These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Crime & Punishment

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Who Gets All The Freighter Ganking Loot?

Author
Princess Bride
SharkNado
#161 - 2014-10-19 15:06:07 UTC
If James (and possibly other managers) are embezzling a large portion of CODE's profits for their own personal wallets, then in my opinion CODE is a scam.

The question of whether CODE donors and CODE pilots who do not receive a share of the loot "care" about this fact is inconsequential. But in reality, I think many of them would be disillusioned to discover this, regardless of what some of the more dedicated CODE fanboys (or the profiting management) in the forums would say. I think most of them buy into the assumption that the ISK they donate, and the loot they forgo, will be used exclusively for the purpose of buying ships to explode in suicide ganks. If that were to be "not exactly the truth", I doubt they would be so generous.

CODE could very well be a "long con", started with the primary purpose of fattening their personal wallets by siphoning large chunks of the treasury out of the corp wallet under the guise of "far more reimbursements than you would imagine". A CEO doing this would hardly be a novel idea, as it happens all the time in Eve.

Without a full API, there's no transparency. Without transparency, you have the potential for abuse. And considering James' past exploits, I think it's a fair estimation that this is exactly what is happening.

There are plenty of historical examples of hundreds of people happily marching to the tune of a charismatic pied piper, giving him everything they own in exchange for a personal sense of relevance. Especially in a religious context. Just sayin',

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

Jonah Gravenstein
Machiavellian Space Bastards
#162 - 2014-10-19 15:12:00 UTC  |  Edited by: Jonah Gravenstein
Veers Belvar wrote:
Seriously? Goons have now gotten so pathetic to the point where they no longer know how to look up killmails? This must really be a new low....maybe it's just time to disband and move on.

Here is one JF kill https://zkillboard.com/kill/41759169/

And another..... https://zkillboard.com/kill/41843905/


I mean come on Goons....this is easy. I mean getting owned by PL is one thing - being too incompetent to even look through Zkill is quite another!
When you're the person making claims it's up to you to provide the evidence to back them up, expecting others to do it for you because you're too damn lazy just about sums up you and your ilk.

Veers Belvar (from another thread) wrote:
10 people in 10 million isk gank ships blowing up a 1.3 bil freighter in the 20 seconds before CONCORD arrives, while being shot at by gate guns and faction police.
Both the killmails you provided show significantly more than 10 people involved.

Would you care to contradict yourself some more?

In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.

New Player FAQ

Feyd's Survival Pack

La Nariz
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#163 - 2014-10-19 15:13:46 UTC  |  Edited by: La Nariz
Veers Belvar wrote:
La Nariz wrote:
Angelique Duchemin wrote:
Veers Belvar wrote:

... you will understand the multiple offers I've received to join Goonwaffe, for a fee of course.
I already told you that you're not welcome to join. Are the other 5 offers imagined just like you imagine mine?


Seconding this, we have enough horrible pubbies we don't need you.

E: This is the only forum you are allowed to post killmails in too so **** or get off the pot.


Seriously? Goons have now gotten so pathetic to the point where they no longer know how to look up killmails? This must really be a new low....maybe it's just time to disband and move on.

Here is one JF kill https://zkillboard.com/kill/41759169/

And another..... https://zkillboard.com/kill/41843905/


I mean come on Goons....this is easy. I mean getting owned by PL is one thing - being too incompetent to even look through Zkill is quite another!


You are the one making the point so the onus is on you to provide evidence. I knew my compatriot called it right when she said we don't want you. You're so terrible you wouldn't fit in with FCON or SMA.

Princess Bride wrote:
... then in my opinion CODE is a scam.


Your opinion does not matter either so I guess the thread is done now?

This post was loving crafted by a member of the Official GoonWaffe recruitment team. Improve the forums, support this idea: https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&find=unread&t=345133

Lady Areola Fappington
#164 - 2014-10-19 15:18:04 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
If James (and possibly other managers) are embezzling a large portion of CODE's profits for their own personal wallets, then in my opinion CODE is a scam.

