These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Autocannons and Minnie fittings balance

Author
Onictus
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#61 - 2012-02-22 13:10:18 UTC
Jeremy Ironforge wrote:
^ Cap boosters... Armor Cane has only one neut which is not enough to break through.


with a PG1 you can get 2 neuts
Tanya Powers
Doomheim
#62 - 2012-02-22 14:10:34 UTC
Ayeshah Volfield wrote:
Was under the impression some Gallente hulls were missing a slot to compensate for larger drone bays and ability to field more drones than their counterparts.


Was a valid argument back when gallente could use all the drones you had in your cruiser hull drone bay. Not any more.

Not any more for Brutix neither that still can't fit properly 250's without the lolest fit ever with an unused bonus only noobs doing it wrong all the way will try to use it.

On the same record of lol fits and silly stuff try to fit with 250's a decent snipe Deimos and you'll get some smiles in your face when you'll figure out how silly Gallente hulls are. You can add some hybrid caldari hulls too but hey it's not like if Missiles weren't fine right?
OfBalance
Caldari State
#63 - 2012-02-22 17:40:25 UTC
Tanya Powers wrote:
You can add some hybrid caldari hulls too but hey it's not like if heavy Missiles weren't fine right?


FYP
Buzzmong
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#64 - 2012-02-22 20:26:17 UTC
Tanya Powers wrote:

Was a valid argument back when gallente could use all the drones you had in your cruiser hull drone bay. Not any more.

Not any more for Brutix neither that still can't fit properly 250's without the lolest fit ever with an unused bonus only noobs doing it wrong all the way will try to use it.

On the same record of lol fits and silly stuff try to fit with 250's a decent snipe Deimos and you'll get some smiles in your face when you'll figure out how silly Gallente hulls are. You can add some hybrid caldari hulls too but hey it's not like if Missiles weren't fine right?


This. TBQFH.

/ Wistfully remembers blasterax's with 5 heavy drones *swoons*
Vladimir Smugdog
#65 - 2012-02-23 02:59:23 UTC
Buzzmong wrote:
Tanya Powers wrote:

Was a valid argument back when gallente could use all the drones you had in your cruiser hull drone bay. Not any more.

Not any more for Brutix neither that still can't fit properly 250's without the lolest fit ever with an unused bonus only noobs doing it wrong all the way will try to use it.

On the same record of lol fits and silly stuff try to fit with 250's a decent snipe Deimos and you'll get some smiles in your face when you'll figure out how silly Gallente hulls are. You can add some hybrid caldari hulls too but hey it's not like if Missiles weren't fine right?


This. TBQFH.

/ Wistfully remembers blasterax's with 5 heavy drones *swoons*


All hacs suck TBQFH and chief among the ones that don't is the ishtar for pve reasons. Lol
Cindy Marco
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#66 - 2012-02-23 04:14:12 UTC  |  Edited by: Cindy Marco
Buzzmong wrote:
Tanya Powers wrote:

Was a valid argument back when gallente could use all the drones you had in your cruiser hull drone bay. Not any more.

Not any more for Brutix neither that still can't fit properly 250's without the lolest fit ever with an unused bonus only noobs doing it wrong all the way will try to use it.

On the same record of lol fits and silly stuff try to fit with 250's a decent snipe Deimos and you'll get some smiles in your face when you'll figure out how silly Gallente hulls are. You can add some hybrid caldari hulls too but hey it's not like if Missiles weren't fine right?


This. TBQFH.

/ Wistfully remembers blasterax's with 5 heavy drones *swoons*


Those were fun times. That and cruise/torp Kestrels.
Tanya Powers
Doomheim
#67 - 2012-02-23 12:22:27 UTC
You can still have fun on sisi with Guardian Vexor and 10 drones out Lol

I use it as remote rep with logistic drones, if you try to use it like you would expect to use a navy vexor but 10 drones out, you'll be very disappointed.

Back on topic: I would like CCP to change Gallente BC's battlecruisers Tiers.

