These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Not great PVP game as it's marketing campraign says

Author
FT Diomedes
The Graduates
#21 - 2014-01-04 20:01:24 UTC
Egravant Alduin wrote:
I went to try factional warfare since I was told only in factional warfare I can find good PVP (player vs player and not players vs player) combats.


This was your first mistake - thinking that Factional Warfare was the only place you can find good PVP. For the record, I almost never found good PVP in FW (yes, I did it several years ago, so perhaps things have changed). FW is where alts go to farm ISK.

Eve is an MMO, in case someone forgot to tell you that. It pays to cooperate with others, not to be a solo player. That is not to say that you cannot find solo PVP opportunities - you just have to look for other honorable space samurai or put other people in a position where they have to fight you.

I find occasional solo PVP opportunities in 0.0 - and not just ganks - usually in interceptors or other small ships. Most of my current solo PVP currently consists of solo roaming and looking for targets I can take down before the cavalry can arrive. Before you look at my killboard and scream "No solo kills!" please bear in mind that this is one of about 6 characters I use for PVP.

Before I joined RAZOR, I used to find good solo PVP in certain 0.0 entry systems - there it was usually a matter of enticing fast tackle off a gate camp to engage me and killing them before their friends could arrive. Additionally, there are quite a few people out there who will honor 1v1's.

Eve is also a game about reputation. If you develop a reputation as someone who is truly solo, people will be more likely to duel with you (not all). You just have to learn who honors 1v1's and who doesn't.

CCP should add more NPC 0.0 space to open it up and liven things up: the Stepping Stones project.

FT Diomedes
The Graduates
#22 - 2014-01-04 20:02:45 UTC
Sal Landry wrote:
Felsusguy wrote:

I have no idea what this is supposed to mean, but if I try to take it literally I might lose my sanity.


He wants instanced pvp arena systems that only allow the same number of ships to face off against each other in honourable internet spaceship duels.

lol


Yes, I think he missed the point of the sandbox.

CCP should add more NPC 0.0 space to open it up and liven things up: the Stepping Stones project.

Egravant Alduin
Ascendance Rising
Ascendance..
#23 - 2014-01-04 20:08:05 UTC
FT Diomedes wrote:
Egravant Alduin wrote:
I went to try factional warfare since I was told only in factional warfare I can find good PVP (player vs player and not players vs player) combats.


This was your first mistake - thinking that Factional Warfare was the only place you can find good PVP. For the record, I almost never found good PVP in FW (yes, I did it several years ago, so perhaps things have changed). FW is where alts go to farm ISK.

Eve is an MMO, in case someone forgot to tell you that. It pays to cooperate with others, not to be a solo player. That is not to say that you cannot find solo PVP opportunities - you just have to look for other honorable space samurai or put other people in a position where they have to fight you.

I find occasional solo PVP opportunities in 0.0 - and not just ganks - usually in interceptors or other small ships. Most of my current solo PVP currently consists of solo roaming and looking for targets I can take down before the cavalry can arrive. Before you look at my killboard and scream "No solo kills!" please bear in mind that this is one of about 6 characters I use for PVP.

Before I joined RAZOR, I used to find good solo PVP in certain 0.0 entry systems - there it was usually a matter of enticing fast tackle off a gate camp to engage me and killing them before their friends could arrive. Additionally, there are quite a few people out there who will honor 1v1's.

Eve is also a game about reputation. If you develop a reputation as someone who is truly solo, people will be more likely to duel with you (not all). You just have to learn who honors 1v1's and who doesn't.


You speak nicely and respectively. The thing is I have played almost all good MMOs and many of them had better PVP than this.Runes of magic in PVP server(epic one vs one ),AION (also nice one vs one and you could fly) , Lineage 2 (simple the king), WOW (very nice but nt for my tastes),fallen earth (kill and survive).I am saying that this game doesn t represents what everyones is saying in forums magazines sites etc.No it s not a PVP game it s just a god sci fi MMO.

Feel the wrath of the GECKO!

Egravant Alduin
Ascendance Rising
Ascendance..
#24 - 2014-01-04 20:09:18 UTC
FT Diomedes wrote:
Sal Landry wrote:
Felsusguy wrote:

I have no idea what this is supposed to mean, but if I try to take it literally I might lose my sanity.


He wants instanced pvp arena systems that only allow the same number of ships to face off against each other in honourable internet spaceship duels.

lol


Yes, I think he missed the point of the sandbox.