The question of whether CODE donors and CODE pilots who do not receive a share of the loot "care" about this fact is inconsequential. But in reality, I think many of them would be disillusioned to discover this, regardless of what some of the more dedicated CODE fanboys (or the profiting management) in the forums would say. I think most of them buy into the assumption that the ISK they donate, and the loot they forgo, will be used exclusively for the purpose of buying ships to explode in suicide ganks. If that were to be "not exactly the truth", I doubt they would be so generous.

CODE could very well be a "long con", started with the primary purpose of fattening their personal wallets by siphoning large chunks of the treasury out of the corp wallet under the guise of "far more reimbursements than you would imagine". A CEO doing this would hardly be a novel idea, as it happens all the time in Eve.

Without a full API, there's no transparency. Without transparency, you have the potential for abuse. And considering James' past exploits, I think it's a fair estimation that this is exactly what is happening.

There are plenty of historical examples of hundreds of people happily marching to the tune of a charismatic pied piper, giving him everything they own in exchange for a personal sense of relevance. Especially in a religious context. Just sayin',



And we get back to the important point, nobody in Code cares. James could be using the SRP pot for anything, but so long as the ganks roll and the SRP happens when needed, nobody cares.

Hell, James could cash out and keep all the ISK tomorrow (which would be quite dumb), and I doubt many would care then. The vast majority of gankers play EVE for amusement, not ISK. Giving ISK to Code is like giving ISK to a newbie, nobody expects to get it back, they just want to see fun things happen.

7.2 CAN I AVOID PVP COMPLETELY? No; there are no systems or locations in New Eden where PvP may be completely avoided. --Eve New Player Guide

Angelique Duchemin
Team Evil
#165 - 2014-10-19 15:48:53 UTC
Veers Belvar wrote:
La Nariz wrote:
Angelique Duchemin wrote:
Veers Belvar wrote:

... you will understand the multiple offers I've received to join Goonwaffe, for a fee of course.
I already told you that you're not welcome to join. Are the other 5 offers imagined just like you imagine mine?


Seconding this, we have enough horrible pubbies we don't need you.

E: This is the only forum you are allowed to post killmails in too so **** or get off the pot.


Seriously? Goons have now gotten so pathetic to the point where they no longer know how to look up killmails? This must really be a new low....maybe it's just time to disband and move on.

Here is one JF kill https://zkillboard.com/kill/41759169/

And another..... https://zkillboard.com/kill/41843905/


I mean come on Goons....this is easy. I mean getting owned by PL is one thing - being too incompetent to even look through Zkill is quite another!


No one ever said Eve was safe.

The very sun of heaven seemed distorted when viewed through the polarising miasma welling out from this sea-soaked perversion, and twisted menace and suspense lurked leeringly in those crazily elusive angles of carven rock where a second glance shewed concavity after the first shewed convexity.

Black Pedro
Mine.
#166 - 2014-10-19 16:18:56 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
If James (and possibly other managers) are embezzling a large portion of CODE's profits for their own personal wallets, then in my opinion CODE is a scam.

The question of whether CODE donors and CODE pilots who do not receive a share of the loot "care" about this fact is inconsequential. But in reality, I think many of them would be disillusioned to discover this, regardless of what some of the more dedicated CODE fanboys (or the profiting management) in the forums would say. I think most of them buy into the assumption that the ISK they donate, and the loot they forgo, will be used exclusively for the purpose of buying ships to explode in suicide ganks. If that were to be "not exactly the truth", I doubt they would be so generous.

CODE could very well be a "long con", started with the primary purpose of fattening their personal wallets by siphoning large chunks of the treasury out of the corp wallet under the guise of "far more reimbursements than you would imagine". A CEO doing this would hardly be a novel idea, as it happens all the time in Eve.

