pittance a week towards keeping you out of the skies. An alliance like mine pays a slightly higher pittance, but it would also take up comparitively fewer of our resources.

In short, your corporation does not offer security. It does not offer any guarantees that a lone capsuleer cannot seize for themselves. It is a foolish endeavor, and will ultimately be ground under the boot of either an opposing philosophy, or general capsuleer boredom and cruelty.


Now here is a criticism that I can respect. Thanks for getting past the accountability issue. OK. Mr. Cresthill, Mr. Thessalonia is correct. If you want security, join a big corp in a big alliance or stay in Viziam. If someone war dec'd us, we would be limited in what we could accomplish. But, of course, were that to happen I would encourage you to leave the corp for your own safety. Heck, I might even kick you out. There you have it. Give it a try or don't. Sooner or later, you are going to start paying taxes to Viziam if you stay with them.


Or he could form his own corporation, keep his taxes, and give whatever he felt was appropriate, to anyone he liked.

I'm still not seeing the advantage to joining YOUR corporation, Mr. Numenor.
Edaine Numenor
Numenor Benevolent Holdings
#256 - 2012-03-16 18:58:03 UTC
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:


Or he could form his own corporation, keep his taxes, and give whatever he felt was appropriate, to anyone he liked.

I'm still not seeing the advantage to joining YOUR corporation, Mr. Numenor.


I believe we had this discussion on The Summit once. We disagreed obviously, but I'll explain the principle behind the concept again. There are two driving motivations behind NUVOS.
1. Freeing Slaves.
2. Providing an automatic, discipline, accountable way of making donations that cosst about 1% less that your typical default corporation membership. Mr. Thessalonia, you don't value this, fine. But, maybe Mr. Cresthill would. Who knows? Philanthropic intentions can so easily evaporate, especially with capsuleers. Its just to easy to hold on to all that ISK. NUVOS's second goal addresses that. Take it or leave it. Yes, Mr. Thessalonia could do the same by starting his own corp, but would he? NUVOS provides a service that helps pilots maintain their philanthropy and we do it without making one ISK for ourselves in the process. I wonder what is so bad about that?

I still wonder why you, Mr. Thessalonia, are spending so much time and effort arguing against it. What is that is really bothering you? What's really under your skin?

Liberating slaves wherever, whenever, and however I can.

Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#257 - 2012-03-16 19:07:51 UTC
Tibs is with Sansha, Edaine. Most likely his motivation is nothing more than to annoy you and disrupt your operations.

Else
Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#258 - 2012-03-16 19:16:28 UTC
Edaine Numenor wrote:
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:


Or he could form his own corporation, keep his taxes, and give whatever he felt was appropriate, to anyone he liked.

I'm still not seeing the advantage to joining YOUR corporation, Mr. Numenor.


I believe we had this discussion on The Summit once. We disagreed obviously, but I'll explain the principle behind the concept again. There are two driving motivations behind NUVOS.
1. Freeing Slaves.
2. Providing an automatic, discipline, accountable way of making donations that cosst about 1% less that your typical default corporation membership. Mr. Thessalonia, you don't value this, fine. But, maybe Mr. Cresthill would. Who knows? Philanthropic intentions can so easily evaporate, especially with capsuleers. Its just to easy to hold on to all that ISK. NUVOS's second goal addresses that. Take it or leave it. Yes, Mr. Thessalonia could do the same by starting his own corp, but would he? NUVOS provides a service that helps pilots maintain their philanthropy and we do it without making one ISK for ourselves in the process. I wonder what is so bad about that?

I still wonder why you, Mr. Thessalonia, are spending so much time and effort arguing against it. What is that is really bothering you? What's really under your skin?


My issues, Edaine, is that I dont trust your motives, and I do not see how your corporation will help more than doing nothing.

Contrary to Ms. Rhiannons accusation, I care deeply about the universe. I want to see the people in it do well. One of my first actions upon joining TS-F was to study Nation agriculture techniques, adapt it slightly for general non-Nation use, and distributed it. When these techniques are used, even without True Slave minders, they still result in an 8% increase in yield efficiency over most standard similar farming techniques. Because the method uses hydroponics, it also allows land that would have no other practical application to be used.

That was the first thing I did. It was not the last, nor will I stop doing other such things.

What I am concerned about with your corporation is that it will not result in any net positive benefit over a philanthropy minded capsuleer acting on their own, and this is the question you have so far been unable to answer. Why are you better than the control case?
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#259 - 2012-03-16 19:45:22 UTC
For someone to join them, why should they be better than going at it alone? Isn't being as good as and offering the company enough?
Edaine Numenor
Numenor Benevolent Holdings
#260 - 2012-03-16 19:45:33 UTC
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:

What I am concerned about with your corporation is that it will not result in any net positive benefit over a philanthropy minded capsuleer acting on their own, and this is the question you have so far been unable to answer. Why are you better than the control case?


NUVOS has been responsible for the liberation of over two million slaves. Ask those two million+ if they feel a "net positive benefit." Who are you to question my motives and exalt your own? This is irony, you say that you "care deeply." That, Mr. is a motive or an internal feeling that can't be judged, yet you believe that you are in a position to judge me when I claim to care. Isn't that hypocritical? You ask me why am I better... and then turn and foist your own action as better. Isn't that hypocritical? Look in the mirror before you question my motives again.

Liberating slaves wherever, whenever, and however I can.