These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[GMVA] Congratulations on President Roden's Victory

Author
Elmund Egivand
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#41 - 2015-02-05 01:40:26 UTC
iyammarrok wrote:
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
If it's ironic to you, imagine how ironic it is for me - but I fear we lost the idealistic neighbour who did awful things out of the best of intentions and wound up with a cold-eyed neighbour who does awful things out of expediency. And no, I'm not laying it on too thick. I've had the Black Eagles pointed at me and, like many Caldari who've done time in Black Rise, I've seen the labour camps. The execution trenches. The mass graves.



Black Eagles.
Dragonaurs.

All governments it seems have their black flags.
Before anyone tries to tar another, best to be sure you've not caught yourself with the same brush.


The Black Eagles, last I checked, didn't blow up an underwater city. They are more interested in terrorising Fed citizens more than anything else.

A Minmatar warship is like a rusting Beetle with 500 horsepower Cardillac engines in the rear, armour plating bolted to chassis and a M2 Browning stuck on top.

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#42 - 2015-02-05 02:22:51 UTC
Elmund Egivand wrote:

The Black Eagles, last I checked, didn't blow up an underwater city. They are more interested in terrorising Fed citizens more than anything else.


In case the distinction escapes you, one of these two groups is a terrorist group and the other is an arm of the government.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#43 - 2015-02-05 03:05:05 UTC
As I recall, when the rogue clone soldier unit accused of killing civilians in Black Rise were caught by Federation Navy Military Police they were executed on the spot.

Sounds like a pretty definitive response to Gallente terrorism to me.
KaRa DaVuT
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#44 - 2015-02-05 08:36:05 UTC
Diana Kim wrote:
Gwen Ikiryo wrote:
The Federation is more fluid then a lot of people give it credit for. Roden is not their first flirtation with nationalist conservatism, nor are the Black Eagles their first fliration with quasi-totalitarian law enforcement - In both cases, the honor goes to the U-Nats, though there are many others that have come close. It'll likely default back in the other direction sooner or later. It's a quick ship to turn, far quicker then any other of it's size in the cluster. Though it's debateable if that is a good thing.

It is also good to remember that if Roden is a ripple in the Federal pond, Tibus Heth was the pebble. He is a natural result of the States invasion, it's "fault", to whatever point you can assign it to something as abstract and tremendous in scale as interstellar politics.

That's the only imperfection of Tibus Heth: he was just the pebble. He got us our homeworld, but he believed words of gallenteans, that they will give our home back. Word of gallentean lasted only five years.

We don't need pebbles anymore. We need whole BOMB to throw into their pond, bomb so powerful so it not just cause ripples, but dry this damn filthy water out. Bomb so powerful, that will teach them respect. So powerful, it will not just make them sign peace, but will FORCE them to follow peace, so they won't ever dare to raise weapons on us.

FOR THE STATE!


You really are a propaganda artist.

Terrorist Heth and his so called "beliefs" have no room in Federation Political talks.

But you are a vermin Kim, who believes Terrorist Heth got good motivations.. Well youa re wrong.

What he started, the war, took more civilian lifes than the previous wars ever did. He started a flame and it spread to whole galaxy. Now even after all these years, not you, not me or not Rinai Vero but mortals, civilians, non-combatants all paid the price.

You people lost your humanity. I did not.

Rinai thinks supporting Roden will help Federation. Yes maybe it will, maybe we will won the coflict. But at what cost? how many people have to die? because we cannot die but those poor sods on those planets can.

I see no difference in Roden's recklessness or Heth's pure racism terms of approach. yes they aims right on target, which means winning the war. But the costs are too damn High. Those people do not ever think cvilillians or non-combatants.

That is the sole reason why I supported and wanted Mayor Ramnev as President. Because she is still a human. She did not lost it. She resisted and helped the people on that planet. She did not differed any race from another. She helped People, not Gallenteans or Caldari... She saved people.

Now you go fight your war.. Kim or Rinai... I see no difference... Roden or Heth.. Go fight for them, Caldari or Gallente go wage your war.

But think a second, those lifes. civilians, mortals, non-combatants who died.. At what cost.

Holiness is in right action and courage on behalf of those who cannot defend themselves, and goodness. What God desires is in your heart and on your mind... And what you decide to do every day, makes you - not your race - a good man - or not.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#45 - 2015-02-05 16:48:25 UTC
Spare me more of your false equivalency and self righteous moralizing, KaRa.

