These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[New PLEX System] An Alternative Change

Author
Uriel Paradisi Anteovnuecci
Itsukame-Zainou Hyperspatial Inquiries Ltd.
Arataka Research Consortium
#1 - 2017-04-29 06:53:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Uriel Paradisi Anteovnuecci
So we all know about the new PLEX system coming soon - it's a change many take issue with for lots of different reasons (the Vault being one of the biggest), and I've come up with what I'd personally have preferred in place of what's happening now. I know many might think otherwise, but that's why it's a "suggestion":

Instead of "PLEX", call the new currency a different name (there's no reason to call it a Pilot-License-Extension):
  • New (currency) would be tradeable on-market as with the current new system, & have an accout-wide "Vault"
  • Instead of using 500 "PLEX" to add 30 days of game time, spend 500 (currency) for a PLEX on the NES

  • A "PLEX" bought on the store would exist as an item, and not be reverse-redeemable for (currency):
  • The License Extension would be tradeable on-market, the same as other pilot services (e.g. Extractors/Resculpts)
  • The License can be activated to add 30 days of gametime to your account or to a chosen other character's account
  • The License would not be able to be safe in the "(currency) Vault", retaining the risk that comes with moving one
  • (This also preserves PLEX-tanking as a viable fitting option)

  • Additionally, an easy change for immersion's sake would be to change the New Eden Store's name:
  • The store might be called, for example, "The Empyrean Exchange - a joint service of CONCORD and Interbus"
  • This provides a more immersive and less jarring store, which makes more sense in-world
  • It also matches the idea of CONCORD providing the licenses and services available to "Empyreans"

  • Adding some personal bias into this as well, the new system makes PLEX feel worthless in comparison to the old system - the new icons seem cheap compared to the old & gold & valuable-looking one, and the images for purchase of the new PLEX on the online store are uncomfortably close to how lots of freemium or mobile games advertize their premium currency.

    Thinking of why CCP may have gone with what they did for the new system, though, it seems like the new system's currency is only called PLEX for the sake of name recognition by players; if they took PLEX off the online store and only had this differently named currency, the "no more buying plex oh no! they're doing microtransactions CCP is bad!" crowd would likely be very vocal and backlash could occur, even if you could purchase a REAL PLEX in-game and trade it around exactly as before.

    I'd personally be far happier with things changing to be more like what I described above - and I know it likely won't affect anything to suggest it here, but I've got some strong feelings about the new system and I know many others who feel similarly.

    -Uriel
    Akrasjel Lanate
    Immemorial Coalescence Administration
    Immemorial Coalescence
    #2 - 2017-04-29 07:26:41 UTC
    If it going be live on 9th May it's a bit late about thinking of any more changes, maybe there will be more in the future.

    CEO of Lanate Industries

    Citizen of Solitude

    Rivr Luzade
    Coreli Corporation
    Pandemic Legion
    #3 - 2017-04-29 09:19:59 UTC
    Uriel Paradisi Anteovnuecci wrote:
    Adding some personal bias into this as well, the new system makes PLEX feel worthless in comparison to the old system - the new icons seem cheap compared to the old & gold & valuable-looking one, and the images for purchase of the new PLEX on the online store are uncomfortably close to how lots of freemium or mobile games advertize their premium currency.

    That's likely the point behind it. With these changes, you are supposed to hoard and buy lots of cheap, worthless currency to exchange it for money-grab-scheme items in their store in order to give them more money than they deserve from the subscription. CCP has been pushing hard into that same direction for a couple of years now. Instead of giving people more compelling reasons to subscribe, they go the way of clawing money out of the player pockets with cheap and largely useless items of questionable appeal and quality.

    UI Improvement Collective

    My ridicule, heavy criticism and general pale outlook about your or CCP's ideas is nothing but an encouragement to prove me wrong. Give it a try.

    Merin Ryskin
    Peregrine Industries
    #4 - 2017-04-29 09:39:21 UTC
    Rivr Luzade wrote:
    That's likely the point behind it. With these changes, you are supposed to hoard and buy lots of cheap, worthless currency to exchange it for money-grab-scheme items in their store in order to give them more money than they deserve from the subscription. CCP has been pushing hard into that same direction for a couple of years now. Instead of giving people more compelling reasons to subscribe, they go the way of clawing money out of the player pockets with cheap and largely useless items of questionable appeal and quality.


