These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Market Discussions

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Financial Fraud, Cartels, Monopoly, API's and you.

First post First post
Author
Rhodopsin Pserad
Ho Theos Geometrei
#201 - 2013-07-12 19:30:19 UTC  |  Edited by: Rhodopsin Pserad
X ATM092 wrote:
Rhodopsin Pserad wrote:
X ATM092 wrote:
Likewise I don't need my dragon to get to work every day. Doesn't mean God should remove dragons as an exploit.


I'm not a dev, it's just a mechanism included in game which ensures I will not spend another penny. Supply and demand, I demand fair market info from an MMO, CCP doesn't want to supply that. Therefore I pay them nothing more. But I paid for six months, so I can be annoying until then at least.

You missed the point of the dragon metaphor. God doesn't need to nerf dragons to stop me flying my dragon to work because I don't actually fly my dragon to work because I don't have a dragon and nor does anyone else. Likewise CCP don't need to remove financial APIs to stop dragons assembling databases and becoming EVE tycoons because the dragons that run the databases exist only in your head.

On the other hand, I'm arguing with a person who, when I claimed that I flew to work by dragon, thought "sounds legit".


No, they don't exist only in my head. Especially, as I see, the APIs stream data to you rather than giving it you as a predetermined UI. So you don't even need to bother copying and pasting to assemble a database.

Yes, I clearly stated that I think you fly a dragon... honestly, I thought it was a ship in game possibly...

My favorite part is the people who make the websites that access the information for you - they've got to be the ones with the best API databases.

Now I know why CCP didn't fire the guy that was seeding BPO's to his corp that worked for the company.

"Does the Eagle know what is in the pit, Or wilt thou go ask the Mole? Can Wisdom be put in a silver rod, Or Love in a golden bowl?"  "Above all, you can believe in Providence in either of two ways, either as thirst believes in the orange, or as the ass believes in the whip."

Entity
X-Factor Industries
Synthetic Existence
#202 - 2013-07-12 19:32:01 UTC
Rhivre wrote:
Entity wrote:
[quote=Rhodopsin Pserad]

I'd say "Can I have your stuff" but you probably don't have anything.



You only know that cos you datamined the API.

Admit it.

You are in on this to....it goes all the way to the......well, somewhere


Oh darn, my secret is out. I built my multi-trillion ISK wealth on the financial corpses of all the dunces that provided me with their API details. I didn't actually make any sensible investments and profitable trades.

╦......║...╔╗.║.║.╔╗.╦║.╔╗╔╦╗╔╗

║.╔╗╔╗╔╣.╔╗╠..╠ ╠╗╠╝.║╠ ╠╝║║║╚╗

╩═╚╝║.╚╝.╚╝║..╚╝║║╚╝.╩╚╝╚╝║.║╚╝

Got Item?

X ATM092
The Hatchery
RAZOR Alliance
#203 - 2013-07-12 19:32:42 UTC
Oh, not real imaginary dragons, that'd be absurd. You think I flew to my real job on a fictional in game spaceship dragon. Well okay then. Thanks for clearing that one up.

So the villains in this story are the coders who make third party tools like evemon which are pretty much essential to the playing of eve? Although I'm not sure you know what evemon is. But if you do it'll break your mind.
Zaxix
State War Academy
Caldari State
#204 - 2013-07-12 19:33:32 UTC
WTF? You haven't addressed the quote in which you contradict yourself. I was looking forward to it!

Bokononist

 

arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#205 - 2013-07-12 19:39:33 UTC
Entity wrote:
Rhodopsin Pserad wrote:
X ATM092 wrote:
Likewise I don't need my dragon to get to work every day. Doesn't mean God should remove dragons as an exploit.


I'm not a dev so I won't be making any changes to the game, it's just a mechanism included in game which ensures I will not spend another penny. Supply and demand, I demand fair market info from an MMO, CCP doesn't want to supply that. Therefore I pay them nothing more. But I paid for six months, so I can be annoying until then at least.


