These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
123Next pageLast page
 

Most ice miners are bots! *SHOCK* (not really...)

Author
Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#1 - 2012-01-12 15:28:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Smodab Ongalot
A few friends and I are currently on a purification pilgrimage to the regions of Heimatar, Metropolis, and Molden Heath (that'd be Minnie Ice belts); our goal is to purify the belts of all ice mining bots and lazy AFK miners by sending them to the deity of their choosing. I realize that the purification process is messy and that sometimes honest miners get caught. I make no apologies for this. As is said, you need to break some eggs to make an omelet.

During the pilgrimage I've been keeping some numbers; you honest ice miners might be interested in these statistics.

The data covers the 393 exhumer kills during the months of December and January.

January Kills
December Kills

Out of these kills, a whopping 328 of the remaining pods remained in the belt for greater than 10 minutes after their ship was destroyed.

That's 83.6 percent of ice miners did not warp their pods off after having their ships destroyed.

Out of these 328 pods, an alarming 113 of the pods continued to warp back and forth to the station after having their ship destroyed.

That's 34.4 percent of remaining pods continue to warp between station and belt in a pod after having their exhumer purified.


Frankly, I find it shameful that this number of people are able to make free isk (no work invested) and CCP continues to allow it. Till CCP does something about these slothful players, we will continue the purification.
Salcon Cliff
Zephyr Corp
#2 - 2012-01-12 15:33:38 UTC  |  Edited by: Salcon Cliff
That is why I add a tank to my Mack (as opposed to optimizing) and keep an alt in a Vulture floating in system :).

Do the bot miners use haulers or just fill their hold and run back and forth?

I do ice mine when I spend some time afk/distracted (feeding the kids or cleaning up around the house, etc.), so I could see my pod floating for a while, but probably not more than 10 minutes in an absolute worst-case scenario (i.e. you ganked me right as I walked away from the computer).
Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#3 - 2012-01-12 15:37:10 UTC
Salcon Cliff wrote:
That is why I add a tank to my Mack (as opposed to optimizing) and keep an alt in a Vulture floating in system :).

Do the bot miners use haulers or just fill their hold and run back and forth?



It doesn't matter what tank the bots fit, we are able to kill even the most heartily tanked mackinaws with ease. No bots escape the purification.

We see both types of bots. Some will have an orca, 4 mackinaws, and a hauler alt that warps between station and the orca. I assume the mackinaws mine into the orca. We have nabbed entire fleets this way:

Killing a bot fleet, including the orca, with catalysts.

We also see individual mackinaws that mine till full and warp back.
Zifrian
The Frog Pond
Ribbit.
#4 - 2012-01-12 15:53:59 UTC
Why don't you report them? Destroying their ships doesn't seem to matter. If you really care about bot mining that is.

Maximze your Industry Potential! - Download EVE Isk per Hour!

Import CCP's SDE - EVE SDE Database Builder

Skorpynekomimi
#5 - 2012-01-12 16:00:37 UTC
Zifrian wrote:
Why don't you report them? Destroying their ships doesn't seem to matter. If you really care about bot mining that is.


Because they want to pretend their suicide ganking has a point beyond increasing demand for minerals.

Economic PVP

Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#6 - 2012-01-12 16:02:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Smodab Ongalot
Zifrian wrote:
Why don't you report them? Destroying their ships doesn't seem to matter. If you really care about bot mining that is.


We usually do report them, though some admittedly get missed as the volume of bots is quite high.
Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#7 - 2012-01-12 16:03:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Smodab Ongalot
Skorpynekomimi wrote:

Because they want to pretend their suicide ganking has a point beyond increasing demand for minerals.


Didn't realize CCP changed ice mining in Crucible to also give minerals.


Clearly this person bot/afk mines ice.
Lady Ayeipsia
BlueWaffe
#8 - 2012-01-12 16:03:57 UTC
It takes 3 cycles, at about 5 minutes per cycle to fill my Mack's hold. If I am playing skryim while i ice mine on my pc, I don't necessarily check every 10 minutes if I am full or podded. In other words, I find the value of your statistic of pods in space after 10 minutes to be useless. 20 to 30, it may be a now broken bot. 10 minutes, it's just timing.

As for killing bots in general... Um... Good for you, but why should we care?
Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#9 - 2012-01-12 16:06:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Smodab Ongalot
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
Good for you, but why should we care?


If you are not a bot miner, then you should care because bots depress the value of the material you are mining.

Doesn't it **** you off that someone else is stealing your income by breaking the rules of the game?

If it does not, then please contact me IG. I have some faction ships for trade in station at a good price. Honest. Pirate
Lady Ayeipsia
BlueWaffe
#10 - 2012-01-12 16:28:56 UTC
Smodab Ongalot wrote:
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
Good for you, but why should we care?


