These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Market Discussions

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
12Next page
 

Isk exchange between Dust and Eve; updated exchange rates

Author
Min Lo
Docwagon
#1 - 2013-10-04 17:46:58 UTC  |  Edited by: Min Lo
Updated rates, as of Feb. 11th, 2014:

I'm changing the way I display the available Dust to Eve batches. From now on, I'll just show the current batch price, in a variety of batch sizes, the amount of isk available at that price, and what the price will change to when the current batches run out. So:

Quote:


For customers converting Dust isk into Eve isk the rate of exchange is about 1 to 5 (smaller size batches are a little more expensive), so:
~1,500,000,000 Eve isk is for sale at:
52M Dust isk buys 250m Eve isk, or
101M Dust isk buys 500M Eve isk, or
110M Dust isk buys 550M Eve isk, or
120M Dust isk buys 600M Eve isk, or
130M Dust isk buys 650M Eve isk, or
500M Dust isk buys 2.6B Eve isk.

After the above pile of Eve isk is sold, the ratio shifts closer to 1 to 4.8 which would be:

The next ~2,500,000,000 Eve isk would sell for:
52M Dust isk buys 240m Eve isk, or
101M Dust isk buys 480M Eve isk, or
110M Dust isk buys 528M Eve isk, or
120M Dust isk buys 576M Eve isk, or
130M Dust isk buys 624M Eve isk, or
500M Dust isk buys 2.5B Eve isk.


For the opposite direction of isk transfers, converting Eve isk into Dust isk, various batch sizes are available:
Quote:


300M Eve buys 25M Dust isk for the smaller "tiny A" batch
300M Eve buys 25M Dust isk for the smaller "tiny B" batch

600M Eve buys 60M Dust isk for the "AX" batch;
600M Eve buys 60M Dust isk for the "AY" batch;
600M Eve buys 60M Dust isk for the "AZ" batch;
600M Eve buys 60M Dust isk for the "BA" batch;
600M Eve buys 60M Dust isk for the "BB" batch;
600M Eve buys 60M Dust isk for the "BC" batch;

5B Eve buys 500M Dust isk for the large "AAA" batch
10B Eve buys 1B Dust isk for the large "BBB" batch
10.25B Eve buys 1B Dust isk for the large "CCC" batch
10.5B Eve buys 1B Dust isk for the large "DDD" batch


-Gyn Wallace/Min Lo



original post follows:
Quote:

Hello,

I've opened an exchange to convert players Dust isk into Eve isk, and vice versa. See Dust and Eve forum threads titled: "Rules Question re: player run isk exchange between Dust and Eve"

One response suggested that I should use an established escrow service such as Chribba.
I have two questions for the financial gurus of MD:
#1 What is the neighborhood of a reasonable fee for an escrow services to charge? and
#2 Can I offer potential customers some degree of reliability by memorializing transaction agreements on the Dust forums, so that if I turned out just to be a scammer, the aggrieved Dust player could get my Dust character banned?
I'm aware that CCP tolerates scamming among Eve players, but I'm unaware of any stance tolerating scamming among the console players. Can I offer potential customers any peace of mind by memorializing transfer agreements on the Dust forums? The log in for the Dust forums suggest that Sony runs them, rather than CCP, so that scamming through the Dust forums might be a rule violation.
I'd rather not reinvent the wheel if someone else has already looked into this.

Thanks for your replies,
Min Lo, Eve Online
Gyn Wallace, Dust 514

[Badly out of date rates follow, current rates are at the top, above this original post]

Currently offering 600M Eve isk at a price of 12M Dust isk, and
6M Dust isk at a price of 600M Eve isk.*

*Exchange rates subject to change as soon as one-sided transactions begin drawing down my reserves of Dust or Eve isk. I'm open to discussion of what the exchange rate and minimum batch sizes should be.

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Min Lo
Docwagon
#2 - 2013-10-04 17:50:11 UTC
reserved

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Tigerras
Smash Incorporated
#3 - 2013-10-04 18:40:28 UTC
Your best bet to have people "trust" you is to have a general trusted third party hold assets worth at least what you will be trasnferring. That way if you do scam people, then they still get their money from the held collateral.

