These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page123Next page
 

[SANXI] Press Release: Victims of Nauplius

Author
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#21 - 2016-05-22 14:46:56 UTC
We're presently entering the second week of this humanitarian crisis. In the scheme of things, it's perhaps a small one, but, then, the scheme of things is awfully, awfully large.

If you walk through a crowd of them, thirty-three thousand people is ... a lot.

Fortunately, the response has been enormous. We believe we now have the staff and resources needed to aid and comfort those in our care, and to pursue an effective treatment with all possible diligence.

At this time, I'd like to offer our thanks to all those who've made the effort to aid us with materials and personnel: PIE, Sanxing, Alexylva Paradox, pilot Literia of The OSS, and my fellow members of SFRIM. Special thanks and condolences to CVA, for loss suffered on our behalf.

Special thanks also to those who, for whatever reason, cannot here be named.

We understand that in places those aiding us have been constrained to only providing aid where conscience allowed. We exist in a universe we share with our fellow human beings, but also of deep divisions. Perhaps no one in this world has as much reason as the Amarr to understand the power and importance of a deeply-held belief. No one should dishonor charity by demanding that it be provided beyond ethical or moral limits.

At this point, we have the resources in place to produce perhaps the best odds for success we could have hoped for. To all who made this possible, in however large or small a way:

Thank you all.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#22 - 2016-05-22 15:00:11 UTC
Feeding them back into the Imperial slave markets under the excuse of "bound by law". You're capsuleers taking on other capsuleers' property, and Imperial Law got **** all to do with it. Unless CONCORD started camping your stations, you're in the legal position to do whatever you want with them, and so feeding them back into the Empire is an active and conscious choice on your behalf.

Don't try and foist off the responsibility for your choices on laws that don't apply to you. Don't foist off discarding these people's suffering and bondage as anything but your choices. It would have been the simplest thing in the world to keep this out of public view and all these people being treated, then given free citizenship wherever they wanted. That choice was always there, and it wouldn't even have cost you anything in the end.

The Empire had no claim on these people once they were in the clown's hands, and funneling them right back in is the active act of enslavement... done by an Achur.
Aedre Lafisques
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#23 - 2016-05-22 15:05:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Aedre Lafisques
Really? Then I get the feeling I've been lied to on a number of crucial occasions. I'll be looking into this one.

(--Turns out, it works out to a matter of logic, rather than legality. It does appear to be the case that if one eschews all Empire and cultural laws about what to do in a given circumstance, Capsuleers are theoretically 'allowed' to do whatever we want. However, if one is to work within a system, the laws apply as they would.)
Deitra Vess
Non-Hostile Target
Wild Geese.
#24 - 2016-05-22 15:36:19 UTC
I don't see the Amarr pilots' issue on letting them free to take command of their own lives. If their faith is so strong, what's to worry about? They'll obviously remain true to their Amarrian convictions after slavery no matter where they go right? I hope Mokks offer is considered because atleast it has the possibility to end well. As far as Sanxing's issues towards letting them go free by their own hand, I don't think how they conduct themselves on social issues such as this is any of our concern. They have no necessity to explain their private decisions any more than anyone else. Of course in turn nobody here has to hold them in a good light inspite of questions that have arisen.
Bong-cha Jones
Sanxing
#25 - 2016-05-22 15:52:59 UTC
I am in full agreement with Sanxing's stance on the matter. We are heavily invested in our own relief efforts in Lirsautton, and have little desire to defray the labor costs of slave-owning Holders. Since we are neither the organization who recovered the victims, nor the only organization involved in caring for them, we are free to limit what we do. Nobody in this cluster has unlimited resources, and we all must choose how to spend our limited (if often great) wealth. Nonetheless, we agreed to help not just any Jin Mei recovered, but all citizens of the Federation and of our ally the Republic.

