These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Missions & Complexes

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

Ded 5 Complexes in Hi-sec

Author
Zhilia Mann
Tide Way Out Productions
#21 - 2013-02-05 01:54:56 UTC
Faulx wrote:
Zhilia Mann wrote:
Why are you quoting me here?

dex quoted you without citation after linking the other thread What? He's trying to argue that scanable 5/10s don't spawn in high sec because no one's reported seeing them.


Fair. I hadn't followed that link. And yeah, it's something I've said before.

Faulx wrote:
My argument is that it's certainly a possibility, but, before there is demonstrable proof or citation of such, it's premature to deny the possibility that the sites are simply rare and that the few who do find one might simply not be bothering to report it.

It's really nothing to worry about: your information merely demonstrated a little over generalization, suggesting that its probably as much a conglomeration of data as anything currently on the wiki. What you linked, what exists now... it's all built on player reports. Thus my argument not to discard reports without good cause.


Again, fair. I have a different bias: that unsubstantiated reports from people who don't seem to repeat the story anywhere I can document are likely wrong given the very small number of them. But you're certainly right that there's no deductive proof to deny 5/10s in high sec.

I think we'd both agree, however, that if someone is looking for 5/10s, they should definitely go to low as their odds of finding one in high are either zero or so very near zero as to be of little practical consequence.
Faulx
Brother Fox Corp
#22 - 2013-02-05 02:04:13 UTC
Hah, if they're looking to run one, yes. It'd probably be a good idea to have additional columns on the list for site frequency... but that would also need some hard data (and more screen real-estate).
Wudin
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#23 - 2013-02-05 03:49:50 UTC
Largely speculation, but I have a theory as to why 5/10s may have appeared in highsec, but don't naturally spawn in highsec (sounds ********, I know, just read until the end).

First off, a sidestory--a couple years ago, when I was (more) noobish, I liked nothing more than zooming around highsec in a BC and doing anomalies for a chance at faction spawns/escalations. I don't quite remember WHY, but I did.

Regardless, occasionally I DID get DED escalations; one time in particular I got a 4/10 escalation that happened to go into lowsec. While I am not a regular lowsec guy, checking up on the system showed low traffic and no recent kills, so I threw on a cloak/mwd and went to it.

As I was doing the complex, a couple -10s popped into local, so I immediately warped out and activated the cloak once I landed. I waited until they left (which wasn't for about 30 minutes), and then warped back to the complex.

What did I find once I took the acceleration gate? two rooms full of yellow wrecks. The bastards had cleared my plex! (No, they didn't scan me down and then warp in, I was pre-aligned and warped out within 10 sec of them entering local.)

The significance of this is this: it seems like escalated DED plexes from anoms may actually become scannable sites once started.

Now, the reason I spent the last five paragraphs relating goes back to my speculation as well as something people seem to agree on in this thread--certain highsec anoms have a small, small chance of causing a 5/10 escalation in highsec. If this happens and, say, the person who GOT the escalation is a noob (not a stretch, they were probably spamming highsec anoms), they very well might not have been equipped to deal with a 5/10 and warped out and left it behind once that became clear.

If that happened, some explorer coming across the abandoned plex would think they had found a naturally spawning 5/10. It would also explain how rare they are: they wouldn't spawn based off normal mechanics, but only when someone got an (already extremely rare) 5/10 escalation and then abandoned it. In that case, a search on the test server would be the WORST way to find one, as I am fairly sure people aren't running many highsec plexes on there.

TLDR: I used proper paragraphs and grammer, no excuses, don't be so lazy.
Faulx
Brother Fox Corp
#24 - 2013-02-05 03:56:10 UTC
It's a good theory; it could probably be tested fairly easily: assuming one of us gets up the gumption to spam anoms till they escalate.
Zhilia Mann
Tide Way Out Productions
#25 - 2013-02-05 04:05:16 UTC
Wudin wrote:
Largely speculation, but I have a theory as to why 5/10s may have appeared in highsec, but don't naturally spawn in highsec (sounds ********, I know, just read until the end).

