These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

A Letter to Her Empress Catiz Tash-Murkon

Author
Ashlar Vellum
Esquire Armaments
#21 - 2016-10-01 14:10:17 UTC
How can you even smear the royal heir's name when you are granting them task in accordance with Scriptures. Certain letters with bizarre "opinions" do sound like a bunch of malarkey tho.
SoulLess Zealot
Khaedra's Law
#22 - 2016-10-01 16:21:25 UTC
Letizzia Omanid wrote:
You claim to look to the 'true essence' of faith, and yet you have chosen one of the most blasphemous call signs imaginable. I simply will not repeat it.

The entire tone of your letter and in particular your closing statement is quite shocking. A holder you may be, but you are in no position to question the Lord, or Her Holiness on any subject.

I'm confident my words will fall on deaf ears to one who has strayed so far from the Lord. I do however hope you are truly 'ever vigilant' and can someday find your path to God.



It seems you only serve to further my point of a blinded empire.You can't shade her words in anything other than greed, so you seek to dismiss me based on my chosen name; the allusion of which seems to far removed to ever be in your reach. I am not questioning the lord as the lords work is never done, I cant smile through my dismay however.


Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Starving people seldom have much time to spend in contemplation of scripture. The first duty of every state head is to the prosperity of her polity - without that, nothing else can be accomplished and with it, everything else is possible.

Elmund Egivand wrote:
From my observation, any man deprived of basic human needs, be it food, water and shelter, will usually stop acting like a person and start acting like an animal. Before they can be educated in any way, the needs of biology have to be met first.


There is always time to contemplate ones own position. Only when stripped of everything can we truly gain anything.

Ashlar Vellum wrote:
How can you even smear the royal heir's name when you are granting them task in accordance with Scriptures. Certain letters with bizarre "opinions" do sound like a bunch of malarkey tho.


I have smeared nothing. The only thing i have done is brought her own words to bear before a public that seems to have forgotten who she is.
SoulLess Zealot
Khaedra's Law
#23 - 2016-10-01 16:28:58 UTC
Our illustrious ancestors freed their souls from the evils of the old.
world and created a new one.
The great Amarr Empire was founded to cultivate the spirit of man.
To do so the enemies of the outside had to be defeated and the enemies of the inside controlled.
The Lord gave our Emperor the power to harness the Good and punish the Evil.
Ever since, the Emperor has lived the lives of his subjects and breathed the air of authority."
- The Scriptures, Book I 1:14



I Think this may help some to understand where our great land stands today... The Lord gave our emperor the power she dosn't embody the Lord.

We as Amarr must strive to cleanse the land and cultivate the spirit from enemies outside and within
Ashlar Vellum
Esquire Armaments
#24 - 2016-10-01 17:49:30 UTC
SoulLess Zealot wrote:

Ashlar Vellum wrote:
How can you even smear the royal heir's name when you are granting them task in accordance with Scriptures. Certain letters with bizarre "opinions" do sound like a bunch of malarkey tho.


I have smeared nothing. The only thing i have done is brought her own words to bear before a public that seems to have forgotten who she is.

I was talking about this
Quote:
When Jamil tried to smear his name by granting the Amatar mandate under his tutelage,the empress thought she had outdone herself.

How could his name be smeared by granting him land to govern and subjects to guide closer to God? Was your name smeared when you were given an estate on Radonis?
SoulLess Zealot
Khaedra's Law
#25 - 2016-10-01 17:52:31 UTC  |  Edited by: SoulLess Zealot
Ashlar Vellum wrote:
SoulLess Zealot wrote:

Ashlar Vellum wrote:
How can you even smear the royal heir's name when you are granting them task in accordance with Scriptures. Certain letters with bizarre "opinions" do sound like a bunch of malarkey tho.


I have smeared nothing. The only thing i have done is brought her own words to bear before a public that seems to have forgotten who she is.

I was talking about this
Quote:
When Jamil tried to smear his name by granting the Amatar mandate under his tutelage,the empress thought she had outdone herself.

How could his name be smeared by granting him land to govern and subjects to guide closer to God? Was your name smeared when you were given an estate on Radonis?



