These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Naga is now less fail!

Author
Shadowsword
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#21 - 2011-11-15 15:43:58 UTC
The Underdark wrote:
I'm fighting this change for the Missile users, If this goes through they get nothing this winter.

Caldari is a missile race, at least give them hardpoints back, if not any bonus's.


Hardpoints without bonuses would be behond pointless.

And who said a race was specialized in only one weapon type? By your logic, since gallentes are the drones specialists, then hybrids wouldn't belong to anyone.

The Underdark
Perkone
Caldari State
#22 - 2011-11-15 15:49:17 UTC
Shadowsword wrote:
The Underdark wrote:
I'm fighting this change for the Missile users, If this goes through they get nothing this winter.

Caldari is a missile race, at least give them hardpoints back, if not any bonus's.


Hardpoints without bonuses would be behond pointless.

And who said a race was specialized in only one weapon type? By your logic, since gallentes are the drones specialists, then hybrids wouldn't belong to anyone.



Howdy, I corrected myself in the proper Feedback forums, Please see https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=364253#post364253 Balancing feedback topic
Shawn Pierce
Live For This
#23 - 2011-11-15 15:50:48 UTC
Arthur Frayn wrote:
...Oh FINE, here you go.

Whoa ... the new ships aren't naked any more??

Request: Post several pics of each of the new ships at different angles so we can see them in all their textured glory.

My SSD doesn't have enough room for the Singularity client, otherwise I'd take a look myself.
Goose99
#24 - 2011-11-15 16:15:09 UTC
Arthur Frayn wrote:
Missile hardpoints removed.

New bonuses:

Battlecruiser Skill bonus per level:
5% bonus to Large Hybrid Turret damage
10% bonus to Large Hybrid Turret optimal range

Role Bonus:
95% reduction in the powergrid need of Large Hybrid Turrets
50% reduction in the CPU need of Large Hybrid Turrets
50% reduction in the capacitor need of Large Hybrid Turrets

Thankyou CCP. Now the major difference between the Naga and Talos is range vs tracking.


5% bonus to Large Projectile Turret damage
10% bonus to Large Projectile Turret falloff

^It must be fixed thus for the Naga to not suck.Lol
Marl Shawn
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#25 - 2011-11-15 17:50:56 UTC
Jack Miton wrote:
Oh get stuffed....
It's CALDARI, it should have MISSILES.
Hybrids are for gallente FFS.


THIS!
Kietay Ayari
Caldari State
#26 - 2011-11-15 18:31:41 UTC
The Underdark wrote:
soo we have 2 ships with hybrid bonus's? in other-words missile users get nothing this expansion, way to leave people out.

Caldari specialize in missiles, it's only proper that missiles should be on it


Caldari does not specialize in missiles. Caldari are equally hybrid and missiles. Just count the number of missile ships vs hybrid ships they have. So far HALF of the Caldari ships have been semi useless because of how bad hybrids have been combined with the useless range bonus Caldari hybrid ships usually get D:

I want to be able to use ALL of my Caldari ships :D Please give them damage bonuses!

Ferox #1

Thelron
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#27 - 2011-11-15 18:53:40 UTC
Kietay Ayari wrote:
The Underdark wrote:
soo we have 2 ships with hybrid bonus's? in other-words missile users get nothing this expansion, way to leave people out.

Caldari specialize in missiles, it's only proper that missiles should be on it


Caldari does not specialize in missiles. Caldari are equally hybrid and missiles. Just count the number of missile ships vs hybrid ships they have. So far HALF of the Caldari ships have been semi useless because of how bad hybrids have been combined with the useless range bonus Caldari hybrid ships usually get D:

I want to be able to use ALL of my Caldari ships :D Please give them damage bonuses!


Additionally, many of the missile ships can tote some rails along if they want (hey, it works for the guristas... oh... wait...). So, while there is a strong leaning towards missiles they are by no means the end-all-be-all of caldari weapons systems.

Now, BLASTERS can GTFO- that's where the split should be, really. If a caldari ship is getting in someone's face it should be a one-way trip to deliver torpedo-based death (or, if it's a frigate, rocket-based death. Cruisers need not apply), not to fire off blasters. Even that is, to me, questionable (and I love me some torpedo explosions, but really "in your face" just isn't very Caldari- I'd prefer even the frigate level to be more firmly rails/lights than blasters/rockets). So, not terribly surprised to see the siege launchers go.

I *do* think the hardpoints should stay, both for fail-fit giggles (maybe you want a REALLY BIG platform for your AMLs) and to retain the possibility of cruise launchers (really, if there's *such* a worry about people running missions in cruise-nagas set a role bonus that basically breaks cruise missiles against anything smaller than another BC without penalizing them against BS+ (big hit to explo radius but a boost to velocity? or something that actually works with the missile-math).

