These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Warfare & Tactics

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
Previous page12
 

LP Store: Changes and New Items

Author
Veshta Yoshida
PIE Inc.
Khimi Harar
#21 - 2013-01-16 20:23:43 UTC
X Gallentius wrote:
Hopefully they get around to timer rollback - it will make it easier to run farmers out.

Should be easy enough to do .. merely an intentional recreation of the good ol' timer bug we all loved so much Big smile
Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#22 - 2013-01-16 20:44:57 UTC
CSM minutes are out. Tags are bein looked at as they are ridiculous. The spawn rate of large plexes are open to debate. Other then that CCp is essentially happy with FW.

There is an eve- wide issue of system occupancy and desirability. That will be addressed separately.
Trinkets friend
Sudden Buggery
Sending Thots And Players
#23 - 2013-01-16 23:17:32 UTC
The tags are a thing I have been chewingg the cud on for a while now.

Given that highsec level 4's are apparently such a broken way of getting fat and rich on LP's (lols, 30K for a Novice in FW guys in 10 mins vs 400 for a level 2 in 8 minutes? Please.), clearly the supply of tags is limited only by the faction penalties for accepting missions vs the faction rats. Mission runners may decline faction missions so as to preserve their ability to fly unmolested around highsec. But i really doubt this is a problem. There are plenty of guys who don't travel more than 3 jumps from their mission hub and do their Jita trading on an alt.

There is a large supply of tags - but, guess what - the supply of certain tags is rare, others are plentiful. The majority of the cost of, for example, a RF 10MN Afterburner 5 run BPC is Imperial Navy Major tags - you get 2-3 per faction mission. No, let me clarify. You get 2-3 per level 4 faction mission - and 6 or so per level 3 faction mission. The drop rate for these important tags in level 3's is greater than level 4's, but since more people do L4's, the supply of said tags is lower.

Did the Navy Major tags drop from FW plexes? Not in any appreciable volume. There was hardly a giant fountain of tags coming from the warzone because 99% of pre-retribution plexing was done by gunless 10MN AB Incursus alts who woulddn't farm the tags. If I did blat the rats, and loot the field, I would often DIAF with the tags in hold. Which tallied up, at most, to 5M ISK. Which implies the supply from FW was of trash value tags, not importang Major I's or Sergeant I's.

The importance of these tags is determined by the importance of the faction module in question. RF tracking enhancers, being the only faction TE, are hella expensive because of mission Machs and turret T3's and Incursions. They like AB's require cruiser and BC tags.Hence demand, hence tag demand, etc. Cruiser sized faction gear, also, sells more expensively than BS gear because of T3 cruisers, hence the demand for faction tags in the mid-rank.

However, take for example, some of the faction items like, eg, RF small smartbombs. The tag requirements are insane. Even if you did, perversely, grind level 2's all day long, you would take nearly a year to assemble the hundreds of tags required. No one wants frigate sized smartbombs. And some of the LP costs, when divided out for Level 2's, are absurd, for the size and potency and utility of the module on offfer.

There is also a sink to tags, which can be redeemed directly for cash at certain NPC stations. Which is bad for 2 reasons. One, it is an ISK faucet, spawning nett new ISK into the game. Two, it depletes the market of tags. Boohoo, you say? Assuming CCP even attempted constructing the tag drop rate and missions and mission frequency and balanced them out to allow people to collect enough LP's and enough tags to convert and use their LP stores, having a mechanism that takes tags out of circulation outside of the LP store basically stuffs the calculations up.

Finally, some LP stores offer better deals than others. Some, like the Khanid Navy LP store, offer very attractive faction items (eg; KN dissy's, webs, smartbombs) with blindinly stupid tag requirements, given you almost never actually get the taggs required.

The solution?
Keep faction ships in highsec mission hubs. Zarnak could be accused, here, of trying to make FW more lucrative, via ring-fencing faction ships to FW stores. Thiss may work, but there's hardly a lack of LP's available to print SFI's and ONI's. Just look at the price of SFIs recently - the limiting factor here is stabber hulls. 45K LP for an SFI, versus 120K in some hisec stores (plus boatloads of tags, too). Hardly much competiton! it takes FW guys no time to save 600K LP's for a faction BS, but a guy running level 4's...600K is about 100 missions.

Reduce tag requirements for all small items to reasonable levels. Like, 20 tags per item.

Reduce LP requirements ffor small faction items. 79K LP for a 5 run small smartbomb BPC? You're joking, right? Plus literally 1200 tags in one case for a 1MN MWD. I would like to see, for example, an RF 1MN MWD priced to cost around 3-5M ISK via about 3,000-5,000LP and tags. This would require about 10-15 level 2's, and tags. This would take 1 hour of efficient churning, LP wise. Hardly going to get rich doing this!

