These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

Theological Musings 02: Matari Spirituality

Author
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#21 - 2012-03-10 19:32:01 UTC  |  Edited by: Elsebeth Rhiannon
EDITed to add: I am extremely hesitant to speak about such things. Minmatar Ways are varied, and it is very easy to offend by describing as "the way" a custom that someone of a respectable clan does not follow, and possibly even considers wrong. What I talk about below is based on my obviously limited knowledge of the myriads of clans; no offense is meant if I do not do justice to yours. I encourage others of the tribes to also share their understanding.

Repentence Tyrathlion wrote:
But - to take the obvious example - what if an outsider were to marry into a tribe? Would they then become part of it - or would they remain in some in-between zone? At what point would the traditions and rituals of a given group apply to a newcomer? What about any children? And on a broader scale, what level of differentiation would there be between a Matari of another tribe, a Matari of no tribe (rescued from slavery, for instance), and someone of another race entirely?

There is no one single answer to these questions.

Would the outsider become part of the clan? That depends on that clan's customs. It is common that you marry "into" a clan, becoming its member - and for this reason, many clans do not marry outsiders, not even members of other tribes, because they feel it is impossible to accommodate for a member of a clan that is not of the tribe. Some clans like this do marry from other tribes and even from among foreigners, but such relations are rarely happy, as the people leaving their tribes find it difficult to settle into a new one and are rarely completely accepted. In clans like this, there is a marriage ceremony that also takes care of forming the new kinship, after which traditions and rituals apply, and the clan usually considers the person also a member of their tribe.

When a clan says that someone is their kin, other clans rarely argue, though they might roll their eyes and decide to never marry into or from that clan, due to considering them tainted by the association. Membership in the tribe would be similarly decided by consensus: officially, if a Matari clan claims you as a member, you are part of their tribe, but that does not necessarily mean everyone in the tribe will accept the claim on anywhere else but paper.

There are also clans where you can marry without either party joining the other. I am less familiar myself with such customs, but I believe that some such clans are even stricter about the other party being of the tribe, on the basis that the marriage forms an alliance with the kin of the spouse and they do not wish to be diluted by such associations, while some of them do marry clanless and foreigners, on the basis that the kin of the outsiders would not be a valid party to place demands anyhow.

In interclan marriages, which clan children are counted in is usually specified in the marriage contract - or in any case, it should be, because if it is not, it will lead to quarrels and feuds and a bunch of really unhappy kids. Most clans have traditions specifying the position of children born outside of marriage, which can work out if the father of the child is not aware of the child or his ways are compatible with those of the mother's. I might be mistaken in this, but I believe at least the local law where I come from on Matar has it that if you take it to court, in the absence of a contract the children belong to the mother's clan (this being the one you can be certain of).

Most established clans that I know of marry inside their own tribe exclusively. Generally, I'd guess that for most, for a spouse, someone with a high status clan would be preferred to someone of a lower class, and a clanless person of one's own tribe would be preferred to someone of another Matari tribe. Some clans prefer a higher-status clan of another tribe to a clanless person. Foreigners would come only after that. The lower you are on that scale, the harder it would be for you to fit in your new clan.

Do note that most Matari are rather relaxed about premarital sexual relations, and even discrete relations in parallel with a marriage, which have a much wider scope of "targets", given that they are not considered an alliance between two clans, but rather just a temporary arrangement between individuals. Of course, in reality, things are not so simple - falling in love with someone who can never become kin is a recurring theme in our stories and holovids. It is interesting to note that in Gallentean stories on the theme, love usually prevails, while in the traditional Matari stories that I at least know, the dilemma is usually resolved by the person returning to their kin.
Uraniae Fehrnah
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#22 - 2012-03-10 20:07:38 UTC
I think some people are taking my words a bit more literal and further than I intended, let me try to clarify a few things.

First to the point I've made about selflessness. Gotti, I do not mean selfless in the sense of being less defined as a person, I mean in the sense of thinking of others before thinking of oneself.

Miss Rhiannon, again on the point of selflessness you've taken my words to a further extreme than I intended. Charity and altruism may not be specifically central to Matari spirituality (which I admit is limited to the traditions of only a single clan) but it does seem to be encouraged in practice. Putting the good of the clan and tribe ahead of your personal well being is selfless and charitable in a sense. True technically speaking it is still "looking after one's own" but they are other distinct people and the simple act of putting another person ahead of your own personal gain is, on some level a very selfless act.

