These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[Proposal] War Charters

Author
Mars Theran
Foreign Interloper
#1 - 2012-01-03 06:53:43 UTC  |  Edited by: Mars Theran
Condensed version; moved from another WarDec thread.

Protection Charters

Cost to Maintain: 15 Million/Week

Effect: Corp Holding Protection Charter has the ability to outbid a WarDec cost with the SCC. Should a WarDeccing Corp attempt to declare against this Corporation, they are informed that this corporation has the ability to outbid this WarDec in the next 24 hours.

Should they choose not to do so; War will commence immediately upon the end of that 24 hour period. Alternatively, should they choose to outbid the declaring party, the SCC will return that parties ISK for the declaration fee, and they may press forward with their declaration of War the following day.

In the event that a war occur's where the defending party holds a Protection Charter, that party will have full insurance on any ship losses, for as long as they maintain their protection charter. This insurance will cover a 20% premium over any insurance they may maintain on a given ship.


War Charters and Ammendments

Cost to Maintain: None

Cost to Purchase: 150 million ISK

Cost for Standard Ammendments: 150 million ISK

Including, but not limited to, per allowance of each additional allied Corporation to be included in any War at holders discretion and naming upon signing any War Declaration, extending, as an Executor Corp, said Charter to cover an Alliance with automatic inclusion of all Corporations in any War Declaration, (Not required), and prevention of enemy CEOs and Directorship from leaving a target Alliance or Corporation for the duration of any war in which they are a Target.

Cost for Nominal Ammendments: 75 Million ISK

Including, but not limited to, ability to extend regions of any War beyond the Region of Declarations borders in any direction, allowance the destruction of assets held in space by a target Corporation or Alliance, such as POS, declaration of holding Corporation/Alliance as Mercenary force or entity, allowing use of appropriate UI features and Contracts, and addition to standard number, (1), of wars that may be declared and convened at any time.

Cost for non-standard Ammendments: 200 million ISK

Including use of specific restricted modules and munitions in High or Low Security Space, (These may include, but are not limited to, Smartbombs, Warp Interdiction Spheres, Bombs, and ECM Burst modules), for each exception of Device or Security Classification.

Effect:

War Charter holding Corporations or Alliances may declare on other Corporations or Alliances on a daily basis, with a cost based on the number and power of ammendments to their War Charter.

For every included Corporation without a Charter, that cost will go up marginally, and that Corporation may use Logistics or EWAR support to assist in the War effort, while-in no way-may they provide direct damage support against the enemy.

Any War Declared against aWar Charter holding Corp is automatically made mutual and will commence in 24 hours, unless they are a). Currently holding and maintaining a Protection Charter, or b). Currently nvolved in their or the declaring parties maximum number of Wars.

Any use of restricted weapons use that results in a fatalities or ship loss(es) to an individual or party not involved in a current war will result in the Ammendment for use of that Device to be stripped from the offending Corporation and Allies War Charters. Reaquisition of that Ammendment to the Charter(s)-at cost-will not be available for another 30 standard days.

Any individuals involved in a War effort are not subject to Security Status loss, for the duration of that War effort, evolving from any collateral damage resulting from use of permitted devices that are currently restricted in any security of space.

Discuss.
zubzubzubzubzubzubzubzub
Gerrick Palivorn
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#2 - 2012-01-03 07:27:42 UTC
It's interesting, I just want to decode it a bit

Proteciton Charters: Allows a pvp corp to protect an indy corp by way of outbidding the griefer corp (for ease of wording). Then the pvp corp will have a wardec against the griefer corp instead of the griefer corp deccing the indy corp? Right?

War Charter: Multiple corps or alliances can jointly war dec someone, at the cost of 150 mil per entity

Nominal Ammendment: You can then chain dec other corps that you might think have an affiliation at an additional 75 mil a piece.

Nonstandard ammendment: You can use smartbombs and bubbles and bombs and all that 0.0 love in the war for an additional 200 mil. With the restriction of only the people under wardec can be harmed by them.

Clairification would be nice, examples would be better.

MMOs come and go, but Eve remains.  -Garresh-

Mars Theran
Foreign Interloper
#3 - 2012-01-03 08:07:21 UTC  |  Edited by: Mars Theran
Yeah. Someone made me read the TOS and EULA earlier tonight. It rubs off.

To clarify, Protection Charters can be held by any corporation or Alliance and maintained for a nominal fee. This is essentially the same as a Dec Shield with the exception that the Corp must oubid the Corporation or Alliance that comes to Declare War on them.

