These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Humanitarian Organizations

Author
Valerie Valate
Church of The Crimson Saviour
#21 - 2017-02-21 19:52:43 UTC
Alizabeth Vea wrote:
the Sisters of EVE might be considered humanitarian.


Those naked strumpets ? Humanitarian ?

Outrageous !

Doctor V. Valate, Professor of Archaeology at Kaztropolis Imperial University.

Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#22 - 2017-02-21 19:56:09 UTC
Basically... yeah, some combat is okay. We are fairly unique in New Eden that we don't have anyone to protect us other than ourselves. Humanitarian organizations elsewhere can rely on legal protection or have other forms of protection ensuring that the organization itself can do nothing but humanitarian work.

We don't have that luxury. If we do anything besides staying docked, it's entirely up to us to protect those ventures, be they humanitarian or not.

Combat on its own shouldn't be a factor in whether or not a capsuleer organization qualifies as humanitarian. It's the motivations and primary focus of it that should be the prime yardstick and any combat activity on record needs to be evaluated on its own, to see if it's wanton enough to disqualify the humanitarian aspect.

And just in case someone misunderstands me, no, I have never been part of a humanitarian organization, I personally do not in any way qualify as a humanitarian worker and so on and so forth. The work I do through and for the Network, the staging center in Muttokon or the aid services for freed slaves and so on fall short of those prerequisites on several points.
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#23 - 2017-02-21 19:57:18 UTC  |  Edited by: Aria Jenneth
Alizabeth Vea wrote:
Also, the Sisters of EVE might be considered humanitarian, but I tell you, they are up to some shady stuff.


Well-- really, maybe that's even kind of what this discussion is arising from: "humanitarian" is a great adjective to hide a bunch of awful stuff behind.

The SOE's done some great humanitarian work, and I'm not sure many people really dispute that. That they are, as a whole, a humanitarian organization has gotten a little hard to defend as a statement, though, especially since they gave everybody the Alpha-class clone technology. That basically meant they very proactively helped a very deadly class of weapon proliferate.

Yes, I mean us. Opposing us was, on its face, a more humanitarian policy.

Lately I start to wonder whether "the Sisters of Eve is a humanitarian organization" might be most accurate when talking about diet.



(Joking. But.)
Kador Ouryon
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#24 - 2017-02-21 21:05:54 UTC
Alizabeth Vea wrote:
Should a Humanitarian Organization be afforded some protection from attack, either in custom or de jure?


Doesn't really matter. It was a pitiable display of bravado from State based groups I should be able to respect...

They systematically proved themselves beneath contempt.

What fills the soul? Something that guides a lost child back to it's parents arms. Or waves that dye the shores of the heart gold. A blessed breath to nurture life in a land of wheat. Or the path the Sef descend drawn in ash. In the wake of fire.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#25 - 2017-02-22 05:36:40 UTC  |  Edited by: Pieter Tuulinen
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
@ Pieter: So no wardec and trying to take on my corporation or alliance's assets? Just going to whine at me on the forums instead? I mean, I've pretty much done exactly the same things your latest targets did. I've sent mails, I've spoken the truth about you and so on. This was enough to justify the war then, so I wonder what is different now?

Maybe that you don't actually have the ******* guts to take on organizations that aren't largely non-combat entities, so instead you whine here when called on your nonsense.

Hypocrisy indeed. Coward.

Winds, you've been the one crying about it, Miz. If you don't like what the organisations involved did, why don't YOU do something about it, instead of being the proof of your own pudding?

Explain to me why I should have to put the legwork in, when you're the one with the chapped ass, here?

You know where to find me. If you want to teach me a lesson, stop talking about hitting me and come hit me. Maybe your words would become worth listening to if they were attached to deeds.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#26 - 2017-02-22 05:50:47 UTC
Kador Ouryon wrote:
Alizabeth Vea wrote:
Should a Humanitarian Organization be afforded some protection from attack, either in custom or de jure?


Doesn't really matter. It was a pitiable display of bravado from State based groups I should be able to respect...

They systematically proved themselves beneath contempt.