I should also point out that I know enough of the voluval to understand that it is not some random interesting ritual to go through. I am aware of how significant the voluval ritual and the resulting valuval mark are and that were I to seriously pursue the matter it would take a rather considerable amount of time and effort. It's important to note that when I mentioned the voluval I was speaking quite heavily entrenched in the hypothetical. In all cases I know of the voluval is the first mark a Matari recieves (aside from childhood naming marks) and generally speaking, without the voluval someone wouldn't be granted the right to bear other marks. With that as a base, yes hypthetically speaking the voluval would have to be the mark I receive, if I were to receive any at all.

As to the tattoo I already have, I'm aware that at first glance it would seem disrespectful. However, being that the person the mark is meant to honor is Matari, I felt it appropriate to honor them in a Matari way. I suppose on some level the simple fact that I have a Matari tattoo would suggest I might be trying to pretend to be Matari, but I assure you I am not. Before getting my tattoo I was told that it would undoubtedly offend some people, but I was also told that the nature of this specific type of mark might make it less offensive in that all it truly does is honor a lost loved one.

Again, I do not intend any disrespect in my words or actions. If they are taken as such I accept that and can only appologize and offer my assurances that I hold nothing but the utmost respect for Matari spiritual beliefs, customs, and the culture in general. If I were to make an attempt to join a clan and tribe, I would do so in good faith and with honest effort.
Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#23 - 2012-03-10 20:40:48 UTC
Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:

Your what? What shaman would let a foreigner, and an Amarrian at that, go through a Voluval, which is inherently a rite about becoming an adult member of the tribes and finding your Fate in the eyes of that tribes' ancestors? Especially where you mention that you do not even have a clan to adopt you in - I have heard cases of foreigners joining clans, though I find even that infinitely silly myself - but I have not heard of a foreigner going through a proper voluval without such circumstances. Again, I warn you, that the people informing you that this is not "disrespectful" might not be completely honest, and also warn you that even if you decide to go through it, such a Mark will be viewed as an abomination by many members of the tribes.


What shaman would do that ? Isn't it a little naive to believe that all individuals think the same and all respect the traditions to the same degree ? Especially if offered something invaluable in return, like the money of a capsuleer, for example. Also, the Voluval formula may be well kept by Vherokior mystics, but it does not mean that the product itself is.

Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:
What is it with you Amarrians who want to reform - why is it not enough for you to be reformed Amarrians and to work for the betterment of your own people? Why do you have to play at being Matari?


I can not speak for them, but it would seem logical to me that these individuals may be curious and willing to learn. If people get offended over this and do not want to teach and guide instead, it is their own problem : they can still do like captain Gotti said and consider that this is not a Voluval, if it makes them feel better. Bluntly said, I would be the first to tell them "deal with it".
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#24 - 2012-03-11 08:24:43 UTC  |  Edited by: Elsebeth Rhiannon
As a word of warning, learning only the traditions and ways of one clan and considering those the Minmatar way is close to the worst mistake you can make learning about Minmatar culture.

Now that I wrote that I notice that there is another aspect you also left out in your original, Captain Fehrnah. This one is a little difficult to put into words, it being so ingrained in us that we rarely have to discuss it. This is the respect of each others ways and traditions. We are used to negotiate among and between different and sometimes contradictory customs. An honorable person is not someone who follows a particular way of doing things, but a person who follows the way of their kin.

Thus many of us are rather weirded out by the Amarrian defector tendency to attempt to become Minmatar. It is an awkward and terrible position, of course, where you cannot follow your own people's ways because you believe many of them evil; yet to deny where you come from and seek to become something else completely does not feel like the correct solution. We would expect you to find peace within the context of your Faith, rather than adopt ours, but this is rarely the path these cases seem to choose. (There is resistance to Minmatar doing the same, but that is more because we do not consider the Amarrian God theirs, than about resistance to Amarrians reforming their Faith.)

I would recommend that a better way to learn about Minmatar culture than trying to belong to one clan would be to talk to representatives of several. And then, if you still want to adopt our customs, use what you learn to find your own path, to make best of the customs of your own kin. For that would be the Minmatar way of dealing with it.

