EVE General Discussion

As far as EWAR, I doubt our simple systems could really take them down. Our stuff is designed to fight amongst ourselves and we really have no idea if it would even work on a Starfleet ship. I'm guessing not. The computer systems they had were/are pretty damn advanced. We still operate on tFLOPS.

Standard "deflector" shields can protect them from lasers at a minimum so the Amarr are out from the start. Same with any of our weapons that rely on actual warheads and/or some kind of shot to penetrate and I am left to conclude that their shields would hold up just fine to that. They seem most susceptible to advanced forms of energy weapons and by comparison ours are rather mundane really.

EVE has the superior inertia stabilizers. Bump the Enterprise with a frigate and everybody on board gets smeared over the bulkheads..

I'll chime in as a Star Trek Fan. I'll also try to level the playing field while using equivalencies between the two universes. I'm not going to cover every aspect, but just the basics to help everyone envision how a battle may play out. I'm also sticking with Canon based information, and will limit this post to their defensive and offensive system, as we already discussed their mobility.

Star Terk ships are mainly shield fit, with the exception of Defiant Class, which can be argued is an armor tank due to it's Ablative Armor

Star Trek Ships have better shield system that, among many abilities, are split between six zones (forward, aft, starboard, port, dorsal & ventral). These zones absorb damage independently. As one zone becomes depleted, the shields can be modulated (rotated) and distributed evenly throughout system.

Let's not even begin to discuss the absurdly powerful and flexible use of them being able to reverse and adjust their ship's Shield Polarity .The shielding system furthermore extends throughout the hull structure in the form of a Structural Integrity Field

So long as a Star Trek vessel maintains its shield, it is immensely powerful and able to counter any, if not all of Eve's ewar capabilities.

Let's move on to their weapon systems. To keep this short, I'll stick to the Federation.

First, the Phaser. The Phaser is the primary racial weapon for the Federation. The Starship mounted Phaser banks file a steady stream of energy, which can be modulated for either pinpoint penetration or as beams that fire bolts of explosive energy. The Phaser banks can also be designed to fire bolts of energy in very rapid succession, called the Phaser Cannon. I was not able to find Canon related information pertaining to engagement ranges/tracking abilities. However, going by a similar discussion raised on another site, based upon engagements, within the shows, we can assume Engagement ranges between 100-150KM.

Next, lets move on to the missle based systems. Star Trek uses the Torpedo as their secondary weapon system. The varied types of Torpedoes used is dependent upon the nature of the engagement. All ships are equipped with the basic Photon Torpedo. Larger line ships and Defiant class ship may be equipped with the more advanced and harder hitting Quantum Torpedo. FInally, The granddaddy of them all is the Transphasic Torpedo. Meant to one shot Borg Cubes, Which can be argued are equivalent if side to Eve's Capital/Super Capital Class Ships.

Finally, How would an engagement play out between a Federation Fleet and an Eve Fleet? To play to their the Federal would engage at a distance, in a traditional fleet line. They would attempt to force the Eve fleet to burn in while unleashing phaser fire to cut through the Eve fleet's shields. Once they removed the shields, they would switch to Torpedo fire, both targeted and AOE to disrupt the Blop. The Eve Fleet would in-turn escalate to capitals and super capitals, forcing to Federation fleet to switch to Anti-Borg engagement tactics and weaponry. I think both fleets would be evenly matched and it would be a site to behold. I would give the edge to the Federaltion based upon technological advancement and since it appears their phasers can track shuttles in a fight. Ultimately, I think both sides would sustain massive losses and be forced to withdraw.

Didn't read.
hmmm which fantasy world ships are da strongest?

It will end with Warhammer 40k.

Exterminatus biatch! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h67JpMyrOVE For the EMPRAH!.

star trek whould loose badly, mainly because.
once a trek ship is destroyed, they are gone, for goods.
well that not the case with eve, we just refit then go back to the fray

some may say, they can fight while in warp speed BUT, they have to drop out of warp to fight a eve camp.
or if they dont, the bubble will.
ther shield are verry vulnerable to tachyon weapons.
kinetic weapons will mostly knout out ther crew to sick bay
ther shield and weapons aren't regenerate fast enought.

just imagine 5 milions infinite suicide gank ship can do vs 2000 trek ships

eve is a dark age of space
its just too evil for the punny federation.

actually this is how a battle would go:

1. war is declared.
2. EvE spy disbands starfleet
3. Profit???

forget to add

it is estimated that Federation in Star Trek have around seventh thousand, however would need time to gather all ships in prepare for war

while New Eden probably have capable to pump this much in 1 day.

source:
http://www.ditl.org/pagarticle.php?ArticleID=14&ListID=Articles

Dont they forever have issues with tachyon things? I also know they hate antimatter weapons and they also use torps.

Also we have several thousand years more advanced tech than they do.

ooo ooo did someone say cross-universe ship sizes? :3 :3 :3

http://www.modenstudios.com/EVE/eve-shipsize.jpg
http://www.modenstudios.com/EVE/deathstar_size.jpg

Dont forget the other much more powerful gods they have.

Plot devices.