    You do know that none of the prices are changing, right? The cost in real-world money to buy a given item remains exactly the same, the only change is that you can now trade on the in-game market in units of fractional PLEX. So I don't see how any reasonable person could call this a money grab, especially when you continue to be free to ignore the existence of those "largely useless" items.
    Rivr Luzade
    Coreli Corporation
    Pandemic Legion
    #5 - 2017-04-29 09:53:25 UTC
    The money grab in this entire thing is that you get presented with items of questionable quality (the really lackluster Charon skins, for instance, which have severe defects) that cost or have cost you several months of game time in AUR value (the titan skins or special edition skins, for instance), although this has always been marketed as "micro transactions". CCP so far has also put very little effort into dispersing this false claim and only very recently started offering higher quality skins that actually deserve the title "visual improvement" as well as allow players to gain skins via playing the game, not via paying real money for them. I don't see how a reasonable person could not call this a money grab.

    UI Improvement Collective

    My ridicule, heavy criticism and general pale outlook about your or CCP's ideas is nothing but an encouragement to prove me wrong. Give it a try.

    Cade Windstalker
    #6 - 2017-04-29 14:13:44 UTC
    Your idea here basically defeates the entire point of the change, which is to have a single currency that's bought and sold on the market instead of PLEX which is redeemable for AURUM but can't be transitioned back to PLEX cleanly.

    Also there's nothing stopping you from PLEX tanking your ship after the changes. You don't *have* to use the vault, and I suspect some people won't.

    Oh and the new system removes pretty much all references to PLEX as a Pilot's License Extension. They're calling it PLEX because that's what everyone in and outside the game knows and it's simplifies the transition.

    Rivr Luzade wrote:
    The money grab in this entire thing is that you get presented with items of questionable quality (the really lackluster Charon skins, for instance, which have severe defects) that cost or have cost you several months of game time in AUR value (the titan skins or special edition skins, for instance), although this has always been marketed as "micro transactions". CCP so far has also put very little effort into dispersing this false claim and only very recently started offering higher quality skins that actually deserve the title "visual improvement" as well as allow players to gain skins via playing the game, not via paying real money for them. I don't see how a reasonable person could not call this a money grab.


    Because that's not what a money grab is?

    CCP have spent a ton of time and effort improving the SKIN tech, you also get pretty much full knowledge of what you're buying before you buy it and you can even try it out on the Test Server if you have concerns about the ship preview lighting.

    A money grab indicates some kind of duplicity or scam, and that very little effort is expended in the endeavor. CCP have spent a ton of time and effort on this, at the demand of the players I might add, and the whole thing is pretty transparent in terms of purchasing, what you're getting, ect.

    The only reason I can see for calling anything like this a "money grab" is because you don't like SKINs and feel CCP should have spent their time on something else. That's a fair desire, but it doesn't make the money grab claim true.
    Do Little
    Bluenose Trading
    #7 - 2017-04-29 17:26:47 UTC
    Aurum had an account wide wallet and I imagine the PLEX vault was the easiest way to consolidate the currencies without a lot of development effort. In my opinion both the more granular PLEX and the account wide PLEX vault are quality of life improvements to the game.

    Skins and clothing are vanity items - 100% optional and they confer absolutely no gameplay advantage. A completely voluntary transaction where both parties perceive themselves better off - not a cash grab. Extractors confer no gameplay value by themselves - a player needs to fill them with earned SP. PLEX purchased from CCP and converted to ISK in game will let you buy shiny stuff but most players don't think of that as pay-to-win since the shiny stuff tends to explode unless you have the player skill to use it effectively.
    Vokan Narkar
    Doomheim
    #8 - 2017-04-29 23:31:29 UTC
    The new currency should be named anything but PLEX....
    Sobaan Tali
    Caldari Quick Reaction Force
    #9 - 2017-04-30 01:03:33 UTC
    Vokan Narkar wrote:
    The new currency should be named anything but PLEX....


    Probably the one thing I see being unanimously requested.

    "Tomahawks?"