Without a full API, there's no transparency. Without transparency, you have the potential for abuse. And considering James' past exploits, I think it's a fair estimation that this is exactly what is happening.

There are plenty of historical examples of hundreds of people happily marching to the tune of a charismatic pied piper, giving him everything they own in exchange for a personal sense of relevance. Especially in a religious context. Just sayin',

While everything you say is true, I'm not sure what your point is. Of course James could abscond with the ISK tomorrow, and yes, such things have happened before but everyone knows this. Also, everyone who has bought New Order shares knows (or should know) about James' past adventures, and sent ISK full-well knowning there is no auditing of the organization. But this doesn't matter. What matters is the community, killboards, and tear-filled forum posts these donations, and the time and effort of James 315 produce. So I think you are wrong - even if proof appears tomorrow that the New Order leadership was skimming something off the top, "investors" would not even bat an eye. As long as Catalyst SRP keeps going out and carebear tears keep rolling in - that is people are having fun - the New Order will keep going strong.

But really, there is no evidence that this is the case. The amount of incoming ISK is regularly posted on minerbumping.com and in the forums here, and the CODE. alliance killboard is publically available showing Code losses. Those numbers show there is little-to-no ISK unaccounted for. But as has been explained multiple times, ISK isn't the major dividend that New Order provides - it is things like this thread that investors are buying - and by that measure a New Order share purchase is probably the best investment opportunity in New Eden right now.
Syn Shi
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#167 - 2014-10-19 17:18:11 UTC
Dmitri Dracov wrote:
Thomas Mayaki wrote:
Amyclas Amatin wrote:
We gank everything, even if it isn't profitable.

And we give out the equipment for the ganks. The loot goes towards more ships. We're usually doing this on gank alts or pvp alts.

I'm afk mining in deep deklein while ganking.

If you want to gank for profit, belligerent undesirables still does it that way.


'I'm afk mining in deep deklein while ganking' . And this is why the New Order has zero credibility with highsec players.


To be fair he isn't in CODE he's a Goon.



Code is just bored Goon alts.
Tyyler DURden
Mordechai and Sons Distribution Co.
#168 - 2014-10-19 17:18:20 UTC
So just for fun then, hypothetically speaking of course, if the code SRP one day did just dry up, for whatever reason, and the rank and file code members had to start funding ganks out of pocket. What percentage of code membership would vanish overnight once the free ride was over?
The remaining code members being the individuals for whom the self-mandated crusade to save hisec from carebearism is truly a labour of love.

Tyyler DURden says "use soap"

Lady Areola Fappington
#169 - 2014-10-19 17:34:24 UTC
Tyyler DURden wrote:
So just for fun then, hypothetically speaking of course, if the code SRP one day did just dry up, for whatever reason, and the rank and file code members had to start funding ganks out of pocket. What percentage of code membership would vanish overnight once the free ride was over?
The remaining code members being the individuals for whom the self-mandated crusade to save hisec from carebearism is truly a labour of love.



Not many would leave, TBH. It's considered a good thing to be able to fund your ganking on your own dime. Most people only use the SRP at first to keep ganking. Every ganker I knew bankrolled their own ships, and left the SRP fund for "new guys ganking".

7.2 CAN I AVOID PVP COMPLETELY? No; there are no systems or locations in New Eden where PvP may be completely avoided. --Eve New Player Guide

Jonah Gravenstein
Machiavellian Space Bastards
#170 - 2014-10-19 17:39:54 UTC
Syn Shi wrote:
Dmitri Dracov wrote:
Thomas Mayaki wrote:
Amyclas Amatin wrote:
We gank everything, even if it isn't profitable.

And we give out the equipment for the ganks. The loot goes towards more ships. We're usually doing this on gank alts or pvp alts.

I'm afk mining in deep deklein while ganking.

If you want to gank for profit, belligerent undesirables still does it that way.


