These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

The Sansha Threat: You know, the one nobody is talking about

Author
Tabor Murn
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#21 - 2015-04-23 17:09:39 UTC
Aria Jenneth wrote:

Blood Raiders (why do the Matari count them as allies? I'll have to find out if I get to visit.),


Not to detract from the rest of your arguement, but any Minmatar who claims the Blood Raiders are an ally is a fool.
Liuni Kalthis
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#22 - 2015-04-23 17:14:28 UTC
Well I rather be dead then turn into a few of the tsf folks, they can be a bit nutty and I assume sansha memebers are even worse. Used to put explosives near my pod in my earlier capsuleer days out of irrational fear. Now they are just a way for people to make money and stain just a region like any other. Much more worried about the drifters at the present moment.
Rhiannon Dellacorte
Liberty Vanguard
#23 - 2015-04-23 17:44:14 UTC
Cakzad Arcashiri wrote:
Sansha's Nation is [...] in the Bedroom.

Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Boo.


I knew you were a perv Tiberious, but I wouldn't have pegged you for a voyeur.

Aria Jenneth wrote:
The family's squabbling while the apartment's on fire.


You have a gift for vivid imagery, Ms Jenneth.

Rules of Acquisition #261

A wealthy man can afford anything except a conscience.

Markus Error
Manfios
#24 - 2015-04-23 17:51:35 UTC  |  Edited by: Markus Error
Aaaand realpolitik strikes again.

And yes, the impressive display of solidarity that actually got all four empires bashing the Nation the first time was, well, impressive... but seems unlikely to repeat itself.

Now, we rely solely on capsuleers to repel incursions (if they can even be arsed to do so). Think on that; trillions of baseliners rely entirely on socio- or psychopathic demigods to defend them from a fate worse than death.

And now, the same occurs with the Drifters.

And probably the threat after that.

Is this the future? The empires never bothering to even defend themselves, leaving it to capsuleers? Somehow, despite being one, I can't see things as a good future when capsuleers effectively rule all.

But this begs the question. What do we do about it? With Sansha, the obvious answer is "bash the Nation until it goes away," which might well work. The issue arises in finding sufficient force to do said bashing. You could suggest 'submit to their will', but you'd likely find resistance to that. Similarly, people will almost certainly be split on any other avilable options.

So it seems we're locked in an endless cycle of simply awaiting the next terror/horror/anomaly to show up and threaten us, and hope that somebody in a pod can be bothered to deal with it. Yay.

"If it cannot be shot the #### down, it can always be blown the #### up."

-Unknown

Tootenh'amon
#25 - 2015-04-23 18:03:04 UTC
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Tootenh'amon wrote:
I'm torn. On the one hand, Sansha and his fleets are of course great, yet underestimated threats, present on a daily basis. On the other, seing Amarrians oppose slavery so vehemently, makes me chuckle.


That's just it. It's not conventional slavery. It's directly editing a person until their only option is to be placid and obedient. And maybe even outwardly happy. ... While, very likely, the rest of the mind is screaming.

The Amarr practice slavery. Very well. So do the Angels, Serpentis, Blood Raiders (why do the Matari count them as allies? I'll have to find out if I get to visit.), and even the Guristas, I guess.

Kuvakei's people practice ... something else.

I wouldn't want to be anybody's slave. Even for a kind master, it would be horrible. ... but I could probably live with it. Billions do, after all, and, rhetoric aside, there's little reason to think they want to die.

But the Nation? Death first. Please. No, really....



Not to be the devil's advocate here, but have you heared of Vitoc? Where the Amarrians say "Be obedient or die", they crush the spirit just as much. Sansha just makes them be obedient. It's still slavery of course, but i don't see that great a gap between both practices. So maybe the Amarrians are doing it in white gloves. Doesn't change the fact that their slaves weren't volunteers either.
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#26 - 2015-04-23 18:41:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Aria Jenneth
Tootenh'amon wrote:
Not to be the devil's advocate here, but have you heared of Vitoc? Where the Amarrians say "Be obedient or die", they crush the spirit just as much. Sansha just makes them be obedient. It's still slavery of course, but i don't see that great a gap between both practices. So maybe the Amarrians are doing it in white gloves. Doesn't change the fact that their slaves weren't volunteers either.

Respectfully, yes, I'm aware of Vitoc. Just as I'm aware of slaver dogs that drop on escapees out of trees and eat them.

I'm further aware of black market pleasure hubs and similar establishments (and I should stress I'm talking about the pirate factions now) where enslaved women are forced to do all sorts of demeaning things.

I'm also fully aware that a Blood Raider's slave is likely to lead a short and painful life. In one case I've been threatened with a long, humiliating, and painful life involving cryogenic stasis in between rounds of pain and humiliation. That would have been a special sort of awful.

