These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Regarding Jackdaw and/or Gila for Combat sites

Author
Arya Wiles
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#1 - 2016-12-30 04:59:17 UTC
I'll start with my question, which is I'm wondering if I should save up and go straight for the Gila for combat sites (mix of High and Low sec), or run a Jackdaw to start as a stepping stone?

A bit of context: I live in Placid, which i believe is Serpentis space. Home base is in HS, but there's a nice quiet pocket of LS nearby. When I started playing, I was interested in flying a Manticore and have many of those appropriate skills trained a fair amount (missiles being the relevant category here). I also have drone skills trained decently due to an interest in an eventual Astero/Stratios voyage. Lately I've started running exploration in a Buzzard for ISK and am enjoying it, but I'd like to branch out to combat site running for some variety.

From my research I judge that the Gila is currently my best ultimate goal of a ship to fly, but it is a bit pricey for me. Where as a Jackdaw (which I read the impression is at least a decent site runner as well) is a ship I could get into much sooner if I wish. So again, I'm curious as to opinions of whether I should start with a Jackdaw and upgrade to Gila later, or just save up from exploration and go straight for the Gila?

If I left out any other helpful info, let me know.

"The Universe has a wonderful sense of humor. The trick is learning how to take a joke."

"Rule #1: People are stupid."

"Information never displeases me. It is ignorance that I find unforgivable."

Zhilia Mann
Tide Way Out Productions
#2 - 2016-12-30 06:09:58 UTC
A Jackdaw allows you to run 2/10s, which could be nice. A Gila would open up 5/10s (I think; I'm still a little rusty on whether medium drones are fast enough to snipe the overseer). Neither is going to want to tangle with a Serpentis 6/10 so write those off.

I think I'd just buckle down and go for a Stratios. Placid is a ladar region, which means you should be seeing an occasional distribution base with a reasonable chance of a high value skill book. But you have to hack for it and would want the bonuses.
Arya Wiles
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#3 - 2016-12-30 06:24:02 UTC
Zhilia Mann wrote:
A Jackdaw allows you to run 2/10s, which could be nice. A Gila would open up 5/10s (I think; I'm still a little rusty on whether medium drones are fast enough to snipe the overseer). Neither is going to want to tangle with a Serpentis 6/10 so write those off.

Yeah, my research already showed the Gila was pretty much build for no higher than a 5/10. Wasnt aware exactly what the Jackdaw was capable of, so good to know now. So far I've just kind of dabbled in combat sites with a Cormorant, but that of course doesnt have much capability going solo. haha

Zhilia Mann wrote:
I think I'd just buckle down and go for a Stratios. Placid is a ladar region, which means you should be seeing an occasional distribution base with a reasonable chance of a high value skill book. But you have to hack for it and would want the bonuses.

Hmm, didn't know those were a thing. Still kind of learning the nuances. Are those kinds of sites primarily in HS or LS? The issue I'd expect with a Stratios though is if I understand correctly, its not as combat efficient as the Gila. Correct me if I'm wrong. Beyond that, the Stratios, being similarly priced to the Gila, is equally outside my price range for now. But I will definitely keep it under consideration. I'm curious to see what others respond with.

"The Universe has a wonderful sense of humor. The trick is learning how to take a joke."

"Rule #1: People are stupid."

"Information never displeases me. It is ignorance that I find unforgivable."

Zhilia Mann
Tide Way Out Productions
#4 - 2016-12-30 06:39:58 UTC
Low sec for distribution bases.

Lots of people love the Gila due to raw damage. Medium drones are fast enough that they travel between targets with relative alacrity so there isn't *too* much downtime from drone travel.

However, a Stratios generally runs sentries for higher end sites, which eliminates travel time altogether. It also strikes me as a much better option to get through the last room of a 5/10 since you really want to kill the overseer as fast as possible and then get out -- all while triple webbed and taking substantial damage. I have no doubt a Gila could do it fit for tank but I rather think a Stratios could do it faster.

A Stratios also runs mediums and smalls equally well, which might in theory speed up 3/10s. I actually don't know; I don't run Gilas for comparison.

And I suppose I should add: I really don't like the Jackdaw. It has the lowest damage potential of all T3Ds (200ish with light missiles?) and just strikes me as lackluster. Of course it also acts as a stepping stone into a Tengu, which is a damn fine ship for exploration (as long as you can keep ammo stocked). Still won't run a Serpentis 6/10 solo though, but you could slip into Syndicate and run 7/10s and 10/10s with one.
Arya Wiles
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#5 - 2016-12-30 06:55:20 UTC
Zhilia Mann wrote:
Low sec for distribution bases.

cool, thx.

