These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Will Minmitar-Amarr relations improve?

Author
Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#61 - 2012-02-13 22:50:29 UTC
Ston Momaki wrote:
The slave culture in Amarr is just as much in need of Matriculation to free society as the rescued slave or recently emancipated slave. Until there is a humbling of the slave holder's heart and an admission that the Amarr faith should be spread not through slavery but through genuine living and benefiting all humankind, there will be no improvement of transnational relations.

Slavery was built over millennia; injustice was executed over milennia. Should the slave holder be impatient with a process of reconciliation that takes a long time? The perpetrator of injustice needs to be patient with the process of righting that wrong. Improvement will come when the those who once enslaved others build credibility over time and show over time that they can be trusted. There must first be an admission that slavery is not, nor ever was, of God. There must be an admission that slavery is and has always been ungodly to the core. The slave holder's repentance must not just be toward those enslaved but also towards the God who's name you have dragged into slavery as your justification.

The missing ingredient is humility, that most difficult of qualities that requires the bravest in spirit to realize.


I think you were pretty spot on here. But do you feel that there is a way for the Amarrian government to be able to make these people feel ashamed of owning slaves other than manipulating the words of God?

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Ston Momaki
Disciples of Ston
#62 - 2012-02-14 14:53:57 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Ston Momaki wrote:
The slave culture in Amarr is just as much in need of Matriculation to free society as the rescued slave or recently emancipated slave. Until there is a humbling of the slave holder's heart and an admission that the Amarr faith should be spread not through slavery but through genuine living and benefiting all humankind, there will be no improvement of transnational relations.

Slavery was built over millennia; injustice was executed over milennia. Should the slave holder be impatient with a process of reconciliation that takes a long time? The perpetrator of injustice needs to be patient with the process of righting that wrong. Improvement will come when the those who once enslaved others build credibility over time and show over time that they can be trusted. There must first be an admission that slavery is not, nor ever was, of God. There must be an admission that slavery is and has always been ungodly to the core. The slave holder's repentance must not just be toward those enslaved but also towards the God who's name you have dragged into slavery as your justification.

The missing ingredient is humility, that most difficult of qualities that requires the bravest in spirit to realize.


I think you were pretty spot on here. But do you feel that there is a way for the Amarrian government to be able to make these people feel ashamed of owning slaves other than manipulating the words of God?


The preponderance of theology must shift from God of judgment to God of grace. Both are found in Amarrian Scripture, but judgment has been emphasized. When grace is emphasized, the focus will change.

The Disciples of Ston bid you peace

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#63 - 2012-02-14 15:31:51 UTC  |  Edited by: Rodj Blake
Ston Momaki wrote:
The slave culture in Amarr is just as much in need of Matriculation to free society as the rescued slave or recently emancipated slave. Until there is a humbling of the slave holder's heart and an admission that the Amarr faith should be spread not through slavery but through genuine living and benefiting all humankind, there will be no improvement of transnational relations.

Slavery was built over millennia; injustice was executed over milennia. Should the slave holder be impatient with a process of reconciliation that takes a long time? The perpetrator of injustice needs to be patient with the process of righting that wrong. Improvement will come when the those who once enslaved others build credibility over time and show over time that they can be trusted. There must first be an admission that slavery is not, nor ever was, of God. There must be an admission that slavery is and has always been ungodly to the core. The slave holder's repentance must not just be toward those enslaved but also towards the God who's name you have dragged into slavery as your justification.

The missing ingredient is humility, that most difficult of qualities that requires the bravest in spirit to realize.


How can slavery be ungodly when it has brought many billions of Udorians, Ni-Kunni, Ealurians and Minmatars into God's loving embrace?

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#64 - 2012-02-14 17:05:50 UTC
Rodj Blake wrote:

How can slavery be ungodly when it has brought many billions of Udorians, Ni-Kunni, Ealurians and Minmatars into God's loving embrace?