Also, you didn't bring up transcranial microcontrollers, which generate a sort of artificial reality overlay for a slave to live in that's generally more pleasant than the real thing. It's one of the Khanid Kingdom's more controversial practices, and about as close to Kuvakei as the empires have skated.

I wasn't just using rhetoric when I said that slavery would be horrible even with a kind master. Without one....

But, here's the thing, pilot: in each case, including even the TCMC, my mind would remain my own. There are techniques for crushing the spirit and obliterating even hope, yes, some of them ancient and nigh unspeakably cruel.

But none of them compare to this: Kuvekei's implants, as I understand them, do not replace or eliminate parts of the consciousness; they're focused on directly editing behavior. That means having your very mind edited from a square peg down to fit into a round hole-- but the remnants left in place. One may be in anguish, and unable to express it-- be broken, and insane, and unable to so much as grimace, much less scream.

It's not even a moral question. It's a question of consequence. Slavery is an ancient feature of human history, pilot, and humanity's survived it time and time again. It's not at all clear that we'd survive being edited by Sansha Kuvakei. For starters, he's not a god, but more than that, he's not even very good at editing people so that they can function as people.

Back in the days after the first war, there was a time when Kuvakei's surviving people went into hiding in hidden communities. It was a difficult time, no doubt: starvation was widespread, and many communities died out entirely.

This wasn't because food was wholly unavailable. It's because Kuvakei hadn't thought to give his victims sufficient agency to seek their own food sources.

Can you imagine, being trapped in your own head, feeling yourself starving to death by inches, knowing exactly what you need to do to save your own miserable life but not being able to do it because you haven't been given instructions on that subject?

And now he claims he's modified the nature of the Nation so that you just get reborn into the same nightmare?

At least a slave gets to die....
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#27 - 2015-04-23 18:53:52 UTC
Maria Daphiti wrote:
Liam Antolliere wrote:
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:


If you are choosing capsuleers to represent freedom of choice, then I really think that makes my point for me in regards to the worth of freedom.


As usual, you've got it backwards.

I'm choosing the freedom to be capsuleers over your "Master's" vision of humanity because I would rather accept capsuleers as a byproduct of that freedom than be forced into Kuvakei's idea of a utopia.


Yep! And besides none of the people who follow the Master ever smile! Well.. except Tiberious who only does so sardonically!

Some Utopia! *she shudders*


Many of the former TSF pilots will smile - perhaps they simply see little to smile about in the company of those who hate them so avidly. Now, I've never actually been anywhere near a card carrying member of the actual Sansha Nation - I'd view that as a completely unnecessary security risk - but I have spent some time with Capsuleer loylists of Kuvakei's vision and...

...they just aren't any stranger than the rest of the transhumanists that I know. Sorry guys, but that's how I see it. I don't subscribe to their newsletter and their idea of unity isn't my idea of unity, but they certainly aren't weirder than the Blooders or the EOM fanatics or that Gosakomori woman and her lupine-Sebiestor half-breeds.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Tootenh'amon
#28 - 2015-04-23 18:54:14 UTC  |  Edited by: Tootenh'amon
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Tootenh'amon wrote:
Not to be the devil's advocate here, but have you heared of Vitoc? Where the Amarrians say "Be obedient or die", they crush the spirit just as much. Sansha just makes them be obedient. It's still slavery of course, but i don't see that great a gap between both practices. So maybe the Amarrians are doing it in white gloves. Doesn't change the fact that their slaves weren't volunteers either.

Respectfully, yes, I'm aware of Vitoc. Just as I'm aware of slaver dogs that drop on escapees out of trees and eat them.

I'm further aware of black market pleasure hubs and similar establishments (and I should stress I'm talking about the pirate factions now) where enslaved women are forced to do all sorts of demeaning things.

I'm also fully aware that a Blood Raider's slave is likely to lead a short and painful life. In one case I've been threatened with a long, humiliating, and painful life involving cryogenic stasis in between rounds of pain and humiliation. That would have been a special sort of awful.

Also, you didn't bring up transcranial microcontrollers, which generate a sort of artificial reality overlay for a slave to live in that's generally more pleasant than the real thing. It's one of the Khanid Kingdom's more controversial practices, and about as close to Kuvakei as the empires have skated.

I wasn't just using rhetoric when I said that slavery would be horrible even with a kind master. Without one....

But, here's the thing, pilot: in each case, including even the TCMC, my mind would remain my own. There are techniques for crushing the spirit and obliterating even hope, yes, some of them ancient and nigh unspeakably cruel.

But none of them compare to this: Kuvekei's implants, as I understand them, do not replace or eliminate parts of the consciousness; they're focused on directly editing behavior. That means having your very mind edited from a square peg down to fit into a round hole-- but the remnants left in place. One may be in anguish, and unable to express it-- be broken, and insane, and unable to so much as grimace, much less scream.

