These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

An actual discussion about the Empire and the Federation

Author
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#21 - 2016-08-31 19:39:48 UTC
William Danneskjold wrote:
That ugly cancerous undertone is one of obliteration of other cultures if they refuse to be just like the Federation, which is unpleasant in its own right.


You say that as if it's debatable.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Bel Boma
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#22 - 2016-08-31 19:41:03 UTC
You are right concerning my tone, and I apologize. My word choices were too strong as I let my feelings get the best of me. I meant you no insult by my choice of the word "boast," as I used it as a stand in for "have." I hold a personal grudge against pandemic legion, though I recognize service does not necessitate corporation participation.

I withdraw from this discussion.
Zekiel Iyhr
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#23 - 2016-08-31 19:51:01 UTC
Ayallah wrote:
Bringing up the largest aspect of "where they diverge." apparently is naming the security status of where I currently live and being arrogant.

Calling someone arrogant and saying they "failed in their service" is apparently no longer a personal insult.

I see this thread is for Federation loyalists to swoon about how pretty the Crystal boulevard is and has nothing to do with exploring the actual differences between the culture of the Empire and Federation.



In this thread, I count three Federation loyalists, and that is assuming the Gurista woman is loyal to the Federation for simply basing out of it. There are more posters in this thread who bear the colors of another Empire and are unashamed to do so.

Billions upon billions practice the Faith. Many do so through varied interpretations of the Faith all in an effort to prove themselves to Him and lead lives they believe worth eternal bliss. While some practice war, as I have, many commit their very souls to philanthropy, scholarly and theological studies of the sciences and the Faith. The advancement of culture is held dear as much as economical endeavors to improve the Empire at its very core.

I understand you are a Kameira. I understand your fierce devotion to the Faith. I do not believe, though, you personally understand the plights of those who fulfill their service to Him under any other way. You berate them, scold them, chastise and imply your own scriptural understandings are to be accepted as one of if not the only interpretation. I do not think your words are helpful for such an end goal, as such.

Bel Boma has outwardly done more for the Empire than many individuals I am acquainted with. While I understand your service, I do not understand where you place, having relocated yourself to Pandemic Legion. I do not know what you contribute, and I have not witnessed or heard any such great acts of war or otherwise in honor of God. While ad hominem style discussion always falls flat, in this circumstance I believe it to be a fitting usage as you yourself have utilized such attacks against others in this same thread.

Thusly, I implore you, Ayallah, to distance yourself from such judgments. Our God is a just God, and he will see fit to punish those who deserve such punishments. It is up to neither of us to decide who that may be. (To a point, obviously.)



That being said, it would be ignorant to suggest the Federation is impossible to redeem, nor would it be improbable to suggest there is a better way to adapt the Reclaimation to better suit these modern times. I hope our two societies will find a resolution... some day.

Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#24 - 2016-08-31 20:00:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Ayallah
Tressith Sefira wrote:
Mate, you personally insulted my character for my pretty damn benign post and then went full lecture mode on how shite the Federation is compared to the Empire. 'Snot exactly in a good constructive spirit of discussion. Ye even insulted the whole idea of discussion. You're like a more wordy more angry Blake.
I have re-read my post and fail to see where I insult your character.
Ayallah wrote:
The Federal idea that the opinions of individuals matter, the individual deserves some voice in how the greater whole is directed. Your list of grievances with the Federation as an opening for Amarrians to do the same. You maintain that the majority who have no say in the Empire have some need or right to be heard.

Your efforts to open the discussion for Amarrians to air their grievances by sharing your own is kind but it could not be more misplaced.

In this I think you simply cannot understand that for an Amarrian citizen to "begrudge the greater Empire," and "wish," they highlight only their own inability to follow the proper doctrine of god.
I have isolated all the sections of my post where I am addressing you as the poster and do not see any personal insults to your character at all. In fact, I point out it is kind of you to open the discussion of a list of grievances by first speaking your own. Perhaps you took my speculation that our cultures are too different to understand how in the Empire a feeling of dissatisfaction with the Empire reflects on the individual; my suggestion of a limit to your understanding, as in insult. This was not intended.

Ayallah wrote:
In the Empire, all serve god. In doing so they serve themselves.

Whatever opinion you have on the direction of the Empire is completely irrelevant to your own personal responsibility to serve god and the Empire. There is no entitled attitude to your own emotions wants and needs over all else. All serve god and the Empire, Empress and slave alike.

