These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Fiction

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

Are the Caldari Finnish?

Author
Kharamete
Royal Assent
#1 - 2014-12-06 17:52:14 UTC
I and another player have a bit of a friendly dispute going about the origins of the Caldari, and while discussing the ins and outs of it does idle away the empty hours we are all prone to in this game, I thought maybe it would be wise to find out directly from the source.

The dispute is this: I contend that the Caldari are... Finnish. My disputee claims they are more Japanese.

To me, as a Scandinavian player reading, for instance, the map of Caldari space often feels like opening a map of Finland and reading the names. While I don't speak the language, and the names are probably gibberish to Finnish people, I know how the language sounds in my ears, and reading names like Juunigashi, Hakonen, Uedama, etc my ears tune into Finnish.

So, dear Eve Fiction section, is my friend right that the Caldari are mainly Japanese-Russo inspired, or is there actually a strong Finnish element to the Caldari? Like the Gallente are French, and the Amarrians are Persian-Romans?

CCP FoxFour: "... the what button... oh god I didn't even know that existed. BRB."

My little youtube videos can be found here

Jade Blackwind
#2 - 2014-12-06 19:50:18 UTC  |  Edited by: Jade Blackwind
Why can't they be both? As far as I remember, Caldari Prime was colonized by megacorporations from the old Earth before the EVE gate collapsed, so among the stranded colonists there could be a Finnish group, a Japanese group and a Russian group which later intermingled and created the Caldari nation.
Esna Pitoojee
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#3 - 2014-12-06 23:25:14 UTC
Both Finnish and Japanese have long been cited as influences for the Caldari in lore discussions.
Kyoko Sakoda
Achura-Waschi Exchange
Monyusaiya Industry Trade Group
#4 - 2014-12-07 08:16:27 UTC
25,000 years from now, standard genetic evolution will have changed everyone and the Collapse of the Gate will have created new semi-primitive cultures from scratch.

But it helps artistically and as a matter of communication to reference cultures we know of on Earth.
Kharamete
Royal Assent
#5 - 2014-12-07 20:42:13 UTC
Kyoko Sakoda wrote:
25,000 years from now, standard genetic evolution will have changed everyone and the Collapse of the Gate will have created new semi-primitive cultures from scratch.

But it helps artistically and as a matter of communication to reference cultures we know of on Earth.


Well, true, but cultural origin isn't unimportant, or the Gallente wouldn't be as Francophone as they are.

Thanks all. Looks like we can continue to argue with each other.

CCP FoxFour: "... the what button... oh god I didn't even know that existed. BRB."

My little youtube videos can be found here

Owen Levanth
Sagittarius Unlimited Exploration
#6 - 2014-12-07 22:48:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Owen Levanth
Kharamete wrote:
Kyoko Sakoda wrote:
25,000 years from now, standard genetic evolution will have changed everyone and the Collapse of the Gate will have created new semi-primitive cultures from scratch.

But it helps artistically and as a matter of communication to reference cultures we know of on Earth.


Well, true, but cultural origin isn't unimportant, or the Gallente wouldn't be as Francophone as they are.

Thanks all. Looks like we can continue to argue with each other.


Can't you make a compromise like 40% Finnish influence, 40% Japanese, 20% rest?

Edit:

Seems easy to do, no argument necessary.
Bagrat Skalski
Koinuun Kotei
#7 - 2014-12-09 08:46:43 UTC
Maybe the language is a simplified version of finnish with many european and asiatic influences. It would be dependent on the mixture of colonists inhabiting the planet.
It sure seems altaic-uralic mix, together with Achura.
Makoto Priano
Kirkinen-Arataka Transhuman Zenith Consulting Ltd.
Arataka Research Consortium
#8 - 2014-12-09 17:43:25 UTC
I recall hearing the Caldari described by a CCPer as a mix of, "Finnish mechanic, Japanese zaibatsu, and Prussian general staff," or something else on the German end. Will try to dig up the interview.

Itsukame-Zainou Hyperspatial Inquiries: exploring the edge of the known, advancing the state of the art. Would you like to know more?