Captain Blake, if I didn't know better, I'd think you were trying to understand us.

Believe me, it's a welcome change (no offense).

My wife, Conventia, phrased it extremely well:

'I want you to find God, but I know that I can't force it on you'.

if we're to be perfectly honest, Captain Blake, the issue of whether slavery is 'godly' or not is irrelevant (at least, to me). What matters is this:

You want us to 'find god', yet the way you show us 'God's love' is by chaining us up, beating us and forcing us to work in conditions that are likely to eventually kill us.

Not only that, but slavery effectively renders the thousands of years our ancestors spent developing a rich, vibrant culture -- something that we were proud to have accomplished, given the fickle nature of existence in general -- totally meaningless.

After seeing our people flourish and endure the hardships typical to any growing civilization, the Empire comes along one day and basically tells us we've done it all wrong. That, Captain Blake, reduces all of our accomplishments, all of our developments, all of what our people have created, to the level of a giant mistake.

Do you have any idea how that makes us feel? To suddenly have a bunch of total strangers arrive one day, look at everything we stand for -- everything that we value about our heritage and our culture -- and basically tell us 'everything you've done here is wrong, wrong, wrong'?

That's beyond insulting, Captain Blake. I know that you wouldn't appreciate someone doing it to you -- so why are you doing it to us?

I hope you understand the point I'm trying to make.

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Reann Amelana
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#65 - 2012-02-16 09:59:32 UTC  |  Edited by: Reann Amelana
I think that Minmatar and Amarr relations will be fine in time, after all look at the Ammatar; they have integrated very well into the Empire. Currently there is very little strife in the Ammatar mandate beyond the usual Inter-Empire skirmishes. This nonsense about the Minmatar inability to be self-governed has never been an issue there and is why we are trying to lead all of the nations to God. Surely all people would do well to redeem themselves voluntarily and not force your descendants to serve for generation for your misguided actions.

The proposed argument about forcing the destruction of the soul of those not far from redemption, for some sort of sick and twisted illusion of freedom is foolishness. Leave the Slaves be, within 10 generations as a maximum all the Minmatar slaves would be freed. Criminals will carry on being enslaved and made to work for their redemption, and by this constant aggression by the Minmatar we are being forced to extend the time that Slavery as you claim to hate will continue, as we try to redeem those who have been captured in your incessant raids into our space. As our Holy Empress has said:
And to all who hear my words, I say this; What you give to this Empire I shall give back unto you.

Those who aggress us will pay, those who offer us peace shall have peace, turn to God, redeem yourselves.

((Edited to try and clarify my statements, apologies it has been a tough week at work and I hastily wrote this up and posted it before reviewing it. should really avoid doing this over a rushed lunch in future))
Kalaratiri
Full Broadside
Deepwater Hooligans
#66 - 2012-02-16 12:11:17 UTC
Reann Amelana wrote:
I think that Minmatar and Amarr relations will be fine in time after all look at the Ammatar, they have integrated very well into the Empire, there is very little strife beyond the usual Inter-Empire skirmishes. This nonsense about the Minmatar inability to be self governed has never been an issue there and is why we are trying to lead all of the nations to God.
These arguments about forcing the destruction of the soul of those not far from redemption for some sort of sick and tweisted perversion of freedom is foolishness. Leave the Slaves be, within 10 generations as a maximum all the slaves would be freed. Criminals will carry on being enslaved and made to work for thier redemption, and by this constant agression by the minmatar we are being forced to extend the time that Slavery as you claim to hate will continue as we try to redeem those who have been captured in your incessant raids into our space. As our Holy Empress has said:
And to all who hear my words, I say this; What you give to this Empire I shall give back unto you.

Those who agress us will pay, those who offer us peace shall have peace, turn to God, redeem yourselves.


Sorry.. can you do this again using punctuation and paragraphs? I actually cannot follow what you are saying, my mind just gets lost in the block of text. I've read this through three times now, and by the time I've finished, still have no idea what you said at the start.

