These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Have Multiboxers and Botting ruined Eve Online?

Author
TigerXtrm
KarmaFleet
Goonswarm Federation
#21 - 2017-03-26 02:40:45 UTC
Mina Sebiestar wrote:
Quote:
there is not


If mining wasn't possible to do while in coma than i hazard to guess seeing 20 alts sucking belt away wouldn't be that much of an issue.

you don't see 20 alts running l4 mission


That's why I said "as long as it's practical". Not to mention the majority of these f*cksticks still use ISBoxer anyway, no matter how illegal it is. Commanding 20 accounts manually, even if it's just mining, is no easy task and I refuse to believe people do that entirely by hand. That's also where some of the frustration comes from. Even after the hurf blurf against ISBoxer by CCP, it's still basically cheating.

My YouTube Channel - EVE Tutorials & other game related things!

My Website - Blogs, Livestreams & Forums

Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#22 - 2017-03-26 02:43:11 UTC
Soel Reit wrote:
making mining more interactive can resolve this problem?
basically changing the "semi-afk" style that is required right now to mine :)

through minigames or whatever



As others have posted that mining is a coma operation.... this idea has merit. Again as posted above one person posted " you don't see L4 missions being done by bots and multiboxers"...
There may need to be an addition to mining to curtail th eA.F.K. part of this.
Kaeden 3142
State War Academy
Caldari State
#23 - 2017-03-26 02:53:44 UTC  |  Edited by: Kaeden 3142
A lot of peeps have multi accounts for logistic operations. A game without the local eyes and cyno alt would be much more interesting if the jump mechanic was done on by activing map pinpoints. This would create more opportunities for single account holders
Kapricani
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#24 - 2017-03-26 02:57:48 UTC
7 years ago when i quit eve it was an issue. Multiboxing was a huge thing and there was hulkageddon as a reaction of players for that. The same solutions were proposed like "make mining more of an activity then afk brain dead zombie thing." And yet 7 years have passed and here we are.

This issue is still annoying me in this game. I came back here because of friends that wanted to try eve out but this issue is making me question buying omega anytime soon.

Its clear that CCP does not want to resolve it. and somehow i suspect that multiboxing is build in to the economy now.
I bet its one of the reasons they need those economists to balance the market because the raw materials are just too damn cheap.
Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#25 - 2017-03-26 03:02:10 UTC  |  Edited by: Trebon Luap
Kapricani wrote:
7 years ago when i quit eve it was an issue. Multiboxing was a huge thing and there was hulkageddon as a reaction of players for that. The same solutions were proposed like "make mining more of an activity then afk brain dead zombie thing." And yet 7 years have passed and here we are.

This issue is still annoying me in this game. I came back here because of friends that wanted to try eve out but this issue is making me question buying omega anytime soon.

Its clear that CCP does not want to resolve it. and somehow i suspect that multiboxing is build in to the economy now.
I bet its one of the reasons they need those economists to balance the market because the raw materials are just too damn cheap.



I do understand that Eve is a Player Built Economy and that the raw resources are what drives this, at the most basic point, but is CPP allowing this issue to continue simply because of the drop in the player base and if they were to actually "do something" about it, it would crash the economy?
TackyTachy1
Doomheim
#26 - 2017-03-26 03:20:04 UTC
Don't know much about bots but I am a multi-boxer, three accounts, 7 characters, bunch of ships. On my fourth year with three home built computers and the reason for the three accounts was to fly three ships simultaneously, run specialized characters and yes, have fun with it. Thing is, there are advantages and disadvantages to multi-ship operation. Hi-sec mining is about the only place where multi-ship ops really work; I fly a couple Skiffs and chase cans and rat kills with a freighter.

Three Skiffs in a worm hole can work, right up until it doesn't work. Biggest problem is running three ships in a firefight, especially when I'm not the greatest PvP pilot in the 'Verse. Big heart breaker: Losing three high end ships with three high end fits, think Legion, Dominix NI and a Rapier, all within about a horrifying five minutes. But I'm working on different tactics and so maybe next time out I can do better.

I like the small, routine advantages of multi-boxing. Either selling ore/minerals, rat loot and stuff or buying fit modules, many times the best price is in lo-sec or even in null-sec and I like being able to run an Ares or Nemesis on a scout mission before going in with the big bucks.

