These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

[Rubicon 1.3] New way of acquiring the Astero, Stratios and Nestor

First post First post
Author
Sgt Ocker
What Corp is it
#321 - 2014-03-31 03:00:39 UTC
Arthur Aihaken wrote:
Sgt Ocker wrote:
You honestly don't think a combat capable Logistics Battleship that has refit service and can jump with blops would not find a role?

I'll break it down in point form...

• Fleet hangar and fitting service is fine, but you can't exclude high-sec... so no.
• Black Ops cloak bonus is unique to Black Ops... so no.
• Covert Jump Portal Use... definitely no.
• Slot reassignment, this deviates from the other SoE ships... so no.
• 50% armor repair activation cost, definitely too powerful... no, no and no.

The Nestor should be geared towards wormhole space. It would make much more sense to configure it as follows:

New Attributes:
• Fleet Hangar Capacity: 5,000 m3
• Maximum Jump Clones = 1
• Fuel Bay Capacity 500 m3
Note: There is no hangar maintenance bay and the fleet hangar is only large enough to accommodate one SoE shuttle - which is prominently featured on the underside of the Nestor (the idea here is to allow for a single jump clone to accommodate an alt or team mate, not to replace the Rorqual and not make it overly powerful).

Role Bonuses:
• 90% reduction in Clone Vat Bay powergrid requirement (replaces laser bonuses)
• 50% bonus to Remote Armor Repairer and Remote Shield Boost amount
• 200% bonus to Remote Armor Repairer and Remote Shield Boost range
• Can fit Covert Ops Cloaking Device (no reactivation delay reduction)

New additions:
• SoE Shuttle

Blops jump capability is unique to Black Ops, Covert Ops (including T3's) and Recons so by that logic Stratios should not be able to jump either. Covert Cloak was recon, covert ops specific until stratios and astero, so saying blops cloak bonus is unique to Black ops is saying Stratios and Astero should not have covert cloak.
There is no reason SOE could not have obtained the tech to put Blops cloak capability on to the Nestor. They did obtain the covert cloak tech for Stratios and Astero.

Can't have assembled ships in fleet hanger so it would need to be Ship maintenance array (no biggy) although I can't see the plus with having a shuttle you can jump to in a wh. It is of absolutely no use except to leave an already scanned down exit and if your going to do that, why not just reship in your pos? And where does the clone you are jumping from go?
Unless they change jump cloning so you can jump to a WH from known space, the clone vat bay is somewhat wasted.

The Dual Repair bonuses - yes, I didn't add shield bonuses to my suggestion as it is meant to be an armor boat along the lines of the Oneiros. Giving it shield reps would be good.

The 50% reduction in Activation cost is not really needed, 1 heavy cap booster and you can perma run 3 large armor reppers for 5 mins 50 secs. The cap reduction was to help it be "good" at its logistic role.
200% range bonus gives you 25.2k, ok in a small fleet as long as everyone is close together. 60k range you have a chance to rep your fast moving tackle, 25k range = dead tackle.

CCP has no intention of doing anything to the Nestor to help it fit player ideas of useful.

The best thing that could happen to the Nestor right now - Remove it from game so at least the collectors who have purchased them have a valuable asset. It could become the new Guardian-Vexor.


My opinions are mine.

  If you don't like them or disagree with me that's OK.- - - - - - Just don't bother Hating - I don't care

It really is getting harder and harder to justify $23 a month for each sub.

Arthur Aihaken
CODE.d
#322 - 2014-03-31 03:26:32 UTC  |  Edited by: Arthur Aihaken
Sgt Ocker wrote:
CCP has no intention of doing anything to the Nestor to help it fit player ideas of useful.

I think this sums up all discussions with the Nestor to-date. Realistically, I think the chances of a Covert Ops cloak are less than zero. The Rorqual just got nerfed, so I don't see a Clone Vat Bay in the Nestor's future either. I think if the Nestor is going to be the only Pirate logistics, I think it should be dual armor-shield. I don't that drags it completely out of the abyss, but it's a start.

But here's my original suggestion for the Nestor: Turn that funky SoE rescue shuttle into a feature, by allowing you to leave the Nestor in the shuttle while the Nestor automatically cloaks behind you. This doesn't require a separate cloak module, and only activates when you travel 2000m from the ship. This means you'll need to bookmark it to find your way back, and it also means someone else can inadvertently stumble across the Nestor. What's unique about the SoE shuttle? It features an integrated Covert Ops cloaking device for exploration. You can park the Nestor at the entrance of a wormhole (or gate) and take the shuttle through to scout ahead, then return to the Nestor when it's safe to proceed. Voila.