Her aim was to try to get him to loose face by turning away from the appointment because they are Amatar lands. She believed that because the amatar are not of amarr ancetry that Lord Yonis would see the amatar as beneath him, and he would shun the appointment. Yonis was of greater fortitude of the faith than she realized.
Alizebeth Amalath
Doomheim
#26 - 2016-10-01 18:20:29 UTC
I find it fascinating that you know everything Her Majesty, Empress Jamyl, may she rest in the Light of God, was thinking.
Ashlar Vellum
Esquire Armaments
#27 - 2016-10-01 18:26:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Ashlar Vellum
SoulLess Zealot wrote:
Ashlar Vellum wrote:
SoulLess Zealot wrote:

Ashlar Vellum wrote:
How can you even smear the royal heir's name when you are granting them task in accordance with Scriptures. Certain letters with bizarre "opinions" do sound like a bunch of malarkey tho.


I have smeared nothing. The only thing i have done is brought her own words to bear before a public that seems to have forgotten who she is.

I was talking about this
Quote:
When Jamil tried to smear his name by granting the Amatar mandate under his tutelage,the empress thought she had outdone herself.

How could his name be smeared by granting him land to govern and subjects to guide closer to God? Was your name smeared when you were given an estate on Radonis?



Her aim was to try to get him to loose face by turning away from the appointment because they are Amatar lands. She believed that because the amatar are not of amarr ancetry that Lord Yonis would see the amatar as beneath him, and he would shun the appointment. Yonis is of greater fortitude of the faith than she realized.

That is lord's own bizarre fantasies.

Empress Jamyl saw a pious and energetic upholder of amarr ideals in Lord Yonis and gave this task to him, because she knew that he would not fail.
Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#28 - 2016-10-01 21:45:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Ayallah
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Starving people seldom have much time to spend in contemplation of scripture. The first duty of every state head is to the prosperity of her polity - without that, nothing else can be accomplished and with it, everything else is possible.
Untrue Pieter. I wonder now if you ever truly have been starving. I am sure that you may have had training where you were forced to go hungry but I know you must have trusted in your State then and never truly been in danger.

When the sugar and alcohol smell of starvation finds you unable to move, when a sip of water is painful, when there is nothing but euphoria left and the pain is long gone leaving only peace and bliss, god finds you. You think of your life and who you are, what you have become, what it means and how it works. The closer death comes the more you can feel him Pieter.

Missions 42:5 is not just a clever turn of phrase, it is a fundamental truth about the human body under extreme stress. It is more than an appeal for rich men to simplify their lives, it is a kernel of wisdom as old as hardship itself. "There are no atheists in foxholes," is another phrase that means in the end the same thing. A sort of reflection of that truth cast in troubled waters where the scripture is cast on clear mirrored glass.

In trying to argue that the people of the Empire go hungry, as you often love to imply about the Republic as well, you have forgotten that far more go hungry in your State.

Starvation is not painful. God does find you when everything is taken from you.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Elmund Egivand
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#29 - 2016-10-02 01:01:59 UTC  |  Edited by: Elmund Egivand
Ayallah wrote:
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Starving people seldom have much time to spend in contemplation of scripture. The first duty of every state head is to the prosperity of her polity - without that, nothing else can be accomplished and with it, everything else is possible.
Untrue Pieter. I wonder now if you ever truly have been starving. I am sure that you may have had training where you were forced to go hungry but I know you must have trusted in your State then and never truly been in danger.

When the sugar and alcohol smell of starvation finds you unable to move, when a sip of water is painful, when there is nothing but euphoria left and the pain is long gone leaving only peace and bliss, god finds you. You think of your life and who you are, what you have become, what it means and how it works. The closer death comes the more you can feel him Pieter.

Missions 42:5 is not just a clever turn of phrase, it is a fundamental truth about the human body under extreme stress. It is more than an appeal for rich men to simplify their lives, it is a kernel of wisdom as old as hardship itself. "There are no atheists in foxholes," is another phrase that means in the end the same thing. A sort of reflection of that truth cast in troubled waters where the scripture is cast on clear mirrored glass.

In trying to argue that the people of the Empire go hungry, as you often love to imply about the Republic as well, you have forgotten that far more go hungry in your State.

Starvation is not painful. God does find you when everything is taken from you.


Just go to Skarkon and stay in Sahaal for a year. That place is ample demonstration on what destitution can do to a person's spirit.

Everywhere you go it is always the same. Deprived of food, water and shelter for prolonged periods of time, and they will start considering robbing someone else of everything they have a valid way to survive for another week. Happens anywhere that is stricken with poverty and a chronic lack of life-preserving supplies.

