These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

A plea for the viability of shenanigans

Author
Staten Island
Diversity 101
Domain Research and Mining Inst.
#1 - 2015-10-27 21:17:13 UTC
Once upon a time way back when I first started playing Eve, it was a decidedly edgy place. You could interact with players in ways that were at once both a little anti-social but also fun. At the core of these activities was a simple idea that smart game play was rewarded and stupid (or uninformed) game play punished. There was can flipping, orca jacking, ganking, pos and corp theft, station bumping, corp infiltration and awoxing, etc... I submit that these activities were good for the game. They made eve an edgy place which differentiated eve from every other mmo out there. Sure a player might not like being on the wrong end of one of these activities as they occur, but that added element of danger made everything, even trading in a station, more exciting and interesting.

Now over time, there has been a mellowing of the game, with many of the hard edges smoothed away. We have lost a lot of the activities of yesterday such as can flipping, and orca jacking. And now with the introduction of Citadels we stand to lose even more - with their personal hangers and no force fields, we stand to lose or at least decrease to the point of irrelevance corp and pos theft. Also with Citadels and their random undocks and apparently perfect insta alignment, we may also lose the ability to force engagements on stations.

I submit that we need shenanigans to keep eve fresh and interesting. Without shenanigans, eve just becomes yet another mmo albeit one with very subpar pve. So I hope, that in making the proposed expansion, CCP keeps the need for shenanigans and does not make the Citadels too perfect - that the ability to mess with other players, through corp theft, or otherwise be built into the game and that as time goes on other means for interacting in slightly anti-social but interesting ways be introduced.

That is all
O/
Bumblefck
Kerensky Initiatives
#2 - 2015-10-27 21:24:17 UTC
Players create the content, not barleyjacks

Perfection is a dish best served like wasabi .

Bumble's Space Log

Bobb Bobbington
Rattini Tribe
Minmatar Fleet Alliance
#3 - 2015-10-27 21:57:51 UTC
What's orca-jacking? Sounds fun!!! Smile

This is a signature.

It has a 25m signature.

No it's not a cosmic signature.

Probably.

Btw my corp's recruiting.

Top Guac
Doomheim
#4 - 2015-10-27 22:01:18 UTC
Unfortunately the cotton wool brigade feel it is their right that CCP protect them rather than they HTFU.
Mijel Riak
Extensive Enterprises Space
#5 - 2015-10-27 22:13:09 UTC
Bobb Bobbington wrote:
What's orca-jacking? Sounds fun!!! Smile


Find an Orca, then go jack it...
I think they made a documentary about it called "Free Willy"
Vaju Enki
Secular Wisdom
#6 - 2015-10-27 22:17:32 UTC
I miss jetcan mining. Ore theft was fun.

The Tears Must Flow

Jenshae Chiroptera
#7 - 2015-10-27 22:18:46 UTC
I am all for "shenanigans"

However, there needs to be a clear distinction beween when players are exploiting weak code design to their advantage and when players are in control to make moves and counter moves.

CCP - Building ant hills and magnifying glasses for fat kids

Not even once

EVE is becoming shallow and puerile; it will satisfy neither the veteran nor the "WoW" type crowd in the transition.

Staten Island
Diversity 101
Domain Research and Mining Inst.
#8 - 2015-10-27 22:27:34 UTC
Bobb Bobbington wrote:
What's orca-jacking? Sounds fun!!! Smile


Once upon a time people would load everything they needed to mine into an orca - then they would go find a quite place and pop out and board their hulk leaving their orca pilotless - they could then use the orca like a large jetcan. They would try to keep folk from boarding the orca by targeting it with their hulk. The trick to orca jacking was to break the target lock and board the orca before they could get back on board. A buddy of mine and myself stole about 6 orcas this way. It was great fun. Of course the people doing it were using orcas in surprisingly silly ways, but that was what was great about eve - the ability for folk to do stupid things with the tools that were given to them. Eve killed orca jacking when they made changes to the way fleet hangers work - also folk rarely jet can anymore.
Nevyn Auscent
Broke Sauce
#9 - 2015-10-27 22:36:59 UTC
Staten Island wrote:


