These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Docking capital ships in structures

Author
Beyl Ahashion
Working Community 2
#1 - 2017-03-27 11:33:03 UTC
I propose adding a service for the medium structures (Astrahaus, Raitaru, and whatever the medium refinery is called) that allows capital ships to dock. This will allow those that can't afford the next size up of structure, but feel like they need capital ships for whatever reason, to be able to dock them in the smaller structures. But it will cost them one of the valuable service slots to do so.
Rivr Luzade
Coreli Corporation
Pandemic Legion
#2 - 2017-03-27 13:10:15 UTC
Valuable service slots? You just put up a cheap Raitaru that is dedicated for that purpose.

UI Improvement Collective

My ridicule, heavy criticism and general pale outlook about your or CCP's ideas is nothing but an encouragement to prove me wrong. Give it a try.

Danika Princip
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#3 - 2017-03-27 17:41:20 UTC
...If you can afford a capital ship fleet, you can afford a fortizar.
Cade Windstalker
#4 - 2017-03-27 18:08:32 UTC
I wish I could find something to add to this but the first two responses pretty much summed things up. Lol
Ajem Hinken
WarFear Gaming
#5 - 2017-03-28 00:18:51 UTC
Why would a cap be able to fit into a station that doesn't even have enough space of the right shape to fit it inside?

https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=6875494#post6875494 - Ship mounted explosives. Because explosions and Jita chaos.

Bjorn Tyrson
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#6 - 2017-03-28 02:33:36 UTC
Danika Princip wrote:
...If you can afford a capital ship fleet, you can afford a fortizar.

Arden Elenduil
Unlimited Bear Works
#7 - 2017-03-28 09:23:44 UTC
So what's next, caps in highsec?

Beyl Ahashion
Working Community 2
#8 - 2017-03-30 20:19:09 UTC
Danika Princip wrote:
...If you can afford a capital ship fleet, you can afford a fortizar.

Sometimes responses make me laugh. Cost of a capital ship 1.2 bil, cost of a Fortizar 12 bil plus slots, rigs, and fuel. That is more than a factor of 10 difference. Do you actually think about what you say before you say it?

Currently you can store a capital ship in a tiny part of the smallest tower, that already exists for other purposes, via an SMA (I know because I do). Cost <50 mil. Or you can switch to the new upwell structures, and by the time you are done, it will cost well over 15 bil. And the only reason that you would REQUIRE that huge upwell structure? To replace that 50 mil SMA. That is over 300 times as much isk. And you think the upwell structure qualifies as-is for a 1:1 replacement structure??? Who do we really think that we are kidding. And that 15 bil translates to approximately $220 US dollars. So you want everyone to have to pay an additional $220 dollars just to dock a capital ship a few months from now??? And hope that someone doesn't decide to blow it up just for a few minutes of kicks and giggles, costing you that $220 of real money???

All I was asking for was something to try to make the new upwell structures somewhat more usable as a direct replacement for the exiting towers, without increasing people's costs by a factor of 300 if they try to do so.

I guess we'll see how many people rejoice at a 300 times cost increase, and how many just throw in the towel and say "forget it, its too expensive".

Some day people will realize that out of everyone playing Eve, not everyone is part of a 1000 player alliance, to whom isk means nothing, nor wants to be. For some of us, real money, i.e. isk, really does matter.
Danika Princip
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#9 - 2017-03-30 20:35:06 UTC
If you have enough of a fleet of capital ships to need to dock them in a structure, then you can drop 12b on a fortizar. You don't need to fit the thing to use it as a stager.

The USD cost is irrelevant. If there are enough players to go with your capital fleet, you can make it out of incursions, wormholes, lowsec moons, l5s, industry, even capital ratting if you're one of the cool kids who do that kind of krabbing, in a week or two. Or less if there's more than a dozen of you. Which, since you want a place to stash an entire capital fleet and npc stations are no good, I can only assume there is.

You could also just go with the old 'hey corpmates we're buying a fortizar please donate', which should cover it if anyone in your croup is halfway competent.
Beyl Ahashion
Working Community 2
#10 - 2017-03-30 20:40:24 UTC
Danika Princip wrote:
If you have enough of a fleet of capital ships to need to dock them in a structure, then you can drop 12b on a fortizar. You don't need to fit the thing to use it as a stager.

The USD cost is irrelevant. If there are enough players to go with your capital fleet, you can make it out of incursions, wormholes, lowsec moons, l5s, industry, even capital ratting if you're one of the cool kids who do that kind of krabbing, in a week or two. Or less if there's more than a dozen of you. Which, since you want a place to stash an entire capital fleet and npc stations are no good, I can only assume there is.

You could also just go with the old 'hey corpmates we're buying a fortizar please donate', which should cover it if anyone in your croup is halfway competent.