I respect the work that SFRIM is doing, and am humbled by both the opportunity to assist in this crisis and by their courtesy and gratitude towards us for doing so, even in such a small way.
Jaret Victorian
Itsukame-Zainou Hyperspatial Inquiries Ltd.
Arataka Research Consortium
#26 - 2016-05-22 16:01:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Jaret Victorian
Samira Kernher wrote:
Xun Yu wrote:
Thus it is puzzling to me, and to Sanxing, that we are being criticised for not doing enough - may I ask what aid PIE has given? Or CVA? Or the Amarr authorities themselves?


Most of these organizations don't feel the need to make a public statement every time they take action.

Business doesn't survive without publicity.

Look, all I see here is capsuleers babbling about what they want to do with an enormous amount of people. As if these baseliners haven't suffered enough. Are they your property - like a bunch of chairs and tables that you just can decide what to do with them, where to place them?

These are human beings with real lives that last many years. You are talking about people. Now the right thing to do here would be to get off your high towers and ask these people what do they want to do and where do they want to go and then help them do it. That is what charity is about - helping people get out of a **** hole.

As much as I personally hate slavery, I can understand that some people are afraid of being free. They might not be suited for independant life, they may lack skills, morale and knowledge for it and can simply end up being robbed and killed. These people could easily say "Yeah, this life is not for me, I should get back to a holder and water his flowers in a garden, this is my comfort zone". We should help them. On the other hand, others may not. Others may say "I am sick of being abused by these mindless maniacs, I want my life back, I want to have my own home, my own family, my own children, I want to die of old age surrounded by loving family members". We should help them too.

Our "wants" don't really matter here, as much as some of us would love to shove them all back to a slave market or kick them out on the streets of one of the Federation or Republic cities smiling and chanting "you are free!". We want to help others. And others should decide how we should help them.
Ashlar Vellum
Esquire Armaments
#27 - 2016-05-22 16:35:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Ashlar Vellum
Xun Yu wrote:

Lieutenant Ashlar Vellum,

Firstly may I apologise for Wei Chemineau's rather blunt and forthright tone, however in matters of sincere belief he has a tendency to forget himself - a not unforgivable and in part admirable characteristic.

To address rather the matter of your accusation: As an organisation we are committed to upholding the Five Constants and Four Virtues that are at the core of Jin-Mei society, as well as defending those rights affirmed and enshrined in the Federal Charter of the Gallente Federation. Sanxing refuses to play the part of some petty torturer healing up broken bodies and souls only to send them back to the rack upon which they may be broken afresh by so called gentler hands.

This is not a matter of appearances but of the firm conviction of the morals and ethos which are at the core of our being, both as a collective organisation and the individuals who constitute Sanxing - the decision was put to a general vote of all staff as I had no desire to unilaterally decide the matter.

I would suggest that you look to your own affairs and morals before criticising the affairs and morals of others.

Sang Do Xun Yu
Taishou of Sanxing

No apologies needed, you are trying to help at least 129 people, this is good enough and I am thankful for that.

The thing is you can not be certain what will happen with other people afterwards, they may end up under care of a neglecting Holder they may not.

So I do have to ask what if some out of those 129 people would become a crew members on a combat capsuleer vessel, would you not help them then? They may get killed the same day they leave your care. What if some of those 129 people are criminals or loyal to one of the major pirate groups, what about that kind of people? They may get back to their shady ways afterwards. There is no end to such "what ifs" and "mays".

Mengyao Chemineau wrote:
Again, why does a Federal corp have to be the one to take care of "your" people for you?

So the decision was made on purely economic basis? Don't get me wrong I'm not judging, 33,000 is indeed not a small number of people.
James Syagrius
Luminaire Sovereign Solutions
#28 - 2016-05-22 21:28:19 UTC  |  Edited by: James Syagrius
As one who has long wished for more normalized relations with the Empire.

It is gratifying to see, both Imperial and Federal organizations in frank but productive discussions.

After… consultations with a variety of individuals and organizations, I would like to offer whatever assistance, those primarily responsible for the care of these unfortunates, may require.