    "----in' A, right?"

    "Trouble is, those things cost like a million and a half each."

    "----, you pay me half that and I'll hump in some c4 and blow the ---- out of it my own damn self."

    Nevyn Auscent
    Broke Sauce
    #10 - 2017-04-30 02:27:11 UTC
    Sobaan Tali wrote:

    Probably the one thing I see being unanimously requested.

    I do not think that word means what you think it does.
    Cade Windstalker
    #11 - 2017-04-30 03:26:32 UTC
    Nevyn Auscent wrote:
    Sobaan Tali wrote:

    Probably the one thing I see being unanimously requested.

    I do not think that word means what you think it does.


    Gotta second this. It's been requested a few times by a few people. Most really don't seem to care, and I've seen about an order of magnitude more discussion over whether or not the market history should be carried over, which indicates that the majority of players are fine with the name staying around, even if you can trade it for more things.
    Rivr Luzade
    Coreli Corporation
    Pandemic Legion
    #12 - 2017-04-30 07:37:58 UTC
    Cade Windstalker wrote:
    A money grab indicates some kind of duplicity or scam, and that very little effort is expended in the endeavor. CCP have spent a ton of time and effort on this, at the demand of the players I might add, and the whole thing is pretty transparent in terms of purchasing, what you're getting, ect.

    The only reason I can see for calling anything like this a "money grab" is because you don't like SKINs and feel CCP should have spent their time on something else. That's a fair desire, but it doesn't make the money grab claim true.

    Have you checked the clothing items? Same model for all vastly different empires and cultures, just with different colors. Or the still being sold skins, for instance, for the caldari freighters, which still have massive defects (lack of secondary colors) or the vastly overpriced capital skins? Or the Kador and EOM skins, which is just a color swap? I see all your points for the money grab fulfilled.

    UI Improvement Collective

    My ridicule, heavy criticism and general pale outlook about your or CCP's ideas is nothing but an encouragement to prove me wrong. Give it a try.

    Cade Windstalker
    #13 - 2017-04-30 16:29:38 UTC
    Rivr Luzade wrote:
    Cade Windstalker wrote:
    A money grab indicates some kind of duplicity or scam, and that very little effort is expended in the endeavor. CCP have spent a ton of time and effort on this, at the demand of the players I might add, and the whole thing is pretty transparent in terms of purchasing, what you're getting, ect.

    The only reason I can see for calling anything like this a "money grab" is because you don't like SKINs and feel CCP should have spent their time on something else. That's a fair desire, but it doesn't make the money grab claim true.

    Have you checked the clothing items? Same model for all vastly different empires and cultures, just with different colors. Or the still being sold skins, for instance, for the caldari freighters, which still have massive defects (lack of secondary colors) or the vastly overpriced capital skins? Or the Kador and EOM skins, which is just a color swap? I see all your points for the money grab fulfilled.


    None of that is a money grab:

    • I know people who quite like those Freighter skins. Also if you've missed it they've been going back and tweaking some of the older skins a little as models get updated.

    • EoM and Kador skins have been requested for literally years, even before SKINs were a thing.

    • The various faction shirts are fairly cheap in terms of AUR, as I said before you can see exactly what you're getting, you're not forced to buy anything, and if you don't want it you don't need to get it. Again, there are people who want this stuff and it helps pay for the development of the rest of Eve.

    • There are plenty of clothing options available that are unique to the various empires and cultures.

    • SKIN prices go up as the cost of the hull goes up. They're vanity items, if you can afford a Titan you can afford a couple of PLEX to make every Titan you'll ever fly a different color of shiny.


    Seriously, this seems less like any actual criteria for a money grab and more than you don't like it so you're complaining, but saying "I don't like the available items on offer" is, for some reason, not something you want to express so instead you're calling it a money grab...
    Rivr Luzade
    Coreli Corporation
    Pandemic Legion
    #14 - 2017-04-30 17:34:38 UTC  |  Edited by: Rivr Luzade
    This is not about liking, it's about defective skins. It's also about ridiculous prices for skins. You just need to look at the red crossed out numbers behind the new prices. A full plex worth of AUR for a Dominix skin, this is not micro transaction.

