These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Power Corrupts: The Hidden Threat of Slavery

Author
Vulxanis Viceroy
Offworld Trading Company
Khimi Harar
#61 - 2013-11-23 05:15:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Vulxanis Viceroy
Lady Katherine Devonshire wrote:
Naomi Tichim wrote:
The answer is quite simple. Every culture in New Eden has their own variation of the old maxim "Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely."


Whilst this may indeed be true, do not for a moment lure one's self into thinking that such moral pitfalls exist only within the Empire or our customs. How many Gallente senators have lost their positions over the years due to scandals of embezzlement and dishonesty? How many Minmatar warlords treat their underlings with far less respect than we treat our own servants? Even our Allies in the State, as noble as they may be, still recently had quite a bit of a conundrum with corruption at their very highest office. Of course, unlike the other two powers that I just mentioned, the State actually solved their little problem. Still no word on what fates awaits Blaque or Shakor, hmm?

However, my point still stands: No great nation has ever been truly free of corruption entirely, for no great nation shall ever be truly free of the hierarchies of power itself. They do not truly increase or decrease, either. Rather they merely change form. In authoritarian nations such as the Empire and the State, power is wielded openly and without shame. The same could be said of the Republic, but they seem so hypnotized by their own "freedom" mantra that they often fail to realize that they are more slaves to their own dogmas than the most pious of Amarrian high priests. The Gallente, to their credit, are the far most subtle in the ways that they manipulate their people into believing themselves to be far more free than they really are.

So if you wish to address the heart of the issue then you need to realize that slavery is just another one of power's many faces. It is a manifestation of power, but not by far the only way people are controlled in New Eden. It is simply the most honest, open and direct form.

The advantage to our system is entirely this: Faith. Through religion we Amarrians all acknowledge that no matter how powerful we may become as individuals that there is always a higher power than ourselves. All Amarrians may bow before our Great Empress, but even She in turn must bow before God. Compare this in stark contrast to so many mere mortals (both common and capsuleer alike) whom not only forsake God but have egos so enlarged that they often mistake themselves for God.

So I present to you another axiom of wisdom: In the end there are no good or bad forms of government, only good or bad people. Whether a monarchy, dictatorship, or elective democracy one's government is only as morally correct as the people who hold those seats of office. Again this is where the Amarrians have a distinct advantage. In most societies the rule of power is this: Those who seek it the most are the people you would least want to have it. Sociopaths, liars, con-artists, power mongers and other mental malcontents flock to the banner of political office, seeking power for themselves purely for their own personal gain. In the Empire, however, being theocratic in nature, power goes not the most wicked but the most pious. Here it is strong moral character that advances one in rank, whereas elsewhere such a trait would be an obstacle to achieving power.

Since moral character operates in direct opposition to the temptation of corruption, our system has a build in check against it. True, the system is not perfect, and bad apples slip through, but I still firmly believe that if one were to strip away all veils of secrecy and deception, then laid our every human's true nature & soul before the eyes of God for judgement ... it would be quite obvious that the only real contestants would be ourselves and our Caldari allies.


Very well said!

Albiet all of the empires have their shortcomings, it is a good day to be Amarr. There are good people in every nation, and bad people as well. But in the end, what matters is how you treat people. Even those considered beneath you.

In Character: Only responds to "Lord Draconis"

Pronounced "Vulzanis"

Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/Eve/comments/4fanm8/eve_in_a_nutshell_and_how_to_crack_it/

Public channel: VXV EVE

Twitter: https://wiki.eveonline.com/en/wiki/Vulxanis_Viceroy

Natalcya Katla
Astropolitan Front
#62 - 2013-11-23 06:21:38 UTC
Ibrahim Tash-Murkon wrote:
The Holder/slave relationship is very much like the parent/child relationship. Are there parents who have shortcomings? Yes. Are there parents who are willfully careless or, worse, intentionally harmful to their children? Yes. Does that mean we should end parenthood and send children into the world alone and unguided? Absolutely not.

Actually, we very much should work toward putting an end to the institution of parenthood as soon as (and in as responsible a way as) possible, for exactly the reasons you state. As you correctly point out, parenthood is exactly as arbitrary, inefficient and ultimately disgusting an institution as the Amarrian institution of slavery.

Very few parents have the ability and the inclination to raise a child in a remotely responsible manner. Your typical parent is an unskilled caretaker with an education and career completely unrelated to childraising, who bumbles about using blind intuition in a foolish or sadistic attempt to shoe-horn "their" child into the mold of their own obsolete culture. There is nothing beyond the often arbitrary act of genetic donorship to recommend typical biological parents for the job of childraising. They are parasites preying on the minds and identities of "their" offspring, usually in the hope of achieving some kind of symbolic immortality through "their" descendants.

