These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Skill time gates are killing us alphas

Author
Bjorn Tyrson
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#101 - 2016-12-23 19:37:09 UTC  |  Edited by: Bjorn Tyrson
mkint wrote:
Jenn aSide wrote:
mkint wrote:
So a question for the people who support the status quo... it's obvious why allowing alphas the full skill tree would be a bad thing for everyone. But what's wrong with allowing alphas the normal training speed?

(And don't say it's an incentive to sub, it's just as much an incentive to quit entirely, not give the game a real chance, and it's hypocritical to say they need to be patient when we're not willing to be patient ourselves in waiting for them to decide if they want to sub.)


Skill point farming.

Can't farm skillpoints on an alpha. Not in a meaningful way. That's what SP limits are for and alpha skills can't be extracted. No matter how you do it, you can ONLY extract SP you've paid for.

Any other ways training speed limits protect omegas, EVE, or CCP?


(TLDR Version: rough breakdown of SP farming both as alpha farms and omega farms, as well as rate of return for investment and why 2x training speed for alphas would break the market, resulting in a loss of money for ccp from those accounts)

alpha skills can be extracted, but they can only be extracted in an omega state. so all you need to do is train up to the 5mil alpha limit, omega your account for one month, train up skills that alphas can't use (to give yourself an SP buffer) then extract as many omega skills as you can and re-queue them up (which bypasses the 24 alpha training queue since it was set while you where still omega)

you then let the account lapse back into alpha, and train up those skills as an alpha clone, then once those are done, go omega again, train up more omega only skills (at which point you should be getting close to 4 or 5 mil in omega only) and repeat add nauseum. yes it does mean that you need to activate for omega once in a while. but it takes advantage of the free training time.
People have already started setting up alpha accounts for just this purpose as it allows you to extract 5-7mil+ in SP for the price of a single plex, where as under omega only SP farming you can extract ~2mil for that same price.

if alpha clones had the same training time as omegas you could cycle your farm once every 2-3 months for max profit, with the current alpha times it can only be done every 5 or so months.

we have already started to see the impact of alpha clone SP farms on the injector market, the prices have been steadily dropping ever since they came out. if alphas had full training speed the market would crash so far as to be unsustainable. which would result in many of the current SP farmers either shutting down their operations entirely or switching over to the alpha farming method (resulting in lost revenue for CCP)

Now you might be thinking "wouldn't it mean more money for CCP if alphas did have the faster training, because then the SP farms would have to go omega more times in a year".

Well since omega skills are spread across all of the attributes, which means you cannot actually min-max your attributes with a remap. they also cannot use the +5 training implants. the combination of the reduced alpha training speed, sub optimal remap, and limit to only +3 implants means that while yes, the alpha SP farm gets you a better return on SP per plex investment. the higher rate of SP gain from an omega SP farm means that in the long term it will actually make you more money.

so alpha farming does have an impact on the market, but really the only people who are getting into it are the people who run their SP farms VERY passively. the kind of people who might not run them at all if the alpha farms where not even an option, so any amount of plex per year from them is more than ccp was getting before.

The people who run active SP farms and don't mind putting in the extra work for it, will continue to run their farms the same way they always have.
Sonya Corvinus
Grant Village
#102 - 2016-12-23 19:44:47 UTC
Helix Coils wrote:
You do realize that 15 dollars a month adds up. Do the math if you are capable. I guarantee you that the total is more than what I pay for clothes annually. Most people probably pay more but I don't spend 100 dollars a month on clothes.


...what? EVE is $180/year if you subscribe monthly (I can do the math, 15 x 12 = 180, see?), less if you do it annually. Let's say you play 10 hours/week (which is low for most people) that's 520 hours/year, so $0.34 per hour. Name any other form of entertainment that you can get for $0.34/hour.

If you can't afford that, stop playing games and spend time studying to get a better job.