Once upon a time people would load everything they needed to mine into an orca - then they would go find a quite place and pop out and board their hulk leaving their orca pilotless - they could then use the orca like a large jetcan. They would try to keep folk from boarding the orca by targeting it with their hulk. The trick to orca jacking was to break the target lock and board the orca before they could get back on board. A buddy of mine and myself stole about 6 orcas this way. It was great fun. Of course the people doing it were using orcas in surprisingly silly ways, but that was what was great about eve - the ability for folk to do stupid things with the tools that were given to them. Eve killed orca jacking when they made changes to the way fleet hangers work - also folk rarely jet can anymore.

Or you know possibly people just learnt and stopped being so stupid, since the few stupid people that did that had rage quit already.....
Just a stray thought.

Just like all the big name awox'es (including awox himself) were actually done in low & null and are still entirely possible these days.

Basically, CCP have not removed the ability to do any of this stuff you are complaining about, you can still can flip, orca jack and the like. People now just actually mine in groups, use secure containers, warp back to station etc. As soon as someone jetcans, you can can flip to your hearts content.
Bobb Bobbington
Rattini Tribe
Minmatar Fleet Alliance
#10 - 2015-10-27 23:11:32 UTC
Sounds fun! Much better than baiting/trolling mission runners, although I almost got a rattlesnake yesterday. I can only imagine the tears orca-jacking brought! Twisted

This is a signature.

It has a 25m signature.

No it's not a cosmic signature.

Probably.

Btw my corp's recruiting.

Staten Island
Diversity 101
Domain Research and Mining Inst.
#11 - 2015-10-27 23:49:13 UTC
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Staten Island wrote:


Once upon a time people would load everything they needed to mine into an orca - then they would go find a quite place and pop out and board their hulk leaving their orca pilotless - they could then use the orca like a large jetcan. They would try to keep folk from boarding the orca by targeting it with their hulk. The trick to orca jacking was to break the target lock and board the orca before they could get back on board. A buddy of mine and myself stole about 6 orcas this way. It was great fun. Of course the people doing it were using orcas in surprisingly silly ways, but that was what was great about eve - the ability for folk to do stupid things with the tools that were given to them. Eve killed orca jacking when they made changes to the way fleet hangers work - also folk rarely jet can anymore.

Or you know possibly people just learnt and stopped being so stupid, since the few stupid people that did that had rage quit already.....
Just a stray thought.

Just like all the big name awox'es (including awox himself) were actually done in low & null and are still entirely possible these days.

Basically, CCP have not removed the ability to do any of this stuff you are complaining about, you can still can flip, orca jack and the like. People now just actually mine in groups, use secure containers, warp back to station etc. As soon as someone jetcans, you can can flip to your hearts content.


Nobody ever learns - people just kept doing until ccp changed the rules and made it so you couldnt. And yes you can awox in null and low - but so what? What other games are there out there where you can liberate stuff from other players - without having to actually shoot them? None that I know of. That was the great thing about eve - there were lots of ways to interact with other players besides just shooting at them. Over time the options have gotten less and less. I will also suggest that at the same time the options for shenanigans have gone down - so has the number of folk logging in.
Kinete Jenius
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#12 - 2015-10-27 23:49:54 UTC  |  Edited by: Kinete Jenius
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Staten Island wrote:


Once upon a time people would load everything they needed to mine into an orca - then they would go find a quite place and pop out and board their hulk leaving their orca pilotless - they could then use the orca like a large jetcan. They would try to keep folk from boarding the orca by targeting it with their hulk. The trick to orca jacking was to break the target lock and board the orca before they could get back on board. A buddy of mine and myself stole about 6 orcas this way. It was great fun. Of course the people doing it were using orcas in surprisingly silly ways, but that was what was great about eve - the ability for folk to do stupid things with the tools that were given to them. Eve killed orca jacking when they made changes to the way fleet hangers work - also folk rarely jet can anymore.

Or you know possibly people just learnt and stopped being so stupid, since the few stupid people that did that had rage quit already.....
Just a stray thought.

