These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE New Citizens Q&A

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page123Next page
 

Newbie Opinion: Why it's CRUCIAL that EVE Online does not to free-to-play...

Author
Lost Greybeard
Drunken Yordles
#21 - 2013-02-15 10:19:31 UTC
J'Poll wrote:
A. Eve can be free to play. Just make 600mil a month and buy PLEX.


Well, to be fair, it's more like make

(Amount of isk a dedicated PvE player makes in a month of grinding)*(Number of players willing to buy a PLEX so they don't have to bother with grinding) / (Number of moochers that would rather spend isk on a PLEX than actually give three beers' worth of money a month to the people that make a game they enjoy enough to play)

So as the number of freeloaders that don't want to give money to someone even though they're using the product go up, and the number of people willing to chip in extra beer money for the devs goes down, that price can fluctuate quite a bit. For instance, a year or two back it was more like 200Misk.
Mokepoke
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#22 - 2013-02-15 10:29:35 UTC
Lost Greybeard wrote:
J'Poll wrote:
A. Eve can be free to play. Just make 600mil a month and buy PLEX.


Well, to be fair, it's more like make

(Amount of isk a dedicated PvE player makes in a month of grinding)*(Number of players willing to buy a PLEX so they don't have to bother with grinding) / (Number of moochers that would rather spend isk on a PLEX than actually give three beers' worth of money a month to the people that make a game they enjoy enough to play)

So as the number of freeloaders that don't want to give money to someone even though they're using the product go up, and the number of people willing to chip in extra beer money for the devs goes down, that price can fluctuate quite a bit. For instance, a year or two back it was more like 200Misk.


PLEX doesn't just come out of thin air, though. At the end of the day, someone bought a timecode to create that PLEX. I think if CCP were unhappy with the current PLEX for Isk system they would change it.
Miss Spent Youth
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#23 - 2013-02-15 16:03:28 UTC
Nova Serine wrote:
...would be forced to suffer the influx of casual rubberneckers who feel they have nothing to lose by indulging their worst habits all over this gamespace. Granted, many new players of requisite quality (read: taking this game seriously enough to not be a total d-bag in game and forum) would come to the table, but the risk is too great. Better to keep this experience subscriber based. If you're willing to pay a monthly fee for something that demands that you use your brain as much as you use the mouse and keyboard, you're going to make the experience matter and not squander it with alpha a-hole nonsense.


I find this incredulous TBH. The D'baggery that goes on in this game is the worse I have seen anywhere! Children behave better than most eve players. From what I have witnessed during my month long playing is that many people that play this game are socially inept to a large degree. They associate anonymity with the right to behave like scrubs.

Nova Serine wrote:
There's only so much space out there to play in, and it would be a real damn shame to have to this experience eroded by having to deal with the non-committed who have only signed up to cause havoc, impart grief and lower the reputation of what is unquestionably the greatest MMO of all time.

I would question the greatest MMO of all time. you clearly have not played that many if you conclude that. Also clearly the people that are paying are also paying so they can be aholes. You see them everywhere.
Grimm Griefer
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#24 - 2013-02-15 16:42:04 UTC
WOW (urgh) probably rates as the bet MMO of all time in terms of financial success.
EvE's claim is that it is the only true sandbox MMO and the only one where anyone can be anything, for all the scumbags, pirates, griefers and pains there are those that don't act like that.
The difference is that the level of intellect that is required for this game is much higher than others, where it is is kill xx beasties get xp level up, boring.
here you have choices and a LOOOT of choices on what you want to do, hell its the only game that financial analysts where needed to observe the game to manage inflation.
graphically it kills most other games I have played (bar maybe the secret world) and space combat graphics and sounds are sick.
watching major battles on youtube sends shivers down your spine, and realising that everything on the field is player controlled better.
and seeing 50k online and knowing they are all on the same server as you priceless.
Nova Serine
Republic University
Minmatar Republic
#25 - 2013-02-15 18:48:12 UTC  |  Edited by: Nova Serine
Miss Spent Youth wrote:
Nova Serine wrote:
...would be forced to suffer the influx of casual rubberneckers who feel they have nothing to lose by indulging their worst habits all over this gamespace. Granted, many new players of requisite quality (read: taking this game seriously enough to not be a total d-bag in game and forum) would come to the table, but the risk is too great. Better to keep this experience subscriber based. If you're willing to pay a monthly fee for something that demands that you use your brain as much as you use the mouse and keyboard, you're going to make the experience matter and not squander it with alpha a-hole nonsense.