Captain Farel is of course correct; no doubt there are shamans who will perform rites for money or in pursuit of personal fame. My indignation made me shortly forget the realities of life.
Ava Starfire
Khushakor Clan
#25 - 2012-03-12 02:21:44 UTC
Overall, an extremely good summary, a "glimpse" of some of the facets of the myriad beliefs that comprise Minmatar "religion". It was a good read, and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

The idea of Fate, as Elsebeth said, is important to many of us; this is, after all, part of what the Voluval reveals to us, the ultimate destination our paths will take us in.

The Path, something I speak about often, and have spoken with you about, Ura, is, for many of us, the "core" of our belief. To walk one's path well is do do one's duty, as directed by your Mark, and to do so is to honor one's ancestors, clan, and family. The spiritual component that some Clans, including my own, believe in is not as universal, but still very, very common. However, just what those spirits are, where they come from, and what their role is varies widely among the Tribes, and even within the Tribes, at the subtribal and Clan level, variation will be found.

A small tattoo to honor a lost friend will not be seen as anything other than what it is; a tattoo, in a minmatar style, on a non-Matari. Some will find it offensive, some will appreciate the gesture, most wont give it much thought. I remember speaking with you on the matter, and still stand by what I said; I study the Scriptures, this does not make me Amarrian, nor do i intend to pretend that it does. I believe Uraniae's intent was similar; a mark to honor a friend, not to attempt to "claim" any connection to which she has no right.

I look forward to your next installment. Bravo.

Avlynka Surionen

"There is no strength in numbers; have no such misconception." -Jayka Vofur, "Warfare in the North"

Uraniae Fehrnah
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#26 - 2012-03-12 02:29:52 UTC
Well, I have said, numerous times, that my knowledge of Matari spirituality and culture is in fact limited to only one clan. I don't think I ever made the claim that my interpretations of what I learn are the be all and end all of that particular spiritual group, they certainly aren't for my previous thread about my take on traditional Amarrian faith, so I'm not sure where I might have given that impression in this particular thread.

I would be very eager to learn the ways of other clans and other tribes and have made some attempts but never received any responses. In fact the only reason I know anything at all about Matari faith and customs is because only one small group has bothered to try and teach me. Without their efforts I would know precious little beyond "textbook" levels of awareness that are, in practice, a very poor way to understand another person at all.

I'm rather unsure how my curiosity and attempts to learn make me into some sort of Amarrian defector. I am under no illusions that I am indeed Amarrian by birth and by a great number of mannerisms and customs. But central to what it means to be Amarr is the search for spiritual enlightenment. Most Amarr are able to do this within the Scriptures, but I am not. The simple fact of the matter is I am unconvinced and so I make attempts to learn and experience all I can in a spiritual sense. This little desire of mine quite naturally led me to faiths beyond traditional Amarrian doctrine, and will no doubt continue to drive me to learn all I can from any sources that are willing to teach me. If God created all there is, then surely seeking God within the borders of God's other creations is still quite valid even if it is unconventional by the Amarrian standard.
Repentence Tyrathlion
Tyrathlion Interstellar
#27 - 2012-03-12 13:32:33 UTC
Uraniae Fehrnah wrote:
I'm rather unsure how my curiosity and attempts to learn make me into some sort of Amarrian defector. I am under no illusions that I am indeed Amarrian by birth and by a great number of mannerisms and customs. But central to what it means to be Amarr is the search for spiritual enlightenment. Most Amarr are able to do this within the Scriptures, but I am not. The simple fact of the matter is I am unconvinced and so I make attempts to learn and experience all I can in a spiritual sense. This little desire of mine quite naturally led me to faiths beyond traditional Amarrian doctrine, and will no doubt continue to drive me to learn all I can from any sources that are willing to teach me. If God created all there is, then surely seeking God within the borders of God's other creations is still quite valid even if it is unconventional by the Amarrian standard.


