These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE New Citizens Q&A

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Trade window scamming

First post First post
Author
Cerisia
Red Phoenix Rising
#21 - 2011-10-29 11:46:52 UTC  |  Edited by: Cerisia
As everyone else here is saying , you fell to a simple game mechanic and you were so greedy that you didn't even take the time to make sure that the items you were buying were as described. These scams only work if the player allows greed to overtake common sense.

There are two things you can do at this point.

1, Dust yourself down , learn from your mistakes and carry on playing as a better more informed player.

or

2, Come to the forums and whine about your own greed and lack of common sense, followed by rage quitting.


I see you've chosen the latter route...
This space for rent..
KaarBaak
Squirrel Team
#22 - 2011-10-29 15:05:32 UTC

"Exploit"

You keep using this word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

Dum Spiro Spero

Asta Ddu
Doomheim
#23 - 2011-10-29 15:26:20 UTC
Can I haz your stuff?
Taedrin
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#24 - 2011-10-29 18:20:19 UTC
Sorry OP, the trade system is not actually meant for regular business dealings and instead is only meant as a means to exchange items between friends and not between strangers.

That being said, you can easily protect yourself from this scam by several methods:

1) Faction items have a green triangle with a white diamond in the upper left corner of the icon. If you don't see this symbol, it isn't a faction item.

2) You can always "show info" on the item to double check what the item actually is.

3) NEVER use trades to do business when you can use contracts or the market.

Now, there ARE scams that are exploits which use the trade system. However, these were fixed a loooonnngg time ago, IIRC.
Flakey Foont
#25 - 2011-10-29 19:07:47 UTC
As in RL some are perennial victims...
Reese Tek'al
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#26 - 2011-10-29 22:04:29 UTC
Yeah, so what does that say about the game in general? Welcome to EVE, where it's a crime to be a victim. As in real life the majority of users on the forums are perennial vampires, trolls, and uncaring assholes who's only purpose in life is to 'collect tears' etc. What a joke, and what a let down to all of us that this small group of people is being trained by a ****** game to be even more apathetic.
Dhaul
Reunincapacitated Industries
#27 - 2011-10-29 23:14:15 UTC
If it's allowed by CCP then it isn't an exploit by definition
Surfin's PlunderBunny
Sebiestor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#28 - 2011-10-29 23:52:00 UTC
Reese Tek'al wrote:
Yeah, so what does that say about the game in general? Welcome to EVE, where it's a crime to be a victim. As in real life the majority of users on the forums are perennial vampires, trolls, and uncaring assholes who's only purpose in life is to 'collect tears' etc. What a joke, and what a let down to all of us that this small group of people is being trained by a ****** game to be even more apathetic.


yay! 2 out of 3 because I don't know waht perennial means Big smile

"Little ginger moron" ~David Hasselhoff 

Want to see what Surf is training or how little isk Surf has?  http://eveboard.com/pilot/Surfin%27s_PlunderBunny

TrollFace TrololMcFluf
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#29 - 2011-10-30 03:10:18 UTC
You try and help this guy and this is the response i get for my trouble really now what a ******* he is

From: Reese Tek'al
Sent: 2011.10.30 02:57
To: QQ,

If you met me IRL I'd thump that **** poor attitude right out of you little goblin.

I'm jettisoning my stuff into space ;-)

Justin Credulent
Luv You Long Time
#30 - 2011-10-30 03:29:50 UTC  |  Edited by: Justin Credulent
Quote:
The trade system can be exploited and used to scam players, the GM's know about it and do nothing.


The GMs are lazy, and they use the excuse "EVE is meant to be a harsh and unforgiving Universe" as a front for said laziness.

But just scam CCP out of some cash and you'll quickly see that they don't condone scamming after all...

Quote:
Nowadays trades where you are offered normal ship renamed as faction ship instead of faction ship, should be easy to spot -- just check for that green faction-mark at top left corner of ship icon. If that mark is not there, it is not faction ship.


Something every newbie knows, since the tutorial covers it....

Quote:
You try and help this guy and this is the response i get for my trouble really now what a ******* he is

From: Reese Tek'al
Sent: 2011.10.30 02:57
To: QQ,

If you met me IRL I'd thump that **** poor attitude right out of you little goblin.

I'm jettisoning my stuff into space ;-)


Since the fact in EVE is this: if you've been victimized it's your fault;

then one could only conclude,

since this person is saying something mean to you -

that it is in response to some trollish or antagonistic behavior on your part.

In the future if you don't want people saying such mean things to you then the advise to you is to have a little more respect and courtesy towards other players.

Null-Sec needs to HTFU and stop crying to CCP. If null-sec wants PvP, they need to stop being carebears and start fighting eachother - after years of bot-mining, they have the ships!

TrollFace TrololMcFluf
Imperial Academy
Amarr Empire
#31 - 2011-10-30 04:24:28 UTC
Justin Credulent wrote:
Quote:
The trade system can be exploited and used to scam players, the GM's know about it and do nothing.


The GMs are lazy, and they use the excuse "EVE is meant to be a harsh and unforgiving Universe" as a front for said laziness.