A man's grievances at his duties before god are a weakness for him to bear, not something to share and expect to be comforted. A slave's burden will not decrease should he complain, a Holder's influence will not increase if she whines, and an Empire will not grow strong if the Emperor laments its weaknesses. This idea that feelings are as valid as action and service either to god or nation is ridiculous. How you feel is a child's complaint.
Nor in the body of my description do I find an insult to you.

I am sure that I believe in the superiority of the Empire but so have others shared their belief in the superiority of the Federation and you have shown no protest.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#25 - 2016-08-31 20:13:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Ayallah
Zekiel Iyhr wrote:
In this thread, I count three Federation loyalists, and that is assuming the Gurista woman is loyal to the Federation for simply basing out of it. There are more posters in this thread who bear the colors of another Empire and are unashamed to do so.

Billions upon billions practice the Faith. Many do so through varied interpretations of the Faith all in an effort to prove themselves to Him and lead lives they believe worth eternal bliss. While some practice war, as I have, many commit their very souls to philanthropy, scholarly and theological studies of the sciences and the Faith. The advancement of culture is held dear as much as economical endeavors to improve the Empire at its very core.

I understand you are a Kameira. I understand your fierce devotion to the Faith. I do not believe, though, you personally understand the plights of those who fulfill their service to Him under any other way. You berate them, scold them, chastise and imply your own scriptural understandings are to be accepted as one of if not the only interpretation. I do not think your words are helpful for such an end goal, as such.

Bel Boma has outwardly done more for the Empire than many individuals I am acquainted with. While I understand your service, I do not understand where you place, having relocated yourself to Pandemic Legion. I do not know what you contribute, and I have not witnessed or heard any such great acts of war or otherwise in honor of God. While ad hominem style discussion always falls flat, in this circumstance I believe it to be a fitting usage as you yourself have utilized such attacks against others in this same thread.

Thusly, I implore you, Ayallah, to distance yourself from such judgments. Our God is a just God, and he will see fit to punish those who deserve such punishments. It is up to neither of us to decide who that may be. (To a point, obviously.)



That being said, it would be ignorant to suggest the Federation is impossible to redeem, nor would it be improbable to suggest there is a better way to adapt the Reclaimation to better suit these modern times. I hope our two societies will find a resolution... some day.
I made no effort to point out any service record or return and insult until after I had been insulted twice. I did not use an ad hominem until two were used against me. But I suppose the one who hits harder is often perceived to have started the fight.

You are correct and it is not my place to seem to judge another's service to god. I did not appreciate the hypocrisy of my service record being attacked in the same post as someone admitting they fled from service and I over stepped my bounds. I presumed much of what I did not know.

Thank you for this reminder Zekiel.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Tressith Sefira
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#26 - 2016-08-31 20:29:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Tressith Sefira
You called me childish. You called everything I said childish and irrelevant and ridiculous.

You've been nothing but rude and hostile in everything you've said so far and that's not the tone I really wanted in this thread. You've punished people and made 'em feel bad for opening up and taking risks and you've convinced people to leave and stop posting and not post to begin with. That's the opposite of what I really wanted for this thread and I'd really like it if you could please find some different thread to post in? I'd really really 'preciate that.

Edit: please don't let her keep this thread down. I'm done with that. Has anyone done any fun visiting to places in the Fed or the Empire that they were surprised by? I know I was surprised by the Cathedral of the Seventh Goddess in Caille and the Basilica in Amarr Thal showed me. There's so much loving attention to detail, in the murals!
Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#27 - 2016-08-31 20:58:55 UTC  |  Edited by: Ayallah
I "punished" or "made feel bad" people who insulted me without provocation.

"This idea that feelings are as valid as action and service either to god or nation is ridiculous. How you feel is a child's complaint."

Which is a very large difference between other nations and the Empire. It is something that the State may have in common with the Empire but I do not know. As Zekiel pointed out there may be some place among the trillions where personal feelings toward the decisions of the Empress and Theology Council are considered valid but more often I think to speak them is heresy. Individual feelings are considered to be irrelevant to the direction of the Empire, the Empress speaks and the people follow. I did not personally insult you or attack the premise of this thread but I accept that is how you feel.