Look at balancing the tag supply for Ammatar and Khanid. These items are mid-potency, but basically never produced, because their tag and LP costs are high, stupid, and why would you grind the same missions and spend the same time, to get a lesser item? This is why Derelik and Khanid are so sparsely populated! Well, aside from Palas, where people go to grind for Caldari missiles in Khanid space....
ground ctrl
Goose Swarm Coalition
#24 - 2013-01-17 02:57:55 UTC
TF

You make some decent points. But do remember that fw plexing used to indeed drop allot of tags. It wasn't until a month or 2 after inferno that amarr could complete a plex in a gunless frigate. As long as they had target painters amarr had to kill all the rats. I used run major plexes and make about 20 mill per plex in tags about 60 mill per hour. Most faction war pilots have tanked their standings with the enemy militias anyway so i was thinking quite a few tags would come from fw.

Personally I like the added complexity that tags add to the lp stores and I hope they don't do away with them completely. But a revision would be good.


I'm not sure if the fw mission ships drop tags.
Trinkets friend
Sudden Buggery
Sending Thots And Players
#25 - 2013-01-17 13:59:28 UTC
True, but I stand my my assertion that the vast majority of plexes ran for a long time were not harvested for tags. Doubtless there's less coming from FW now - but there isn't much movement in tag prices. Although, to be fair, the odd caldari tags I get on the side from Smash the Slavers are rocketing in price now. Perhaps due to changes in the Gal/Cal warzone, perhaps due to market manipulation. It's a pretty thin market in hek, easily pushed around.

I don't see any great changge in market volumes (admitting I don't go to jita now, so who knows). So there isn't dumping going on.

And as for the FW mission ships - which neutral alt in a 100MN Tengu who is blatting objectives faster than you can say boo, do you know, who sticks around to DPS down all the rats in a FW mission versus warping off and churning another 40 of them every night, ad nauseum? I honestly believe you would be hard pressed to find a single person harvesting tags this way. (also, another gripe, for another thread)
ground ctrl
Goose Swarm Coalition
#26 - 2013-01-17 15:44:24 UTC
Trinkets friend wrote:
True, but I stand my my assertion that the vast majority of plexes ran for a long time were not harvested for tags. Doubtless there's less coming from FW now - but there isn't much movement in tag prices. Although, to be fair, the odd caldari tags I get on the side from Smash the Slavers are rocketing in price now. Perhaps due to changes in the Gal/Cal warzone, perhaps due to market manipulation. It's a pretty thin market in hek, easily pushed around.


There are basically 2 things that could drive the price up or down. The supply and the demand.

Lets first look at supply:

I am not aware of anything changing on the normal missions for collecting tags - at least since moving level 5s to low sec. In faction war its gets pretty hard to tell.

Pre inferno and the first month or 2 of inferno: The minmatar never had to kill the ships in order to plex but did they kill the rats anyway since they were sitting in the timer? I think it varied. The amarr had to kill all the rats or the rats would tp them and likely blow them up. Since we had to blow them up I would usually loot the more valuable tags. But i wouldn't loot the frigates just the ships that might carry tags worth 250k or more

Inferno in the farmville era (?-October 22nd)): They removed ewar so everyone could farm in gunnless frigates. This would seem to decrease the supply of tags

Preretribution where you had to kill all the rats even though lots of rats spawned (october 22-?) : This would seem to give the largest supply of tags. But the price may have gone up due to market speculation. I know I bought a bunch because ccp announced they would decrease the number of rats in plexes.

Finally they removed allot of the npcs altogether: Again this would seem to decrease the supply

Now the demand:


Normal mission loot drops were nerfed so that may have decreased the general demand for tags

In faction war I think the huge glut of lp may have lead to more fw pilots going for some of the items that required tags. Traditionally fw pilots could sell the unique faction war items like ships and fw implants. But the huge glut in lp drove all the fw specific items down in price so other items like say federation navy webs start to become competitive on an isk/lp basis. These other items in the fw store tend to require tags.

BTW: I don't know what conclusions to draw from these changes. I am just tryign to give some input on what changes happened that might have effected the prices up or down.





Trinkets friend wrote:

I don't see any great changge in market volumes (admitting I don't go to jita now, so who knows). So there isn't dumping going on.