Owen Levanth
Sagittarius Unlimited Exploration
#9 - 2014-12-11 12:47:07 UTC
Makoto Priano wrote:
I recall hearing the Caldari described by a CCPer as a mix of, "Finnish mechanic, Japanese zaibatsu, and Prussian general staff," or something else on the German end. Will try to dig up the interview.


I think they meant this as a description of their culture, not their actual heritage, though.
Vulxanis Viceroy
Offworld Trading Company
Khimi Harar
#10 - 2014-12-11 20:47:49 UTC  |  Edited by: Vulxanis Viceroy
If you look at how the Caldari Government works, you'll notice that they are business men first. However, because the acquisition of wealth is the primary objective, and crime is not something the Caldari are above per se.

Basically they are run by the Yakuza mixed in with some patriotism and a dash of communist.

Except they're all white (The Achura are a later addition, sorry), which is the first obvious sign that they have European heritage.

Esna Pitoojee wrote:
Both Finnish and Japanese have long been cited as influences for the Caldari in lore discussions.


^ That right there sums it up.

Also, something to note. It has been said that the Gallente and Caldari are related. The Civre specifically have French heritage as well (iirc)

The Gallente and Caldari both have similar histories in how they reached for the stars. Similar, though. There are distinct differences.

However, it's simply easier to point out that they have Japanese cultural characteristics. I'm not sure where the Finnish culture comes into play (I know it does), but the Caldari way of referencing eachother as "Haan" or "haani" is along the lines of the Japanese pleasantries. Just a lot more simplified.

So you're not wrong. But neither is your friend.

In Character: Only responds to "Lord Draconis"

Pronounced "Vulzanis"

Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/Eve/comments/4fanm8/eve_in_a_nutshell_and_how_to_crack_it/

Public channel: VXV EVE

Twitter: https://wiki.eveonline.com/en/wiki/Vulxanis_Viceroy

Jukko Riis
Doomheim
#11 - 2014-12-15 00:32:49 UTC
Finnish?


Could be...
Wyke Mossari
Staner Industries
#12 - 2014-12-17 23:40:50 UTC  |  Edited by: Wyke Mossari
Originally the lore of the Caldari and Gallente was an allegory of European discovery of the New World.

The Gallente replacing the French, and the Caldari for New World Americans. Those German, Scandinavian, Anglo Saxon similarities reflecting their influences towards the USA.

Take a look at the Caldari (and other races) Cosmos items for some clues.

However the narrow origins of the lore seems to be slowly being downgraded & retconed.
Vulxanis Viceroy
Offworld Trading Company
Khimi Harar
#13 - 2015-02-15 22:26:38 UTC
Wyke Mossari wrote:
Originally the lore of the Caldari and Gallente was an allegory of European discovery of the New World.

The Gallente replacing the French, and the Caldari for New World Americans. Those German, Scandinavian, Anglo Saxon similarities reflecting their influences towards the USA.

Take a look at the Caldari (and other races) Cosmos items for some clues.

However the narrow origins of the lore seems to be slowly being downgraded & retconed.


I have genuinely never heard of this before. Do you have any lore evidence for this? The Gallente are descended from the french, yes, but where did you get the rest of that assumption? o.O

In Character: Only responds to "Lord Draconis"

Pronounced "Vulzanis"

Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/Eve/comments/4fanm8/eve_in_a_nutshell_and_how_to_crack_it/

Public channel: VXV EVE

Twitter: https://wiki.eveonline.com/en/wiki/Vulxanis_Viceroy

Davey Talvanen
Kingsparrow Wormhole Division
Birds of Prey.
#14 - 2015-02-17 22:36:07 UTC
Kyoko Sakoda wrote:
25,000 years from now, standard genetic evolution will have changed everyone and the Collapse of the Gate will have created new semi-primitive cultures from scratch.

But it helps artistically and as a matter of communication to reference cultures we know of on Earth.