Ah, the respect of jaiiji. How much we crave that.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Nameira Vanis-Tor
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#27 - 2017-02-22 07:55:42 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
@ Pieter: So no wardec and trying to take on my corporation or alliance's assets? Just going to whine at me on the forums instead? I mean, I've pretty much done exactly the same things your latest targets did. I've sent mails, I've spoken the truth about you and so on. This was enough to justify the war then, so I wonder what is different now?

Maybe that you don't actually have the ******* guts to take on organizations that aren't largely non-combat entities, so instead you whine here when called on your nonsense.

Hypocrisy indeed. Coward.


Aside from interpretation of 'truth' from someone uninvolved in events. There is a difference between the actions of a corporations CEO and a member of a corporation undertaking personal interests/grudges. Your equivalency to the situation is false, unless you speak for Corelli or MC suddenly?

It sounds like you are bordering on involving MC in what appears to be a personal objection to our actions; which is likely well beyond your authority.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#28 - 2017-02-22 08:10:31 UTC  |  Edited by: Mizhara Del'thul
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
@ Pieter: So no wardec and trying to take on my corporation or alliance's assets? Just going to whine at me on the forums instead? I mean, I've pretty much done exactly the same things your latest targets did. I've sent mails, I've spoken the truth about you and so on. This was enough to justify the war then, so I wonder what is different now?

Maybe that you don't actually have the ******* guts to take on organizations that aren't largely non-combat entities, so instead you whine here when called on your nonsense.

Hypocrisy indeed. Coward.

Winds, you've been the one crying about it, Miz. If you don't like what the organisations involved did, why don't YOU do something about it, instead of being the proof of your own pudding?

Explain to me why I should have to put the legwork in, when you're the one with the chapped ass, here?

You know where to find me. If you want to teach me a lesson, stop talking about hitting me and come hit me. Maybe your words would become worth listening to if they were attached to deeds.


I have never talked about hitting you, Pieter. All I've done is show right here that you and yours are very selective about who you try to suppress with violence and who you just whine and whinge about when they point out your failings and lies. Again, I am guilty of every little thing you used to justify your attack on your latest targets and we have plenty of shiny assets in space. Tell me, why are you not jumping to 'defend honor' and so on? Why is it suddenly on others to come be as low and pathetic as you and yours? Because you know you can't just silence this one with violence.

You know what would have avoided all of this? Honesty. This kind of thing happens almost every damn day in New Eden and people would barely have raised an eyebrow at it, if it hadn't been for the smarmy torrent of self-contradictory and pathetic pretense about why you did it. Just another day in New Eden, just another act of thuggery and destruction for self-aggrandizement and personal profits and people would have shrugged and moved on.

It just speaks volumes that you and yours still have to play pretend about it and then whine pitifully when called on it, and then demonstrate the hypocrisy quite clearly, that your 'honor' turns out to be worthless when you can't 'defend it' with thuggery. Not even just a coward, but a lying one. Pathetic.

Nameira Vanis-Tor wrote:
Aside from interpretation of 'truth' from someone uninvolved in events. There is a difference between the actions of a corporations CEO and a member of a corporation undertaking personal interests/grudges. Your equivalency to the situation is false, unless you speak for Corelli or MC suddenly?

It sounds like you are bordering on involving MC in what appears to be a personal objection to our actions; which is likely well beyond your authority.


I speak for no one but myself indeed and I have no influence on who or where Mercenary Coalition deploys against. Since even just undocking for a single op tends to have a price tag of quite a few billion, this largely safeguards almost every entity that is ever represented on these boards from attention simply because it's never a cost effective measure.

It is still rather telling that you and yours scrounge together, what... four or was it five different wardecs over the words of a small and harmless group and then backpedal hard and instead just whine when that's not so easily achieved. Or is your 'honor' suddenly worth quite a bit less when it is impugned by someone like me rather than an easy punching bag?
Elanion
#29 - 2017-02-22 08:11:34 UTC
As spokesperson for UC, I would invite New Eden's capsuleers to refrain from flippant assumptions that every member of every corporation makes every public remark as an official dictum of policy and/or intent for their respective employers.

Your cluster thanks you.

RIP YC111-115"The project discarded, its subjects forgotten... thence must the burden be shouldered."

Kalaratiri
Full Broadside
Deepwater Hooligans
#30 - 2017-02-22 08:30:37 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Again, I am guilty of every little thing you used to justify your attack on your latest targets and we have plenty of shiny assets in space.