Just like all the big name awox'es (including awox himself) were actually done in low & null and are still entirely possible these days.

Basically, CCP have not removed the ability to do any of this stuff you are complaining about, you can still can flip, orca jack and the like. People now just actually mine in groups, use secure containers, warp back to station etc. As soon as someone jetcans, you can can flip to your hearts content.

This is the truth. Everything OP said is still possible to do today. It's just after 12 years people have finally learned to avoid those things. There is also a marked reduction in newbies playing eve so the number of potential targets has never been lower

Staten Island wrote:
Nobody ever learns - people just kept doing until ccp changed the rules and made it so you couldnt. And yes you can awox in null and low - but so what? What other games are there out there where you can liberate stuff from other players - without having to actually shoot them? None that I know of. That was the great thing about eve - there were lots of ways to interact with other players besides just shooting at them. Over time the options have gotten less and less. I will also suggest that at the same time the options for shenanigans have gone down - so has the number of folk logging in.
What are you even talking about? You can still do everything in your original post.

You can awox in highsec too. You can gank in highsec and completely bypass the whole being in the corp thing. There are a **** ton of games out there where you can steal stuff from other people. Probably one of the reasons eve is having so much trouble is the vast number of sandbox games that have come out during it's life.
Thierry Orlenard
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#13 - 2015-10-28 00:08:46 UTC
Staten Island wrote:
Bobb Bobbington wrote:
What's orca-jacking? Sounds fun!!! Smile


Once upon a time people would load everything they needed to mine into an orca - then they would go find a quite place and pop out and board their hulk leaving their orca pilotless - they could then use the orca like a large jetcan. They would try to keep folk from boarding the orca by targeting it with their hulk. The trick to orca jacking was to break the target lock and board the orca before they could get back on board. A buddy of mine and myself stole about 6 orcas this way. It was great fun. Of course the people doing it were using orcas in surprisingly silly ways, but that was what was great about eve - the ability for folk to do stupid things with the tools that were given to them. Eve killed orca jacking when they made changes to the way fleet hangers work - also folk rarely jet can anymore.



People definitely still jet-can; they're just more cautious about it, I guess? It's done in mining fleets quite often.
Orca-jacking sounds like a blast. I'm sorry I missed that kind of thing.

Staten Island
Diversity 101
Domain Research and Mining Inst.
#14 - 2015-10-28 00:13:44 UTC
Kinete Jenius wrote:
Nevyn Auscent wrote:
Staten Island wrote:


Once upon a time people would load everything they needed to mine into an orca - then they would go find a quite place and pop out and board their hulk leaving their orca pilotless - they could then use the orca like a large jetcan. They would try to keep folk from boarding the orca by targeting it with their hulk. The trick to orca jacking was to break the target lock and board the orca before they could get back on board. A buddy of mine and myself stole about 6 orcas this way. It was great fun. Of course the people doing it were using orcas in surprisingly silly ways, but that was what was great about eve - the ability for folk to do stupid things with the tools that were given to them. Eve killed orca jacking when they made changes to the way fleet hangers work - also folk rarely jet can anymore.

Or you know possibly people just learnt and stopped being so stupid, since the few stupid people that did that had rage quit already.....
Just a stray thought.

Just like all the big name awox'es (including awox himself) were actually done in low & null and are still entirely possible these days.

Basically, CCP have not removed the ability to do any of this stuff you are complaining about, you can still can flip, orca jack and the like. People now just actually mine in groups, use secure containers, warp back to station etc. As soon as someone jetcans, you can can flip to your hearts content.

This is the truth. Everything OP said is still possible to do today. It's just after 12 years people have finally learned to avoid those things. There is also a marked reduction in newbies playing eve so the number of potential targets has never been lower

Staten Island wrote:
Nobody ever learns - people just kept doing until ccp changed the rules and made it so you couldnt. And yes you can awox in null and low - but so what? What other games are there out there where you can liberate stuff from other players - without having to actually shoot them? None that I know of. That was the great thing about eve - there were lots of ways to interact with other players besides just shooting at them. Over time the options have gotten less and less. I will also suggest that at the same time the options for shenanigans have gone down - so has the number of folk logging in.
What are you even talking about? You can still do everything in your original post.