Within of course the modest capacity of the organization I represent.
Xun Yu
Sanxing
#29 - 2016-05-22 21:59:02 UTC
Utari Onzo wrote:
CVA has, indeed, provided assistance. Fourth District even lost a freighter in the process of trying to supply medical equipment and staff, so if you want to sit here pointing fingers of who's doing what I suggest you snap your hand back in your pocket. All of our aid is unilateral and will be provided regardless of the status or citizenship of these victims. The only one laying out limitations here is you.


As Wei Chemineau has already expressed a personal condolence, please allow me to add Sanxing's formal condolences to those families of the brave individuals who gave themselves to serve others. We are indeed quite relieved to hear that the Societas is recieving aid from multiple quarters, especially from those organisations that are more easily able to offer unlimited aid given their synergy of morals with the Societas.

Samira Kernher wrote:
Most of these organizations don't feel the need to make a public statement every time they take action.


Sanxing like most, if not all, SCC registered corporations has a dozen or more press releases per day as transparency is important in any business' operation in order to ensure trust and good faith. As we understand that capsuleers have difficulty accessing the GalNet when connected to the pod or via their NeoCom we reproduce here on the IGS only those press releases we believe are of relevance or interest to capsuleers. Again our commitment to transparency is not limited to baseliners, we want to ensure that capsuleers too understand the purpose and actions of Sanxing.

Aria Jenneth wrote:
... At this point, we have the resources in place to produce perhaps the best odds for success we could have hoped for. To all who made this possible, in however large or small a way:

Thank you all.


Nushi Jenneth, as always a civil and polite voice, how very welcome. We are glad to hear that the Societas is now in a position to offer the very best chance to all suffering as a result of all the aid provided. Sanxing will forward on the relevant vitoxin medical data that our research team is presently working on.


Deitra Vess wrote:
... As far as Sanxing's issues towards letting them go free by their own hand, I don't think how they conduct themselves on social issues such as this is any of our concern...


Nushi Vess, forgive me but I do not follow this particular part of your comment. Sanxing was never in a position to free any of the slaves included within the 33,000 as the Societas has them within their care and custody. Those we have taken into care are free Federal and Republic citizens will of course be at liberty once they are well once more. As such I am not sure I follow.

Ashlar Vellum wrote:

No apologies needed, you are trying to help at least 129 people, this is good enough and I am thankful for that.

The thing is you can not be certain what will happen with other people afterwards, they may end up under care of a neglecting Holder they may not.

So I do have to ask what if some out of those 129 people would become a crew members on a combat capsuleer vessel, would you not help them then? They may get killed the same day they leave your care. What if some of those 129 people are criminals or loyal to one of the major pirate groups, what about that kind of people? They may get back to their shady ways afterwards. There is no end to such "what ifs" and "mays".

So the decision was made on purely economic basis? Don't get me wrong I'm not judging, 33,000 is indeed not a small number of people.


Lieutenant Vellum,

I fail to see the point of elucidating that there is an element of the unknown in the future, yes this is something we all acknowledge. In order to act and not be paralysed by the sheer multiplicity of possiblities then we must make such judgments as our morals demand and then act, or else what? We allow others to dictate for us the future and our actions in the present? Or take no actions whatsoever and stand by as idle observers of the gross injustice of the present? Sanxing is a principled organisation, a humanitarian one, and with those principles in mind we undertook what we believed to be the most right course of action: helping how we could while not betraying our commitment to the fundamental dignities of the Federal Charter.

Our decision was also influenced naturally by pragmatic matters, we are in the midst of a planet-wide relief effort, and consequently the majority of our resources and staff are directed to helping the billions impacted by a civil war.