I find this incredulous TBH. The D'baggery that goes on in this game is the worse I have seen anywhere! Children behave better than most eve players. From what I have witnessed during my month long playing is that many people that play this game are socially inept to a large degree. They associate anonymity with the right to behave like scrubs.

Nova Serine wrote:
There's only so much space out there to play in, and it would be a real damn shame to have to this experience eroded by having to deal with the non-committed who have only signed up to cause havoc, impart grief and lower the reputation of what is unquestionably the greatest MMO of all time.

I would question the greatest MMO of all time. you clearly have not played that many if you conclude that. Also clearly the people that are paying are also paying so they can be aholes. You see them everywhere.


I don't doubt that there is indeed d-baggery going on in EVE (in fact I'm sure of it) but if this game were ever to go f2p that sort of bad behaviour would expand exponentially.

And while I haven't played every single MMO out there, I've played most of the heavy hitters and for my money, this one is now at the top of the list. Just my opinion of course.

Blink

Two rolls of duct tape; one for my ship, and the other for unruly ride-alongs.

Zanzbar
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#26 - 2013-02-15 18:53:18 UTC
Mokepoke wrote:
Not entirely. Dust has a lot of microtransactions that directly affect gameplay. I can imagine Dust already funds itself.

It's also a really fun game with a playerbase just as mature as Eve has.


Was agreeing with you up until the maturity part..... have met some of them? Id name specific groups but id probably end up trolling


Also ccp has expressly said that all micro transaction on the eve side of things will be strictly vanity based, it hard to properly fund a game of that alone if they ever were to go full ftp
J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#27 - 2013-02-16 14:12:57 UTC
Mokepoke wrote:
Not entirely. Dust has a lot of microtransactions that directly affect gameplay. I can imagine Dust already funds itself.

It's also a really fun game with a playerbase just as mature as Eve has.


wait....Dust and as mature as EVE.

Are we talking about the same Dust514?

Ever since it went Open beta (so not only EVE players), have you heard comms and seen local...

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Almighty Narshe
The Zetetic Elench
#28 - 2013-02-16 19:00:54 UTC
Just to be the devil's advocate for a moment, going F2P would mean an influx of idiotic noobs who think they're awesome at everything because of their Call of Duty K/D ratio.

And these my friends, would be fun to slaughter in their thousands (and their rage-tears would be DELICIOUS) :D

Who knows, we might even see Joe Phoenix levels of noobishness once more! Zederick would have a field day!
Keno Skir
#29 - 2013-02-16 20:55:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Keno Skir
Miss Spent Youth wrote:
I would question the greatest MMO of all time. you clearly have not played that many if you conclude that. Also clearly the people that are paying are also paying so they can be aholes. You see them everywhere.


I strongly disagree. I have also never found a playerbase like EvE's in other mmo's. All the other games i'v played for any length of time left me feeling a little old dispite my age. EvE has at least for me provided a trully memorable and unique experience with some of the finest folk it's been my pleasure to encounter.

Also there are d-bags, but really it's down to you to sift through the chaff for the really good parts just like real life. I also consider EvE to be the most expansive and deep mmos i'v ever played.

Nova : You are i believe located out in nulsec atm? If not i suggest it, but if i'm correct about that i think it may explain the sharp contrast between your experience of EvE's locals and that of many others. I found that by leaving hisec and embracing some of the most player driven aspects of the game, i naturally encountered others who shared my sense of adventure. These are the people i will mostly remember from my time in EvE.

