These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Ships & Modules

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

RIP Hurricane

Author
Kasutra
No Vacancies
No Vacancies.
#21 - 2013-02-20 22:21:19 UTC
I have to consider PG even when fitting ACs now. This confuses and angers me.
Gabriel Karade
Coreli Corporation
Pandemic Legion
#22 - 2013-02-20 23:04:25 UTC
Kenneth O'Hara wrote:
Tsai Ashitaka wrote:
Minmatar crybaby tears are so delicious...

The hurricane went from "hands down above average at EVERYTHING" to "pretty good", in line with the other battlecruisers.

Being able to easily fit the largest guns AND two neuts on a shield OR armor tanked ship was a little game breaking.

And don't throw the stat about "Hurr durr the drake is the most used ship."

That's due to fleet doctrine, not performance. Drake has a stout tank, so you don't instantly die when you're primaried. It makes sense that big null fleets would want to use it.

If I'm in a small gang, I'd fly the old cane over ANY other BC.

Now, at least, I have options.

Now with the PG nerfs, you can't even do tech 2 guns with a decent armor fit.

I agree that it needed a nerf but to the point where you can't do a decent armor fit? 400 pg was taken off the pg. That's about 50 or 75 too much to be taken away.
Dual 180 II's, 10mn MWD, 1600mm plate and a meta 4 medium neut all fit with exactly 106 pg spare.

You really are doing it very wrong if you have 3x ancillary current routers fitted...

War Machine: http://www.eveonline.com/ingameboard.asp?a=topic&threadID=386293

Eugene Kerner
TunDraGon
Goonswarm Federation
#23 - 2013-02-20 23:05:15 UTC
Kenneth O'Hara wrote:
Eugene Kerner wrote:
Medium Ancilary Current Router

3 already in use...

You just need one....that means if you want to fit a standard armor cane

TunDraGon is recruiting! "Also, your boobs [:o] "   CCP Eterne, 2012 "When in doubt...make a diȼk joke." Robin Williams - RIP

Ginger Barbarella
#24 - 2013-02-21 00:17:31 UTC
BoSau Hotim wrote:
Honestly? I wish CCP would stop nerfing ships. Only buff those that need buffing to balance out.

Two powergrid nerfs and now a high slot is gone? WTH????

I am now wearing a black armband in memory of a ship that was once the ship that the Dread Pirate Roberts would have sailed...

It's been INCONCEIVABLE!!!


*Insert obligatory "lrn2eve" here*

"Blow it all on Quafe and strippers." --- Sorlac

Katran Luftschreck
Royal Ammatar Engineering Corps
#25 - 2013-02-21 07:20:01 UTC  |  Edited by: Katran Luftschreck
Once again, bitter drone user laughing at prophesied "You'll get yours next" coming true for all the people who told us all to "HTFU" last patch.

Lol

http://youtu.be/t0q2F8NsYQ0

Sigras
Conglomo
#26 - 2013-02-21 07:47:49 UTC
why are people complaining about the hurrucane? Its still the fastest Combat BC slightly edging out the active tanked brutix and way faster than anything else .

This means that it never has to commit to any fight ever; if another BC does something it doesnt like, it just leaves; try that with a brutix where youre basically always in scramble range meaning that you cant even leave if things dont go your way.

Having the best speed and range basically means that you should be the worst in basically every other way; I think people severely underestimate the ability to run away if things get bad.

I have a hurricane that runs 425s an energy neut, two shield extenders and a MWD, if your skills lack a bit, go for a single extender and EM hardener.

The hurricane is still one of the better battlecruisers IMHO and if you disagree try flying a ferox or a brutix.
Seolfor
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#27 - 2013-02-21 08:00:37 UTC  |  Edited by: Seolfor
Quote:
Dual 180 II's, 10mn MWD, 1600mm plate and a meta 4 medium neut all fit with exactly 106 pg spare.

You really are doing it very wrong if you have 3x ancillary current routers fitted...


3 Anci Rigs is dumb, but a brawl cane with this fit or even 220s and a single Med Neut, 1 Anci Rig.. bwahaha. What do you exactly plan to brawl, please do share.

With a single med neut, youre not gonna cap out any competently fit BC - HAM Drakes, Plated Harby, Repping Myrms or Brutixes, Neut or HAM Proph or even a HAM Cyclone with XL-ASB. Whom can an Armor Cane reliably break?