For many years I resisted and ignored the scriptures, in no small part as an act of rebellion, and it is only in recent times that I have returned to them. But during my adventuring days, I ran across many different beliefs and ways of life, and I concur; there is enlightenment and wisdom to be found in much of God's creation.
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#28 - 2012-03-12 17:49:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Elsebeth Rhiannon
Captain Fehrnah

it is possible you were unfairly judged by your speaking of Matari tattoos and a possible Voluval. You intended the latter as a hypothetical, but after seeing many cases where Amarrian defectors indeed seek becoming Matari, we assumed that you were yet another one such

As to seeking salvation via Matari ways, let me tell you a legend that some Sebiestor subtribes tell. Excuse my less than stellar formulation; it has been a long time, and I am not telling you the Rhiannon version, but am abridged conglomerate of several clans' versions

There have always been many gods in this world, each of them a god of a particular aspect or place, each with their own worshippers. All gods but one were content being one of many, but the Amarrian God grew restless. Some say he was hungry for power, so hungry that he wanted to eat the world, so hungry he ate many of the other gods, so hungry that in the end he ate even his own name. That is why of all gods he alone is known just as God; or among those who oppose him the Evil God, or the Nameless God

Such was the power of his hunger that through consuming more and more he gained power over the whole world, even over the immortal souls of men and women, so that he alone had the power to define who would be saved and who would be damned. And many succumbed to his power, and began to say it was good, and to spread his word and his power

But power alone does not imply goodness, and might does not make right. The Minmatar saw this, and they sought a way to fight him. No man or woman alone could stand against a God, but the Minmatar had a unique power in their kin. Allying with each other, they discovered a way to escape the hungry god: ancestor spirits do not live in the world, and so they are not governed by the God of the world.

And so, by living a dutiful life and fulfilling one's Fate, one can leave the world to join one's ancestors, and thus escape the judgment of the Evil God.


As can be seen from this story, many Matari beliefs are not extremely compatible with seeking personal salvation in the eyes of God. Obviously I am just recounting ideas of a subtribe. There are clans who consider themselves free Matari and still followers of the Evil One (though naturally they do not call him that); they probably would have more satisfactory answers for your quest.
Uraniae Fehrnah
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#29 - 2012-03-12 22:57:22 UTC
An interesting story, thank you for sharing it. I do believe I see the point you are making but I still don't believe it applies to me specifically. I seek knowledge and enlightenment, not for any sort of power or promise of salvation, but simply to enjoy the process of seeking spiritual knowledge. It occurs to me that some might consider enlightenment and salvation to go hand-in-hand but in my personal belief, they do not. In a way it is more than likely a bit selfish of me to seek spiritual knowledge simply because I enjoy the process, but I long ago gave up on the hope that any god would accept my soul or spirit or essence and provide me with salvation in this life or any possible one after it.

I'll continue my little quest for enlightenment for the foreseeable future. It will more than likely earn me just as much enmity as it does respect. I can only apologize so much to those I might offend and I can only offer so many assurances that I mean no disrespect. In the end I will continue to learn and experience what I can, regardless of how the seeking might make me appear to others.
Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#30 - 2012-03-14 18:02:35 UTC
Elsebeth Rhiannon wrote:

Your what? What shaman would let a foreigner, and an Amarrian at that, go through a Voluval, which is inherently a rite about becoming an adult member of the tribes and finding your Fate in the eyes of that tribes' ancestors? Especially where you mention that you do not even have a clan to adopt you in - I have heard cases of foreigners joining clans, though I find even that infinitely silly myself - but I have not heard of a foreigner going through a proper voluval without such circumstances. Again, I warn you, that the people informing you that this is not "disrespectful" might not be completely honest, and also warn you that even if you decide to go through it, such a Mark will be viewed as an abomination by many members of the tribes.

What is it with you Amarrians who want to reform - why is it not enough for you to be reformed Amarrians and to work for the betterment of your own people? Why do you have to play at being Matari?


I see nothing disrespectful about honoring my peoples' traditions and customs. Should my wife decide that she wants to formally join my clan and tribe, she will have my full support. In fact, I would consider it a great honor to welcome the woman that I love into Cold Lake clan.

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Rek Jaiga
Teraa Matar
#31 - 2012-03-14 21:47:16 UTC
Funny. I'm still early on in my studies but what that legend speaks of, Elsebeth, sounds a lot like something I've learned a bit about: Nidhoggr.
Elsebeth Rhiannon
Gradient
Electus Matari
#32 - 2012-03-15 16:08:37 UTC  |  Edited by: Elsebeth Rhiannon
True. Old Nid still has a name, though. It would be intriguing to know if this was lack of greed or lack of power. Blink

(No disrespect mean towards people in whose legends the spirit in question strongly features.)
Previous page12