A Minmatar warship is like a rusting Beetle with 500 horsepower Cardillac engines in the rear, armour plating bolted to chassis and a M2 Browning stuck on top.

Arrendis
TK Corp
#30 - 2016-10-02 02:33:44 UTC
Don't bother, man. Remember, Ayallah knows everything. Just ask her.
Letizzia Omanid
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#31 - 2016-10-02 16:11:13 UTC
SoulLess Zealot wrote:
[quote=Letizzia Omanid]You claim to look to the 'true essence' of faith, and yet you have chosen one of the most blasphemous call signs imaginable. I simply will not repeat it.

The entire tone of your letter and in particular your closing statement is quite shocking. A holder you may be, but you are in no position to question the Lord, or Her Holiness on any subject.

I'm confident my words will fall on deaf ears to one who has strayed so far from the Lord. I do however hope you are truly 'ever vigilant' and can someday find your path to God.



Quote:
It seems you only serve to further my point of a blinded empire.You can't shade her words in anything other than greed, so you seek to dismiss me based on my chosen name; the allusion of which seems to far removed to ever be in your reach. I am not questioning the lord as the lords work is never done, I cant smile through my dismay however.
Quote:



You are questioning the Lord.

Her Holiness was selected when her champion Lord Darklight was victorious. To question her selection questions the Lord's judgment in the matter.

Faith requires hardship. Serving the Lord requires the faithful to accept things we may not understand. Just because the heir you wanted to rule wasn't selected, doesn't mean Her Holiness is unfit.

The Lord doesn't make mistakes. We just fail to understand his choices.
Letizzia Omanid
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#32 - 2016-10-02 16:26:17 UTC
Samira Kernher wrote:
[quote=Letizzia Omanid]You claim to look to the 'true essence' of faith, and yet you have chosen one of the most blasphemous call signs imaginable. I simply will not repeat it.


Quote:
It is hardly blasphemous. As clones, there is the likelihood that all of us are soulless.
Quote:


You truly believe you are nothing more than a bit of animated biology?

It seems we have very different understandings of what constitutes a soul.

The soul isn't some vestigial organ left behind in the process of a clone jump. The soul is a spiritual link with the Lord. It's a vital part of the essence of all peoples. It's no more lost than your consciousness is when changing the biological vessel it resides in.




Arrendis
TK Corp
#33 - 2016-10-02 16:27:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Arrendis
Letizzia Omanid wrote:
You are questioning the Lord.

Her Holiness was selected when her champion Lord Darklight was victorious. To question her selection questions the Lord's judgment in the matter.

Faith requires hardship. Serving the Lord requires the faithful to accept things we may not understand. Just because the heir you wanted to rule wasn't selected, doesn't mean Her Holiness is unfit.

The Lord doesn't make mistakes. We just fail to understand his choices.


Actually, a question on that...

A friend of mine who's very devout has told me many times that while the Amarr are tasked with bringing the entire cluster to God, their success is not pre-ordained—that they can fail to carry out God's Will.

If that's the case, isn't it possible that the capsuleers of the Succession Trials could also fail to carry out God's Will, putting someone on the throne he didn't select?

Obviously, the intent of things is that God will make his will known through whoever is on the throne, but that still doesn't guarantee he gets his first choice, does it? I mean, if the Amarr can fail at the task God demands of them, then God's will can be thwarted when humans are relied on to carry it out. If God's will can be thwarted when humans are involved, then... any time humans are involved, isn't it impossible to actually know that God's will has been done, and not just 'well, God will make it work anyway'?

I'm not asking to be a pain in the ass, or **** anyone off, it's a sincere question.

Letizzia Omanid wrote:
The soul isn't some vestigial organ left behind in the process of a clone jump. The soul is a spiritual link with the Lord. It's a vital part of the essence of all peoples. It's no more lost than your consciousness is when changing the biological vessel it resides in.


You know some capsuleers (and baseliners) believe that consciousness doesn't actually transfer, right? That we're just copies, and not the original mind moving from vessel to vessel. If that's true, we're not so much immortal as just... seem that way to other people. To ourselves, we die. And then someone else dies who just looks like us and thinks they're us. But they're not us.
Samira Kernher
Cail Avetatu
#34 - 2016-10-02 18:30:38 UTC  |  Edited by: Samira Kernher
Letizzia Omanid wrote:
You truly believe you are nothing more than a bit of animated biology?