Dispite the horror stories, i have learned that people in Lowsec, Nul and especially wormhole folk are some of the friendliest most down to earth people you could meet. They like me and many others abandoned the "Free to Play" atmosphere of high security space for the unknown and exciting world that is out there for those who seek it. These people are (in my experience) more fun to play with than "Grindin' for this months PLEX" people.

HiSec can be really fun for a short while, but it's easy. You don't have to be very smart (no offence intended) to get by in hisec. There are however parts of this game that REQUIRE an above average intelligence to play effectively. It stands to reason you will encounter a more interesting class of people there, even if all areas have their idiots.

Hope to encounter you one day Nova, always like your posts :)
Keno Skir
#30 - 2013-02-16 21:07:15 UTC  |  Edited by: Keno Skir
Almighty Narshe wrote:
Just to be the devil's advocate for a moment, going F2P would mean an influx of idiotic noobs who think they're awesome at everything because of their Call of Duty K/D ratio.

And these my friends, would be fun to slaughter in their thousands (and their rage-tears would be DELICIOUS) :D

Who knows, we might even see Joe Phoenix levels of noobishness once more! Zederick would have a field day!


True, but in reality if that happened CCP would most likely cut off your nuts for touching the RMT loving new class of player.

Goodbye slaughter, hello.. kitty?

Miss Spent Youth wrote:
what I have witnessed during my month long playing is that many people that play this game are socially inept to a large degree.


You've played what we're saying is the deepest and most involving game ever for a month and feel you have grounds to disagree? I played a year before i even got close to finding my perfect playstyle, and damnit i like it that way Evil
Almighty Narshe
The Zetetic Elench
#31 - 2013-02-16 21:57:19 UTC
Miss Spent Youth wrote:
From what I have witnessed during my month long playing is that many people that play this game are socially inept to a large degree.


YOUR FACE is socially inept to a large degree.

Ha! That showed her! =P
J'Poll
School of Applied Knowledge
Caldari State
#32 - 2013-02-16 22:07:22 UTC
Keno Skir wrote:
Almighty Narshe wrote:
Just to be the devil's advocate for a moment, going F2P would mean an influx of idiotic noobs who think they're awesome at everything because of their Call of Duty K/D ratio.

And these my friends, would be fun to slaughter in their thousands (and their rage-tears would be DELICIOUS) :D

Who knows, we might even see Joe Phoenix levels of noobishness once more! Zederick would have a field day!


True, but in reality if that happened CCP would most likely cut off your nuts for touching the RMT loving new class of player.

Goodbye slaughter, hello.. kitty?

Miss Spent Youth wrote:
what I have witnessed during my month long playing is that many people that play this game are socially inept to a large degree.


You've played what we're saying is the deepest and most involving game ever for a month and feel you have grounds to disagree? I played a year before i even got close to finding my perfect playstyle, and damnit i like it that way Evil


This.

A month hardly qualifies for having an opinion about the game and the community.

Personal channel: Crazy Dutch Guy

Help channel: Help chat - Reloaded

Public roams channels: RvB Ganked / Redemption Road / Spectre Fleet / Bombers bar / The Content Club

Miss Spent Youth
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#33 - 2013-02-16 23:16:27 UTC
Keno Skir wrote:
Miss Spent Youth wrote:
I would question the greatest MMO of all time. you clearly have not played that many if you conclude that. Also clearly the people that are paying are also paying so they can be aholes. You see them everywhere.


I strongly disagree. I have also never found a playerbase like EvE's in other mmo's. All the other games i'v played for any length of time left me feeling a little old dispite my age. EvE has at least for me provided a trully memorable and unique experience with some of the finest folk it's been my pleasure to encounter.

Also there are d-bags, but really it's down to you to sift through the chaff for the really good parts just like real life. I also consider EvE to be the most expansive and deep mmos i'v ever played.

*snip*

HiSec can be really fun for a short while, but it's easy. You don't have to be very smart (no offence intended) to get by in hisec. There are however parts of this game that REQUIRE an above average intelligence to play effectively. It stands to reason you will encounter a more interesting class of people there, even if all areas have their idiots.