Talking about clothes, four dress shirts for work cost more than an annual subscription to this game.
Helix Coils
Subsidy H.R.S.
Xagenic Freymvork
#103 - 2016-12-23 19:47:01 UTC
Bjorn Tyrson wrote:
mkint wrote:
Jenn aSide wrote:
mkint wrote:
So a question for the people who support the status quo... it's obvious why allowing alphas the full skill tree would be a bad thing for everyone. But what's wrong with allowing alphas the normal training speed?

(And don't say it's an incentive to sub, it's just as much an incentive to quit entirely, not give the game a real chance, and it's hypocritical to say they need to be patient when we're not willing to be patient ourselves in waiting for them to decide if they want to sub.)


Skill point farming.

Can't farm skillpoints on an alpha. Not in a meaningful way. That's what SP limits are for and alpha skills can't be extracted. No matter how you do it, you can ONLY extract SP you've paid for.

Any other ways training speed limits protect omegas, EVE, or CCP?


alpha skills can be extracted, but they can only be extracted in an omega state. so all you need to do is train up to the 5mil alpha limit, omega your account for one month, train up skills that alphas can't use (to give yourself an SP buffer) then extract as many omega skills as you can and re-queue them up (which bypasses the 24 alpha training queue since it was set while you where still omega)

you then let the account lapse back into alpha, and train up those skills as an alpha clone, then once those are done, go omega again, train up more omega only skills (at which point you should be getting close to 4 or 5 mil in omega only) and repeat add nauseum. yes it does mean that you need to activate for omega once in a while. but it takes advantage of the free training time.
People have already started setting up alpha accounts for just this purpose as it allows you to extract 5-7mil+ in SP for the price of a single plex, where as under omega only SP farming you can extract ~2mil for that same price.

if alpha clones had the same training time as omegas you could cycle your farm once every 2-3 months for max profit, with the current alpha times it can only be done every 5 or so months.

we have already started to see the impact of alpha clone SP farms on the injector market, the prices have been steadily dropping ever since they came out. if alphas had full training speed the market would crash so far as to be unsustainable.


If people want to do that more power to them, regardless of how much I doubt that would happen. I'm sure this doesn't address the players that would like to try the game and are turned into wandering spectator's because of the fear they might be able to actually do something.
Helix Coils
Subsidy H.R.S.
Xagenic Freymvork
#104 - 2016-12-23 19:55:14 UTC
Sonya Corvinus wrote:
Helix Coils wrote:
You do realize that 15 dollars a month adds up. Do the math if you are capable. I guarantee you that the total is more than what I pay for clothes annually. Most people probably pay more but I don't spend 100 dollars a month on clothes.


...what? EVE is $180/year if you subscribe monthly (I can do the math, 15 x 12 = 180, see?), less if you do it annually. Let's say you play 10 hours/week (which is low for most people) that's 520 hours/year, so $0.34 per hour. Name any other form of entertainment that you can get for $0.34/hour.

If you can't afford that, stop playing games and spend time studying to get a better job.

Talking about clothes, four dress shirts for work cost more than an annual subscription to this game.


Never said I couldn't afford it it's do I really wan't to pay it? There are plenty of games out there that are FREE or you pay ONCE and that's it. Including AAA games like D3 or Guild Wars 2 (which is an MMO by the way) Do I really need to subscribe? So frankly, "is there other forms of entertainment"? yes....free.

You guys really need to stop going the angle that people can't afford it so then they suck. People. don't. want. to. pay. every. freakin. month. to. play. a. video. game.
Sonya Corvinus
Grant Village
#105 - 2016-12-23 20:02:28 UTC
Helix Coils wrote:
Never said I couldn't afford it it's do I really wan't to pay it? There are plenty of games out there that are FREE or you pay ONCE and that's it. Including AAA games like D3 or Guild Wars 2 (which is an MMO by the way) Do I really need to subscribe? So frankly, "is there other forms of entertainment"? yes....free.

You guys really need to stop going the angle that people can't afford it so then they suck. People. don't. want. to. pay. every. freakin. month. to. play. a. video. game.


EVE has multiple updates per year and has been running for 13 years. Have you played D3 for hours every week for 13 years?

