These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Rattlesnake vs Armageddon navy issue

Author
Absolon Echerie
Roving Guns Inc.
Pandemic Legion
#1 - 2013-03-23 12:18:11 UTC
Currently i am flying a gila, doing lvl 4 missions. since the damage is a bit lacking on the gila i want to start skilling for a battleship.

in both cases i will have to skill more for the weapons, and i am in the process of getting tech 2 sentry drones.

since i am coming from gallente and am now flying caldari pirate ship i do have skills for both shield and armor tanking, both not super, but they work well.

now i was looking for ships and the navy armageddon seems nice, but the rattlesnake is supposed to be the direct upgrade from the gila, so i am wondering if someone has experience in both and can tell me what would work better along with the sentry drones. for example, will the navy geddon get a problem tanking some stuff? due to the reputation of the rattlesnake as sick tank, it may be a weird comparison, but that is one of the issues i can think of.

so once more: Armageddon navy issue or a Rattlesnake. both will take about as long skilling for me as far as i can tell
sabre906
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#2 - 2013-03-23 12:38:51 UTC
Absolon Echerie wrote:
Currently i am flying a gila, doing lvl 4 missions. since the damage is a bit lacking on the gila i want to start skilling for a battleship.

in both cases i will have to skill more for the weapons, and i am in the process of getting tech 2 sentry drones.

since i am coming from gallente and am now flying caldari pirate ship i do have skills for both shield and armor tanking, both not super, but they work well.

now i was looking for ships and the navy armageddon seems nice, but the rattlesnake is supposed to be the direct upgrade from the gila, so i am wondering if someone has experience in both and can tell me what would work better along with the sentry drones. for example, will the navy geddon get a problem tanking some stuff? due to the reputation of the rattlesnake as sick tank, it may be a weird comparison, but that is one of the issues i can think of.

so once more: Armageddon navy issue or a Rattlesnake. both will take about as long skilling for me as far as i can tell


No BS should have trouble tank any lvl4. They're lvl4s. Rattlesnake's huge passive tank is essentially wasted.

Applied dps in a Rattler is low, and basically limited to drones. It has no weapon dmg bonus, tp bonus, torps has no range and hit badly. On the flip side, you can get in a Rattler without training weapons, and still be almost as effective. Shorter training, if you skip BS 5s and weapon.

Applied dps in a N. Geddon is much higher, 1.1k at Scorch range with 5 matching range Amar sentries. Weapon dmg bonus is high (-25% rof = +33% dmg), but you need t2 pulse for Scorch. Tachs don't fit without fitting mods. Longer training, even if you skip BS 5, since you need t2 weapon.
John Ratcliffe
Tradors'R'us
IChooseYou Alliance
#3 - 2013-03-23 13:05:14 UTC
As usual with most things in Eve, there's a significant difference between T1 & T2. Wait until you can put T2 Sentries in your Gila, then see how you feel.

I used a Rattlesnake recently - they are not worth the effort IMHO.

Stick to a hull with decent applied DPS rather than relying on drones.

Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose

FortyEight
Brutor Tribe
Minmatar Republic
#4 - 2013-03-23 14:27:17 UTC
Absolon Echerie wrote:
Currently i am flying a gila, doing lvl 4 missions. since the damage is a bit lacking on the gila i want to start skilling for a battleship.

in both cases i will have to skill more for the weapons, and i am in the process of getting tech 2 sentry drones.

since i am coming from gallente and am now flying caldari pirate ship i do have skills for both shield and armor tanking, both not super, but they work well.

now i was looking for ships and the navy armageddon seems nice, but the rattlesnake is supposed to be the direct upgrade from the gila, so i am wondering if someone has experience in both and can tell me what would work better along with the sentry drones. for example, will the navy geddon get a problem tanking some stuff? due to the reputation of the rattlesnake as sick tank, it may be a weird comparison, but that is one of the issues i can think of.

so once more: Armageddon navy issue or a Rattlesnake. both will take about as long skilling for me as far as i can tell


When you get T2 Sentries, your damage will go up by leaps and bounds in the gila/rattlesnake. If you train gallente cruiser 5, and only have gallente BS4, then your gila can still put out competive damage to the rattlesnake, while being smaller, more agile and mostly able to sig tank. The main problem with the gila though is the CPU is limited.

Also, you will have full damage selection with gila/rattlesnake, instead of the Armageddon being locked into EM/Therm + whatever the drones are using, so you can engage a wider variety of missions this way.
Orlacc
#5 - 2013-03-23 16:26:00 UTC  |  Edited by: Orlacc
For once I agree with Sabre. L4s are gank and Rattler is a tank.....Geddon. And yes, T2 sentries are mandatory!

"Measure Twice, Cut Once."