First off, a sidestory--a couple years ago, when I was (more) noobish, I liked nothing more than zooming around highsec in a BC and doing anomalies for a chance at faction spawns/escalations. I don't quite remember WHY, but I did.

Regardless, occasionally I DID get DED escalations; one time in particular I got a 4/10 escalation that happened to go into lowsec. While I am not a regular lowsec guy, checking up on the system showed low traffic and no recent kills, so I threw on a cloak/mwd and went to it.

As I was doing the complex, a couple -10s popped into local, so I immediately warped out and activated the cloak once I landed. I waited until they left (which wasn't for about 30 minutes), and then warped back to the complex.

What did I find once I took the acceleration gate? two rooms full of yellow wrecks. The bastards had cleared my plex! (No, they didn't scan me down and then warp in, I was pre-aligned and warped out within 10 sec of them entering local.)

The significance of this is this: it seems like escalated DED plexes from anoms may actually become scannable sites once started.

Now, the reason I spent the last five paragraphs relating goes back to my speculation as well as something people seem to agree on in this thread--certain highsec anoms have a small, small chance of causing a 5/10 escalation in highsec. If this happens and, say, the person who GOT the escalation is a noob (not a stretch, they were probably spamming highsec anoms), they very well might not have been equipped to deal with a 5/10 and warped out and left it behind once that became clear.

If that happened, some explorer coming across the abandoned plex would think they had found a naturally spawning 5/10. It would also explain how rare they are: they wouldn't spawn based off normal mechanics, but only when someone got an (already extremely rare) 5/10 escalation and then abandoned it. In that case, a search on the test server would be the WORST way to find one, as I am fairly sure people aren't running many highsec plexes on there.

TLDR: I used proper paragraphs and grammer, no excuses, don't be so lazy.


That's an odd story; I'll give you that. The only problem? You actually can't scan down escalation sites. Trust me; I've been on both ends of this one. The damn things don't show up. Sometimes I'm glad they don't, sometimes I'm frustrated that I can't get in to a site someone has partially cleared. But either way, core probes won't do the trick.
Wudin
University of Caille
Gallente Federation
#26 - 2013-02-05 04:18:26 UTC  |  Edited by: Wudin
Zhilia Mann wrote:
Wudin wrote:
Largely speculation, but I have a theory as to why 5/10s may have appeared in highsec, but don't naturally spawn in highsec (sounds ********, I know, just read until the end).

First off, a sidestory--a couple years ago, when I was (more) noobish, I liked nothing more than zooming around highsec in a BC and doing anomalies for a chance at faction spawns/escalations. I don't quite remember WHY, but I did.

Regardless, occasionally I DID get DED escalations; one time in particular I got a 4/10 escalation that happened to go into lowsec. While I am not a regular lowsec guy, checking up on the system showed low traffic and no recent kills, so I threw on a cloak/mwd and went to it.

As I was doing the complex, a couple -10s popped into local, so I immediately warped out and activated the cloak once I landed. I waited until they left (which wasn't for about 30 minutes), and then warped back to the complex.

What did I find once I took the acceleration gate? two rooms full of yellow wrecks. The bastards had cleared my plex! (No, they didn't scan me down and then warp in, I was pre-aligned and warped out within 10 sec of them entering local.)

The significance of this is this: it seems like escalated DED plexes from anoms may actually become scannable sites once started.

Now, the reason I spent the last five paragraphs relating goes back to my speculation as well as something people seem to agree on in this thread--certain highsec anoms have a small, small chance of causing a 5/10 escalation in highsec. If this happens and, say, the person who GOT the escalation is a noob (not a stretch, they were probably spamming highsec anoms), they very well might not have been equipped to deal with a 5/10 and warped out and left it behind once that became clear.