'I'm afk mining in deep deklein while ganking' . And this is why the New Order has zero credibility with highsec players.


To be fair he isn't in CODE he's a Goon.



Code is just bored Goon alts.
Are you including those people who are red to GSF but are willing to ignore their differences to gank with CODE.? Or are they bored Goon alts too?

In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.

New Player FAQ

Feyd's Survival Pack

Syn Shi
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#171 - 2014-10-19 17:59:05 UTC
Lady Areola Fappington wrote:
Tyyler DURden wrote:
So just for fun then, hypothetically speaking of course, if the code SRP one day did just dry up, for whatever reason, and the rank and file code members had to start funding ganks out of pocket. What percentage of code membership would vanish overnight once the free ride was over?
The remaining code members being the individuals for whom the self-mandated crusade to save hisec from carebearism is truly a labour of love.



Not many would leave, TBH. It's considered a good thing to be able to fund your ganking on your own dime. Most people only use the SRP at first to keep ganking. Every ganker I knew bankrolled their own ships, and left the SRP fund for "new guys ganking".



So Code discourages the rank and file from using the srp further increasing the profit for management?
Syn Shi
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#172 - 2014-10-19 18:02:00 UTC
Jonah Gravenstein wrote:
Syn Shi wrote:
Dmitri Dracov wrote:
Thomas Mayaki wrote:
Amyclas Amatin wrote:
We gank everything, even if it isn't profitable.

And we give out the equipment for the ganks. The loot goes towards more ships. We're usually doing this on gank alts or pvp alts.

I'm afk mining in deep deklein while ganking.

If you want to gank for profit, belligerent undesirables still does it that way.


'I'm afk mining in deep deklein while ganking' . And this is why the New Order has zero credibility with highsec players.


To be fair he isn't in CODE he's a Goon.



Code is just bored Goon alts.
Are you including those people who are red to GSF but are willing to ignore their differences to gank with CODE.? Or are they bored Goon alts too?



Just because you are a goon doesn't mean you are a goon. There are a certain portion of goons that are needed and tolerated and killing them on alts is not off limits at all.
Jonah Gravenstein
Machiavellian Space Bastards
#173 - 2014-10-19 18:17:55 UTC
Syn Shi wrote:
Just because you are a goon doesn't mean you are a goon. There are a certain portion of goons that are needed and tolerated and killing them on alts is not off limits at all.
This makes no sense without the aid of recreational drugs, would you be willing to share yours?

In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.

New Player FAQ

Feyd's Survival Pack

Black Pedro
Mine.
#174 - 2014-10-19 18:36:42 UTC
Syn Shi wrote:
Lady Areola Fappington wrote:
Tyyler DURden wrote:
So just for fun then, hypothetically speaking of course, if the code SRP one day did just dry up, for whatever reason, and the rank and file code members had to start funding ganks out of pocket. What percentage of code membership would vanish overnight once the free ride was over?
The remaining code members being the individuals for whom the self-mandated crusade to save hisec from carebearism is truly a labour of love.



Not many would leave, TBH. It's considered a good thing to be able to fund your ganking on your own dime. Most people only use the SRP at first to keep ganking. Every ganker I knew bankrolled their own ships, and left the SRP fund for "new guys ganking".



So Code discourages the rank and file from using the srp further increasing the profit for management?


What are you going on about? How is the careful use of a limited SRP a profit for management?

Most gankers - New Order or otherwise - are "independent contractors" who fund their career by either by the careful choosing of targets, or side projects that earn them ISK to keep them in Catalysts. The SRP is used to help new players get into Code enforcement, and perhaps sustain a few of the casual players who just want to blow things up.

The SRP is nice to have and all, but most gankers would keep at it if it disappeared. The absence of it might slow down the number of new players getting into highsec ganking by raising the bar to the profession, but most of those that do it now would keep at their chosen play style. After all, when you realize that ISK is just a means to increase your fun/hour, not a idol to be worshiped and accumulated for its own sake, it isn't hard to scrounge up a dozen fitted Catalysts for an evening's entertainment.
Leto Thule
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#175 - 2014-10-19 18:37:12 UTC
I can't take it anymore.