It's not even a moral question. It's a question of consequence. Slavery is an ancient feature of human history, pilot, and humanity's survived it time and time again. It's not at all clear that we'd survive being edited by Sansha Kuvakei. For starters, he's not a god, but more than that, he's not even very good at editing people so that they can function as people.

Back in the days after the first war, there was a time when Kuvakei's surviving people went into hiding in hidden communities. It was a difficult time, no doubt: starvation was widespread, and many communities died out entirely.

This wasn't because food was wholly unavailable. It's because Kuvakei hadn't thought to give his victims sufficient agency to seek their own food sources.

Can you imagine, being trapped in your own head, feeling yourself starving to death by inches, knowing exactly what you need to do to save your own miserable life but not being able to do it because you haven't been given instructions on that subject?

And now he claims he's modified the nature of the Nation so that you just get reborn into the same nightmare?

At least a slave gets to die....



I admit that I don't personally know how the Sansha's implants work or what they do to a person. All I'm saying is Sansha's attacking everyone, been doing that for a while now. And in the case of Minmatar, Caldari, Gallente, as well as Border and Independent Worlds, it's a great tragedy. But in the case of Amarr, seeing Amarrians getting all rattled because "Sansha three jumps from Amarr, must be the End of Days"... Has that smell of poetic justice to it.
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#29 - 2015-04-23 19:13:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Aria Jenneth
Tootenh'amon wrote:
... seeing Amarrians getting all rattled because "Sansha three jumps from Amarr, must be the End of Days"... Has that smell of poetic justice to it.

It's maybe worth getting to know people before you decide that it's okay if Nation takes them all.

The Amarr do still scare me a little, sometimes, but....

People are people, mostly.


Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
...they just aren't any stranger than the rest of the transhumanists that I know. Sorry guys, but that's how I see it. I don't subscribe to their newsletter and their idea of unity isn't my idea of unity, but they certainly aren't weirder than the Blooders or the EOM fanatics or that Gosakomori woman and her lupine-Sebiestor half-breeds.

Mr. Tuulinen ... respectfully ... oh, gods.

Um. So. I don't personally remember any of this, but ... Vikarion told me to remember Kostantin Mort.

I don't. Remember, I mean, of course, but ... having researched the subject, it looks like he was a pilot at the Omerta Syndicate, which I guess was back in its day sort of what PYRE is now, right down to the wildly diverse backgrounds and the State loyalty. He was there for medical treatment, and apparently he and I grew pretty close.

Then, well ... apparently he was getting the implants to cure his condition from IzzyChan, who was one of the few Nation capsuleers at the time, and also an Omerta Syndicate pilot. Once the set was complete.... As the implants took effect, he basically had time to beg for death. Then he was theirs for good.

They're treacherous. It's not like the rest of us can't be, but....

Please be careful.
Tootenh'amon
#30 - 2015-04-23 19:28:12 UTC
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Tootenh'amon wrote:
... seeing Amarrians getting all rattled because "Sansha three jumps from Amarr, must be the End of Days"... Has that smell of poetic justice to it.

It's maybe worth getting to know people before you decide that it's okay if Nation takes them all.


I don't remember the Amarrians showing the same courtesy. I'm not defending Sansha, but I'm not going to move an inch to protect the Amarr. Besides, don't they have a gargantuan fleet of their own to save them?
Aria Jenneth
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#31 - 2015-04-23 19:33:02 UTC
Tootenh'amon wrote:
I don't remember the Amarrians showing the same courtesy. I'm not defending Sansha, but I'm not going to move an inch to protect the Amarr. Besides, don't they have a gargantuan fleet of their own to save them?

And so it goes.
Tootenh'amon
#32 - 2015-04-23 19:40:03 UTC
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Tootenh'amon wrote:
I don't remember the Amarrians showing the same courtesy. I'm not defending Sansha, but I'm not going to move an inch to protect the Amarr. Besides, don't they have a gargantuan fleet of their own to save them?

And so it goes.


No, really. Why is it that their ships are available for abducting people and getting their asses handed to them by the Jovians and the Federation, but they are suddenly out of reach when they have to defend their own home systems?
Liam Antolliere
Doomheim
#33 - 2015-04-23 19:47:07 UTC
Tootenh'amon wrote:
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Tootenh'amon wrote:
I don't remember the Amarrians showing the same courtesy. I'm not defending Sansha, but I'm not going to move an inch to protect the Amarr. Besides, don't they have a gargantuan fleet of their own to save them?

And so it goes.


No, really. Why is it that their ships are available for abducting people and getting their asses handed to them by the Jovians and the Federation, but they are suddenly out of reach when they have to defend their own home systems?