If that happened, some explorer coming across the abandoned plex would think they had found a naturally spawning 5/10. It would also explain how rare they are: they wouldn't spawn based off normal mechanics, but only when someone got an (already extremely rare) 5/10 escalation and then abandoned it. In that case, a search on the test server would be the WORST way to find one, as I am fairly sure people aren't running many highsec plexes on there.

TLDR: I used proper paragraphs and grammer, no excuses, don't be so lazy.


That's an odd story; I'll give you that. The only problem? You actually can't scan down escalation sites. Trust me; I've been on both ends of this one. The damn things don't show up. Sometimes I'm glad they don't, sometimes I'm frustrated that I can't get in to a site someone has partially cleared. But either way, core probes won't do the trick.


I am well aware that NORMAL escalations are unscannable (aside from using combat probes to scan down someone in them). That was the whole reason I went on that sidestory--it seems as though "escalations" from anomalies may just be treated as normal DED plexes once the person warps in to it the first time. That part would certainly be easy enough to test though; you could simply get ANY anom escalation, warp to it, then have a friend/alt try to scan it with core probes.
Mnemosyne Gloob
#27 - 2013-02-05 04:52:20 UTC  |  Edited by: Mnemosyne Gloob
Theres plenty of them in highsec, you just go scan them down. They are in the k162 band btw. honest.

That aside as someone has pointed out here: 'user supplied information might be incorrect/misleading'

I am certain there are no scannable DED5 sites in highec. Expeditions from anomalies however might be a different story. Very rarely i get an Annex/Minor Annex/Outpost end up in lowsec - which is not where they are supposed to end. Something to do with the pathfinding for expeditions. I assume the same thing could happen if someone gets an escalation to a DED 5 in highsec and it sends him to highec instead of lowsec. [And then of course he has 'found' a DED 5 in highsec and happily contributes this find to the wiki - without saying how it happened]

Oh and DEDs as an expedition certainly are not scannable by core probes.

[edit] i assume the person talking about gistum stuff was referring to the a-types when they dropped form angel 4/10[/edit]
Mnemosyne Gloob
#28 - 2013-02-05 05:38:17 UTC  |  Edited by: Mnemosyne Gloob
blablubb
Tauranon
Weeesearch
CAStabouts
#29 - 2013-02-05 06:21:16 UTC  |  Edited by: Tauranon
Wudin wrote:


I am well aware that NORMAL escalations are unscannable (aside from using combat probes to scan down someone in them). That was the whole reason I went on that sidestory--it seems as though "escalations" from anomalies may just be treated as normal DED plexes once the person warps in to it the first time. That part would certainly be easy enough to test though; you could simply get ANY anom escalation, warp to it, then have a friend/alt try to scan it with core probes.


Once you leave a wreck on scan, then someone else can work to the grid with d-scan and bookmarks, so long as your grid is within the outer bounds defined by all the anoms, celestials, and any deep safes that the d-scanner might possess. If your grid is outside those bounds, then it can be difficult to reach within the wrecks lifetime. (You have to log-walk to get a bookmark on the otherside of the wreck).

Takes about 15 minutes, and is not inconceivable that pirates know how to do that, as once apon a time it was the only practical way of hunting a safed afk.
dexington
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#30 - 2013-02-05 07:19:10 UTC  |  Edited by: dexington
Faulx wrote:
My argument is that it's certainly a possibility, but, before there is demonstrable proof or citation of such, it's premature to deny the possibility that the sites are simply rare and that the few who do find one might simply not be bothering to report it.


That's more then bending the truth just a little...

On the wiki page you claim they spawn in hi-sec, not that it's undocumented and very likely rumor based on 2010 information and people not understand that difference between anomalies, signatures and escalation sites.

When you decided that the wiki page should be changed to say that 5/10 spawn in hi-sec, what evidence did you have that they did spawn?