Jacus Roden has been a strong wartime President, but it was also Roden who signed the peace treaty establishing the Caldari Prime DMZ and allowing Ishukone to peacefully administrate the Caldari Districts. I have every expectation of Roden to continue to further the peace process, and urged him to do just that in my speech.

I have no idea how any member of a Nullsec powerbloc gets the idea to lecture anyone about casualties of war. As if your wars have any more noble purpose.

Anyway, we agree on one thing and that is that Ramnev had a positive influence. I look forward to her continued involvement in shaping the future of our Federation.
Gwen Ikiryo
Alexylva Paradox
#46 - 2015-02-05 17:20:19 UTC
I'm not sure it's really quite fair to compare the Black Eagles to the CPD, though both are obviously unpleasant organizations. While the Black Eagles get up to some pretty foul things, most of their activities are, to speak frankly, a drop in the bucket in terms of law enforcement in the west of the cluster - The average Federal will never even meet one, much less see them have any notable effect on their lives, because their role is so specific and narrow. Hells, the average Federal is barely affected by anything the presidency does, because of the way their society is structured and managed, with everything from the bottom up. I would imagine the vast majority of people (outside of the warzone of course) have barely noticed any difference in their lives since this whole ugly affair started.

The CPD, on the other hand, were unavoidable during their reign. They involved themselves in practically every strata of State society, from intelligence, to policing, to management. It was impossible to avoid knowing that they were watching, and that they were in charge... Which is probably why their day in the sun was so short.

The Black Eagles are a lot smarter then the CPD ever were. They know how to keep to their specific niche and not stir the pot to the point the public pushes for their removal, which allows them to exert the influence they do have with great efficiency. They know how to get people to forget about them, but at the same time, to inspire incredible fear in the tiny percentile of the population which, for whatever reason, attractstheir interest.

I'm not pointing that out to compliment them as an organization. I'm saying it because it's chilling.
KaRa DaVuT
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#47 - 2015-02-05 18:57:19 UTC
Rinai Vero wrote:
Spare me more of your false equivalency and self righteous moralizing, KaRa.

I have no idea how any member of a Nullsec powerbloc gets the idea to lecture anyone about casualties of war. As if your wars have any more noble purpose.

Anyway, we agree on one thing and that is that Ramnev had a positive influence. I look forward to her continued involvement in shaping the future of our Federation.


I salute your honest appraoch and dignity and I respect to your point of view.

I fought in the militia and fought together, bled together with Gallente Forces against Caldari State. Sadly after some time, the civillian casualities and non-combatants died on that war from both sides for the false assumptions of "state" or "federation" made me sick.

Roden or Heth, just another name or cause to kill another civilian. So I left the Navy. Made contracts with Mordus Legion. Their appraoch and the flexibility gave me opportunity to save non-combatants fromc onflict.

Now I am in Razor for more than 7 years. We are fighting for ourself. Not for any tyrant or to make a corporate man richer.

Still, I admire your dedication Rinai and slute you with respect. and happy to see you share my views on Mayor Ramnev.

I hope you will one day understand me.

With respect

KaRa DaVuT

Holiness is in right action and courage on behalf of those who cannot defend themselves, and goodness. What God desires is in your heart and on your mind... And what you decide to do every day, makes you - not your race - a good man - or not.

Claudia Osyn
Non-Hostile Target
Wild Geese.
#48 - 2015-02-05 20:00:02 UTC
Diana Kim wrote:
Gwen Ikiryo wrote:
The Federation is more fluid then a lot of people give it credit for. Roden is not their first flirtation with nationalist conservatism, nor are the Black Eagles their first fliration with quasi-totalitarian law enforcement - In both cases, the honor goes to the U-Nats, though there are many others that have come close. It'll likely default back in the other direction sooner or later. It's a quick ship to turn, far quicker then any other of it's size in the cluster. Though it's debateable if that is a good thing.

It is also good to remember that if Roden is a ripple in the Federal pond, Tibus Heth was the pebble. He is a natural result of the States invasion, it's "fault", to whatever point you can assign it to something as abstract and tremendous in scale as interstellar politics.

That's the only imperfection of Tibus Heth: he was just the pebble. He got us our homeworld, but he believed words of gallenteans, that they will give our home back. Word of gallentean lasted only five years.