Thing is, if the bots and the gankers and even the over aggressive cowboys next door get on your nerves you can always move. There are quiet systems with all the services and asteroid belts you could ask for, and while not exactly safe (nowhere in Eve is exactly safe) the characters that inhabit these systems tend to be a bit more laid back than the more excitable denizens of what usually winds up having high percentages of noobs in house.

I've moved twice in four years, and while my current home is working out rather well if it goes sour then I can move again.

And while I realize there as many ways to play this game as there are players I've never understood the obsession with maximizing ISK/hr, seems like a stressed out job, and I've had enough of those. I play to have fun, and when I don't especially feel logging on then I don't.

Forum Rep for a bunch of characters, couple corps and one seriously Lost In Space multiboxer.

Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#27 - 2017-03-26 03:33:57 UTC
TackyTachy1 wrote:
Don't know much about bots but I am a multi-boxer, three accounts, 7 characters, bunch of ships. On my fourth year with three home built computers and the reason for the three accounts was to fly three ships simultaneously, run specialized characters and yes, have fun with it. Thing is, there are advantages and disadvantages to multi-ship operation. Hi-sec mining is about the only place where multi-ship ops really work; I fly a couple Skiffs and chase cans and rat kills with a freighter.

Three Skiffs in a worm hole can work, right up until it doesn't work. Biggest problem is running three ships in a firefight, especially when I'm not the greatest PvP pilot in the 'Verse. Big heart breaker: Losing three high end ships with three high end fits, think Legion, Dominix NI and a Rapier, all within about a horrifying five minutes. But I'm working on different tactics and so maybe next time out I can do better.

I like the small, routine advantages of multi-boxing. Either selling ore/minerals, rat loot and stuff or buying fit modules, many times the best price is in lo-sec or even in null-sec and I like being able to run an Ares or Nemesis on a scout mission before going in with the big bucks.

Thing is, if the bots and the gankers and even the over aggressive cowboys next door get on your nerves you can always move. There are quiet systems with all the services and asteroid belts you could ask for, and while not exactly safe (nowhere in Eve is exactly safe) the characters that inhabit these systems tend to be a bit more laid back than the more excitable denizens of what usually winds up having high percentages of noobs in house.

I've moved twice in four years, and while my current home is working out rather well if it goes sour then I can move again.

And while I realize there as many ways to play this game as there are players I've never understood the obsession with maximizing ISK/hr, seems like a stressed out job, and I've had enough of those. I play to have fun, and when I don't especially feel logging on then I don't.



To be fair, in my opinion, What you are doing, running three ships at once is not the problem. To simply put a number on it... when a multiboxer is running seven or more ships at the same time, that is when things take a turn for the worst.
Multiboxing at the higher numbers just destroys the concept of Eve; or any other MMO for that matter.

I can watch a Corp. hit an Ice belt with 30+ members and have no ill feelings toward the players, but when I know a Multiboxer is at a belt and harvesting all the materials, I get a bad taste in my mouth.
The Corp. members are and will bring so much more to the game simply because they are a diverse group of people interacting in the game world. Massive Multiboxers are just a bad sign that a game has gone down a undesirable path that can lead to ruin.
Vash Bloodstone
State War Academy
Caldari State
#28 - 2017-03-26 03:46:36 UTC
You've played this game 4 years, supposedly, and than you see this multi-box fleet and now your at the end of your rope? You about to quit now? Sounds to me, like you not having fun and you were eventually going to quit Eve anyway and this multi-box fleet is just a excuse. Ask yourself, why did you mine in the first place? Do you even like mining? If you do, you shouldn't be so concerned with what others are doing. The other guy is probably spending a lot of time and resources to multi-box. He is making a trade-off, that you haven't made. It may not ideal that he could be using real life money to get ahead. But who wants to spend lots of money on this game anyway? That's no accomplishment. Instead, focus on why your playing. If your playing for fun, than your good, but if your mining just to earn isk, than not only are you a fool, but your doomed to failure. Chasing isk, especially by mining will only lead to disappointment. It is my belief that the true measure of success in Eve is not how much isk you have, but how much fun you have. If your not having fun, than maybe you should just quit.
Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#29 - 2017-03-26 04:09:43 UTC
Vash Bloodstone wrote:
You've played this game 4 years, supposedly, and than you see this multi-box fleet and now your at the end of your rope? You about to quit now? Sounds to me, like you not having fun and you were eventually going to quit Eve anyway and this multi-box fleet is just a excuse. Ask yourself, why did you mine in the first place? Do you even like mining? If you do, you shouldn't be so concerned with what others are doing. The other guy is probably spending a lot of time and resources to multi-box. He is making a trade-off, that you haven't made. It may not ideal that he could be using real life money to get ahead. But who wants to spend lots of money on this game anyway? That's no accomplishment. Instead, focus on why your playing. If your playing for fun, than your good, but if your mining just to earn isk, than not only are you a fool, but your doomed to failure. Chasing isk, especially by mining will only lead to disappointment. It is my belief that the true measure of success in Eve is not how much isk you have, but how much fun you have. If your not having fun, than maybe you should just quit.



