These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Intergalactic Summit

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

The chains you choose to wear.

Author
von Khan
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#61 - 2013-02-12 15:20:09 UTC
Hold on, correct me if I’m wrong.
You realize that your will is not your own, your reason follows modes of behavior that don’t rise from yourself. You realize free will is just an illusion. Then you decide by your own will that you think you don’t have, to follow the reason of someone else, that you think it came from the preconception of others, which tells you to discard your freedom that you didn’t believe in the first place and become part of a willing collective to follow the results of chemical reactions and raw animal instinct of one man.

Seems your chasing your own tail to avoid responsibility for your actions.

von Khan

Evi Polevhia
Phoenix Naval Operations
Phoenix Naval Systems
#62 - 2013-02-12 15:35:59 UTC
Nothing has so thoroughly convinced me of the evil and malice of Capsuleers then most of the responses in this thread. All it takes is for me to believe in the unkillable Dream, and suddenly I am some mad machine. Either my mind has been replaced by controlling implants or I am some mouthpiece for Master Kuvakei. Because I believe that every thing in the cluster should be united in harmony, I am now somehow defective.

I have taken no offensive action to anyone else, yet, many now consider me someone to be killed on sight without a second thought. For simple words, some are now so afraid of me as to wish my annihilation.

What a magnificent bunch you all are.
Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#63 - 2013-02-12 15:42:06 UTC
von Khan wrote:
Hold on, correct me if I’m wrong.
You realize that your will is not your own, your reason follows modes of behavior that don’t rise from yourself. You realize free will is just an illusion. Then you decide by your own will that you think you don’t have, to follow the reason of someone else, that you think it came from the preconception of others, which tells you to discard your freedom that you didn’t believe in the first place and become part of a willing collective to follow the results of chemical reactions and raw animal instinct of one man.

Seems your chasing your own tail to avoid responsibility for your actions.


Hardly. Allow me to lay out the process.

Our will is not our own, no matter whom we follow.
Reason does not allow you to violate this first clause, but it does allow new ways of interacting with the world beyond instinct.
Free will, as such, does not exist. There is an illusion of free will that arises from interacting with the world using reason.

We do not decide to join Nation of our own free will (as it doesn't exist). What we do have is our reason, and the evidence that a world where people are allowed to react via instinct and not reason is not a viable method of growth for human potential.

We do not follow the reason of another, we follow our own reason.

We discard our freedom (freedom and free will are different things, in that the first exists in a way that can be defined as "without limits to potential actions") to act in ways contrary to the good of the whole, which is actually not all that different from any other social contract other than that we have better ways to enforce it.

And if you believe that Sansha Kuvakei rules via the results of chemical reactions and raw animal instinct, you have clearly never actually met the man and are getting all your information out of the propaganda filled information spread via CONCORD-signatory run news networks. Why would we (here defined as Nation and Nation Loyalists) focus so much attention on augmentation and improvement and yet leave the most important cog-in-the-machine-that-is-Nation unupgraded?

You're letting your hate get the better of you, von Khan. You're usually better than this. Take a few breaths and examine once again your motivations. Commune with your god and ask if he wants you to be reacting in anger and frustration, or with the gifts of reason and intellect that you believe he gave you. Do not discard your many gifts.
Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#64 - 2013-02-12 15:43:20 UTC
Evi Polevhia wrote:
Nothing has so thoroughly convinced me of the evil and malice of Capsuleers then most of the responses in this thread. All it takes is for me to believe in the unkillable Dream, and suddenly I am some mad machine. Either my mind has been replaced by controlling implants or I am some mouthpiece for Master Kuvakei. Because I believe that every thing in the cluster should be united in harmony, I am now somehow defective.

I have taken no offensive action to anyone else, yet, many now consider me someone to be killed on sight without a second thought. For simple words, some are now so afraid of me as to wish my annihilation.

What a magnificent bunch you all are.