I am currently away, traveling through time and will be returning last week.

Forlorn Wongraven
Habitual Euthanasia
Pandemic Legion
#323 - 2014-03-31 15:03:41 UTC
After 40 sentient spawns I just gave up farming for the nexus chips. Zero dropped, while I earned about 3 bil ISK bounties. That's not how you make any SoE ships going down in prices, especially since all other SoE LP items increased their value due to implementation of the ships.

Winner ATXI , 3rd place ATXII, winner ATXIII, 2nd ATXIV - follow me on twitter: @ForlornW

Super Nintendo SegaGenesis
Kramer-Seinfield Inc.
#324 - 2014-03-31 17:26:42 UTC
Forlorn Wongraven wrote:
After 40 sentient spawns I just gave up farming for the nexus chips. Zero dropped, while I earned about 3 bil ISK bounties. That's not how you make any SoE ships going down in prices, especially since all other SoE LP items increased their value due to implementation of the ships.

+1, after 100+ sentient BS spawns, i've got 0 (ZERO ! ) chip drops ... What the hell , did they forgot to put them in the game ???
Mr Doctor
Star Nation
Goonswarm Federation
#325 - 2014-03-31 18:36:48 UTC
I've never had a Nightmare drop having killed litterally thousands of True BS over the years... so whats your point? Faction BS drops are rare as sparkly dogsheet.
Forlorn Wongraven
Habitual Euthanasia
Pandemic Legion
#326 - 2014-03-31 19:05:08 UTC
Mr Doctor wrote:
I've never had a Nightmare drop having killed litterally thousands of True BS over the years... so whats your point? Faction BS drops are rare as sparkly dogsheet.

IDK, i had like 50 or so of Nightmare BPC. The thing is that drones have no other faction stuff that drops from the sentients, while that is not true of ANY other faction.

Winner ATXI , 3rd place ATXII, winner ATXIII, 2nd ATXIV - follow me on twitter: @ForlornW

Mr Doctor
Star Nation
Goonswarm Federation
#327 - 2014-04-01 00:30:35 UTC
Thats not going to change the diceroll for a billion+ BS drop. I take it theres no commander drone at the end of plexes with a chance? Every faction BS BPC Ive had is from DEDs because those spawns are fairly consistent as maybe a 30% chance of drop.
Sgt Ocker
What Corp is it
#328 - 2014-04-01 01:24:53 UTC
Mr Doctor wrote:
Thats not going to change the diceroll for a billion+ BS drop. I take it theres no commander drone at the end of plexes with a chance? Every faction BS BPC Ive had is from DEDs because those spawns are fairly consistent as maybe a 30% chance of drop.

I thought the idea of the chips was to bring the price down by making it more available.
Maybe i got it wrong, I thought ccp had realized the ship isn't worth a billion + which is why the chips were brought in.

If the drop rate is so low people have already started to give up looking -

Maybe like everything else with the Nestor, CCP just got it wrong..

Quote:
Arthur Aihaken
But here's my original suggestion for the Nestor:

While this would be a very unique thing, I agree it is only a start. The Nestor needs to be able to do 1 thing well to get it out of peoples hangers and right now it just does not do that.
If it is to be a true logistics battleship, give it the right bonuses to reflect this, armor only and 25k range is not going to win it fans.
If it doesn't have fans, it doesn't get used.
It needs a cloak, whether it be a normal cloak with Blops bonuses or a covert cloak, it needs a cloak. So it fits with other SOE ships, so it is able to be used.

Right now my Geddon is more versatile than a Nestor could be (at 1/10th the cost)

My opinions are mine.

  If you don't like them or disagree with me that's OK.- - - - - - Just don't bother Hating - I don't care

It really is getting harder and harder to justify $23 a month for each sub.

Arthur Aihaken
CODE.d
#329 - 2014-04-01 01:54:53 UTC
Sgt Ocker wrote:
The Nestor needs to be able to do 1 thing well to get it out of peoples hangers and right now it just does not do that.

I couldn't agree more - the Nestor doesn't do anything well. The Astero is a great scout/tackle, the Stratios excels in a combat/dual-propulsion role and the Nestor… excels at sitting in the hangar. The cold-hearted reality is that the Nestor isn't going to receive a Covert Ops cloak (or even Black Ops) bonus, a buff to its power grid or an improvement to speed and agility. It's highly unlikely it would be enhanced with a dual shield-armor logistics role, and it's definitely not going to get any additional laser bonuses.