If you are not a bot miner, then you should care because bots depress the value of the material you are mining.

Doesn't it **** you off that someone else is stealing your income by breaking the rules of the game?

If it does not, then please contact me IG. I have some faction ships for trade in station at a good price. Honest. Pirate



Or perhaps I run a minmitar pos and you are driving up my fuel costs? Or fly a min dread it carrier and again, fuel costs?
Or perhaps I have no stake in this at all and simply see your topic as wasting time and energy?
Or feel that ganking the botters solves nothing at all, but rather encourages other gankers which may eventually lead to myself being ganked?
Or that the proper course of action is to report/petition the botters, allowing ccp to observe the repetative behavior of the accounts, leading to account bans, instead of disrupting that cycle, making ccp have to work harder to have evidence for a ban?
Or maybe I feel you are not doing enough. Pod the bots, run locator agents to see where they have thier clone bays and if they continue to undock in newbie ships, and keep podding them till they lose enough skill points that they can't fly their ships?
Or perhaps, just perhaps, I'm bored at work, trolling you, and will be contrary no matter what you say simply so I have sinething to do!
Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#11 - 2012-01-12 16:29:23 UTC
Smodab Ongalot wrote:
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
Good for you, but why should we care?


If you are not a bot miner, then you should care because bots depress the value of the material you are mining.

Doesn't it **** you off that someone else is stealing your income by breaking the rules of the game?

If it does not, then please contact me IG. I have some faction ships for trade in station at a good price. Honest. Pirate


^^ Very much this...

Bots are a plague that should be eradicated!!!!!!
Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#12 - 2012-01-12 16:31:19 UTC
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
......!


Some good points...

Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
......
Or maybe I feel you are not doing enough. Pod the bots, run locator agents to see where they have thier clone bays and if they continue to undock in newbie ships, and keep podding them till they lose enough skill points that they can't fly their ships?


^ an OUTSTANDING idea!!!!
Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#13 - 2012-01-12 16:35:40 UTC
Lady Ayeipsia wrote:

Or that the proper course of action is to report/petition the botters, allowing ccp to observe the repetative behavior of the accounts, leading to account bans, instead of disrupting that cycle, making ccp have to work harder to have evidence for a ban?


We do report them. Unfortunately, my method of determining if someone is a bot requires me to blow them up first.

Lady Ayeipsia wrote:

Or maybe I feel you are not doing enough. Pod the bots, run locator agents to see where they have thier clone bays and if they continue to undock in newbie ships, and keep podding them till they lose enough skill points that they can't fly their ships?


Locator agent is in Hek, we use him quite frequently. Pirate

Lady Ayeipsia wrote:

Or perhaps, just perhaps, I'm bored at work, trolling you, and will be contrary no matter what you say simply so I have sinething to do!


Works for me! Lol
Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#14 - 2012-01-12 16:37:43 UTC
Salcon Cliff wrote:
That is why I add a tank to my Mack (as opposed to optimizing) and keep an alt in a Vulture floating in system :).

Do the bot miners use haulers or just fill their hold and run back and forth?


I suggest using a Hulk rather than a Mack:
Guide to Fighting Back as a Miner

And don't truly afk.... If you're reading or doing something else on your computer.... Set the shield "warning" level high enough that you are alerted to an attack and can take action before your ship is in dire need.

Defending against a wave of three catalysts should be very easy.... One BB will typically do the trick, but it can't be afk to do the job!

Nekopyat
Nee-Co
#15 - 2012-01-12 16:38:15 UTC
You do realize that ganking is one of the big reasons there are so many bots in the first place?

Bot miners can afford to replace ships easily, loosing a few hundred million in exhumer is not a big deal so it simply becomes a cost of doing business.

Human miners on the other hand play a lot less and their ROI is a lot lower, so often when they get ganked they simply do not return to mining, they can't afford it. So over time human miners leave the profession while the bot ones keep at about the same numbers.

So you are not doing some noble deed, you are making the problem worse.
Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#16 - 2012-01-12 16:49:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Gizznitt Malikite
Nekopyat wrote:
You do realize that ganking is one of the big reasons there are so many bots in the first place?

Bot miners can afford to replace ships easily, loosing a few hundred million in exhumer is not a big deal so it simply becomes a cost of doing business.

Human miners on the other hand play a lot less and their ROI is a lot lower, so often when they get ganked they simply do not return to mining, they can't afford it. So over time human miners leave the profession while the bot ones keep at about the same numbers.

So you are not doing some noble deed, you are making the problem worse.


I think your argument is very flawed.

