These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Burn Huola - A Minmatar POV

Author
Aslon Seridith
Biohazard.
#21 - 2014-07-29 10:34:44 UTC
Nice to read write-up Major Trant, shows some light on minmatar perspective i was wondering about. To that though I have this to add:

WINMATAR. went ballsdeep, with the intent to take a system. We YOLO'd in, with our full weight,
For those who have flown with us know we're all about creating content. This is what we do, and it turned out to be legendary.PiratePirate

Seeing the last minmatar stronghold rise to 65% Has definately put a scar on the minmatar militia.

The fact AVNG leadership collapsed after causing so much attention on public media and then not pulling it's weight is a funny story to say the least. I've read many forum posts about their involvement but in reality all it's leadership did was causing major diplomatic problems within the Amarr / Caldari Militia coordination, on which I facedesked furiously. Coordination was our campaign's reoccurring problem that had it's impact on the push.
For the Amarr I think AVNG's leadership collapse will be for the better, but time will tell.Roll

BurnHuola has pauzed rightnow. Maybe it will restart tomorrow, or next week. Fact is Huola will never feel the same again, as it can be any day Amarr see an opening and launch a full scale assault, YOLO in, bigger & stronger than before.Bear

To that day I look forward, as it may mean I finnaly can undock my tornado from Huola.Lol Unless someone here wants to buy it?

All trolls and drama aside,
Good fights everyone! And may your corporations & alliances rise or fall from the past weeks fighting.

~Aslon Seridith

㋡ it's ASLON SERIDTH? | Minmatar Most Loved #1 | Gave Amarr a Medal | Orchestrator of BurnHuola'14 |

Author of: How to win FW in 3 months | Nullsec Bittervet | www.winmatar.com

Major Trant
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#22 - 2014-07-29 10:59:16 UTC
Aslon Seridith wrote:
Good stuff...

~Aslon Seridith

Props to Biohazard, I have to admit, I did think you would be the weak link, not the one that actually held it all together for so long. o7
Major Trant
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#23 - 2014-07-29 12:25:34 UTC
I agree some great content was created and I look forward to more of the same. With that in mind, can I ask people from all sides of the Burn Huola campaign to sign this thread to enable more of the same:

Content, not Exploit
Master Sergeant MacRobert
Red Sky Morning
The Amarr Militia.
#24 - 2014-07-29 13:00:09 UTC
It is interesting to see how far apart both sides can be even on the impression of situations where both were present to see. Thanks for the read, Major Trant.

From my understanding, a few things you are clearly not aware or chose to omit:

1. The operation, if I am correct, was to begin a month later after some preparations - instead there was a what the hell gung ho!
2. Activity in Amarr forces was acutally in decline amongst some of the players (24eme in particular). RL is just a *****.
3. Being backs against the wall, pushed the MinGall to use any and all resources in order to get the "win".
4. A number of brand new (I think you used the term "power of two") toons in 24th IC were created (most likely by Gall) solely to Awox.
5. There are plenty of "neutrals" in the four farthings (regions) that have alignment due to their isk making alts. I think this was in your favour.
6. Stats, no matter how accurate, do not present the full picture. (This is why killboard stats and participation values add up to so very little of the whole picture).


Many GF's were had and whilst it is accurate the ultimate desire was to flip you out of there (AVNG primary purpose) a lot of us were there simply to get the fun factor and watch explosions.


Look forward to being online again and staring down the barrel of them AC's and Howie's. Big smile



Ninlarra wrote:
I'm in the OPs and alliance and it was TL;DR


This just goes to confirm my opinion of you.

"Remedy this situation or you shall live out the rest of your life in a pain amplifier"

Master Sergeant MacRobert
Red Sky Morning
The Amarr Militia.
#25 - 2014-07-29 13:02:51 UTC  |  Edited by: Master Sergeant MacRobert
Nameira Vanis-Tor wrote:
It was a blast all round, Majors view is pretty accurate perception of the Minmatar as well.


Fixed

"Remedy this situation or you shall live out the rest of your life in a pain amplifier"

Ninlarra
Ninlarra Brand Ships and Modules
#26 - 2014-07-29 13:11:57 UTC
Major Trant wrote:
TL'DR : Did Read, Can't think of a valid Counter. LOOK AT ME!


LOL You're kinda right. I read the first three posts =p
Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#27 - 2014-07-29 13:53:03 UTC
Zarnak Wulf wrote:
1) XG was in system as the POS where being set up. I remember hopping on TS and expressing dismay at the 'Burn Huola' thread. Laughter and 'Spais!' Was the response. Templar kept tabs on Huola local for a week to gauge presence. It was also thought hitting Minmatar in the middle if tier 4 rather then tier 1 (bored and sitting in Huola) would maximize surprise.