This is essentially gives them 24 hours until the WarDec mechanics allow the declaring Corporation or Alliance to attempt to declare War on them again. Following that period, the Corporation or Alliance pressing for War, may place another fee with the SCC, (there first being returned when they were outbid), to continue their efforts to achieve a legal and consensual War.

Should the targeted Corporation or Alliance, (the holder of the Protection Charter), not outbid them a second time, War will commence in 24 hours in a consensual fashion.

In this way, a Corporation or Alliance holding a Protection Charter can stave off War for an indefinite amount of time, provided they have the funds to do so, or can earn them in due process. It becomes a War of Attrition. One side presses for War, while the other lobbies the SCC to prevent that War from taking place.

The Protection Charter also guarantees insurance at a higher than standard rate for the duration of any War pressed against the Corporation or Alliance holding the Charter; but only for those losses that are incurred as a direct result of an ongoing War.


War Charters on the other hand, allow a Corporation or Alliance to lobby the SCC for entitlement to wage war on another Corporation or Alliance with all the power their Charter and Ammendments allow them to wield.

A Standard War Charter only allows a Corporation to field ships against a target Corporation, using pilots who are members of the War Charter holding Corporation. No restricted modules or Devices are allowed, nor does the War Charter have the ability to extend to an Alliance of which that Corporation is a member.

So a Corporation within an Alliance may declare War on another Corporation outside of, or even within that same Alliance, but does not have the ability to bring other Corporations within their own Alliance or outside of it into that War.

An Executor Corp may aquire a Standard Ammendment to extend a War Charter to their Alliance, which will enable any Corporation in the Alliance to be brought into War with them.

A Corporation within that Alliance, which is brought into War, may only participate in that War as their Charter, or lack thereof, allows. This means, if that Corporation holds no War Charter, they may only bring Logistical or EWAR support. If however, they have a War Charter and potentially Ammendments to that Charter, they may participate in a fashion as befits the Charter which they hold and its Ammendments.

Each Ammendment is seperate, and comes with its own fee. To legally qualify as a Mercenary Corporation or Alliance, and gain income as such through marketable contracts, a Corporation or Alliance Executor Corp must purchase an Ammendment to that effect for their Charter. Without it, they may still act as a Mercenary Corporation, but without the help of in-game UI and Contract Assets.

One benefit of purchasing such an Ammendment might be, for example, a Channel specific to their Corporation or Alliance intended for discussing Contracts, prices, and details of Mercenary activities, and accessible from anyones UI through an interface used to find Mercenary Corporations and Alliances.

Effectively, they become listed, and have in-game tools for both arranging and aquiring Contracts, and accepting payment for them.

Each non-standard Ammendment only applies to a specific device or module, (i.e: Bombs and Bomb Launchers on a Stealth Bomber, or Warp Interdiction Spheres, or ECM Burst Modules.), and only for the Corporation Holding such an Ammendment.

This means it may be wise for a typically non-warring Corp to aquire not only Protection Charters but War Charters as well.

Additionally, you may wat to include a bounty system where the uninsured loss of any ship resulting from War engagements, is held until the end of the War, with the percentage loss from the losing side going to the winner.

Winners being determined by a point system based on Ship kills and overall ISK lost over the period in which the War was fought, that directly resulted from engagements between the two forces. To the winner go the spoils.

Given the Protection Charters above standard Insurance premiums, this will typically mean the WarDec'd party stands to gain more from winning a given War than the Declaring party provided everything else is equal.
zubzubzubzubzubzubzubzub
Mars Theran
Foreign Interloper
#4 - 2012-01-03 08:48:14 UTC
Costs for a War Declaration might incur as Follows, per day.

Standard War Charter: 500K ISK

Per Standard Ammendment: 3 00K ISK

Per Nominal Ammendment: 1,000K ISK

Per Non-Standard Ammendment: 1,500K ISK

Per Corporation Holding a War Charter on the Declaring side: 500K ISK

Per Corporation not Holding a War Charter on the Declaring Side: 300K ISK

Per Targeted Corporation: 300K ISK.

So the more Ammendments to a given War Charter, and Corporations involved; the higher the cost of declaring a War based on that War Charter, and the higher the cost to outbid it.

Effectively, it also means that a Protection Charter used to delay the onset of a War will potentially share the cost of the total War should it occur.

Additionally, you may want to include that a Protection Charter may be invoked during a War to halt the Wars progress; though at the cost of forfeiting the War to that point. All points are subsequently lost, and the Declaring party gets the Bounty for winning the War.