You are oversimplifying this issue. The multiboxing and botting fleets are becoming more and more prevalent in "day-to-day" game play.
This is not some ad hoc issue that I just decided to start posting about after four years of game play.
Yes, I am considering letting my sub run out and not re-upping because I see no real tangible effort from CCP to actually engage the issue; other than some random bans (so they say) from time to time, with no noticeable effect in the actual game play . No, not just from my first hand experience, but from the many other people I interact with in game.

For you to say that I need to feel for some multiboxer that is at the heart of this issue.... I say huh? what? The actions they are taking are what I am against and the question being....if what they are doing is ruining Eve?
I would not of kept playing Eve if I did not enjoy it on some level. So I say you make assumptions. You call me a fool? What?
You call me a Fool for discussing a topic on a forum set up to discuss issues people have concern with...? Again Huh? What?
Aitu
Slap Fight Martial Artists
#30 - 2017-03-26 04:13:29 UTC
I've never found this game entertaining when just running one client. Everything's slower and more frustrating.
I manually multi box but I would love to see how far I could take scripting and botting.
I'd love it if they allowed all kinds of botting since I feel like CCP just tries to look the other way if they can anyway.
Defecanda
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#31 - 2017-03-26 04:15:52 UTC
Developers put intensive work into this game throughout the years.
Server maintenance, payroll, accounting, etc.. all these things are more than likely routine and machine-like for CCP a this point.
This being said, you probably now have a few apathetic guys at the top who are receiving a comfortable income from the player base and do not care about reinvestment. Thus, the game will not improve until this revenue stream is drastically interrupted.

Create a database of multi-boxers.
Harass them relentlessly via coalition (like a Hulkageddon initiative).
If done consistently, these multiboxers will no longer be profitable.
Combine the loss of these 10x revenue generators with the average player loss already occurring, then the few guys at the top in Iceland will be forced to get back to development.


SAVE EVE!!!!!

[i][b]CCP Zulu.....      Forcing players to dock at the captain's quarters is a form of what we actually wanted to get through, which is making Incarna a seamless part of the EVE Online experience. [/b](i like to steal sigs)[/i]

Alasdan Helminthauge
AirHogs
Hogs Collective
#32 - 2017-03-26 04:31:18 UTC
I guess that if this is really ruining Eve Online, CCP will definitely do something to solve it. Now that CCP hasn't done anything, so multiboxers and botting shouldn't have been a threat to the player base. EVE is not a young game, and multiboxers and botting have existed as long as EVE itself, but we're still playing here. People leave (you can also leave), People come. Eve is neither too lively, but it's always alive.
Even if the situation gets worse, like on the Chinese server where the proxy company does nothing against RMT and bots, there're still people playing and having fun.
If you find this a fatal problem, just quit and look for fun elsewhere. We don't consider this as a problem and we'll still play.

Or maybe you can try to bump those 30 mining alts out of mining range one by one and mock the multiboxer in local Pirate.
Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#33 - 2017-03-26 04:33:52 UTC
Aitu wrote:
I've never found this game entertaining when just running one client. Everything's slower and more frustrating.
I manually multi box but I would love to see how far I could take scripting and botting.
I'd love it if they allowed all kinds of botting since I feel like CCP just tries to look the other way if they can anyway.