In actuality the only people to use the word "childish" were Bel and William later referring to Seraphim.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Tressith Sefira
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#28 - 2016-08-31 21:37:09 UTC
William Danneskjold wrote:
I've lived in all the Empires for varying amounts of time. The Federation and Empire share some traits in a love of beauty, but it is definitely different reasons. The Empire's form of beauty tends to be one of unification under a strong singular vision. Individual artists can add flourishes and nuances, sure, but it is a crushing, suffocating beauty. "Look like this or be pushed out."

The Federation promotes the opposite. A beauty and art form so divergent as to appear as a tree of life, splitting into dozens of unique genus and species. Drones, life forms, tattooes, dancing, sex, all of these can be art forms in the Federation. Of course, whether this is art or not is subjective.


Iunno about that. I'm from the outside but certain parts a the Empire seem real diverse considering how it's 'posed to be unified. Like the Ammatar being their own distinct thing and the Khanids - I dunno enough about the separate kingdom there to talk about it - still having their own special touches and like I said before, the Ni Kunni and their wind dancing and the spicy things they eat and the love a sand and water. I guess the cultural unification thingy means they're all trying to reach the same goal but I always thinka it as people takin' different paths and methods to get there. Y'know?

William Danneskjold wrote:
There are other complaints, of course. The Amarr Empire actively participates in pruning of branches, for example. This does give it a stronger, unified front to appear to enemies, but also encourages fanaticism and discourages free thought and expression. Of course, one could argue that those are trademarks of the Deceiver.

My argument would be that, if I understood the original post, that the Federation's form of art and growth is healthier, but has a ugly cancerous undertone, like the scent of gum disease on a prospective date's breath. That ugly cancerous undertone is one of obliteration of other cultures if they refuse to be just like the Federation, which is unpleasant in its own right.


Iunno. If we're talkin' flowery metaphors, I think I'd liken the Federation to noise. They're loud. There's so many different noises going on at once that it's like, tough to translate and decipher and parse. Quieter ones get drowned out. My little delta - it's weird and strange and no one off a it cares about it even though it's got a whole bunch ta offer. It's just not as loud, important, as the gorgeous and rich core worlds. You might be like distinct and doing your own thing and separate but... You're just not important. Like do people know that Luminaire is actually ruled by a Kingdom? Can't hear that over the wub wub of the party scene.

And it scares me because I always feel like the fact all these things can exist at once is the strength of the Federation. Inside the Federation, citizens, I don't think, think too much about the bigger Federation. The Gallente language used for space stuff isn't even spoken by half of all Federal citizens. The overwhelming majority don't think it. But if no one takes the time to appreciate all the differences and notice all the differences, what's the point of being so diverse? If everyone's special, is anyone special?
Arrendis
TK Corp
#29 - 2016-08-31 22:18:58 UTC
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Arrendis wrote:
You know, people always quote those same verses. I'm kind of curious what the verses immediately before and after them are. After all, context matters.


Sounds like someone just nominated herself for a book report.


Why? We've got plenty of Amarr here. If they want to keep tossing these verses around like they prove a point, then they can provide the context the quotes fit into.
Arrendis
TK Corp
#30 - 2016-08-31 22:32:03 UTC
Ayallah wrote:
I have been a Kameira my entire life. Please point out where me denying your attack on my service was "boasting."
Do you think that every servant of god flies with PIE?


No, but does get really funny when a Republic University grad who flew as a merc and then for the TLF tries to lecture people about how devoted a servant of the Empire they've been for their 'entire life'. How dedicated was TEST to serving the Empire? Or Waffles?

I'm not gonna claim to be some paragon of virtue or anything, Ayallah, but you know, I send money home every month. That doesn't make me a devoted servant of the Republic. You are what you are, sure as I'm a Goon. Own it. Stop hiding behind your 'I was a trained assassin from the age of negative twelve!' nonsense. You serve the same master you always have: money.
William Danneskjold
#31 - 2016-08-31 22:55:15 UTC
Ayallah is right. Especially under Heth, such rabble would be considered seditious and potentially punishable by death. Since capsuleers are sovereign entities, it is largely irrelevant unless you're willing to take the time to hunt someone down.

Tressith Sefira wrote:

Iunno about that. I'm from the outside but certain parts a the Empire seem real diverse considering how it's 'posed to be unified. Like the Ammatar being their own distinct thing and the Khanids - I dunno enough about the separate kingdom there to talk about it - still having their own special touches and like I said before, the Ni Kunni and their wind dancing and the spicy things they eat and the love a sand and water. I guess the cultural unification thingy means they're all trying to reach the same goal but I always thinka it as people takin' different paths and methods to get there. Y'know?


