These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Petition to Caldari State leadership Form:PET01a

Author
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#41 - 2015-07-10 21:31:06 UTC
James Syagrius wrote:

You have a lot to say about what “we” don’t know about “you”.


To be fair, James, I can't very well speak intelligently about what the Caldari don't know about the Gallente. I don't know it!

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Liam Antolliere
Doomheim
#42 - 2015-07-10 21:41:36 UTC
Lyn Farel wrote:
Also... The Shigeru was already a titan in itself. The incentive was already here.


Precisely. Why provide capsuleers with an equal (or greater) target of opportunity? If the Shiigeru was the only titan on the field, it would be the one most capsuleers were targeting.


Lyn Farel wrote:

I would also think that rationally, taking away the Shigeru in one sweep is the sensible and tactical choice to do, rather than leaving it with plenty of time to execute what everybody knew it was supposed to execute.

That it did not carry out his orders while being slowly beaten by a fleet of navy dreadnaughts was actually, a miracle.


Except that targeting a titan in low orbit with other titans could very well have ended up as an unintentional planetary bombardment.

"Though the people may hate me, that does not relieve me of my charge."

iyammarrok
Drunken Beaver Mining
#43 - 2015-07-10 23:16:17 UTC
Lyn Farel wrote:
Otherwise, a few things have always bothered me:

Firstly, a lot of people see admiral Yanala as a hero for her actions... Could someone explain me why ? I am humbly asking here, as she essentially seems to have neither executed the orders she was issued, and neither saved her crew and took a stand against said orders, except maybe symbolically.

Is she admired because of her efficiency and skill as an officer ? If so, why such a hesitation ? Why such an indecision, eventually leading to the loss of her whole ship ?

Is she admired due to her hesitation and reluctance to fire ? And thus, she did not take any stance to that effect and eventually resolved to execute her orders... too late.

Or is she admired because of her political compromise ? That she managed to remain true to her duty as a caldari superior officer without outright refusing an order, and yet delaying it enough to avoid committing a tragedy over her own homeworld ? This with the risk of being considered as incompetent... ?

Considering the extreme pressure and probable mental nightmare that must have happened in such a dire situation, none would discuss the hard choices that were to be taken... And yet, she took none due to an impossible dilemna.

Shouldn't she rather be considered a victim, instead of a... hero ? Or do we sometime equate victims to heroes, the same way that the Amarr elevate some of their victims as Saints ?

I really hope not to offend over this, as I intend this as a serious question, for that I do not understand.


My personal reasoning:
Yanala's final act upon that day, prior to the destruction of the Shiigeru, was to offload all ordnance and power down both primary and secondary reactors within the titan, This ensured that the damage caused was far less severe than it could have been.
Her choice to delay firing her Oblivion weapon at the planetary surface, while repeatedly requesting confirmation of the order to fire, was also a calculated risk, and one that she unfortunately paid the price for in later days.

These acts were heroic, they were choices she made, that saved many lives, at risk of her own.

Schere, I say that she would, if Heth had been able to apply further leverage, have fired upon the planet due to a simple truth. It is far easier to choose death for yourself, or a number of faceless strangers, than it is to choose that fate or worse for your children, or grandchildren.

Do you doubt that, if he had thought it necessary, Heth would not have given her family over to the tender embrace of his Dragonaur allies? I would not wish that fate upon anyone.

I do not question her resolve or loyalty to the State and it's people, but I understand implicitly how painful it can be to know those you love have been hurt or worse.

Not indicative of corporate policy unless otherwise stated.

Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#44 - 2015-07-10 23:17:59 UTC
Liam Antolliere wrote:


Precisely. Why provide capsuleers with an equal (or greater) target of opportunity? If the Shiigeru was the only titan on the field, it would be the one most capsuleers were targeting.


Oh... you mean as an incentive to pain the bigger target for them ? That is true.

They could not have involved capsuleers in the first place though.


Liam Antolliere wrote:


Except that targeting a titan in low orbit with other titans could very well have ended up as an unintentional planetary bombardment.


