These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Player Features and Ideas Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Pirate Ship Designs

Author
Jotunspor
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#1 - 2013-08-17 18:27:45 UTC
Alright, now, EVE players who have been around for some time will remember the way Tech 2 ships looked in comparison to their T1 counterparts of the same hull. Basically, T2 variants of ships looked identical, aside from aesthetic changes in the form of colour schemes. Aside from the colour, a T1 and T2 variant of a ship would look identical. However, lately, CCP have changed this for the better. The Kestrel is a perfect example. We've got the T1 standard Kestrel we all know and recognize, and can picture in our minds.

Then, we've got the Manticore, T2 variant. It has the same basic shape and form, mainly hull layout and outline but with a different colour scheme of course, and most importantly; differently-shaped body/outer shell panels. And that's what i love to see.
It really emphasizes the fact that this ship is in fact DIFFERENT, and is NOT your regular Kestrel. It's a Stealth Bomber.


You may be asking "what's he trying to say". Well, basically, with all of that in mind, apply it to the pirate ships. I can't help but feel really disappointed in certain pirate ships for the way they look. We're going back to the days of old, and simply slapping on another colour scheme for pirate ships. I don't think that's good enough. There should be a little more to visually distinguish those ships, and overall make them more special. Certain ships are out of the question, such as all Sansha ships, which easily look the most alien, and have a completely independant design. NO ships look like the Sansha ships. And there are others, such as the Machariel, Cynabal, etc.


The Guristas ships are a perfect example to which you may apply this design idea. We have the Worm, and the Rattlesnake. The Worm is basically a reskinned Merlin, while a Rattlesnake is a reskinned Scorpion. CCP should really take pirate ships such as these, that are basically reskins of T1 variant ships, and bring out a bit more personality and define them more through design.

Some certain parts of the ship body could be re-shaped into new forms to really distinguish these ships from their T1, non-pirate, Empire variants.



Again, that's fine if they look SOMEWHAT like their T1 variants, but again, go back to what i said about the Kestrel, and apply it to the pirate ships. Make these pirate ships more distinct. Reshape those body panels, give them more character. They are pirate ships, after all. Everything from the Worm, to the Vindicator. Every single ship that simply is a T1 reskin.

This really should happen. All pirate ships based off of a T1 variant look too similar. We've going back to the old, inferior days of EVE in terms of ship design; all applied to just the pirate ships. We need to make this a thing of the past as well.

Keep the overall shape and structure, but reshape those body panels a bit, distinguish these pirate variants of T1 Empire ships a bit more. Give it the Kestrel treatment, or any empire T2 variant ship that was changed physically in a similar manner. Doing away with the lazy repainting treatment. These ships must be even more specialized than they already are. The finishing touch is the physical look being given a good once-over.
Katia Echerie
The Tuskers
The Tuskers Co.
#2 - 2013-08-17 18:35:23 UTC
I'm sure they will get to it eventually. I'm more concerned with balance. Pirate ships in general should be awesome to fly. Some already are but some are absolute trash (Worm, Succubus - I'm looking at you). I rather have them rebalance and tweak those ships so they are all awesome to fly for a reason than give them new models.
Harvey James
The Sengoku Legacy
#3 - 2013-08-17 18:41:19 UTC
Indeed ... i think CCP feel the same at least about T2 anyway the problem is the long gaps between each batch of changes its simply too slow they need to invest more into the art department to allow for quicker and more frequent changes.

Guristas .. should have a tougher more heavily plated look to them to represent the tankiness of them and more prominent drone bays too boot...

Serpentis .. are all about damage dealing so more aggressive hunkier meaner looking ships would be nice.

Blood Raider ... the Cruor and Ashimmu look good actually the Bhaalgorn needs to follow their looks.

T3's need to be versatile so no rigs are necessary ... they should not have OP dps and tank

ABC's should be T2, remove drone assist, separate HAM's and Torps range, -3 HS for droneboats

Nerf web strength, Make the blaster Eagle worth using

Cade Windstalker
#4 - 2013-08-17 18:48:49 UTC
If CCP ever gave me a Mordu's skinned Rokh hull I think I would be too busy whooping for joy to be arsed about not having some new ship hull that took months more to develop.

On that note, you all might want to look at this thread over here where there is a discussion about what ships need to be remodeled. There's also some useful info from the art devs. Link is to first blue post for simplicity of clicking through to other blue posts (click the ribbon on the portrait for next blue post in thread).
Kirimeena D'Zbrkesbris
Republic Military Tax Avoiders
#5 - 2013-08-17 19:12:10 UTC
Jotunspor wrote:
~wall of text~

TL;DR.

You typed that wall of text just to say that pirate ships need unique models?

Opinions are like assholes. Everybody got one and everyone thinks everyone else's stinks.

Jotunspor
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#6 - 2013-08-17 19:22:57 UTC
Harvey James wrote:
Indeed ... i think CCP feel the same at least about T2 anyway the problem is the long gaps between each batch of changes its simply too slow they need to invest more into the art department to allow for quicker and more frequent changes.



Guristas .. should have a tougher more heavily plated look to them to represent the tankiness of them and more prominent drone bays too boot...



Serpentis .. are all about damage dealing so more aggressive hunkier meaner looking ships would be nice.

Blood Raider ... the Cruor and Ashimmu look good actually the Bhaalgorn needs to follow their looks.