Because Myrmidon performs +/- like every other race Tier one BC and because Brutix needs almost double pg, mid slots and lows to play the same game than drakes and canes witch is eve online.

-I want a 250mm II Brutix cargo with T2 ammo short/long range
-not cap out because I'm shooting
-not cap out because my crappy afterburner is On
-not cap out because a frig orbiting at 500 that I can't hit with my rails just neut me with 2 cycles of his small NOS...
-not have to choose to put guns or reps on my ship to profit from an unused bonus, lolilol fits are lol
-have enough CPU to fit it decently and cap stable either with rails or blasters when I have all 5's and without implants
-have that crappy rep bonus changed to +10% speed per level or 5% fall off or something else BUT USEFUL
-Same slot layout than Cane, less one mid plus one low

Pimp the PG of Deimos enough so I can fit other thing than 200's on it without having a ridiculous fit and even more ridiculous dps.

Thx
Wacktopia
Fleet-Up.com
Keep It Simple Software Group
#68 - 2012-02-23 12:25:08 UTC
Fronkfurter McSheebleton wrote:
Typically no, unless it's a drone bonused hull....the myrmidon could have another high slot and not be OP, though.


100 b/width.

Kitchen sink? Seriousy, get your ship together -  Fleet-Up.com

Tanya Powers
Doomheim
#69 - 2012-02-23 12:59:20 UTC
And I too confirm that Minmatar ships have fitting problems.

I never know what to fit in that dam cane to use all the PG and CPU available, I feel shame for my self being that bad.

Please CCP nerf the dam hurricane and spew on it 8-8-8 slots so I have trouble fitting my ship.
Ahrieman
Codex Praedonum
Divine Damnation
#70 - 2012-02-25 01:31:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Ahrieman
Where to start? So many ridiculous things have been said so this will prob take way too much text to deal with them and I will not be multi quoting all that nonsense, just going over the more gross atrocities of logic.

To say "a torp phoon is easy to fit, so nerf minmatar" is ridiculous. The torp phoon is probably the most skill intensive ship a dedicated Minmatar pilot could train for. Maybe the most skill intensive ship that any dedicated racial pilot could train for imho. Even a rokh doesn't need neut skills.

Secondly, Minmatar T2 resist profiles are good, but anyone who compares the paper stats against the 2 most common damage types (thermal and kinetic) will easily see that minmatar T2 resists are only optimized for dealing with laser damage (racial design for the minmatar v amarr thing). If you are someone who runs around with emp loaded all the time, then you are only 2 years behind the bell curve. Maybe there is hope for you, but I doubt it.

Very few minmatar ships can be viably fit with artillery cannons even with the "generous" fittings that they have.

I would take a close range geddon over an AC phoon any day of the week. In ships that size, you aren't skirmishing (where minmatar has the advantage) you are brawling and the geddon's dps and tank are both better than the AC phoon. The TRADEOFF is that the geddon is tough to fit. Seems like a fair tradeoff: if you want to fly a geddon and train to fly a geddon, it will be better than an AC phoon.

AC's have great damage projection. LOL. Compared to what? Blasters loaded with antimatter? Well no s**! What happens to this damage projection when you are being kept at range and being shot with Scorch? Scorch is prob the best ammo in the game. Many rail fits outdamage AC fits with Barrage...and to even try to fit arties means going with a paper thin tank.

BTW, you guys should try null. It projects damage very well and it's hard to beat with barrage considering the small range difference and significant dps advantage of blasters if you can close those few km needed (almost impossible to beat null on frig hulls by using barrage).

Not having T2 rockets but flying a Drake with T2 heavies doesn't mean you have "s*** support skills". It just means you don't fly rocket boats. Tell me how you can fly a cane with T2 AC's without training small T2 AC's...

As for "Angel ships", they are not minmatar or a race (as I said the problems aren't racially defined). There are problems there, but to say ALL angel ships - just proves how little you have undocked since the hybrid rebalancing, null buff, and dram nerf. DD is clearly the most OP frig in the game. If you consider it an "angel ship", then please be more precise as to what you are talking about. If you want to suggest ways to fix the cynabal, then post a link to that thread so I can go there and discuss that with you. There are a number of problems with many faction ships and I will follow a link to the appropriate thread for discussing them.