Zhilia Mann wrote:
Lots of people love the Gila due to raw damage. Medium drones are fast enough that they travel between targets with relative alacrity so there isn't *too* much downtime from drone travel.

This is what i seemed to observe in other people's posts, as well as the idea of just popping drones and almost going AFK while the site gets cleared appealed to many.

Zhilia Mann wrote:
However, a Stratios generally runs sentries for higher end sites, which eliminates travel time altogether. It also strikes me as a much better option to get through the last room of a 5/10 since you really want to kill the overseer as fast as possible and then get out -- all while triple webbed and taking substantial damage. I have no doubt a Gila could do it fit for tank but I rather think a Stratios could do it faster.

Ok, I really wasn't sure how well a stratios can do straight up combat (PVE). Most people talk about using it for hacking/combat hybrid fit which kind of puts it on a handicap for either unless you use a mobile depot (I'd be willing to use one if the ship really is that good when specialized).

Zhilia Mann wrote:
A Stratios also runs mediums and smalls equally well, which might in theory speed up 3/10s. I actually don't know; I don't run Gilas for comparison.

That's fair then.

Zhilia Mann wrote:
And I suppose I should add: I really don't like the Jackdaw. It has the lowest damage potential of all T3Ds (200ish with light missiles?) and just strikes me as lackluster. Of course it also acts as a stepping stone into a Tengu, which is a damn fine ship for exploration (as long as you can keep ammo stocked). Still won't run a Serpentis 6/10 solo though, but you could slip into Syndicate and run 7/10s and 10/10s with one.

Yeah, I did catch on that the Jackdaw really isnt the best T3D, but its the one I have training the closest too, so I could get in the quickest (started Caldari and already have Destroyers V there). Plus my missile skills are much higher than my others right now. Gunnery isn't bad, though. And I did read a few posts that the DPS at least gets better if you use rockets instead of light missiles. I did also see a lot about the Tengu being even better than the Gila (and other ships with other purposes, lol), but I'm quite a ways off from being able to fly one, whereas a Gila I already have the skills for, if not the ISK. Maybe one day.

"The Universe has a wonderful sense of humor. The trick is learning how to take a joke."

"Rule #1: People are stupid."

"Information never displeases me. It is ignorance that I find unforgivable."

Jeremiah Saken
The Fall of Leviathan
#6 - 2016-12-30 08:49:20 UTC
Don't use jackdaw, really bad ship for combat exploration. +1 low didn't help it much. Serpents use damps, your LML will be useless there, plus "high alpha" is not that high at all. Gila is very good even after the nerf, and if you want to stay in your comfort zone use stratios for covert flying, just fit it straight for combat, something like JP shield fit. Tengu is a killer with proper fit, just remember missiles will take vast amount of cargo hold so if you want to use it far from your base take a freighter full of them with you.

"I am tormented with an everlasting itch for things remote. I love to sail forbidden seas..." - Herman Melville

Arya Wiles
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#7 - 2016-12-30 12:30:06 UTC
Jeremiah Saken wrote:
Don't use jackdaw, really bad ship for combat exploration. +1 low didn't help it much. Serpents use damps, your LML will be useless there, plus "high alpha" is not that high at all.

Hmm, alright, you seem quite confident/convincing. I shall hold off on the Jacky.

Jeremiah Saken wrote:
Gila is very good even after the nerf

That's what i keep reading from people.

Jeremiah Saken wrote:
and if you want to stay in your comfort zone use stratios for covert flying, just fit it straight for combat, something like JP shield fit.

True, I'll definitely have to keep it in consideration. Can't figure out what "JP" stands for though. :/

Jeremiah Saken wrote:
Tengu is a killer with proper fit, just remember missiles will take vast amount of cargo hold so if you want to use it far from your base take a freighter full of them with you.

I read a lot of posts where people called Tengu the very best for running sites, actually. But its just quite a bit farther away from me both skill and ISK-wise. Definitely one to remember for the far future, though. As for the ammo thing, I've already grown accustomed to that with flying the Manticore, and even a very brief spell in a Corax.

Thanks a lot. Appreciate it.

"The Universe has a wonderful sense of humor. The trick is learning how to take a joke."

"Rule #1: People are stupid."

"Information never displeases me. It is ignorance that I find unforgivable."

