These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Consensual wars only

First post
Author
EI Digin
irc.zulusquad.org
#121 - 2013-03-05 19:58:25 UTC
LHA Tarawa wrote:

Mercs fight when there is profit in it. If they get war dec'ed directly, where is the profit? Why would they fight?
You fight and prove you're a good merc corp who can handle anything or you disband.

LHA Tarawa wrote:

So, you are implying that the ONLY PVP is grifers picking on carebears? There are NO fights that occur because both sides want to fight?
Non-consensual PVP does involve picking on people, but you better be careful because there's ways they can get back at you. Meaningful PVP in this game will always mean non-consensual, because no one wants to give up anything they've earned, whether it's space, moons, a pos, or the opportunity cost you lose when someone could come and blow you up. Everyone consents to winning. Very few people consent to losing.

LHA Tarawa wrote:

It is less about feeling "entitled" to PLEX every month. It is more about the simply mathematical reality. No ISK, no PLEX. No PLEX, no account. No account, no revenue for CCP.

CCP wants revenue. Therefor, CCP ensures I have a way to get ISK to buy PLEX to fund my accounts so they can get paid.

I'm not entitled to it. CCP provides the mechanisms that permit it without me even asking, because if they did not, my accounts never would have existed in the first place.
If you disappeared off of the face of the Earth, people would jump in and buy the plexes you would have bought at a cheaper price. New players might find it easier to play for free. Others might want more alts. You are completely 100% replaceable at zero cost to the company and no one cares if you stay or leave.
Alavaria Fera
GoonWaffe
#122 - 2013-03-05 20:25:00 UTC
EI Digin wrote:
LHA Tarawa wrote:

It is less about feeling "entitled" to PLEX every month. It is more about the simply mathematical reality. No ISK, no PLEX. No PLEX, no account. No account, no revenue for CCP.

CCP wants revenue. Therefor, CCP ensures I have a way to get ISK to buy PLEX to fund my accounts so they can get paid.

I'm not entitled to it. CCP provides the mechanisms that permit it without me even asking, because if they did not, my accounts never would have existed in the first place.
If you disappeared off of the face of the Earth, people would jump in and buy the plexes you would have bought at a cheaper price. New players might find it easier to play for free. Others might want more alts. You are completely 100% replaceable at zero cost to the company and no one cares if you stay or leave.

It's you being entitled. No need for fancy words that try to claim your entitlement is a good thing.

Triggered by: Wars of Sovless Agression, Bending the Knee, Twisting the Knife, Eating Sov Wheaties, Bombless Bombers, Fizzlesov, Interceptor Fleets, Running Away, GhostTime Vuln, Renters, Bombs, Bubbles ?

Sariah Kion
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#123 - 2013-03-05 20:27:33 UTC
Alavaria Fera wrote:
EI Digin wrote:
LHA Tarawa wrote:

It is less about feeling "entitled" to PLEX every month. It is more about the simply mathematical reality. No ISK, no PLEX. No PLEX, no account. No account, no revenue for CCP.

CCP wants revenue. Therefor, CCP ensures I have a way to get ISK to buy PLEX to fund my accounts so they can get paid.

I'm not entitled to it. CCP provides the mechanisms that permit it without me even asking, because if they did not, my accounts never would have existed in the first place.
If you disappeared off of the face of the Earth, people would jump in and buy the plexes you would have bought at a cheaper price. New players might find it easier to play for free. Others might want more alts. You are completely 100% replaceable at zero cost to the company and no one cares if you stay or leave.

It's you being entitled. No need for fancy words that try to claim your entitlement is a good thing.


CFC members calling others "entitled"

That's rich.

[b]Librarian and Exotic Dancer Extraordinaire Champion of the Working Men and Women of Empire Space Anti-Null Sec Opium Den Movement President[/b] Not the woman high sec wants but the Woman high sec needs. [u]A modern girl for a modern world.[/u]

Angelic Resolution
The Arcanum
#124 - 2013-03-05 21:16:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Angelic Resolution
After reading everyones comment posted and finding I was reading so slowly that 3 new pages had spawned I've got to laugh at all of those saying they'll leave or they'll be angry if non-consent war decs are removed.

What will you honestly lose? Think about it for a moment. If you can't war dec a non-consenting corporation, what will happen? You'll have to get your PvP fix from LowSec/Null, Faction Warfare, Dueling or worse yet; facing an opponent that's ready to fight. Knows how to fight and even worse yet, might actually be a challenge.

Examining those; LowSec/Null runs the risk of running into a bigger badder opponents and losing. Faction Warfare from what I've played of it is rather entertaining but you still run that risk. Dueling? Well.. that's only one v one and the opponent is prepared and probably knows how to fight you.

There's a few people I talk to that war dec for the simple real reason of ransoms. In fact, that's all they really do with the War Dec mechanic. It's not making the game any fun for their opponent, it's just a simple low-risk ISK making mechanic for them. If they get the odd fight, they're happy. But given the mechanic, do you really believe they'd pick a target that could fight back properly if their main goal is making ISK as a corp?

No, I think not sadly.

Wars in real life are fought over resources, land, ideology, emotions and race.

Resources?
Fight over a belt in high sec, winner gains rights to the system(s) mining belts and prevents any miners from opposing corp from mining in the system(s) - which means the agreement between the two parties needs to be honored. Better yet; require a corporation to plant a flag in the system(s) (.7 and below) that prevent mining by other corporations? Doubt it but who knows.

Land?
Fight over a moon in high sec for a POS. But wait.. there are a lot of moons so why bother fighting? Well they're used for Tech3, why should High-Sec even be able to produce that lovely lovely Tech? For starters, 0.0 alliances sell to their own. They don't want their enemy having Tech3. Secondly; your fancy ships you fly - some of you at least =P - where'd you buy them from? Who made them? Either a worm-hole corp who produces in their womhole - which most don't as that'd be insanely risky and who wants the risk - or.. that's right, the high-sec industrial alt. The great thing here: if anyone producing decent tech wants an advantage they can pay a merc corp to war dec the competition. No POS, no Tech3. But that's not a risk for the Player, they've just loaned the risk out and even then.. Wait.. in that scenario where's the Risk vs Reward exactly?

Ideology? No one gives a rats except those New Order crazies (Let's face it.. Hulkageddon was much funnier and relaxed then you lot, sorry but it's true). Except of course for the "High Sec is too profitable" or "Why should a miner/mission runner be able to do what they want? I want to attack them and spice things up for them!" Don't like people being good at what they do? Be better at it. Want to attack them to spice it up, got news for you. That's called self-entitlement. Your self-entitlement gets inflated whilst the other person just sits there wondering "What the hell did I ever do to that guy?", in-game you're effectively going up to someone with a Disadvantage, punching them in the face and saying "Haha learn to fight back you ******* loser".

If it were real life, you'd get the **** kicked out of you as it's a much even playing field. If I saw someone trying to destroy my lively hood or prevent me from enjoying playing footy for no other reason other than "Why not?" or "Cause I can, what are you going to do about it?!" well.. I'm 6"4, weighing in at 105kgs with 9.5% body fat, you do the math.

Emotions? 0.0 alliance fight over that, we know if for a fact thanks to G and ASCN. High Sec corps.. I'm not sure, maybe a forum post makes someone upset. Causes them to go nuts, wait the 24 hours, jump the 32 jumps in the hopes of finding their prey and smacking the **** out of them because they're upset? It'd be a laugh but honestly, why bother? That poor noobie corp is just a jump away from you and the other great thing; you're assured he's smaller than you.

Race? That's the one thing covered at the moment through Faction Warfare. Not bad from what I hear, it does the job of real PvP (Not ganking, griefing or tear hoarding ) and people actually have a real IN GAME reason to fight.

In your country, where ever you are, sitting at your computer or laptop I can only hope that you're safe and free to live the way you want. I hope you've got police that can follow up on that guy who stole from you. An army to protect you in case your countries neighbors try to invade. A legal system that prevents you from being extorted or black mailed.

Because I know the vast majority of you reading this thinking "Yeah I do what's your point", playing the "game" and enjoy your time with your corp mates. Doing exactly the aforementioned to people with practical impunity because hey, it's just a game right?

And those who just want to have a giggle, do a few missions, mine, do station trading (Which hey, you can't attack them so bl trying to war dec those guys), courier peoples cargo, setup a POS to do research or prepare yourself for 0.0 keep this in mind: without you, all those high-sec war dec'ing, griefers don't have a game to play. Without them though, you have nothing to build or your ISK is worth nothing at all. Respect goes both ways so keep it in mind.

One last point before my 671 odd characters run out; the threads about High-Sec war decs. Not about "James" or "New Order" bullshit. I'd love to read from people who have fought over something 'real' in high-sec that was worth while and had a point. No arguments over plex or people having it too easy - as the points already been made, 0.0 for a few alliances can be safer than empire at times.
Emily Natalios
CFB Training Corp
#125 - 2013-03-05 21:21:48 UTC
Sariah Kion wrote:
[quote=Feyd Rautha Harkonnen]

My advice:

Fight the corps and alliances next door in 0.0 if you want the "gf". Until you are willing to do that your "concerns" about high sec. should fall on deaf ears.


^^^This.
LHA Tarawa
Pator Tech School
Minmatar Republic
#126 - 2013-03-05 21:25:08 UTC
EI Digin wrote:
If you disappeared off of the face of the Earth, people would jump in and buy the plexes you would have bought at a cheaper price. New players might find it easier to play for free. Others might want more alts. You are completely 100% replaceable at zero cost to the company and no one cares if you stay or leave.



An individual is easily replaced. All high sec carebears are not easily replaced.

Something like a nerf to high sec, would not effect just me. A big nerf to high sec that effects all high sec carebears is going to drive away a lot more carebears than just me, and they would not all be easily replaced.

EI Digin
irc.zulusquad.org
#127 - 2013-03-05 21:33:22 UTC
LHA Tarawa wrote:



An individual is easily replaced. All high sec carebears are not easily replaced.

Something like a nerf to high sec, would not effect just me. A big nerf to high sec that effects all high sec carebears is going to drive away a lot more carebears than just me, and they would not all be easily replaced.



Some losers who can't adapt will quit. But the majority of "carebears" will adapt and find they are enjoying the game more, because their purpose ingame isn't just to grind up for another month's PLEX (which might be cheaper).

Highsec carebears are not one giant monolithic bloc as much as you would like to believe. And you do not represent all of them.
Alavaria Fera
GoonWaffe
#128 - 2013-03-05 21:38:14 UTC
EI Digin wrote:
LHA Tarawa wrote:
An individual is easily replaced. All high sec carebears are not easily replaced.

Something like a nerf to high sec, would not effect just me. A big nerf to high sec that effects all high sec carebears is going to drive away a lot more carebears than just me, and they would not all be easily replaced.

Some losers who can't adapt will quit. But the majority of "carebears" will adapt and find they are enjoying the game more, because their purpose ingame isn't just to grind up for another month's PLEX (which might be cheaper).

Highsec carebears are not one giant monolithic bloc as much as you would like to believe. And you do not represent all of them.

They're not a massive bloc, really??

Triggered by: Wars of Sovless Agression, Bending the Knee, Twisting the Knife, Eating Sov Wheaties, Bombless Bombers, Fizzlesov, Interceptor Fleets, Running Away, GhostTime Vuln, Renters, Bombs, Bubbles ?

Andski
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#129 - 2013-03-05 21:44:00 UTC
Vincent Athena wrote:
Athena Maldoran wrote:
I think removing wardecks is a good thing, but only if you found solutions for removing structures and such in highsec.

1) Keep war decs, but only allow them for corps that have a structure.
2) War dec the structure. If you do not actually aggrerss the structure, the war is canceled.
3) Economic warfare. The structure rental slot goes to the highest bidder.


What part of "cold and harsh universe" don't you understand?

Twitter: @EVEAndski

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths."    - Abrazzar

Domina Trix
McKNOBBLER DRINKING CLAN
#130 - 2013-03-05 21:51:17 UTC
Wescro wrote:
Wars already are consensual. You consent to be in a deccable player corp, you consent to stay in one and not dissolve it to escape the wardec. I wardecced someone once, they dissolved corp. Yea no thanks, I'm not paying 50m for you to go through the laborious task of clicking 5 times to reform your corp.

The current mechanics discourage wars and conflict, you know, the kind of thing that we all heard grand tales about before we subbed.


You claim you want to fight yet all you and the OP seem to be after is fighting players that have little or no interest in PvP or in other words easy kills. How many pvp corps have you decced compared to mining corps? There are plenty of corps around that will gladly give you a fight but then again, a fight isn't what you are after.

Two of the defining characteristics of a carebear are wanting other players to play the way the carebear wants and whining on the forums for the game to change when they don't. Yet I see more threads on these forums from gankers than I do miners whining about wanting the game changed to suit them.

Alavaria Fera
GoonWaffe
#131 - 2013-03-05 21:51:22 UTC
Andski wrote:
Vincent Athena wrote:
Athena Maldoran wrote:
I think removing wardecks is a good thing, but only if you found solutions for removing structures and such in highsec.