Why do you deserve entertainment for free? Your sense of entitlement is ridiculous. People. want. to. pay every. month. for. a. video. game. so. developers. have. money. to. keep. improving. that. game.

If you could afford $15/mo for a hobby you enjoy, you wouldn't have made this thread.
Maekchu
Doomheim
#106 - 2016-12-23 20:02:51 UTC  |  Edited by: Maekchu
Helix Coils wrote:
You guys really need to stop going the angle that people can't afford it so then they suck. People. don't. want. to. pay. every. freakin. month. to. play. a. video. game.

Then don't...

No one is forcing you to do this.

I for one prefer the current pay model... You need to understand, that in order to be able to play EvE, CCP actually needs to make money to keep the game going. This would be obvious knowledge, if you have any basic understanding of business or just some common sense.

Sure, CCP could open up all of the game with a different F2P model. It would probably include a lot more invasive microtransactions than we see today. But you cannot just give away the game for free and expect to live off peoples charity... It has been done before on other products, turns out people are not that charitable.

The current pay model is good and I suspect the majority of the EvE players prefer this model. You need to understand that the majority of the playerbase are older players with stable jobs, that don't mind paying a sub each month, in order to have less intrusive and less P2W microtransactions.

You are basically arguing that you want a different pay model, but the majority of EvE players are fine with the current one. Which is probably why this thread haven't received huge amounts of support.
Tipa Riot
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#107 - 2016-12-23 20:21:49 UTC
Would say now, don't feed the troll. Blink

I'm my own NPC alt.

Vigirr
#108 - 2016-12-23 20:41:04 UTC
Malcanis wrote:
I honestly don't see how it harms me if alpha players train at the same base speed. If nothing less, they could do so for the first n days of the account. Say 10 or 20, enough to speed them through the very basic skills.


Why?

we used to have fixed (and terrible) attributes
we used to have to train learning skills
We didn't have any hand holding NPE
we didn't have an overpowered Venture
we didn't have the abundance of information and guidance like today
we didn't start with 400k SP
We didn't have all those skills, we had to make money for them and buy them

EVE grew just fine. Not saying all of those were good ideas and some didn't need changing. but this "we MUST change the game", no not at all. If only because it'll just attract (even more) players who don't understand EVE and who'll quit for the next cool new game (probably COD 17 or FIFA 3248).

EVE needs long term players and isn't helped by, at the cost of losing its identity, frantically trying to attract short term players. It's FINE if someone, or a majority of people, don't like the game. There's nothing wrong with that and in fact I'd say it's actually a GOOD thing.

Besides, most new alphas are just alts anyway. trying to get their way pretending to be new. OP as well, probably.
Sameli Adelora
Celestial Industrial Supplies
Templis Strategic Division
#109 - 2016-12-23 20:42:02 UTC
I don't really see the point in having alphas train at 1/2 speed. When they hit the cap they are at the cap having it take longer to get there makes no sense. I guess maybe ccp figures that when they hit the cap they might quit, which may be the case. However, its a very boring wait to the cap at 1/2 speed which could lead people to quit. I for one would like to see alpha players stick around. More players is good for the game. And by the way I have 4 omega accounts so I'm not wanting anything for free.
Mara Pahrdi
The Order of Anoyia
#110 - 2016-12-23 20:46:09 UTC
Tipa Riot wrote:
Would say now, don't feed the troll. Blink

Remove standings and insurance.

Helix Coils
Subsidy H.R.S.
Xagenic Freymvork
#111 - 2016-12-23 21:14:52 UTC
Mara Pahrdi wrote:
Tipa Riot wrote:
Would say now, don't feed the troll. Blink



Just because I say something you don't wan't to hear doesn't make me a troll. Same goes for the previous poster. You guys need to start rethinking your positions.
Tuttomenui II
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#112 - 2016-12-23 21:21:39 UTC
Helix Coils wrote:
Mara Pahrdi wrote:
Tipa Riot wrote:
Would say now, don't feed the troll. Blink



Just because I say something you don't wan't to hear doesn't make me a troll. Same goes for the previous poster. You guys need to start rethinking your positions.