I played age of wushu which is sandbox base and had great PVP. If it had more understanding market I would still play it.

Feel the wrath of the GECKO!

Danika Princip
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#25 - 2014-01-04 20:16:46 UTC
Egravant Alduin wrote:
Danika Princip wrote:
ANY system you bring in to try and reward or encourage solo play can and will be abused to hell and back by virtually every EVE player. Just so you know.


No it will encourage skilled players to show their potential.Like a fight club or something like that .1 vs 1 .The best holds and wins against many opponents(not at the same time,one vs one)



...No, if there is any kind of a reward for it, such as the LP you get for FW complexes, we can and will abuse the hell out of the mechanic. This is EVE, it's kind of what people DO.
Egravant Alduin
Ascendance Rising
Ascendance..
#26 - 2014-01-04 20:45:37 UTC  |  Edited by: Egravant Alduin
Danika Princip wrote:
Egravant Alduin wrote:
Danika Princip wrote:
ANY system you bring in to try and reward or encourage solo play can and will be abused to hell and back by virtually every EVE player. Just so you know.


No it will encourage skilled players to show their potential.Like a fight club or something like that .1 vs 1 .The best holds and wins against many opponents(not at the same time,one vs one)



...No, if there is any kind of a reward for it, such as the LP you get for FW complexes, we can and will abuse the hell out of the mechanic. This is EVE, it's kind of what people DO.


They can limit the times which you can get LPS from same plex.So you travel travel again and find new fights.

Feel the wrath of the GECKO!

Tchulen
Trumpets and Bookmarks
#27 - 2014-01-04 21:13:23 UTC
Egravant Alduin wrote:
...No it s not a PVP game it s just a god sci fi MMO.


I've read repeated arguments on these forums that state that EVE is entirely PVP, that all aspects of the game in one way or another constitute PVP.

I disagree with that for several reasons which I won't repeat here but the arguments for are compelling.

However, I've also played many MMO PVP games and I've quit all of them except EVE purely because EVE has the best PVP of any game I've played. I don't play solo though. That's the thing with EVE. Whilst you can play solo the PVP side is best played in groups.

If EVE PVP isn't for you don't worry. There are many other PVP games out there as you've stated. One of those might be more to your tastes if you don't want to adapt. After all, in EVE, you adapt or you die.

I started trying to force 1v1 fights and I died a lot. I then adapted and now have a lot of fun doing PVP. I'm not particularly good at it yet but I have been having a lot of fun improving.

My advice is give it a go with more than just one of you and then decide if that changes your view. If it doesn't, just move onto a game that does do it for you. EVE isn't for everybody.

Good luck in your hunt for your type of PVP.
Egravant Alduin
Ascendance Rising
Ascendance..
#28 - 2014-01-04 21:21:15 UTC
Tchulen wrote:
Egravant Alduin wrote:
...No it s not a PVP game it s just a god sci fi MMO.


I've read repeated arguments on these forums that state that EVE is entirely PVP, that all aspects of the game in one way or another constitute PVP.

I disagree with that for several reasons which I won't repeat here but the arguments for are compelling.

However, I've also played many MMO PVP games and I've quit all of them except EVE purely because EVE has the best PVP of any game I've played. I don't play solo though. That's the thing with EVE. Whilst you can play solo the PVP side is best played in groups.

If EVE PVP isn't for you don't worry. There are many other PVP games out there as you've stated. One of those might be more to your tastes if you don't want to adapt. After all, in EVE, you adapt or you die.

I started trying to force 1v1 fights and I died a lot. I then adapted and now have a lot of fun doing PVP. I'm not particularly good at it yet but I have been having a lot of fun improving.

My advice is give it a go with more than just one of you and then decide if that changes your view. If it doesn't, just move onto a game that does do it for you. EVE isn't for everybody.

Good luck in your hunt for your type of PVP.


Great point and answer but the thing is since you have played other games as you say that other games have 1 vs 1 and group fights.In my one year of eve i have almost never fought 1 vs 1 .A good PVP game is a game that has 1 vs 1 and group fights.Then it can advertise as a good PVP game.

Feel the wrath of the GECKO!

Danika Princip
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#29 - 2014-01-04 21:40:46 UTC
Egravant Alduin wrote:


They can limit the times which you can get LPS from same plex.So you travel travel again and find new fights.



