These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

PIE transporting Slaves within the Republic

Author
Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#121 - 2012-01-21 12:08:20 UTC
Astrid Stjerna wrote:
Silas Vitalia wrote:
Astrid Stjerna wrote:
That was a major element of the Pax Amarria (which, in point of fact, I've been reading to better understand my wife's culture and upbringing), which Heideran's descendants seem to have forgotten.


You people always take the short view.

A more astute observation would be that -Heideran- was a very brief aberration in the long line of Imperial rulers following essentially the same unchanged agenda for the last thousand years.



Which raises another point: why is the Empire so scared of change? Surely, as an enlightened society, social change would be a wonderful example of your progressiveness.

Instead, you fight tooth-and-nail to maintain the status quo.

Why is that?


If you know the Minmatar culture and society well, then you probably know the answer to that question.


Rek Jaiga wrote:
Now forgive me if I'm short, as I've had some drinks. But if the Amarrians hadn't done anything in the first place, there wouldn't be an issue at all. That's all this entire damned conflict is about.


The Amarr invaded hundreds of years ago, and through abuse and brainwashing have genuinely convinced some Matari that the Empire is a good place to be, and then claim these people as their own. Would the ancestors of both groups considered this to be the case? Some eight-hudnred years ago, would a True Amarrian have looked upon a Brutor and said "This is a man of the Empire"? Surely not; he would have said "This is a man from outside of the Empire; he is not of the Empire". Likewise, the Brutor would have looked at the True Amarrian and said "I am not of your Empire; I am of my Tribe".

At what point does this change? Only when your interests, Amarrian, are threatened. You are too ashamed to admit your crimes. Yes. Crimes.

It is not fair that you can invade, enslave, slaughter, and ****, and then turn around and whine about "innocent lives being lost or risked". Are you ******* kidding me?! Get back down into mud holes you dirty rotten ******* pigs. Stay out of our space entirely.


I am not sure if your corporation and fellow members deserve to get associated to that kind of messages - the ones that precisely make the IGS the cesspool it often is.
Rodj Blake
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#122 - 2012-01-21 15:46:10 UTC
Rek Jaiga wrote:


It is not fair that you can invade, enslave, slaughter, and ****, and then turn around and whine about "innocent lives being lost or risked". Are you ******* kidding me?! Get back down into mud holes you dirty rotten ******* pigs. Stay out of our space entirely.



We had peace. We were happy to leave your Republic alone. And then you decided to attack the Empire.

Dolce et decorum est pro Imperium mori

Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#123 - 2012-01-21 15:49:06 UTC
Lyn Farel wrote:
I am not sure if your corporation and fellow members deserve to get associated to that kind of messages - the ones that precisely make the IGS the cesspool it often is.


While it is certainly not the most diplomatic and curt of responses, it does make a change to see someone on here speak their mind and say exactly what they mean without clever worded ambiguity.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#124 - 2012-01-21 15:55:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Lyn Farel
Caellach Marellus wrote:
Lyn Farel wrote:
I am not sure if your corporation and fellow members deserve to get associated to that kind of messages - the ones that precisely make the IGS the cesspool it often is.


While it is certainly not the most diplomatic and curt of responses, it does make a change to see someone on here speak their mind and say exactly what they mean without clever worded ambiguity.


This is the only thing I see everywhere, especially coming from emo-minmatars.

I prefer ten times clever and reasonable answers, even if biased, like Mr Sadik usually does, than meaningless emotive answers that lead to nowhere, except maybe on more hatred.

Edit : how can you even have a decent discussion with someone yelling at the other party all the insanities in the world ? And this without even mentionning how poorly it performs in terms of public image.
Rek Jaiga
Teraa Matar
#125 - 2012-01-21 16:05:21 UTC
Lyn Farel wrote:


I am not sure if your corporation and fellow members deserve to get associated to that kind of messages - the ones that precisely make the IGS the cesspool it often is.


Looking back the morning after, the only thing I'll apologize for is my uncivil tone. It is, however, still very true that the Amarr Empire initiated all of this. In vino veritas.

The Imperials love to point to the Republic and say "Look at your poor and starving! The Empire is surely a better place." You think? Pre-Invasion the Minmatar people expanded in population naturally and according to their means of food production, much like any civilization would. It is the Empire which came, expanded the ethnic Matari population through cruel breeding populations, and then later throws its hands up when the Republic faces issues like poverty and hunger. Again: you think? When population exceeds a nation's ability to produce, you will see these issues. Everything was fine and growing at a natural rate until the Empire stuck its hand in.