No It is my opinion you should rethink your position. Lol
March rabbit
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#113 - 2016-12-23 21:28:55 UTC
Helix Coils wrote:
Mara Pahrdi wrote:
Tipa Riot wrote:
Would say now, don't feed the troll. Blink



Just because I say something you don't wan't to hear doesn't make me a troll. Same goes for the previous poster. You guys need to start rethinking your positions.

It is not that you "say something you don't wan't to hear".
It is that you do not accept any others opinion. You actually do not read what people write. You just continue the same accusations and complaints changing it every time to something new.

That's what trolls do. That's what YOU do here. That's why you won't have any support.

The Mittani: "the inappropriate drunked joke"

Hallvardr
#114 - 2016-12-23 22:49:42 UTC
Hey Helix - you keep saying "Like I said, I'm fine with restrictions." Why do you keep saying that? I do not think it means what you think it means as obviously you DO have a problem with restrictions or you wouldn't have opened this inane, repetitive thread to begin with.

And as far as the response so far not having an effect of retaining noobs. Some whiny noobs are not worth keeping around. They're more destructive than constructive.

Demonspawn 666
State War Academy
Caldari State
#115 - 2016-12-23 22:54:21 UTC
Hallvardr wrote:
Hey Helix - you keep saying "Like I said, I'm fine with restrictions." Why do you keep saying that? I do not think it means what you think it means as obviously you DO have a problem with restrictions or you wouldn't have opened this inane, repetitive thread to begin with.

And as far as the response so far not having an effect of retaining noobs. Some whiny noobs are not worth keeping around. They're more destructive than constructive.



I asked that back on page 2 when this thread was young and wasn't yet a complete troll.

Still awaiting an answer.

I also pointed out that his whole issue appears to be a massive case of pen...Sorry ship envy.

Still seems to be the case. Wants everything for free and wants it now.


He's very much a glass half empty kinda guy!

The Dirty Rejects are recruiting!
Come play with me...... I like being played with!

TDR Recruitment

Salvos Rhoska
#116 - 2016-12-23 23:08:17 UTC
Why is this thread 6 pages deep?

I demand better content.
Demonspawn 666
State War Academy
Caldari State
#117 - 2016-12-23 23:09:56 UTC
Salvos Rhoska wrote:
Why is this thread 6 pages deep?

I demand better content.

You need to be in range to demand better content.

The Dirty Rejects are recruiting!
Come play with me...... I like being played with!

TDR Recruitment

Iain Cariaba
#118 - 2016-12-23 23:14:11 UTC
Helix Coils wrote:
You guys need to start rethinking your positions.

Why? Because you said so?

Sorry, once you leave Pretty Fanciful Unicorn Land, or wherever the hell it is you live, compelling arguments cause people to rethink their positions. As you have yet to bring a compelling argument, you can likely see why no one is reconsidering their positions.
Demonspawn 666
State War Academy
Caldari State
#119 - 2016-12-23 23:29:28 UTC
Iain Cariaba wrote:
Helix Coils wrote:
You guys need to start rethinking your positions.

Why? Because you said so?

Sorry, once you leave Pretty Fanciful Unicorn Land, or wherever the hell it is you live, compelling arguments cause people to rethink their positions. As you have yet to bring a compelling argument, you can likely see why no one is reconsidering their positions.

Pretty Fanciful Unicorn Land?
That doesn't work, we need a better acronym than PFUM!

How about Pretty Random Imaginary Creatures?

I wanna join PRI..... Oh wait....

The Dirty Rejects are recruiting!
Come play with me...... I like being played with!

TDR Recruitment

Mara Pahrdi
The Order of Anoyia
#120 - 2016-12-23 23:42:04 UTC
Salvos Rhoska wrote:
Why is this thread 6 pages deep?

I demand better content.

Because it was moderated. Else you'd post on p7.

Remove standings and insurance.