I'd say "Can I have your stuff" but you probably don't have anything.


DUDE, there is a line! take a number...
I was here first Evil

Troll for hire. Cheap prices.

arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#206 - 2013-07-12 19:40:25 UTC
Zaxix wrote:
WTF? You haven't addressed the quote in which you contradict yourself. I was looking forward to it!


You should write it in caps, only way he sees it Big smileBig smile

Troll for hire. Cheap prices.

Rhodopsin Pserad
Ho Theos Geometrei
#207 - 2013-07-12 19:50:42 UTC
I'm fine with unfair pvp mechanics - just like you play on the PvP server at WoW and that guy 40 levels above you drops out of the sky and one shots you. And then does it again several times every time you come back to life. And then moves on to terrorize the next unsuspecting lowbie. I'm fine with the risk that my 75 mil cargo will get blown up in my Mark V. I'm fine with people cargo scanning me. Those all, to me, seem like regular game mechanics that one would expect. Just like if I sign up for the minecraft server with no protections, someone might come steal all my diamonds.

People will play unbalanced games, but few players want to play fixed games.

"Does the Eagle know what is in the pit, Or wilt thou go ask the Mole? Can Wisdom be put in a silver rod, Or Love in a golden bowl?"  "Above all, you can believe in Providence in either of two ways, either as thirst believes in the orange, or as the ass believes in the whip."

Rhivre
TarNec
Invisible Exchequer
#208 - 2013-07-12 19:51:06 UTC  |  Edited by: Rhivre
Rhodopsin Pserad wrote:


I didn't say one "needs" it... in fact, I specifically said they don't need it... which is why it should be removed because it's an exploit.

You can only look in the hanger if your corp has an office there, and if the player hasn't stashed all their stuff in containers. MMO's that demand I submit my account status in the form of assets, finances, and inventory to other players aren't ones that I will participate in in that way. Neither the Gallente nor the Calderi would approve of APIs either... the former because it interfereces with a person's independence and the latter because it interferes with a free-market.


No one forces you to hand over your API.....which, if you could stop slamming the keyboard for a second you would understand.

I would love for you to point me to an MMO which FORCES you to hand over your account status to players. That would require actual factual evidence instead of screaming on a forum with your fingers in your ears.

As someone who has, in your own words, studied hard science, you will be familiar with the scientific method. If this knowledge was removed from you via mind control, allow me to re-enlighten you as to the process:

First:
We formulate a question, multiple questions are also possible

1)"Why do people want my API"
2) "Do I HAVE to give my API?"
3) "What can it be used for"

Second;

We formulate a hypothesis, this is an educated guess, but is still pure conjecture

1) "Because they want to mine my data and steal my trade secrets"
2) "Yes, in every circumstance"
3) "The only use of this is to get rich through my data"

Third:

We make predictions based on our hypothesis

1) "If this is the case, then other people will know about it"
2) "I will not be able to find other people who have never handed over an API and are in a corp or trading, or participating in Eve"
3) "I will not find any other uses of the API, especially on a personal level"

Fourth:

We test the hypothesis

There are several ways to test the aforementioned hypotheses, in this case, I would recommend the following courses of action:
* Ask Google about "Eve Online API Key"
* Ask people who have actually got their API key
* Ask people who know about Eve whether it is compulsory, or I am forced in any way to hand over my API key.
*Read around the Eve Technology Lab forum for developers who use the API in their apps, if I dont understand what an API is and how it can be used, ask someone who knows about coding apps.
* Ask people who are responsible for managing API keys
* Install a program by which I can see my own API key, and try out the various functions, and discover their limitations

Fifth

Having collected the data from the testing, we analyse the results and see if they correlate in any way to our initial preditions.

If not, because we are scientists, and not newsreaders, we have to reject the initial hypothesis, and attempt to formulate a new one.