I'm not sure if you are just out fishing with this post but.....I'll bite.

So in the future if Eve was to open up the gates for multiboxing and a large majority of players where to do this, the online numbers would probably look amazing, but if you were to break the numbers down you would most likely see that the actual player base was dismal.
With the dismal player base there would be no future for Eve.

I do tend to believe that CCP has looked the other way on this issue, as the sticky thread that was locked shows; I am leaning towards the reality that no matter what people say here in the forums nothing will be done about this issue; another thread is discussing the topic of multiboxers in PvP and Mission running; it is more of a discussion on how hard it is to do than the effects it has on Eve in general.

In reality they know how to fix it, but the cost , the true cost would close the doors of operation. The bottom line is, after all, based in Real Life and real money.
Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#34 - 2017-03-26 04:41:45 UTC
Alasdan Helminthauge wrote:
I guess that if this is really ruining Eve Online, CCP will definitely do something to solve it. Now that CCP hasn't done anything, so multiboxers and botting shouldn't have been a threat to the player base. EVE is not a young game, and multiboxers and botting have existed as long as EVE itself, but we're still playing here. People leave (you can also leave), People come. Eve is neither too lively, but it's always alive.
Even if the situation gets worse, like on the Chinese server where the proxy company does nothing against RMT and bots, there're still people playing and having fun.
If you find this a fatal problem, just quit and look for fun elsewhere. We don't consider this as a problem and we'll still play.

Or maybe you can try to bump those 30 mining alts out of mining range one by one and mock the multiboxer in local Pirate.




I would like to see the numbers for the player base of Eve.
To see how many and how long the multiboxers have been playing their characters in relation to the newly subed player base; and the time gap in between the two.

If most of the multiboxers have been playing Eve for 5+ plus years and the newer players have been only been around for one year +- a few months. It would be interesting to see if the new players are sticking around and if new players are actually signing up, or if the player base is actually just consisting of the new alts and accounts of the senior players.

That ratio would show if Eve is still here or not.
Shae Tadaruwa
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#35 - 2017-03-26 04:51:11 UTC
Trebon Luap wrote:
On average there is what? 24000 pilots online? With the Botts and the Multiboxers added into this number there is what? only 18000 to 16000 individual players online? (Or less?)

CCP Quant has previously published details on the numbers of alts per player:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Eve/comments/3j7nso/at_least_we_know_how_many_alts_there_are/cun2q2o/

He's also previously outlined, at least back for 2014, the number of players logging in per day and month, showing that PCU isn't really a good measure of the number of people playing EVE:

https://puu.sh/uDuwy/d40321e21b.png

Lrebon Laup wrote:
And as the sub base has gone down in the same time frame.... would you you not say that the issue is not playing out?

Has it?

How do you know this? Do you have the numbers?

Dracvlad - "...Your intel is free intel, all you do is pay for it..." && "...If you warp on the same path as a cloaked ship, you'll make a bookmark at exactly the same spot as the cloaky camper..."

Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#36 - 2017-03-26 05:05:23 UTC
Shae Tadaruwa wrote:
Trebon Luap wrote:
On average there is what? 24000 pilots online? With the Botts and the Multiboxers added into this number there is what? only 18000 to 16000 individual players online? (Or less?)

CCP Quant has previously published details on the numbers of alts per player:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Eve/comments/3j7nso/at_least_we_know_how_many_alts_there_are/cun2q2o/

He's also previously outlined, at least back for 2014, the number of players logging in per day and month, showing that PCU isn't really a good measure of the number of people playing EVE:

https://puu.sh/uDuwy/d40321e21b.png

Lrebon Laup wrote:
And as the sub base has gone down in the same time frame.... would you you not say that the issue is not playing out?

Has it?

How do you know this? Do you have the numbers?




I don't have the official number to share but, I am guessing since you have the knowledge of where to find the number you have "post quoted" you could direct me to them.

As anecdotal... When I first started playing Eve the average number of players online was right around the 40,000 number mark.
Vash Bloodstone
State War Academy
Caldari State
#37 - 2017-03-26 05:07:33 UTC
Trebon Luap wrote:

The actions they are taking are what I am against and the question being....if what they are doing is ruining Eve?
I would not of kept playing Eve if I did not enjoy it on some level. So I say you make assumptions. You call me a fool? What?
You call me a Fool for discussing a topic on a forum set up to discuss issues people have concern with...? Again Huh? What?