2) The whole FW meta has changed. Farmers no longer plex your home system immediately as soon as you leave. Small groups can live in the war zone without 24/7 coverage. ..


As long as they are willing to put alts in and dplex for the time they are not there. I see plenty of vigils defensive plexing ready to warp off if anything comes in all over the warzone. I'm not sure this is so great.

And I liked the huola campaign and took a few days off work to play. But when you have these big battles in a single system it seems like 45% of the time the enemy is outnumbered and won't fight so you sit in the plex alone and the other 45% of the time the reverse. Sure during the 10% of the time when fighting happens you get lots of kills but it's an on or off thing.

If your faction is currently outnumbered there isn't much you can do. Enter a plex and a huge group of enemies will of course push you out. Try to plex a system over and no one is there to fight. Don't get me wrong I enjoyed the Huola campaign and am happy and thankful amarr decided to do the campaign. I had fun, but I also hope faction war doesn't entirely turn into you either are in one single system in the bigger blob or there is no fight to be had.


Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Thanatos Marathon
Moira.
#28 - 2014-07-29 14:02:17 UTC
Cearain wrote:
Zarnak Wulf wrote:
1) XG was in system as the POS where being set up. I remember hopping on TS and expressing dismay at the 'Burn Huola' thread. Laughter and 'Spais!' Was the response. Templar kept tabs on Huola local for a week to gauge presence. It was also thought hitting Minmatar in the middle if tier 4 rather then tier 1 (bored and sitting in Huola) would maximize surprise.

2) The whole FW meta has changed. Farmers no longer plex your home system immediately as soon as you leave. Small groups can live in the war zone without 24/7 coverage. ..


As long as they are willing to put alts in and dplex for the time they are not there. I see plenty of vigils defensive plexing ready to warp off if anything comes in all over the warzone. I'm not sure this is so great.

And I liked the huola campaign and took a few days off work to play. But when you have these big battles in a single system it seems like 45% of the time the enemy is outnumbered and won't fight so you sit in the plex alone and the other 45% of the time the reverse. Sure during the 10% of the time when fighting happens you get lots of kills but it's an on or off thing.

If your faction is currently outnumbered there isn't much you can do. Enter a plex and a huge group of enemies will of course push you out. Try to plex a system over and no one is there to fight. Don't get me wrong I enjoyed the Huola campaign and am happy and thankful amarr decided to do the campaign. I had fun, but I also hope faction war doesn't entirely turn into you either are in one single system in the bigger blob or there is no fight to be had.




Yeah, cuz a smaller group can never defeat a larger group.........
Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#29 - 2014-07-29 14:22:44 UTC
Thanatos Marathon wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Zarnak Wulf wrote:
1) XG was in system as the POS where being set up. I remember hopping on TS and expressing dismay at the 'Burn Huola' thread. Laughter and 'Spais!' Was the response. Templar kept tabs on Huola local for a week to gauge presence. It was also thought hitting Minmatar in the middle if tier 4 rather then tier 1 (bored and sitting in Huola) would maximize surprise.

2) The whole FW meta has changed. Farmers no longer plex your home system immediately as soon as you leave. Small groups can live in the war zone without 24/7 coverage. ..


As long as they are willing to put alts in and dplex for the time they are not there. I see plenty of vigils defensive plexing ready to warp off if anything comes in all over the warzone. I'm not sure this is so great.

And I liked the huola campaign and took a few days off work to play. But when you have these big battles in a single system it seems like 45% of the time the enemy is outnumbered and won't fight so you sit in the plex alone and the other 45% of the time the reverse. Sure during the 10% of the time when fighting happens you get lots of kills but it's an on or off thing.

If your faction is currently outnumbered there isn't much you can do. Enter a plex and a huge group of enemies will of course push you out. Try to plex a system over and no one is there to fight. Don't get me wrong I enjoyed the Huola campaign and am happy and thankful amarr decided to do the campaign. I had fun, but I also hope faction war doesn't entirely turn into you either are in one single system in the bigger blob or there is no fight to be had.




Yeah, cuz a smaller group can never defeat a larger group.........


I didn't say that. But by and large the smaller side might leeroy one or 2 fleets trying and then we would have the wait. At least when I was on, I didn't see gallente/minmatar fighting outnumbered very often and certainly not for very long. Reading the op talk about minmatar winning fights 3,4 and 5 to 1, I am not sure what campaign he is talking about. But I wasn't always there so maybe I missed those fights.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Loryanna
T.T.S.P Solutions
#30 - 2014-07-29 14:44:08 UTC
Colt Blackhawk wrote:
ROFLROFLROFL...

