These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

Wormhole K162: Understanding the Mechanism [ALXVP public release]

Author
Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#21 - 2013-05-12 16:27:00 UTC
So essentially life in Anoikis did come from the known cluster, but it wasn't a fungus or prion that was being quarantined.

So what was? As I hinted at earlier, reverse-engineers who engage in the tech-three shipbuilding industry know the Sleepers were probably advanced in the areas of cryogenics and virtual reality. If the Sleepers really can just "sleep" and preserve their minds over a period of thousands of years within a virtual reality then it seems to me that their civilization would have been much less vulnerable to biological threats at all.

Why would a group such as the Sleepers need to quarantine microbial threats when they could likely have just place themselves in stasis?

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Gosakumori Noh
Coven of One
#22 - 2013-05-12 17:11:04 UTC
Ollie Rundle wrote:
The publically available data on Kyonoke is very limited. What information we do have suggests it is likely to be a prion - a misfolded protein that acts independently of reliance on nucleic acids (in contrast to bacterial, viral, parasitic and fungal agents).


Are you suggesting that Kyonoke evolved to be "as virulent as they come," presenting "no safe means of containment" through a natural process?
Ollie Rundle
#23 - 2013-05-12 23:22:13 UTC
Streya Jormagdnir wrote:
Why would a group such as the Sleepers need to quarantine microbial threats when they could likely have just place themselves in stasis?

What did they quarantine themselves from? That's the golden question which remains unanswered.

It's interesting that the Alobe virus is linked with a near-extinction level event that cost billions of lives in the distant past. It's of greater interest that a variant of that same virus exists in Ani constellation to this day, the only known space constellation where Sleeper ruins have been identified. However your conclusion that biologicals would present a limited threat to an infomorph society is quite reasonable.

So was whatever threat the Sleepers quarantined themselves against non-biological? Theoretically a society sufficiently advanced to exist predominantly as infomorphs may have faced dangers which we are now only just beginning to encounter. What happens if a networked virus is introduced into such a society? On a speculative basis, how would an emergent AI evolving within an infomorph society develop and what might be the reaction to it from the inhabitants of that society? Would a technological 'threat' adequately explain why no conclusive evidence of a biological one has been found yet?

The golden question, as I said.

Gosakumori Noh wrote:
Are you suggesting that Kyonoke evolved to be "as virulent as they come," presenting "no safe means of containment" through a natural process?

With regards to Kyonoke I didn't suggest anything save for my points on why I find it difficult to rationalise Kyonoke - weaponised or otherwise - with the decline of Sleeper civilisation in w-space. I presented the (limited) known information on the Kyonoke speck and my reasoning in order to answer Streya's question.

My own position on Kyonoke's origin remains undecided.

Extrapolating on our existing knowledge of prions we know that they usually present with neuro-degenerative disease and that they are invariably fatal. It should be noted that prions - being misfolded proteins - do evolve naturally, usually through mutation or means which help them avoid inherent biological repair mechanisms. Whether this explains Kyonoke or not is up for debate.

Perhaps you have some primary data that is not available to the public at large which supports your own theories. If so, would you consider presenting it?
Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#24 - 2013-05-13 00:04:31 UTC
Ollie Rundle wrote:

What did they quarantine themselves from? That's the golden question which remains unanswered.

It's interesting that the Alobe virus is linked with a near-extinction level event that cost billions of lives in the distant past. It's of greater interest that a variant of that same virus exists in Ani constellation to this day, the only known space constellation where Sleeper ruins have been identified. However your conclusion that biologicals would present a limited threat to an infomorph society is quite reasonable.

So was whatever threat the Sleepers quarantined themselves against non-biological? Theoretically a society sufficiently advanced to exist predominantly as infomorphs may have faced dangers which we are now only just beginning to encounter. What happens if a networked virus is introduced into such a society? On a speculative basis, how would an emergent AI evolving within an infomorph society develop and what might be the reaction to it from the inhabitants of that society? Would a technological 'threat' adequately explain why no conclusive evidence of a biological one has been found yet?

The golden question, as I said.



I believe we could more easily test for a network-virus or emergent AI since there is a ton of Sleeper databases, data shards, and libraries being found by capsuleers all the time. With a sample size potentially as large as every bit of Sleeper computing technology on the market, the signs of an electronic-based infestation or attack should be tell-tale and widespread.

Has anyone deciphered Sleeper computing systems enough to determine whether or not the "disease" could have been a network-virus or emergent AI? We should at least rule out as many variables as possible if we're going to speculate further on what the Sleeper were quarantining..

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Ollie Rundle
#25 - 2013-05-13 00:26:55 UTC
Streya Jormagdnir wrote:
Has anyone deciphered Sleeper computing systems enough to determine whether or not the "disease" could have been a network-virus or emergent AI?