Faulx wrote:
Elisa's data did not include sources, that's why she's sited as the source. So if you want to know why its in there, take it up with her. I can say, that the vast majority of her data was correct.


I'm guessing that you didn't have any evidence... You probably read the old wiki page that said security: low/high, and read that as the site could spawn as a normal signature in high and low sec.

Do you have any evidence that Guristas Hallucinogen Supply Waypoint can spawn in hi-sec as a signature?

I'm a relatively respectable citizen. Multiple felon perhaps, but certainly not dangerous.

Zhilia Mann
Tide Way Out Productions
#31 - 2013-02-05 08:14:24 UTC
Wudin wrote:
I am well aware that NORMAL escalations are unscannable (aside from using combat probes to scan down someone in them). That was the whole reason I went on that sidestory--it seems as though "escalations" from anomalies may just be treated as normal DED plexes once the person warps in to it the first time. That part would certainly be easy enough to test though; you could simply get ANY anom escalation, warp to it, then have a friend/alt try to scan it with core probes.


Been there, done that, can't be done. I kept a 7/10 alive (in low sec!) for over a week in a system that got cleared of everything else twice daily. It didn't show on my scans and the fact that no one else cleared it is evidence enough for me that no one else could find it either.
dexington
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#32 - 2013-02-05 08:20:54 UTC
Zhilia Mann wrote:
Wudin wrote:
I am well aware that NORMAL escalations are unscannable (aside from using combat probes to scan down someone in them). That was the whole reason I went on that sidestory--it seems as though "escalations" from anomalies may just be treated as normal DED plexes once the person warps in to it the first time. That part would certainly be easy enough to test though; you could simply get ANY anom escalation, warp to it, then have a friend/alt try to scan it with core probes.


Been there, done that, can't be done. I kept a 7/10 alive (in low sec!) for over a week in a system that got cleared of everything else twice daily. It didn't show on my scans and the fact that no one else cleared it is evidence enough for me that no one else could find it either.


I've done the same, reset the timer on escalation sites in low-sec and they never got cleared.

I'm a relatively respectable citizen. Multiple felon perhaps, but certainly not dangerous.

Faulx
Brother Fox Corp
#33 - 2013-02-05 08:42:43 UTC
dexington wrote:
I'm guessing that you didn't have any evidence... You probably read the old wiki page that said security: low/high, and read that as the site could spawn as a normal signature in high and low sec.

Do you have any evidence that Guristas Hallucinogen Supply Waypoint can spawn in hi-sec as a signature?


I have only Elisa's processed data, which appears as you see it in the first overhaul of the chart (before... after).

There's a few mistakes in there on my part, (later corrected, with citation), can you spot them?

You'll notice, the previous chart had no mention of high/low sec or signature strengths.
dexington
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#34 - 2013-02-05 08:58:09 UTC  |  Edited by: dexington
Faulx wrote:
dexington wrote:
I'm guessing that you didn't have any evidence... You probably read the old wiki page that said security: low/high, and read that as the site could spawn as a normal signature in high and low sec.

Do you have any evidence that Guristas Hallucinogen Supply Waypoint can spawn in hi-sec as a signature?


I have only Elisa's processed data, which appears as you see it in the first overhaul of the chart (before... after).

There's a few mistakes in there on my part, (later corrected, with citation), can you spot them?

You'll notice, the previous chart had no mention of high/low sec or signature strengths.


The angle 5/10 was said to spawn in hi-sec, before the sites was balanced, your chart show all 5/10 spawning in hi-sec.

Do you have any evidence that Guristas Hallucinogen Supply Waypoint can spawn in hi-sec as a signature?

I'm a relatively respectable citizen. Multiple felon perhaps, but certainly not dangerous.

seth Hendar
I love you miners
#35 - 2013-02-05 09:34:42 UTC  |  Edited by: seth Hendar
Wudin wrote:
Zhilia Mann wrote:
Wudin wrote:
Largely speculation, but I have a theory as to why 5/10s may have appeared in highsec, but don't naturally spawn in highsec (sounds ********, I know, just read until the end).

