These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE Information Portal

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Dev blog: The great ship skill change of summer 2013

First post First post
Author
ITTigerClawIK
Galactic Rangers
#101 - 2013-02-07 15:27:32 UTC
i am curius as to why the decision to have all all the warfare skills as lvl 5 before getting into a command ship even if the command ship is speced for armor rather than shield, this seems like an odd choice, and for a sec there i also though you guys were gunna give me all the warfare skills to V as well :-P
Weaselior
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#102 - 2013-02-07 15:28:20 UTC
CCP Ytterbium wrote:
FinalFlash84 wrote:
According to your explanation, shouldn't the DD prereqs (like Science V, EPW V and AWU V) also be added to the titan?

edit:
Also Fighter V and EW V for supercarriers


Ideally, yes, but we wanted to keep close hard training times, so we had to take a pick between the Doomsday and the Jump Portal.

given current titan usage you picked wrong: the dd is required, the jpg is optional

Head of the Goonswarm Economic Warfare Cabal Pubbie Management and Exploitation Division.

Iosue
League of Gentlemen
The Initiative.
#103 - 2013-02-07 15:30:45 UTC
Irregessa wrote:
So, someone I know is saying that when they had Large Railgun Spec 2 trained and happened to lose Large Hybrid Turret 5 due to dying in an insufficient clone, he could not continue to train Large Railgun Spec until he got Large Hybrid Turret back up to 5 again.

If that is how it works, if I have a character who presently knows Command Ships 3 but doesn't have the leadership skills to 5, he won't be able to train Command Ships 4 until he does?

edit: I now have had multiple people tell me they have had the above situation happen to them.


that's not how it works. if you have the skill injected, you can train it. i've tested this several times, mostly on cyno alts that loose electronics V due to no clones.
Gizznitt Malikite
Agony Unleashed
Agony Empire
#104 - 2013-02-07 15:32:05 UTC  |  Edited by: Gizznitt Malikite
tgl3 wrote:
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:



Many people in situations similar to mine can currently fly the Archon with these skills:
BS at V, JDO at 1, and Amarr Carrier at I.....

After this change, I will not be able to fly the Archon, as I wont have JDO V, let alone JFC or JDC

CCP CLEARLY state "if we can fly it today, we can fly it tomorrow.... "

Are you planning to address this?

You will still have the Carrier skill trained, so you can fly the ship.
What you may NOT be able to do, is train the Carrier skill further.


But I do have the carrier skill... and can easily fly EVERY CARRIER In the game simply by training it now.....

To put it blatantly....

Today, I CAN FLY any regular carrier in this game.... (although I've only skill trained on the archon).

I do NOT have JDO V, let alone JFC or JDC....

With the changes, I could NOT FLY a regular carrier when the skiil changes happen....

This is a direct contradiction to the quote: If you can fly it today, you can fly it tomorrow....

How does CCP plan to address this?

*Edit* I misread the post above me.... so I could continue to fly the archon.... I just wouldn't be able to further train it until the new prereqs gett trained?
Iosue
League of Gentlemen
The Initiative.
#105 - 2013-02-07 15:32:45 UTC
ITTigerClawIK wrote:
i am curius as to why the decision to have all all the warfare skills as lvl 5 before getting into a command ship even if the command ship is speced for armor rather than shield, this seems like an odd choice, and for a sec there i also though you guys were gunna give me all the warfare skills to V as well :-P


except that command ships isn't a racial skill, so no telling if the pilot will be armor/shield.
Artemis Picoazaksat
State War Academy
Caldari State
#106 - 2013-02-07 15:35:24 UTC
So let me get this Straight:

I have BC5 and Destroyer 5 so I am fine on the T1 BC and Destroyers

If I want to continue to just use my carrier as a Ship Hauler. I will have to get Capital Ships 4 as it is currently only at 3?

If I want to use all the Command Ship that I can Currently I will have to get ALL the leadership skills to 5!? If that is the case then it is ridiculous and adds 51 Days of training for link I don't use.

For my Freighter ALT to continue to use it Charon I am going to have to train Advanced Spaceship Command 5 which is currently at Advanced Spaceship Command 4 adding 23 Days so if I don't have it by the time the Patch Hits, what? I cannot use it anymore? IF so that is complete BS!

And on all three of my Mining ALT's I am going to have to training Mining Frigate 3.

This would all be achievable if all these Characters where on separate accounts but I am going to get completely screwed on some of them.. so thanks for that......................................................................................
James Amril-Kesh
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#107 - 2013-02-07 15:37:16 UTC
Chi'Nane T'Kal wrote:
Awesome change all in all, even though the imbusement has a big chance to completely mess with my skill plans. :)

Missing one single piece of information.

The EXACT datetime. You wrote to tell us "exactly [...] when this is happening".
The only thing that can be interpreted as a date is 'within the Summer 2013 expansion". That is hardly exact.

How about something like, you know, a DATE?

They can't give you what they don't know.