Anyway, I've got to work tomorrow, and it's high time I shuold be getting to bed. That's all for now.
zubzubzubzubzubzubzubzub
Nestara Aldent
Citimatics
#5 - 2012-01-03 09:13:34 UTC
In essence its the same as removing pvp from highsec because carebear corp will always have more ISK than wardeccers.

Also it breaks the game immersion and fiction. Istead of "bribing" Concord to somehow enable war, it institutionalizes the war. Like Empires would allow it.

So no thanks.
Monty Kvaran
State War Academy
Caldari State
#6 - 2012-01-03 15:03:24 UTC
At the very least, the wardec corp should be able to counter bid the target corp...

Wardec corp pays 2m for dec
Target counters with 4m
....Repeat till one side stops bidding
Wardec corp raises to 256m
Target raises to 512m

Target is then protected for a day/week in exchange for half a bil, next day/week the process starts over. This way it would be possible for small low value targets to make a war unaffordable, while allowing the wardeccer to ratchet up the cost of protection a major target they really want to fight must pay...
ShipToaster
#7 - 2012-01-03 15:10:58 UTC
Monty Kvaran wrote:
At the very least, the wardec corp should be able to counter bid the target corp...

Wardec corp pays 2m for dec
Target counters with 4m
....Repeat till one side stops bidding
Wardec corp raises to 256m
Target raises to 512m

Target is then protected for a day/week in exchange for half a bil, next day/week the process starts over. This way it would be possible for small low value targets to make a war unaffordable, while allowing the wardeccer to ratchet up the cost of protection a major target they really want to fight must pay...


The loser in this bidding war should get their ISK back, the immunity should only be against that group.

Still a crap idea for the one major reason stated by Nestara Aldent.

.

Monty Kvaran
State War Academy
Caldari State
#8 - 2012-01-03 15:14:56 UTC
ShipToaster wrote:


The loser in this bidding war should get their ISK back, the immunity should only be against that group.

Still a crap idea for the one major reason stated by Nestara Aldent.


I should have made that clear, yes only the winner should pay.
Goose99
#9 - 2012-01-03 17:32:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Goose99
Instead of this, allow publicizing wardecs free of charge. This idea floated up recently. It's gotta be the most brilliant wardec concept in all of the threadnaughts the topic produced.

You got decced? Publicize it for free. Want fights? Accept every publicized decs in Eve for free. Original deccer get lots of additional wars for free. Decs should be freer. It's a win-win.Bear
Nika Dekaia
#10 - 2012-01-04 00:04:08 UTC
Nestara Aldent wrote:
In essence its the same as removing pvp from highsec because carebear corp will always have more ISK than wardeccers.

Also it breaks the game immersion and fiction. Istead of "bribing" Concord to somehow enable war, it institutionalizes the war. Like Empires would allow it.

So no thanks.
This needs to be emphasized once again. ISK should not be the deciding factor. (2mil is too less, though).

Goose99 wrote:
Instead of this, allow publicizing wardecs free of charge. This idea floated up recently. It's gotta be the most brilliant wardec concept in all of the threadnaughts the topic produced.

You got decced? Publicize it for free. Want fights? Accept every publicized decs in Eve for free. Original deccer get lots of additional wars for free. Decs should be freer. It's a win-win.
You got to keep in mind that not all corps wardeccing other corps just want as much pvp targets as possible.

The "real" purpose of wardecs in Eve is/or should be (imho) financial and territorial warfare. Pushing out competitors from certain systems / regoins should be possible without opening yourself up to wardecs from a bunch of people just wanting to pewpew you for no reason and without costs.

Balancing that is not an easy task, but publicizing wardecs without costs is not the way to go. You can always hire mercs to wardec the offending corp. It will then be limited to your wallet/connections - fitting mechanic for an MMO.

Mars Theran
Foreign Interloper
#11 - 2012-01-04 00:06:22 UTC
Monty Kvaran wrote:
At the very least, the wardec corp should be able to counter bid the target corp...

Wardec corp pays 2m for dec
Target counters with 4m
....Repeat till one side stops bidding
Wardec corp raises to 256m
Target raises to 512m

Target is then protected for a day/week in exchange for half a bil, next day/week the process starts over. This way it would be possible for small low value targets to make a war unaffordable, while allowing the wardeccer to ratchet up the cost of protection a major target they really want to fight must pay...


I think the issue here, is that there seems to be some lack of cost calculation and advantage for the WarDeccing party.