We don't need pebbles anymore. We need whole BOMB to throw into their pond, bomb so powerful so it not just cause ripples, but dry this damn filthy water out. Bomb so powerful, that will teach them respect. So powerful, it will not just make them sign peace, but will FORCE them to follow peace, so they won't ever dare to raise weapons on us.

FOR THE STATE!

No bomb that big exists. Your outta luck sweetie.

A little trust goes a long way. The less you use, the further you'll go.

Nomistrav
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#49 - 2015-02-05 21:45:32 UTC
Bataav wrote:
Namas Nomistrav.

It's been a long time.


You'll need to take care with your assertions of neglect from the Federal powers-that-be.

In my experience that line of thinking tends to attract the almost inevitable response, from some within the Federal Militia, that "Intaki requested minimal protection at the founding of the Federation" and so the fact that the challenges of today's New Eden are greatly different to generations ago is handwaved aside as conveniently irrelevent. Instead we must make do and be satisfied with minimal Federal military intervention.

Paradoxically we are also told that it is only Federal forces can truly protect Intaki from the imminent threat that is the Caldari State.


For example during another discussion on the recent election I was asked what opposition had groups such as the ILF offered in the face of Heth's Provists? It's a fair enough question and I'll answer it here.

We offered the greatest opposition we had.

We refused to bow to Provist pressure and continued to work hard in Intaki's interests. It was the ILF who rallied around the Homeworld in the wake of the occupation and began the Intaki V Relief Effort. It was the ILF who followed the Intaki Assembly's lead and built bridges, partnering with Ishukone groups such as I-RED, investing in local infrastructure and economic initiatives.

To change who and what we were, how we operate and the things we hope to achieve would have been to admit defeat. Instead we showed Heth and his Provists that despite their wishes, the ILF and the Intaki system would remain independent of their influence.


Regarding Mordu's Legion, while there's some truth to the current security contract not being a permanent solution to Intaki's security concerns, I believe it's been a great step in the right direction. It illustrated the Assembly's ability to act when necessary, and provides a foundation upon which a long term domestic solution can be built. After all, he was one of Mordu's lackeys years ago.

Remember, it was Mordu's Legion, not FedMil, that fought for Intaki interests and defeated Provist forcess who had assaulted Ishukone assets on Intaki V, in early YC115.


You'll have my thanks for clarifying. Admittedly, I have been out of touch and somewhat disconnected with the affairs of the Intaki as a whole, ever since a dear friend of mine achieved the state of immortality. Albeit, he's an infantryman, but none-the-less my loyalties toward our friendship... outweigh those of my heritage.

If it's one thing the Intaki can be called, it's self-sufficient; maybe not in the truest sense of the word but we are capable of finding solutions when others would have simply given up. Regardless of the semantics it has been one of my highest concerns that Intaki (the system) is still a low security sector that is still under conflict between the State and the Federation. It pains me to think that the Federation would be so quick to dismiss our concerns while simultaneously quoting archaic justifications and continuing their own war despite those involved.

Perhaps I am speaking as an amateur of affairs. To be blunt: My only concern is why Intaki cannot gain at least some measure of security from any entity in the present day beside's Mordu's Mercenaries.

"As long as space endures,

as long as sentient beings exist,

until then, may I too remain

and dispel the miseries of the world."

~ Vremaja Idama

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#50 - 2015-02-05 22:44:22 UTC
Nomistrav wrote:

You'll have my thanks for clarifying. Admittedly, I have been out of touch and somewhat disconnected with the affairs of the Intaki as a whole, ever since a dear friend of mine achieved the state of immortality. Albeit, he's an infantryman, but none-the-less my loyalties toward our friendship... outweigh those of my heritage.

If it's one thing the Intaki can be called, it's self-sufficient; maybe not in the truest sense of the word but we are capable of finding solutions when others would have simply given up. Regardless of the semantics it has been one of my highest concerns that Intaki (the system) is still a low security sector that is still under conflict between the State and the Federation. It pains me to think that the Federation would be so quick to dismiss our concerns while simultaneously quoting archaic justifications and continuing their own war despite those involved.

Perhaps I am speaking as an amateur of affairs. To be blunt: My only concern is why Intaki cannot gain at least some measure of security from any entity in the present day beside's Mordu's Mercenaries.


Perhaps I can provide a different perspective than Bataav on this issue that may be relevant to your concerns.