Now, as you are a learned individual, with vast stores of knowledge, you will of course, have followed these simple steps, and will be able to provide me, and the rest of this forum with evidence to back up your claims, because, if not, then you are merely restating the same opinion over and over in the hope that doing so makes it true.

Carl Sagan called this the invisible dragon in the garage.


EDIT: And yes, I know the horse is about to reach Nirvana, but I hear the leather improves with each level gained, and I am hoping for Exotic Leather and Prismatic Scales on the next drop
arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#209 - 2013-07-12 19:53:36 UTC
Rhodopsin Pserad wrote:
I'm fine with unfair pvp mechanics - just like you play on the PvP server at WoW and that guy 40 levels above you drops out of the sky and one shots you. And then does it again several times every time you come back to life. And then moves on to terrorize the next unsuspecting lowbie. I'm fine with the risk that my 75 mil cargo will get blown up in my Mark V. I'm fine with people cargo scanning me. Those all, to me, seem like regular game mechanics that one would expect. Just like if I sign up for the minecraft server with no protections, someone might come steal all my diamonds.

People will play unbalanced games, but few players want to play fixed games.


How about you got back to WOW and help raise the average IQ of both games then? Blink

Isn't the Casino is "fixed" too, but BEHOLD! people still play there...


Troll for hire. Cheap prices.

arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#210 - 2013-07-12 20:02:41 UTC
Rhivre wrote:
[quote=Rhodopsin Pserad]

EDIT: And yes, I know the horse is about to reach Nirvana, but I hear the leather improves with each level gained, and I am hoping for Exotic Leather and Prismatic Scales on the next drop


Beg your pardon, Is that the horse you were talking about??
I think i saw him pass in front of CCP Headquarters screaming "let me go demons, leave me alone"... Big smile

Troll for hire. Cheap prices.

Rhivre
TarNec
Invisible Exchequer
#211 - 2013-07-12 20:12:11 UTC
arabella blood wrote:


Beg your pardon, Is that the horse you were talking about??
I think i saw him pass in front of CCP Headquarters screaming "let me go demons, leave me alone"... Big smile


No, that was the other horse, 4 incarnations ago, now it is something like this.

Horsey!
arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#212 - 2013-07-12 20:15:46 UTC
Rhivre wrote:
arabella blood wrote:


Beg your pardon, Is that the horse you were talking about??
I think i saw him pass in front of CCP Headquarters screaming "let me go demons, leave me alone"... Big smile


No, that was the other horse, 4 incarnations ago, now it is something like this.

Horsey!


OP, Keanu got something to tell you: http://i.qkme.me/3v5qpp.jpg

Troll for hire. Cheap prices.

Rhodopsin Pserad
Ho Theos Geometrei
#213 - 2013-07-13 04:46:56 UTC  |  Edited by: Rhodopsin Pserad
arabella blood wrote:
Rhodopsin Pserad wrote:
I'm fine with unfair pvp mechanics - just like you play on the PvP server at WoW and that guy 40 levels above you drops out of the sky and one shots you. And then does it again several times every time you come back to life. And then moves on to terrorize the next unsuspecting lowbie. I'm fine with the risk that my 75 mil cargo will get blown up in my Mark V. I'm fine with people cargo scanning me. Those all, to me, seem like regular game mechanics that one would expect. Just like if I sign up for the minecraft server with no protections, someone might come steal all my diamonds.

People will play unbalanced games, but few players want to play fixed games.


How about you got back to WOW and help raise the average IQ of both games then? Blink

Isn't the Casino is "fixed" too, but BEHOLD! people still play there...




Who said I'm in favor of Casinos? I picked Amarr - Khanid - Zealot.

Blackjack is a fair game, and poker is a fair game as long as you don't have players at the same table working together... other than that, unless you're relatively wealthy, I had really wished there were an option in FO: NV to level the strip at the end.