I've made no assumptions, I've only speculated. Anyway, you've offered no evidence of how multi-boxers have hurt the game, except that they've hurt you in some in some unspecified way. On the contrary, I would argue they help game tremendously. If you accept the idea that miners help the game by providing the ores needed to build ships, than multi-boxers do this in spades. By providing the ores, they help keep prices lower, which keeps ships affordable and allows others to keep flying. It's critical to the economy. On top of this, multi-boxers may help give CCP more money, which is good for the game in the long run. So, how exactly is Eve being ruined by them?

Think of mining like farming in the real world. Multi boxers are like advanced farming equipment, they allow 1 person to do the work of many. Which is good, because instead of working on the farm, people can go into the city and get better jobs. Or instead of everyone mining, people can pvp or something.
Trebon Luap
Hard Rock Mining Inc.
#38 - 2017-03-26 05:20:15 UTC
Vash Bloodstone wrote:
Trebon Luap wrote:

The actions they are taking are what I am against and the question being....if what they are doing is ruining Eve?
I would not of kept playing Eve if I did not enjoy it on some level. So I say you make assumptions. You call me a fool? What?
You call me a Fool for discussing a topic on a forum set up to discuss issues people have concern with...? Again Huh? What?


I've made no assumptions, I've only speculated. Anyway, you've offered no evidence of how multi-boxers have hurt the game, except that they've hurt you in some in some unspecified way. On the contrary, I would argue they help game tremendously. If you accept the idea that miners help the game by providing the ores needed to build ships, than multi-boxers do this in spades. By providing the ores, they help keep prices lower, which keeps ships affordable and allows others to keep flying. It's critical to the economy. On top of this, multi-boxers may help give CCP more money, which is good for the game in the long run. So, how exactly is Eve being ruined by them?

Think of mining like farming in the real world. Multi boxers are like advanced farming equipment, they allow 1 person to do the work of many. Which is good, because instead of working on the farm, people can go into the city and get better jobs. Or instead of everyone mining, people can pvp or something.



I am saying they are hurting Eve in the way that their game play affect the new to Eve player base. New and not so new players see and compete with these multiboxers and find that there is no way to compete with them on any footing. Then because of this, these people leave Eve and the player base does not grow. A multiboxer may add another account to his fold but , in my opinion, this new multibox account is far less useful to the Eve gaming community.

If you want to compare Multibox miners to Farming in the real world, you may want to look into that analogy a little deeper.
When the corporations took over the Family Farms, they may produce more at lower cost, but the ripple effect of the loss of small family farms was enormous. The deep negative effects far outweighed the positives. Overworking of the soil, massive increase in the use of pesticides and herbicides, cattle and hog waste run-off into waterways... the list goes on.

Sorry I digress....
Shae Tadaruwa
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#39 - 2017-03-26 05:41:57 UTC
Trebon Luap wrote:
I don't have the official number to share but, I am guessing since you have the knowledge of where to find the number you have "post quoted" you could direct me to them.

No one but CCP has the numbers, which makes your declaration that the sub base has gone down kind of a useless statement.

How much has it declined?

Quote:
As anecdotal... When I first started playing Eve the average number of players online was right around the 40,000 number mark.

Really? Average was 40,000? Where are the numbers coming from?

Dracvlad - "...Your intel is free intel, all you do is pay for it..." && "...If you warp on the same path as a cloaked ship, you'll make a bookmark at exactly the same spot as the cloaky camper..."

Bjorn Tyrson
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#40 - 2017-03-26 06:17:32 UTC
can someone explain this to me please... on the one hand I keep hearing about how multi-boxers are ruining eve. and how no one can ever make a profit because of how many afk miners are in the belts.

but at the same time I constantly hear about how no one can ever make money mining because the second they get into a belt they get ganked...

so is it the afk miners who are running the gank fleets or something? or is there somehow a plague of gankers preventing any mining AND an armada of afk miners prevening mining??? why are the afk mining fleets not being bothered? and if mining ships are so easy to gank, why aren't you out ganking the afk miners?