The same way it could have ended in an unintentional planetary bombardment with dozens of dreadnoughts having to fire a thousand times more for each of them.
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#45 - 2015-07-11 22:46:33 UTC  |  Edited by: Pieter Tuulinen
Lyn Farel wrote:


That is a populist fad, Mr Antolliere. The first time this term has started to be used by many Caldari freelance capsuleers was right after the attack and the blockade on Luminaire.

I do not remember any caldari of the 'old guard' to have even used it that way. No matter how we look at our short history here, this is very heavily loaded, ultra nationalist term that originated with the rise of the Providence Directorate.

Also, isn't this a bit... weird ? I always thought that calm, level headed considerations were always preferable to overtly emotive reactions that most of the time lead precisely to that kind of tragedy...


Go on, Imperial, continue to tell me how I was raised - perhaps I wasn't paying attention, but I really don't remember seeing you there when I was in my creche.

Haajakin Kalen in Napaani. Just a little phrase that's been kicking around as the primary toast of the Caldari Military and government for centuries.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Lyn Farel
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#46 - 2015-07-11 23:23:02 UTC
Hnolai ki tuul, ti sei oni a tiu, right ?
Matar Ronin
#47 - 2015-07-12 06:06:02 UTC  |  Edited by: Matar Ronin
Diana Kim wrote:

4. Isogen 5 based weaponry was developed, built and used by Her Majesty Empress Sarum.

Could you please provide a link to support this statement.

I have publicly enquired about the wonder weapon if you have some actual facts please share them.

‘Vain flame burns fast/and its lick is light/Modest flame lasts long/and burns to the bone.’

" We lost a war we chose not to fight." Without a doubt this is the best way to lose any war and the worst excuse to explain the beating afterwards.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#48 - 2015-07-12 06:27:21 UTC
Lyn Farel wrote:
Hnolai ki tuul, ti sei oni a tiu, right ?


Actually, that saying nicely sums up why the late Admiral is a heroine. Her legacy guides us and makes all of us just a little more than we were. I used to have a very odd sense of honour and the late Admiral educated me in a very succinct manner as to the worth of honour when measured against the suffering of one's people.

The people come first. Always. Forever. If you truly want to be a servant of the people there has to be nothing, nothing that is more precious to you than they are. Not your good name. Not your life. Not your honour. Not your legacy. Nothing.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Matar Ronin
#49 - 2015-07-12 06:35:47 UTC  |  Edited by: Matar Ronin
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
The people come first. Always. Forever. If you truly want to be a servant of the people there has to be nothing, nothing that is more precious to you than they are. Not your good name. Not your life. Not your honour. Not your legacy. Nothing.
You speak with the passion of a Matari. What a cruel reality that the Caldari and Matari are not allies. Your hearts beat true as do ours.

‘Vain flame burns fast/and its lick is light/Modest flame lasts long/and burns to the bone.’

" We lost a war we chose not to fight." Without a doubt this is the best way to lose any war and the worst excuse to explain the beating afterwards.

Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#50 - 2015-07-13 21:25:00 UTC
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:

I believed strongly in the Shiigeru's Commander - that she would not desecrate Home. That faith was borne out in the field.

Desecration of our Home is letting gallenteans stay there after all they did to our planet and its children.
And we will continue the fight...
... until there are no Gallente on Caldari Prime!

Glory to the State!

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#51 - 2015-07-13 21:31:27 UTC
Makoto Priano wrote:
Best to just ignore the madwoman. You'll find more peace and get more done.

And this is the still barking known liar Makoto, who lost her honor with extreme cowardice.
Your words have lost the value the moment you refused to stand for them ( https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=381560 )
Be gone. Shame on you.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Andreus Ixiris
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#52 - 2015-07-15 23:36:20 UTC
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
I believe that the greatest source of misunderstanding between our peoples has always been your inability to empathise with how the loss of our ancestral home makes us feel and the lengths to which many of us are willing to go to recover it.