Absolon Echerie
Roving Guns Inc.
Pandemic Legion
#6 - 2013-03-25 09:50:47 UTC
Orlacc wrote:
For once I agree with Sabre. L4s are gank and Rattler is a tank.....Geddon. And yes, T2 sentries are mandatory!


is that also vs guristas NPC's? since i have been reading into the geddon a bit more (planning on using t2 heavy though) and a lot of people say laser dmg just sucks against guristas due to their kinetic resist hole..

so does the navy geddon still stand for that? or should i look at something with more versatile ammo like a projectile ship (though i have not found anything with 125mb/s yet)
Denuo Secus
#7 - 2013-03-25 10:19:42 UTC
sabre906 wrote:
...Rattlesnake's huge passive tank is essentially wasted.

Applied dps in a Rattler is low, and basically limited to drones. It has no weapon dmg bonus....


Then don't fit a massive tank. Benefit of the Rattlesnake is free slots for modules to help with damage application. Such as Omnidirectionals. The Rattlesnake can fit 3 of them without sacrificing tank needed for any lvl4 mission. TPs are nice as well to help with additional missile DPS (Fury Cruises). No weapon dmg bonus? Rattler has drone damage bonus.

A Rattlesnake with 3 Omnis, 3 Drone Damage Amplifiers and (maybe) 2 Ballistics deals ~1000 DPS @52+12km with Gardes and Cruises (180km range). I'd call this 'applied dps'. Ewar proof and cap independent. Nice against Gurista, Serpentis and Bloodraider for instance. Use other sentries for more range and light drones against small stuff if needed. Flexibility! 247 DPS with Hobgobs II due to the drone damage bonus. It is awesome.
feihcsiM
THE B0YS
#8 - 2013-03-25 10:28:35 UTC
If you are running a lot of Guristas missions and like drones, I would say go for a Navy Dominix. It's a great ship, has good dps and hits the resist holes you need.

Personally I use a rattlesnake on the odd occasion I do lvl 4s nowadays, but mainly because when I do I'm often at work and might need to go afk for a bit. Even with a tank that just won't break in a lvl 4 it still does a touch over 800dps out to 50km+ purely from the sentry drones.

It's the end of the world as we know it and I feel fine.

Absolon Echerie
Roving Guns Inc.
Pandemic Legion
#9 - 2013-03-25 10:32:58 UTC
feihcsiM wrote:
If you are running a lot of Guristas missions and like drones, I would say go for a Navy Dominix. It's a great ship, has good dps and hits the resist holes you need.

Personally I use a rattlesnake on the odd occasion I do lvl 4s nowadays, but mainly because when I do I'm often at work and might need to go afk for a bit. Even with a tank that just won't break in a lvl 4 it still does a touch over 800dps out to 50km+ purely from the sentry drones.


well i also like running complexes, but i think doing that in high sec with a battleship is not going to work well since you won't go up against stuff bigger then battlecruisers (what i encountered so far)

and i think if you use a rattler with 3 omni, 3 dda and 2 ballistics you will only have some buffer left? or am i thinking the wrong way with any tank.
Denuo Secus
#10 - 2013-03-25 10:45:28 UTC  |  Edited by: Denuo Secus
Absolon Echerie wrote:
...and i think if you use a rattler with 3 omni, 3 dda and 2 ballistics you will only have some buffer left? or am i thinking the wrong way with any tank.


Active tank it. You have still 4 med slots, 1 low slot and an inbuilt resist bonus left. No MWD. That's the catch. But since a sentry boat is immobile anyway it is a problem in missions with widely separated gates only.


EDIT: added a fit as example against Gurista and Serpentis.


[Rattlesnake, Gurista/Serpentis]
Drone Damage Amplifier II
Drone Damage Amplifier II
Drone Damage Amplifier II
Ballistic Control System II
Ballistic Control System II
Internal Force Field Array I

Federation Navy Omnidirectional Tracking Link
Federation Navy Omnidirectional Tracking Link
Phased Weapon Navigation Array Generation Extron
X-Large Shield Booster II
Thermic Dissipation Field II
Kinetic Deflection Field II
Heavy Capacitor Booster II, Cap Booster 800

Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Drone Link Augmentor II
Small Tractor Beam II /OFFLINE

Large Core Defense Operational Solidifier I
Large Core Defense Capacitor Safeguard I
Large Core Defense Operational Solidifier I


Garde II x5
Curator II x5
Hobgoblin II x5


- 878 Gurista/Serp DPS tanked for 4mins 39 sec
- 717 Gurista/Serp DPS tanked cap stable as long cap boosters are left
- 1032 DPS @49+12km using Gardes and Furies
- There are better options for rigs maybe, this is just an example

Tbh I'd fit a more expensive shield booster on a PvE pirate faction BS...obviously you'd get better results then. Main goal is: tank only as much as needed, damage as much as possible. Maybe I overtanked it. So you should play with the fit until you feel comfortable with it.
Saile Litestrider
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#11 - 2013-03-25 15:34:56 UTC
I love both of these ships, but they're both pretty hard to fit and misunderstood. People's opinions on the rattlesnake in particular irk me, "it's just a fat tank, low dps BS" and then their fit is always 90% tank modules with nothing on it to help the damage. Personally I really couldn't choose one over the other, assuming you're fighting em/thermal weak rats.