Thanks.

She's mad but she's magic, there's no lie in her fire.

This is possibly one of the worst threads in the history of these forums.  - CCP Falcon

I don't remember when last time you said something that wasn't either dumb or absurd. - Diana Kim

ValentinaDLM
SoE Roughriders
Electus Matari
#67 - 2012-02-16 13:28:24 UTC
Kalaratiri wrote:
Reann Amelana wrote:
I think that Minmatar and Amarr relations will be fine in time after all look at the Ammatar, they have integrated very well into the Empire, there is very little strife beyond the usual Inter-Empire skirmishes. This nonsense about the Minmatar inability to be self governed has never been an issue there and is why we are trying to lead all of the nations to God.
These arguments about forcing the destruction of the soul of those not far from redemption for some sort of sick and tweisted perversion of freedom is foolishness. Leave the Slaves be, within 10 generations as a maximum all the slaves would be freed. Criminals will carry on being enslaved and made to work for thier redemption, and by this constant agression by the minmatar we are being forced to extend the time that Slavery as you claim to hate will continue as we try to redeem those who have been captured in your incessant raids into our space. As our Holy Empress has said:
And to all who hear my words, I say this; What you give to this Empire I shall give back unto you.

Those who agress us will pay, those who offer us peace shall have peace, turn to God, redeem yourselves.


Sorry.. can you do this again using punctuation and paragraphs? I actually cannot follow what you are saying, my mind just gets lost in the block of text. I've read this through three times now, and by the time I've finished, still have no idea what you said at the start.

Thanks.


It says something like, "Everything is gonna work out, just look at the Ammatar, and people who don't like slavery are the ones making it take so long."

There is a certain logic in what he says, but the truth is outside of implants, vitoc, etc you probably will never have a situation where everyone just embraces god, and even if they do, what does it matter? I see people who "embrace god" fight each other all the time, so the way I am seeing it, a lasting peace isn't going to result from a Victorious Amarr Empire, merely fighting will shift from proxy wars between states, to proxy wars between nobles.
Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#68 - 2012-02-16 20:32:35 UTC
Clarification : the Ammatar have never been slaves to the Amarr.
Payens De'Molay
Retired Soldier Ltd.
#69 - 2012-02-17 01:56:58 UTC
WHY would these so called "relations" improve?

We of the TRUE Amarr are simply the superior race and the Minmatar are our slaves - it is that simple.
However, do not be fooled thinking it is only the "rugged mixed genepool of a race" who are of the lesser races.

Necrophor - my new Death/Black metal project; http://www.facebook.com/Necrophor

Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#70 - 2012-02-17 04:09:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Astrid Stjerna
Payens De'Molay wrote:
WHY would these so called "relations" improve?

We of the TRUE Amarr are simply the superior race and the Minmatar are our slaves - it is that simple.
However, do not be fooled thinking it is only the "rugged mixed genepool of a race" who are of the lesser races.


It's very telling that for such a 'superior race', you make such extensive use of slaves to do the work you can't handle.

What's the matter? Can't find the 'on' button on that fancy mining laser?

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Uraniae Fehrnah
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#71 - 2012-02-17 05:18:57 UTC
The occasional humorously intended comment aside, I've been trying to avoid this conversation. However it doesn't appear to be going away and at some point, if something doesn't go away then it's simply prudent to acknowledge it.

With the current state of affairs, and the current leadership of each respective empire, I personally do not see how relations between the Amarr and the Matari could improve in any meaningful fashion. A good deal of changes, on both sides, will need to naturally come about for the peace process to have any sort of foundation to be built upon. Those changes are of course going to be, if they even come about at all, difficult for both parties. Those changes have been and continue to be resisted, stifled, and stymied at every official turn. Thus far the only saving grace of the entire situation is that both sides are currently abiding by Concord regulations and keeping the conflict limited in scope, for the most part.