Stalking Mantis wrote quite nice and tried to be objective but that one here... HAHAHAHAHA.
Nothing else than propaganda.

Summary about Arzad:
Minnies had 3 times the numbers first few weeks and were defending well. When they had to face even numbers they ran away.
Plain and simple.
Your science fiction fantasy stuff is funny.


Such obvious heavy handed lies aren't actually very clever. They are easily refuted by the cold hard facts found on killboards or by the reports of people on your own side. Check out FHP and I talking about Arzad in the infamous Burn Huola thread, somewhere in the mid-20s, for something nearer the truth. A lie this blatant cannot stand. Try going somewhere even vaguely near reality for your psych-ops to have any value, mate.

If you actually believe what you said and you were in the Arzad Campaign I strongly suggest seeking medical attention because your brain has malfunctioned spectacularly.
Major Trant
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#31 - 2014-07-29 15:23:15 UTC
I have received complaints that my OP is biased towards the Minmatar POV. I do apologise if this is the case. People who know me will tell you that I always try to give a fair and balanced view.

Thus in the interests of correcting any balance issues I offer you this link:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGoukavPXww

I would request that the Amarr stop complaining. Please try to remember that you opened this can of worms.

Now... please bend over, the Minmatar haven't finished shoving.
Rahelis
Doomheim
#32 - 2014-07-29 16:43:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Rahelis
Every POV is biased - so I respect MTs tale of the burn houla campaign. MTs story adds content to EVE - and that is what faction warfare is about. Every man has to stand for his own opinion.

Some facts from an insider:

-The campaign started one month before schedule. After the inital command meeting (I attended on TS) the attack was begun with a the mere prep time of 24 hours.

-We sold nearly all our stuff and mobilzed the corp (AVNG) with about 4-6 active pilots. Compare this to Unternehmen Barbarossa - that attack was stalled six weeks, so the assault forces had to fight an an early beginning winter. I want to point out that a rush is not optimal when timing is of the essence. So Barbarossa failed - with advance troops in the suburbs of the emeny capital. The same happend in burn huola.


-The amarr miltia - mostly Biohazard and AVNG attacked and fought against the full weight of the scrambling minmatar milita, a gal expedition force (big respect for your gals effort on field and in command) and local pirate entities- PL etc. Big respect to Biohazard -they really bled with us.


-Neutrals helped us - Misty in the first place. Most neutrals fought us.


Who ever dared and did that in FW? - Nobody.


-This all out assault was done only because of one reason: Boredom about the dead warzone. Some of our pilots had no fun playing EVE any more and wanted to do one last thing before quitting the game.


-The attack force did break from the inside - some agreements that were made at the command meeting were not met. Many allies did not show - due to the rush and some unneccesary diplomatic incidents. Some "allies" even avoxed the amarr milita.

-Many facts that AVNG command pointed out to their allies where not recieved - until the **** started flying. So many allies learned how to wage faction war at the front - even a known mercanary commander had to learn on the fly how to take plexes.

The SS did refresh at the front - our ppl did not met this harsh standarts that some in the attack force where used to.

This was quite the same situation that Napoleon had at Waterloo - he won the field against the English - but the Rhine froze over and a Prussian force decided that biggest battle of that time. At Austerliz Napoleon won the same battle - so war is often decided by chance.


Nevertheless - Burn Huola was the biggest fun I had in Eve since the Bos campaign.

I would engage in an offensive like this any time again - I burned some 4 bil in about 100 hours fighting and made 400-500 kms.

Exact numbers are hard to tell.

The funny thing - even in a game like EVE "history" is distorted and bent, so any historian has a hell of a job even to get a glimpse about what happend.


As I posted before: 07 to all who fought in the burn huola campaign!

This is how EVE faction war should be!!!
Zen Guerrilla
CTRL-Q
Ushra'Khan
#33 - 2014-07-29 17:34:57 UTC
Rahelis wrote:
-We sold nearly all our stuff and mobilzed the corp (AVNG) with about 4-6 active pilots. Compare this to Unternehmen Barbarossa - that attack was stalled six weeks, so the assault forces had to fight an an early beginning winter. I want to point out that a rush is not optimal when timing is of the essence. So Barbarossa failed - with advance troops in the suburbs of the emeny capital. The same happend in burn huola.
You're really comparing your advance with Hitlers invasion of russia?

I know you're a lunatic plus you're playing a spacerace of religious slaver zealots but you might want to rethink that analogy. Because you're Hitler in it.