For the majority of you, start here:

tl;dr
Yes there are individual ships that need work. Even some ship classes as a whole need work and fixes are currently in the works. To say nerf minmatar is beyond ignorant and just proves how little you play the game or how little you understand what you are doing when you undock. The game has great balance right now and it would be a shame to watch it destroyed by another epic whine thread. After all, do you really want to see a race almost unusable for 2 years again (read: Gallente)?

Solo Rifter since 2009

M1k3y Koontz
House of Musashi
Stay Feral
#71 - 2012-03-01 21:12:11 UTC
Jeremy Ironforge wrote:
Ahh just tried a Meta3 guns Armor Cane VS a T2 fitted Armor Harby. Guess who won?

Now that's ridiculous cuz Harby wasn't drained or jammed... Just outanked and outdpsed at all ranges.


I call shenanigans. With scorch a harby will easily out DPS an ARMOR cane at the edge of the harby's optimal. Also I know for a fact because I have flown both that a harby has more tank than a cane, so either that harby got neuted out because he was a lasor ship without a cap booster (terrible idea) or he decided to sit point blank on a ship that he could have out DPS'd at range.
Projectiles, lasors, heavy/HAMs and blasters are quite well balanced right now.

How much herp could a herp derp derp if a herp derp could herp derp.

Dirty Teacher
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#72 - 2012-03-02 01:12:08 UTC
M1k3y Koontz wrote:
Jeremy Ironforge wrote:
Ahh just tried a Meta3 guns Armor Cane VS a T2 fitted Armor Harby. Guess who won?

Now that's ridiculous cuz Harby wasn't drained or jammed... Just outanked and outdpsed at all ranges.


I call shenanigans. With scorch a harby will easily out DPS an ARMOR cane at the edge of the harby's optimal. Also I know for a fact because I have flown both that a harby has more tank than a cane, so either that harby got neuted out because he was a lasor ship without a cap booster (terrible idea) or he decided to sit point blank on a ship that he could have out DPS'd at range.
Projectiles, lasors, heavy/HAMs and blasters are quite well balanced right now.


because it's totally easy for the harby to dictate range vs a hurricane right?
Liang Nuren
No Salvation
Divine Damnation
#73 - 2012-03-02 01:40:23 UTC  |  Edited by: Liang Nuren
Dirty Teacher wrote:
M1k3y Koontz wrote:
Jeremy Ironforge wrote:
Ahh just tried a Meta3 guns Armor Cane VS a T2 fitted Armor Harby. Guess who won?

Now that's ridiculous cuz Harby wasn't drained or jammed... Just outanked and outdpsed at all ranges.


I call shenanigans. With scorch a harby will easily out DPS an ARMOR cane at the edge of the harby's optimal. Also I know for a fact because I have flown both that a harby has more tank than a cane, so either that harby got neuted out because he was a lasor ship without a cap booster (terrible idea) or he decided to sit point blank on a ship that he could have out DPS'd at range.
Projectiles, lasors, heavy/HAMs and blasters are quite well balanced right now.


because it's totally easy for the harby to dictate range vs a hurricane right?


Did you read what he responded to? He's right to call shenanigans. Its just not possible.

-Liang

Ed: At least, not as presented it isn't possible.

I'm an idiot, don't mind me.

Tarryn Nightstorm
Hellstar Towing and Recovery
#74 - 2012-03-02 02:19:00 UTC
Ahrieman wrote:
Where to start? So many ridiculous things have been said so this will prob take way too much text to deal with them and I will not be multi quoting all that nonsense, just going over the more gross atrocities of logic.

To say "a torp phoon is easy to fit, so nerf minmatar" is ridiculous. The torp phoon is probably the most skill intensive ship a dedicated Minmatar pilot could train for. Maybe the most skill intensive ship that any dedicated racial pilot could train for imho. Even a rokh doesn't need neut skills.