No, these cultures are direct cultures from earth and at least the amarr have maintain literacy and a single faith throughout the millenia (they were originally roman-catholics I belive)
Perosteck Neuchatel
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#15 - 2015-03-01 08:18:31 UTC
Davey Talvanen wrote:
Kyoko Sakoda wrote:
25,000 years from now, standard genetic evolution will have changed everyone and the Collapse of the Gate will have created new semi-primitive cultures from scratch.

But it helps artistically and as a matter of communication to reference cultures we know of on Earth.


No, these cultures are direct cultures from earth and at least the amarr have maintain literacy and a single faith throughout the millenia (they were originally roman-catholics I belive)



Yes. Scholars and Antropologist of the EVE lore have had a lot of diatribes about this and the results are very clear, but we always turn over and over the same problems, that guide us to the same conclusions and silogisms.

It is clear that when the Human Kind is able to reach far spots in the Galaxy minor cultures would have been absorbed and assmilated by the 3 big Cultural and Strategics Blocks that actually exists in the Earth today. The most outstanding Block is the West and their idea of unlimited progress and technological obssession and the advancement in social and cultural wealth and their focus on Science and a very advanced Space programs. It includes the USA, EU, Australia, New Zealand and their allies. In some moment the critical situation in the Russian Federation will make it come into the West Block as they can't go forward. Second Block is Russia and China, but they are formally still at war and Chinese are not improving very well in the long-run and their Space Program is non-existant even when they launched a rocket that was their highest demonstration of "Technology" but for example the EU uses much more advanced Rockets to just simply put the TV Corporations and Mobile companies everyday. So that, we have found that the Chinese remained in Earth. The third block is the 3rd world and is irrelevant as the Radical Religious Leaders are destroying the litlle capacity that remained for them to jump for example to a Reinassene kind of society as we had in the XVII Century, but they remain in their mix of a very dark Middle Age and a Neolithic main culture and style of life.

So back to the topic: Yes, it seems that at some point Caldari were formed in reality by a Big part of the USA and the EU, and they use a simplified Finnish as a neutral language to baptize their systems and even they use this culture to form Surnames and lore. It indicates that New Eden had heavy conflicts in the past with old cultures from the Earth trying to keep their heritage but at some point they dealt it out adopting a neutral language and a non-factor country(In Military Big terms,. as a country Finland is rich, clever, peaceful and highly developed today) to tie the Caldari State to a neutral basis to start from the scratch after heavy neo-feudal wars which took place in former centuries. As a Prussian reader (Sorry, my country was nuked by Russia after WW2 and it does not exist anymore, some Prussian reaching the Stars?, we are scattered all over the world and being asimilated by our new national identities, but as a kind, we inherit some cultural traits as Military formation since children and understanding of what our nation was.... it was nuked in 1945 and we all were massacred or migrating.... but as we remain Prussian in our hearts, well, it's very improbable that Prussians reach anything in the future as we are only Prussians in our souls but legally and nationally does not exist but as a background culture, and in Germany they still are relieved that we were nuked and their - really good and impressive - jokes about the Prussians are present and I laugh as the joke resembles the reality much more than they think. So NO Prussians in space!

Caldari is mainly a North American/Japanese/Atlantic Europe side Nation, as it is a real Block in Earth today and behave the same way it does in New Eden we think we are right with our including philosophy, and not excluding.