However, despite how dire this whole situation seems to be, and regardless of the fact that by all indications things will get worse before they get better, I hold out hope for one simple reason. Few and far between they might be, but there are capsuleers who rise above the petty and simple hatreds. There are Amarrian capsuleers who respect Matari capsuleers and the reverse is true as well. Further, some take that beyond simple respect and can honestly say they have friends "on the other side" of this convoluted conflict. This fact, plain and insignificant as it might seem, might actually be enough to serve as a catalyst for better relations. After all, we are the latest breed of humanity's social, economic, and military elite.

Perhaps it's time more of us carry the flag to the negotiation table rather than to the battlefield.
Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#72 - 2012-02-17 20:25:07 UTC
Payens De'Molay wrote:
WHY would these so called "relations" improve?

We of the TRUE Amarr are simply the superior race and the Minmatar are our slaves - it is that simple.
However, do not be fooled thinking it is only the "rugged mixed genepool of a race" who are of the lesser races.



Racial superiority is a rather poor argument for anything these days. Especially considering us capsuleers can genetically modify ourselves to take on somewhat different appearances.

Plus recent history shows that the Minmatar can definitely take on the Amarr in a frontal assault. Gallente intervention would be enough to overwhelm the empire.

Which brings me back to my point, the Caldari are the only people stopping the Republic and the Federation from out right teaming up on the Empire.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Drasden
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#73 - 2012-02-18 01:15:47 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
Plus recent history shows that the Minmatar can definitely take on the Amarr in a frontal assault. Gallente intervention would be enough to overwhelm the empire.


If by 'Frontal Assault' you refer to the Elder Fleet invasion, then I will point out that the Republic does not have access to those forces. Neither do the Minmatar that launched the invasion, not after Sarum's 'miracle' wiped a third of it from existence and a good deal of the rest was destroyed by more conventional means.

The Minmatar Republic has the weakest military of the four major powers, while the Amarr Empire has both the largest fleet in the cluster and the military support of the Ammatar Mandate and the Khanid Kingdom (Which, I will point out, is somewhat more advanced than that of the Republic or Federation). While the Minmatar people as a whole were certainly capable of doing some considerable damage once, the idea that the Republic is capable of taking the Amarr States in a straight fight is nothing more than fantasy.

I will say that it would be a hard fight if the Amarr faced both the Gallente and Minmatar, but I wouldn't place a single ISK on the Caldari State sitting idle while the Federation's military was preoccupied with an armed invasion of it's ally. Politics aside, that would be an awfully large target for Heth to pass up.
Ares Renton
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#74 - 2012-02-18 01:24:48 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
After all much of why the Republic despises the Empire is because of Slavery.


Myth.

The Republic despises the Empire because they are a primitive and warlike people whose only uniting trait is jealousy of their betters.
Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#75 - 2012-02-18 06:15:59 UTC
Ares Renton wrote:
Fredfredbug4 wrote:
After all much of why the Republic despises the Empire is because of Slavery.


Myth.

The Republic despises the Empire because they are a primitive and warlike people whose only uniting trait is jealousy of their betters.


Jealousy.

Really.

It's not because they invaded our home, attempted to destroy our people, and used Vitoxin to poison us for seven hundred years?

Could've fooled me.

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#76 - 2012-02-18 06:21:21 UTC
Drasden wrote:
Khanid Kingdom (Which, I will point out, is somewhat more advanced than that of the Republic or Federation).


Putting missile weapon systems on heavy armour ships is hardly advanced, even Roden's managed to achieve that.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Drasden
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#77 - 2012-02-18 11:53:32 UTC
Caellach Marellus wrote:

Putting missile weapon systems on heavy armour ships is hardly advanced, even Roden's managed to achieve that.