With a single med neut, you can no longer 1 v/s X Cruisers, which most current Brawl BCs will easily manage. Any 2 of Mallers, Moa, Thorax, MedBlaster Vexors, Ruptures, competently brawl fit will tear the current Cane a new one.

Stop looking at the Cane in isolation. Relatively, to other BCs, its fraked.

- Cant brawl, period.
- Cant kite AS WELL AS the other BCs: Sure, its faster, with inferior gank and tank AND projection, grats you can run away
- Sure, Arty Fits enjoy their 3-4k Alpha niche, that's about it
- Damage selection makes the dps even lower

So what you gonna use your armor cane for? Frig killing? Might as well stick with the SFI, does it way better.

Quote:
Having the best speed and range basically


Wat? Better range than who? Blaster BCs? Cause the Harbinger and Drake are far better at damage projection than the Cane.

All that speed, yes, you can run away.
Super spikinator
Hegemonous Conscripts
#28 - 2013-02-21 08:17:03 UTC  |  Edited by: Super spikinator
Kenneth O'Hara wrote:
Eugene Kerner wrote:
Medium Ancilary Current Router

3 already in use...


what are you trying to fit...

EDIT: also, what toolset are you using?
BoSau Hotim
Uitraan Diversified Holdings Incorporated
#29 - 2013-02-21 08:35:55 UTC  |  Edited by: BoSau Hotim
Naomi Anthar wrote:
BoSau Hotim wrote:
Honestly? I wish CCP would stop nerfing ships. Only buff those that need buffing to balance out.

Two powergrid nerfs and now a high slot is gone? WTH????

I am now wearing a black armband in memory of a ship that was once the ship that the Dread Pirate Roberts would have sailed...

It's been INCONCEIVABLE!!!


Can you cry more ? Please ? I'm serious ! So enjoyable !

There are 2 diffrent types of crybabies - one type is right and the others are wrong. Both cry. And i'm afraid not only you cry but also belong to 2nd group.
I was hoping for more sever nerfs. But i guess thats better than nothing.


Lol.. if you think this is crying your pretty slow. No wonder you only have 51 likes to your name. What I say is a simple statement with some humor to it.. you must not be able to read very well. I am also suggesting to CCP not to nerf what is already good, but to buff the other ships instead to make for some epic battles. It is a legit suggestion.

If you are here on the boards to troll and torch people you might want to actually say something that is new with some actual thought behind it.... and grow up a little. I prefer mature or truly funny people to chat with.

I'm not a carebear... I'm a SPACE BARBIE!  Now... where's Ken?

Sigras
Conglomo
#30 - 2013-02-21 08:49:07 UTC
Seolfor wrote:
Sigras wrote:
Having the best speed and range basically

Wat? Better range than who? Blaster BCs? Cause the Harbinger and Drake are far better at damage projection than the Cane.

All that speed, yes, you can run away.

I suppose I should have been a bit more specific; the hurricane has the best range options of any combat BC.

Against the harb, it can close to 0 km where it has a slight damage advantage and a huge tracking advantage and a neut or sit at 35 km where it has a massive damage advantage; all the harb can do is hope to get a clean shot off as the hurricane pilot sets him up for whatever plan he decides to use to take the harb down.

The drake has far less damage potential than the cane, so closing to 0 and using hail would be the best strategy against the drake.

That being said, all of these things are in the seat of the hurricane pilot which gives him an inherent advantage as he gets to pick his fights.

As for the running away comment, this is the most valuable thing that people often gloss over.

If youre sitting in a hurricane battling any other combat BC, your thought process goes "if he has friends i have to run away"

If youre sitting in any other combat BC battling a hurricane, your thought process goes "if he has friends im going to die"

Ill take a 5% worse ship that can run away if things go sour on me over a 5% better ship that always has to commit to a fight any day. I might not get as many kills, but ill almost never take a loss.
Sigras
Conglomo
#31 - 2013-02-21 09:01:15 UTC
BoSau Hotim wrote:
Naomi Anthar wrote:
BoSau Hotim wrote:
Honestly? I wish CCP would stop nerfing ships. Only buff those that need buffing to balance out.

Two powergrid nerfs and now a high slot is gone? WTH????

I am now wearing a black armband in memory of a ship that was once the ship that the Dread Pirate Roberts would have sailed...

It's been INCONCEIVABLE!!!


Can you cry more ? Please ? I'm serious ! So enjoyable !

There are 2 diffrent types of crybabies - one type is right and the others are wrong. Both cry. And i'm afraid not only you cry but also belong to 2nd group.
I was hoping for more sever nerfs. But i guess thats better than nothing.