Remember, Evi, to most of these people killing you permanently would not be murder, but euthanasia. Always remember that when you're dealing with them.
Simon Louvaki
Khaldari InnoTektoniks and Analytical Solutions
#65 - 2013-02-12 15:53:34 UTC  |  Edited by: Simon Louvaki
Evi Polevhia wrote:
Nothing has so thoroughly convinced me of the evil and malice of Capsuleers then most of the responses in this thread. All it takes is for me to believe in the unkillable Dream, and suddenly I am some mad machine. Either my mind has been replaced by controlling implants or I am some mouthpiece for Master Kuvakei. Because I believe that every thing in the cluster should be united in harmony, I am now somehow defective.

I have taken no offensive action to anyone else, yet, many now consider me someone to be killed on sight without a second thought. For simple words, some are now so afraid of me as to wish my annihilation.

What a magnificent bunch you all are.


Mrs. Polevhia,

First off I want to wish you well in your new life, no one has the right to tell you how you should live it. That however is the issue with the Nation in the eyes of most us. I don't think most people here react adversely so much as to your choice of become as True Citizen, but the fact that your actively helping an organization that is invading Empire space and desires the conquest of the cluster in either revenge for past misdeeds against them or Master Kuvakei's dream. A dream that involves them becoming part of your Utopian ideal if they like it or not. Most people will not so easily accept the destruction of free will for someone elses idea of paradise. When it comes down to it and Sansha calls for you to bring the cluster to his fold, you will obey, you won't think twice (not that you'll have the option) and people will have that reason to fear you and wish you dead.

Sansha doesn't have a good reputation with the cluster. When you announce to the world that you are joining him, people are going to react. Some do it in malice and hate, others do it in fear of what he represents, but all are united in the common defense of freedom of the right to chose. Something I've never seen Sansha offer.

Again, I wish you much happiness in your new life among your brothers and sisters. I hope that we may never meet however. My encounters with Sansha have been less than pleasant and for the most part ended in them attempting to kill me.

Respectfully,

Simon Malkov Louvaki, CEO
Sengokuvaa Corporate HQ
Federal Administration Information Center
Office Complex 781, Tier V
Luminaire VII (Caldari Prime)

-- "The weak of mind are quick to judge with slightest tempt; Thus fools go forth to spread false word." - The Scriptures, Book of Trials 2:13 - 2:21

--"At the narrow passage, there is no brother and no friend." - Hyasyoda Proverb

Ollie Rundle
#66 - 2013-02-12 15:59:15 UTC
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Evi Polevhia wrote:
Nothing has so thoroughly convinced me of the evil and malice of Capsuleers then most of the responses in this thread. All it takes is for me to believe in the unkillable Dream, and suddenly I am some mad machine. Either my mind has been replaced by controlling implants or I am some mouthpiece for Master Kuvakei. Because I believe that every thing in the cluster should be united in harmony, I am now somehow defective.

I have taken no offensive action to anyone else, yet, many now consider me someone to be killed on sight without a second thought. For simple words, some are now so afraid of me as to wish my annihilation.

What a magnificent bunch you all are.


Remember, Evi, to most of these people killing you permanently would not be murder, but euthanasia. Always remember that when you're dealing with them.


Ms. Polevhia, take heart. We will not regard you as mad, misguided or defective. We will not give that excuse to you for the ownership of your future actions.

It is not your hope for a better existence we oppose - indeed, we too strive for this. It is your megalomaniac master's method we reject.

And should you die then your deaths, such as they are for a capsuleer, will not be regarded by us as euthanasia because that term implies a measure of mercy.
von Khan
Ministry of War
Amarr Empire
#67 - 2013-02-12 16:30:02 UTC  |  Edited by: von Khan
Tiberious, pardon me if I’m not making much sense I’m just following your line of thought.