Enjoying the rain today? ;)

tgl3
The Scope
Gallente Federation
#108 - 2013-02-07 15:37:55 UTC
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:
tgl3 wrote:
Gizznitt Malikite wrote:



Many people in situations similar to mine can currently fly the Archon with these skills:
BS at V, JDO at 1, and Amarr Carrier at I.....

After this change, I will not be able to fly the Archon, as I wont have JDO V, let alone JFC or JDC

CCP CLEARLY state "if we can fly it today, we can fly it tomorrow.... "

Are you planning to address this?

You will still have the Carrier skill trained, so you can fly the ship.
What you may NOT be able to do, is train the Carrier skill further.


But I do have the carrier skill... and can easily fly EVERY CARRIER In the game simply by training it now.....

To put it blatantly....

Today, I CAN FLY any regular carrier in this game.... (although I've only skill trained on the archon).

I do NOT have JDO V, let alone JFC or JDC....

With the changes, I could NOT FLY a regular carrier when the skiil changes happen....

This is a direct contradiction to the quote: If you can fly it today, you can fly it tomorrow....

How does CCP plan to address this?

If you do not have the other carrier skills trained, then you cannot fly them and therefore would not be able to after the change regardless.

Quote:
*Edit* I misread the post above me.... so I could continue to fly the archon.... I just wouldn't be able to further train it until the

Correct
Madlof Chev
GoonWaffe
Goonswarm Federation
#109 - 2013-02-07 15:38:06 UTC
calm yourselves, the world isn't ending


Now, I've seen quite a few "OH GOD THE REQUIREMENTS FOR MY FAVORITE SHIP ARE CHANGING UNDER ME MY LIFE NO LONGER MAKES SENSE" posts, so let's clear this up:

The most important thing to know about this is the way that the nested skill system in EVE works.

As long as you have the top level prerequisites for a ship, regardless of what their pre-requisites are, you will still be able to use that ship. Here's an example (we'll use the Revelation).

The main additions here are requiring Capital Ships III and Tactical Weapon Reconfiguration I (thereby requiring Advanced Weapon Upgrades V).

Now, you ask, what if I all ready have a Revelation that I'm able to fly now? Am I no longer able to fly it? Do I get Siege and Capital Ships III for free?

The answer to both of those questions is no. Due to you already having JDO I, Capital Ships I, and Amarr Dreadnought I, the prerequisites system no longer cares about everything nested underneath it.

This works the same with T2 guns - if you have specialization skills but lose Turret V, you keep your ability to use those T2 guns. You can no longer train the skills any further if you don't have the prerequisites for the skill, but you keep the skills as they are.

Thankfully, CCP's prerequisites for a lot of things are pretty sane and things that you want anyway to fly that class of ship (apart from Energy Grid Upgrades V for HACs what the christ), so you will probably end up training those prereqs anyway if you don't have them.

To sum up:

Yes, you can still fly your ships.
No, you won't get any free SP.
Yes, you should probably train those prerequisites anyway.
Irregessa
Obfuscation and Reflections
#110 - 2013-02-07 15:38:14 UTC
Artemis Picoazaksat wrote:
So let me get this Straight:

I have BC5 and Destroyer 5 so I am fine on the T1 BC and Destroyers

If I want to continue to just use my carrier as a Ship Hauler. I will have to get Capital Ships 4 as it is currently only at 3?

If I want to use all the Command Ship that I can Currently I will have to get ALL the leadership skills to 5!? If that is the case then it is ridiculous and adds 51 Days of training for link I don't use.

For my Freighter ALT to continue to use it Charon I am going to have to train Advanced Spaceship Command 5 which is currently at Advanced Spaceship Command 4 adding 23 Days so if I don't have it by the time the Patch Hits, what? I cannot use it anymore? IF so that is complete BS!

And on all three of my Mining ALT's I am going to have to training Mining Frigate 3.

This would all be achievable if all these Characters where on separate accounts but I am going to get completely screwed on some of them.. so thanks for that......................................................................................


None of that is true. There has just been a failure to communicate.
Aineko Macx
#111 - 2013-02-07 15:38:25 UTC
Artemis Picoazaksat wrote:
So let me get this Straight:

You misunderstood.
If you can fly it now, you'll get all skills to fly them later for free.
Chi'Nane T'Kal
Interminatus
#112 - 2013-02-07 15:39:29 UTC
Artemis Picoazaksat wrote:
So let me get this Straight:

I have BC5 and Destroyer 5 so I am fine on the T1 BC and Destroyers

If I want to continue to just use my carrier as a Ship Hauler. I will have to get Capital Ships 4 as it is currently only at 3?

If I want to use all the Command Ship that I can Currently I will have to get ALL the leadership skills to 5!? If that is the case then it is ridiculous and adds 51 Days of training for link I don't use.

For my Freighter ALT to continue to use it Charon I am going to have to train Advanced Spaceship Command 5 which is currently at Advanced Spaceship Command 4 adding 23 Days so if I don't have it by the time the Patch Hits, what? I cannot use it anymore? IF so that is complete BS!