For 5 Corporations to Declare War against a single Corporation based on these rules, and using a War Charter with 5 Standard, 4 Nominal, and 8 Non-Standard Ammendments; it would be roughly as follows.

War Charter = 500K /day
5 Standard Ammendments = 300K*5 = 1.5 million /day
4 Nominal Ammendments = 1000K*4 = 4 million /day
8 Non Standard Ammendments = 1500K*8 = 12 Million /day
5 Declaring Parties = 500K*5 = 2.5 million /day
1 Target Corporation = 300K /day

Total WarDec cost per day: 20.8 million

Cost to outbid for target Corp, paid to the SCC calculated by rate n*0.9 @90%: 20.8 million * 0.9 = 18.72 Million - Declaring Corporations get their 20.8 million ISK returned to them by the SCC upon payment.

Remember, the Corporation(s) holding a Protection Charter are paying 15 million a week to maintain their Protection Charter with the SCC.

Net result, if no War takes place, but a Declaring party presses for War over a period of 10 days, the Corporation holding the Protection Charter pays the SCC 187.2 million ISK in addition to their weekly maintenance fee of 15 million ISK. The Declaring party has no cost for Pressing the War Declaration.

War of Attrition; it's still PvP. It also damages the protection Charter holding Corporation.
zubzubzubzubzubzubzubzub
Monty Kvaran
State War Academy
Caldari State
#12 - 2012-01-04 03:48:29 UTC
The problem is that a flat rate to avoid decs is never going to be balanced. A newb corp with a bunch of miners in cruisers/frigates would struggle to raise 40m in the course of a week, but would also be a low value target for a war-dec corp. A corp with a shiny Vanguard fleet could raise 40m in approximately 3-5 minutes, and has ships that a war-dec corp would give almost anything to have on their killboard. The incursion corp with a shiny fleet could afford billions a week to avoid decs before it would substantially effect the corp members income...
Caliph Muhammed
Perkone
Caldari State
#13 - 2012-01-04 05:08:13 UTC
When I read these threads I ask myself does this suggestion lead to more Pew and Explosions. I don't believe it does and as such is a bad idea.

The economy is already saturated to the point of absurdity on many items and killing off ship destruction is the wrong direction.

Personal enjoyment is a tertiary concern.
Mars Theran
Foreign Interloper
#14 - 2012-01-04 15:04:29 UTC  |  Edited by: Mars Theran
Caliph Muhammed wrote:
When I read these threads I ask myself does this suggestion lead to more Pew and Explosions. I don't believe it does and as such is a bad idea.

The economy is already saturated to the point of absurdity on many items and killing off ship destruction is the wrong direction.

Personal enjoyment is a tertiary concern.


It doesn't matter what you do; that is going to be the case.

Either way, a Corp can dock up for the duration of the WarDec, and nobody gets any kills. Eventually the Deccer gets bored and moves off. Sure, maybe you can shrug that off as preventing manufacturing and mining; but smaller Corps probably don't produce much of anything anyway.

If you took my old Corp, when we were in Highsec, and measured our weekly production; you would have found it laughably small, despite our best efforts to the contrary. Really, we could only impact small scall shuttle production in one system at most, with our resources at the time.

Even now, where they are today; best effect is a small market share of T3 production. Mostly subsystems for Caldari T3 if things haven't changed too much. Still almost no real impact.

Put 500 of those Corps together, and you might have something; even then, it would amass to no great measure of market resources.

Actually, the most accurate statement for reasons to WarDec I've seen here; is the one that involves shiny new ships on your Killboard. Fact is, that's all anyone really cares about; when you are looking at the ast amount of WarDecs in Empire space.

edit: Production, best I can tell, occurs on another level entirely; and you can't even touch these toons/corps because they never undock. They are Alt's, and they manage production lines using market aquired minerals and resources; which they pay less for than most anybody else, with limited to no logistics requirements.

Where does it all come from? I think that's simple enough to answer; if you have half an idea of where all these resources come from.
zubzubzubzubzubzubzubzub
Jafit McJafitson
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#15 - 2012-01-04 15:15:04 UTC
I'm going to start paying merc corps to wardec any highsec pubbie corp or alliance that starts a thread complaining about or trying to change wardec mechanics.
Mars Theran
Foreign Interloper
#16 - 2012-01-04 15:24:11 UTC
Jafit McJafitson wrote:
I'm going to start paying merc corps to wardec any highsec pubbie corp or alliance that starts a thread complaining about or trying to change wardec mechanics.


Why would you care about WarDec mechanics?
zubzubzubzubzubzubzubzub