No you're not.

She's mad but she's magic, there's no lie in her fire.

This is possibly one of the worst threads in the history of these forums.  - CCP Falcon

I don't remember when last time you said something that wasn't either dumb or absurd. - Diana Kim

Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#31 - 2017-02-22 08:31:35 UTC
Kalaratiri wrote:
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Again, I am guilty of every little thing you used to justify your attack on your latest targets and we have plenty of shiny assets in space.


No you're not.


Might want to go have a lot of posts in that other thread 'justifying' the attacks edited out then.
Kalaratiri
Full Broadside
Deepwater Hooligans
#32 - 2017-02-22 08:46:22 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Kalaratiri wrote:
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Again, I am guilty of every little thing you used to justify your attack on your latest targets and we have plenty of shiny assets in space.


No you're not.


Might want to go have a lot of posts in that other thread 'justifying' the attacks edited out then.


Why?

She's mad but she's magic, there's no lie in her fire.

This is possibly one of the worst threads in the history of these forums.  - CCP Falcon

I don't remember when last time you said something that wasn't either dumb or absurd. - Diana Kim

Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#33 - 2017-02-22 09:00:20 UTC
The State Protectorate is a humanitarian organization, as we slay those, who threaten the humanity - Gallente Federation armed forces. Oh, and TLF of course, because these savages threaten the civilization as well.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Syenna Celeste
Sunny Weather Mercenaries
The Initiative.
#34 - 2017-02-22 09:57:03 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Kalaratiri wrote:
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Again, I am guilty of every little thing you used to justify your attack on your latest targets and we have plenty of shiny assets in space.


No you're not.


Might want to go have a lot of posts in that other thread 'justifying' the attacks edited out then.


Are we thinking of the same thread?

Thinking about it I can see why you'd have trouble reading from the usual Minmatar engagement range of 300km. What I didn't realise is that this methodology carried across to the IGS.

Put your hands around my heart and squeeze me until I'm dry.

Tyrukko Sakala
Guri Raiders
#35 - 2017-02-23 20:52:51 UTC
I wouldn't mind a list of these Humanitarian groups. I'm sure we could work out an arrangement to ensure their protection.

Guri Raiders Pirate // Don't want to get your hands dirty? Drop a line.

Olga Drottning
Sunny Weather Mercenaries
The Initiative.
#36 - 2017-02-23 22:01:38 UTC
Alizabeth Vea wrote:

Second Question: Should a Humanitarian Organization be afforded some protection from attack, either in custom or de jure?


I don't see any reason why capsuleer organizations should need any protection in and of themselves. If a group devoted to the protection of baseliners is incapable of defending itself then it isn't serving its purpose. Of course, I'm biased: Antumbra is founded on this principal.
Nameira Vanis-Tor
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#37 - 2017-02-23 22:21:23 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
@ Pieter: So no wardec and trying to take on my corporation or alliance's assets? Just going to whine at me on the forums instead? I mean, I've pretty much done exactly the same things your latest targets did. I've sent mails, I've spoken the truth about you and so on. This was enough to justify the war then, so I wonder what is different now?

Maybe that you don't actually have the ******* guts to take on organizations that aren't largely non-combat entities, so instead you whine here when called on your nonsense.

Hypocrisy indeed. Coward.

Winds, you've been the one crying about it, Miz. If you don't like what the organisations involved did, why don't YOU do something about it, instead of being the proof of your own pudding?

Explain to me why I should have to put the legwork in, when you're the one with the chapped ass, here?

You know where to find me. If you want to teach me a lesson, stop talking about hitting me and come hit me. Maybe your words would become worth listening to if they were attached to deeds.


I have never talked about hitting you, Pieter. All I've done is show right here that you and yours are very selective about who you try to suppress with violence and who you just whine and whinge about when they point out your failings and lies. Again, I am guilty of every little thing you used to justify your attack on your latest targets and we have plenty of shiny assets in space. Tell me, why are you not jumping to 'defend honor' and so on? Why is it suddenly on others to come be as low and pathetic as you and yours? Because you know you can't just silence this one with violence.