FIrst, if Bot miner's are anywhere near as prevelant as Smodab suggests, they really suppress the value of ice/ore. If you take the Bots out of the picture, the cost of minerals/ice will balance itself between the risks of mining ice and the need for it (see supply and demand). This will not only make the ROI worth it for human players, it will even draw people back into mining!

Besides, Human players adapt a lot quicker to hostile situations than Bots. A human player can easily learn to defend themselves, and lets be honest... One ship can defend an entire belt against 3 catalysts... as long as they're not afk.

If Smodab wants to test it, l'm willing to bring a BB, Falcon, or Rook out to be a nice juicy target...
Lady Ayeipsia
BlueWaffe
#17 - 2012-01-12 16:53:12 UTC
Um... Take action before dire need? That doesn't work. If a tanker plans to get you, they will scram or disrupt you. There is no warping. If you mean have time to run a booster, again they usually bring extra ships to compensate. 3 to 4 catalysts will beat a shield boosters.

Better to stay passively aligned to your warp out and run when people arrive at the belt if you are not afk.

As for hulk, remember, the Mack gains a 100% yield bonus for ice mining, but mines a tad slower. Still, for ice mining if you do not use a Mack, then you are hurting your profits more than a gank will.

As for cost... About 1000 units of ice equal 200 mil isk, which is about 21 hours solo mining and with no bonuses. That really is a day of bot mining for a single botting account. (a week if you have limited play time for a normal miner) you would have to kill over a ship per day to hurt their profit.
Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#18 - 2012-01-12 16:54:02 UTC
Nekopyat wrote:
You do realize that ganking is one of the big reasons there are so many bots in the first place?

Bot miners can afford to replace ships easily, loosing a few hundred million in exhumer is not a big deal so it simply becomes a cost of doing business.

Human miners on the other hand play a lot less and their ROI is a lot lower, so often when they get ganked they simply do not return to mining, they can't afford it. So over time human miners leave the profession while the bot ones keep at about the same numbers.

So you are not doing some noble deed, you are making the problem worse.


Interesting point, but I disagree.

Bots exist because ice mining in high sec is (outside of ganking) completely risk free and exceptionally easy to perform. It is because it only takes ~12 mouse clicks every 10 minutes to make 6m/hr, that so many bots exist in the ice belts. It is so simple, I believe it would be possible to make an ice mining macro on one of those fancy logitech keyboards with the LCD screen. That's just not right.

By increasing the level of risk substantially, we hope to drive them out of ice mining by making it too much hassle.

Furthermore, we are ganking them repeatadly, making sure the cost of their ships is high.

And if you look closely at the link I posted above, that one bot operation is out 7 Billion isk now. With 4 mackinaws, that's going to take him some 10.5 days of non stop mining to make back. That ain't no pocket change, son.

Now you say we are driving out the real miners. I would say that if they are real miners, then they would get out of the belt after the first gank and stay safe. And this does happen. Often after the first gank, some small percentage of people will dock up and wait for us to finish killing the bots that remained in the belt.


We are only doing God's work here, people.


Smodab Ongalot
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#19 - 2012-01-12 16:59:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Smodab Ongalot
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:


If Smodab wants to test it, l'm willing to bring a BB, Falcon, or Rook out to be a nice juicy target...


We encourage this type of behavior. Nice critical thinking, some planning, the motivation to do something. These are all good things, and just further my justification of what we are doing (getting people to actively play the game, instead of a bot playing for them).

We have also created content for several different groups here.

1) People like the bloke above now get to come up with ways to defend themselves (and I will tell you that a few of the real miners have already done this and are quite effective)

2) Manufacturers have more business because of this. People building mackinaws, ice miner IIs, catalysts, blasters, etc. Since we started we've blown up roughly 1300 catalysts. That'd be about 10,000 meta and t1 blasters gone too.

3) Real miners will now hopefully get a little better return on their time.

I'm sure if you try, you can think of other people that now have more "game to play" because of our actions.


Lady Ayeipsia wrote:
As for cost... About 1000 units of ice equal 200 mil isk, which is about 21 hours solo mining and with no bonuses. That really is a day of bot mining for a single botting account. (a week if you have limited play time for a normal miner) you would have to kill over a ship per day to hurt their profit.


We try

And try

And try....

Also, don't forget that after we kill them, they can't mine anymore until their master comes back and starts the bot up again. This is lost income that needs to be accounted for.
Velicitia
XS Tech
#20 - 2012-01-12 17:06:52 UTC
I support this product and/or service. Looks like you're missing an ice belt or two from your kills though ...

One of the bitter points of a good bittervet is the realisation that all those SP don't really do much, and that the newbie is having much more fun with what little he has. - Tippia

123Next pageLast page