Amarrians are Roman? What the hell is that? Roman Empire ceased to exist in the Ancient Age, before the most dark Middle Age, maybe what you mean is that the heirs of the Roman Catholic Imperialistic thinking have created a new one Empire in New Eden: Right. In short time the Hispanic Block included in the Western Block will be rich and so vast that is impossible to think that in some centuries in the future they will land wherever the Western culture lands and form their own block as they have the men, the money and the resources to do it, so that, as History teach us, if they can. they will do it. So the Amarrians are a Spanish Block(Not including the Kingdom of Spain, which belongs to the NATO and its an average european country of the Atlantic side, so is, the seed of the Caldari) that developes together with a highly cultivated Elite that brings the Hebrew, the Greek and the Persian language with them to form an Ultimate Empire which legitimates itself from the earlier civilizations of the world and act as the Head of Mankind as they are one and undivided. They speak One Language, the Ladino(Jewish-Spanish), the international Spanish and take with them the feeling of being a Nation under God. They know so well their own culture that targets that Ancient Persia was the initial point of all the Neo-Christian ideas and its ancient background so that they include a Persian system that allows them to be the Empire of Empires, and the Rulers of the Rulers and the Definite Overlords. Of course, if you don't think we are right in our assumptions to read Robert A. Heinlein's "Starship Troopers" would help to have the right scope on the Amarrian question. I could quote much more resources, as Philosoper Jürgen Habermas works on Religion and Cultures and is the head of the Hermeneutic School at its highest developemet or Economist Stiglitz(Nobel Prize) to defend this "more-than-a-theory" about the Amarrian Empire.

So as we all know intuitively that Minmatar are Scandinavians that not succeed.
Perosteck Neuchatel
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#16 - 2015-03-01 08:50:09 UTC
And as Scandinavians are short in number they reached New Eden and were inmediately submitted by a Major Population who owned a strong culture and the power and resources of almost the third part of the actual mankind, so that, they were enslaved. The Minmatars speaks MSM that all people here agrees is a form of a even most simplified Scandinavian language - been the Scandinavian languages the most simple ones of the whole Europe, dialects of the Dannish in reality, being the only exceptions the Finnish who can be hardly considered as Europeans as their language is Hune and came from Asia with Atila and their hordes and is related to Hungrian of Hungary, that is too an European country but is not culturallly nor linguistically related to Europe and their strong Indo-European languages and culture and haplotypes. So the Minmatar are the Scandinavians of the future isolated among very strong forces that owns materials, men, resources and technology that outnumber them by millions of millions and posseses cultural solid grounds to start from, where they only have been a nation looking for peace and finding an incident as the EVE gate closed the most black fate a nation can find in its developement as the other cultures assumed that domination was the only way to survive and were able to do it, the Nordic peoples failed and were subdued to a Major Historical Massive Force and they are still recovering from it.

What makes me wonder about everything is the Gallente.... they are not very probable, but only probable. But I will try to give the best of our discussions and diatribes here: Gallente Federation is the result of the never hidden plan of France and their allies and friends to be a Block in the world. with a clever usage of all their resources and diplomatic intelligence they have overseized the whole Europe many times and even to this day they declare they don't want to be a NATO-member and that France will stand alone and in their own feet in the future. From outside Europe it looks that Germany is in command but... France always win against Germany, by any means necessary, being the Germans the agressors, as the French does not need to attack Germany to create a worldwide empire (Which they did and still keep all over the planet), and many times they play the underdog role but in reality France is dominating the EU with a soft velvet hand and with the other keeping their own Global Agenda as they have always did in the past. So maybe in the future as they own the technology and the strong idea of the Francophony if they found themselves isolated from the metropolis they only had to keep being what they are, and it works and as many do not realize, maybe the Gallente Federation will play a major role in EVE. They are so clever that they have a french client years before than the Hispanics, who are the second largest language in the world. And if their ideals have seduced many other cultures, maybe it happened the same in New Eden and to form the Gallente Federation was as natural as breathing and many other cultures joined them to avoid disasters - as the most inhuman failure of the Minmatar -. So that. here you have all the questions answered.

Yes, The Caldari State uses Finnish as a lingua franca and yes, they are in part finnish as the West Block includes them., so that many Finnish reached New Eden.

As I am Minmatar in my heart in EVE, I can tell you that: You are right and its a very probable situation if sometimes what is fiction here happened that strong but diverse cultures chose an almost neutral lingua franca to form a new Block. Many real nations have came to birth by taking such a choice, and they still exists.

And for the lovers of denying everything remember that this is not "The Truth" and I will not defend this as a crusader of any idea or beholder or owner of any kind of real proofs or that I think my assumptions are better than others. EVE is so rich and inclusive that many theories can be stated solidly as mine. But I love lore and antropology and couldn't resist tthe temptation to explain what many think about the origins of New Eden.