In an ideal universe - which is still a long way off, to be sure - every child would be raised and taught by professional and highly motivated caretakers and tutors, in the same environment and with access to the same resources as their peers. They would be neurally mapped with some frequency, to assist their caretakers in seeing to it that each of them would receive the proper training and stimuli to develop their individual talents. This, in turn, would eventually allow them to take their optimal places as highly-functioning members of society.
Katran Luftschreck
Royal Ammatar Engineering Corps
#63 - 2013-11-24 18:32:25 UTC
Natalcya Katla wrote:
In an ideal universe - which is still a long way off, to be sure - every child would be raised and taught by professional and highly motivated caretakers and tutors, in the same environment and with access to the same resources as their peers. They would be neurally mapped with some frequency, to assist their caretakers in seeing to it that each of them would receive the proper training and stimuli to develop their individual talents. This, in turn, would eventually allow them to take their optimal places as highly-functioning members of society.


This is where someone from the Caldari State usually chimes in, yeah? Because isn't this what they already do? They could explain it better.

http://youtu.be/t0q2F8NsYQ0

Naomi Tichim
Sovereign Hospitaller Order of Saint Katherine
#64 - 2013-11-25 14:22:51 UTC  |  Edited by: Naomi Tichim
Lady Katherine Devonshire wrote:
So I present to you another axiom of wisdom: In the end there are no good or bad forms of government, only good or bad people. Whether a monarchy, dictatorship, or elective democracy one's government is only as morally correct as the people who hold those seats of office. Again this is where the Amarrians have a distinct advantage. In most societies the rule of power is this: Those who seek it the most are the people you would least want to have it. Sociopaths, liars, con-artists, power mongers and other mental malcontents flock to the banner of political office, seeking power for themselves purely for their own personal gain. In the Empire, however, being theocratic in nature, power goes not the most wicked but the most pious. Here it is strong moral character that advances one in rank, whereas elsewhere such a trait would be an obstacle to achieving power.

Since moral character operates in direct opposition to the temptation of corruption, our system has a build in check against it. True, the system is not perfect, and bad apples slip through, but I still firmly believe that if one were to strip away all veils of secrecy and deception, then laid our every human's true nature & soul before the eyes of God for judgement ... it would be quite obvious that the only real contestants would be ourselves and our Caldari allies.


You describe the ideal. In practice, the Amarrian religious hierarchy is as vulnerable to power politics as any other organization.

We are all imperfect. We all have our sins. The Caldari are driven by their desire for power and wealth. The Minmatar are blinded by their desire for vengeance. And the Gallente... well, they are like us. Confident in their own superiority, they are blind to the corruption within. They are also perhaps the most decadent, although we are hardly innocent in that regard. Don't believe me, check out some of the "relaxation centers" in certain out of the way Amarrian systems. My experiences pale before what happens to some of the slaves there.
Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#65 - 2013-11-25 16:54:17 UTC  |  Edited by: Pieter Tuulinen
Katran Luftschreck wrote:
Natalcya Katla wrote:
In an ideal universe - which is still a long way off, to be sure - every child would be raised and taught by professional and highly motivated caretakers and tutors, in the same environment and with access to the same resources as their peers. They would be neurally mapped with some frequency, to assist their caretakers in seeing to it that each of them would receive the proper training and stimuli to develop their individual talents. This, in turn, would eventually allow them to take their optimal places as highly-functioning members of society.


This is where someone from the Caldari State usually chimes in, yeah? Because isn't this what they already do? They could explain it better.


After my batch was decanted we immediately entered a creche system, which was run by skilled professionals. For the first five years we soaked up corporate orientation and general socialisation lessons. After five the vocational testing and training started. Because my sibkin and I had a specific vocational endgoal in mind, and our training program would be structured accordingly, those who didn't 'pass' our vocational testing effectively washed out of the program and were removed from our group - I later learned that many of them were successful in their alternate vocations.

Around age ten we moved away from completely separated schooling and into the general creche system. This was to encourage us to bond with children outside our sibkin and prevent us from forming an encysted population sub-group. Our training from that point was roughly 50% specialised and 50% generalised. At age 15 I graduated from my program and entered the Peace and Order Unit.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.

Stitcher
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#66 - 2013-11-25 17:13:14 UTC
Makes you wonder why we've never seen a juvenile creche carer become a capsuleer. They'd certainly have the tenacity, poise, multi-tasking skills and sharp powers of observation for it.

I guess after retiring from a stressful career in looking after a class full of toddlers, dealing with capsuleers on a daily basis might seem depressingly familiar.

AKA Hambone

Author of The Deathworlders

Pieter Tuulinen
Societas Imperialis Sceptri Coronaeque
Khimi Harar
#67 - 2013-11-26 04:14:12 UTC
Stitcher wrote:
Makes you wonder why we've never seen a juvenile creche carer become a capsuleer. They'd certainly have the tenacity, poise, multi-tasking skills and sharp powers of observation for it.

I guess after retiring from a stressful career in looking after a class full of toddlers, dealing with capsuleers on a daily basis might seem depressingly familiar.


My theory is that few Juvenile creche leaders actually survive a tour of duty.

For the first time since I started the conversation, he looks me dead in the eye. In his gaze are steel jackhammers, quiet vengeance, a hundred thousand orbital bombs frozen in still life.