As for the amount to charge, that is up to you and the market. A small percentage is probably best (5-10% maybe).

I would also double check rules and regulations on this, just to be sure you aren't stepping on CCP toes for some reason. I don't know how the interaction between Dust and Eve works financially.

Also, characters are cheap in eve (and I assume they are not super expensive in Dust either) so nobody will care that you have posted your characters.
I Was There
Habemus
#4 - 2013-10-05 10:39:02 UTC
wait. Can I transfer isk to my Dust toon?

If so, jesus christ I'm going to be pimp.
Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#5 - 2013-10-05 14:40:48 UTC  |  Edited by: Vaerah Vahrokha
@OP

1) How often do you perform these kinds of transactions?

2) How do you show your customers your locked down collateral vs how much you are floating in your transactions?

I want to expecially stress on point 2, because you won't get any Chribba / Grendell or even me back up if you don't provide metrics to assure you are not overextending (in good or bad faith) vs your locked down assets.

If you are for single transactions with immediate collateral lockdown => get Dust currency => send EvE ISK => collateral restitution then point 1 has to be much more detailed.
Min Lo
Docwagon
#6 - 2013-10-05 15:22:30 UTC  |  Edited by: Min Lo
Tigerras wrote:

As for the amount to charge, that is up to you and the market. A small percentage is probably best (5-10% maybe).


Thanks, does anyone know whether someone as prominent as Chribba charges this much? I'm not sure if there is value in a Third Party service offered by someone much less prominent...

I Was There wrote:
wait. Can I transfer isk to my Dust toon?

If so, jesus christ I'm going to be pimp.


Yes, but not at a 1:1 ratio. My current offer is 1:50 ratio for Dust->Eve transfers and 100:1 for Eve->Dust transfers, with a minimum batch size of something around 300M Eve isk, but I'm amenable to persuasion. Those rates are also subject to change as my isk reserves in each game get drawn down by too much one-sided traffic.

Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
@OP
1) How often do you perform these kinds of transactions?

2) How do you show your customers your locked down collateral vs how much you are floating in your transactions?


Never (yet) and I don't. That's why I'm posting here, to find out the best way to do this.

Did you have any information that might bear on the questions I asked? Do you know how escrow agents figure out what they should charge? Do you know whether stating agreements for exchanges on Sony's forums and then breaking those agreements results in any redress for victims or punishment for scammers?

If I can simply make my exchanges explicit on Dust forums, and offer the redress of getting me banned if I scam customers, I don't think I need an escrow service, so my first question would be moot.

Perhaps I can ask my most important question differently: Has anyone heard of a scammer scamming his victims on the Dust forums, and either getting away with it or being punished/banned by Sony or CCP?

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Min Lo
Docwagon
#7 - 2013-10-05 15:52:02 UTC
" In addition, you agree not to use the Site for any unlawful purpose or in any way that might harm, damage, or disparage any other party. " - Dust Forum rules, from dust514.com/terms-of-use , emphasis added.

It is my understanding that Eve has an analogous rule for its Character Bazaar forums, to prevent scamming. Would this rule for the Dust forums offer potential customers a sufficient remedy against currency exchange scammers?

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

X ATM092
The Hatchery
RAZOR Alliance
#8 - 2013-10-05 19:23:38 UTC
Tigerras wrote:
Your best bet to have people "trust" you is to have a general trusted third party hold assets worth at least what you will be trasnferring. That way if you do scam people, then they still get their money from the held collateral.

As for the amount to charge, that is up to you and the market. A small percentage is probably best (5-10% maybe).

I would also double check rules and regulations on this, just to be sure you aren't stepping on CCP toes for some reason. I don't know how the interaction between Dust and Eve works financially.

Also, characters are cheap in eve (and I assume they are not super expensive in Dust either) so nobody will care that you have posted your characters.