Q: Who gets the loot from ganking freighters?

A: The pilots who ganked it.

9 motherfucking pages for that?

Thunderdome ringmaster, Community Leader and Lord Inquisitor to the Court of Crime and Punishment

Quinn Hatfield
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#176 - 2014-10-19 18:42:12 UTC
Black Pedro wrote:
Syn Shi wrote:
So Code discourages the rank and file from using the srp further increasing the profit for management?


What are you going on about? How is the careful use of a limited SRP a profit for management?

Most gankers - New Order or otherwise - are "independent contractors" who fund their career by either by the careful choosing of targets, or side projects that earn them ISK to keep them in Catalysts. The SRP is used to help new players get into Code enforcement, and perhaps sustain a few of the casual players who just want to blow things up.

The SRP is nice to have and all, but most gankers would keep at it if it disappeared. The absence of it might slow down the number of new players getting into highsec ganking by raising the bar to the profession, but most of those that do it now would keep at their chosen play style. After all, when you realize that ISK is just a means to increase your fun/hour, not a idol to be worshiped and accumulated for its own sake, it isn't hard to scrounge up a dozen fitted Catalysts for an evening's entertainment.
If it doesn't fit Syn Shi's world view, it is irrelevant, regardless of any truth it may contain.

I don't burn bridges, I merely steal a bolt a day.

Princess Bride
SharkNado
#177 - 2014-10-19 18:44:12 UTC  |  Edited by: Princess Bride
Black Pedro wrote:
Princess Bride wrote:
If James (and possibly other managers) are embezzling a large portion of CODE's profits for their own personal wallets, then in my opinion CODE is a scam.

The question of whether CODE donors and CODE pilots who do not receive a share of the loot "care" about this fact is inconsequential. But in reality, I think many of them would be disillusioned to discover this, regardless of what some of the more dedicated CODE fanboys (or the profiting management) in the forums would say. I think most of them buy into the assumption that the ISK they donate, and the loot they forgo, will be used exclusively for the purpose of buying ships to explode in suicide ganks. If that were to be "not exactly the truth", I doubt they would be so generous.

CODE could very well be a "long con", started with the primary purpose of fattening their personal wallets by siphoning large chunks of the treasury out of the corp wallet under the guise of "far more reimbursements than you would imagine". A CEO doing this would hardly be a novel idea, as it happens all the time in Eve.

Without a full API, there's no transparency. Without transparency, you have the potential for abuse. And considering James' past exploits, I think it's a fair estimation that this is exactly what is happening.

There are plenty of historical examples of hundreds of people happily marching to the tune of a charismatic pied piper, giving him everything they own in exchange for a personal sense of relevance. Especially in a religious context. Just sayin',

While everything you say is true, I'm not sure what your point is. Of course James could abscond with the ISK tomorrow, and yes, such things have happened before but everyone knows this. Also, everyone who has bought New Order shares knows (or should know) about James' past adventures, and sent ISK full-well knowning there is no auditing of the organization. But this doesn't matter. What matters is the community, killboards, and tear-filled forum posts these donations, and the time and effort of James 315 produce. So I think you are wrong - even if proof appears tomorrow that the New Order leadership was skimming something off the top, "investors" would not even bat an eye. As long as Catalyst SRP keeps going out and carebear tears keep rolling in - that is people are having fun - the New Order will keep going strong.

But really, there is no evidence that this is the case. The amount of incoming ISK is regularly posted on minerbumping.com and in the forums here, and the CODE. alliance killboard is publically available showing Code losses. Those numbers show there is little-to-no ISK unaccounted for. But as has been explained multiple times, ISK isn't the major dividend that New Order provides - it is things like this thread that investors are buying - and by that measure a New Order share purchase is probably the best investment opportunity in New Eden right now.