Remember those words next time you talk to an Intaki about anything.

Andreus Ixiris > A Civire without a chin is barely a Civire at all.

Pieter Tuulinen > He'd be Civirely disadvantaged, Andreus.

Andreus Ixiris > ...

Andreus Ixiris > This is why we're at war.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#53 - 2015-07-16 05:04:45 UTC
Andreus Ixiris wrote:
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
I believe that the greatest source of misunderstanding between our peoples has always been your inability to empathise with how the loss of our ancestral home makes us feel and the lengths to which many of us are willing to go to recover it.

Remember those words next time you talk to an Intaki about anything.

Andreus, you know my opinion on Intaki is that they should be out of the war zone and have self-determination.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Mitchell Striker
#54 - 2015-07-16 10:27:21 UTC


Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
I completely understand why you would feel that way but, with the greatest of respect and empathy, you do not feel as passionately as we do unless you would consider acceptable any action short of the total destruction of your Federation and your people as an exchange for keeping Home.

Do you think that I would lightly commit the kind of atrocity that would see me turned into a Caldari version of Alexander Noir? I believe that the greatest source of misunderstanding between our peoples has always been your inability to empathise with how the loss of our ancestral home makes us feel and the lengths to which many of us are willing to go to recover it.


Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
The people come first. Always. Forever. If you truly want to be a servant of the people there has to be nothing, nothing that is more precious to you than they are. Not your good name. Not your life. Not your honour. Not your legacy. Nothing.



This sort of cognitive dissonance and disparity of values illustrates perfectly why the Federation will outlast the State. We have moved our capital from Gallente Prime despite it being our ancestral home, because our home is not dictated by geographical borders but by ideals, ideals that carried us to victory over your forebears and to the conquest of the Luminaire system in times past.

They will carry us into the future, as well. And they would carry us beyond any atrocity you could imagine up to try and crush our spirit. You claim you would strip and shame those commanders who fled the battle for Caldari Prime when they were outnumbered, yet you being a man of long tradition, one would think you would honour the Caldari tradition of fleeing "home".

Your inner conflict must be frustrating Colonel, to want to be a moral man who values the lives of his people while simultaneously being willing and ready to sacrifice those same lives without hesitation if it means placing a flag (which one, exactly? Your State has so many megacorps it must be hard to decide) on a piece of dirt.

Let us both be thankful that your conflicted mind will never have the ability to dictate the fate of a planetary population, and that the Federation is eminently reasonable in its dealings with your troubled State.

"The Federation is not a defined region of space, of planets, of mountains, rivers, or woods. It is a vision." - Former President of the Gallente Federation, Arlette Villers.

Utari Onzo
Escalated.
OnlyFleets.
#55 - 2015-07-16 11:41:51 UTC
With respect, sir, it was easy for your people to move Capital since it was done by choice. You weren't bombarded from the air and space, or chased by a hostile fleet, but it's a seperate debate to establish who is to blame for what.

I am with Tuulinen when he says the greatest issue is the lack of empathy from the Federal leaders. I may not be Caldari by virtue of being Amarr having joined the Amarr Empire, but my father was a State citizen, a Civire. My ancestors came from Caldari Prime. Put simply, the soul of the Caldari people has a great void, an open wound, that cannot heal so long as Home does not belong to the Caldari people. I am no exception.

Even with my faith and living with my Mother's people, I still feel that void. It's a black hole, threatning to consume your soul, demanding to be filled. Some fill it with hatred, allowing the wound to open ever further until not even the destruction of the Federaion along with the return of home would satisfy it. Others try to push back, controlling the pain and torment and seeking a more peaceful, diplomatic approach, but still Home must be returned as the ultimate aim. Others, still, react to that insatiable black hole in different ways, their own ways, but the same fact remains. The Caldari people have been displaced, and regardless of who's to blame for what it in the conflict between the State and the Federation, the Caldari people can never be at peace until their soul is made whole again.

The Federation can never empathise with this fact for as long as they have never had their home taken from them. For all the talk of not needing their ancestral home, the Gallente cannot know how they'd feel until it's taken from them. They do not have that very same wound that every ethnic Caldari carries. However, they can atleast try to understand, to be aware of how deeply ingrained this need is, how serious the wound has become, how far it can potentially fester.

I pray for the Caldari people that home is returned so my my own yearning, passed on from my father, might be healed also, but I also carry the hope that it might be resolved peacefully in time. Neither side gains if home is left in ashes, and all that will be left should Home be destroyed by either side would be eternal tears of regret.

"Face the enemy as a solid wall For faith is your armor And through it, the enemy will find no breach Wrap your arms around the enemy For faith is your fire And with it, burn away his evil"

Utari Onzo
Escalated.
OnlyFleets.
#56 - 2015-07-16 11:46:48 UTC
I realised I haven't contributed to the OP of this thread and will correct that. Whatever misgivings I have of some of Commander Kim's actions, thoughts or the like, put simply..

Down with this sort of thing. Unsigned.

"Face the enemy as a solid wall For faith is your armor And through it, the enemy will find no breach Wrap your arms around the enemy For faith is your fire And with it, burn away his evil"

Liam Antolliere
Doomheim
#57 - 2015-07-16 12:03:01 UTC
Utari Onzo wrote:
I am with Tuulinen when he says the greatest issue is the lack of empathy from the Federal leaders.


I would argue that the greatest issue is the lack of empathy from both sides.

Both sides are too busy justifying themselves and making demands to actually come to the table and try to understand one another.

That part is left to us.

"Though the people may hate me, that does not relieve me of my charge."

Utari Onzo
Escalated.
OnlyFleets.
#58 - 2015-07-16 12:10:38 UTC  |  Edited by: Utari Onzo
Liam Antolliere wrote:
Utari Onzo wrote:
I am with Tuulinen when he says the greatest issue is the lack of empathy from the Federal leaders.


I would argue that the greatest issue is the lack of empathy from both sides.

Both sides are too busy justifying themselves and making demands to actually come to the table and try to understand one another.

That part is left to us.


Agreed on that count, forgive me for not addressing that one better. I did touch on how some of the Caldari get consumed by blind hatred but failed to point out how that might be unhelpful towards a lasting peacefull resolution. I know from the work of the PPC a peaceful resolution is possible that saves Federal face yet satisfies the Caldari people is possible when both sides are willing to talk.

"Face the enemy as a solid wall For faith is your armor And through it, the enemy will find no breach Wrap your arms around the enemy For faith is your fire And with it, burn away his evil"

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#59 - 2015-07-16 15:29:40 UTC  |  Edited by: Pieter Tuulinen
Mitchell Striker wrote:
This sort of cognitive dissonance and disparity of values illustrates perfectly why the Federation will outlast the State. We have moved our capital from Gallente Prime despite it being our ancestral home, because our home is not dictated by geographical borders but by ideals, ideals that carried us to victory over your forebears and to the conquest of the Luminaire system in times past.


How's that victory looking now? Military experts agree that the Federal Navy is now incapable of taking the State by force. The only recent engagement between our two forces led you to a victory that can only be described as pyrrhic in the extreme, and which led to you voluntarily surrendering much of the planet it was fought over. Face facts, Mr Striker, the State has won the battle for independence and it has achieved the stability it needs to exist without you and without your toxic ideals in the longer term. And many of the others that chafe under your yoke have seen us succeed without your "benevolent guidance".

Mitchell Striker wrote:
They will carry us into the future, as well. And they would carry us beyond any atrocity you could imagine up to try and crush our spirit. You claim you would strip and shame those commanders who fled the battle for Caldari Prime when they were outnumbered, yet you being a man of long tradition, one would think you would honour the Caldari tradition of fleeing "home".


