These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

EVE General Discussion

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Pulling the Plug on WiS

First post First post First post
Author
Juno Valerii
Federal Navy Academy
Gallente Federation
#761 - 2013-01-12 17:51:57 UTC
While the idea of WiS does intrigue me, STO has had toons running around in stations since launch and to be honest I don't think we're missing that here. if by some chance the project should be revitalized then great but for now I'm content with my toon being merely a blueprint for my avatar.
Ghazu
#762 - 2013-01-12 17:55:50 UTC
Natsett Amuinn wrote:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/6gtNI.jpg[/IMG]

That's my EVE, 99% of the time I'm playing.

I don't actually play EVE that much, and there are a lot of people like me playing EVE. We'd really love it if we atually got that other part of the game we were promised many, many years ago.

You can ask me any day, at any time, "show us what you're doing in EVE" and it would look exactly like that screenshot.

Being able to just walk around a station and emote would be a huge firgging deal to people like me, and I"m not as small a minority as people would think. I'm not an RPer, I don't want barbies, I'm just a dude that started EVE in '05. I don't really want to fly spaceships all that much anymore.

I have time I'd love to spend doing things in EVE, but I have nothing to actually do outside of staring at what you see in that screenshot.

I want meaningful, but I would elated to get simple that eventually turns into meaningful.


If you fly in space a lot, and enjoy it, then you probably won't relate.
The only reason I"m still with EVE is because when I got tired of doing one thing, I had other things to do. Once you get tired of running around killing mobs in WoW, you don't have much to move on to.

Unfortunetly a big part of industry and the market doesn't really provide a lot of engaging gameplay. It would be much more enjoyable to do something on a station and look at that screenshot every now and then.

Instead, I only have that screenshot to look at.

wow you literally want to emote with a bunch of dudes in a pretend bar on your computer screen gtfo.

http://www.minerbumping.com/ lol what the christ https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=2299984#post2299984

oldbutfeelingyoung
Perkone
Caldari State
#763 - 2013-01-12 18:10:13 UTC
Ghazu wrote:

wow you literally want to emote with a bunch of dudes in a pretend bar on your computer screen gtfo.



Keep trying Ghazu ,maybe you succeed .

Maybe that i am the most pessimistic guy lately ,when it comes to WIS and Team Absent and their management ,but reading the different WIS threads lately ,it makes me clear that there are more Barbielovers as you call them ,then ever before.

So instead of saluting ,i emote you , Mr or Mrs Ghazu

R.S.I2014

Natsett Amuinn
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#764 - 2013-01-12 18:16:12 UTC
Ghazu wrote:
Natsett Amuinn wrote:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/6gtNI.jpg[/IMG]

That's my EVE, 99% of the time I'm playing.

I don't actually play EVE that much, and there are a lot of people like me playing EVE. We'd really love it if we atually got that other part of the game we were promised many, many years ago.

You can ask me any day, at any time, "show us what you're doing in EVE" and it would look exactly like that screenshot.

Being able to just walk around a station and emote would be a huge firgging deal to people like me, and I"m not as small a minority as people would think. I'm not an RPer, I don't want barbies, I'm just a dude that started EVE in '05. I don't really want to fly spaceships all that much anymore.

I have time I'd love to spend doing things in EVE, but I have nothing to actually do outside of staring at what you see in that screenshot.

I want meaningful, but I would elated to get simple that eventually turns into meaningful.


If you fly in space a lot, and enjoy it, then you probably won't relate.
The only reason I"m still with EVE is because when I got tired of doing one thing, I had other things to do. Once you get tired of running around killing mobs in WoW, you don't have much to move on to.

Unfortunetly a big part of industry and the market doesn't really provide a lot of engaging gameplay. It would be much more enjoyable to do something on a station and look at that screenshot every now and then.

Instead, I only have that screenshot to look at.

wow you literally want to emote with a bunch of dudes in a pretend bar on your computer screen gtfo.

Said the guy with the female avatar gtfo?

What do you do in EVE?
Ghazu
#765 - 2013-01-12 18:48:18 UTC
Natsett Amuinn wrote:
Ghazu wrote:
Natsett Amuinn wrote:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/6gtNI.jpg[/IMG]

That's my EVE, 99% of the time I'm playing.

I don't actually play EVE that much, and there are a lot of people like me playing EVE. We'd really love it if we atually got that other part of the game we were promised many, many years ago.