I recently saw a Chribba post on the subject saying he refuses to be a third party for third parties because he then is forced to judge the legitimacy of transactions he was not involved in and it becomes a shitstorm that can call his legitimacy into question.
Min Lo
Docwagon
#9 - 2013-10-05 19:42:32 UTC
X ATM092 wrote:
I recently saw a Chribba post on the subject saying he refuses to be a third party for third parties because he then is forced to judge the legitimacy of transactions he was not involved in and it becomes a shitstorm that can call his legitimacy into question.

I think this is more like a straightforward escrow service, which he's indicated that he's willing to do in the Dust thread, where ChribbaX has posted (Dust Forum subsection: Feedback/Requests, Thread titled "Rules Question re: player run isk exchange between Dust and Eve"). I've outlined an example of how that might work in that Dust thread.

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Chribba
Otherworld Enterprises
Otherworld Empire
#10 - 2013-10-05 19:50:19 UTC
I don't really hold collateral for others so they can conduct their 3rd party doings sort of. Doing transaction by transaction escrow is a different thing that I do do Smile

★★★ Secure 3rd party service ★★★

Visit my in-game channel 'Holy Veldspar'

Twitter @ChribbaVeldspar

Hel O'Ween
Men On A Mission
#11 - 2013-10-07 14:46:03 UTC
Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:

I want to expecially stress on point 2, because you won't get any Chribba / Grendell or even me back up if you don't provide metrics to assure you are not overextending (in good or bad faith) vs your locked down assets.


It seems like you just invented a new profession: "Escrow of escrows". Blink

EVEWalletAware - an offline wallet manager.

Min Lo
Docwagon
#12 - 2013-10-17 03:47:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Min Lo
Rates updated in first post.

and perhaps of interest, a quote from my latest post in the Dust side thread

Gyn Wallace wrote:
That's what I'm really betting on, if my initial exchange rate has over valued Dust isk. I'm hoping the Eve/Dust connection is strengthened before an official exchange opens, so I'll have a chance to sell some of the Dust isk I've been buying in these early batches, and at least break even before an official CCP currency exchange opens. I think Flint touched on the best real measure of their relative value, the RL time it takes a player to earn isk in each game. My optimal Dust isk buying customers are Eve players who can make billions of isk in a very short time, perhaps large alliance leaders, if they decide to fund Dust side players. I wouldn't mind having a billion Dust isk available to sell them.

On the other hand, if I've miscalculated and wind up having traded a bunch of my idle Eve isk for more Dust isk than I can spend, I'll have fun trying, since I play Dust a heck of a lot more than I play Eve these days. :D

I also like the sandbox aspect of the player's supply and demand determining the exchange rate, rather than CCP pulling a number out of the air. I like playing a small part in making that happen. Selling several billion Eve isk for some Dust isk has been the most fun I've had in Eve lately. <- My impression of a bitter-vet rant, lol.

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Min Lo
Docwagon
#13 - 2013-11-15 15:07:16 UTC
How long would it be reasonable to let someone sit in the queue? Is one week too long or too short? I'm tempted to say that someone can post in this thread or the Dust forum thread to reserve a place in the queue for 5 days or one week; but if they don't confirm terms and complete their delivery to me or an escrow agent within that time, they should go back to the end of the line.

I haven't made explicit queue rules. I don't believe I'm under any obligation until I've confirmed the terms of a specific transfer with someone, but I'd like to nip any problems in the bud by addressing this sooner rather than later. Any suggestions for appropriate queue rules are appreciated.

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Jdestars
Stars Research systems Incorporation
#14 - 2013-11-21 09:08:27 UTC  |  Edited by: Jdestars
Impressing ....the imagination has an equal only the greed of capsulers Shocked

We decided to award the medal of the Scam of the Scam for this decadeBlink
Min Lo
Docwagon
#15 - 2013-12-01 21:40:57 UTC
Rates updated.

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Pheota Sansu
Kings.Guard.
#16 - 2013-12-03 15:26:45 UTC
Min Lo wrote:
Rates updated.