There is only one other faction outside of the Empire which abducts people, enslaves them, leaves their homes wrecked, and then genuinely convinces them that their new "home" is the best entity in the cluster. Guess who that is?

In short: get off the pedestal and stop playing victim.
Caellach Marellus
Stormcrows
#126 - 2012-01-21 16:05:28 UTC
Lyn Farel wrote:
Caellach Marellus wrote:
Lyn Farel wrote:
I am not sure if your corporation and fellow members deserve to get associated to that kind of messages - the ones that precisely make the IGS the cesspool it often is.


While it is certainly not the most diplomatic and curt of responses, it does make a change to see someone on here speak their mind and say exactly what they mean without clever worded ambiguity.


This is the only thing I see everywhere, especially coming from emo-minmatars.

I prefer ten times clever and reasonable answers, even if biased, like Mr Sadik usually does, than meaningless emotive answers that lead to nowhere, except maybe on more hatred.


I rarely see people express their point to a level of blunt honesty, I find that it's more likely they'll take sniping cheap shots back and forth instead of coming out and being blunt honest. Even the ones that are trying to pass it off as being polite and reasonable aren't above subtle digs.

Personally I think posting under the influence of alcohol isn't the greatest idea on here, but it offers a level of sincerity without room for confusion that has an admirable trait to it.


Now only if people could be reasonable and blunt honest at the same time. That said topics like this are always going to lead to a rise in temper, not everyone can stay as calm and rational as others.

When your gut instincts tell you something is wrong, trust them. When your heart tells you something is right, ignore it, check with your brain first. Accept nothing, challenge everything.

Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#127 - 2012-01-21 16:49:34 UTC
Laerise wrote:

So your excuse for mass murder or your fellow matari is that, until recently, you abused alcohol to get out of the responsibility that way?

I must say, you are doing a great job of discrediting an organisation that set out with quite some high standards.

Do indulge me, how many of your co-pilots still fly under the influence of alcohol or other substances? I am sure the widows and orphans left behind by your indiscriminate killing are thrilled to hear more about their brave "liberators".


You don't want to go down this road with me. You really don't.

Tell me something -- why do you crew your ships with slaves? Is it because you'll have something to crow about when your ships are inevitably destroyed? 'Oh, look at those savage Matari, they shoot without looking!'

Or maybe it's because you don't truly care about your slaves. I'm sure that they'd love hearing about how their brave 'saviors' consider them expendable.

So, you just go on playing the innocent martyrs.

I'm sure the slaves on your ship will thank you when you get them all killed.

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Laerise
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#128 - 2012-01-21 17:40:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Laerise
Astrid Stjerna wrote:
Laerise wrote:

So your excuse for mass murder or your fellow matari is that, until recently, you abused alcohol to get out of the responsibility that way?

I must say, you are doing a great job of discrediting an organisation that set out with quite some high standards.

Do indulge me, how many of your co-pilots still fly under the influence of alcohol or other substances? I am sure the widows and orphans left behind by your indiscriminate killing are thrilled to hear more about their brave "liberators".


You don't want to go down this road with me. You really don't.

Tell me something -- why do you crew your ships with slaves? Is it because you'll have something to crow about when your ships are inevitably destroyed? 'Oh, look at those savage Matari, they shoot without looking!'

Or maybe it's because you don't truly care about your slaves. I'm sure that they'd love hearing about how their brave 'saviors' consider them expendable.

So, you just go on playing the innocent martyrs.

I'm sure the slaves on your ship will thank you when you get them all killed.


Actually, it's you who kills them.

Anyways, what if I really want to go down this road with you?
Substance abuse really is not the way forward - especially if it leads to unnecessary suffering for yourself and others.


As Admiral Blake points out rightly it was your so-called republic who started this war.

It was minmatar who attacked CONCORD central, an international and neutral station - leading to great loss of life.

It was minmatar who attacked the Empire without provocation - leading to great loss of life.



Oh and, by the by, unlike you and others PIE actually does care about our slaves. It is for good reason that most members adhere to the strict SPCS guidelines and principles.