But just scam CCP out of some cash and you'll quickly see that they don't condone scamming after all...

Quote:
Nowadays trades where you are offered normal ship renamed as faction ship instead of faction ship, should be easy to spot -- just check for that green faction-mark at top left corner of ship icon. If that mark is not there, it is not faction ship.


Something every newbie knows, since the tutorial covers it....

Quote:
You try and help this guy and this is the response i get for my trouble really now what a ******* he is

From: Reese Tek'al
Sent: 2011.10.30 02:57
To: QQ,

If you met me IRL I'd thump that **** poor attitude right out of you little goblin.

I'm jettisoning my stuff into space ;-)


Since the fact in EVE is this: if you've been victimized it's your fault;

then one could only conclude,

since this person is saying something mean to you -

that it is in response to some trollish or antagonistic behavior on your part.

In the future if you don't want people saying such mean things to you then the advise to you is to have a little more respect and courtesy towards other players.


Ohh aint you a smart little one

And we all know what happens to vocal smart little ones dont we
Zillam Reynardine
Stargazer Holdings
#32 - 2011-10-30 12:54:47 UTC
Reese Tek'al wrote:
Yeah, so what does that say about the game in general? Welcome to EVE, where it's a crime to be a victim. As in real life the majority of users on the forums are perennial vampires, trolls, and uncaring assholes who's only purpose in life is to 'collect tears' etc. What a joke, and what a let down to all of us that this small group of people is being trained by a ****** game to be even more apathetic.

It's a crime to ***** on the forums about an aspect of the game that the playerbase has, for a very long time, come to accept as "the way of things".

From what I can tell about EVE, when things don't go your way, there are, essentially, two paths you can take:

1. You can get mad. You can ***** and whine at EVE's unfairness to anyone who will give you even a moment of attention (and, more often, to those who won't), and wallow in your pathetic sadness, or

2. You can get even. Get scammed? Scam the scammer. Get ganked? Go gank the ganker. No player in EVE is invincible (except maybe Chribba).

Sure, getting even won't be easy, but no one said it was. And if you don't want to spend the time and effort it takes to get even... well then, admit defeat. You got scammed/ganked/owned/rolled/whatever, and you're too soft/lazy to do anything constructive about it. Suck it up or GTFO.

tl;dr: HTFU.
CCP Navigator
C C P
C C P Alliance
#33 - 2011-10-30 13:36:39 UTC
I have edited the thread title as it is both misleading and discussing exploits would be against the forum rules.
Justin Credulent
Luv You Long Time
#34 - 2011-10-30 18:49:49 UTC
Quote:
As everyone else here is saying , you fell to a simple game mechanic and you were so greedy that you didn't even take the time to make sure that the items you were buying were as described. These scams only work if the player allows greed to overtake common sense.


lol"greedy". Isn't the person running the scam is really the greedy one?

Not a lot of critical thinking in this thread...

Quote:
Ohh aint you a smart little one

And we all know what happens to vocal smart little ones dont we


Yes. They are frequently on the receiving end of empty threats.

Null-Sec needs to HTFU and stop crying to CCP. If null-sec wants PvP, they need to stop being carebears and start fighting eachother - after years of bot-mining, they have the ships!

Justin Credulent
Luv You Long Time
#35 - 2011-10-30 19:01:33 UTC
Quote:
You got scammed because you thought you were taking advantage of another player who didn't know enough to offer a reasonable price. Given that your attempt to take advantage of someone else led to you being rooked in turn, it's difficult to understand why you think we should sympathise with you.


Nice try but no. I have to call "troll" on this because I can't honestly believe that you're that idiotic.

Quote:
The big kicker ? The person that gets "scammed" this way CAN ACTUALLY SCAM THE SCAMMER BACK, all within the exact same system.


Yes, because we all know scammers are susceptible to the very same scams they utilize... not. Roll

Null-Sec needs to HTFU and stop crying to CCP. If null-sec wants PvP, they need to stop being carebears and start fighting eachother - after years of bot-mining, they have the ships!

Killstealing
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#36 - 2011-10-30 22:35:26 UTC
I got scammed like that as well (in my defense, I was intoxicated) and all I can say to you is: if someone is advertising items below the average order on the market it's a scam, if the item name is Republic Fleet Stabber but the ship looks like a normal one it's a scam, if you get a mail that's sent to you and many others with the same starting letter in your name it's also a scam.

Deal with it nerd etc
Killstealing
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#37 - 2011-10-30 22:38:36 UTC
Justin Credulent wrote:
Quote:
You got scammed because you thought you were taking advantage of another player who didn't know enough to offer a reasonable price. Given that your attempt to take advantage of someone else led to you being rooked in turn, it's difficult to understand why you think we should sympathise with you.


Nice try but no. I have to call "troll" on this because I can't honestly believe that you're that idiotic.

Quote:
The big kicker ? The person that gets "scammed" this way CAN ACTUALLY SCAM THE SCAMMER BACK, all within the exact same system.


