These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Gallente got their Medal.

First post
Author
X Gallentius
Black Eagle1
#121 - 2013-01-31 22:49:24 UTC
chatgris wrote:
At the very least, this medal represents a "we kicked your asses out of FW space, even your home systems could not hold" pvp achievement.

THIS. And we get a high five too! But whether or not Fozzie washes his hands before giving them out is still a question.
Garr Earthbender
Imperial Shipment
Amarr Empire
#122 - 2013-01-31 23:10:08 UTC
This thread is so full of win and fail it's amazing.

-Scissors is overpowered, rock is fine. -Paper

Dread Operative
Lowlife.
Snuffed Out
#123 - 2013-01-31 23:17:49 UTC  |  Edited by: Dread Operative
Caldari Medal - Awarded June 2009

June, 2009 4,016
May, 2009 4,165
April, 2009 4,009
March, 2009 3,432
= 15,622 kills

Gallente Medal - Awarded January 2013

January, 2013 10,410
December, 2012 8,168
= 18,578 kills

So we killed more in two months earning our medal, then in four months that it took the Caldari to earn theirs.

Please tell me again how we didn't earn our medal but that you guys earned yours?
Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#124 - 2013-02-01 03:13:29 UTC
chatgris wrote:
Cearain wrote:
If so, please give the argument you offered countering the people who have expressed negative views regarding value of this medal. Because in the meantime your post appears to just say "this person doesn't agree with me so I will call him a "whiner" and tell him to stop crying."


Unlike the last time a medal was achieved for warzone control, we actually had to kick the Caldari out of all their home systems in the FW warzone. This led to quite fierce fighting, the peak of which was around the clock in Rakapas.

Yes, plexing was still a pve activity in systems people didn't care about docking in. But those that cared, regardless of timezone, could participate, again unlike the previous one.

At the very least, this medal represents a "we kicked your asses out of FW space, even your home systems could not hold" pvp achievement.



I wasn't sayign this is less deserving than the caldari medal. I was saying both medals are for a carebear race.

But if you want to compare it appears sov war is even more of a pve activity:

http://www.eve-search.com/thread/1098959-0/page/3#85

We can see that Caldari were getting plexing at the rate of 74.24 vp per kill.

Current fw stats show Gallente receive 170k vp last week. divide that by 7 and we get 24,285 vp per day. Gallente had 2625 kills per week or 375 kills per day. However CCP reduced the amount of vp per plex to 20% of what it was. So in reality Gallente did a whopping 121425 vp worth of plexing per day. Divide that by 375 and you get 323.8 vp per kill. 4.3 xs fewer kills per plex.

Given that there was no actual benefit for cross plexing it probably did not exist as much back then as it does now. Since cross plexing vp does not show up the actual relation between vp and kills is likely even worse than these numbers show.

This shows that sov war is dramatically more of a pve activity than it used to be.

Unfortunately the way they count players has changed so we can't really compare that.

Certainly as far as pve game the current one is better. But a medal for pve has value only as a collectors item. Not really demonstrating something the community as a whole thinks is meritorious.

I know allot of people ahve given up on the fw sov game, as doomed to be this carebear race. I haven't. So I will keep pushing for changes until it is something worthwhile.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

March rabbit
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#125 - 2013-02-01 12:48:57 UTC
Colt Blackhawk wrote:
Congrats gals.
...
Congrats. We now know who is biggest carebear alliance in eve^^

you said it like this is somehow bad Shocked

The Mittani: "the inappropriate drunked joke"

Destru Kaneda
Arzad Police Department
#126 - 2013-02-01 14:19:52 UTC
Congratulations Gallente, well deserved.

The bitter in this thread is astonishing, not to mention out of place and pathetic.

PS: Farmers flood to whatever side it's easier to deplex for (look at how we're hemorrhaging after Amarr started steamrolling Metro). Defensive plexing doesn't win the war, sure it helps, but ultimately you need to win fights. By your own account farmers don't fight, so they're of very little use when the frontline pushes occur. To put it bluntly, all you needed to do to prevent Gallente from accomplishing this feat was to beat them when it mattered. And you didn't. Now shake their hands like a man.
Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#127 - 2013-02-01 17:06:06 UTC
Dread Operative wrote:
Caldari Medal - Awarded June 2009

June, 2009 4,016
May, 2009 4,165
April, 2009 4,009
March, 2009 3,432
= 15,622 kills

Gallente Medal - Awarded January 2013

January, 2013 10,410
December, 2012 8,168
= 18,578 kills

So we killed more in two months earning our medal, then in four months that it took the Caldari to earn theirs.

Please tell me again how we didn't earn our medal but that you guys earned yours?