To my knowledge the answer is no, or at least any findings along these lines have not been opened to the public. A simple pilot study design might be to analyse whether sites - particularly quarantine sites - within a single system are networked or isolated from each other.
Gosakumori Noh
Coven of One
#26 - 2013-05-13 00:53:06 UTC
Ollie Rundle wrote:
It should be noted that prions - being misfolded proteins - do evolve naturally, usually through mutation or means which help them avoid inherent biological repair mechanisms.


An organism that kills within minutes is not challenged by inherent biological repair mechanisms; and consequently, circumventing such mechanisms would seem an unlikely catalyst for mutating to its present state. It is either a weapon or a miracle; and if it is a weapon, it was fashioned by a civilization that predates our own.

It is of course possible Kyonoke is both a weapon and *not* responsible for eviscerating the Sleepers.

But the fact capsuleers have not found it in Anoikis is not particularly compelling. Capsuleers were not the ones who found it in Taisy. Perhaps members of that new breed of mercenary soldier will be the first to enter places where it is hidden. I also seem to recall that Kuvakei took sufficient interest in it to raid Taisy through a "Sleeper-like" wormhole shortly after bursting back onto the scene.

He might "shed some light" on its True Nature. I would tickle Tibby for a clue or two, but that never works.
Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#27 - 2013-05-13 00:58:38 UTC
Ollie Rundle wrote:
Streya Jormagdnir wrote:
Has anyone deciphered Sleeper computing systems enough to determine whether or not the "disease" could have been a network-virus or emergent AI?

To my knowledge the answer is no, or at least any findings along these lines have not been opened to the public. A simple pilot study design might be to analyse whether sites - particularly quarantine sites - within a single system are networked or isolated from each other.


I agree. If the installations are not networked with one another, they might be air-gapped in order to preserve network integrity against a viral attack or rampant AI. If the installations are not air-gapped, we can at least conclude that the Sleepers were not concerned about an electronic infestation of any sort. If the installations are isolated from one another then the likelihood that the Sleepers were attempting to quarantine an cyber-attack or rampant AI increases.

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Ollie Rundle
#28 - 2013-05-13 03:03:09 UTC
Gosakumori Noh wrote:
An organism that kills within minutes is not challenged by inherent biological repair mechanisms; and consequently, circumventing such mechanisms would seem an unlikely catalyst for mutating to its present state. It is either a weapon or a miracle; and if it is a weapon, it was fashioned by a civilization that predates our own.

It is of course possible Kyonoke is both a weapon and *not* responsible for eviscerating the Sleepers.

But the fact capsuleers have not found it in Anoikis is not particularly compelling. Capsuleers were not the ones who found it in Taisy. Perhaps members of that new breed of mercenary soldier will be the first to enter places where it is hidden. I also seem to recall that Kuvakei took sufficient interest in it to raid Taisy through a "Sleeper-like" wormhole shortly after bursting back onto the scene.

Technically, the only available data we have suggests it's not an organism but rather a lifeless protein speck. There are a number of hypotheses available for how prions develop, cause disease and even some which try to establish whether they cause disease themselves or are the symptoms of some other agent. There is also the dual nature of the speck which has added further obstacles to research into it.

I agree that a single point does not an argument make. You will note, however, that I made three related observations all of which I think add to the weight of the specific argument against Kyonoke as the Sleeper killer. I maintain that the question of whether it was weaponised or naturally occurring - a separate topic - remains unanswered.

You are correct in noting the Nation raid on the Taisy system in May YC112. Despite correspondence to Gurista loyalist alliances suggesting the raid was successful in obtaining Kyonoke samples or data no documented applications of the speck have been recorded since that day.

So as not to derail the intent of Streya's topic further and presuming you find it acceptable I'm happy to discuss anything relating to these points with you in private or in a separate thread.

Gosakumori Noh
Coven of One
#29 - 2013-05-13 04:40:40 UTC
Streya Jormagdnir wrote:
I agree. If the installations are not networked with one another, they might be air-gapped in order to preserve network integrity against a viral attack or rampant AI. If the installations are not air-gapped, we can at least conclude that the Sleepers were not concerned about an electronic infestation of any sort. If the installations are isolated from one another then the likelihood that the Sleepers were attempting to quarantine an cyber-attack or rampant AI increases.


At least some of the installations are (or were) networked. Arriving at the location known as "The Line," I observed:

"Long-range scanning reveals a chaotic line of asteroids and debris, stretching out endlessly as it twists onwards into the darkness. Upon arrival, it seems as if the place is empty and has been for quite some time. There is the sense however, that it was not always this way. Huge amounts of data are passing through the area, as if there was once a receiver for it somewhere nearby."