Lol.. if you think this is crying your pretty slow. No wonder you only have 51 likes to your name. What I say is a simple statement with some humor to it.. you must not be able to read very well. I am also suggesting to CCP not to nerf what is already good, but to buff the other ships instead to make for some epic battles. It is a legit suggestion.

Have you ever heard of power creep? Never nerfing anything but buffing everything else instead is not power creep thats power LEAP

It is far far easier to drop the power of one overpowered ship/module than it is to buff the 5000+ other ships/modules

think about it; if the new harbinger is OP after this patch (not saying it is just using it as an example) than you're suggesting they slightly buff every other ship in Eve in order to reduce the releative effectiveness of the harbinger?

Thats not only ridiculous, but also would lead to several other balance problems for the game designers.
BoSau Hotim
Uitraan Diversified Holdings Incorporated
#32 - 2013-02-21 09:26:26 UTC
Sigras wrote:
BoSau Hotim wrote:
Naomi Anthar wrote:
BoSau Hotim wrote:
Honestly? I wish CCP would stop nerfing ships. Only buff those that need buffing to balance out.

Two powergrid nerfs and now a high slot is gone? WTH????

I am now wearing a black armband in memory of a ship that was once the ship that the Dread Pirate Roberts would have sailed...

It's been INCONCEIVABLE!!!


Can you cry more ? Please ? I'm serious ! So enjoyable !

There are 2 diffrent types of crybabies - one type is right and the others are wrong. Both cry. And i'm afraid not only you cry but also belong to 2nd group.
I was hoping for more sever nerfs. But i guess thats better than nothing.


Lol.. if you think this is crying your pretty slow. No wonder you only have 51 likes to your name. What I say is a simple statement with some humor to it.. you must not be able to read very well. I am also suggesting to CCP not to nerf what is already good, but to buff the other ships instead to make for some epic battles. It is a legit suggestion.

Have you ever heard of power creep? Never nerfing anything but buffing everything else instead is not power creep thats power LEAP

It is far far easier to drop the power of one overpowered ship/module than it is to buff the 5000+ other ships/modules

think about it; if the new harbinger is OP after this patch (not saying it is just using it as an example) than you're suggesting they slightly buff every other ship in Eve in order to reduce the releative effectiveness of the harbinger?

Thats not only ridiculous, but also would lead to several other balance problems for the game designers.


Nah, never heard of power creep. They already are buffing/nerfing a huge amount of ships anyway so i don't see your point being valid in stating that they would have to do that... because they already are. Balancing BC's is what I am talking about and what the Dev's are doing. I liked my idea of them not nerfing ships but buffing/balancing the lesser BC's.

So have you fit the harby yet to see how it would compare to a cane? I would be quite interested in that since I fly both ships.

I'm not a carebear... I'm a SPACE BARBIE!  Now... where's Ken?

Sigras
Conglomo
#33 - 2013-02-21 09:50:42 UTC
somehow i think you completely missed the point of my post. Yes currently they're rebalancing all of the ships, but just pretend with me for a moment, use your imagination.

Pretend they get all done with balancing all the ships, and pretend they're all pretty well balanced except for one ship (lets call it the harbinger) which is totally overpowered.

now with your idea of never nerfing anything they would need to go back over every ship and bring it up to the balance level of the harbinger (in this case)

any sane game developer would just nerf the one ship that was causing the problem because thats WAY simpler than buffing all the other ships in relation to it.

And yes i have fit out the harb . . . its a pretty good ship as long as you dont want to go anywhere . . . but if you need mobility that is not the ship for you.
culo duro
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#34 - 2013-02-21 10:01:12 UTC  |  Edited by: culo duro
RIP Cane? How even?
It's still among one of the most powerful BCs, except now you have to fit it like other BCs.

You know, before the nerfs you could fit a Cane with 220s guns and 2x 1600mm plates, AND 3 Trimarks, you had to put 1 med neut on though and leave a high so.
Then they nerfed it so it was a decent boat, 220s 1x 1600mm plate, AND 3 trimarks, you could only have 1 small neut on though.

Now where you gotta fit it like a brutix you complain. The Harb was even worse, you had to have a cap booster on it, and it was almost impossible to fit with any T2s.

The Cane got a balance it's still in the game. You got access to all damage types + a insane falloff.
I'm sorry they made your "I Win at PVP" boat into a regular BC. It was waaaay OP and needed the nerfs it got.

Edit: i'm sorry i just had to point this out.
Blasters are locked to Kinetic/Thermal damage.
Lasers are locked to EM.
Projectiles got access to all damage types, which is why they do less Damage overall.

Fit this
Quote:

[Hurricane, buffer Cane]
Damage Control II
Energized Adaptive Nano Membrane II
Energized Adaptive Nano Membrane II
1600mm Reinforced Steel Plates II
Gyrostabilizer II
Gyrostabilizer II

Warp Disruptor II
Stasis Webifier II
Stasis Webifier II
10MN Microwarpdrive II

220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
Medium Energy Neutralizer II

Medium Ancillary Current Router I
Medium Trimark Armor Pump I
Medium Trimark Armor Pump I


Warrior II x5
Warrior II x1

I've starting blogging http://www.epvpc.blogspot.com 

BoSau Hotim
Uitraan Diversified Holdings Incorporated
#35 - 2013-02-21 10:46:57 UTC
culo duro wrote:
RIP Cane? How even?
It's still among one of the most powerful BCs, except now you have to fit it like other BCs.

You know, before the nerfs you could fit a Cane with 220s guns and 2x 1600mm plates, AND 3 Trimarks, you had to put 1 med neut on though and leave a high so.
Then they nerfed it so it was a decent boat, 220s 1x 1600mm plate, AND 3 trimarks, you could only have 1 small neut on though.

Now where you gotta fit it like a brutix you complain. The Harb was even worse, you had to have a cap booster on it, and it was almost impossible to fit with any T2s.

The Cane got a balance it's still in the game. You got access to all damage types + a insane falloff.
I'm sorry they made your "I Win at PVP" boat into a regular BC. It was waaaay OP and needed the nerfs it got.

Edit: i'm sorry i just had to point this out.
Blasters are locked to Kinetic/Thermal damage.
Lasers are locked to EM.
Projectiles got access to all damage types, which is why they do less Damage overall.



Oh my gosh yesss... the projectiles do have allll the damage. I actually really hate that. ... and yes I loved my win at pvp boat... and that is why my post was RIP hurricane... :)

I'm not a carebear... I'm a SPACE BARBIE!  Now... where's Ken?

Seolfor
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#36 - 2013-02-21 11:51:04 UTC
Quote:
You got access to all damage types


Quote:
Fit this
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M
220mm Vulcan AutoCannon II, Hail M


Hey man, I like your damage type.

Ya, to make it competitive to other BC brawlers, you need to use HAIL.

Quote:
As for the running away comment, this is the most valuable thing that people often gloss over.

If youre sitting in a hurricane battling any other combat BC, your thought process goes "if he has friends i have to run away"

If youre sitting in any other combat BC battling a hurricane, your thought process goes "if he has friends im going to die"

Ill take a 5% worse ship that can run away if things go sour on me over a 5% better ship that always has to commit to a fight any day. I might not get as many kills, but ill almost never take a loss.


I don't get all these speed arguments - are you saying, that we should celebrate the fact - that with a quicker BC (Cane), you can keep your targets pointed till your blob arrives?

Quote:
sit at 35 km where it has a massive damage advantage


Yup, lets assume a faction point and Loki Links, got it.

I'll simplify it for you:

- Can you still kill and win in a Cane, Yes, Ofcourse

- Can you brawl in a Cane, yes, but a HAM Drake, Plated Harbi, Brutix, Myrm, Neut/HAM Prophecy do it much better. Your double neuts previously gave you an edge. No more. Hail gives you similar gank to most, but then no dmg selection.(Prophecy has best Tank, Brutix has best Gank, Drake has best Combo, Harbi has best projection with insta-Scorch to 24km)

- Can you kite in a Cane, yes, but your gank (between 20-28km), tank and projection is worse than a Shield Harbinger or HAM & HML Drake or HML/HAM Cyclone. Barrage removes the core strength of AC's i.e. Damage Selection, grats youre like the Kinetic Drake or Scorch Harbi as far as Damage versatility goes (Cyclone has best dmg selection amongst kiting BCs).

Yes, youre viable, youre unfortunately the worst of the lot - someone had to be at the bottom, its you.

culo duro
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#37 - 2013-02-21 12:07:33 UTC
Quote:
Quote:
As for the running away comment, this is the most valuable thing that people often gloss over.

If youre sitting in a hurricane battling any other combat BC, your thought process goes "if he has friends i have to run away"

If youre sitting in any other combat BC battling a hurricane, your thought process goes "if he has friends im going to die"

Ill take a 5% worse ship that can run away if things go sour on me over a 5% better ship that always has to commit to a fight any day. I might not get as many kills, but ill almost never take a loss.