Well, since the PLEX despawns when you run the button down (Doesn't it?), you'd have to move on anyway.

And really, moving two alts one system over is your ENTIRE counter to LP farming?
Tchulen
Trumpets and Bookmarks
#30 - 2014-01-04 22:00:12 UTC
Egravant Alduin wrote:
Great point and answer but the thing is since you have played other games as you say that other games have 1 vs 1 and group fights.In my one year of eve i have almost never fought 1 vs 1 .A good PVP game is a game that has 1 vs 1 and group fights.Then it can advertise as a good PVP game.

You're stating that assertion as though it were fact when it is actually merely your opinion.

A good PVP game is a game that has good PVP, by definition. EVE has, in my opinion, the best PVP of any game I've played and therefore for me (and most people that play EVE PVP) it is a good PVP game.

What it isn't is a PVP game that holds your hand by imposing rigorous rules to protect what you would suppose to be fairness.

That is really what you're saying, I think. You seem to be saying saying that because it doesn't enforce the PVP rules you would like to have it isn't a good PVP game but you're couching it as though your view of what the rules should be is the same as everyone else's which, just from this thread alone, you can see isn't the case.

I do have a suggestion for you, however. Use the dueling system in order to get fair(ish) 1v1 fights in highsec. If you can't find people who'll accept your duels you can join a corporation that specialises in pvp and duel your corp mates to your heart's content.

This is a form of adapting. You can get the PVP you're asking for in EVE. You just need to look a little harder and put some effort in. Obviously, if you don't like the idea of putting effort into finding duels EVE probably isn't the game for you. Pretty much everything in EVE requires at least some effort.
Sigras
Conglomo
#31 - 2014-01-04 22:39:36 UTC
PvP doesn't specifically mean 1v1.

This is a game that prizes freedom and choice over everything else.

You want a fight club where players duel 1v1 to see who is the best? You start one... Pssst it's Garmon

You want a place where the game forces fair fights? The WoW arenas are calling your name.

You want a game where winning a battle actually means something more than just a gold star and numbers on a leader board? This is the game for you, but don't expect the game to force the fights to be fair... Those two concepts are mutually exclusive.
Loki Feiht
Warcrows
THE OLD SCHOOL
#32 - 2014-01-04 23:35:15 UTC
Implement more 'NPC life'.
Create missions based on killing / defending said life.
More creative use of suspect / limited aggression flags.
Contractable killrights.

To the OP you will have to learn to use guerilla tactics (among others) to seperate players from their gangs, Eve is full of people who feel their way is the only way and solo PvP is definatly the more challenging. (I don't mean 'solo' in your homesystem with ganglinks, reps and a counter for everything you might possibly come across).

More NPC - Randomly Generated Modular Content thread https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=220858

Little Dragon Khamez
Guardians of the Underworld
#33 - 2014-01-04 23:49:15 UTC
Egravant Alduin wrote:
I have said it and I will say it once more.I went to try factional warfare since I was told only in factional warfare I can find good PVP (player vs player and not players vs player) combats.Well at first 3 fights I was excited since I had great one vs one battles even if i lost.After that ,20 combats followed and all were ganging ganging and more ganging.

So in my 20 fights only 3 were one vs one we are talking for a pathetic 10-15%.

Why not gates in factional warfare don t let one ship from each faction to pass only once so they could fight each other?This would make 1 vs 1 real PVP possible.

Why not systems that would allow certain numbers of ships can t be created?

Compared to lineage 2 or other MMOs this is the worst PVP game I have ever tried end really regretting paying for it in first months.

It s current PVP system only allows ganging and nothing more.


Your doing it wrong, there's no revolving door of solo pvp battles out there, you choose your fights, sometimes that might mean waiting for the gangs to fly on by.

Dumbing down of Eve Online will result in it's destruction...

Kaerakh
Obscure Joke Implied
#34 - 2014-01-05 00:45:13 UTC  |  Edited by: Kaerakh
I'd like to take a moment to say that this topic is rather abstract and broad, and doesn't really have a sense of direction beyond, "make it better" and general gaming philosophy.
Gimme more Cynos
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#35 - 2014-01-05 01:08:18 UTC
Felsusguy wrote:
What is this? "The PVP isn't good because there's not enough solo". Seriously?


I think it's more of an:

PvP isn't good if you get blobbed.