Also, your damage in a gila probably shouldn't be that lacking if your drone skills are up, it packs a lot of punch in that little package!

The thing about these two ships is that they both use split weapon systems (don't you dare neglect that huge navygeddon drone bay). So the fitting is really skill intensive, and really hard to design, but extremely satisfying. The typhoon is like this as well, and the domi.

As far as which to choose, the rattlesnake isn't locked to em/thermal damage like the navygeddon is, and it's a bit easier to fit up and fly too since you can fat tank it and get away with just drones if you're lazy. The geddon on the other hand will crush it in damage if you're up against sanshas or blood raiders and have perfect laser, drone and fitting skills, it can push a downright ludicrous amount of dps out. It pretty much comes down to personal preference and situational use at the end of the day, you probably couldn't force me to pick between the two.
sabre906
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#12 - 2013-03-25 17:28:27 UTC  |  Edited by: sabre906
Denuo Secus wrote:
Absolon Echerie wrote:
...and i think if you use a rattler with 3 omni, 3 dda and 2 ballistics you will only have some buffer left? or am i thinking the wrong way with any tank.


Active tank it. You have still 4 med slots, 1 low slot and an inbuilt resist bonus left. No MWD. That's the catch. But since a sentry boat is immobile anyway it is a problem in missions with widely separated gates only.


EDIT: added a fit as example against Gurista and Serpentis.


[Rattlesnake, Gurista/Serpentis]
Drone Damage Amplifier II
Drone Damage Amplifier II
Drone Damage Amplifier II
Ballistic Control System II
Ballistic Control System II
Internal Force Field Array I

Federation Navy Omnidirectional Tracking Link
Federation Navy Omnidirectional Tracking Link
Phased Weapon Navigation Array Generation Extron
X-Large Shield Booster II
Thermic Dissipation Field II
Kinetic Deflection Field II
Heavy Capacitor Booster II, Cap Booster 800

Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Cruise Missile Launcher II, Scourge Fury Cruise Missile
Drone Link Augmentor II
Small Tractor Beam II /OFFLINE

Large Core Defense Operational Solidifier I
Large Core Defense Capacitor Safeguard I
Large Core Defense Operational Solidifier I


Garde II x5
Curator II x5
Hobgoblin II x5


- 878 Gurista/Serp DPS tanked for 4mins 39 sec
- 717 Gurista/Serp DPS tanked cap stable as long cap boosters are left
- 1032 DPS @49+12km using Gardes and Furies
- There are better options for rigs maybe, this is just an example

Tbh I'd fit a more expensive shield booster on a PvE pirate faction BS...obviously you'd get better results then. Main goal is: tank only as much as needed, damage as much as possible. Maybe I overtanked it. So you should play with the fit until you feel comfortable with it.


Fury Cruise has larger exp radius than torps. It's a 3 slot tank depending on cap booster with small cargo that also have to hold ammo, slowboat, and extremely tight fittings with t1 dc and an offlined small tractor (cpu, Im guessing?). This is one of these EFT fits...

Applied dps is nowhere close to the N. geddon's Scorch tracking and range, with matching sentries. It does allow dmg type selection, but the applied dmg there is still mostly in drones, as these 4 unbonused Fury Cruises hit badly anything below BS.

If you decide to get hardwirings to increase dps, gap grows larger, as there are no drone dmg implants, only missile/gun. In one case it would boost 4 unbonused missiles' dps, in the other, rack of rof bonused guns.

tl;dr:
If you want gank, projection, and dmg selection, go for something else, not Rattlesnake. Mach/Vargur beats it hands down.

If you want cheap gank, projection, without much dmg selection, go for N. Geddon. It matches NM gank minus the price tag.
Denuo Secus
#13 - 2013-03-25 19:27:15 UTC  |  Edited by: Denuo Secus
sabre906 wrote:
Fury Cruise has larger exp radius than torps. It's a 3 slot tank depending on cap booster with small cargo that also have to hold ammo, slowboat, and extremely tight fittings with t1 dc and an offlined small tractor (cpu, Im guessing?). This is one of these EFT fits...

Applied dps is nowhere close to the N. geddon's Scorch tracking and range, with matching sentries. It does allow dmg type selection, but the applied dmg there is still mostly in drones, as these 4 unbonused Fury Cruises hit badly anything below BS.