You don't need a "fleet". You only need 1. So my comparison of 1 in an SMA vs needing a Fortizar, IS valid.

As I said, try to stop thinking about trying to force everyone into Goons, and try thinking about people that are smaller than Goons. Believe it or not, they DO exist. Atleast until CPP prices them out of the game.
Danika Princip
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#11 - 2017-03-30 20:43:13 UTC
Why is an NPC station not an option for you? Why is just using the tether range of an astrahus not good enough for you? Why is a pos not good enough? We'll have them around for a few years yet.

Have CCP actually announced docking rules for refineries yet? Or is one of those too expensive for you as well?
Beyl Ahashion
Working Community 2
#12 - 2017-03-30 21:00:28 UTC
Danika Princip wrote:
Why is an NPC station not an option for you? Why is just using the tether range of an astrahus not good enough for you? Why is a pos not good enough? We'll have them around for a few years yet.

Have CCP actually announced docking rules for refineries yet? Or is one of those too expensive for you as well?


If I had access to an NPC station, then that would do just fine, even be preferred, but I don't. The tether range of an Astrahaus requires that the character never leave the ship, making that character no longer able to "play the game" when the capital ship is not needed, which is most of the time. A POS is a fantastic solution, and I am more than happy with the current POS arrangements, but my understanding is that those are going away, and certainly all the other uses of the POS (which currently justify the high fuel costs) are all going away and being moved to the new structures.

This is not a "refineries" problem. This is a problem with the new direction of moving everything over to the new Upwell Structures. I don't care if capital ship docking is limited to only Astrahauses. I don't care if I have to trade something, like a service slot, to get the functionality. I don't even care if a limit of only a few capitals (perhaps 3 or 4) is placed on the new ability. All I am trying to do is to maintain the ability of small groups to be able to still do what they are currently doing, when the transition to the new structures is complete. I am not asking for any new abilities. I'm not even asking for the price of the abilities to remain as low as it currently is today (~50 mil one-time expense). I am just asking that the ability to continue doing it, with one or more of the entry level structures, remains some how, some way.
FT Diomedes
The Graduates
#13 - 2017-03-31 11:31:05 UTC
Beyl Ahashion wrote:
Danika Princip wrote:
Why is an NPC station not an option for you? Why is just using the tether range of an astrahus not good enough for you? Why is a pos not good enough? We'll have them around for a few years yet.

Have CCP actually announced docking rules for refineries yet? Or is one of those too expensive for you as well?


If I had access to an NPC station, then that would do just fine, even be preferred, but I don't. The tether range of an Astrahaus requires that the character never leave the ship, making that character no longer able to "play the game" when the capital ship is not needed, which is most of the time. A POS is a fantastic solution, and I am more than happy with the current POS arrangements, but my understanding is that those are going away, and certainly all the other uses of the POS (which currently justify the high fuel costs) are all going away and being moved to the new structures.

This is not a "refineries" problem. This is a problem with the new direction of moving everything over to the new Upwell Structures. I don't care if capital ship docking is limited to only Astrahauses. I don't care if I have to trade something, like a service slot, to get the functionality. I don't even care if a limit of only a few capitals (perhaps 3 or 4) is placed on the new ability. All I am trying to do is to maintain the ability of small groups to be able to still do what they are currently doing, when the transition to the new structures is complete. I am not asking for any new abilities. I'm not even asking for the price of the abilities to remain as low as it currently is today (~50 mil one-time expense). I am just asking that the ability to continue doing it, with one or more of the entry level structures, remains some how, some way.


I agree with the OP. The new structures are a significant gut punch in this regard for smaller groups. They work just fine for large groups. Expecting a smaller group to actually get a Fortizar online is an absurdity in most parts of space, even without looking at the cost of the structure. I really loath the "you must be this large to ride" aspect that permeates the Upwell structures. It's a significant limitation on who can thrive in the sandbox. And so, it does not surprise me to see Goons and Darkness in here saying "it works just fine."

With that said, any modification that benefits smaller groups will also benefit larger groups immensely. So, the OP needs to adjust his request. Add a service module that allows capitals to dock to an Astrahus (but only an Astrahus) and then allow one or two capital ships to dock for each service module of that type that is fitted. If you have more capital ships in the Astrahus than you have service modules fitted, the structure automatically ejects the excess capital ships into space. This allows the smaller groups to actually use Upwell structures and capitals (without having to use capital holding alts), while limiting larger groups' ability to spam cheap structures to hold capital fleets.

CCP should add more NPC 0.0 space to open it up and liven things up: the Stepping Stones project.

Kenrailae
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#14 - 2017-03-31 13:44:21 UTC
A fortizar CAN be done, depending on the variables...... but good luck joining the keepstar klub without paying the requisite isk to everyone to not blow it up.

The Law is a point of View

The NPE IS a big deal