You talk about a method of growth for human potential, what would that be?

von Khan

Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#68 - 2013-02-12 16:36:08 UTC  |  Edited by: Sepherim
I can't agree more with captain Rundle. If we were to kill you, or any of your equals, it would be an act of war, not murder. A war your people started and that has already cost many lives. Oh, and before you disregard my words due to my hatred of the Nation, I can tell you I don't hate you at all. It's a matter of duty. My hatred lies elsewhere.

As for your questions, captain Khan, I believe he means cybertechnological "improvements" of body and mind: mental processors, reduction of chemical implications and such procedures. I don't know much about cybernetics, but I believe that's the way of the Nation to some extent: instead of fusioning the machine into the man as we all do, they put the man inside the machine.

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Evi Polevhia
Phoenix Naval Operations
Phoenix Naval Systems
#69 - 2013-02-12 16:53:03 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
...they put the man inside the machine.


It serves Capsuleers well enough.
Natalcya Katla
Astropolitan Front
#70 - 2013-02-12 17:21:00 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
A war your people started [...].

This is factually incorrect, Captain. The central Empires attacked and invaded the Nation in YC 37. There has never been a peace agreement in the years since, nor a surrender.

A counter-offensive does not make the Nation the aggressor in the war.
Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#71 - 2013-02-12 17:38:43 UTC  |  Edited by: Sepherim
How many years of peace have been since YC 37 until the Sansha invaded our lands? I served in the Imperial Navy for years, and our problems were Omir Sirakusa, The Defiants, and then the Minmatarr Republic. Sansha Kuvakei wasn't on the list. There may have been no formal peace agreement, but an informal peace has lasted for many years now, and it's the Nation the one to blame for breaking it. They could have lived as peacefully and utopially as they'd like on the other side of their wormholes, but instead they chose to attack the empires, and enslave our populace.

So, legally this might be the same war, but in truth it is far from so.

As for the capsuleers being the man inside the machine, only in physical terms, and I wasn't speaking in those. It was a metaphor: we capsuleers have our implants under our human command, you Nation slaves have the human under the implant's command once those are active. Better?

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#72 - 2013-02-12 17:43:42 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
How many years of peace have been since YC 37 until the Sansha invaded our lands? I served in the Imperial Navy for years, and our problems were Omir Sirakusa, The Defiants, and then the Minmatarr Republic. Sansha Kuvakei wasn't on the list. There may have been no formal peace agreement, but an informal peace has lasted for many years now, and it's the Nation the one to blame for breaking it. They could have lived as peacefully and utopially as they'd like on the other side of their wormholes, but instead they chose to attack the empires, and enslave our populace.

So, legally this might be the same war, but in truth it is far from so.

As for the capsuleers being the man inside the machine, only in physical terms, and I wasn't speaking in those. It was a metaphor: we capsuleers have our implants under our human command, you Nation slaves have the human under the implant's command once those are active. Better?


It took us that long to regrow from the beating we took. That doesn't constitute a peace. That constitutes surviving a near genocide. It is legally and in truth the exact same war your people started. We have just learned our lessons from the last outbreak of hostilities and now know that we cannot, ever, afford to let CONCORD and its lapdogs get the upper hand.

You do not have your implants under your command, Captain. Unless you feel it is particularly human to start considering death on the megadeath scale to be something enjoyable. If that is humanity, I gleefully discard it.
Natalcya Katla
Astropolitan Front
#73 - 2013-02-12 18:30:01 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
So, legally this might be the same war, but in truth it is far from so.

This is an utterly nonsensical statement. The only sane way to affix any kind of objective (or at least shared subjective) truth to questions of political and social reality is through formal and binding law. If you discard legality and law as "untrue", all you are left with are your own personal whims and fancies. You'll understand then, I hope, that I decide to look to the law instead of to your opinion when I say that yes, this is in truth the same war.