Well, i think you missed my point once you started talking about the Blood ships. Remember, i'm saying that all ships that are not unique, must change, and look more distinct, instead of just looking like a reskin/repaint.

As far as i know, both the Cruor and Ashimmu are completely unique designs.

I'm talking specifically about all ships that are T1 reskins. The Vindicator, Rattlesnake, Worm, etc, etc.



Those Blood ships are completely unique. Although we can't say the same about the Bhaalgorn. Again, just a reskinned T1.

HOWEVER... that being said, now that you've mentioned it, some pirate ships do look whoopty. But that's a subject of debate, naturally...



The Cynabal, i hate the way it looks. It just... looks like a metallic blob of poop that's been freeze-dried, then bent downwards. Big smile Sorry, but there's no other way to describe it :D. It's.. it's like a pastry-turned spaceship. Lol

We should start calling it the Cinnabon.

Sarkelias Anophius
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#7 - 2013-08-17 19:57:10 UTC
Jotunspor wrote:
Harvey James wrote:
Indeed ... i think CCP feel the same at least about T2 anyway the problem is the long gaps between each batch of changes its simply too slow they need to invest more into the art department to allow for quicker and more frequent changes.



Guristas .. should have a tougher more heavily plated look to them to represent the tankiness of them and more prominent drone bays too boot...



Serpentis .. are all about damage dealing so more aggressive hunkier meaner looking ships would be nice.

Blood Raider ... the Cruor and Ashimmu look good actually the Bhaalgorn needs to follow their looks.







Well, i think you missed my point once you started talking about the Blood ships. Remember, i'm saying that all ships that are not unique, must change, and look more distinct, instead of just looking like a reskin/repaint.

As far as i know, both the Cruor and Ashimmu are completely unique designs.

I'm talking specifically about all ships that are T1 reskins. The Vindicator, Rattlesnake, Worm, etc, etc.



Those Blood ships are completely unique. Although we can't say the same about the Bhaalgorn. Again, just a reskinned T1.

HOWEVER... that being said, now that you've mentioned it, some pirate ships do look whoopty. But that's a subject of debate, naturally...



The Cynabal, i hate the way it looks. It just... looks like a metallic blob of poop that's been freeze-dried, then bent downwards. Big smile Sorry, but there's no other way to describe it :D. It's.. it's like a pastry-turned spaceship. Lol

We should start calling it the Cinnabon.



I have referred to this ship exclusively as the "Cinnabon" both in and out of game for nearly two years.
Jotunspor
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#8 - 2013-08-17 20:11:06 UTC
Sarkelias Anophius wrote:
[

I have referred to this ship exclusively as the "Cinnabon" both in and out of game for nearly two years.



Oh, ok. Great, so it's not just me. Lol

Not the best looking ship in EVE, if you ask me.

Could use a makeover.
Silivar Karkun
Doomheim
#9 - 2013-08-17 20:13:37 UTC
the only pirate ship that has been remodeled this days was the daredevil, it looks really cool now. i agree with the OP that pirate ships should have unique hull designs, or be like the bombers, and have some parts that make players remember that some of these ships are heavily modified versions of certain empires hulls.

worm, gila and rattlesnake along with the vindicator and vigilant would enter in that type of remodelation, due to lore origins (their creators robbed the blueprints of these ships and experimented with them in order to make them what they are now). while the bhaalgorn needs a complete remodelation that reflects the bloodraider style (the description of the ship doesnt state if it was created from scratch or if it was the product of stealing an armageddon design so it has sense to make it a unique hull instead of a modified one)
Alex Tutuola
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#10 - 2013-08-17 20:21:06 UTC
I think it would be sort of neat to see "uglies" in EVE. Ships where you can see that the pirates took the regular factions' ships, cut them up, and slapped different ones together, along with some other parts just for good measure. Want the dragon head from the stabber, and the body of a moa? (Hint: nobody wants this) Sold! Guardian Angel ship! :)
Jureth22
State War Academy
Caldari State
#11 - 2013-08-17 21:23:09 UTC
Katia Echerie wrote:
I'm sure they will get to it eventually. I'm more concerned with balance. Pirate ships in general should be awesome to fly. Some already are but some are absolute trash (Worm, Succubus - I'm looking at you). I rather have them rebalance and tweak those ships so they are all awesome to fly for a reason than give them new models.


cruor,ashimu,phantasm,nightmare,gila etc :D
Harvey James
The Sengoku Legacy
#12 - 2013-08-17 21:26:58 UTC
well when i spoke about the blood raiders ships ... i kind of meant that the Bhaalgorn should match the ashimmu and cruor design as they look nice and sleek and i like the colour scheme

T3's need to be versatile so no rigs are necessary ... they should not have OP dps and tank

ABC's should be T2, remove drone assist, separate HAM's and Torps range, -3 HS for droneboats

Nerf web strength, Make the blaster Eagle worth using

Solhild
Doomheim
#13 - 2013-08-18 12:39:05 UTC
Harvey James wrote:
well when i spoke about the blood raiders ships ... i kind of meant that the Bhaalgorn should match the ashimmu and cruor design as they look nice and sleek and i like the colour scheme


I think the Bhaalgorn sort of does, maybe a slight update to freshen it up is all. The Armageddon and variants should get another model to be closer to other Amarr BS designs.