"Does the Eagle know what is in the pit, Or wilt thou go ask the Mole? Can Wisdom be put in a silver rod, Or Love in a golden bowl?"  "Above all, you can believe in Providence in either of two ways, either as thirst believes in the orange, or as the ass believes in the whip."

Rhodopsin Pserad
Ho Theos Geometrei
#214 - 2013-07-13 04:58:14 UTC
Zaxix wrote:
WTF? You haven't addressed the quote in which you contradict yourself. I was looking forward to it!


I only feed trolls that are entertaining. If you think that I think dragons are real, you're the dupe.

"Does the Eagle know what is in the pit, Or wilt thou go ask the Mole? Can Wisdom be put in a silver rod, Or Love in a golden bowl?"  "Above all, you can believe in Providence in either of two ways, either as thirst believes in the orange, or as the ass believes in the whip."

Rhodopsin Pserad
Ho Theos Geometrei
#215 - 2013-07-13 05:22:24 UTC
Rhivre wrote:
[quote=Rhodopsin Pserad]

.....[removed for character limit]

First:
We formulate a question, multiple questions are also possible

1)"Why do people want my API"
2) "Do I HAVE to give my API?"
3) "What can it be used for"

Second;

We formulate a hypothesis, this is an educated guess, but is still pure conjecture

1) "Because they want to mine my data and steal my trade secrets"
2) "Yes, in every circumstance"
3) "The only use of this is to get rich through my data"

Third:

We make predictions based on our hypothesis

1) "If this is the case, then other people will know about it"
2) "I will not be able to find other people who have never handed over an API and are in a corp or trading, or participating in Eve"
3) "I will not find any other uses of the API, especially on a personal level"

Fourth:

We test the hypothesis

There are several ways to test the aforementioned hypotheses, in this case, I would recommend the following courses of action:
* Ask Google about "Eve Online API Key"
* Ask people who have actually got their API key
* Ask people who know about Eve whether it is compulsory, or I am forced in any way to hand over my API key.
*Read around the Eve Technology Lab forum for developers who use the API in their apps, if I dont understand what an API is and how it can be used, ask someone who knows about coding apps.
* Ask people who are responsible for managing API keys
* Install a program by which I can see my own API key, and try out the various functions, and discover their limitations

Fifth

Having collected the data from the testing, we analyse the results and see if they correlate in any way to our initial preditions.

If not, because we are scientists, and not newsreaders, we have to reject the initial hypothesis, and attempt to formulate a new one.


Now, as you are a learned individual, with vast stores of knowledge, you will of course, have followed these simple steps, and will be able to provide me, and the rest of this forum with evidence to back up your claims, because, if not, then you are merely restating the same opinion over and over in the hope that doing so makes it true.

Carl Sagan called this the invisible dragon in the garage.


EDIT: And yes, I know the horse is about to reach Nirvana, but I hear the leather improves with each level gained, and I am hoping for Exotic Leather and Prismatic Scales on the next drop


Firstly, I never said the only use was to get rich. As I stated, it can also be used to simply muscle people out of markets. It can be used to spy on other players through seeing what they bought from that player. It can be used to determine data not otherwise available in game, such as specific price differences between stations rather than only getting a regional overview presented in game. And, yes, it can be used for checking whether people were somehow stupid enough to transfer large sums of money from an alt to their character because they've been assigned to spy on you and are otherwise pretending to be a noob. After all, I'm so nefariously conniving that, having played the game for so long, that if I'm going to create a character to spy on a corp and having subsequently made the mistake of somehow polluting my finances with evidence that I was a spy, that fourteen days is really a lot of time lost in comparison to the six years I've been playing...

Secondly, one doesn't and cannot apply the direct deductive scientific method to most questions of sociology, or, more specifically, one doesn't apply deductive reasoning to things for which empirical data is out of reach, destroyed, or inherently non-existent. I cannot hack peoples' computers or API service websites as that is both illegal and beyond my skillset to empirically gather data. And, nobody would admit to having large databases of Eve financial info.