I refer to the main Empire, not the Mandate nor the Kingdom. There are smaller works allowed at local levels but overwhelmingly they push a unified art form for the public to see. I refer to the architecture et al. It is also worth noting that frequently it is the case that the Empire doesn't promote these smaller art forms so much as permits them to exist, which is a profound difference between it and the Federation.

Tressith Sefira wrote:
Iunno. If we're talkin' flowery metaphors, I think I'd liken the Federation to noise. They're loud. There's so many different noises going on at once that it's like, tough to translate and decipher and parse. Quieter ones get drowned out. My little delta - it's weird and strange and no one off a it cares about it even though it's got a whole bunch ta offer. It's just not as loud, important, as the gorgeous and rich core worlds. You might be like distinct and doing your own thing and separate but... You're just not important. Like do people know that Luminaire is actually ruled by a Kingdom? Can't hear that over the wub wub of the party scene.

And it scares me because I always feel like the fact all these things can exist at once is the strength of the Federation. Inside the Federation, citizens, I don't think, think too much about the bigger Federation. The Gallente language used for space stuff isn't even spoken by half of all Federal citizens. The overwhelming majority don't think it. But if no one takes the time to appreciate all the differences and notice all the differences, what's the point of being so diverse? If everyone's special, is anyone special?


What's the point to life? To existence? In my opinion, life is its own justification. The infinite pathways down which one can travel are a self justification to the infinite capacity of human creativity. Human cruelty also seems to be infinite, perhaps even moreso, which makes the shows of freedom, liberty, and art that much more important to cherish.

War is murder. It always has been, always will be. Murder in the name of God. Freedom. Your country. Whatever it is, it is murder. I am already against the next set of wars.

Aldrith Shutaq
Atash e Sarum Vanguard
#32 - 2016-08-31 22:55:44 UTC
And this is why we can't have an actual discussion about the Empire and the Federation.

Back to war everyone, nothing to see here.

Aldrith Ter'neth Shutaq Newelle

Fleet Captain of the Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris

Divine Commodore of the 24th Imperial Crusade

Lord Consort of Lady Mitara Newelle, Champion of House Sarum and Holder of Damnidios Para'nashu

Tressith Sefira
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#33 - 2016-08-31 23:22:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Tressith Sefira
Charles Cambridge Schmidt wrote:
The border systems are unregulated and run by criminals who inhabit the omega cities and run them to their desires, throwing taxes at Roden by the fistful to stay out of FedNavy's sights. Zero-point-one security Federation space may as well be Null that has sovereignty with respect to the Federation.


Took the words straight outta my head. But then you knew that.

That apathy's prolly the number one reason the Federation breaks down. I can't say it'd be good for my delta to be in the limelight but maybe if it was the omega cities next door woulda been protected and funded. Maybe if we were a little closer to Caille and we weren't in lowsec, that sansha incursion that pummeled Esmes III woulda actually been stopped. Maybe if Esmes was next door to Caille, the Federal government wouldn't have collapsed. Maybe maybe maybe. And I can't help but be afraid that maybe, maybe some Federal corporations think the whole system of Esmes and its cities are more profitable as an Omega than it was as a Delta.

Charles Cambridge Schmidt wrote:
Despite it all, I love it. The whole shebang. The whole Federation... It's a place where you can be raised and realize your true calling lies elsewhere, and where the society welcomes and embraces the ethical divergence that pops up (and is repressed) so often in other cultures across the cluster.

The Federation and Empire have always worked out their issues, no matter how shaky the ground they decided to settle on. Diplomacy and dare I say co-existence is a very real, very palpable possibility at this point. There is something to be learned from each and something that each can teach one another.

It's a very unique position at the moment, and here's hoping it doesn't teeter and collapse.


Everyone's said it before but yeppers, that unrestrained quality is both the Federation's biggest strength and biggest failing. And that's so reasonable when we're talking about that collective a all sorts of individual things. Love me some classical and big band and jazz but the more electronic stuff gives me a headache. Love me tea and biscuits but then some prats here put their milk in first. 'Sjust not right. Guess it'd be nice if we could agree on everything at once but then I love travelling and there's something to be gained in the motion towards new likes and new opinions and new conclusions.