Although the esteemed representative of the ILF portrayed FedMil's attitude as neglectful due to the original articles of Intaki's membership in the Federal Union, there are actually much more recent events that bear the most relevance. When Federal Defense Union aligned forces liberated Intaki from its initial conquest by the State Protectorate five years ago there was an immediate mobilization by the Federation Navy to restore control of the solar system.

The FedNav fleet was denied permission to enter the system by the local Intaki government.

Gallente Loyalist pilots are not hand waving towards arcane legal precedents to justify our position. In fact, the Intaki Assembly itself are the authors of the present status quo. As is their sovereign right. Personally, I would think that the Federal government's respect for this development would be counted in their favor by organizations such as the ILF.

It is perhaps justifiable for the Intaki Assembly to seek to "build bridges" with groups like Ishukone and Mordus Legion, especially when faced with the alternative of total domination by a State Protectorate dominated by Provists. Both Ishukone and the Legion have provided a degree of stability during the mercurial shifts between occupying Militia forces. I respect the Intaki Assembly's pragmatism in maintaining friends in both camps during this time of strife. I believe they do what they must to protect the lives of their people.

I am less convinced of the pure motives of the ILF. As an organization, they have maintained a fairly obvious Pro Caldari bias. Ostensibly "neutral" they have in the past refused to disavow ties to blatantly militant Caldari aligned separatists such as Yuri Intaki and his Intaki Milita corporation.

From what I can tell, ILF "bridge building" only seems to happen in the direction of the Caldari. I-RED are avowed State Loyalists, Liberals though they may be... and are currently deployed in support of the State Protectorate. These are their self described "allies." This alliance literally amounts to providing material support to belligerent parties to the Federation.

If their organization is "neutral" as they claim, where are their attempts to build friendships and networks of support among Gallente Loyalist organizations within the warzone? Instead, Bataav's line has been to publicly petition to have the FDU expelled from the Intaki System entirely. Some neutrality.
Bataav
Intaki Liberation Front
Intaki Prosperity Initiative
#51 - 2015-02-05 23:43:49 UTC
Rinai Vero wrote:
I am less convinced of the pure motives of the ILF. As an organization, they have maintained a fairly obvious Pro Caldari bias. Ostensibly "neutral" they have in the past refused to disavow ties to blatantly militant Caldari aligned separatists such as Yuri Intaki and his Intaki Milita corporation.

From what I can tell, ILF "bridge building" only seems to happen in the direction of the Caldari. I-RED are avowed State Loyalists, Liberals though they may be... and are currently deployed in support of the State Protectorate. These are their self described "allies." This alliance literally amounts to providing material support to belligerent parties to the Federation.

If their organization is "neutral" as they claim, where are their attempts to build friendships and networks of support among Gallente Loyalist organizations within the warzone? Instead, Bataav's line has been to publicly petition to have the FDU expelled from the Intaki System entirely. Some neutrality.

Up until a couple of years ago, there were a number of "Gallente loyalist" groups that had negotiated mutual positive standings with the ILF and IPI, including those in the Federal militia, such as QCATS. Even within your own alliance, Eleutherian Guard, and Penumbra Institute to name just two, had come to the table.

In mid-YC114 however, at a time when six separate GMVA member corporations were flagged as blue to the IPI, they attacked and destroyed yet another IPI industrial vessel. In the discussions that followed we were informed that our pilots would continue to be targetted regardless, and we were recommended to adjust our standings accordingly.

I retained the communication records after these events, including the conversation between ILF leadership and Ans Blix of EL-G who was dismayed by the attack, and relieved to find none of his own pilots was directly involved.

That is what our neutrality earned us.

You'll find we're not as naive as we once were when it comes to diplomacy, and we're more selective with our partners.
Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#52 - 2015-02-06 00:41:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Rinai Vero
Bataav wrote:


You'll find we're not as naive as we once were when it comes to diplomacy, and we're more selective with our partners.



No. Indeed, the partners you selected were aforementioned militant Pro Caldari separatists. What you call naive neutrality has to me the appearance of duplicitous bias.

But, I'll admit this is my historical perspective on events I was not directly involved with. I'm not married to the idea of eternal hostilities between our organizations. If you think you can make a convincing case that the ILF is simply misunderstood over all these years and you aren't a 5th Column for the Caldari... by all means contact me privately and present your argument.
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#53 - 2015-02-06 00:49:26 UTC
Remind me, Bataav, after Pyre Falcon agreed not to engage ILF vessels, how many times did WE shoot at your pilots and assets?