You can ask me any day, at any time, "show us what you're doing in EVE" and it would look exactly like that screenshot.

Being able to just walk around a station and emote would be a huge firgging deal to people like me, and I"m not as small a minority as people would think. I'm not an RPer, I don't want barbies, I'm just a dude that started EVE in '05. I don't really want to fly spaceships all that much anymore.

I have time I'd love to spend doing things in EVE, but I have nothing to actually do outside of staring at what you see in that screenshot.

I want meaningful, but I would elated to get simple that eventually turns into meaningful.


If you fly in space a lot, and enjoy it, then you probably won't relate.
The only reason I"m still with EVE is because when I got tired of doing one thing, I had other things to do. Once you get tired of running around killing mobs in WoW, you don't have much to move on to.

Unfortunetly a big part of industry and the market doesn't really provide a lot of engaging gameplay. It would be much more enjoyable to do something on a station and look at that screenshot every now and then.

Instead, I only have that screenshot to look at.

wow you literally want to emote with a bunch of dudes in a pretend bar on your computer screen gtfo.

Said the guy with the female avatar gtfo?

What do you do in EVE?

oh hey you really got me there, now tell me how it's a "big deal" for "people like you" to emote in their avatars.

http://www.minerbumping.com/ lol what the christ https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=2299984#post2299984

Ghazu
#766 - 2013-01-12 18:54:24 UTC
i don't do much in game now since there's no war and sigs are sorta inactive.

http://www.minerbumping.com/ lol what the christ https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=2299984#post2299984

Ghazu
#767 - 2013-01-12 18:55:16 UTC
oh wow look at that https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=193051&find=unread

http://www.minerbumping.com/ lol what the christ https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=2299984#post2299984

Scatim Helicon
State War Academy
Caldari State
#768 - 2013-01-12 20:52:48 UTC
Ghazu wrote:
i don't do much in game now since there's no war and sigs are sorta inactive.

This just means you're in the wrong sigs.

Every time you post a WiS thread, Hilmar strangles a kitten.

Celly Smunt
Neutin Local LLC
#769 - 2013-01-13 04:09:45 UTC
Juno Valerii wrote:
While the idea of WiS does intrigue me, STO has had toons running around in stations since launch and to be honest I don't think we're missing that here. if by some chance the project should be revitalized then great but for now I'm content with my toon being merely a blueprint for my avatar.



I actually have a lifetime sub to STO (from the "pre-order" days) and the running around and dealing with consoles and crap is fun, but getting in the ship and flying it is fun too.

I would like to see some of that here in EvE, but not if it ever detracts from our spaceships...

That's also why I very rarely ever even log into that game any more.

o/
Celly

Don't mistake fact for arrogance, supposition for fact, or disagreement for dismissal. Perception is unique in that it can be shared or singular. Run with the pack if you wish, but think for yourself. A sandwich can be a great motivator.

Scatim Helicon
State War Academy
Caldari State
#770 - 2013-01-13 09:00:59 UTC
Natsett Amuinn wrote:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/6gtNI.jpg[/IMG]

That's my EVE, 99% of the time I'm playing.

I don't actually play EVE that much, and there are a lot of people like me playing EVE. We'd really love it if we atually got that other part of the game we were promised many, many years ago.

You can ask me any day, at any time, "show us what you're doing in EVE" and it would look exactly like that screenshot.

Being able to just walk around a station and emote would be a huge firgging deal to people like me, and I"m not as small a minority as people would think. I'm not an RPer, I don't want barbies, I'm just a dude that started EVE in '05. I don't really want to fly spaceships all that much anymore.


Your argument is basically "I don't really like Eve any more and I want to play a game other than Eve, but without having to log into a game that isn't Eve."

I'm sure someone has created a space station themed social environment for Second Life that you could walk around in and emote to your heart's content, why do you argue that CCP needs to spend millions of dollars and months of development time playing catchup to Linden Lab when they could be developing Eve along its own path?

Every time you post a WiS thread, Hilmar strangles a kitten.

Sura Sadiva
Entropic Tactical Crew
#771 - 2013-01-13 12:48:58 UTC
Scatim Helicon wrote:
[quote=Natsett Amuinn]
why do you argue that CCP needs to spend millions of dollars and months of development time playing catchup to Linden Lab when they could be developing Eve along its own path?