Yes, because we all know scammers are susceptible to the very same scams they utilize... not. Roll

It's totally not greedy to want to buy stuff under market to relist them guys. That is, unless that guy wanted to fly faction stabbers because he pvps a lot right Roll

Also yeah you can scam them back, works out sometimes, put 40k in the offer and get a cheap stabber v0v
Cerisia
Red Phoenix Rising
#38 - 2011-10-30 23:53:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Cerisia
Justin Credulent wrote:
Quote:
As everyone else here is saying , you fell to a simple game mechanic and you were so greedy that you didn't even take the time to make sure that the items you were buying were as described. These scams only work if the player allows greed to overtake common sense.


lol"greedy". Isn't the person running the scam is really the greedy one?

Not a lot of critical thinking in this thread...




Actually the person running the scam has probably sat there for hours linking the same contract over and over. Even if it took him an hour I can probably earn more doing level 4 missions , or ransoming someone.

So no , I wouldn't say the scammer was greedy at all.

Patient., tenacious maybe but not greedy.

In the OP's case, he was offered some cheap Navy Stabbers (how cheap? We don't know) But one would assume that they were cheap enough for him to think he could make a good profit from them. (For most of us that's where the alarm bells would have started ringing)

However powered by his desire (or greed) for them he went to the station.

The scammer told him that he could only trade them (again , most of us would balk at this or indeed wonder why the scammer was refusing to put them into a private contract)

But his desire for them (or greed) was too strong and blinded him.

The items were presented in the trade window, all the OP had to do was check the info on them (or look for the coloured corner on the icon) but the OP was in such a rush to make the deal (because he was driven by his desire - or greed to make the deal as fast as possible, before the scammer had a chance to back out) that he traded without checking.

In all scams, both ingame and in real life - the one thing a scammer uses to his advantage in his chosen mark , is the mark's greed - without that the scammer is unlikely to pull the scam off.
This space for rent..
Justin Credulent
Luv You Long Time
#39 - 2011-10-31 00:02:11 UTC  |  Edited by: CCP Spitfire
Quote:
Actually the person running the scam has probably sat there for hours linking the same contract over and over. Even if it took him an hour I can probably earn more doing level 4 missions , or ransoming someone.

So no , I wouldn't say the scammer was greedy at all.

Patient., tenacious maybe but not greedy.


That's not gonna work, though. If the scammer really was so "patient and tenacious", he could have earned his ISK the honest way, instead of trying to make a quick buck via scams.

So, no, so sorry, but you're not going to glorify and make the scammer into some hero.

Quote:
In the OP's case, he was offered some cheap Navy Stabbers (how cheap? We don't know) But one would assume that they were cheap enough for him to think he could make a good profit from them. (For most of us that's where the alarm bells would have started ringing)


Says you. But do we really know how many the OP purchased or what he intended them for? No. For all we know the OP only purchased 1 to run missions with.

Sorry, again nice try but no cigar.

Quote:
The scammer told him that he could only trade them (again , most of us would balk at this or indeed wonder why the scammer was refusing to put them into a private contract)

But his desire for them (or greed) was too strong and blinded him.

The items were presented in the trade window, all the OP had to do was check the info on them (or look for the coloured corner on the icon) but the OP was in such a rush to make the deal (because he was driven by his desire - or greed to make the deal as fast as possible, before the scammer had a chance to back out) that he traded without checking.


Sounds more like a naive newbie or casual than some nefarious, greed ridden fiend.

I give you credit for the effort, but you've failed trying to pain the victim as the bad guy. Sorry again.

Quote:
In all scams, both ingame and in real life - the one thing a scammer uses to his advantage in his chosen mark , is the mark's greed - without that the scammer is unlikely to pull the scam off.


Another failed attempt at projecting the scammer's guilt onto the person who got scammed.

Please refrain from personal attacks. Spitfire

Null-Sec needs to HTFU and stop crying to CCP. If null-sec wants PvP, they need to stop being carebears and start fighting eachother - after years of bot-mining, they have the ships!

Mara Rinn
Cosmic Goo Convertor
#40 - 2011-10-31 00:54:10 UTC
Reese Tek'al wrote:
Yeah, so what does that say about the game in general?


If the scam you are speaking of is the one where someone offers you e.g.: a "Raven Navy Issue" via trade window, then once you've handed over your 300M ISK you find that what you have is a Raven that has been named "Raven Navy Issue", I'd suggest that what this says about the game in general is that EVE Online is an excellent training ground for people to be aware of contract law in general.

Scams like this happen all the time in real life, and they're perfectly legal because the paperwork describes exactly what you're buying. There are some consumer protection arrangements in place, but generally you'll find that it's impossible to get a refund from a company that no longer exists.

So here is what you can learn from this: read the fine print. Examine the details of the transaction and make sure that you are in fact getting what you paid for. Even going to the supermarket, make sure that the price marked on the shelf is what was advertised in the brochure, and is the price that rings up on the till when you're paying for it. Insist on only paying the lowest of the three prices. When signing a contract to buy a new house, make sure the company has been in business for a few years, and check that the principals have not had a history of running businesses which then declare bankruptcy.

Welcome to EVE Online, oft referred to as "Capitalism 101" and designed as a cruel harsh world where you can learn some valuable life lessons in safety.