Did I point to the armour/missile combination as proof of the Kingdom's technological advantage? I don't recall doing so. If I were to get into specifics, I would likely put more stress on the fact that the Royal Khanid Navy's ships are kept more up-to-date than the most. This is for the very simple reason, of course, that up until just recently (In the timespan of Holders) it was constantly under the threat of an invasion from the Imperial Fleet. Lacking the materials or personnel necessary to field a large navy (The Ammatar Mandate has slightly more territory and infrastructure than us), the King instead chose to make sure what he had was on the cutting edge of military technology.

It is difficult for capsuleers to remember that factional navies vary in how updated they ,are since we only use the latest versions of each chassis. But just because a pod-equipped Merlin and a pod-equipped Punisher can be compared as vessels of roughly equal value (Subject to personal taste) does not mean that a State Navy Merlin and an Imperial Fleet Punisher can be held side-by side with a straight face.
Payens De'Molay
Retired Soldier Ltd.
#78 - 2012-02-18 17:07:25 UTC
Fredfredbug4 wrote:


Racial superiority is a rather poor argument for anything these days. Especially considering us capsuleers can genetically modify ourselves to take on somewhat different appearances.



Poor Argument? Just because YOU think your powers are equal to that of God does not make it so.
It is a simple fact, we ARE the chosen of God and thus superiour in every way.

And dear Astrid Stjerna, really, tasks we could not handle?
For feeble minds I will put it very simple, think of it as we being the Ceo of a company and the minmatar as the cleaners of that said company. If they do a good job they might very well one day earn the blessing of being taught the holy scriptures.

Necrophor - my new Death/Black metal project; http://www.facebook.com/Necrophor

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#79 - 2012-02-18 17:58:23 UTC
Payens De'Molay wrote:
Fredfredbug4 wrote:


Racial superiority is a rather poor argument for anything these days. Especially considering us capsuleers can genetically modify ourselves to take on somewhat different appearances.



Poor Argument? Just because YOU think your powers are equal to that of God does not make it so.
It is a simple fact, we ARE the chosen of God and thus superiour in every way.



I agree, you are the Chosen of God. The children of God even. Do you know what properties a child has?

- Ignorance
- Impatience
- Helplessness
- Laziness
- and Unrealistic views on the world

God has realized that you people are worthless and insignificant on your own and because God is kind he has decided to help you out a bit. But like any parent when their children start to get older, the parent gets fed up that the kids are still leeching off of their success and as a result the Empire has been slowly, but surely losing it's ancient glory. It is apparent to anyone who has visited the Empire or are among the lower classes within it but like a child, True Amarr don't understand what is happening and merely think that nothing is wrong.

Your wealth and power? A birthright coupled with the blood sweat and tears of millions of hard working people.

I'll even use my nation's enemies, the Caldari State as an example. While they may have wayward views, their determination, and hard work has brought them up to become one of the most powerful, if not the most powerful nation in all of New Eden. They did the work themselves. I feel that God has chosen people like the Caldari in another, way. As a people that God knows will work hard so he guarantees their success.

God has given the my Federation the ability of free will and reason. The ability to feel and act how we want paired with the ability to think our way though every situation has got us to the position of power and success we enjoy today.

The Republic has been bestowed with cunning and reliability. They have been known to come up with great ways to get a job done and make sure it actually gets done.

And back to the Empire. What has he given them? Luck, to make up for the Empire's inability to act and think on it's own.




Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#80 - 2012-02-18 18:22:24 UTC  |  Edited by: Rodj Blake
Fredfredbug4 wrote:


I agree, you are the Chosen of God. The children of God even. Do you know what properties a child has?

- Ignorance
- Impatience
- Helplessness
- Laziness
- and Unrealistic views on the world



And yet amazingly this race that you consider to be ignorant, impatient, helpless, lazy and unrealistic has not only created the largest and most powerful empire in human history but has also absorbed many other races along the way.

But of course, we're none of those things.

Take the charge of impatience for example. It's not us that's calling for rapid change - it's you.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori