These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

What's your best PvP / PvE Jackdaw fits?

First post
Author
Doctor Knuckles
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#21 - 2015-06-08 09:23:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Doctor Knuckles
W0lf Crendraven wrote:
Doctor Knuckles wrote:
really glad no one posted the very obvious cheat / op / godlike fit yet lol

hint: i foresee a cpu nerf coming


People who see medium abs usually overrate them tanking wise due to them only running for 20 seconds every minute, you get about 200 sustained rep, 7k ehp and 260dps.


A zero bling dual rep + small cap booster svipul does more dps, tanks more, is way faster, applied dps way better, has the same tackle and has 2 small neuts or nos ontop of that.


Oh you're right, difference is when you go full ****** with them with crystals, blue pill and siege links, and we both know plenty of people will do that. And, well, even with full ****** but just half ****** it's still pretty ******* impressive, and cap independent.


Now a single masb suddenly goes from "eh, ok, i can manage that" to "yeah right, **** that" tanking more than 900 dps. 20 secs every 60 (well, more, no savvy masb user lets it go continously really)... but you have 3 of them.

Also, uhmm. you sure about applying damage better? I really am not
Lloyd Roses
Artificial Memories
#22 - 2015-06-08 10:21:39 UTC
Get light missiles instead of the triple MASB sh1tfit.

I like dualprop/LMLs with ~18k buffer and paint/point/web together with 265 fury dps regarding cheap cookie cutters, and 10mn minitengu for something moderately pimped (i.E. the 150mil fitted range)
W0lf Crendraven
The Tuskers
The Tuskers Co.
#23 - 2015-06-08 11:19:12 UTC
Doctor Knuckles wrote:
W0lf Crendraven wrote:
Doctor Knuckles wrote:
really glad no one posted the very obvious cheat / op / godlike fit yet lol

hint: i foresee a cpu nerf coming


People who see medium abs usually overrate them tanking wise due to them only running for 20 seconds every minute, you get about 200 sustained rep, 7k ehp and 260dps.


A zero bling dual rep + small cap booster svipul does more dps, tanks more, is way faster, applied dps way better, has the same tackle and has 2 small neuts or nos ontop of that.


Oh you're right, difference is when you go full ****** with them with crystals, blue pill and siege links, and we both know plenty of people will do that. And, well, even with full ****** but just half ****** it's still pretty ******* impressive, and cap independent.


Now a single masb suddenly goes from "eh, ok, i can manage that" to "yeah right, **** that" tanking more than 900 dps. 20 secs every 60 (well, more, no savvy masb user lets it go continously really)... but you have 3 of them.

Also, uhmm. you sure about applying damage better? I really am not


Links dont do so well with asbs as links have 3 effects, resitances, cap usage and cycle time. While resistances are great the other 2 are fairly bad as cycle time means you get faster into reload and cap usage is just plainly useless for asbs.

And pith c type medium booster one tanks way way more (and can be made just as cap independent if you go dual injection). And anyways what would make this strong are the crystals (and the links). Lastly, the svipul can do the same thing all around better yet again.
SFM Hobb3s
Perkone
Caldari State
#24 - 2015-06-08 17:05:40 UTC
For kiting, this ship is FAR outclassed by the Confessor. If you are going up against frigs or anything actually moving, your damage application is going to be far better with confessor. You will also do considerably more damage in far less time due to missile travel time (cancer in tidi btw so don't waste your time brining a kiting jackdaw on big fleets).

Most of the time in a Confessor I have to pop my target within two volleys or they can react and warp off. Now, with Jackdaw, the target can warp off in the same amount of time before the first volley even hits them. That's missiles for you.

Doctor Knuckles
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#25 - 2015-06-08 18:06:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Doctor Knuckles
W0lf Crendraven wrote:
Doctor Knuckles wrote:
W0lf Crendraven wrote:
Doctor Knuckles wrote:
really glad no one posted the very obvious cheat / op / godlike fit yet lol

hint: i foresee a cpu nerf coming


People who see medium abs usually overrate them tanking wise due to them only running for 20 seconds every minute, you get about 200 sustained rep, 7k ehp and 260dps.


A zero bling dual rep + small cap booster svipul does more dps, tanks more, is way faster, applied dps way better, has the same tackle and has 2 small neuts or nos ontop of that.


Oh you're right, difference is when you go full ****** with them with crystals, blue pill and siege links, and we both know plenty of people will do that. And, well, even with full ****** but just half ****** it's still pretty ******* impressive, and cap independent.


Now a single masb suddenly goes from "eh, ok, i can manage that" to "yeah right, **** that" tanking more than 900 dps. 20 secs every 60 (well, more, no savvy masb user lets it go continously really)... but you have 3 of them.

Also, uhmm. you sure about applying damage better? I really am not


Links dont do so well with asbs as links have 3 effects, resitances, cap usage and cycle time. While resistances are great the other 2 are fairly bad as cycle time means you get faster into reload and cap usage is just plainly useless for asbs.

And pith c type medium booster one tanks way way more (and can be made just as cap independent if you go dual injection). And anyways what would make this strong are the crystals (and the links). Lastly, the svipul can do the same thing all around better yet again.


let's consider it a moment (no links, implants, pills).