Those brave and desperate sixhundred-and-fifty souls chose the safety and prosperity of their true home, the empire, over the squalor of your ill-managed and crime ridden refugee-concentration-camps.
Valerie Valate
Church of The Crimson Saviour
#129 - 2012-01-21 17:45:04 UTC
Rek Jaiga wrote:
get off the pedestal and stop playing victim.


Ahahaahaaa, this is amusing in several ways.

Congratulations to all in providing such entertainment.

Doctor V. Valate, Professor of Archaeology at Kaztropolis Imperial University.

Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#130 - 2012-01-21 20:06:23 UTC  |  Edited by: Astrid Stjerna
Laerise wrote:

Actually, it's you who kills them.

Anyways, what if I really want to go down this road with you?
Substance abuse really is not the way forward - especially if it leads to unnecessary suffering for yourself and others.


As Admiral Blake points out rightly it was your so-called republic who started this war.

It was minmatar who attacked CONCORD central, an international and neutral station - leading to great loss of life.

It was minmatar who attacked the Empire without provocation - leading to great loss of life.



Oh and, by the by, unlike you and others PIE actually does care about our slaves. It is for good reason that most members adhere to the strict SPCS guidelines and principles.

Those brave and desperate sixhundred-and-fifty souls chose the safety and prosperity of their true home, the empire, over the squalor of your ill-managed and crime ridden refugee-concentration-camps.


Oh, now, that's a bit of a laugh. We put them on spaceships and flew them into a battleground? Tell me, how precisely did we do that?

And no, you don't want to go down this road -- because until someone in this thread accused me of butchery, I was perfectly content to let sleeping fedo lie.

Whose ships were crewed with slaves in that battle?

Not ours, Laerise. Not ours.

Whose pilots willingly took those slaves into a warzone?

Not ours, Laerise. Not ours.

You can't lay this on us, however much you desperately want to avoid accepting that you got six hundred and fifty people blown into a fine atomic mist not two days ago.

Your ships -- your crew -- flew into a warzone. We didn't force you there, we didn't somehow command your slaves to man those ships.

You did.

So you can take your sanctimonius, holier-than-thou opinions and throw them into the heart of Old Man Star. Because it's not going to work with me.

*Astrid signs off with an angry glare*

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Rek Jaiga
Teraa Matar
#131 - 2012-01-21 20:16:24 UTC
Laerise wrote:


Those brave and desperate sixhundred-and-fifty souls chose the safety and prosperity of their true home, the empire, over the squalor of your ill-managed and crime ridden refugee-concentration-camps.



Again, the only reason things are as they are now is because of the Amarr Empire. If you lot hadn't came at all, these issues would not exist. Don't believe me? The Minmatar people were spacefaring before the invasion and were doing great things; colonizing new worlds and exploring.

And then you came. Don't wag your finger and say "But your Republic is bad". As Aphoxema said, everything about our government is new because you tore us down.

How is the Amarr Empire any better than Sansha's Nation? Both of you take people up and then talk about how much better they like it on the other side of the border. That truly is what's going on here. When Nation destroys life-supporting infrastructure, even you would say that it is a tragedy. When the Empire does the same, it is just "helping people".


Repent of your sins, Holy Amarr.
Laerise
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#132 - 2012-01-21 20:31:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Laerise
It remains a simple and unrefutable truth that most slaves that were kidnapped by the republic, most Ammatar who foolishly left the empire and most of the recently freed slaves of ninth generation and above who went to the republic not knowing better have been better off in the empire than they are now in the republic.

Your ineffectual attempts to paint a humanitarian effort with a tarred brush are evidence enough to your still subhuman point of view on even the most basic realities.


Astrid Stjerna wrote:


Oh, now, that's a bit of a laugh. We put them on spaceships and flew them into a battleground? Tell me, how precisely did we do that?

And no, you don't want to go down this road -- because until someone in this thread accused me of butchery, I was perfectly content to let sleeping fedo lie.

Whose ships were crewed with slaves in that battle?

Not ours, Laerise. Not ours.

Whose pilots willingly took those slaves into a warzone?

Not ours, Laerise. Not ours.



It was not our ships either. The simple fact remains that they, somehow, ended up in a warzone and we made the humanitarian effort to relocate them to a safer place.


Astrid Stjerna wrote:
You can't lay this on us, however much you desperately want to avoid accepting that you got six hundred and fifty people blown into a fine atomic mist not two days ago.