In that same vein, an "informal peace" is not peace. It falls in the same bin as many other oxymoronic, irrelevant and/or nonsensical concepts like "unwritten law", "spirit of the law", "unspoken agreement" and "justice".

There was no "informal peace". You just forgot you were at war. Whose fault is that but your own?
Takrow Matoris
Republic Military School
Minmatar Republic
#74 - 2013-02-12 18:44:34 UTC
Tiberious Thessalonia wrote:
Halete wrote:
Takrow Matoris wrote:
When your mind is not your own, how can you really say your free?


When can we ever truly claim that our mind is our own?


This is exactly what I was going to ask.

You speak of "impulses" being things that arise from the self, but they do not. Impulses are the results of chemical reactions and raw animal instinct. The human being also has another option, called "reason", but reason follows rules and modes of behavior, and so is similarly not something that arises from the self.

What you call free will is nothing more than an illusion. We understand this, and in discarding our reliance on it, we become part of the True Power.



Reason? Reason is another form of impulses, that we humans seek out. We use reason as a way to define what we do. Our true self is at the center of our impulses. Weather or not you wish to see it or not, with out our impulses, with out our instinct we lose everything.

I do not expect you to understand this, nor why I follow such a line of thinking. But what I do know is my mind, my impulses have always been of my own. This is how I define myself and how I live my life. And I assume that many others follow this in their own way, moving forward with their own minds, not giving up on what defines them. Even if it leads us down a path of pain and sorrow, we would never throw it all away just to get a glimpse of somebody else Utopia.

Those that freely give it up, are the ones who let others decide things for them. They probably never even thought about their own impulses, let alone what they truly wanted in life. That's the truth to many who have joined the Nation, as far as I'm concerned.
Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#75 - 2013-02-12 19:04:42 UTC
Takrow Matoris wrote:

Reason? Reason is another form of impulses, that we humans seek out. We use reason as a way to define what we do. Our true self is at the center of our impulses. Weather or not you wish to see it or not, with out our impulses, with out our instinct we lose everything.

I do not expect you to understand this, nor why I follow such a line of thinking. But what I do know is my mind, my impulses have always been of my own. This is how I define myself and how I live my life. And I assume that many others follow this in their own way, moving forward with their own minds, not giving up on what defines them. Even if it leads us down a path of pain and sorrow, we would never throw it all away just to get a glimpse of somebody else Utopia.

Those that freely give it up, are the ones who let others decide things for them. They probably never even thought about their own impulses, let alone what they truly wanted in life. That's the truth to many who have joined the Nation, as far as I'm concerned.


This is that illusion I was talking about. Do you know what happiness is? Endorphins and dopamine. These get released when you do something enjoyable, and that encourages you to do more of the same. You have no more control over the release of these chemicals than you do any other autonomic function, and hence your pursuit of these things is not really something you choose to do.

Examine your own motivations deep enough, the things you consider to be the center of your self, and you begin to see that these biological processes lie at the center of everything you do. Everything you are, in fact.

It is quite disturbing at first, and when confronted with this for the first time (in the real sense of being confronted with it, not simply being told academically) people have one of two reactions. Either they say "Nothing matters", and become nihilists, or they understand that the biological processes that run the machines that is the human body are just tools to be used, and that humanities true greatness comes not in division, or individuality, but in unity of purpose and shared work towards a cause.

The illusion of free will is the greatest threat that humanity has ever known and we are lucky to have survived it so far. Now we are turning believers in free will into living weapons, and putting no effort into controlling their actions. I fear that humanity doesn't have much time left if it doesn't start getting a handle on things.

And since you lot seem singularly unwilling to submit yourselves to controls, I see no reason to give you the choice in the matter.

Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#76 - 2013-02-12 19:24:09 UTC
Tiberius Thessalonia wrote:
It took us that long to regrow from the beating we took. That doesn't constitute a peace. That constitutes surviving a near genocide. It is legally and in truth the exact same war your people started. We have just learned our lessons from the last outbreak of hostilities and now know that we cannot, ever, afford to let CONCORD and its lapdogs get the upper hand.