And on all three of my Mining ALT's I am going to have to training Mining Frigate 3.

This would all be achievable if all these Characters where on separate accounts but I am going to get completely screwed on some of them.. so thanks for that......................................................................................


Please reread some of the comments that were already answered, specifically those making a distinction between ship and skill requirements.
James Amril-Kesh
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#113 - 2013-02-07 15:42:41 UTC
Aineko Macx wrote:
Artemis Picoazaksat wrote:
So let me get this Straight:

You misunderstood.
If you can fly it now, you'll get all skills to fly them later for free.

No, that's not true at all.
If you can fly it now, you already have all the skills to fly it even after the change.


For example, I have Heavy Assault Ships trained to 4, but I do not have Energy Grid Upgrades 5.
When the skill requirements are changed, the HAS (will become HAC) skill will have a prerequisite of EGU 5.
Since I already have HAS injected I don't need EGU 5 in order to train it, nor will I need it to fly my Zealot.
Essentially I'll be grandfathered in. However CCP will not give me EGU 5.

Enjoying the rain today? ;)

Dato Koppla
Balls Deep Inc.
Minmatar Fleet Alliance
#114 - 2013-02-07 15:45:00 UTC
Wow thank god I got my HAC skill already, Energy Grid Upgrades V is a horrible skill to have to train, would be nice to include a reasoning why. If it was to keep a similar training time thats kinda lame.

So does this also mean I can't train my HAC skill from IV to V without training EGU V first after patch hits?
James Amril-Kesh
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#115 - 2013-02-07 15:46:46 UTC  |  Edited by: James Amril-Kesh
Dato Koppla wrote:
Wow thank god I got my HAC skill already, Energy Grid Upgrades V is a horrible skill to have to train, would be nice to include a reasoning why. If it was to keep a similar training time thats kinda lame.

So does this also mean I can't train my HAC skill from IV to V without training EGU V first after patch hits?

See above. Several people in this thread have stated that they have been able to train skills even after losing a prerequisite for that skill (for example, a cyno alt loses electronics 5, but is still able to train cyno field generation). Prerequisites are required to inject the skill, beyond that they do not affect your ability to train it or use any items or ships that are unlocked by that skill.

Enjoying the rain today? ;)

Juwi Kotch
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#116 - 2013-02-07 15:47:07 UTC  |  Edited by: Juwi Kotch
Generally, I like the changes. I can then train the Carrier, Dread, and Freighter skills instantly, without having to train the racial Battleship and Industrial skills to lvl5 first, since I have all non-Gallente already to lvl3. Since I have all the other prereq skills for my Gallente specialization already (with the exception of Capital Ships, which I have only at lvl3 atm, but which is not very problematic to train to lvl4), I'm fine. For me, this change reduces training time for non-Gallente cap ships by months. And just in time, as this was on my plan for the second half of this year.

"Our lives are not our own. We are bound to others, past and present. And by each crime, and every kindness, we birth our future." Sonmi-451

Irregessa
Obfuscation and Reflections
#117 - 2013-02-07 15:50:18 UTC
James Amril-Kesh wrote:
Dato Koppla wrote:
Wow thank god I got my HAC skill already, Energy Grid Upgrades V is a horrible skill to have to train, would be nice to include a reasoning why. If it was to keep a similar training time thats kinda lame.

So does this also mean I can't train my HAC skill from IV to V without training EGU V first after patch hits?

See above. Several people in this thread have stated that they have been able to train skills even after losing a prerequisite for that skill (for example, a cyno alt loses electronics 5, but is still able to train cyno field generation). Prerequisites are required to inject the skill, beyond that they do not affect your ability to train it or use any items or ships that are unlocked by that skill.


Except several people have said the reverse, and a dev has essentially confirmed it (though not unambiguously, IMO).
Ingen Kerr
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#118 - 2013-02-07 15:51:02 UTC
Aineko Macx wrote:
Dedicated supercap chars should get their skillpoints for racial BS 4 and 5 reimbursed.


How about all these drones I can't use anymore?
Unforgiven Storm
Eternity INC.
Goonswarm Federation
#119 - 2013-02-07 15:51:49 UTC
CCP Ytterbium wrote:
FinalFlash84 wrote:
According to your explanation, shouldn't the DD prereqs (like Science V, EPW V and AWU V) also be added to the titan?

edit:
Also Fighter V and EW V for supercarriers


Ideally, yes, but we wanted to keep close hard training times, so we had to take a pick between the Doomsday and the Jump Portal.


Do it right!

it is not suppose to be easy to get into a titan or a supercarrier, add them both to the requisites list: Doomsday + Jump Portal

In the case of a super carrier add Fighter Bombers to the requirements and done it right, nobody is supose to fly one without them anyway...

Unforgiven Storm for CSM 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13. (If I don't get in in the next 5 years I will quit trying) :-)

Bariolage
Control F9
#120 - 2013-02-07 15:52:51 UTC
Most thorough blog post ever. 6 pages of questions in 3 hours.