A single c type tanks 188 dps. a single masb tanks 170, both running cold (around 240 and 270 with an invuln). With three, you're never gonna be without charges to run it, and you can occasionally run a cycle on the second for some burst tank if needed, plus cap independent. C-type relies on a cap booster, a single medium neut will **** your day, so a lot of cruisers will be out of the questions, while this thing can be a cruiser killing monster with rage rockets. 2 cap boosters are idiotic when you can run 3 masbs. A better argument would be one more midslot for i dunno, ewar, second web, another invuln, whatever really, but 2 cap boosters... really?

SFM Hobb3s wrote:
For kiting, this ship is FAR outclassed by the Confessor. If you are going up against frigs or anything actually moving, your damage application is going to be far better with confessor. You will also do considerably more damage in far less time due to missile travel time (cancer in tidi btw so don't waste your time brining a kiting jackdaw on big fleets).

Most of the time in a Confessor I have to pop my target within two volleys or they can react and warp off. Now, with Jackdaw, the target can warp off in the same amount of time before the first volley even hits them. That's missiles for you.


very true. but imo it has its uses. small gang of confessor has trouble engaging bigger targets that can project damage, they're paper thin. This one you cna monster tank. Against small stuff, volley damage from a half dozen of this is going to be scary
Caleb Seremshur
Commando Guri
Guristas Pirates
#26 - 2015-06-09 15:24:08 UTC
If you're putting an invul on a jackdaw you're seriusly doing it wrong.
Lloyd Roses
Artificial Memories
#27 - 2015-06-09 17:48:08 UTC
SFM Hobb3s wrote:
For kiting, this ship is FAR outclassed by the Confessor. If you are going up against frigs or anything actually moving, your damage application is going to be far better with confessor. You will also do considerably more damage in far less time due to missile travel time (cancer in tidi btw so don't waste your time brining a kiting jackdaw on big fleets).

Most of the time in a Confessor I have to pop my target within two volleys or they can react and warp off. Now, with Jackdaw, the target can warp off in the same amount of time before the first volley even hits them. That's missiles for you.


If you're putting a confessor next to about anything and ask for long range damage only, confessor will win handily. However, if you got a small gang and need some ewar like paints or a web on the combat prober, then the jackdaw has merit. Same when you're to apply dps at mid ranges to a tankier primary and you're not running with a 10man ishtar gang, the jackdaw does fine while providing a paint. If your group shrinks to 4-5 guys, the additional mids can make hell of a difference given the jackdaw's tank (at range) is fine with as little as an MSE and a rig or two.
SFM Hobb3s
Perkone
Caldari State
#28 - 2015-06-16 19:26:51 UTC
Very good responses from Dr Knuckles and Lloyd Roses. +1'd you both
Dato Koppla
Balls Deep Inc.
Minmatar Fleet Alliance
#29 - 2015-06-17 00:38:42 UTC
The main problem with any argument for a kiting LML Jackdaw is: You're slow as ****. The Jackdaw is insanely slow, with THREE speed mods and no links no implants in speed mode, you're doing 2.5km/s which is downright pathetic, an Omen Navy with 1 speed mod will run you down easily. Frigate gangs (which you're supposed to excel at killing) will just dogpile you easily since even the slowest MWD frigate will be able to catch you. Being able to mount a decent tank on your LML fit isn't going to help, once caught you're pretty much screwed TBH. There could be an argument for a Pithum C-Type fit with LML so when you get caught you can tank and continue fighting, but if you're going to get caught every time, why not just go rockets in the first place.

Also after flying it around abit, here's a fun random 'ninja' pre nerf I noticed to make the Jackdaw worse than it already is: The Jackdaw gets cruiser scan res when not in sharpshooter mode. So when you're in sharpshooter mode your top speed is basically a 1600plate Maller so you're probably never going to go into sharpshooter when kiting unless you're just dpsing from a very long range. Outside of sharpshooter mode the Jackdaw takes 6.2 (yes SIX) seconds to lock a frigate (it's intended target). For comparison, the Svipul gets 36% better scan res (4.5 second lock on frigates) and the Confessor gets 20% better scan res (5.1 second lock on frigates) outside of Sharpshooter mode. I really don't get why there has to be such a huge disparity other than to just screw the Jackdaw over as much as possible.
afkalt
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#30 - 2015-06-18 08:22:31 UTC
Well, I was wrong in my initial estimates, the dual web brawler is really nasty. Really, really really nasty. The only thing you dont get full DPS with fury on is an inty O_O

Alone, not great, part of a little fleet - I'll certainly give it a home.
Lloyd Roses
Artificial Memories
#31 - 2015-06-18 09:51:39 UTC
Jackdaw seems to make a lot of sense fitted as a maulus. You get 210dps with CN at 85k, while carrying 3-4 damps and still have 10-18k ehp..
Apex Bex
Princess Aiko Hold My Hand
Safety. Net
#32 - 2015-06-19 06:46:44 UTC
I don't think the LML variety is viable in solo PvP, your range control is non-existent. This is my take on how I think I'll use it, maybe it can work for you, I dunno.
Dr Longbow
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#33 - 2015-07-26 16:02:33 UTC
Caldari T3 ships = Biggest let down in new ships on eve. Tengu and Jackdaw.

CCP Y U hate Caldari so much?

I was so stoked about this ship.... but if you wanna missile fit it, you are literally better off with a corax or maybe even kestral.

Next to all the other t3 dessi you get a half rate runner up.

Its good for poping mtu's tho. What?

Previous page12