There are now likely more pilots active in faction war so the overall kills may go up, even though the sov war involves less pvp. How they calculate the number of pilots changed kills per player are impossible to calculate.

The key is Gallente captured @ 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari did. This suggests that fw occupancy is even more pve than it was when caldari capped all the systems. The numbers show the changes just made it worse for those who wanted sov to be focused on pvp.




Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Dread Operative
Lowlife.
Snuffed Out
#128 - 2013-02-01 18:51:34 UTC
Cearain wrote:
Dread Operative wrote:
Caldari Medal - Awarded June 2009

June, 2009 4,016
May, 2009 4,165
April, 2009 4,009
March, 2009 3,432
= 15,622 kills

Gallente Medal - Awarded January 2013

January, 2013 10,410
December, 2012 8,168
= 18,578 kills

So we killed more in two months earning our medal, then in four months that it took the Caldari to earn theirs.

Please tell me again how we didn't earn our medal but that you guys earned yours?


There are now likely more pilots active in faction war so the overall kills may go up, even though the sov war involves less pvp. How they calculate the number of pilots changed kills per player are impossible to calculate.

The key is Gallente captured @ 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari did. This suggests that fw occupancy is even more pve than it was when caldari capped all the systems. The numbers show the changes just made it worse for those who wanted sov to be focused on pvp.





Nope. Because it wasn't a gradual increase. From 2009 to 2012 the number of kills are consistent, between 4k to 6k kills. It wasn't till Decemeber when DnD made the thread of our intentions did the number double and then triple into January.
Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#129 - 2013-02-01 19:25:42 UTC  |  Edited by: Cearain
Dread Operative wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Dread Operative wrote:
Caldari Medal - Awarded June 2009

June, 2009 4,016
May, 2009 4,165
April, 2009 4,009
March, 2009 3,432
= 15,622 kills

Gallente Medal - Awarded January 2013

January, 2013 10,410
December, 2012 8,168
= 18,578 kills

So we killed more in two months earning our medal, then in four months that it took the Caldari to earn theirs.

Please tell me again how we didn't earn our medal but that you guys earned yours?


There are now likely more pilots active in faction war so the overall kills may go up, even though the sov war involves less pvp. How they calculate the number of pilots changed kills per player are impossible to calculate.

The key is Gallente captured @ 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari did. This suggests that fw occupancy is even more pve than it was when caldari capped all the systems. The numbers show the changes just made it worse for those who wanted sov to be focused on pvp.





Nope. Because it wasn't a gradual increase. From 2009 to 2012 the number of kills are consistent, between 4k to 6k kills. It wasn't till Decemeber when DnD made the thread of our intentions did the number double and then triple into January.


I'm not sure what you are disagreeing with.

I think you gallente captured all the systems on january 12th. Most of January's kills were after the fact.

Second As you gained systems you gained players. You can see and the big spike in the number of gallente pilots in january on this graph:

http://facwarstats.appspot.com/

You went rom 3664 on jan 9th to 4394 on january 14th and ended january with 4889. With that many mroe pilots one would expect the kills to go from 6k to 10k.

Where are you getting your statistics btw?

Like I said yes the number of kills has gone up as the number of players has gone up. But for someone who was hoping they would make fw sov a pvp game the numbers suggest they went the opposite way.

Gallente were capturing 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari were. This is the best data we have on this issue, and it strongly suggests that the sov war is much less of a pvp game than it was years ago.

edit: as of today it is showing Gallente had 2763 kills last week. Clearly this is after the push for sov yet it equates to 11,973 kills per month. So it should be clear that the increase in pvp had more to to with the increase in numbers of pilots than with any sort of sov push.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Irya Boone
The Scope
#130 - 2013-02-01 21:01:01 UTC
Just remember caldari won their medal because of ewar ..... Been balanced since.... So....Cry

CCP it's time to remove Off Grid Boost and Put Them on Killmail too, add Logi on killmails .... Open that damn door !!

you shall all bow and pray BoB

Dread Operative
Lowlife.
Snuffed Out
#131 - 2013-02-02 03:50:21 UTC
Cearain wrote:
Dread Operative wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Dread Operative wrote:
Caldari Medal - Awarded June 2009

June, 2009 4,016
May, 2009 4,165
April, 2009 4,009
March, 2009 3,432
= 15,622 kills

Gallente Medal - Awarded January 2013

January, 2013 10,410
December, 2012 8,168
= 18,578 kills

So we killed more in two months earning our medal, then in four months that it took the Caldari to earn theirs.

Please tell me again how we didn't earn our medal but that you guys earned yours?