Point is just: WiS IS along EvE's own path. Always been. It's a strategic feauture in EvE core design and DNA almost since the game release; as often happens has been implemented poorly and badly and need iterations.

What is not in EvE's path is having this core feauture released as something totally separated in respect of the main gameplay, with no chance to interact/integegrate with it and restricted by a stupid item mall.

Then, yes, an iteration/redesign of WiS as gameplay interacting and integrating with EvE main gameplay is challenging; but it's just the ability to deal with this kind of challenges rthat made EvE a great game surviving so long.

Then, yes, we can say CCP shouldn't do nothing but continue to tweek ships in a neverending nerf/buff loop, and yes, this requires no effort and no risks for CCP but will not last long, to survive the game needs to evolve, attract new players and develop brand new options. Needs to adapt or die.





Ghazu
#772 - 2013-01-13 12:54:06 UTC
Sura Sadiva wrote:
Scatim Helicon wrote:
[quote=Natsett Amuinn]
why do you argue that CCP needs to spend millions of dollars and months of development time playing catchup to Linden Lab when they could be developing Eve along its own path?


Point is just: WiS IS along EvE's own path. Always been. It's a strategic feauture in EvE core design and DNA almost since the game release; as often happens has been implemented poorly and badly and need iterations.

What is not in EvE's path is having this core feauture released as something totally separated in respect of the main gameplay, with no chance to interact/integegrate with it and restricted by a stupid item mall.

Then, yes, an iteration/redesign of WiS as gameplay interacting and integrating with EvE main gameplay is challenging; but it's just the ability to deal with this kind of challenges rthat made EvE a great game surviving so long.

Then, yes, we can say CCP shouldn't do nothing but continue to tweek ships in a neverending nerf/buff loop, and yes, this requires no effort and no risks for CCP but will not last long, to survive the game needs to evolve, attract new players and develop brand new options. Needs to adapt or die.






Oh wow I need to adapt to dudes emoting or die?

http://www.minerbumping.com/ lol what the christ https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=2299984#post2299984

Arduemont
Rotten Legion
#773 - 2013-01-13 15:28:20 UTC  |  Edited by: Arduemont
Ghazu wrote:

Oh wow I need to adapt to dudes emoting or die?


This dudes emoting stuff was old the first time you did it. And no, that's not what they said anyway.

Scatim Helicon wrote:

Your argument is basically "I don't really like Eve any more and I want to play a game other than Eve, but without having to log into a game that isn't Eve."

I'm sure someone has created a space station themed social environment for Second Life that you could walk around in and emote to your heart's content, why do you argue that CCP needs to spend millions of dollars and months of development time playing catchup to Linden Lab when they could be developing Eve along its own path?


And your argument would imply you don't want anything new in Eve at all. If you follow your logic then anything that anyone wants in the game shouldn't be there because they could just play another game to get it. You could say exactly the same for any new FiS content that people ask for. Want new POSes that you can build from scratch to do exactly what you need them to do, and be customisable and individual? Go play mine-craft, you can build stuff in much more detail there.

Ultimately, what people want in the game is important, because the developers base their changes on what their customer base wants. That's how good marketing works. You can't tell people not to ask for what they want because they can get is somewhere else. They don't want to play second life, they want a space sim.

Don't get me wrong, I want CCP to work on meaningful WiS content, with impact on the FiS word that matches most of the other content. But that doesn't exclude the idea of people actually being able to walk around in relatively peaceful environments.

"In the age of information, ignorance is a choice." www.stateofwar.co.nf

Ghazu
#774 - 2013-01-13 16:27:23 UTC  |  Edited by: Ghazu
Arduemont wrote:
Ghazu wrote:

Oh wow I need to adapt to dudes emoting or die?


This dudes emoting stuff was old the first time you did it. And no, that's not what they said anyway.

Scatim Helicon wrote:

Your argument is basically "I don't really like Eve any more and I want to play a game other than Eve, but without having to log into a game that isn't Eve."

I'm sure someone has created a space station themed social environment for Second Life that you could walk around in and emote to your heart's content, why do you argue that CCP needs to spend millions of dollars and months of development time playing catchup to Linden Lab when they could be developing Eve along its own path?


And your argument would imply you don't want anything new in Eve at all. If you follow your logic then anything that anyone wants in the game shouldn't be there because they could just play another game to get it. You could say exactly the same for any new FiS content that people ask for. Want new POSes that you can build from scratch to do exactly what you need them to do, and be customisable and individual? Go play mine-craft, you can build stuff in much more detail there.