Your ships -- your crew -- flew into a warzone. We didn't force you there, we didn't somehow command your slaves to man those ships.

You did.

So you can take your sanctimonius, holier-than-thou opinions and throw them into the heart of Old Man Star. Because it's not going to work with me.

*Astrid signs off with an angry glare*


It is quite evident that you're the one who is looking for justification here. Unlike you PIE has and will always stand for the protection of the empire and it's godfearing people.


Rek Jaiga wrote:
Laerise wrote:


Those brave and desperate sixhundred-and-fifty souls chose the safety and prosperity of their true home, the empire, over the squalor of your ill-managed and crime ridden refugee-concentration-camps.



Again, the only reason things are as they are now is because of the Amarr Empire. If you lot hadn't came at all, these issues would not exist. Don't believe me? The Minmatar people were spacefaring before the invasion and were doing great things; colonizing new worlds and exploring.

And then you came. Don't wag your finger and say "But your Republic is bad". As Aphoxema said, everything about our government is new because you tore us down.

How is the Amarr Empire any better than Sansha's Nation? Both of you take people up and then talk about how much better they like it on the other side of the border. That truly is what's going on here. When Nation destroys life-supporting infrastructure, even you would say that it is a tragedy. When the Empire does the same, it is just "helping people".


Repent of your sins, Holy Amarr.


I suggest you spare us all the old and boring routine. Everyone here knows about your lies and historical half truths.

The idiocy of your claims aside I have yet to hear such a hate filled diatribe from my caldari allies - who, we will all agree - actually have been the victims of persecution and even genocide in the past.
Unlike you though they managed to become the most civilized, safe and peaceful faction in the cluster next to the Amarr Empire. I am sure this is in part because they are actually building towards a brighter future, much like the Empire.
Vallek Arkonnis
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#133 - 2012-01-21 21:43:45 UTC
Caellach Marellus wrote:

Still not sure who's bright idea it was to use a bloody Sigil though, and further more to not at least give it a travel fit to give it a chance to avoid conflicts.


The Sigil, while lacking in cargo space in relation to the Bestower, can fit a more resilient armor setup. But even then, no amount of armor or agility would make that behemoth survive/evade an assault by a 21 ship fleet, 14 of which were Battlecruisers.

Quote:
Infact after looking at it once again, the Sigil was fit to offer repair support and E-War for the fleet, so not only was it used to transport civilians but was designed to be used as an active combat ship. This is purely reckless and irresponsible and shows little regard for the safety of the people on board the ship.


We're not talking about Interbus or Concord, it was an Amarrian cargo vessel, if it had the means to support the fleet, it did. You can't expect it to be neutral. Judging by the outcome, there was every reason to fit the Sigil for fleet support and defense seeing as it was attacked. That being said, tracking disruptors and armor reppers will not an exploding ship make. The ship could have effortlessly been locked down with a webber and a warp scrambler. It's destruction was completely unnecessary.
Thgil Goldcore
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#134 - 2012-01-21 21:47:32 UTC
Should be noted how foolish the notion of this being a slave fleet instead of a rescue fleet truely is.

If you sit down and think about it, the very idea that we would risk hundreds of millions of isk worth of ships, our crew's lives, and our reputation for ONE sigil worth of slaves (worth less than a million isk) is silly. The markets in Amarr are not that starved, if we where there to simply collect slaves, this would NOT be the way to do it.

So what is worth risking an entire fleet and our crew on? A mission of mercy is really the only option left to you. As God's people we follow God's word. Saving helpless innocents from certain death is a very noble endeavor. Noble enough for PIE to risk a great deal of assets on for sure. I believe a risk we are willing to make again in the future.

Thgil Goldcore
Commodore of PIE
Divine Commodore of the 24th Imperial Crusade
Vallek Arkonnis
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#135 - 2012-01-21 22:01:55 UTC
Valerie Valate wrote:
Rek Jaiga wrote:
get off the pedestal and stop playing victim.


Ahahaahaaa, this is amusing in several ways.

Congratulations to all in providing such entertainment.



That is amusing. Such teen angst they have; thinking the chip on their shoulder not only grants them immunity for their actions, but actually makes their actions the fault of others:

UK invades Amarrian space and destroys Amarrian and DED vessels and a facility designed to combat invasions from Nation, then has the audacity to demand an explanation as to why Amarrian and DED ships were there. All after being told to stay out of the system. Whose fault is it? Not theirs, oh no. Those God-botherers and the wicked DED, they're the ones to blame...