First off, a sidestory--a couple years ago, when I was (more) noobish, I liked nothing more than zooming around highsec in a BC and doing anomalies for a chance at faction spawns/escalations. I don't quite remember WHY, but I did.

Regardless, occasionally I DID get DED escalations; one time in particular I got a 4/10 escalation that happened to go into lowsec. While I am not a regular lowsec guy, checking up on the system showed low traffic and no recent kills, so I threw on a cloak/mwd and went to it.

As I was doing the complex, a couple -10s popped into local, so I immediately warped out and activated the cloak once I landed. I waited until they left (which wasn't for about 30 minutes), and then warped back to the complex.

What did I find once I took the acceleration gate? two rooms full of yellow wrecks. The bastards had cleared my plex! (No, they didn't scan me down and then warp in, I was pre-aligned and warped out within 10 sec of them entering local.)

The significance of this is this: it seems like escalated DED plexes from anoms may actually become scannable sites once started.

Now, the reason I spent the last five paragraphs relating goes back to my speculation as well as something people seem to agree on in this thread--certain highsec anoms have a small, small chance of causing a 5/10 escalation in highsec. If this happens and, say, the person who GOT the escalation is a noob (not a stretch, they were probably spamming highsec anoms), they very well might not have been equipped to deal with a 5/10 and warped out and left it behind once that became clear.

If that happened, some explorer coming across the abandoned plex would think they had found a naturally spawning 5/10. It would also explain how rare they are: they wouldn't spawn based off normal mechanics, but only when someone got an (already extremely rare) 5/10 escalation and then abandoned it. In that case, a search on the test server would be the WORST way to find one, as I am fairly sure people aren't running many highsec plexes on there.

TLDR: I used proper paragraphs and grammer, no excuses, don't be so lazy.


That's an odd story; I'll give you that. The only problem? You actually can't scan down escalation sites. Trust me; I've been on both ends of this one. The damn things don't show up. Sometimes I'm glad they don't, sometimes I'm frustrated that I can't get in to a site someone has partially cleared. But either way, core probes won't do the trick.


I am well aware that NORMAL escalations are unscannable (aside from using combat probes to scan down someone in them). That was the whole reason I went on that sidestory--it seems as though "escalations" from anomalies may just be treated as normal DED plexes once the person warps in to it the first time. That part would certainly be easy enough to test though; you could simply get ANY anom escalation, warp to it, then have a friend/alt try to scan it with core probes.

doesn't work, for training purpose we tried to scan down corpmates doing anoms (including escalations), one group runs the sig, the other one hunt them.

while we usually resume scanning the anom instead of the ship once we figured out the person on it warped out , to go wait them there (believe it or not, often ratters still come back 10 min later on the same anom even wit you in local).

each time the "target" is on an escalation, the only one thing you can probe is the ship, even if the ship warp out, the escalation remain impossible to probe down, regardless of how long the site remains "empty" from players
Tauranon
Weeesearch
CAStabouts
#36 - 2013-02-05 09:46:36 UTC
seth Hendar wrote:


each time the "target" is on an escalation, the only one thing you can probe is the ship, even if the ship warp out, the escalation remain impossible to probe down, regardless of how long the site remains "empty" from players


As I said before you can get onto the grid of a wreck with just d-scan and bookmarks.
Teri Cox
Doomheim
#37 - 2013-02-06 08:37:31 UTC
I farmed yesterday a Guristas Den in Uedama and got an escalation to a DED 5 Complex in Hysera.
Tauranon
Weeesearch
CAStabouts
#38 - 2013-02-06 08:57:06 UTC
Teri Cox wrote:
I farmed yesterday a Guristas Den in Uedama and got an escalation to a DED 5 Complex in Hysera.


a lowsec 4 jumps away, thats what I'd expect to see.
Previous page12