So how exactly does this work? I dont have dust yet, but I've been thinking about grabbing it. In dust is your weaponry and stuff dependant on your isk? or is there a leveling system? What does it take to kind of pimp a dust toon out? I'm very interested in this if I can get those answers. I'd be performing a eve to dusk transfer.
Min Lo
Docwagon
#17 - 2013-12-03 16:15:20 UTC
Pheota Sansu wrote:

So how exactly does this work? I dont have dust yet, but I've been thinking about grabbing it. In dust is your weaponry and stuff dependant on your isk? or is there a leveling system? What does it take to kind of pimp a dust toon out? I'm very interested in this if I can get those answers. I'd be performing a eve to dusk transfer.


First things first, if you're thinking about playing Dust, make a PSN account, create a character, and begin accruing passive skill points. Even if you need to visit a friend with a ps3 to do this, its worth doing sooner rather than later.

Since Dust 514 is free to download and play, the real question is whether you have a PS3 with space to download and install it. As for the game itself, I don't think I can adequately summarize it in a single forum post. The official Dust 514 site gives a pretty good overview.

I haven't looked carefully at whether its more efficient to spend real money on Aurum, or on a plex to convert to Eve isk, to convert to Dust isk. The advantage to the Aurum equipment is that it typically has lower skill requirements to equip it, so its better for beginners.

Again, I haven't done a side by side comparison, but I suspect that you'll find that spending your real money on Aurum is more advantageous when you're new to Dust, but once your skills are higher, so you can use the best prototype equipment, converting Dollars to Plex, to Eve isk, to Dust isk, might be more efficient. That's a really good question.

On the other hand, if you're not looking for the most efficient bang for your real money buck, and are just looking to use your massive pile of Eve isk on something fun, yes, that's what this exchange service is all about. Facilitating wealthy Eve players having fun in Dust, and helping Dust players convert their Dust isk into Eve isk to support the demand for plex.

The most up to date rates are in this this Dust forum thread re: isk exchange.

-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Vaerah Vahrokha
Vahrokh Consulting
#18 - 2013-12-03 16:29:55 UTC
If you feel very pro, you could save those values in a CSV file or XLS sheet so everybody could make himself an idea about how the two games economies are interacting.

You never know, you could get luckly and the next Fanfest see Dr. Ejyo show your data, possibly nicely presented in some bar / pie chart or even candlestick chart.
Min Lo
Docwagon
#19 - 2013-12-03 19:07:39 UTC
It occurred to me that I really didn't answer your precise questions, and regarding passive skill points I should be clear: unlike Eve Online, you don't have to update a currently training skill. You simply have a total unallocated skill points number that slowly creep upward, passively. If you create a character today, start passive skill point accrual and log in a year from now, you should have 7 or 8 million skill points to spend. Most people earn most of their skill points by playing actively though. You can earn about 180,000 additional skill points per week playing actively, and at a slower active rate thereafter.

Pheota Sansu wrote:

So how exactly does this work? I dont have dust yet, but I've been thinking about grabbing it. In dust is your weaponry and stuff dependant on your isk? or is there a leveling system?


Sort of. You use prepackaged free loadouts (like the newbie ship in Eve) or build suits, loaded up with gear that costs Dust isk or aurum. There are also blueprints that allow you to fit equipment to a suit for free. (Unlike Eve Online blueprints which require you to go through a manufacturing process; you simply fit the product of the blueprint in your Fitting screen.)

Every time you spawn, you use one of your predefined fits (kind of like undocking). Every time you get killed and respawn, you've used up one of your fits. In Very rough numbers: Free suits are free, Basic fits are about 20k isk, advanced fits are about 30-70k, and prototype fits can be around 90k to 180k.

So if you run proto gear and die six times in a match, you can easily be a million Dust isk poorer. As they payout at the end of the match partially depends on how much enemy equipment you destroyed, you might easily fail to make a profit. On the other hand, of you run free gear, die ten times, and kill a few enemies wearing proto gear, you'll likely make something like 150k to 250k. Again those are Very rough numbers. Lots of people in similar circumstances might see payouts half or twice as big, depending on how much other stuff they did. (My logi has gotten top place with over 4000 war points, with zero kills, and a payout of over 700k.) I honestly don't have a superb grasp of how war points or payouts are calculated.