    This is not about how many people have requested EOM/Kador skins, it's about how EOM/Kador are exact mirror copies of each other. Not to mention that the EOM paintjob was ruined by CCP before they introduced that skin. It used to be a really nice looking matte gray base with metallic ocean blue accents, after the changes it all turned into the same plasticy look.

    There are barely any unique clothing items available at all for any faction. There are Marshall jackets or Outlaw packs for every faction, which are just different paintjobs for the same jacket, same goes for trousers, women clothing like the "Executor" and so on. There is no unique Blood Raider clothing available, no unique Serpentis or Angel Cartel clothing, nothing, it's all just copies with different colors.

    I do not like these things at all. However, this is not primarily the reason why I complain about them. The reason why I do that is because CCP puts no effort into them. There is lots of potential for really awesome clothing items (I would look for a deviant art concept collection on unique new eden clothing lines for the empires and pirates that I found years ago, but neither you nor CCP care about that. This is something related, though ) but instead of putting proper effort into this and make it really awesome, CCP hides behind "maintainability of features" and puts out cheap stuff for exorbitant prices.

    UI Improvement Collective

    My ridicule, heavy criticism and general pale outlook about your or CCP's ideas is nothing but an encouragement to prove me wrong. Give it a try.

    Cade Windstalker
    #15 - 2017-05-01 15:15:58 UTC
    Rivr Luzade wrote:
    This is not about liking, it's about defective skins. It's also about ridiculous prices for skins. You just need to look at the red crossed out numbers behind the new prices. A full plex worth of AUR for a Dominix skin, this is not micro transaction.

    This is not about how many people have requested EOM/Kador skins, it's about how EOM/Kador are exact mirror copies of each other. Not to mention that the EOM paintjob was ruined by CCP before they introduced that skin. It used to be a really nice looking matte gray base with metallic ocean blue accents, after the changes it all turned into the same plasticy look.

    There are barely any unique clothing items available at all for any faction. There are Marshall jackets or Outlaw packs for every faction, which are just different paintjobs for the same jacket, same goes for trousers, women clothing like the "Executor" and so on. There is no unique Blood Raider clothing available, no unique Serpentis or Angel Cartel clothing, nothing, it's all just copies with different colors.

    I do not like these things at all. However, this is not primarily the reason why I complain about them. The reason why I do that is because CCP puts no effort into them. There is lots of potential for really awesome clothing items (I would look for a deviant art concept collection on unique new eden clothing lines for the empires and pirates that I found years ago, but neither you nor CCP care about that. This is something related, though ) but instead of putting proper effort into this and make it really awesome, CCP hides behind "maintainability of features" and puts out cheap stuff for exorbitant prices.


    It really is, just because you think it's priced too high doesn't mean it's not a micro-transaction. $20 for a permanent cosmetic is no where near the most I've seen charged, and when you consider that it really is 100% permanent and can be bought with in-game money it's not even that much. Every micro-transaction model is going to have a different pricing setup, if CCP are selling SKINs and their internal metrics say that the model is working and meeting expectations based on their pricing structure then it's working fine.

    That's been the EoM and Kador color scheme going back to basically the start of the game, if CCP changed it you can bet they'd get complaints. Yes, EoM used to have a more matte-black base, though the new look is metallic grey, not plastic. That's kinda down to personal preference though.

    That's probably because modeling unique clothing for niche factions like the pirates is really really time consuming and isn't likely to have a great return on the time and effort spent. That's why all of the unique and faction specific stuff is for the base races. Not making stuff that won't sell well doesn't make the other stuff a cash grab, it's just smart time management.

    I don't think it's that CCP doesn't care. They've put a *ton* of time and effort into developing their SKIN tech, and I'm sure there are artists at CCP who would love to spend more time doing more interesting clothing. The fact of the matter is though that the playerbase has indicated, strongly, that they don't want CCP to focus on anything WiS related at the cost of in-space features. So when you say "puts no effort into them" what the project manager in me sees is "doesn't allocate time away from other things for them" because it's not a case of effort, it's a case of time spent on that vs something else.

    Want more interesting clothing? Poke the CSM, organize the playerbase, and get enough people together to show CCP that there's demand for iteration on WiS without another riot occurring.