Just for reference?

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#54 - 2015-02-06 00:53:48 UTC
Not exactly helping the case that ILF aren't overly friendly with the Caldari State there Pieter.
Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#55 - 2015-02-06 02:13:26 UTC
KaRa DaVuT wrote:

Terrorist Heth and his so called "beliefs" have no room in Federation Political talks.

But you are a vermin Kim, who believes Terrorist Heth got good motivations.. Well youa re wrong.

No, vermin is you, who are insulting memory of a dead man, who lived and died as a hero.
Tibus Heth was not a terrorist. He dedicated his life to the State and State citizens. And you just bark on him with your incompetence.

KaRa DaVuT wrote:

What he started, the war, took more civilian lifes than the previous wars ever did. He started a flame and it spread to whole galaxy. Now even after all these years, not you, not me or not Rinai Vero but mortals, civilians, non-combatants all paid the price.

The war was started with gallentean attack of their nyx on our station and with gallente genocidal attacks on Caldari peoples on Caldari Prime. Pity your brainwashing by gallente propaganda can't make you think clear.

KaRa DaVuT wrote:

You people lost your humanity. I did not.

Said a gallentean, when gallenteans were screaming to "Exterminate all Caldari", and Caldari fought just to liberate our home from occupants. And now a gallentean said WE lost humanity.
Interesting, what is humanity now in a gallentean sense?

KaRa DaVuT wrote:

But think a second, those lifes. civilians, mortals, non-combatants who died.. At what cost.

All these deaths are because of you and peoples like you. Your type of scum, who supported genocidal operation Highlander, Federal prison camps with tortured POWs, orbital bombings... There are many crimes you gallenteans have committed.

You can close your eyes on them.

You can deny them.

BUT YOU WON'T BE ABLE TO DENY US FROM JUSTICE WE WILL BRING ON YOU.


For the State.

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#56 - 2015-02-06 02:43:44 UTC  |  Edited by: Rinai Vero
If the Federation wanted to "Exterminate all Caldari" on Caldari Prime it would have been a simple matter of following Operation Highlander with another series of orbital bombardments. The defenses being held by State ground forces couldn't have stopped such an attack, only made it very costly for the Federation Navy.

Obviously the Federation wants to do nothing of the sort, but whatever.

What we have now is realistically the best outcome for both sides. As long as our governments can retain pragmatic leadership during the ongoing process of negotiation, the situation will continue to improve.

That is why I am hopeful for Jacus Roden's next term.
Diana Kim
State Protectorate
Caldari State
#57 - 2015-02-06 03:08:44 UTC
Rinai Vero wrote:
If the Federation wanted to "Exterminate all Caldari" on Caldari Prime it would have been a simple matter of following Operation Highlander with another series of orbital bombardments. The defenses being held by State ground forces couldn't have stopped such an attack, only made it very costly for the Federation Navy.

We basically smashed down all gallente fleet that attacked Caldari Prime during operation Highlander.

Rinai Vero wrote:

Obviously the Federation wants to do nothing of the sort, but whatever.

Or licking its wounds after that criminal attack. Gallente scum might call it victory, but they paid great price for that. And you all will continue paying, until all criminals, who participated in this, won't be dead or detained.

And, as a pilot of I-RED Mantel said, "until there is no Gallente on Caldari Prime"

Honored are the dead, for their legacy guides us.

In memory of Tibus Heth, Caldari State Executor YC110-115, Hero and Patriot.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#58 - 2015-02-06 04:42:43 UTC
Thankfully everyone with any influence in either my government or yours is working to accomplish the opposite of what you want to see happen.
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#59 - 2015-02-06 05:42:08 UTC
Rinai Vero wrote:
Not exactly helping the case that ILF aren't overly friendly with the Caldari State there Pieter.

There were, by that time, special reasons not to subject the homeworld of a sovereign race to wars desolation. I did say that I always felt it was a monumental crime to include the Intaki system in the war zone.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Rinai Vero
Blades of Liberty
#60 - 2015-02-06 05:44:01 UTC
Pieter Tuulinen wrote:
Rinai Vero wrote:
Not exactly helping the case that ILF aren't overly friendly with the Caldari State there Pieter.

There were, by that time, special reasons not to subject the homeworld of a sovereign race to wars desolation. I did say that I always felt it was a monumental crime to include the Intaki system in the war zone.


On that we most certainly agree.