There isn't a "leveling" system so much as a skill tree that enables you to use better gear, or increases your damage, etc. Aurum gear routinely has lower skill requirements than gear with similar stats that costs isk.

Pheota Sansu wrote:
What does it take to kind of pimp a dust toon out? I'm very interested in this if I can get those answers. I'd be performing a eve to dusk transfer.


Real money, at first, to buy aurum, so you can afford Aurum gear, and help CCP and Sony conclude that their investment in Dust 514 was worthwhile. If you're less interested in supporting CCP and Sony, and just want to have fun: nothing. You'll get stomped sometimes running free gear, but getting in the game, getting experience, and most importantly, getting into squads and corps that use teamwork, is far more important than the gear. Once you've got comparable teams fighting against one another, then the gear definitely makes a difference.

Tanks are expensive though (cheap ones are about 200k, well fitted expensive ones can cost a couple million). Once you've got the skills to run better gear without buying aurum, you might want to shift idle Eve isk into Dust to support what can be an expensive role. Tankers rarely profit at the end of the match if they lost a single tank. Piloting drop ships can also be expensive.

Vaerah Vahrokha wrote:
...so everybody could make himself an idea about how the two games economies are interacting.


I don't think we need anything complex yet, because the current interaction is pretty simple. The bond between games is still weak, so the only isk traffic so far consists of people who want to play the other game, rather than people who want to advance in their main game by supporting friends and allies in the other.

I'm amazed CCP is leaving isk transfers to the private exchanges rather than building an official one, since one way of looking at Dust 514 is as a massive advertisement for Eve Online. Failing to follow up on that ad by making it easy for Dust players to support plex demand within Eve seems like a big opportunity missed.

As you can see from the batch numbers, all the traffic I've seen so far consists of Dust players wanting to keep playing Eve. Pheota would be my first transfer in the opposite direction.

Perhaps this is a good time to ask everyone, "Should the batch size be smaller than the current price of a plex, for Eve to Dust transfers?

I wonder if transfers from Eve to Dust isk, should be more like:

550M Eve for 56.8M Dust isk, for the "A" batch;
550M Eve for 56.8M Dust isk, for the "B" batch;
550M Eve for 55.9M Dust isk for the "C" batch;
550M Eve for 55.9M Dust isk for the "D" batch;
550M Eve for 55M Dust isk for the "E" batch;
550M Eve for 55M Dust isk for the "F" batch;
550M Eve for 55M Dust isk for the "G" batch;

So that Eve players can buy a plex, sell it, and convert that isk to Dust... which the 600M Eve isk batch size doesn't facilitate when plex prices are below 600M.



-Gyn Wallace, Dust

-Min Lo, Eve

The Eve/Dust Isk Exchange Thread

Pheota Sansu
Kings.Guard.
#20 - 2013-12-03 19:53:52 UTC
Min Lo wrote:




As you can see from the batch numbers, all the traffic I've seen so far consists of Dust players wanting to keep playing Eve. Pheota would be my first transfer in the opposite direction.

Perhaps this is a good time to ask everyone, "Should the batch size be smaller than the current price of a plex, for Eve to Dust transfers?

I wonder if transfers from Eve to Dust isk, should be more like:

550M Eve for 56.8M Dust isk, for the "A" batch;
550M Eve for 56.8M Dust isk, for the "B" batch;
550M Eve for 55.9M Dust isk for the "C" batch;
550M Eve for 55.9M Dust isk for the "D" batch;
550M Eve for 55M Dust isk for the "E" batch;
550M Eve for 55M Dust isk for the "F" batch;
550M Eve for 55M Dust isk for the "G" batch;

So that Eve players can buy a plex, sell it, and convert that isk to Dust... which the 600M Eve isk batch size doesn't facilitate when plex prices are below 600M.





I wanted to transfer because I have extra eve iskies and just want to be able to play with semi decent gear. i will almost certainly be requesting this as soon as I get dust set up tonight.
12Next page