Secondly, Minmatar T2 resist profiles are good, but anyone who compares the paper stats against the 2 most common damage types (thermal and kinetic) will easily see that minmatar T2 resists are only optimized for dealing with laser damage (racial design for the minmatar v amarr thing). If you are someone who runs around with emp loaded all the time, then you are only 2 years behind the bell curve. Maybe there is hope for you, but I doubt it.

Very few minmatar ships can be viably fit with artillery cannons even with the "generous" fittings that they have.

I would take a close range geddon over an AC phoon any day of the week. In ships that size, you aren't skirmishing (where minmatar has the advantage) you are brawling and the geddon's dps and tank are both better than the AC phoon. The TRADEOFF is that the geddon is tough to fit. Seems like a fair tradeoff: if you want to fly a geddon and train to fly a geddon, it will be better than an AC phoon.

AC's have great damage projection. LOL. Compared to what? Blasters loaded with antimatter? Well no s**! What happens to this damage projection when you are being kept at range and being shot with Scorch? Scorch is prob the best ammo in the game. Many rail fits outdamage AC fits with Barrage...and to even try to fit arties means going with a paper thin tank.

BTW, you guys should try null. It projects damage very well and it's hard to beat with barrage considering the small range difference and significant dps advantage of blasters if you can close those few km needed (almost impossible to beat null on frig hulls by using barrage).

Not having T2 rockets but flying a Drake with T2 heavies doesn't mean you have "s*** support skills". It just means you don't fly rocket boats. Tell me how you can fly a cane with T2 AC's without training small T2 AC's...

As for "Angel ships", they are not minmatar or a race (as I said the problems aren't racially defined). There are problems there, but to say ALL angel ships - just proves how little you have undocked since the hybrid rebalancing, null buff, and dram nerf. DD is clearly the most OP frig in the game. If you consider it an "angel ship", then please be more precise as to what you are talking about. If you want to suggest ways to fix the cynabal, then post a link to that thread so I can go there and discuss that with you. There are a number of problems with many faction ships and I will follow a link to the appropriate thread for discussing them.

For the majority of you, start here:

tl;dr
Yes there are individual ships that need work. Even some ship classes as a whole need work and fixes are currently in the works. To say nerf minmatar is beyond ignorant and just proves how little you play the game or how little you understand what you are doing when you undock. The game has great balance right now and it would be a shame to watch it destroyed by another epic whine thread. After all, do you really want to see a race almost unusable for 2 years again (read: Gallente)?


This.

OhmyfreakingGod THIS!!

Thank you, Sir: My faith in humanity--such as it ever isRoll--has been restored, for now.

Star Wars: the Old Republic may not be EVE. But I'll take the sound of dual blaster-pistols over "NURVV CLAOKING NAOW!!!11oneone!!" any day of the week.

Ahrieman
Codex Praedonum
Divine Damnation
#75 - 2012-03-02 04:36:10 UTC
Tarryn Nightstorm wrote:

Thank you, Sir: My faith in humanity--such as it ever isRoll--has been restored, for now.


Every once in a while, logic and reason needs to be brought into these discussions. Haven't seen those whiners around this thread much lately Cool

Solo Rifter since 2009

ElCholo
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#76 - 2012-03-02 05:15:39 UTC
This is for you idiots who still think that Minmatar are the end all be all of the pixel space ship world.
Izziee
University of Izziee
#77 - 2012-03-02 13:40:27 UTC
Jeremy Ironforge wrote:
1) Minnie vessels have the 2nd highest PG numbers, and often those numbers aren't that much lower than that of amarr.

2) Same goes for CPU... Horay! We stupid "technologically not advanced" nation sport awesome computers!

3) Meanwhile Autocannons require the least ammount of PG/CPU among turret close range systems.

4) Minnie vessels almost always have more slots! than their same tier counterparts from other races. And since you have ftting resources left...

wtf where's the balance here? Why does the game about ships anwsers the most crucial question - "which ship should I train for?" - with either "Drake" or "Cane" for years now!