Sang Do Xun Yu
Taishou of Sanxing

Sanxing - 'Three Stars' - Committed to the Jin-Mei and the Federation

Find us on your Neocom on the router: Sanxing

Aleria Angelis
Black Sun Enclave
Blue Echo
#30 - 2016-05-22 22:53:42 UTC
Jaret Victorian wrote:


As much as I personally hate slavery, I can understand that some people are afraid of being free. They might not be suited for independant life, they may lack skills, morale and knowledge for it and can simply end up being robbed and killed. These people could easily say "Yeah, this life is not for me, I should get back to a holder and water his flowers in a garden, this is my comfort zone". We should help them. On the other hand, others may not. Others may say "I am sick of being abused by these mindless maniacs, I want my life back, I want to have my own home, my own family, my own children, I want to die of old age surrounded by loving family members". We should help them too.

Our "wants" don't really matter here, as much as some of us would love to shove them all back to a slave market or kick them out on the streets of one of the Federation or Republic cities smiling and chanting "you are free!". We want to help others. And others should decide how we should help them.


We are condescending to assume freed servants will struggle to thrive outside of their familiar slave system, even if the system has been indoctrinated upon them since birth. Being restricted by Amarrian law is one thing, but the former is no moral justification for these victims continued enslavement. Unfortunately it doesn't look like the the majority of these victims will have any choice in their own future.

James Syagrius wrote:
As one who has long wished for more normalized relations with the Empire.

It is gratifying to see, both Imperial and Federal organizations in frank but productive discussions.


This is atleast something to take solace in, although the humanitarian outcome of this rescue is disappointing, Societas Imperialis's decision to allow 129 civilians to return to their normal lives does represent a willingness for co-operation despite faction tensions. And this can be applauded, as well as Sanxing's restraint and respect or other cultures in what must have been difficult discussions.
It is extremely difficult for humanitarian organizations to remain neutral in these kind of affairs.
Jaret Victorian
Itsukame-Zainou Hyperspatial Inquiries Ltd.
Arataka Research Consortium
#31 - 2016-05-22 23:36:06 UTC
Aleria Angelis wrote:
Unfortunately it doesn't look like the the majority of these victims will have any choice in their own future.

If people aren't given the choice of what they want to do with their lives then this is not a charity.
Aedre Lafisques
Nadire Security Consultants
Federation Peacekeepers
#32 - 2016-05-22 23:59:09 UTC
Aleria Angelis wrote:
We are condescending to assume freed servants will struggle to thrive outside of their familiar slave system, even if the system has been indoctrinated upon them since birth.



But it is also unrealistic to simply assume that they can or want to. Support should be given beyond simply granting freedom. I'm not convinced that coaching solves every individual's personal concerns, readying them for a Federal or Republic reality, which is in many cases not very forgiving.

We are also playing with the very idea of religion. A conservative slave believes that they must advance traditionally. I'm not ready to tear that away just because I happen not to believe and oppose some of what that entails. Individuals are different and we should be ready to address that if it should come up. It shouldn't be difficult for people like us to organise, even for 30 000, which as mentioned is actually quite a lot.



However, I think it still qualifies as charity, technically. Having done nothing is also an option. Everyone currently involved deserves appropriate commendation for right action. I've heard nothing but concern for these people and that is a good thing. We shouldn't be cutting at each other about the details while attempting something just. This doesn't have to be perfect, we're doing better than nothing already, which is where these people were at when we began. It is for the best that a multicultural force is debating over their fate than no debate at all. While I don't appreciate the tone of 'what to do with them', at least it is a discussion we are having.
Sinti Vailatti
Angelis Exploration
#33 - 2016-05-23 16:08:44 UTC
Xun Yu wrote:
[
Deitra Vess wrote:
... As far as Sanxing's issues towards letting them go free by their own hand, I don't think how they conduct themselves on social issues such as this is any of our concern...


Nushi Vess, forgive me but I do not follow this particular part of your comment. Sanxing was never in a position to free any of the slaves included within the 33,000 as the Societas has them within their care and custody. Those we have taken into care are free Federal and Republic citizens will of course be at liberty once they are well once more. As such I am not sure I follow.

Ashlar Vellum wrote:

No apologies needed, you are trying to help at least 129 people, this is good enough and I am thankful for that.