They're not.

Nation has demonstrated (and continues to demonstrate) that it has the ability to be in any system at any time and the Amarr Empire is very, very vast. Mobilizing a fleet to any part of the Empire takes time. Against an adversary that can be anywhere at any time, without warning and nigh instantly removes time as a resource.

Do not misunderstand me, the Amarr Empire has much to answer for but I would not condemn anyone to the fate Nation has in store for them nor would I stand idly by and let them face it alone. Some things are worth setting aside our differences for.

Nation is one such thing.

"Though the people may hate me, that does not relieve me of my charge."

Aldrith Shutaq
Atash e Sarum Vanguard
#34 - 2015-04-23 19:52:17 UTC
Just like with the other great powers, the Empire has the Sansha threat handled for now. No one is saying the sky is falling, only that the persistence of Nation's forces are obviously rather annoying.

Aldrith Ter'neth Shutaq Newelle

Fleet Captain of the Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris

Divine Commodore of the 24th Imperial Crusade

Lord Consort of Lady Mitara Newelle, Champion of House Sarum and Holder of Damnidios Para'nashu

Evi Polevhia
Phoenix Naval Operations
Phoenix Naval Systems
#35 - 2015-04-23 20:11:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Evi Polevhia
Normally I'm content to let people I don't like simply wade about in their own ignorance. But given the subject I am going to throw you a bone here.

Nation's leadership is a collection and merging of infomorphs who have unified into a more single entity. Like limbs with sentience they originally had an option to work on selfish or greedy paths. But a leg can only move so far before it requires eyes to see, hands to grasp, and so on. The mitochondria in your body is a nonsentient and primordial example of this process from countless years ago. Governments do this too. From tribes of dozens, to settlements of hundreds, to cities of thousands. States, countries, worlds, empires. Man has always sought to unite, sometimes by force sometimes by peace, because unifying a people is always preferable to division when your future is at risk. Nation is the infomorph continuation of this idea. Continuing reverence to Master Kuvakei is twofold. One part to honor the man who started it, one part to honor the current entity of Nation.

Master Kuvakei is dead.

Let me say that again. The man who founded Nation is dead. But before he died, like Capsuleers his infomorph was recorded. Unlike Capsuleers who maintain a relatively insular mind, his was connected to Nation's. And when he died, Nation granted him Rebirth. But he is not the same. Instead of the man who founded Nation, if there is anything wearing his face it is most likely more an amalgamation of the will of the True Citizens of Nation than anything else. To claim his singular will is controlling Nation is to misunderstand what we say by the word Unity.

As far as progress made in Incursions, I'll be one of the first to admit it is far from an efficient war. Instead it is a war of attrition. Nation's industrial power will not be exhausted by the losses Capsuleers inflict. So any loss Capsuleers sustain is a victory of sorts. If Nation ever slows on their ship production due to losses, then maybe I will admit the war is a loss. Till then, remember always that the empires started this war.
Evi Polevhia
Phoenix Naval Operations
Phoenix Naval Systems
#36 - 2015-04-23 20:24:33 UTC
Aldrith Shutaq wrote:
Just like with the other great powers, the Empire has the Sansha threat handled for now. No one is saying the sky is falling, only that the persistence of Nation's forces are obviously rather annoying.

Speaking of presistance, why don't you ever invite me to your parties? You guys can't be all stuck up and inflexible.
Wendrika Hydreiga
#37 - 2015-04-23 20:30:34 UTC
Boo! Hiss! Go home, you stupid Sansha! Back to Stain with you!
Desiderya
Blue Canary
Watch This
#38 - 2015-04-23 20:50:38 UTC
"The Sansha Threat: You know, the one nobody is talking about."[citation needed]

Ruthlessness is the kindness of the wise.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#39 - 2015-04-23 20:55:25 UTC
Aria Jenneth wrote:
Please be careful.


When I have issues with my grey matter I entrust it to two individuals - Scherezad of Lai Dai and Arista Shani. Neither have any affiliation with Nation.

Believe me - your concerns are definitely ones that I share, even though none of the Nation Loyalists now affiliated with my company have ever expressed any interest in recruiting more capsuleers to Nation. Again, I stress, that they have all acted with integrity in our employment.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

iyammarrok
Drunken Beaver Mining
Gnawthority
#40 - 2015-04-23 21:08:37 UTC
Interesting concept Evi.
Though, it doesn't seem to mesh with the remarkably individualistic statements made by your 'master' during nation's resurgence.

Good story, but i'll stick with verifiable facts.
Unless of course, you can verify what you have stated without claiming inside knowledge.

-Tertianus Rethelior

Not indicative of corporate policy unless otherwise stated.