I am currently away, traveling through time and will be returning last week.

Arthur Aihaken
CODE.d
#330 - 2014-04-01 03:23:45 UTC  |  Edited by: Arthur Aihaken
I just came up with a brilliant idea for the Nestor, and it actually fits perfectly with the SoE lore. This is my take on doing "one thing well"… The Nestor has its attributes modified as follows:

• Signature Radius: 320m (from 465m)
• Inertia Modifier: 0.06x (from 0.18x)

The Nestor's role bonus is revised as follows (losing logistics capability and laser bonuses):

Role Bonus
• 10+ bonus to Relic and Data Analyzer virus strength
• 37.5% bonus to Core and Combat Scanner Probe strength
• Can fit SoE Cloaking Device and SoE Covert Scanner

This introduces two new SoE-exclusive modules, available only in the SoE LP store (for an as yet to be determined cost). Both are active, high-slot modules - and while both can be installed - they cannot be operated simultaneously (mutually exclusive):

• SoE Covert Scanner (+100% scan resolution, -50% targeting range installed; stacking penalized). When active, this will automatically detect all wormholes and covert cynosural fields within normal or wormhole space and any cloaked ships within 20km. Cloaked ships do not appear on D-Scan and only appear on the Overview as a flashing "unknown" entry (unknown range, velocity, name and type).
• SoE Cloaking Device (-50% maximum velocity modifier, 10s reactivation delay; -0% scan resolution bonus installed). This operates as a standard cloaking device with one exception: it is undetectable by a SoE Covert Scanner.

So while it's not fast, it's extremely agile - which means it can take advantage of Hyperspacial and Polycarbon rigs to give it a very fast warp speed and align time. It also has a smaller signature radius, making it much harder to scan down when EECM fit. And it becomes a predator - effectively able to actively hunt down covert incursions and potential threats (cloaked or otherwise).

I am currently away, traveling through time and will be returning last week.

Super Nintendo SegaGenesis
Kramer-Seinfield Inc.
#331 - 2014-04-01 05:58:12 UTC
Mr Doctor wrote:
I've never had a Nightmare drop having killed litterally thousands of True BS over the years... so whats your point? Faction BS drops are rare as sparkly dogsheet.

Hmm its bad luck i guess, back in Fountain i was getting Vindicator bpc's, or if not bpc at least some faction items for like 100m+ ... With the drones there is no faction items that drops, only the chip but no one have seen them .... Roll Thats why we were thinking that the chip drop rate will be better, because its the only valuable thing that they drop ...
Forlorn Wongraven
Habitual Euthanasia
Pandemic Legion
#332 - 2014-04-01 07:11:35 UTC
Mr Doctor wrote:
Thats not going to change the diceroll for a billion+ BS drop. I take it theres no commander drone at the end of plexes with a chance? Every faction BS BPC Ive had is from DEDs because those spawns are fairly consistent as maybe a 30% chance of drop.

Nope.

Winner ATXI , 3rd place ATXII, winner ATXIII, 2nd ATXIV - follow me on twitter: @ForlornW

epicurus ataraxia
Illusion of Solitude.
Illusion of Solitude
#333 - 2014-04-04 19:49:10 UTC  |  Edited by: epicurus ataraxia
Arthur Aihaken wrote:
I just came up with a brilliant idea for the Nestor, and it actually fits perfectly with the SoE lore. This is my take on doing "one thing well"… The Nestor has its attributes modified as follows:

• Signature Radius: 320m (from 465m)
• Inertia Modifier: 0.06x (from 0.18x)

The Nestor's role bonus is revised as follows (losing logistics capability and laser bonuses):

Role Bonus
• 10+ bonus to Relic and Data Analyzer virus strength
• 37.5% bonus to Core and Combat Scanner Probe strength
• Can fit SoE Cloaking Device and SoE Covert Scanner

This introduces two new SoE-exclusive modules, available only in the SoE LP store (for an as yet to be determined cost). Both are active, high-slot modules - and while both can be installed - they cannot be operated simultaneously (mutually exclusive):

• SoE Covert Scanner (+100% scan resolution, -50% targeting range installed; stacking penalized). When active, this will automatically detect all wormholes and covert cynosural fields within normal or wormhole space and any cloaked ships within 20km. Cloaked ships do not appear on D-Scan and only appear on the Overview as a flashing "unknown" entry (unknown range, velocity, name and type).
• SoE Cloaking Device (-50% maximum velocity modifier, 10s reactivation delay; -0% scan resolution bonus installed). This operates as a standard cloaking device with one exception: it is undetectable by a SoE Covert Scanner.