I am curious as to why a civilization in torpor would need to transmit so much information; and why such a sophisticated operation's network protocols would have failed to detect the absence of a receiver.

All of this is almost enough to make me want to flit around inside wormholes again, though external events and the never-ending winter of my discontent have conspired against me on that point.
Herzog Wolfhammer
Sigma Special Tactics Group
#30 - 2013-05-13 05:24:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Herzog Wolfhammer
I have long theorized that the collapse of the Eve Gate and the fall of New Eden are not directly linked to each other, but that there was a third element that suggest some cataclysmic event that involved some kind of contagion.

And possibly the gate was destroyed on purpose. Something was found in New Eden that should have never been found.

But that all these worlds relied on old Earth and the connection to it through the gate, and many perished for that lack of that "lifeline" is, as we call it on Intaki "hogwash".

As if the worlds themselves had no farming equipment and people who knew how to use it.


My research leads me to theorize that some kind of contagion developed for which the gate was destroyed to quarantine, and this was an "infomorphic virus" that could affect biological, information, and infomorphic system, going from one type to the other. This brought down entire systems and would have killed a lot of people.

Note that the 4 empires are so different in their ways, but would have comprised far less cosmopolitan and connected social groups.

The Amarr have a lot of cult undertones to their civilization. It's not unknown for religious sects to break away from civilization to get closer to God or something like that - seeking enlightenment or religious freedom.

The Minmatar have a tribal family and government structure that would find itself at odds with large centralized government and hence such a culture might be inclined to break away from it.

The Gallente and the Caldari share a lot in their past, even a solar system, but what would their ancestors have sought that would lead them away from mainstream civilization? Large centralized states, even one controlled from a planet on the other end of a wormhole, are not conducive to liberty and merit. They tend to fall towards a more socialistic and nepotistic direction. Cultures seeking to be left alone or seeking to be producers in their own right without interference or being looted by regulation would certainly be driven to off-the-path worlds.
(I have seen some references in ancient information systems referring to someone named "John Galt" who might have led such a movement but there is no more information to be found beyond a reference to a book. Even people from his time kept asking who he was).



So, imagine you got you pilgrims, your large extended families, and your libertarians getting away from the centralized state and their systems, to strike out their own direction.

Then the cataclysm hits. Some kind of contagion. People are getting killed, systems are going down. The people on the other end of the Eve Gate may have sent a bomb to close it. The large centralized metropolises become ghost towns, stations hang dead in their orbits. We have heard nothing from "the other end" - not even stray radio transmissions that could have reached New Eden by now. If there was any civilization that could survive, it would be the ones who could disconnect fast - and the sleepers appear to be that kind. As for our kin on the other end of the gate, I fear they didn't have enough time and the home of our ancestors is a ghost world.

But the people who have left these hubs of information (network connections) would not be so easily harmed by it. They may have had time to disconnect from it. Their ships of course, coming from an industrial infrastructure, would fall out of repair eventually and their plans were interrupted most certainly. Actual accounts, news, video feeds, and whatever technology at that time, would not be spared. All we know was that the gate collapsed. If anybody wrote about it in a journal, perhaps as a witness to these events, they may have scrawled it in a book as their lives were ending. Such books would not be well-kept in such a manner to last.. And we have yet to uncover anything that has anything to say on the matter, not a data core, not a memory chip, nothing. There's a lot of information floating around about ships, cargo, movements of people, and basic stuff like text messages (most of them short and about work-related tasks) prior to the collapse of the gate. But there's an informational black hole about the event itself. This is why I favor the idea of a contagion being involved with information systems and affecting infomorph infrastructure - the virus itself being such.

Now, 3 groups, with homogenous ideals, religion, or a family structure, would be able to survive. If the polyglotistic centralized systems managed to have any survivors, they would not have had enough coordination to survive. Heck, without the centralized state to control them (as we see in cases where states decline and ethnic groups start to conflict) they might have had wars with each other. Overall it could be said that they simply lacked enough reproductive capability and so they dwindled out, people becoming few and far between.

This is of course my gathering on the great big "what the heck happened". It's based on years of research and time in an out of wormholes. There's much to sleeper systems and the arrangement of their defenses to suggest some kind of contagion.


Regardless of my own findings, I think there is excellent work abound in this thread and that's quite a read from the OP. I have only had time to skim it today, but will be planning my reading time around this soon to reread all of it in detail.

Bring back DEEEEP Space!

Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#31 - 2013-05-13 09:26:49 UTC
Pilot Wolfhammer, I would very much like to see your data. Common Origin theory is among the least accepted in the mainstream scientific community, and while I do like to consider what I see from all possible angles, I feel as though simply assuming it is correct from the outset and then biasing one's observations based on that premise is a poor way to do archaeology.