There are now likely more pilots active in faction war so the overall kills may go up, even though the sov war involves less pvp. How they calculate the number of pilots changed kills per player are impossible to calculate.

The key is Gallente captured @ 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari did. This suggests that fw occupancy is even more pve than it was when caldari capped all the systems. The numbers show the changes just made it worse for those who wanted sov to be focused on pvp.





Nope. Because it wasn't a gradual increase. From 2009 to 2012 the number of kills are consistent, between 4k to 6k kills. It wasn't till Decemeber when DnD made the thread of our intentions did the number double and then triple into January.


I'm not sure what you are disagreeing with.

I think you gallente captured all the systems on january 12th. Most of January's kills were after the fact.

Second As you gained systems you gained players. You can see and the big spike in the number of gallente pilots in january on this graph:

http://facwarstats.appspot.com/

You went rom 3664 on jan 9th to 4394 on january 14th and ended january with 4889. With that many mroe pilots one would expect the kills to go from 6k to 10k.

Where are you getting your statistics btw?

Like I said yes the number of kills has gone up as the number of players has gone up. But for someone who was hoping they would make fw sov a pvp game the numbers suggest they went the opposite way.

Gallente were capturing 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari were. This is the best data we have on this issue, and it strongly suggests that the sov war is much less of a pvp game than it was years ago.

edit: as of today it is showing Gallente had 2763 kills last week. Clearly this is after the push for sov yet it equates to 11,973 kills per month. So it should be clear that the increase in pvp had more to to with the increase in numbers of pilots than with any sort of sov push.


Evekill Stats. And the numbers went towards non contributing farmers more then actually PVP entities. Shoot I have 2 deplexing accounts even. Take a look at most violent systems for the month of January. All of them were where major Caldari strong holds were. Now I am not saying sovereign is pve, because it is everywhere in eve. This was mostly directed at those saying that we didn't earn it and it was earned with "great fights" in 2009.
BloodBird
The Crucible.
#132 - 2013-02-02 10:25:04 UTC
Cearain wrote:


Hello Mr. Alt.


Starting right off the bat with what you hoped was an insult. Lame, but I can forgive your ignorance however, I have not been around much on this toon for quite a while, after all.

Cearain wrote:
Your post is illogical with respect to the problems raised about the fw sov mechanics.


My arguments are not illogical in regards to the FW mechanics - FW mechanics are irrelevant to my point.

You don't like the mechanics. To bad. They are in place, and unless you make constructive ideas in the right places (hint: not in this tread) there is little that will be done to alter them. If they get changed? GREAT. If not, you will have to soldier on and deal.

Or alternatively, quit either the game or FW. My point was that no matter what option you pick between those two whining in here will have no effect beyond irritating your fellow players and/or wasting everyone's time, yours included. Loud whining on the forums is not worth paying for your sub to do, so you and everyone else who engage in this, should decide what options to pursue between gritting your teeth and moving on even when on the low-end, or quit FW and/or EVE for greener pastures.

Cearain wrote:
But perhaps I misunderstood. If so, please give the argument you offered countering the people who have expressed negative views regarding value of this medal. Because in the meantime your post appears to just say "this person doesn't agree with me so I will call him a "whiner" and tell him to stop crying."


The people expressing negative views about the 'value' of this medal are frankly and simply, only complaining that they lost. They won't allow their 'enemy' to have a victory without trying their best to make it feel hollow and cheap. This is impossible for a variety of reasons that have been pointed out several times.

The FEDEF Victory medal was earned with lots of honest game-play. People logged on, got on coms, got in fleets, plexed, blew stuff up, got blown up, went back for rounds 2-3-4-5, moved on, fought for the next system, defeated the enemy, constantly reported enemy movements, acted on those, deflected Pirate fleets, fought pirate fleets, chased out farmers, installed their own, and so on, and so forth, etc. etc.

In the end, since the termination of artificial advantages like the impossible-to-block perma-jamming of the Caldari NPC's, the missile spam that reach to hundreds of km even with light missiles and rockets, and the worthlessness of taking space at all, FEDEF players finally found themselves on an even playing field, doing what they loved and this helped motivate them to log in every day and play the game as well as they could.

They fleeted together, fought together, died together, returned together, fought together again, and won together. And they earned it, and to top it all off, now there are more people to fight, so they keep logging in, fighting and having fun.

Why the hell can't all of you who complain so much in here just do that instead?

BloodBird
The Crucible.
#133 - 2013-02-02 10:25:16 UTC
Cearain wrote:
There may be others who agree with you and are happy the fw sov is a carebear race and they may give you a thumbs up. But that doesn't mean your post has any worth.