If you decide to get hardwirings to increase dps, gap grows larger, as there are no drone dmg implants, only missile/gun. In one case it would boost 4 unbonused missiles' dps, in the other, rack of rof bonused guns.

tl;dr:
If you want gank, projection, and dmg selection, go for something else, not Rattlesnake. Mach/Vargur beats it hands down.

If you want cheap gank, projection, without much dmg selection, go for N. Geddon. It matches NM gank minus the price tag.


@EFT theorycrafting: I did missions in that Rattlesnake. It worked very well for me. I never stated other ships are bad. The NM or the Mach are known as very good mission runners. But since we have drone damage mods now the Rattlesnake is an equivalent option as well. With pros (ewar proof) and cons (immobility). Also fun: I just like the auto-aggro nature of drones. It was kinda refreshing to see my sentries doing the work for me.

@Fury exp radius: t1 cruises or even torps are ofc an option. Furies are for damage support against BSs only. Unbonused or not - it makes a difference. Sentries deal with smaller stuff very well. I preferred cruises because of their damage projection. Torp launchers are hard to fit also. Range is another issue in some missions. See torp Golem: a lot of micro management, ammo switches between t1 and javelin torps. As I said, this fit is a bit overtanked maybe. So the option to fit Rigors is there. Works like a charm on a cruise CNR - a very solid mission boat.

@Tracking: Apoc using 2x TC with tracking scripts...Tachyons with Multi: 0.028 rad/sec. Mega Pulse with Scorch: 0.051 rad/sec. Garde: 0.059 rad/sec. Gardes win. I was able to blap frigs on approach. Never needed to switch to small drones until said frig was below 10km.

@T1 DC: best named. Barely a difference compared to a T2 DC. Yip, CPU was the issue here. A faction or deadspace shield booster helps here maybe. Or Genolution implants. I just wanted to offer a more or less cheap option.

@Cap booster + cargo: not a problem on a CNR - so why here? Pick your missiles according to the mission rats and don't waste cargo that way. Idea is to pulse the shield booster. Perma running means wrong aggro management.
Absolon Echerie
Roving Guns Inc.
Pandemic Legion
#14 - 2013-03-25 21:10:50 UTC
I have been looking at other ships and found the Typhoon fleet issue. It has 125Mb/s bandwidth and 200m3 drone space.
This along with a nice amount of projectile turret slots or even launchers. so damage type selection has enough options.

i guess this would be a nice one to train for, also considering the variety in NPC's you get to fight in level 4 missions.
shame i also have t fit in the battlecruiser and destroyer skills before june 4th :(

http://www.eve-wiki.net/index.php?title=Typhoon_Fleet_Issue

this one :)
sabre906
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#15 - 2013-03-25 21:15:43 UTC
Absolon Echerie wrote:
I have been looking at other ships and found the Typhoon fleet issue. It has 125Mb/s bandwidth and 200m3 drone space.
This along with a nice amount of projectile turret slots or even launchers. so damage type selection has enough options.

i guess this would be a nice one to train for, also considering the variety in NPC's you get to fight in level 4 missions.
shame i also have t fit in the battlecruiser and destroyer skills before june 4th :(

http://www.eve-wiki.net/index.php?title=Typhoon_Fleet_Issue

this one :)


The split weapon systems will give you some trouble. Word is, CCP's going to revamp it into single weapon. Hopefully it'll be projectile and not cruise/torp...
Absolon Echerie
Roving Guns Inc.
Pandemic Legion
#16 - 2013-03-26 07:00:25 UTC  |  Edited by: Absolon Echerie
sabre906 wrote:
Absolon Echerie wrote:
I have been looking at other ships and found the Typhoon fleet issue. It has 125Mb/s bandwidth and 200m3 drone space.
This along with a nice amount of projectile turret slots or even launchers. so damage type selection has enough options.

i guess this would be a nice one to train for, also considering the variety in NPC's you get to fight in level 4 missions.
shame i also have t fit in the battlecruiser and destroyer skills before june 4th :(

http://www.eve-wiki.net/index.php?title=Typhoon_Fleet_Issue

this one :)


The split weapon systems will give you some trouble. Word is, CCP's going to revamp it into single weapon. Hopefully it'll be projectile and not cruise/torp...


yeah, let's hope so...

missiles would make it easier to use sentries though. just sit there, deploy them and shoot stuff around you. i rather be more active, and use moving drones so i don't have to scoop them



small update: I have bought myself a new gila, since i still have a lot of skills that are at low rank and i can improve on the gila a lot. that and it works fine for the lvl 4 missions i run.

Now i can focus on getting the battlecruiser 5 and destroyer 5 before the summer expansion :D and getting my core skills up to where i want them as well as improving my industry skills so i may make some profit manufacturing stuff (if i can find something profitable :D )

For now thanks for the advice, since i still got at least 2 months of training i guess i have some time to go EFT-warrioring and try to figure out what advice would suit my playstyle and skillset best