PS I know there's Arty that requies hell lot of PG but there are also RCU's and some gallente ships with "-1 slot" to balance things out.



Okay, firstly, what does training for a drake have to do with minny ships? You're right with the fact which ship should I train for being the drake. I'm not saying it's OP, it's versatile. I don't care for it much, but I don't care how much others care for it either, each to their own, but it is one of the best ships to train for. Great at PvP, super cheap, can do L4's...well, almost any PvE except mining, tanks great...well,the list would go on.

So, yeah, that's caldari.

Anyway, you basically put all the great points about Minny into one post and call it OP. Each race has their own advantages too you know?

Amarr - Works in optimal, has huge optimal. Instant changing of ammo, has a lot of drone space on more ships than the other races (bar gal ofc!) Looks super sexy (Abaddon? I'd do that) and has a light show to light up all of space.

Caldari - Drake. Nothing else needs to be said really. Easily the best in choosing damage types, huge range.

Gal - Drones, drones and more drones. Huge range on rails, massive damage on blasters.

All have their good and bad sides, sure, blasters you need to get into range, and gallente are slow, but drones can be a nightmare to face. Amarr can struggle with certain damage types, Caldari have the drake (Bad side too you know! everyone uses it) and minny work in their fall off.

Ofc, it's a very simple post and there's a lot more to it than that, but each race has it's niche and place in space. It's not like you can't fly anything.

If you were forced down one path only able to choose one race's ship, then there would be problems, but you're not. You're capable of using any so there isn't a problem really. It's all about preference. If gallente ships wasn't so ugly I'd be flying in nothing but them, but alas, I can't handle how ugly they are. Min ships are strong but I'd personally put that down to them being shield tanked so all the lows can be fitted with gank, where as amarr/gal are usually armour meaning less gank. Can leave caldari out though since missiles are a whole different system from turrets, and rails generally are weak, but I think that's more to do with being a secondary weapon for Gal with drones primary.

Yeah, I don't know what I'm talking about, I just like hearing myself talk. It's still want i think though
OfBalance
Caldari State
#78 - 2012-03-02 20:23:31 UTC  |  Edited by: OfBalance
Izziee wrote:

Yeah, I don't know what I'm talking about, I just like hearing myself talk. It's still want i think though
DarkAegix
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#79 - 2012-03-02 20:51:18 UTC
Liang Nuren wrote:
Dirty Teacher wrote:
M1k3y Koontz wrote:
Jeremy Ironforge wrote:
Ahh just tried a Meta3 guns Armor Cane VS a T2 fitted Armor Harby. Guess who won?

Now that's ridiculous cuz Harby wasn't drained or jammed... Just outanked and outdpsed at all ranges.


I call shenanigans. With scorch a harby will easily out DPS an ARMOR cane at the edge of the harby's optimal. Also I know for a fact because I have flown both that a harby has more tank than a cane, so either that harby got neuted out because he was a lasor ship without a cap booster (terrible idea) or he decided to sit point blank on a ship that he could have out DPS'd at range.
Projectiles, lasors, heavy/HAMs and blasters are quite well balanced right now.


because it's totally easy for the harby to dictate range vs a hurricane right?


Did you read what he responded to? He's right to call shenanigans. Its just not possible.

-Liang

Ed: At least, not as presented it isn't possible.

EM damage multiF/Scorch vs. Armour Cane = A happy Cane
Explosive damage Fusion vs Armour Harby = An unhappy Harby

Receiving Fusion's damage types reduces my Harby's ehp by 7%, to 68.3k ehp.
Receiving Multi F's damage types increase my Cane's ehp by 23%, to 84.8k ehp.
Effectively, the Cane has 24% more ehp.

The flexibility of selectable damage types is a boon to Minmatar ships.
Ahrieman
Codex Praedonum
Divine Damnation
#80 - 2012-03-02 20:56:20 UTC
I agree that the selectable damage types for minnie is an advantage to the race, but that's one of the racial strengths that helps to offset many of their weaknesses.

Solo Rifter since 2009