It seems we have very different understandings of what constitutes a soul.

The soul isn't some vestigial organ left behind in the process of a clone jump. The soul is a spiritual link with the Lord. It's a vital part of the essence of all peoples. It's no more lost than your consciousness is when changing the biological vessel it resides in.


Your consciousness is lost. We are clones, and a clone is a copy. We can create a hundred simultaneous models of ourselves, yet which is supposed to have "our" consciousness? Well, they all have a consciousness, certainly. A copy modeled after the original.

Our cloning is a rigorous scientific procedure like any other. A scan is made of your brain's neural map. Your being, your consciousness, is diluted into its most simple measure: a series of 1s and 0s that make up you. And that information alone is communicated (communicated!) through flipping the quantum state of entangled particles to a cloning center, where it can then be used to create a new brain, programmed according to the exact specifications of that neural blueprint.

Where, in that process, does this technology actually take hold of the soul? Does your copy serve as some divine beacon, luring the soul back to it from across space and time? What happens when you make multiple copies of yourself? At best, your new body has its own, new soul. Presuming that growing a person in a lab from reprocessed matter can actually produce a soul, seeing as we are not God. But say we do. Why should God accept this fabrication, this artificial byproduct of humanity's hubris? The gates of Heaven open only once, and the Lord forever forsakes the one who turns from the Light--what else do you think that attempting to escape God's judgment with a clone is?

There is a reason the nature of the soul and the clone is still heavily debated in theological circles. The nature of what we are, and if we can still call ourselves creatures worthy of God's love, is a terrifying question that we have no answer to.


Letizzia Omanid wrote:
The Lord doesn't make mistakes. We just fail to under His choices.


The Lord doesn't make mistakes, but we do. It is a common excuse made by people in their failure to claim that the future was set in stone from the beginning, that their loss happened because God willed it. To save themselves from doubt by believing they are doing God's work even at their worst. It was the excuse made at Vak'atioth, it was the excuse made during the secessions of Khanid and the Minmatar, it's the excuse made by those champions who failed their heirs.

God commands us to prove our worthiness to him. That is the nature of the Trials. The winner is the one that has proven themselves. I am Minmatar. I forever carry the mark of the failures of my ancestors. They were not cast from God's sight because it was part of the plan, they failed Him and were punished for it. And God did not choose the Amarr as His Chosen by chance, He chose them because they lived righteously and in fear of Him. The original Amarr were no more destined to become True than the Minmatar were destined to fall. They each made their bed, just as our heirs do today. We're all given a mission, and that mission is to defeat the enemies without and the demons within and to Reclaim all that He has given. Our success in that mission isn't guaranteed, and we are stronger as a people when we accept that we always can, and must, do better.

We lost Vak'atioth, not because it was planned, but because we failed. We lost half our empire to rebellions because we failed. We were lead by a Sani Sabik heretic during the interregnum for years because we failed. Her Imperial Majesty, long may she reign, was not destined to win. Her team proved their worth, and she was chosen because of their success in battle (though one wonders why our recent succession trials have taken to somehow proving the worth of the heir through capsuleer surrogates, since in faith before God and efforts towards the Reclaiming Lord Yonis was equaled by none). Her Imperial Majesty's reign will be marked by victory or defeat, according to the choices that she makes, and that we make, in the years to come, for even those who are True must always work to prove themselves before God. Such was said by the Prophet Anoyia.

May Catiz I rule well. She's been given a great responsibility.
Ashlar Vellum
Esquire Armaments
#35 - 2016-10-02 18:51:05 UTC
Letizzia Omanid wrote:
Samira Kernher wrote:
[quote=Letizzia Omanid]You claim to look to the 'true essence' of faith, and yet you have chosen one of the most blasphemous call signs imaginable. I simply will not repeat it.


Quote:
It is hardly blasphemous. As clones, there is the likelihood that all of us are soulless.
Quote:


You truly believe you are nothing more than a bit of animated biology?

It seems we have very different understandings of what constitutes a soul.

The soul isn't some vestigial organ left behind in the process of a clone jump. The soul is a spiritual link with the Lord. It's a vital part of the essence of all peoples. It's no more lost than your consciousness is when changing the biological vessel it resides in.