The thing is you can not be certain what will happen with other people afterwards, they may end up under care of a neglecting Holder they may not.

So I do have to ask what if some out of those 129 people would become a crew members on a combat capsuleer vessel, would you not help them then? They may get killed the same day they leave your care. What if some of those 129 people are criminals or loyal to one of the major pirate groups, what about that kind of people? They may get back to their shady ways afterwards. There is no end to such "what ifs" and "mays".

So the decision was made on purely economic basis? Don't get me wrong I'm not judging, 33,000 is indeed not a small number of people.


Lieutenant Vellum,

I fail to see the point of elucidating that there is an element of the unknown in the future, yes this is something we all acknowledge. In order to act and not be paralysed by the sheer multiplicity of possiblities then we must make such judgments as our morals demand and then act, or else what? We allow others to dictate for us the future and our actions in the present? Or take no actions whatsoever and stand by as idle observers of the gross injustice of the present? Sanxing is a principled organisation, a humanitarian one, and with those principles in mind we undertook what we believed to be the most right course of action: helping how we could while not betraying our commitment to the fundamental dignities of the Federal Charter.

Our decision was also influenced naturally by pragmatic matters, we are in the midst of a planet-wide relief effort, and consequently the majority of our resources and staff are directed to helping the billions impacted by a civil war.

Sang Do Xun Yu
Taishou of Sanxing




What's the issue here?

If the Amarr want to free the people under legal guidelines, Sinjin gave them a legal way out. The 33,000 were the remnants of House Mokk and now that they've been recovered, we're freeing them. Nauplius stole them from us. Prove me wrong. I dare ya. I double dare ya. Once a slave crosses over to the State, Republic or Federation they're technically free anyway. There. Legal **** solved. But as was mentioned, being Capsuleers, we really don't need the legal way out. The decision is totally up to the people who are holding them.

Legal option #2 would be to sell them to us (I think 1 ISK per head is fair) and we'll free them and then donate the proceeds to charity. Again, not needed. Transport all the people to Mr. Yu and their status as slaves becomes a null issue.

If certain Amarr want to keep them as slaves anyway, what does that tell you about their intentions and what kind of people they are under the skin?

Up to you Amarr. Free these people and prove you actually care about their well-being. Keep them classified as slaves, and you're basically continuing Nauplius' abusive work for him.

Of course, since Naup is still listed as an active pilot for Hoi Andrapodistai, maybe he's sitting back and laughing at the dilemma this has caused? Maybe he's been playing you for fools? 33,000 slaves is a drop in the bucket for him. It's a small price to pay to prove that the Societa, PIE, and CVA are using the Amarr religion and legal system to further their own ends.

“Where must we go...we who wander this wasteland, in search of our better selves?”

Ashlar Vellum
Esquire Armaments
#34 - 2016-05-23 18:16:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Ashlar Vellum
Sinti Vailatti wrote:

What's the issue here?

I believe that SFRIM already solved everything, so there are no issues left.

Aria Jenneth wrote:
Fortunately, the response has been enormous. We believe we now have the staff and resources needed to aid and comfort those in our care, and to pursue an effective treatment with all possible diligence.
Jaret Victorian
Itsukame-Zainou Hyperspatial Inquiries Ltd.
Arataka Research Consortium
#35 - 2016-05-23 19:11:07 UTC
Sinti Vailatti wrote:

What's the issue here?

If the Amarr want to free the people under legal guidelines, Sinjin gave them a legal way out. The 33,000 were the remnants of House Mokk and now that they've been recovered, we're freeing them. Nauplius stole them from us. Prove me wrong. I dare ya. I double dare ya. Once a slave crosses over to the State, Republic or Federation they're technically free anyway. There. Legal **** solved.

You have no idea how laws and people work, don't you?
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#36 - 2016-05-23 19:15:12 UTC
The law is clear. This is a capsuleer matter and Imperial law doesn't get a say in it. The Empire has agreed to those terms just like all the other nations in CONCORD. That these men and women are now enslaved by these capsuleers is a result of their choices, not any law they're bound by.