Damage bonus to rails is an interesting thought, though it makes me wonder where this leaves the Rokh (since both ships have similarly rediculous range, is the BC *really* able to *out*-damage the BS, and if so has CCP indicated if that's where they want things or??? Don't have access to/time to crunch the actual numbers atm...)?
Kietay Ayari
Caldari State
#28 - 2011-11-15 19:18:16 UTC
xD Of course it will out DPS the Rokh. It has the same amount of turrets but with a damage bonus. It will just have 1/10 the tank a Rokh has D: Either way, considering how powerful the Tornado is, the Naga should get both weapon systems as well as a full bonus to both weapon systems. And the Talos and Oracle should get something too, for them to be on par with the Tornado.

Ferox #1

Daergaar
The League of Extraordinary Opportunists
Intergalactic Conservation Movement
#29 - 2011-11-15 19:59:11 UTC
The Underdark wrote:
I'm fighting this change for the Missile users, If this goes through they get nothing this winter.

Caldari is a missile race, at least give them hardpoints back, if not any bonus's.


We actually have enough missle boats, thank you. We don't need another, especially one with a split weapons system with no bonus to missiles. That's what the Rokh is for (and yes I'm aware it's a battleship).

We don't actually have any good hybrid turret battlecruisers yet (the Ferox is not a ship).
Kietay Ayari
Caldari State
#30 - 2011-11-15 20:08:13 UTC
The Rokh is not a split weapons platform... it only has 4 missile hard points so no one in their right mind is ever going to use them. There is no reason to complain if they give it full bonuses for both weapon types like it should have D:

Ferox #1

The Underdark
Perkone
Caldari State
#31 - 2011-11-15 20:09:34 UTC
Daergaar wrote:
The Underdark wrote:
I'm fighting this change for the Missile users, If this goes through they get nothing this winter.

Caldari is a missile race, at least give them hardpoints back, if not any bonus's.


We actually have enough missle boats, thank you. We don't need another, especially one with a split weapons system with no bonus to missiles. That's what the Rokh is for (and yes I'm aware it's a battleship).

We don't actually have any good hybrid turret battlecruisers yet (the Ferox is not a ship).



If you want a good Hybrid ship and you already have the skills for the turrets, just train the measly skills needed to fly a gal BC..

changing a ship type is far FAR less taxing than training a whole new weapon type and all it's specializations
Arthur Frayn
V.O.F.L IRON CORE
#32 - 2011-11-15 22:11:18 UTC  |  Edited by: Arthur Frayn
Jack Miton wrote:
Oh get stuffed....
It's CALDARI, it should have MISSILES.
Hybrids are for gallente FFS.



You sir have been found guilty of being a whining baby and are hereby prohibited from spreading your worthless tainted seed.
Arthur Frayn
V.O.F.L IRON CORE
#33 - 2011-11-15 22:16:46 UTC  |  Edited by: Arthur Frayn
The Underdark wrote:
If you want a good Hybrid ship and you already have the skills for the turrets, just train the measly skills needed to fly a gal BC..


Wrong. Gallente are drone race. Hybrids are their secondary weapon system. You're very glad I caught that one before you looked stupid.
Nimrod Nemesis
Doomheim
#34 - 2011-11-15 22:16:58 UTC
Probably the best choice they could've made, kudoz to Tallest and co. looking forward to sisi tonight.
The Underdark
Perkone
Caldari State
#35 - 2011-11-15 22:20:05 UTC
Arthur Frayn wrote:
The Underdark wrote:
If you want a good Hybrid ship and you already have the skills for the turrets, just train the measly skills needed to fly a gal BC..


Wrong. Gallente are drone race. Hybrids are their secondary weapon system. You're very glad I caught that one before you looked stupid.


are you joking? drones are a variety, utility item. a FEW ships specialize in them, far more Gal ships are suited for Hybrids
Arthur Frayn
V.O.F.L IRON CORE
#36 - 2011-11-15 22:33:15 UTC
The Underdark wrote:
are you joking? drones are a variety, utility item. a FEW ships specialize in them, far more Gal ships are suited for Hybrids


All Gallente battleships have huge dronebays and bandwidth. Gallente cruisers and battlecruisers are the same. Gallente are only race with frigates that have big drone bays and drone damage bonuses. Even the hybrid Caldari/Gallente ships have their primary Gallente bonus being drone damage and huge drone bays.