History has shown that the Gallente people are highly susceptible to atrocity - both as a means of fomenting conflicts and as a means of ending them. Nonetheless, I was simply speaking of the idiocy of threatening to fire on Home when the Caldari reverence for the place is notorious. Threatening to fire on a planet we don't give a damn about would have been a much more plausible threat.

Mitchell Striker wrote:
Your inner conflict must be frustrating Colonel, to want to be a moral man who values the lives of his people while simultaneously being willing and ready to sacrifice those same lives without hesitation if it means placing a flag (which one, exactly? Your State has so many megacorps it must be hard to decide) on a piece of dirt.

Let us both be thankful that your conflicted mind will never have the ability to dictate the fate of a planetary population, and that the Federation is eminently reasonable in its dealings with your troubled State.


There is no conflict. The fact that I value the lives of my people doesn't affect the fact that they have placed me in the position to spend them if I believed the potential gain warranted it. In fact only a man who is willing to spend the lives of his men should ever be in a position of command - those who volunteer don't expect to be safe, they expect the risks that they take to mean something. As Capsuleers we make this decision every day - perhaps if you spend some time serving in a forward position you'll come to understand that a little better.

As for Gallente 'reasonableness' I'm very pleased that our RECENT dealings with your people have been much more so. Past treatment has been anything but - despite your belief in your morality the truth of your track record is plain to see in history.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Mitchell Striker
#60 - 2015-07-16 17:13:24 UTC  |  Edited by: Mitchell Striker
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
How's that victory looking now? Military experts agree that the Federal Navy is now incapable of taking the State by force. The only recent engagement between our two forces led you to a victory that can only be described as pyrrhic in the extreme, and which led to you voluntarily surrendering much of the planet it was fought over. Face facts, Mr Striker, the State has won the battle for independence and it has achieved the stability it needs to exist without you and without your toxic ideals in the longer term. And many of the others that chafe under your yoke have seen us succeed without your "benevolent guidance".


The victory is looking like what it is, a victory. We achieved our strategic objectives and won the conflict, your (former) commander in chief (now terrorist?) did not. And your State suffered large political turmoil as a direct result. The Luminaire system remains Federation sovereign space, not State.

The fact we allowed the State to claim parts of Caldari Prime only emphasizes our own reasonable nature, despite driving you out of the system we still made concessions in the interests of peace, peace we've been pursuing for many years.

The Federation has no interest in "taking the State by force", but I certainly hope our "pyrrhic" victory has demonstrated to you that when it comes to sacrificing our lives in defense of our sovereign space and security, we will do so.

Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
History has shown that the Gallente people are highly susceptible to atrocity - both as a means of fomenting conflicts and as a means of ending them. Nonetheless, I was simply speaking of the idiocy of threatening to fire on Home when the Caldari reverence for the place is notorious. Threatening to fire on a planet we don't give a damn about would have been a much more plausible threat.


I dare say you would find it difficult to find a nation in New Eden that hasn't had some atrocity committed under a regime at one time or another. We acknowledge this history and learn from it so that we might not repeat it in the future.

Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
There is no conflict. The fact that I value the lives of my people doesn't affect the fact that they have placed me in the position to spend them if I believed the potential gain warranted it. In fact only a man who is willing to spend the lives of his men should ever be in a position of command - those who volunteer don't expect to be safe, they expect the risks that they take to mean something. As Capsuleers we make this decision every day - perhaps if you spend some time serving in a forward position you'll come to understand that a little better.

As for Gallente 'reasonableness' I'm very pleased that our RECENT dealings with your people have been much more so. Past treatment has been anything but - despite your belief in your morality the truth of your track record is plain to see in history.


While we agree that a decent commander is one that is prepared to sacrifice the lives of his men to achieve his objectives, a better sort of commander is one who can devise a way to achieve them without having to do so.

You have a bit of an obsession with our history Colonel, one might think you were fond of it. As for myself, I must confess I'm more interested in the present, the regimes that govern it and the living who shape it.

"The Federation is not a defined region of space, of planets, of mountains, rivers, or woods. It is a vision." - Former President of the Gallente Federation, Arlette Villers.