And I think it's a disservice to separate the Empire from the Ammatar and the Khanids and the Ni-Kunni and their distinct cultural groups who bring their own things to the table! No one would accuse a Khanid of not being real Amarr in the Empire I don't think. And no one says Ni-Kunni can't be Amarr because they eat bugs.
Arrendis
TK Corp
#34 - 2016-08-31 23:25:21 UTC
Tressith Sefira wrote:
And I think it's a disservice to separate the Empire from the Ammatar


And now... now you start to enter into dangerous waters.
Tressith Sefira
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#35 - 2016-08-31 23:27:12 UTC
Arrendis wrote:

And now... now you start to enter into dangerous waters.


Wait sorry did I put my foot in my mouth and say something offensive?
Arrendis
TK Corp
#36 - 2016-08-31 23:48:46 UTC
Tressith Sefira wrote:
Arrendis wrote:

And now... now you start to enter into dangerous waters.


Wait sorry did I put my foot in my mouth and say something offensive?


I will simply council avoiding raising the issue of the traitors altogether. You risk stirring... That Which Knows Only Hate™.
Tressith Sefira
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#37 - 2016-08-31 23:50:34 UTC  |  Edited by: Tressith Sefira
Arrendis wrote:
I will simply council avoiding raising the issue of the traitors altogether. You risk stirring... That Which Knows Only Hate™.


I'm gonna remember that in the future and try to be a lil more sensitive about it. Thankye.
Ayallah
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#38 - 2016-09-01 00:37:44 UTC  |  Edited by: Ayallah
Arrendis wrote:
No, but does get really funny when a Republic University grad who flew as a merc and then for the TLF tries to lecture people about how devoted a servant of the Empire they've been for their 'entire life'. How dedicated was TEST to serving the Empire? Or Waffles?

I'm not gonna claim to be some paragon of virtue or anything, Ayallah, but you know, I send money home every month. That doesn't make me a devoted servant of the Republic. You are what you are, sure as I'm a Goon. Own it. Stop hiding behind your 'I was a trained assassin from the age of negative twelve!' nonsense. You serve the same master you always have: money.
Now this is a strange assertion, that I chase money over anything else. Off the mark though Arrendis, perhaps you could have said I prefer aggregating my personal power over serving the Empire. Or that my loyalty to the legion has conflicted with my loyalty to the Empire.

But money? Arrendis, I already own everything I could ever possibly want. I was more wealthy the day I became a pilot than I ever dreamed of before. Your attack is as off the mark as activating your small neutron blasters at a target 290km away. It just shows ignorance, certainly you meant it to be pointed in my direction at least. By the way a Kameira is a soldier not an assassin ...and I started at six.

Goddess of the IGS

As strength goes.

Arrendis
TK Corp
#39 - 2016-09-01 00:56:06 UTC
Ayallah wrote:
Now this is a strange assertion, that I chase money over anything else. Off the mark though Arrendis, perhaps you could have said I prefer aggregating my personal power over serving the Empire. Or that my loyalty to the legion has conflicted with my loyalty to the Empire.


Money is power, Ayallah, and power is the ability to generate all the money you want. Don't act like Pandemic Legion doesn't know that. There's a reason your organization forces smaller groups like the League of Unaligned Master PIlots to tend and administer R64s for you. Without money, you can't operate.

Quote:
By the way a Kameira is a soldier not an assassin ...and I started at six.


Yes, I know. We all know. The never-born children of the Jove know. You tell everyone all about it at absolutely every opportunity.

"Hello, Ayallah, what did you have for breakfast?"
"Gruel. I have eaten gruel every morning since I began my training as a soldier at age six. That is why all others in the cluster are inferior beings who can never understand my greatness."

Kinda why I was intentionally distorting it. You should try finding a 'scorn and mockery' skillbook sometime.
James Syagrius
Luminaire Sovereign Solutions
#40 - 2016-09-01 02:33:43 UTC
Good afternoon.

I have a profound and abiding love for the Empire, despite her sins, as I do for our Federal Union.

I was delighted to see this thread. I supposed it overdue as I have long advocated for closer relations between our two great civilisations.

It started well and now due to familiar equivocations has descended into the zealot's charge. But no matter.

In the world of diplomacy, some things are better left unsaid and there I will leave them. Unlike some who wish to prove the axiom ‘Diplomacy is the art of saying 'Nice doggie' until you can find a rock.’ I trust that despite our sundry differences both secular and theological, that our civilisations are fated to either rise together or fall separately.