Gallente carriers are all damage bonus with fighters (just bigger drones). Drones are a primary weapon system. Hybrids are secondary. Same with Caldari. Missiles are primary, hybrids secondary. Doesn't matter that both races have one or two ships built around their secondary weapon systems. So to say Caldari Naga should have missiles is silly. Gallente Talos should be drone boat, by that logic. Hence, Naga is fine as is. You are stupid for not seeing this.

If you want a cheap torp boat, fly a Raven which is awesome for that role. Torps have flight time which means you want a ship that can survive being shot at while the big slow lumbering torps stroll over to the target and BOOM. Torp Naga vs every other tier 3 BC = dead Naga due to other BC being low sig and faster and insta-hit with their guns while torp Naga cries itself to sleep. Torp naga also useless against bigger ships that can insta-hit with guns and smaller ships that torps can't hurt. Naga cries itself to sleep again if CCP listens to your dumb opinion.

You are not smart.
Jennifer Starling
Imperial Navy Forum Patrol
#37 - 2011-11-15 22:40:23 UTC  |  Edited by: Jennifer Starling
Kietay Ayari wrote:
D: I know the tornado is better... but its better than all 3 by miles. I really have no idea why CCP did this... even when they nerfed all 4 the Tornado received the least nerfs :| But minmatar already win everything so as long as its as good as the other two races Im happy! I think a Torp Naga will be a good ratting ship if you are just trying to clear all the battleships!

Yea training large projectile turrets next .. too bad for the torpedoes.
Another niche ship, just what we needed ..

Thanks CCP for rendering a promising ship useless for me for no good reason.
Nimrod Nemesis
Doomheim
#38 - 2011-11-15 22:47:51 UTC
Jennifer Starling wrote:

Thanks CCP for rendering a promising ship useless for me for no good reason.


Really, because of torps? Why the hell would you want a paper-thin glass-cannon sniper that was limited to using torps? Keeping in mind the rigs and painters necessary to get anything out of them, i'm pretty glad that ccp went the hybrid way.
The Underdark
Perkone
Caldari State
#39 - 2011-11-15 22:57:41 UTC
Arthur Frayn wrote:
The Underdark wrote:
are you joking? drones are a variety, utility item. a FEW ships specialize in them, far more Gal ships are suited for Hybrids


All Gallente battleships have huge dronebays and bandwidth. Gallente cruisers and battlecruisers are the same. Gallente are only race with frigates that have big drone bays and drone damage bonuses. Even the hybrid Caldari/Gallente ships have their primary Gallente bonus being drone damage and huge drone bays.

Gallente carriers are all damage bonus with fighters (just bigger drones). Drones are a primary weapon system. Hybrids are secondary. Same with Caldari. Missiles are primary, hybrids secondary. Doesn't matter that both races have one or two ships built around their secondary weapon systems. So to say Caldari Naga should have missiles is silly. Gallente Talos should be drone boat, by that logic. Hence, Naga is fine as is. You are stupid for not seeing this.

If you want a cheap torp boat, fly a Raven which is awesome for that role. Torps have flight time which means you want a ship that can survive being shot at while the big slow lumbering torps stroll over to the target and BOOM. Torp Naga vs every other tier 3 BC = dead Naga due to other BC being low sig and faster and insta-hit with their guns while torp Naga cries itself to sleep. Torp naga also useless against bigger ships that can insta-hit with guns and smaller ships that torps can't hurt. Naga cries itself to sleep again if CCP listens to your dumb opinion.

You are not smart.


Simply because Gal ships can carry drones more often and larger ones does not mean they are primarily drone based. Unless given a specific bonus drones are a small part of the damage for hybrid ships even with heavies compared to Hybrid's output and otherwise they are used as a utility device, ecm, web, anti-frig with damage type variety.. and if you're really going to argue that the main point of Gal carriers is the fighter damage, that's simply rediculous.

This is getting derailed though, this is not a what do Gal use as a primary weapon, It's that every weapon type now has a Over-sized weapon platform except the Missiles. fly a torp raven? yeah sure, except the whole point of these things is to be fast, small and fragile with a TON of damage, neither do they have a single 8x launcher ship.. or hell even launcher models on their ships. Missiles are harder to use in a lot of situations, and considering how fragile these ships are they will be significantly more effective in a fleet with web's, scrams, painters, plenty of utility mod's to enable the torp's / cruise / whatever missile to hit.
Nimrod Nemesis
Doomheim
#40 - 2011-11-15 22:59:28 UTC  |  Edited by: Nimrod Nemesis
The Underdark wrote:
It's that every weapon type now has a Over-sized weapon platform except the Missiles.


Two words: Stealth Bombers.