Very well, thus you come back to punish, enslave and kill people who weren't even born by the time of your offense, such as myself. You probably weren't born back then either. Thus you avenge on something that wasn't done to you, and avenge on people that didn't do it. Even the empires have changed their leaders in this time: we've seen the ascense of Tibus Heth in the State, the alleged return of the Elders in the Republic (though I agree this is mostly fiction it does show a change in the way the Republic matters are handled), the changes in the internal working of the Federation, and the change from one Emperor to the next until Empress Jamyl I took her rightful place in the throne.

So, you're not fighting the people that invaded you, you are not fighting the powers that invaded you, nor actually were you personally present during the invasion most probably (and certainly not most of the true slaves). Thus, when we've changed all the players and the rules of the game (thus wormholes), are we still playing the same game? The answer is not. The Amarr Empire has launched 24 Imperial Crusades up to now, most in the name of Reclaiming, are they all the same war of Reclaiming? No. And neither is this war with the Sansha Nation.

Quote:
You do not have your implants under your command, Captain. Unless you feel it is particularly human to start considering death on the megadeath scale to be something enjoyable. If that is humanity, I gleefully discard it.


I don't enjoy death on the megadeath scale at all, and frown upon it whenever it happens. I already called both Tibus Heth and the leaders of the Minmatarr Republic to be held accountable for all the deaths caused by their violation of the Yulai Accords and starting the current wars. I kill, I won't deny that, but I do it for duty and not out of enjoyment. Thus, following your reasoning, I do keep my implants under my command and remain quite human. As do many pilots I know.

Natalcya Katla wrote:
This is an utterly nonsensical statement. The only sane way to affix any kind of objective (or at least shared subjective) truth to questions of political and social reality is through formal and binding law. If you discard legality and law as "untrue", all you are left with are your own personal whims and fancies. You'll understand then, I hope, that I decide to look to the law instead of to your opinion when I say that yes, this is in truth the same war.

In that same vein, an "informal peace" is not peace. It falls in the same bin as many other oxymoronic, irrelevant and/or nonsensical concepts like "unwritten law", "spirit of the law", "unspoken agreement" and "justice".

There was no "informal peace". You just forgot you were at war. Whose fault is that but your own?


Then, which law is the one that is objective? Amarrian law? CONCORD law? Caldari law? Or maybe the Republic's? Or is it the Federation's, the Kingdom's or the Mandate's? Or is it the law that reigns over any 0.0 space controlled by any corporation, be it pod-pilot based or those of the Angels, Blood Raiders or any other such particular faction? Or maybe the law that is the collective will of Sansha Kuvakei over all his denizens?

No, captain Katla, law is far from being objective. It's only a paper written by people, with all the subjective faults and perceptions those people put into it. Some more flawed than others, but humanely limited none the less.

So, as far as forgetting a war... I never knew it, I can't forget what is never known to me, only an entry in the books of history. The previous war is a matter of history, the current one is a new one.

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Sepherim
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#77 - 2013-02-12 19:27:52 UTC
Tiberius Thessalonia wrote:
This is that illusion I was talking about. Do you know what happiness is? Endorphins and dopamine. These get released when you do something enjoyable, and that encourages you to do more of the same. You have no more control over the release of these chemicals than you do any other autonomic function, and hence your pursuit of these things is not really something you choose to do.


You make a classical theologian division that doesn't apply. We are humans, and humans are both body and mind, and soul for those who such believe. If your body loves, your mind loves, you love. End of it. But even if your body loves, your mind can decide to accept it, or react against it, or move in an unexpected direction. The mind is not tied to the body, it interacts with it, and on the whole of those interactions arise will, and the self.