You know what would have avoided all of this? Honesty. This kind of thing happens almost every damn day in New Eden and people would barely have raised an eyebrow at it, if it hadn't been for the smarmy torrent of self-contradictory and pathetic pretense about why you did it. Just another day in New Eden, just another act of thuggery and destruction for self-aggrandizement and personal profits and people would have shrugged and moved on.

It just speaks volumes that you and yours still have to play pretend about it and then whine pitifully when called on it, and then demonstrate the hypocrisy quite clearly, that your 'honor' turns out to be worthless when you can't 'defend it' with thuggery. Not even just a coward, but a lying one. Pathetic.

Nameira Vanis-Tor wrote:
Aside from interpretation of 'truth' from someone uninvolved in events. There is a difference between the actions of a corporations CEO and a member of a corporation undertaking personal interests/grudges. Your equivalency to the situation is false, unless you speak for Corelli or MC suddenly?

It sounds like you are bordering on involving MC in what appears to be a personal objection to our actions; which is likely well beyond your authority.


I speak for no one but myself indeed and I have no influence on who or where Mercenary Coalition deploys against. Since even just undocking for a single op tends to have a price tag of quite a few billion, this largely safeguards almost every entity that is ever represented on these boards from attention simply because it's never a cost effective measure.

It is still rather telling that you and yours scrounge together, what... four or was it five different wardecs over the words of a small and harmless group and then backpedal hard and instead just whine when that's not so easily achieved. Or is your 'honor' suddenly worth quite a bit less when it is impugned by someone like me rather than an easy punching bag?


I'm glad you have such a low opinion of our opponents in the war of MITG (70 pilots) vs Sanxing, Electus Matari and Villore Accords (237 Pilots). Fortunately for our 'punching bag' they dared not risk too much in opposing us, although they had multiple opportunities and plenty of time to form a response.

The other war decs were entirely those other entities affairs. Additionally Sanxing only received aid against our war declaration to my knowledge, their allies could have engaged our assets without having to worry about any other parties on the field. In fact we were disappointed that they didn't make an appearance.

We would happily relieve you of some assets should the opportunity arise, a mercenary who shrieks in sympathy pain with incompetent humanitarians and their mostly cowering allies is hardly worthy of the profession due to rank hypocrisy. Shout 'oh the humanity' as much as you like whilst you go on about your clients business of killing for cash.

For us you as a pilot are a target of opportunity, for you we are unassailable and that drives you to these great shows of public outrage backed by total inaction.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#38 - 2017-02-23 22:28:35 UTC
Oh dear, I must have hit a nerve. An illiterate one at that, or perhaps it's just cherrypicking and willful ignorance on display. Next you'll tell me all twenty thousand goons are combat operatives or something.

What astounds me is just how many of you starts whining and whinging when called on your nonsense.
Nameira Vanis-Tor
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#39 - 2017-02-23 22:44:53 UTC
Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
Oh dear, I must have hit a nerve. An illiterate one at that, or perhaps it's just cherrypicking and willful ignorance on display. Next you'll tell me all twenty thousand goons are combat operatives or something.

What astounds me is just how many of you starts whining and whinging when called on your nonsense.


Your grief at the loss of Sanxing will pas Miz, now go back to killing who you are told, when you are told at the behest of those who are rich but not strong/motivated enough to handle their own affairs or are not bold enough to strike openly against their targets. Mind you don't fall from your imaginary high horse whilst doing so.

(As a disclaimer I have nothing against people who hire Mercs, I merely take issue with being lectured on morals by a murderous pawn.)
Kolodi Ramal
Sanxing Yi
#40 - 2017-02-23 22:50:43 UTC
Nameira Vanis-Tor wrote:
MITG (70 pilots) vs Sanxing, Electus Matari and Villore Accords (237 Pilots)

Pretending those numbers mean anything is laughable.
Sanxing had no more than 5 potentially available pilots, GMVA couldn't join the war until after the second vulnerability window because of complications, and the mercenaries Sanxing hired never showed. So that's why there was only EM at the second vulnerability window, and obviously they didn't bring all their pilots because it's impossible to field all your pilots at once unless you strictly never recruit anyone who isn't on the same shift and kick anyone who's not consistently active.
For the third vulnerability window the number of wardecs on us went from four to six. Not knowing how many pilots would be attacking, I decided it wasn't worth risking any more lives. 64, it turned out: not a force we would have had a real chance of countering.