You may be happy with fw as a carebear race. That is your opinion. But just telling people who don't share your view to stop posting will only get positive reactions from idiots.


My my, aren't we bitter. a "carebear race"? So that's what you want to claim now, all the FEDEF players are carebears?

Do you even know what a carebear is and what the term mean in EVE Online?

Granted its been used so much that the term is nearly useless now, but when I was a wee little noob, "Carebear" was a negative term for PVP averse, industry minded players. Players whose enjoyment of the game stemmed SOLELY from loads of PVE. Mining, missioning, ratting, that sort of thing. A Carebear would typically run off as soon as any PVP came knocking on their door. Many PVP minded players hate that, but they usually fail to realize that players who pay for this game can play the game as they please, and the people who enjoy PVP and PVE in equal measure don't fit the term. Your average FEDEF player then can't be carebears - they do to much PVP for that to be even remotely true.

No matter, let's get to the important part relevant to FW.

You obviously mean to whine about plex farmers, especially FEDEF ones. Those are in all the factions, and if you want to claim to have never seen one in the Caldari or Amarr FW camps you are either intentionally ignoring them, or are lying through your teeth to us about them.

Farmers, being carebears, usually try to avoid PVP to go for the most profit. They move around alot. Through space and the various militias. I recall Caldari had loads of plexing alts running around. I ESPECIALLY recall the period when you did not have to shoot one measly little rat and could just orbit the button for your victory. Yeah that was BAD.

Finally, having again pointed out my advice for you and why the medal earned was indeed well earned, and why claiming the FEDEF is the 'carebear faction' is idiotic, I will finish this with a short bit of objective truth.

Carebears are omnipresent in EVE online.

You likely know this as well as I do. There is hardly a single part of EVE online they are not part of, and FW is no exception. Complaining about them will not stop them. You will need to find ways to cope. If the Amarr were winning plenty of ground the farmers would be joining them to leech of their progress. Many of them have leeched of the Caldari, Minmatar and Federal players all in turn. You can not stop this with any game mechanic - so long as there are ways to fight in FW and gains to be had, they will be there, the eye-sore you can't get rid off.

For your own sake, I hope you can get past the issue of farmers and play the game without all this drama. Most of the FEDEF seem to manage, after all.
Mutnin
SQUIDS.
#134 - 2013-02-02 10:40:02 UTC
Dread Operative wrote:
Caldari Medal - Awarded June 2009

June, 2009 4,016
May, 2009 4,165
April, 2009 4,009
March, 2009 3,432
= 15,622 kills

Gallente Medal - Awarded January 2013

January, 2013 10,410
December, 2012 8,168
= 18,578 kills

So we killed more in two months earning our medal, then in four months that it took the Caldari to earn theirs.

Please tell me again how we didn't earn our medal but that you guys earned yours?


umm lets get real here FW was very different back then..
Andreus Ixiris
Center for Advanced Studies
Gallente Federation
#135 - 2013-02-02 11:24:52 UTC
Mutnin wrote:
umm lets get real here FW was very different back then..


Wow, you'll use literally any excuse, won't you?

Andreus Ixiris > A Civire without a chin is barely a Civire at all.

Pieter Tuulinen > He'd be Civirely disadvantaged, Andreus.

Andreus Ixiris > ...

Andreus Ixiris > This is why we're at war.

Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#136 - 2013-02-02 13:58:49 UTC
Dread Operative wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Dread Operative wrote:
Cearain wrote:
Dread Operative wrote:
Caldari Medal - Awarded June 2009

June, 2009 4,016
May, 2009 4,165
April, 2009 4,009
March, 2009 3,432
= 15,622 kills

Gallente Medal - Awarded January 2013

January, 2013 10,410
December, 2012 8,168
= 18,578 kills

So we killed more in two months earning our medal, then in four months that it took the Caldari to earn theirs.

Please tell me again how we didn't earn our medal but that you guys earned yours?


There are now likely more pilots active in faction war so the overall kills may go up, even though the sov war involves less pvp. How they calculate the number of pilots changed kills per player are impossible to calculate.

The key is Gallente captured @ 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari did. This suggests that fw occupancy is even more pve than it was when caldari capped all the systems. The numbers show the changes just made it worse for those who wanted sov to be focused on pvp.





Nope. Because it wasn't a gradual increase. From 2009 to 2012 the number of kills are consistent, between 4k to 6k kills. It wasn't till Decemeber when DnD made the thread of our intentions did the number double and then triple into January.


I'm not sure what you are disagreeing with.

I think you gallente captured all the systems on january 12th. Most of January's kills were after the fact.