Quote:
The illusion of free will is the greatest threat that humanity has ever known and we are lucky to have survived it so far. Now we are turning believers in free will into living weapons, and putting no effort into controlling their actions. I fear that humanity doesn't have much time left if it doesn't start getting a handle on things.

And since you lot seem singularly unwilling to submit yourselves to controls, I see no reason to give you the choice in the matter.


About time a sincere affirmation on the ideals of the Nation. But a contradictory one at that, if we are "unwilling to submit to controls", that's because there is a will there. And where there is will there is choice. And where there is choice there is humanity, and the specific degree of liberty we all have (which isn't absolute, unless you believe in the anarchist's theories). Thus, by accepting this, you are also accepting the existance of a certain free will, which forcefully is not an illusion thus.

Sepherim Catillah Praetoria Imperialis Excubitoris Liuteneant Ex-Imperial Navy Imperator Commander

Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#78 - 2013-02-12 19:38:18 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
Tiberius Thessalonia wrote:
This is that illusion I was talking about. Do you know what happiness is? Endorphins and dopamine. These get released when you do something enjoyable, and that encourages you to do more of the same. You have no more control over the release of these chemicals than you do any other autonomic function, and hence your pursuit of these things is not really something you choose to do.


You make a classical theologian division that doesn't apply. We are humans, and humans are both body and mind, and soul for those who such believe. If your body loves, your mind loves, you love. End of it. But even if your body loves, your mind can decide to accept it, or react against it, or move in an unexpected direction. The mind is not tied to the body, it interacts with it, and on the whole of those interactions arise will, and the self.

Quote:
The illusion of free will is the greatest threat that humanity has ever known and we are lucky to have survived it so far. Now we are turning believers in free will into living weapons, and putting no effort into controlling their actions. I fear that humanity doesn't have much time left if it doesn't start getting a handle on things.

And since you lot seem singularly unwilling to submit yourselves to controls, I see no reason to give you the choice in the matter.


About time a sincere affirmation on the ideals of the Nation. But a contradictory one at that, if we are "unwilling to submit to controls", that's because there is a will there. And where there is will there is choice. And where there is choice there is humanity, and the specific degree of liberty we all have (which isn't absolute, unless you believe in the anarchist's theories). Thus, by accepting this, you are also accepting the existance of a certain free will, which forcefully is not an illusion thus.


If there is such a division, Captain, why is the mind so easily overwritten by simply changing around a few neuropeptides? The mind is just another part of your body. There is nothing unique or special about it. The reason you consider us so alien to you is because we have accepted this, and you have not.

Your chain of thinking at the bottom of your post is incorrect. You rebel against controls because you are a biological being that has evolved in a certain way, and natural evolution is a surprisingly conservative method of change. It's only natural that the animal part of you wants to maintain divisions and its illusion of free will, but this does not make it something that actually exists. There is no free will to start the chain, no choice, and choice is not an essential element of humanity.
Scherezad
Revenent Defence Corperation
Ishuk-Raata Enforcement Directive
#79 - 2013-02-12 19:44:16 UTC
Natalcya Katla wrote:
The only sane way to affix any kind of objective (or at least shared subjective) truth to questions of political and social reality is through formal and binding law.


Today I enact a decree to all employees beneath my auspices. The sun has passed behind Kakakela VI, and we shall never see it again.

I anticipate a lovely star-rise tomorrow.
Tiberious Thessalonia
True Slave Foundations
#80 - 2013-02-12 19:46:38 UTC
Sepherim wrote:
The previous quote which I missed the first time.


I am going to be brief and succinct here. This is not a war about vengeance. Revenge is a very small emotional taint floating around in some of the network.

This war is about the continued safety of our Nation, which we now know we will never have as long as the CONCORD signatories are on an equal footing with us in terms of power. Would that war not be necessary, but your side of this war has already proven to us that winning this war is the only method we will have to continue our way of life against unbridled aggression.

Want proof? Look at some of the responses to Evi in this thread.