Thanks for the discussion and the reading. Fly safe and remember, life is adventure!
Bagrat Skalski
Koinuun Kotei
#17 - 2015-03-01 13:33:17 UTC  |  Edited by: Bagrat Skalski
Quote:
the Finnish who can be hardly considered as Europeans as their language is Hune and came from Asia with Atila and their hordes and is related to Hungrian of Hungary


Not with Attila, it is in Finland probably for 4000 years already. And the homeland of Uralic language family, not "Hune", is Kama river watershed. Hungarian also have roots there. Before Russians came in with expanding their empire, Uralic languages were common in the east-north regions of Europe, and spanned regions located near the Ural mountains on the Asian side.
Russell Denton
Cool Heads Investments
#18 - 2015-03-02 16:42:40 UTC
Caldari system names certainly make them appear so
Perosteck Neuchatel
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#19 - 2015-03-03 07:07:40 UTC
Bagrat Skalski wrote:
Quote:
the Finnish who can be hardly considered as Europeans as their language is Hune and came from Asia with Atila and their hordes and is related to Hungrian of Hungary


Not with Attila, it is in Finland probably for 4000 years already. And the homeland of Uralic language family, not "Hune", is Kama river watershed. Hungarian also have roots there. Before Russians came in with expanding their empire, Uralic languages were common in the east-north regions of Europe, and spanned regions located near the Ural mountains on the Asian side.


Thanks, Sir. I don't have many information about them, which in real life are a clever and intelligent, kind people ~ as I deal with them often for musical matters ~ as Finland produces very good bands.

Fine to know more about them. Well, the Hungarians themselves say they came with Atila and they consider themselves the descendants of the Hunes; are we maybe in front of a national foundation myth?
Perosteck Neuchatel
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#20 - 2015-03-03 07:32:38 UTC
Many places in New Eden present a Finnish-morph way of constructing words and names. But there are other languages in the Earth and some Scifi Constructed Languages who resembles to that style and structure. the Aglutinative languages appear to be the most far away from our Indo-Europeans ones, which are ~ all of them ~ Nominative, Accusative, Analytic (evolving to Highly Analytic in our days) and Highly Fussionant. Agglutinatives languages do not share any of these structural or linguistic phenomena neither methods, so they are very strange for us, but if you look further, they result to be very useful and capable of expressing very complicated meanings with an outstanding efficiency, because many of the language is able to adapt to what they are trying to express naturally and their level of expressing the matisations and "shades" is pretty impressive.

The idea of a Finnish-like language being set as a Standard in the Future would be a very intelligent step once you have settled and want to develope. But the Indo-European Lamguages are much more capable for describing things in movement, scalating concepts and describe facts in a very fast and exact way. It seems the Indo-European language was developed by Hunters and War-raids ancient nations who were in need to communicate exact things and to describe movement and directional frames so as to be able to have imperative forms, which are conditioning the whole structure of the language. But it was mandatory to survive so our ancestors knew what they need.

Indo-European is not better than Finnish or the opposite, they are diferent, reflecting different rich cultures and the main tool for communication of two different but friendly kind of people. I love the Agglutinative languages as they are rich and complex, and I love my Indo-European languages because their are first my own and second because all the important writtings of mankind are written originally in some Indo-European language, being a culture who never stops in their idea of unlimited progress. And is a language that serves to this purpose.

Klingon language is Agglutinative and is very proficient for movement and describing exact objects too, and is farily a language for iron-made warriors, so we can state that all our languages could serve for the purpose we choose to, but some are more eficient in some areas while lacking in others. As I am into Lingüistics, I can assure many languages are top notch a technology of communication, and that some nations owns hidden treasures... the most unexpected. But their aims are not the same as ours, so they use it for succeding in achieving their aims, what they pretty do.

Thanks to you all.

And Yes, Caldari State is USA and Japan using Finnish as a strong Language to be a Strong State wich will expand in the future. Or at least they are perfectly capable to expand and Caldarize other Nations.
12Next page