Oh, and he is totally right --> getting blobbed isn't exactly good PvP. Not that I say it's wrong that this happens in EvE.
Rovinia
Exotic Dancers Union
Hatakani Trade Winds Combine
#36 - 2014-01-05 03:06:45 UTC  |  Edited by: Rovinia
I have played DaoC, WoW, WAR, Guild Wars and many other pvp MMO's and other games. Even if they had 1v1 or Instances with 16 vs 16 and such, you will never find "fair" solo-pvp in one of these games. A 1v1 can be as unfair as a 3v1, depending on level, equipment (time spent to the game) or class your opponent has.

For example, if i see you in a Enyo assault frigate (mostly blaster fitted and so restricted to short range), i can reship to a Hookbill. It has 5 Medslots, enough for 1-2 Tracking Disruptors with Range scripts, Scram and Web. The fight, even if it's a 1v1, will not be a fair fight, it will be an execution of the Enyo.

Does that makes me to an "honorable space samurai"? Hell no, the other pilot would have had more fun if i called in a friend and killed him in a 2v1.

Eve doesn't make a claim to to be a 1v1 game, it's not balanced for that. It's balanced for Fleet compositions. And it works pretty good there in most cases.
Gimme more Cynos
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#37 - 2014-01-05 03:19:20 UTC
Rovinia wrote:
you will never find "fair" pvp in one of these games.
.


This is simply not true. If you haven't had such PvP yet, you simply have not played enough PvP. OR you played too much EvE where this is practically impossible :)
Rovinia
Exotic Dancers Union
Hatakani Trade Winds Combine
#38 - 2014-01-05 03:23:59 UTC  |  Edited by: Rovinia
Than show me one. I had fun 1v1 in all of these games, also in Eve. But all of these were very rare. Really balanced were allways only the group fights. And that's a good thing.

Ok, i should have changed "never" to "seldom" Blink
Fourteen Maken
Karma and Causality
#39 - 2014-01-05 06:56:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Fourteen Maken
Egravant Alduin wrote:
I have said it and I will say it once more.I went to try factional warfare since I was told only in factional warfare I can find good PVP (player vs player and not players vs player) combats.Well at first 3 fights I was excited since I had great one vs one battles even if i lost.After that ,20 combats followed and all were ganging ganging and more ganging.

So in my 20 fights only 3 were one vs one we are talking for a pathetic 10-15%.

Why not gates in factional warfare don t let one ship from each faction to pass only once so they could fight each other?This would make 1 vs 1 real PVP possible.

Why not systems that would allow certain numbers of ships can t be created?

Compared to lineage 2 or other MMOs this is the worst PVP game I have ever tried end really regretting paying for it in first months.

It s current PVP system only allows ganging and nothing more.


Most of the marketing I see shows fleet fights, actually I don't think I've ever seen an add with solo pvp. Having said that I wish there was more solo pvp because fleets last for hours and even in gangs its hard to get balanced fights.
FT Diomedes
The Graduates
#40 - 2014-01-05 07:23:24 UTC  |  Edited by: FT Diomedes
Fourteen Maken wrote:
Egravant Alduin wrote:
I have said it and I will say it once more.I went to try factional warfare since I was told only in factional warfare I can find good PVP (player vs player and not players vs player) combats.Well at first 3 fights I was excited since I had great one vs one battles even if i lost.After that ,20 combats followed and all were ganging ganging and more ganging.

So in my 20 fights only 3 were one vs one we are talking for a pathetic 10-15%.

Why not gates in factional warfare don t let one ship from each faction to pass only once so they could fight each other?This would make 1 vs 1 real PVP possible.

Why not systems that would allow certain numbers of ships can t be created?

Compared to lineage 2 or other MMOs this is the worst PVP game I have ever tried end really regretting paying for it in first months.

It s current PVP system only allows ganging and nothing more.


Most of the marketing I see shows fleet fights, actually I don't think I've ever seen an add with solo pvp. Having said that I wish there was more solo pvp because fleets last for hours and even in gangs its hard to get balanced fights.


If the fight is fair or balanced one side or the other screwed up. That is as true in a 1v1 as it is in a fleet.

Finding PVP in Eve is always a delicate balance of "do I have enough to win, without taking pyrrhic losses, and without appearing so strong that the enemy just runs."

CCP should add more NPC 0.0 space to open it up and liven things up: the Stepping Stones project.