So while it's not fast, it's extremely agile - which means it can take advantage of Hyperspacial and Polycarbon rigs to give it a very fast warp speed and align time. It also has a smaller signature radius, making it much harder to scan down when EECM fit. And it becomes a predator - effectively able to actively hunt down covert incursions and potential threats (cloaked or otherwise).


Not sure if I like this at all, just so i understand, you are suggesting it shows that there are cloaked ships within 20km but not where? Trying to see how that would be advantageous? Space is big. And i hate the idea if cloaky ships being somehow visible.
Insta scanning of wormhole sigs is nice and convenient but not really hard now as it is. More agile? Yes sure, would be nice.

I really like some of your other ideas in your other posts, lots of good suggestions there.

but we still have the elephant in the room. (White)

As discussed hundreds of times, Without the ability to warp cloaked the nestor has no place in wormhole space outside of it's home system.
And then the only advantage of the nestor, it's low mass is irrelevant.

It really is looking as if this is a ship to bury at the back of the hanger and forget. Shame.

It has happened before, and it will happen again.

There is one EvE. Many people. Many lifestyles. WE are EvE

Sgt Ocker
What Corp is it
#334 - 2014-04-05 03:19:36 UTC
All the Nestor has done is fulfilled what CCP promised - an SOE battleship.

Unfortunately they never said it would be useful.

With a choice between an orange or a lemon, most would pick the orange.
CCP decided we should have a lemon.

My opinions are mine.

  If you don't like them or disagree with me that's OK.- - - - - - Just don't bother Hating - I don't care

It really is getting harder and harder to justify $23 a month for each sub.

Arthur Aihaken
CODE.d
#335 - 2014-04-05 03:21:34 UTC
No longer a sticky, so I guess the Nestor is fixed in stone...

I am currently away, traveling through time and will be returning last week.

epicurus ataraxia
Illusion of Solitude.
Illusion of Solitude
#336 - 2014-04-05 08:11:50 UTC  |  Edited by: epicurus ataraxia
But hardly a monument.......... More a monumental waste.

CCP can sometimes make brilliant decisions, in other cases not so much, I am guessing that this was designed long long ago, and they needed to update things to take account of the overall change in ships since then, but were cautious of being controversial.

Well they certainly didn't introduce any controversy,

They say an elephant is a mouse designed by committee,
The nestor seems to suffer from the same thought processes.

Break out of the rut on this CCP,

Decide where it is meant to be used and design accordingly.
It just doesn't work designing on the basis of "we have this ship what can we bolt on to it? " , to make it somewhat wanted.
Rip up the spec and start again, think what it should do and give it the fittings, cpu, grid, cap and shield recharge and bonuses to make it actually do that job and the following too!

The low mass indicates it is for wormhole space, but without warping cloaked it will never work or be wanted there.
Do they really have so little understanding of WH space that this is not screamingly obvious?


By all means, don't give it a covert ops cloak with all the additional bonuses to speed of travel while cloaked, just let it fit a standard cloak with the sisters special ability, the ability to warp cloaked. 15 seconds reactivation delay is fine, if it remains a logistics ship locking and sensor strength to match it's role.

But if not Wormholes, where do you want it's role to be?

One might get away with this design method with a frigate or cruiser, but with an aspirational ship costing hundreds of millions if not billions, a player would need to be absurdly profligate to consider it for more than a few seconds in it's current iteration.

Apart from market PvP are they actually selling any??
There are probably so few it would not be too disruptive just to pull it and relaunch it in it's new form, as in primera / noctis.

There is one EvE. Many people. Many lifestyles. WE are EvE

Sgt Ocker
What Corp is it
#337 - 2014-05-10 10:34:34 UTC
Rattlesnake has an attribute that no other ship does or is every likely to have.

Rattlesnake Special Ability;

Distract everyone from the, meh not quite right yet - Nestor

Still sitting at around 1.5 bil with a moving average of 1 a day.

It may just be me but I don't see this ship as a resounding success.


Any word on the Nestor's future ??
Does it in fact have 1?

My opinions are mine.

  If you don't like them or disagree with me that's OK.- - - - - - Just don't bother Hating - I don't care

It really is getting harder and harder to justify $23 a month for each sub.