Jovian Aideron
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#8 - 2016-12-30 13:27:42 UTC
JP is JonnyPew. If you google JonnyPew Stratios, you will find a ton of stuff. Here is an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xd0UzJ_IWdU
Jeremiah Saken
The Fall of Leviathan
#9 - 2016-12-30 14:30:21 UTC
Arya Wiles wrote:
Hmm, alright, you seem quite confident/convincing. I shall hold off on the Jacky.

As a missles user from the begining Jack is not what it should be. I tried confessor lately and hide jack deep below after that Rockets has no range for PvE and LML are slow, very slow. Alpha doesn't help that much. What alpha do we talked about if I can't oneshoot destro in anom?

If you want versatile ship Gila is a must. Passive brick tank and two most versatile dps systems in game = missiles and drones. That bird never disappointed me. It hold ground for so long when I was captured in a site in lowsec.

"I am tormented with an everlasting itch for things remote. I love to sail forbidden seas..." - Herman Melville

Tung Yoggi
University of Caille
#10 - 2016-12-30 17:26:29 UTC
I actually have both.

Jackdaw is great for 2/10, 3/10 and chaining high sec anomalies to escalate into 3 to 5/10. The trick is light missiles, and Auto-guided (FoF) missiles, ECM and damp have now next to no effect on you, and you just have to orbit with tank on and missiles will do the job for you.

4/10 is the breaking point, where the Gila starts to be the better choice (some 4/10 are still doable with the jackdaw). If you go with a pure passive tank, you can play with the modules to have either a brick tank, or max DPS.
With the right amount of money thrown at it, the Gila can perform really well in mid-tier complexes.
Arya Wiles
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#11 - 2016-12-30 23:36:34 UTC
Tung Yoggi wrote:
Jackdaw is great for 2/10, 3/10 and chaining high sec anomalies to escalate into 3 to 5/10. The trick is light missiles, and Auto-guided (FoF) missiles, ECM and damp have now next to no effect on you, and you just have to orbit with tank on and missiles will do the job for you.

Jeremiah Saken wrote:
As a missles user from the begining Jack is not what it should be. I tried confessor lately and hide jack deep below after that Rockets has no range for PvE and LML are slow, very slow. Alpha doesn't help that much. What alpha do we talked about if I can't oneshoot destro in anom?

So what I'm getting here is that while the Jack is certainly capable of running these sites, it is considerably less potent than its sister ships, and not as much worth the ISK. While I'm sure it's fun to fly, I do still like to take ISK efficiency into account, so I'll probably just stick with my Buzzard exploration to save up (I do enjoy that as well) and save up for the Gila and/or Stratios. Actually just bought a new Buzzard last night after losing one over the weekend

Tung Yoggi wrote:
4/10 is the breaking point, where the Gila starts to be the better choice (some 4/10 are still doable with the jackdaw). If you go with a pure passive tank, you can play with the modules to have either a brick tank, or max DPS.
With the right amount of money thrown at it, the Gila can perform really well in mid-tier complexes.

Jeremiah Saken wrote:
If you want versatile ship Gila is a must. Passive brick tank and two most versatile dps systems in game = missiles and drones. That bird never disappointed me. It hold ground for so long when I was captured in a site in lowsec.

I did find a few good videos demostrating the Gila tearing through sites. Most of them don't even bother with the Missile Launchers, the just drop the drones and calmly drift through while they devour fire from 3 dozen sources like nothing. Only a few used the missiles when trying to focus down a boss NPC or whatever it was, so they could loot and get out. I do believe most were also passive tanked. Maybe one booster if anything.

"The Universe has a wonderful sense of humor. The trick is learning how to take a joke."

"Rule #1: People are stupid."

"Information never displeases me. It is ignorance that I find unforgivable."

elitatwo
Zansha Expansion
#12 - 2016-12-31 08:59:26 UTC
Zhilia Mann wrote:
...And I suppose I should add: I really don't like the Jackdaw. It has the lowest damage potential of all T3Ds ....


That part isn't entirely true anymore. With 2x ballistic controls you can get up to 280dps and 320dps in sharpshooter mode and 281 / 341 and hot 401.1 rocket dps.

And remember the dps is a confusing value for long range missiles, since you are throwing 1672hp damage volley every 5 seconds or so with rage missiles.

If you would compare that to my favorite example, the artillery turret, which has low(er) dps but is still being used a lot since the "alpha" is high.

The sharpshooter mode volley damage is more than a scourge heavy fury missile on a Drake.

Eve Minions is recruiting.

This is the law of ship progression!

Aura sound-clips: Aura forever