And now, the TLF destroys a transport carrying 650 lives, no one bothers to do a cargo scan and let it go, no one bothers to lock it down and demand to know its contents, they just open fire and consign hundreds to the vacuum of space. Their fitting space and time are precious, you know. How dare we make them think they were slaves and force them to destroy the ship. Makes perfect sense.

Their indiscriminate rage and hatred has, once again, cost lives and now they need to save face and blame everyone else to maintain The Matari Victim(TM) image.
Astrid Stjerna
Sebiestor Tribe
#136 - 2012-01-21 22:05:34 UTC
Vallek Arkonnis wrote:

Judging by the outcome, there was every reason to fit the Sigil for fleet support and defense seeing as it was attacked.


So, you're saying that you fit a cargo vessel for a fleet support role, and it's our fault we targeted that potential threat?

I can't get rid of my darn signature!  Oh, wait....

Vallek Arkonnis
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#137 - 2012-01-21 22:26:03 UTC
Astrid Stjerna wrote:
Vallek Arkonnis wrote:

Judging by the outcome, there was every reason to fit the Sigil for fleet support and defense seeing as it was attacked.


So, you're saying that you fit a cargo vessel for a fleet support role, and it's our fault we targeted that potential threat?


Ah, so now the excuse goes from "We didn't know what was on board" to "We thought it was carrying slaves" to "It was a potential threat". Which is it? All crumble under scrutiny; 1. Not knowing what was on-board is easily rectified with a module so abundant more are reprocessed than used. 2. A cargo vessel fitted for ewar and fleet support is hardly a threat against 14 Battlecruisers. What was it going to do, rep you to death? Fragments from the explosion were more of a danger to your fleet than when it was whole.
Arkady Sadik
Gradient
Electus Matari
#138 - 2012-01-21 23:00:44 UTC
Seven pages of discussion because a ship flown during a war was shot down in the course of that war.

Impressive.
Aphoxema G
Khushakor Clan
#139 - 2012-01-22 00:11:17 UTC
Astrid Stjerna wrote:
Vallek Arkonnis wrote:

Judging by the outcome, there was every reason to fit the Sigil for fleet support and defense seeing as it was attacked.


So, you're saying that you fit a cargo vessel for a fleet support role, and it's our fault we targeted that potential threat?


If they were so concerned for the safety of the cargo they should have flown a Prorator. I mean, when I'm carrying precious and valuable items I do it in a Prowler. You know, so I can't be easily caught in a battle and have my ship destroyed thereby destroying the contents. I also fit my Prowler with hardeners and a microwarp drive, so, like, I can further ensure my precious and valuable cargo will remain safe if I run into trouble.

I also avoid trouble, instead of running with a combat-oriented fleet.

When I see trouble, I run away.

This sounds to me like this "loss" was intentional in order to lambast those who are acting typically. I suppose I'll kidnap some Amarrian citizens and fly through Amarr space in a hoarder, then when they don't act abnormally in scanning my cargohold and go on to destroy my ship, I can call them the villains for assaulting a harmless ship full of poor, helpless Amarrian citizens. Clearly, no fault of my own.
Vaarun
Labrynth Logististics
#140 - 2012-01-22 00:44:32 UTC
Conventia Underking wrote:
Given that transportation of Slaves is illegal in the Republic, PIE Inc. is in violation of Republic laws...


My word. Violating the laws of the enemy...in a warzone...in low security space. Scandalous. When did PIE or any other Amarr bow to the will of the Minamatar Empire? Are you so desperate to make any headway against PIE that you resort to...this? What is next? Dresscode violations? Poor penmanship?

PIE has since the outset of the Faction Warfare been nearly synonomous with the 24th Imperial Crusade. I have not looked at the numbers in a long time, but for many years, they were in some ways (based upon the numbers) the "5th" faction. That fact aside, PIE has also been at the forefront of slave rights and helped many later-generation slaves, as decreed by the Empress, make the transition from slave to citizen with the Amarr Empire.

If this is how you seek to discredit the efforts of PIE, Ms. Underking, I suggest you try harder or find more unsavory actvities within the ranks of PIE pilots in good standing. I wish you luck on that endeavor. You will need it.

CMDR. Vaarun Dakurra