These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Missing Scientists Spark Ethics Debate

Author
Mira Ming Wei
Transhumanity Today
#1 - 2014-02-14 11:18:27 UTC
Missing Scientists Spark Ethics Debate

14.02.YC116

Indigo City, Apophenia-Renaissance Lagrange — Two astrophysicists are missing today in Indigo City. Classified police reports leaked to Transhumanity Today indicate that the young scientists went missing early in the day on January 20th; however, the administration and the families of the pair chose to keep the investigation a secret, citing public alarm and lack of information. But now, with almost a month passed since the two have gone missing, the families have decided to go public in attempt to locate their loved ones.

Arkady Julan (female, 24, Jin-Mei, black hair, green eyes) and Kyobi Maelrend (male, 23, Sebiestor, brown hair, brown eyes) both went missing from Indigo City on the morning of January 20th. They were last seen together via CCHV after leaving their respective housing ships, en route for their day jobs as interns under the prestigious Dr. Amota Khitari. Dr. Khitari was the first to report the pair missing, after they failed to report for their shift, expecting the pair had decided to elope. “They were always goggling each other” the doctor was reported having said.

When it was determined that the young couple was not at either of their homes, a manhunt was begun. While the administration is keeping a tight lid on their internal investigation procedures, several witnesses report seeing a DUST mercenary aboard Indigo City, acting in the role of an official investigator.

With nearly a month having gone by with no sign of the pair and little evidence, prospects of their being found appear bleak. While both Julan and Maelrend have clone backups, a fierce debate has started over the ethical ramifications of re-lifing the pair, without evidence of their deaths.

"Imagine coming home from a long trip, and finding someone else was now living your life." Says cloning services manager Mikai Heliokanen. "If no foul play is involved, and they did just elope, it puts us in a very bad position if we re-life them now."

Julan’s mother however, is not convinced. “Arkady loved her work, and her family. She would always come home so full of energy, bursting to talk about her day.” Said Melisandra Julan from the kitchen of her home aboard Indigo City. “I just know something’s happened to her, I just know it. She wouldn’t run off like this. It isn’t who she is.”

The administration has as of yet, failed to provide comment on either side, beyond stating that an ongoing investigation is not a matter of public discourse.

If you see either of this pair, it is requested that you report it immediately to the Origin Department of Investigations. I’m Mira Ming Wei, and you’re reading Transhumanity Today.
Dreygun
Alexylva Paradox
#2 - 2014-02-14 14:26:40 UTC
I don't recall either of the two missing personally, but I am sure I have seen them working in the lab. Dr. Khitari is a colleague and friend. I have visited him on several occasions in his lab. I will have to pass along condolences I know he cared deeply for all his staff.

The moral issue here is certainly a biting one. I know the family believes they know the missing well enough to be sure they would not abandon their family and jobs, but the risk of activating a clone without certainty that their previous clones have passed, is significant. I know the family wants their loved ones back, but it is not their call. The clones are activated on death. It is and can only be the choice of the clone owner to activate their clone which is accomplished thru their death and brain scan.
Katrina Oniseki
Oniseki-Raata Internal Watch
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#3 - 2014-02-14 15:52:10 UTC
You look an awful lot like the vague description of this missing Jin Mei, Mira.

Katrina Oniseki

Jandice Ymladris
Aurora Arcology
#4 - 2014-02-14 16:56:57 UTC  |  Edited by: Jandice Ymladris
As clones are activated on death, there is indeed the risk this duo is still alive. Either they choose to run, for whatever reason, or they got taken by a band of criminals as hostage/prisoner. In both cases they are still alive and would not warrant a reactivation of their clone.
In case of their deaths somehow not being registrated and thereby the backup clone failed to activate, it would indeed be unfortunate. But technology is not infallaible.

Consider this: if you activate these clones, it also means you stop any form of searches & investigations for these people. Effectivly giving slavers of various kinds to go & raid your settlement, knowing they'll give up searches for people afetr a time & reactivate their clones.
Note: speaking of the more *abduct on order* slavers, not the *I raid the whole settlement* ones.

Or an alternative scenario, it gives criminals of various forms reason to abduct people with impunity & keep them imprisoned & alive for various malicious reasons.

So to me, an activation of the clone withotu confirmed death will only make matters worse for the whole of the community in the future. Also if you activate it for them, where do you draw the line? When do you say *sorry we can't do this for your lost relative because it isn't suspicious enough*

Providing a new home for refugees in the Aurora Arcology

Fredfredbug4
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#5 - 2014-02-14 22:32:39 UTC
Are these two scientist capsuleers? If so, then their deaths *should* have activated the clones already (assuming they were in their pods). In which case, they are very much alive. If they aren't capsuleers, then I suppose any outcome is possible.

I would advise against activating their clones. Especially only after a month of searching. Some people are found, either dead or alive, years after their disappearance. To activate their clones after only a month would be hasty, reckless, and just plain careless. If they are pronounced dead, then and only then should their clones be activated.

Let's look at it from both perspectives. If you were the family of the two missing, wouldn't you do anything in your power to bring your loved ones back? Now if you were one of the missing, wouldn't it be devastating to come home and find that someone has stolen your life? Would it even be worth coming home at all?

As hard as it must be for everyone involved, I strongly urge authorities to wait this out and restrain their desire to activate the missing's clones.

Watch_ Fred Fred Frederation_ and stop [u]cryptozoologist[/u]! Fight against the brutal genocide of fictional creatures across New Eden! Is that a metaphor? Probably not, but the fru-fru- people will sure love it!

Valerie Valate
Church of The Crimson Saviour
#6 - 2014-02-15 10:14:23 UTC
I'm sure the authorities have it well in hand.

After all, with the two having a clone backup, then it would be a trivial matter to construct a couple of false bodies and plant them somewhere to be found.

And then, as the Gallente say "et voila!", lo and behold, "the bodies of the missing scientists have been found, and their clone backups can be safely activated".

Then the only loose end is to shoot the real ones as being impostors, in the event they aren't actually dead, and turn up later.

Would be convenient. Stops people trying to escape the system, should they have a disagreement with the authorities. No-out system travel except by the capsuleer ships of the authorities? Convenient. Most convenient. For a prison planet.

Doctor V. Valate, Professor of Archaeology at Kaztropolis Imperial University.

Gosakumori Noh
Coven of One
#7 - 2014-02-15 17:48:38 UTC
Diabolical blonde is diabolical, darling!
Agiri Falken
Akagi Initiative
#8 - 2014-02-16 01:04:48 UTC
Valerie Valate wrote:
I'm sure the authorities have it well in hand.

After all, with the two having a clone backup, then it would be a trivial matter to construct a couple of false bodies and plant them somewhere to be found.

And then, as the Gallente say "et voila!", lo and behold, "the bodies of the missing scientists have been found, and their clone backups can be safely activated".

Then the only loose end is to shoot the real ones as being impostors, in the event they aren't actually dead, and turn up later.

Would be convenient. Stops people trying to escape the system, should they have a disagreement with the authorities. No-out system travel except by the capsuleer ships of the authorities? Convenient. Most convenient. For a prison planet.

Well, well... Either you've done this before, or you've got a decent mind for it. Either way, not bad.