1) Keep war decs, but only allow them for corps that have a structure.
2) War dec the structure. If you do not actually aggrerss the structure, the war is canceled.
3) Economic warfare. The structure rental slot goes to the highest bidder.

What part of "cold and harsh universe" don't you understand?

If you are a "highsec wardeccer pvp" you'll feel very cold when you think about such things.

Triggered by: Wars of Sovless Agression, Bending the Knee, Twisting the Knife, Eating Sov Wheaties, Bombless Bombers, Fizzlesov, Interceptor Fleets, Running Away, GhostTime Vuln, Renters, Bombs, Bubbles ?

Takseen
Federal Defense Union
Gallente Federation
#132 - 2013-03-05 21:53:53 UTC
LHA Tarawa wrote:
EI Digin wrote:
If you disappeared off of the face of the Earth, people would jump in and buy the plexes you would have bought at a cheaper price. New players might find it easier to play for free. Others might want more alts. You are completely 100% replaceable at zero cost to the company and no one cares if you stay or leave.



An individual is easily replaced. All high sec carebears are not easily replaced.
Something like a nerf to high sec, would not effect just me. A big nerf to high sec that effects all high sec carebears is going to drive away a lot more carebears than just me, and they would not all be easily replaced.


A few bears said that about the 11% NPC corp tax. Turns out it didn't matter.
LHA Tarawa
Pator Tech School
Minmatar Republic
#133 - 2013-03-05 21:54:25 UTC
EI Digin wrote:

Some losers who can't adapt will quit. But the majority of "carebears" will adapt and find they are enjoying the game more, because their purpose ingame isn't just to grind up for another month's PLEX (which might be cheaper).

Highsec carebears are not one giant monolithic bloc as much as you would like to believe. And you do not represent all of them.



Yet another fool claiming to know what someone else enjoys (would enjoy), more than the person himself knows what he enjoys.

How arrogant must you be to think that you know better than me, what I, and those like me, enjoy?

And not just a few wayward souls lost in carebearr land... You claim to know that the majority of carebears are just to ignorant to know what they enjoy!


Let's play Occam Razor. What is more likely?

1) People become carebears because they enjoy a casual play style and have no interest in violently trading ammo in space to grow their epeen.

2) The majority of carebears are just too ignorant of their own subjective tastes to know that they would enjoy trying to ruin someone else's day because at our heart, we're all evil people that enjoy ripping the wings of flies and salting snails for our jollies.



While I don't represent all carebears, I suspect I've been in a lot more high sec carebear industry corps than you, have talked with a lot more high sec carebears than you, and know what and how they think, a lot more than you do.

I trust them to know their own tastes, better than you know their tastes. I trust them to know what they enjoy, more than you know what they enjoy.
Andski
Science and Trade Institute
Caldari State
#134 - 2013-03-05 21:55:25 UTC
CCP has not created any incentive for hisec players to build their own infrastructure. None. Virtually everything you need is provided for free - there is no shortage of available manufacturing slots even within a few jumps of Jita. Literally the only benefit of doing /anything/ in a POS is a 25% research/'manufacturing time reduction. Even if you did argue that that is an incentive to build infrastructure of your own, there's nothing preventing hiseccers from simply using an alt corp while keeping their mains in wardec-immune 0% tax personal corps, with literally the only risk they face being a suicide gank.

Twitter: @EVEAndski

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths."    - Abrazzar

LHA Tarawa
Pator Tech School
Minmatar Republic
#135 - 2013-03-05 21:59:38 UTC
Takseen wrote:
LHA Tarawa wrote:
EI Digin wrote:
If you disappeared off of the face of the Earth, people would jump in and buy the plexes you would have bought at a cheaper price. New players might find it easier to play for free. Others might want more alts. You are completely 100% replaceable at zero cost to the company and no one cares if you stay or leave.



An individual is easily replaced. All high sec carebears are not easily replaced.
Something like a nerf to high sec, would not effect just me. A big nerf to high sec that effects all high sec carebears is going to drive away a lot more carebears than just me, and they would not all be easily replaced.


A few bears said that about the 11% NPC corp tax. Turns out it didn't matter.


Because it is so easy to get around the tax. Create a corp of just you and your alts. Do not do any recruiting. Don't post under a traceable toon. Never talk in local. If you get a war dec, disband and create another corp of just your alts.



Sure, some minor tweak to mechanics that are easily avoided at not going to drive a significant number of carebears from the game.

Something like locking you into a corp when the corp is at war, so there is no easy way to avoid it? That is SUCH a larger change.