You can awox in highsec too. You can gank in highsec and completely bypass the whole being in the corp thing. There are a **** ton of games out there where you can steal stuff from other people. Probably one of the reasons eve is having so much trouble is the vast number of sandbox games that have come out during it's life.


The idea that people dont can mine because they have learned is ridiculous - ccp changed the barges and the safety rules so can mining became obsolete.. As for orca jacking - ccp changed the way fleet hangers worked - so no you cant do that anymore. As for awoxing - ccp added a toggle so that most corps now have corp ganking set as illegal. making hs awoxing largely a thing of the past. So no you cant do everything you used to be able to do in the past. In fact, only ganking has fairly much remained the same - which is fairly odd given that all of the other things were much easier to protect against then ganking.

As for other games where you can steal people's stuff - name one major title. The only one that I can remember off hand is ultima online.
Tau Cabalander
Retirement Retreat
Working Stiffs
#15 - 2015-10-28 00:39:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Tau Cabalander
Vaju Enki wrote:
I miss jetcan mining. Ore theft was fun.

Umm... you can still do that.

Look for Ventures, dumb miners, and ice fields.

Staten Island wrote:
There was can flipping, orca jacking, ganking, pos and corp theft, station bumping, corp infiltration and awoxing, etc.

* Can flipping is gone.
* Orca jacking? No idea what this is.
* Ganking is still done.
* POS and corp theft is still done.
* Station bumping? No idea what this is.
* Corp infiltration and awoxing are still done. [Heck, many don't know about the blue switch.]

Sorry, my EVE memory starts Feb 2009, about two weeks pre-Apocrypha.
Otso Bakarti
Doomheim
#16 - 2015-10-28 00:51:15 UTC
"Emergent game play!

"Content creation!"

Where's CODE when you need 'em???

Cool

There just isn't anything that can be said!

Nevyn Auscent
Broke Sauce
#17 - 2015-10-28 01:09:08 UTC
Staten Island wrote:

As for other games where you can steal people's stuff - name one major title. The only one that I can remember off hand is ultima online.

Day Z
Ark I think though I've not played it.

Just to start you down the right list.
You are trying to look at classic fantasy MMO's rather than the Sandbox MMO's, of course you aren't finding many where you can steal stuff when you are looking at such a narrow subset.
Kinete Jenius
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#18 - 2015-10-28 02:40:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Kinete Jenius
Staten Island wrote:
The idea that people dont can mine because they have learned is ridiculous - ccp changed the barges and the safety rules so can mining became obsolete.. As for orca jacking - ccp changed the way fleet hangers worked - so no you cant do that anymore. As for awoxing - ccp added a toggle so that most corps now have corp ganking set as illegal. making hs awoxing largely a thing of the past. So no you cant do everything you used to be able to do in the past. In fact, only ganking has fairly much remained the same - which is fairly odd given that all of the other things were much easier to protect against then ganking.

As for other games where you can steal people's stuff - name one major title. The only one that I can remember off hand is ultima online.
The increase in ore hold was incredibly minor. If you have an issue with someone not jetcanning then get a budy and gank them. Most retrievers can be ganked with one catalyst (thanks to the change boosting destroyers) so you wouldn't even need help on them. Someone running a skiff or procurer will jetcan or eat a loss in profit from all the docking. That's why I've seen jet canning galore although these days they tend to use MTUs. BTW you can shoot MTUS and other stuff without going criminal. So actually there's more stuff you can do to mess with them.

Safety has nothing to do with anything. People who run green wouldn't shoot anyway prior to the safety.

CCP has done absolutely nothing to change orca jacking. It was always a tiny few that was stupid enough to try such things. Those people have either learned or rage quit by now.

As for Awox you can clearly see if a corp has FF or not before joining so spend a couple more seconds to check before joining your victim corp. You're crying because you're too lazy to click a couple times?

You can still gank your corp mates just as easily as before.

There's a **** ton of survivor horror games alone that have such a function. Not even getting into the korean MMos and such.