And as for the FW mission ships - which neutral alt in a 100MN Tengu who is blatting objectives faster than you can say boo, do you know, who sticks around to DPS down all the rats in a FW mission versus warping off and churning another 40 of them every night, ad nauseum? I honestly believe you would be hard pressed to find a single person harvesting tags this way. (also, another gripe, for another thread)


I don't even know if you can harvest tags this way in fw missions. I honestly haven't tried. But if you could pick up a 5 million isk tag out of every battleship in a fw mission it wouldn't be a bad way to make some money. If there are no tags in the fw missions perhaps ccp should put some tags in there. Players would stay in missions longer and Pirates/enemies could loot the tags if the mission runners run off.
Trinkets friend
Sudden Buggery
Sending Thots And Players
#27 - 2013-01-17 23:58:33 UTC
There is a vastly reduced supply of tags from FW. I just don't see FW as being the largest supply - conventional level 4's in hisec where people salvage is the greatest source. But even there, the mismatch between mission drops and tag:LP dynamics restricts the consumption. Believe me, it is much more efficient to hump conventional missions and loot tags than it is to put yourself at risk in a plex blatting rats. You also make far more ISK sticking to level 4s than trying to top up with FW tags and always have - people in FW are just converting for implants, ammo and ship BPCs - none of which require tags.

Currently exchanging tags for 260M profit for 48K LP's in krusual tribe's LP store, or 60M profit for 16K LP store in Republic Fleet, for example. But that is only on ceertain items. I also get left with thousands upon thousands of useless tags, like midshipman IIs, which lie about the place.

In fact, if I could somehow ONLY get missions vs faction rats, I'd be down for that.
Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#28 - 2013-01-18 17:05:02 UTC
The reason I limited this to the LP store is because I believe FW's time in the sun is over. The CSM minutes seem to support this. We might get some tweaks (more large plexes), but massive revamps after a full year of attention just aren't going to happen. There is currently a thread naught in Jita's park from people who fear a POS revamp might not happen. Other areas of Eve need to get addressed or the game will suffer more then from having some notables not happy with FW. There are enough who think CCP got a solid hit for them to move on.

Now an area that they have not addressed and that would also benefit other areas of the game are the Lp stores. The CSM minute mentioned tags specifically and for that I'm thankful. I would like to see more faction only items in the stores to feed supply and demand. A future rebalance of the lesser FW cruisers, for example (fleet issue scythe anyone?), would help. New tools to assist Militia's in their battle would also be nice. If you don't like my ideas I'm sure there are others out there.
X Gallentius
Black Eagle1
#29 - 2013-01-18 17:11:51 UTC
ground ctrl wrote:

I don't even know if you can harvest tags this way in fw missions. I honestly haven't tried. But if you could pick up a 5 million isk tag out of every battleship in a fw mission it wouldn't be a bad way to make some money.

You can.
Trinkets friend
Sudden Buggery
Sending Thots And Players
#30 - 2013-01-19 03:44:46 UTC
Zarnak, I agree.

People in FW whine continually aand demand fixes, fixes, fixes. Right now, Dust is going to eat CCP's life for the next...well, forever. it is possible it could royally screw FW, just from existing. Certainly in the short term it is doing immeasurable damage to things because the dust modifiers are tipping the balance of plexing/deplexing effort one way or the other - and every militia is suffering because of it. And what can we do? Absolutely nothing, because you can't even coordinate a response. You just lose your key systems due to a 37% modifier to the plex percentage movements you can do nothing about.

Even so, a POS revamp is way overdue. A look at CFC/HBCsec....I mean "bluesec", I mean "nullsec" is urgently required. These are things way more neccessary than FW, which although it has its issues, they are minor.

LP stores are an easy enough fix. In my expert opinion, ofc. Not just FW ones. And its not the supply side, its the prices in terms of tags, for items which clog up the database.

The Scythe Fleet and other 'tier 1' navy cruisers will probably get a balance pass after Fozzie screws the pooch by adjusting the EHP and slot layouts on BS's as an alleged fix for what ails them versus tackling the root cause of the problem (ie; sig-speed-gun resolution-tracking algotithms which are so laughably bad I am selling my BSs).

So, yes. Cearain and alts can shut it, as far as I'm concerned, because his complaints are self-indulgent solipsistic twaddle.
Zarnak Wulf
Task Force 641
Empyrean Edict
#31 - 2013-01-19 04:12:27 UTC
I was laughing as I googled webster's dictionary...
Tsobai Hashimoto
State War Academy
Caldari State
#32 - 2013-01-20 02:24:30 UTC
i think we need a whole new take on tags and mix it in with a concept along the new bounty system


each faction lp store should take tags in exchange for "valor points" "bounty points" whatever name you wamt

a faction would take a type of tag. ie amarr factions would take bloodraiders and minnies....maybe gal?


each tag is worth a set amount of points. they are saved up like lp and the store items dont take tags. but a number of valor points


this makes all tags equal in a way


so a midshipmen 1 might give 3 points and a midshipmen 2 gives 4. while some high fleet commamder gives 50 etc



then that item that wants a mix of 80 low end tags. now just wants 375 valor points plus the lp and isk


the market trades might get more stable. as the isk would be based on points given and for what stores
Previous page12