Second As you gained systems you gained players. You can see and the big spike in the number of gallente pilots in january on this graph:

http://facwarstats.appspot.com/

You went rom 3664 on jan 9th to 4394 on january 14th and ended january with 4889. With that many mroe pilots one would expect the kills to go from 6k to 10k.

Where are you getting your statistics btw?

Like I said yes the number of kills has gone up as the number of players has gone up. But for someone who was hoping they would make fw sov a pvp game the numbers suggest they went the opposite way.

Gallente were capturing 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari were. This is the best data we have on this issue, and it strongly suggests that the sov war is much less of a pvp game than it was years ago.

edit: as of today it is showing Gallente had 2763 kills last week. Clearly this is after the push for sov yet it equates to 11,973 kills per month. So it should be clear that the increase in pvp had more to to with the increase in numbers of pilots than with any sort of sov push.


Evekill Stats. And the numbers went towards non contributing farmers more then actually PVP entities. Shoot I have 2 deplexing accounts even. Take a look at most violent systems for the month of January. All of them were where major Caldari strong holds were. Now I am not saying sovereign is pve, because it is everywhere in eve. This was mostly directed at those saying that we didn't earn it and it was earned with "great fights" in 2009.



Thanks for the information. I wasn't aware that Evekill stats gave the number of kills per miltiia. That is a nice feature. Do they give the number of kills per miltiia back in 2009?

Regardless of sov war concerns there will always be more kills in base systems. If they completely removed the sov aspect this would still be the same.

I'm not sure what you mean when you say:
"And the numbers went towards non contributing farmers more then actually PVP entities."


What do you think of the fact that Gallente are getting a much higher number of kills after they did the sov push than before they did the sov push? See my post above.

Also what do you think of the fact that Gallente are capturing abou 4xs as many plexes per kill as the caldari did? Would you agree that suggests that plexing now is more of a pve game than before?

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#137 - 2013-02-02 14:04:44 UTC
BloodBird wrote:
Cearain wrote:
There may be others who agree with you and are happy the fw sov is a carebear race and they may give you a thumbs up. But that doesn't mean your post has any worth.

You may be happy with fw as a carebear race. That is your opinion. But just telling people who don't share your view to stop posting will only get positive reactions from idiots.


My my, aren't we bitter. a "carebear race"? So that's what you want to claim now, all the FEDEF players are carebears?

Do you even know what a carebear is and what the term mean in EVE Online?

Granted its been used so much that the term is nearly useless now, but when I was a wee little noob, "Carebear" was a negative term for PVP averse, industry minded players. Players whose enjoyment of the game stemmed SOLELY from loads of PVE. Mining, missioning, ratting, that sort of thing. A Carebear would typically run off as soon as any PVP came knocking on their door. Many PVP minded players hate that, but they usually fail to realize that players who pay for this game can play the game as they please, and the people who enjoy PVP and PVE in equal measure don't fit the term. Your average FEDEF player then can't be carebears - they do to much PVP for that to be even remotely true.



Have you been in the plexes to see how many plexxers run at the first sign of a pvper? If you have you would agree that the plexing war is a carebear race. Its not just gallente its all of faction war.

It has only gotten worse after the changes. The number of plexes the gallente capture per kill is about four times higher than the number of plexes the caldari captured per kill back in 2009. Look at my posts where I give links to the data. Or play the game and see how much hide and seek plexing we have now.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815

ALUCARD 1208
Digital Ghosts
Nourv Gate Security Commission
#138 - 2013-02-02 17:59:18 UTC
cearian why write the same **** post after post, thread after thread the issue will not be sorted ccp are done with fw now we all have the system to work by if it bugs u that much dont log in this isnt the thread for ur bleatings try some of the other 100s of threads uv infected with this ****
Cat Casidy
Percussive Diplomacy
Sedition.
#139 - 2013-02-02 18:28:25 UTC
Oh is he still posting? I turned him off a few days ago.

.

Cearain
Plus 10 NV
#140 - 2013-02-02 19:15:41 UTC
ALUCARD 1208 wrote:
cearian why write the same **** post after post, thread after thread the issue will not be sorted ccp are done with fw now we all have the system to work by if it bugs u that much dont log in this isnt the thread for ur bleatings try some of the other 100s of threads uv infected with this ****



Posting some facts about how gallente won this medal seems appropriate for this thread regarding the medal. I am sorry the facts upset you, but that is not my problem.

You and the other fw cheerleaders can stop your whiney tantrums about my posts. I don't really care, but I am not going to post the way you want me to. So you might as well stop shitting up every thread crying about it.

Make faction war occupancy pvp instead of pve https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=53815&#post53815