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#32 - 2013-05-13 09:31:50 UTC
Gosakumori Noh wrote:

At least some of the installations are (or were) networked. Arriving at the location known as "The Line," I observed:

"Long-range scanning reveals a chaotic line of asteroids and debris, stretching out endlessly as it twists onwards into the darkness. Upon arrival, it seems as if the place is empty and has been for quite some time. There is the sense however, that it was not always this way. Huge amounts of data are passing through the area, as if there was once a receiver for it somewhere nearby."

I am curious as to why a civilization in torpor would need to transmit so much information; and why such a sophisticated operation's network protocols would have failed to detect the absence of a receiver.

All of this is almost enough to make me want to flit around inside wormholes again, though external events and the never-ending winter of my discontent have conspired against me on that point.


Was that installation an example of a quarantine site? I'm sorry if I was unclear in my previous post, but I had meant to discuss whether or not quarantine sites, very specifically, are air-gapped or not.

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Herzog Wolfhammer
Sigma Special Tactics Group
#33 - 2013-05-13 17:51:01 UTC
Streya Jormagdnir wrote:
Pilot Wolfhammer, I would very much like to see your data. Common Origin theory is among the least accepted in the mainstream scientific community, and while I do like to consider what I see from all possible angles, I feel as though simply assuming it is correct from the outset and then biasing one's observations based on that premise is a poor way to do archaeology.


The findings are all around you actually. I don't have a long lost computer with some records on it, or some cave paintings from some long forgotten castaway.

It's all based on observation and I don't have a long thesis for it. I won't bother with it until I have hard evidence for without that, I will have wasted my time.


You need only look at what the sleeper systems self-identify as, what you find there, the layout of their complexes, and the level of ferocity they attack depending on where they are. You need to look at what their structures reveal.

But a lot of what I have observed is based on what I know about the empires and working with the people in them too. Remember, we are connected to this past through our ancestors and the answers we seek are not on some altar somewhere to answer all questions once we find them.

In the end, the knowledge changes nothing too.

For the most part, regarding this notion of bias, when I do my research, I seek to DISPROVE my own theories. This has yet to happen, and so there is no resolution.


But we well advised that working together, the findings of many, from the top scientists to the lowly mining colony that finds a discarded tool in the very rocks, is how we would find our answers someday.

It will not happen from writing long drawn out document whist telling others how to do research.

Bring back DEEEEP Space!

Streya Jormagdnir
Alexylva Paradox
#34 - 2013-05-14 05:22:09 UTC
Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

You need only look at what the sleeper systems self-identify as, what you find there, the layout of their complexes, and the level of ferocity they attack depending on where they are. You need to look at what their structures reveal.


I have been. As far as I am aware, no one has broken through the seamless armor found on many Sleeper structures, and in any case there are many many ways in which one could interpret the goings-on of the Sleeper drones and their ruins. While I agree that the Sleepers most likely originated from the known cluster, whether or not all of humanity originated from a point of common origin is a separate discussion entirely and is not what this thread is concerned with. One thing is clear though: mankind has been among the stars far longer than we previously thought. You could interpret the simultaneous existence of multiple ancient civilizations to mean there was a common point of origin for the human species, yes, or you could interpret it to mean that mold theory works on a cyclical basis.

Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

But a lot of what I have observed is based on what I know about the empires and working with the people in them too. Remember, we are connected to this past through our ancestors and the answers we seek are not on some altar somewhere to answer all questions once we find them.

I agree: there is no "smoking gun" for answering the mysteries of the past, but rather a collection of individual facts and observations which paint a general picture of what most likely happened.

Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

For the most part, regarding this notion of bias, when I do my research, I seek to DISPROVE my own theories. This has yet to happen, and so there is no resolution.

I just suggested a plausible alternative to the conclusions you draw. Simply stating that your own theories have yet to be disproven doesn't make them correct. That's how science work; a theory can be overturned at any point later in time by new data and observations. Note that I draw no definite conclusions in my writings here, but rather use words such as "likely" and "possibly" in order to portray the rather real possibility that all of this is wild speculation and has no basis in fact at all. While I would like my speculations to be something resembling correct, it is much more worthwhile to arrive at actual truth rather than belief.

Herzog Wolfhammer wrote:

It will not happen from writing long drawn out document whist telling others how to do research.


It won't happen by making extraordinary claims without providing extraordinary evidence either.

I am also a human, straggling between the present world... and our future. I am a regulator, a coordinator, one who is meant to guide the way.

Destination Unreachable: the worst Wspace blog ever

Previous page12