Thirdly, I don't need to test every molecule in the universe to believe they're all made of atoms which are all composed of neutrons, protons, and electrons (the most-abundant hydrogen isotope doesn't have a neutron, being the exception to those compositional components). This is the principle of falsifiability. When things exist so frequently in nature that they become, essentially, rules by which things operate, one can safely infer that the law is applicable everywhere.

Fourthly, Eve is about abuse of game mechanics for advantage, API collection of financial info creates a substantial dataset from which information not regularly provided in game can be gleaned, such as, as I stated, price gradients across individual stations (though most of this can also be inferred simply by aging numbers of players in the region, agent missions present in the area, etc - but that requires actual work - not just having everyone hand over their transaction history).

Fifthly, I clearly didn't hand out my financial API as I believe it is nefarious, this does not exempt the unfair advantage other players can get by data-mining them from those who are careless with their assets and financials, henceforth creating an unfair market. Of course, things which are unfair are part of Eve, but things like that are game-breakingly unfair in my view.

Sixth, I posted here to alert people to the possibility of data abuse from the financials. This is under the uninformed assumption that it doesn't truncate in any way what I see in game from my transaction history. On that, I could be wrong and will investigate further, but I somehow doubt it does truncate that.

(update) I see here that it most certainly includes that information I am most concerned about, station locations and client names: http://wiki.eveonline.com/en/wiki/EVE_API_Character_Wallet_Transactions

"Does the Eagle know what is in the pit, Or wilt thou go ask the Mole? Can Wisdom be put in a silver rod, Or Love in a golden bowl?"  "Above all, you can believe in Providence in either of two ways, either as thirst believes in the orange, or as the ass believes in the whip."

arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#216 - 2013-07-13 08:04:00 UTC
Rhodopsin Pserad wrote:



Sixth, I posted here to alert people to the possibility of data abuse from the financials.



I know what we should do.
As this is concerning the entire population of new eden, i believe we are entitled to move this thread to GD by a GM.
This way we can alert everyone that API are used to review your data!!

(and also everyone can join laughing at op Twisted)

Troll for hire. Cheap prices.

RAW23
#217 - 2013-07-13 09:32:23 UTC
The fact that this thread is still alive is a testament to how quiet MD has become recently. Sadly, this is the most entertaining thread there has been for weeks. It has to be said, though, that whether troll or not the OP is good value.

There are two types of EVE player:

those who believe there are two types of EVE player and those who do not.

arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#218 - 2013-07-13 09:46:38 UTC
RAW23 wrote:
The fact that this thread is still alive is a testament to how quiet MD has become recently. Sadly, this is the most entertaining thread there has been for weeks. It has to be said, though, that whether troll or not the OP is good value.



We should keep him as a jester and pay him with trit!!!

Troll for hire. Cheap prices.

Caleb Ayrania
TarNec
Invisible Exchequer
#219 - 2013-07-14 00:06:09 UTC
arabella blood wrote:
RAW23 wrote:
The fact that this thread is still alive is a testament to how quiet MD has become recently. Sadly, this is the most entertaining thread there has been for weeks. It has to be said, though, that whether troll or not the OP is good value.



We should keep him as a jester and pay him with trit!!!


I had no idea Jesters could eat TRT.

arabella blood
Keyboard Jihad
#220 - 2013-07-14 03:21:47 UTC
Caleb Ayrania wrote:
arabella blood wrote:
RAW23 wrote:
The fact that this thread is still alive is a testament to how quiet MD has become recently. Sadly, this is the most entertaining thread there has been for weeks. It has to be said, though, that whether troll or not the OP is good value.



We should keep him as a jester and pay him with trit!!!


I had no idea Jesters could eat TRT.



They can't. But ours is special, his jester's hat is made of tinfoil...
Besides, he could possible trady it, and make a million a day!!!

Troll for hire. Cheap prices.