It's like saying an elephant wont die from a bullet through the brain, because it it unaffected by mosquito bites.


Easily avoided small change != huge, unavoidable change.
Alavaria Fera
GoonWaffe
#136 - 2013-03-05 22:01:15 UTC
Andski wrote:
CCP has not created any incentive for hisec players to build their own infrastructure. None. Virtually everything you need is provided for free - there is no shortage of available manufacturing slots even within a few jumps of Jita. Literally the only benefit of doing /anything/ in a POS is a 25% research/'manufacturing time reduction. Even if you did argue that that is an incentive to build infrastructure of your own, there's nothing preventing hiseccers from simply using an alt corp while keeping their mains in wardec-immune 0% tax personal corps, with literally the only risk they face being a suicide gank.

Is suicide ganking still a thing? That needs to be ... "taken care of"

Triggered by: Wars of Sovless Agression, Bending the Knee, Twisting the Knife, Eating Sov Wheaties, Bombless Bombers, Fizzlesov, Interceptor Fleets, Running Away, GhostTime Vuln, Renters, Bombs, Bubbles ?

Takseen
Federal Defense Union
Gallente Federation
#137 - 2013-03-05 22:02:02 UTC
LHA Tarawa wrote:

1) People become carebears because they enjoy a casual play style and have no interest in violently trading ammo in space to grow their epeen.
2) The majority of carebears are just too ignorant of their own subjective tastes to know that they would enjoy trying to ruin someone else's day because at our heart, we're all evil people that enjoy ripping the wings of flies and salting snails for our jollies.


Yes, but those aren't the only two playstyles in Eve. You have Pve players who don't mind some pvp danger, and pvpers who prefer fighting other pvpers.
LHA Tarawa
Pator Tech School
Minmatar Republic
#138 - 2013-03-05 22:02:10 UTC
Andski wrote:
CCP has not created any incentive for hisec players to build their own infrastructure. None. Virtually everything you need is provided for free - there is no shortage of available manufacturing slots even within a few jumps of Jita. Literally the only benefit of doing /anything/ in a POS is a 25% research/'manufacturing time reduction. Even if you did argue that that is an incentive to build infrastructure of your own, there's nothing preventing hiseccers from simply using an alt corp while keeping their mains in wardec-immune 0% tax personal corps, with literally the only risk they face being a suicide gank.


You need the POS for ME and copy for invention as the available public slots have very, very long waits that dwarf the 25% boost from the POS.


Even if there was incentive to build our own infrastructure, we'd just have manufactruing/research lats that don't undock, and then use out of corp/NPC corp alts for mining, transporting, etc.
Takseen
Federal Defense Union
Gallente Federation
#139 - 2013-03-05 22:03:45 UTC
LHA Tarawa wrote:
Takseen wrote:

A few bears said that about the 11% NPC corp tax. Turns out it didn't matter.


Because it is so easy to get around the tax. Create a corp of just you and your alts. Do not do any recruiting. Don't post under a traceable toon. Never talk in local. If you get a war dec, disband and create another corp of just your alts.


I assume some players did do that. Poor sods. Many just stayed in the NPC corp, because an 11% tax just isn't that big a deal, and they liked talking to people in an MMO. Weirdos.
Alavaria Fera
GoonWaffe
#140 - 2013-03-05 22:06:37 UTC
LHA Tarawa wrote:
Andski wrote:
CCP has not created any incentive for hisec players to build their own infrastructure. None. Virtually everything you need is provided for free - there is no shortage of available manufacturing slots even within a few jumps of Jita. Literally the only benefit of doing /anything/ in a POS is a 25% research/'manufacturing time reduction. Even if you did argue that that is an incentive to build infrastructure of your own, there's nothing preventing hiseccers from simply using an alt corp while keeping their mains in wardec-immune 0% tax personal corps, with literally the only risk they face being a suicide gank.

You need the POS for ME and copy for invention as the available public slots have very, very long waits that dwarf the 25% boost from the POS.

Even if there was incentive to build our own infrastructure, we'd just have manufactruing/research lats that don't undock, and then use out of corp/NPC corp alts for mining, transporting, etc.

Sounds like smart and efficient use of the game mechanics in highsec.

Triggered by: Wars of Sovless Agression, Bending the Knee, Twisting the Knife, Eating Sov Wheaties, Bombless Bombers, Fizzlesov, Interceptor Fleets, Running Away, GhostTime Vuln, Renters, Bombs, Bubbles ?