Thanks Keno good post. Disagreeing without a disrespectful tone! Who would have thought it?

What I have experienced so far in the game is that many seem to love the anonymity behave in an unsavoury way. I must have caught it on a bad few days. I have been lurking on the forums for a while and there do seem alot of people that love to troll. saying things to people they would never say face to face. It has certainly been as bad as any gaming forum I have ever seen. At times no better than "Barrens chat" <--- Famous WoW reference for "your mom jokes and the like. (yes I did play WoW for about six months in Vanilla WoW. Not ashamed of it either. Had some great times and still am friends to this day with many of the folks I met there)

On the other hand I have, I agree with you, also met some great folks too. Several have helped me and showed great kindness. Given advice etc. Through the rookie help channel I have lost count of the people that have private convoed me to offer help. I am sitting on 50 million ISK from one guy! But that is the same in all the MMO games I have ever played.

As for the greatest MMO of all time, this is surly subjective at best? I have played perhaps 30 odd titles in the last 10 years or so many of them fine games. Eve is truly a masterpiece, but to label it the best MMO of all time is egging the pudding.
Katran Luftschreck
Royal Ammatar Engineering Corps
#34 - 2013-02-17 00:55:14 UTC
I agree with OP but for different reasons:

1) I've yet to see a "Free to Play" game that wasn't "Pay to Win." This turns the entire game into a sad wasteland where victory goes to whoever is willing to blow the most RL cash on it. Yes, you can sell enough PLEX to buy a battleship in EvE, but that won't get you the skills to fly it and that battleship can be just blown up as easily as any other battleship out there. You cannot buy any permanent advantages with PLEX.

2) As for the trollish behavior, yes we've plenty of that from two-week trial accounts aplenty. The anarchist mentality that goes with people who have no intention of ever actually subscribing can be pretty much ignored by the actual subscribers, however, because it comes down to "No troll in a rookie ship is ever going to threaten your peace of mind." But in a F2P model... those exact same two-week minor annoyances can turn into two-year royal pains in the ass. No thanks.

3) The scamming... oh gawd the scamming. You think EvE is scam central now? Imagine what happens when F2P people show up and all decide they want PLEX and/or Aurum to unlock all their crap for them and they want you to pay for it for them? Every system in the game will look like Jita... local in all of New Eden would be just an endless ticker tape of chat bots running lottery scam macros.

http://youtu.be/t0q2F8NsYQ0

First Bass
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#35 - 2013-02-17 09:25:11 UTC  |  Edited by: First Bass
Greener than a Christmas tree fresh off the farm, and you sound like as much an insufferable shithead as the Old Guard in the days of yore. Well, let me tell you a story kid: a long time ago in a galaxy far far away, a bunch of people who'd been playing this game for a long-ass while and thought they were pretty hot **** up in null sec got pissy about some upstarts in Rifters playing around in their sandbox. On principle, they decided they wanted to wipe these doe-eyed newcomers out of existence and once and for all establish their sovereignty over 0.0. Do you know what happened to this Old Guard? They got their teeth kicked in by days-old players 90% of whom could only fly frigates, said players then going on to topple some of the most well-established and powerful corporations and alliances in EVE. As for those newbies, the kindred and progenitors of those unwashed knuckle-dragging scum you seem to hold in so much contempt, they went on to become the single corporation, then alliance, to have the greatest the course of this game's history.

I am, of course, referring to Goonswarm. From a bunch of new bees recruited on Something Awful in Goonfleet, then Goonswarm and the Red Swarm Federation, then Goonwaffe and SOLODRAKBANSOLODRAKBANSOLODRAK, then Goonswarm again and the Clusterfuck Coalition-their entire history, nay, legend, runs contrary to such elitist snobbery.