I understand the point you are making. Everyone involved is happy, so why question it. Allow me to use a real-world analogy to explain what I am saying here.

Say for example a popular charity is soliciting funds to "do good" by saving children from starvation in Africa. You listen to their shpeel on TV and decide to send them $5/month on a subscription basis. In the ad, it is clearly implied that your donation would be used to help children, not to make some CEO rich. Later, an investigation is launched and it turns out that 70% of donations actually go to buy the charity's CEO private jets, mansions, etc. etc. even though all of the donors assumed that most of their donation would go toward helping children. Charges are issued against the CEO, claiming he engaged in fraud. During the trial, the CEO makes the following arguments:

1) His charity did, in fact, help many many children in Africa.
2) Until the charges were filed, no one knew about his diversion of funds, and all donors were happy with the arrangement.
3) Donors never expected to get their money back, so nothing was actually stolen.
4) Many donors are still quite happy, because children were helped, and they state loudly their support of the charity and CEO despite the "fraud" being alleged.
5) He never said he wasn't keeping a lot of the money for himself, only that he would help children in Africa, which he did.
6) He never "packed it all up and ran", and instead kept his operation going until interrupted by his arrest.

Of course, he would still be convicted of fraud in such a case, because despite all of his points, the fact that remains that donors were mislead, and his ignoble goal was clearly to make money, not to help people.

So really this boils down to the difference between right and wrong, moral and immoral, legitimate business and scam. The situation is analogous to CODE because most supporters of CODE assume that their donations are used to buy ships used to gank. If it turned out this was not true, it would constitute fraud, and I think most donors indeed would feel cheated, and rightfully so.

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

Veers Belvar
Swordmasters of New Eden
#178 - 2014-10-19 18:46:36 UTC
Leto Thule wrote:
I can't take it anymore.

Q: Who gets the loot from ganking freighters?

A: The pilots who ganked it.

9 motherfucking pages for that?


I agree with you for once, buddy. The money goes to the individual pilots, not to CODE, etc....
Princess Bride
SharkNado
#179 - 2014-10-19 18:53:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Princess Bride
Veers Belvar wrote:
Leto Thule wrote:
I can't take it anymore.

Q: Who gets the loot from ganking freighters?

A: The pilots who ganked it.

9 motherfucking pages for that?


I agree with you for once, buddy. The money goes to the individual pilots, not to CODE, etc....


Um, wow, no.

Quite the opposite in fact. The pilots who gank the freighters do NOT share in the loot. The loot, is NOT shared with the gank pilots but instead, allegedly, goes to make up the deficit between donations and ISK expended reimbursing gank catalysts.

Can you quote even a single person in this thread alleging that CODE gank pilots get a share of the loot? I mean, not counting getting a replacement ~1m gank cat?

http://eveprincessbride.wordpress.com/

Veers Belvar
Swordmasters of New Eden
#180 - 2014-10-19 19:03:45 UTC
Princess Bride wrote:
Veers Belvar wrote:
Leto Thule wrote:
I can't take it anymore.

Q: Who gets the loot from ganking freighters?

A: The pilots who ganked it.

9 motherfucking pages for that?


I agree with you for once, buddy. The money goes to the individual pilots, not to CODE, etc....


Um, wow, no.

Quite the opposite in fact. The pilots who gank the freighters do NOT share in the loot. The loot, is NOT shared with the gank pilots but instead, allegedly, goes to make up the deficit between donations and ISK expended reimbursing gank catalysts.

Can you quote even a single person in this thread alleging that CODE gank pilots get a share of the loot? I mean, not counting getting a replacement ~1m gank cat?


I know the individual pilots - I happen to be something of an expert on this. Whoever grabs the loot gets it, some people choose to invest back in CODE, but that is at their discretion.