Lol

pew pew

Rahelis
Doomheim
#34 - 2014-07-29 18:05:19 UTC
Zen - that is military history.

England refered to Napoleon simply as "the monster" in the times of the napoleonic wars. That was propaganda. Napoleon may threw europe into an unequalled war at his time - but he also was the man that broke many ppl form the old yokes. German law to this day has many remnants of napoleonic laws, called "code civil".

I know you are german - the Unternehmen Barbarossa took place and it was the biggest assault in known history.

It failed - barely - I know, in Germany ppl do not talk and think much about recent history (I live in Germany).

In England ppl think otherwise, and military history is part of daily life.

Also nive style to insult me for posting here - I did not create the Amarr as content - blame CCP for that - start thinking.


If you pod someone in EVE you simulate the act of killing - this is a war game, after all.


The huola campaign was content is EVE - in a war game - faction war is a game of war.

If you do not like that - start mining, bro.
Christine Peeveepeeski
Low Sec Concepts
#35 - 2014-07-29 18:05:42 UTC
from a tactics perspective why would you not recall those used by the nazi's? There morale and ethical reasoning was ****** up no doubt but their military strategy is worth learning from if you are into that kind fo thing.

Oh but wait, space Nazi makes better trolling :)
Rahelis
Doomheim
#36 - 2014-07-29 18:21:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Rahelis
Shelling ppl is never humane - does not matter who shelles whom - war is a crime in itself. War is barbaric - at all times.

Neither dropping bombs on ppl is humane - there is no excuse for that.

We here are lucky to wage pixel war - where only pixels die.

Noone of the internet though guys dies here - and I am glad about it.

Today I ratted in a SFI and some pirates dropped 2 cloaky legions, a sin and a sleipnir on me - I had a good laugh - this is a game.

Rommel telegraphed to Montgomery that he would fight him in his best tank with the best tank crew - in his own best tank and his best tank crew - to decide the campaign, but that their respective leadership would not approve.

Wake up, mate.


I am not happy with the Amarr content CCP made. I do not like racism - in any form.


As I started to play I asked the guy that brought me to EVE: "Which race has the weakest ships?"

Back in march 2010 he answered without thinking twice: "Amarr."

So I joined Amarr.
Merely Runaway
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#37 - 2014-07-29 19:44:58 UTC
I'm calling Godwin's Law on this entire thread.

The Amarr mentioned Nazis first so I guess that means that we, the Minmatar, won the forum war/psy-ops or whatever nonsense you clever military types want to call poasting on a forum.

gg
Colt Blackhawk
Doomheim
#38 - 2014-07-29 20:45:30 UTC
Loryanna wrote:
Colt Blackhawk wrote:
ROFLROFLROFL...

Stalking Mantis wrote quite nice and tried to be objective but that one here... HAHAHAHAHA.
Nothing else than propaganda.

Summary about Arzad:
Minnies had 3 times the numbers first few weeks and were defending well. When they had to face even numbers they ran away.
Plain and simple.
Your science fiction fantasy stuff is funny.


Such obvious heavy handed lies aren't actually very clever. They are easily refuted by the cold hard facts found on killboards or by the reports of people on your own side. Check out FHP and I talking about Arzad in the infamous Burn Huola thread, somewhere in the mid-20s, for something nearer the truth. A lie this blatant cannot stand. Try going somewhere even vaguely near reality for your psych-ops to have any value, mate.

If you actually believe what you said and you were in the Arzad Campaign I strongly suggest seeking medical attention because your brain has malfunctioned spectacularly.


Omg...
Grow up, finish college, get certain level and we may discuss.

[09:04:53] Ashira Twilight > Plant the f****** amarr flag and s*** on their smoking wrecks.

Destru Kaneda
Arzad Police Department
#39 - 2014-07-29 21:41:42 UTC
So, are you gonna share those drugs with the rest of the class or?
Anslo
Scope Works
#40 - 2014-07-30 02:31:47 UTC
A shout out to my bros in the various pirate alliances that either came to Huola or ran large/small scale interference. I owe you the beer and cigs i promised haha. This event started out fun and I did enjoy it. However, there was a point where the Amarr just really rubbed I and others of the Pirate Coalition very very wrong. It wasn't just one thing, but a combination.

In the end, we have more fun with the Minmatar. They chilled out since we've moved in and Huola has become a pretty cool place that let's us do our thing to help newbros and carebears get into lowsec. The way the Amarr conducted themselves led us to believe they'd end the cool little set up we'd made.

We didnt like that.

If you wanna come fight, come fight. Pew pew is always happy fun times.

But don't ever try this bullshit again. Ever.

[center]-_For the Proveldtariat_/-[/center]