Is EVE likely to go FTP soon? Not likely, especially with the moratorium on AURUM and 70$ monocles. But if it were, I'd say bring it on. This game lives and thrives on fresh blood.

edit: Words of wisdom.
lollerwaffle
Tribal Liberation Force
Minmatar Republic
#36 - 2013-02-18 09:42:31 UTC
First Bass wrote:
Greener than a Christmas tree fresh off the farm, and you sound like as much an insufferable shithead as the Old Guard in the days of yore. Well, let me tell you a story kid: a long time ago in a galaxy far far away, a bunch of people who'd been playing this game for a long-ass while and thought they were pretty hot **** up in null sec got pissy about some upstarts in Rifters playing around in their sandbox. On principle, they decided they wanted to wipe these doe-eyed newcomers out of existence and once and for all establish their sovereignty over 0.0. Do you know what happened to this Old Guard? They got their teeth kicked in by days-old players 90% of whom could only fly frigates, said players then going on to topple some of the most well-established and powerful corporations and alliances in EVE. As for those newbies, the kindred and progenitors of those unwashed knuckle-dragging scum you seem to hold in so much contempt, they went on to become the single corporation, then alliance, to have the greatest the course of this game's history.

I am, of course, referring to Goonswarm. From a bunch of new bees recruited on Something Awful in Goonfleet, then Goonswarm and the Red Swarm Federation, then Goonwaffe and SOLODRAKBANSOLODRAKBANSOLODRAK, then Goonswarm again and the Clusterfuck Coalition-their entire history, nay, legend, runs contrary to such elitist snobbery.

Is EVE likely to go FTP soon? Not likely, especially with the moratorium on AURUM and 70$ monocles. But if it were, I'd say bring it on. This game lives and thrives on fresh blood.

edit: Words of wisdom.


lol tears
NightCrawler 85
Phoibe Enterprises
#37 - 2013-02-18 10:11:51 UTC
J'Poll wrote:
Mokepoke wrote:
Not entirely. Dust has a lot of microtransactions that directly affect gameplay. I can imagine Dust already funds itself.

It's also a really fun game with a playerbase just as mature as Eve has.


wait....Dust and as mature as EVE.

Are we talking about the same Dust514?

Ever since it went Open beta (so not only EVE players), have you heard comms and seen local...


Sadly i have seen how Dust players talk in local. Im sure that a lot of them are EVE players who are messing around, but some of it is just stupid and embaressing to watch/read and makes me really wish there was some way to block Dust players as a whole from local.

Are there immature people in EVE? Ofc there is! But in general you will find that if you are polite to the player(s) in question they will be polite back. Trying to be a smart ass and/or a know it all are most likely two of the best ways to make sure an EVE player will dislike you/loose respect for you in general. Avoid this and in most cases you will find that its a very nice community to be a part of.
Nova Serine
Republic University
Minmatar Republic
#38 - 2013-02-18 10:23:10 UTC
NightCrawler 85 wrote:


Sadly i have seen how Dust players talk in local. Im sure that a lot of them are EVE players who are messing around, but some of it is just stupid and embaressing to watch/read and makes me really wish there was some way to block Dust players as a whole from local.

Are there immature people in EVE? Ofc there is! But in general you will find that if you are polite to the player(s) in question they will be polite back. Trying to be a smart ass and/or a know it all are most likely two of the best ways to make sure an EVE player will dislike you/loose respect for you in general. Avoid this and in most cases you will find that its a very nice community to be a part of.


It's also worth mentioning just how incredibly easy it is to misconstrue someone's intended sentiment on the forums. It might not always be easy to query for clarification first before putting someone on blast, but the payoff is usually worth it in the end.

Two rolls of duct tape; one for my ship, and the other for unruly ride-alongs.

Cannibal Kane
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#39 - 2013-02-18 13:51:26 UTC
I like you

"Kane is the End Boss of Highsec." -Psychotic Monk

Keno Skir
#40 - 2013-02-18 21:35:38 UTC  |  Edited by: Keno Skir
Cane has never said that before to my knowledge :D

Tbh i'm surprised his face didnt crack open just thinking something so soft.
Previous page123Next page