Ms Kernher does have a point and question about clone souls or lack thereof is a highly debated topic across the Empire. If memory serves me right one of the pro arguments against clone souls is passage 5:14 Book of Missions.
Anabella Rella
Gradient
Electus Matari
#36 - 2016-10-02 21:35:40 UTC
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Starving people seldom have much time to spend in contemplation of scripture. The first duty of every state head is to the prosperity of her polity - without that, nothing else can be accomplished and with it, everything else is possible.

I wholeheartedly agree with this statement. In the hierarchy of human needs the very basics include food, water, shelter and some semblance of security. All other aspects of civilization are based on people having these needs fulfilled.

No one I've ever pulled from a drifting cargo container or liberated from some deadspace facility has asked me to return them so that they could contemplate their spiritual salvation. They asked for food, shelter, medical care and/or safe transport.

When the world is running down, you make the best of what's still around.

Veikitamo Gesakaarin
Doomheim
#37 - 2016-10-03 01:06:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Veikitamo Gesakaarin
Ayallah wrote:
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Starving people seldom have much time to spend in contemplation of scripture. The first duty of every state head is to the prosperity of her polity - without that, nothing else can be accomplished and with it, everything else is possible.
Untrue Pieter. I wonder now if you ever truly have been starving. I am sure that you may have had training where you were forced to go hungry but I know you must have trusted in your State then and never truly been in danger.


The point of most training in the State where hunger or starvation is an issue, such as infantry behind-lines escape and evasion, is the reduction of hunger and starvation as much as possible. This is because it is well known that even a minor reduction of blood salts from food or rations; combined with dehydration can have a deleterious effect on combat performance due to increased fatigue; impaired mental functions; a decrease in cardiovascular and muscular function; and a higher risk of death due to environmental factors such as heat or cold.

It is thus the responsibility and duty of any Caldari warfighter to prevent these symptoms in themselves and their unit partners by ensuring a regular fluid intake and calorie consumption through proper rationing or on-site procurement of water and food as outlined in their relevant Health & Safety; Food and Water Preparation; Local Environment Survival, Escape & Evasion guides. Which all can be made available on request either in hardcopy or in digital format to a Company HQ Commissar-Leutnant or above, if not already enforced at a section or platoon level by the Commissar-Corporal and Commissar-Sargeant.

Whilst the Amarr Empire may find benefit in their armed forces expressing and experiencing their faith in the hallucinatory state of extreme starvation and dehydration, you are quite correct that in the State it would be considered a medical emergency requiring treatment just like any other injury to a warfighter.

Kurilaivonen|Concern

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#38 - 2016-10-03 06:11:11 UTC
I have never starved. The closest would be the weeks I spent trapped in a crippled Caracal.

The "insights" I gained from the experience required extensive therapy to banish.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#39 - 2016-10-05 14:43:44 UTC
Elmund Egivand wrote:
Just go to Skarkon and stay in Sahaal for a year. That place is ample demonstration on what destitution can do to a person's spirit.

Everywhere you go it is always the same. Deprived of food, water and shelter for prolonged periods of time, and they will start considering robbing someone else of everything they have a valid way to survive for another week. Happens anywhere that is stricken with poverty and a chronic lack of life-preserving supplies.

Poverty and hardship is not the same as the reactions of a body when it is shutting down due to extreme environmental stress. People dying of hypothermia feel warm for example. Poor and deprived people like those of Skarkon are an example in the Empire of why generational slavery is a good idea, people left to rot and waste away. There is a difference between a forged blade and one rusting.

Veikitamo Gesakaarin wrote:
. . .This is because it is well known that even a minor reduction of blood salts from food or rations; combined with dehydration can have a deleterious effect on combat performance due to increased fatigue; impaired mental functions; a decrease in cardiovascular and muscular function; and a higher risk of death due to environmental factors such as heat or cold.

. . .Whilst the Amarr Empire may find benefit in their armed forces expressing and experiencing their faith in the hallucinatory state of extreme starvation and dehydration, you are quite correct that in the State it would be considered a medical emergency requiring treatment just like any other injury to a warfighter.
You are correct as to the effects of exposure, it certainly can ruin developmental potential. Extreme starvation and exposure is not really something that can be learned from to the benefit of soldiering, as far as I know it is not a part of normal training regimes in the Empire. I am doubtful that it is much different than the State's own exercises with similar training goals.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

DJ puar
Covert Economics
#40 - 2016-10-05 23:32:44 UTC
Her empire will burn