My EVE

although i dont really like vids where you catch ratting ships, your vid is good, i like it. I like how you show the tactics of catching them.

I take it back. Blink 182 came on.

And i though that a good video had to have challenging fights that are exciting to watch. That was what i was criticized for not having in my 'Rebirth 4' and 'Clash of the Empires' videos by many 0.0 space players in my topic about those videos. So i'm gonna give the same criticizing back.

At least i was shooting other PVP players that did actually shoot back in my videos, so i can't really say i enjoyed this video. Because shooting / killing carebears with overwhelming force isn't what i call challenging and exciting.

So i'll give this a 4/10. And that's being nice. You get the 4/10 for having a good edited video and for having more instructions on how to scan for targets and how to get them effectively. That's the positive of the video.

So basicly, this video is fine just because it's from 0.0 space?

Here is a hint. It doesn't matter where the video is made.

Well, i actually gave Gulnar props for having a video where i gives him good words for showing how to scan and catch those targets in my first post. That was the best thing with the video. The editing was also fine. But the actual content where he just use a cyno to jump in more Black Ops on them was boring. The targets basicly had no chance what so ever because they were overwhelmed by a large margin in most of the fights.

Did you watch the 'Clash of the Empires' video at all?

We had more numbers than RvB in that video, but we was fighting a force that was WAY more powerfull and experienced than us in that type of fights, because we had never done such a fight in empire before and because the FC we had there made some mistakes. And what about the first fight in Amarr where we was fighting 7x Dominix'es and 1x Tempest?

Our Bhaalgorn was actually down in deep armor at the end of the fight before they started to deaggro and we barely managed to kill anyone of them. But thanks to our Falcons, we managed to break up their RR chain and kill some few of them. So the fight in Amarr and the fights against RvB was by no means overwhelming them and killing them without any challenge.


Wrong, i told him in my first post that i gave him the 4/10 because his video was made in a good way and because it's an instructional video where he shows how to catch those carebears. That's fine. But as a PVP video it was bad and boring and therefor i gave him the score as i did.


I know it's his alts and maybe some few others. But having neutrals in local isn't enough to have an overwhelming force to kill single targets like that. If he have had some balls, he would take the risk (YES, risk vs reward) and jump on them to make a really good and thrilling video out of it.

To take an example. We didn't really know how many ships RvB was going to bring against us in my 'Clash of the Empires' video. So we only knew what they had when they already where closeby. We did the same and did bring alot of ships to be on the safe side incase they would bring more ships.


See answer over. We took a massive risk in the fights against RvB as we mercenaries that went together against RvB had never done such fights before and because our FC there (which we had in the fights in Muvolailen and Jita) had no direct experience in such fights. So we had to take what we had available. And not to mention on how much bigger RvB combined is over how many we mercenaries that went against them had. They could have brought double the numbers of what we had and even more.

The reason we went into that fight was to be a part of something historical that most likely wont happen again in a VERY long time in high sec. The fight in Jita is the biggest fight ot happen there in EVE's history. That alone is enough to make a video about that.

And lastly. My videos and Gulnar's video here is not the same, at all. But they still have to be challenging and exciting to watch anyways. That's the beauty of making EVE videos which i was told many times in my topics about my videos.

Some of the best PVPers in EvE commented in your 'Clash of the Empires' thread with a wide range of constructive criticism. It's clear you haven't taken any of it onboard otherwise we would not be having this discussion, and the fact that you still think the content in your video was a beacon of light is evidence of that.

Considering Gulnar did not even comment in your thread is even more disgraceful, as here you are giving him bad feedback based on the feedback you were given by others on your own videos.

I'd like to receive constructive comments in this thread, comments from people that could help me to improve my future videos, After watching more or less all your releases I'd like you to cease posting in this thread as you are clearly not a part of the aforementioned group , thank you!

Also I never stated that this was a PVP video

It does not matter what kind of player you are fighting. If they are in fact a player, then fighting with them is to be considered a player versus player fight, by any reasonable definition of the term "PvP".

I am actually a fan of NightmareX and his videos, and I think that much of the EVE community is comprised of elitist d-bags who try way too hard to define PvP by how they choose to PvP, without looking at the bigger picture.

On the other hand, NightmareX this has turned into a bit of a shitpost thread and there is no reason to continue with this nonsensical argument.

Gulnar, it was a fine video and I quite enjoyed it. It's refreshing to see different stuff once in a while and yours was enjoyable and informative. Quality video.

Quite simply put, that was the best carebear killing vidya I have seen. Awesome tactics, excellent probing, excellent scouting and very nicely edited.

You'll do well by ignoring that bitter **** not understanding anything.

Also I am sad to see you go AFK. I hope you have a good AFK and will return with renewed strength to punish them zerobears and their ridiciliousely expensive stuff.

ohseven