It is rather telling indeed, after having heard a lot of blather about "what they'd really prefer" and such nonsense, now proven to be flat out lies. These actions speak quite eloquently of their true colors.
Sinti Vailatti
Angelis Exploration
#37 - 2016-05-23 19:36:19 UTC
Jaret Victorian wrote:

You have no idea how laws and people work, don't you?


Actually, yes I do.

I also know first-hand what slavery is like in the Empire.


Mizhara Del'thul wrote:
The law is clear. This is a capsuleer matter and Imperial law doesn't get a say in it. The Empire has agreed to those terms just like all the other nations in CONCORD. That these men and women are now enslaved by these capsuleers is a result of their choices, not any law they're bound by.

It is rather telling indeed, after having heard a lot of blather about "what they'd really prefer" and such nonsense, now proven to be flat out lies. These actions speak quite eloquently of their true colors.



Exactly my point.

“Where must we go...we who wander this wasteland, in search of our better selves?”

Jaret Victorian
Itsukame-Zainou Hyperspatial Inquiries Ltd.
Arataka Research Consortium
#38 - 2016-05-23 20:55:14 UTC
You clearly don't.

This is a huge amount of people to deal with.. This isn't just a matter of you saying "You are free! Go and be you!"

You need to accommodate them first. Then you need to get supplies to feed these people - all variety of food, taking into account potential allergies, kids and various different aspects. You need to find volunteers and assistants, hire professional doctors, counselors, psychologists to treat their physical and psychological traumas, buy and ship all the necessary equipment for that. You need to get all the necessary medical supplies for that, get a crew that will take care of all kinds of waste produced in the process. Treating process itself takes time.

33,000 people is an enormous amount of variety, all the different mindsets and life stories. You need to take all these differences into account, you can't just dump them somewhere in Federation thinking they will be able to take care of themselves.

Then after you process these people you will need to arrange papers for them, citizenship, slave market papers and so on. Bureaucracy. Lawyers. Politicians. Eventually you will have to start making "donations" to speed up the process.

Then, if you are still interested, you will have to help these people set themselves up for a new life - where they will go, what they will do, where they will live.

"Charity" isn't just you giving commands and expecting everything to happen like som magic trick. This is responsibility. This is time, money and people heavily invested in what they do.

This is just something off the top of my head. The real process is much more complicated and ugly than that.
Mizhara Del'thul
Kyn'aldrnari
#39 - 2016-05-23 21:09:07 UTC
All of which we are very much experienced at. Thirty-three thousand? Try two hundred and fifty thousand, and that's just what the facilities I have been part of setting up and maintaining. If all the freedom fighters who have had years and years of experience with this, maintaining and cultivating transport, health and treatment staff, reintroduction to society training, mental welfare programs and so on came together... thirty three thousand would barely make a dent in our resources.

This isn't something new or unprecedented. Slaves have been treated in atrocious and horrifying ways by Imperials and criminals for a very long time, and we've gotten extremely good at providing for those victims over time.

We've offered this sort of assistance before, but it just wouldn't look very good on the IGS, would it? Naw, let's just funnel these victims back into the system that landed them into their terror in the first place. That'll solve matters in a satisfactory manner. What SFRIM and Aria Jenneth here has done is very clear. They've taken thirty three thousand men and women who no nation in New Eden have any claim over, and enslaved them at the point in time they were the most vulnerable.

Slavers. Feh.

I don't know why I've wasted my time on them. It's not like it's the first time they've chosen to inflict more suffering rather than give their victims a chance.
Jaret Victorian
Itsukame-Zainou Hyperspatial Inquiries Ltd.
Arataka Research Consortium
#40 - 2016-05-23 21:27:14 UTC
This is not a pissing contest about how we are successful managers.

But I do agree with you that shoving all these people back into the slave market system is completely wrong.
Previous page123Next page