I don't get all these speed arguments - are you saying, that we should celebrate the fact - that with a quicker BC (Cane), you can keep your targets pointed till your blob arrives?


Do you pvp alot in a cane? or have you ever encountered a blaster boat?
Blasters = Shortest range / Most DPS
Projectiles = Medium Range / Medium DPS
Lasers = Longest Range / Lowest DPS

Quote:
Quote:
sit at 35 km where it has a massive damage advantage


Yup, lets assume a faction point and Loki Links, got it.

I'll simplify it for you:

- Can you still kill and win in a Cane, Yes, Ofcourse

- Can you brawl in a Cane, yes, but a HAM Drake, Plated Harbi, Brutix, Myrm, Neut/HAM Prophecy do it much better. Your double neuts previously gave you an edge. No more. Hail gives you similar gank to most, but then no dmg selection.(Prophecy has best Tank, Brutix has best Gank, Drake has best Combo, Harbi has best projection with insta-Scorch to 24km)

- Can you kite in a Cane, yes, but your gank (between 20-28km), tank and projection is worse than a Shield Harbinger or HAM & HML Drake or HML/HAM Cyclone. Barrage removes the core strength of AC's i.e. Damage Selection, grats youre like the Kinetic Drake or Scorch Harbi as far as Damage versatility goes (Cyclone has best dmg selection amongst kiting BCs).

Yes, youre viable, youre unfortunately the worst of the lot - someone had to be at the bottom, its you.


You don't get the core of the cane. Capless Weapons, you can't be neuted in cane. Besides throw that Brutix at me, i'd love to get a brutix kill in a cane. The Cane is fine where it is.

Now answer this, Why would anyone fly a loki then? Low DPS, and low armor compared to the Proteus. God dammit.

I've starting blogging http://www.epvpc.blogspot.com 

Daniel Whateley
#38 - 2013-02-21 12:08:44 UTC
Hurricane was never overpowered, its range with autocannons was within 30km any further and you wouldn't do any damage, and as for an arty boat it was only 300-400 dps at most, and we all know how terrible arties track, this shouldn't of happened to the cane, almost all of the other battlecruisers were more powerful than the cane, shorter range of coarse but in a 1v1 against a gallente ship, the gallente ship would win in brawling, the changes to it have unbalanced it...
culo duro
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#39 - 2013-02-21 12:10:31 UTC
Daniel Whateley wrote:
Hurricane was never overpowered, its range with autocannons was within 30km any further and you wouldn't do any damage, and as for an arty boat it was only 300-400 dps at most, and we all know how terrible arties track, this shouldn't of happened to the cane, almost all of the other battlecruisers were more powerful than the cane, shorter range of coarse but in a 1v1 against a gallente ship, the gallente ship would win in brawling, the changes to it have unbalanced it...


Gallente Boats = Brawlers, for max DPS which is why alot of people prefer them.

I've starting blogging http://www.epvpc.blogspot.com 

Seolfor
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#40 - 2013-02-21 12:15:11 UTC  |  Edited by: Seolfor
Quote:
Lasers = Longest Range / Lowest DPS


I don't think the Harbinger got your memo squirt.

Or the Drake, cause if capless weapon systems is the Canes 'core' - its shared by Drake, Cyclone, Prophecy, Myrmidon. (5 outta 8 Combat BCs)

Youre saying Gallente ships need to be superior brawlers - er ok. The cane had a plan B with the 2 neuts previously against blaster boats i.e. I cant out dps you, ill shut ur guns off and hence win the fight.

The present cane CANNOT brawl - its actually not limited to Cane, since the blaster buff, no equivalent Matari Hull can Brawl vs the equivalent Gallente Hull.

- Rifter vs Incursus
- Wolf vs Enyo
- Rupture vs Thorax or Vexor
- Cane vs Brutix or Myrmidon (it could due to the 2 med neuts in the past, but not with a single neut, now it cant)

[All in the name of damage selection]

This is why the Cane needs a 2nd utility high - its cap-less guns and passive tank was previously complemented by the 2 med neuts, giving it staying power vs cruisers and BCs. No longer can you outbrawl the blaster cruisers/BCs. (or even the Drake or Harbinger)

Finally, the kiting AC Cane is outperformed by Harbi and Drake - so what is the Cane's niche?

Speed!! - TO RUN AWAY, ammirite??