Ultimately, what people want in the game is important, because the developers base their changes on what their customer base wants. That's how good marketing works. You can't tell people not to ask for what they want because they can get is somewhere else. They don't want to play second life, they want a space sim.

Don't get me wrong, I want CCP to work on meaningful WiS content, with impact on the FiS word that matches most of the other content. But that doesn't exclude the idea of people actually being able to walk around in relatively peaceful environments.


Natsett Amuinn wrote:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/6gtNI.jpg[/IMG]

That's my EVE, 99% of the time I'm playing.

I don't actually play EVE that much, and there are a lot of people like me playing EVE. We'd really love it if we atually got that other part of the game we were promised many, many years ago.

You can ask me any day, at any time, "show us what you're doing in EVE" and it would look exactly like that screenshot.

Being able to just walk around a station and emote would be a huge firgging deal to people like me, and I"m not as small a minority as people would think. I'm not an RPer, I don't want barbies, I'm just a dude that started EVE in '05. I don't really want to fly spaceships all that much anymore.

I have time I'd love to spend doing things in EVE, but I have nothing to actually do outside of staring at what you see in that screenshot.

I want meaningful, but I would elated to get simple that eventually turns into meaningful.


If you fly in space a lot, and enjoy it, then you probably won't relate.
The only reason I"m still with EVE is because when I got tired of doing one thing, I had other things to do. Once you get tired of running around killing mobs in WoW, you don't have much to move on to.

Unfortunetly a big part of industry and the market doesn't really provide a lot of engaging gameplay. It would be much more enjoyable to do something on a station and look at that screenshot every now and then.

Instead, I only have that screenshot to look at.

Was just concerned about that bolded part. Meaningful wis yes, emoting lol no.

http://www.minerbumping.com/ lol what the christ https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=2299984#post2299984

Natsett Amuinn
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#775 - 2013-01-13 16:53:20 UTC  |  Edited by: Natsett Amuinn
Scatim Helicon wrote:
Natsett Amuinn wrote:
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/6gtNI.jpg[/IMG]

That's my EVE, 99% of the time I'm playing.

I don't actually play EVE that much, and there are a lot of people like me playing EVE. We'd really love it if we atually got that other part of the game we were promised many, many years ago.

You can ask me any day, at any time, "show us what you're doing in EVE" and it would look exactly like that screenshot.

Being able to just walk around a station and emote would be a huge firgging deal to people like me, and I"m not as small a minority as people would think. I'm not an RPer, I don't want barbies, I'm just a dude that started EVE in '05. I don't really want to fly spaceships all that much anymore.


Your argument is basically "I don't really like Eve any more and I want to play a game other than Eve, but without having to log into a game that isn't Eve."

I'm sure someone has created a space station themed social environment for Second Life that you could walk around in and emote to your heart's content, why do you argue that CCP needs to spend millions of dollars and months of development time playing catchup to Linden Lab when they could be developing Eve along its own path?

I love EVE.

It's more, I wouldn't mind the rest of that stuff that got started like 7 years ago so that I have something other then a bunch of lists to stare at.

Nor am I saying I just want to emote. I'm saying that I'd love the idea of being able to do things like walk into your bar and gambe. Something like that would be better than nothing, and was one of the original ideas behind walking in stations.

I'd like to spend more time playing, but the only thing to do is more flying around.
Think about how many times you hear the "I don't log in anymore except to update my skill Q or if there's a big OP I should be at."

I'm sure CCP doesn't mind that they've got a ton of people who don't really play, just log in for 5 or 10 minutes and then log out, they're still paying each month. I'm also sure CCP would love it if all those people logged in and did stuff.


Like I said way earlier in the thread,
If CCP had been iterating on WiS sinse the relase of Incarna, we'd probably be shooting each other on stations today.

I'm not an RPer, but I"m also not to cool to admit that I do play an RPG. CCP does a great job giving us sandbox tools, they've done a rather poor job over the last decade of providing RP ones.

RP tools can be very valuable. I"m not really sure where so many people here seem to turn there nose up at idea of tools that would support RP in EVE, when pretty much every other MMO I've ever played has had a community that embraces such tools. I never see people telling other in Rift, WoW, EQ2, or any other MMO for asking for more RP tools, no. I usually see the non RPers supporting the RPers, even though they won't actively utilize those sorts of tools.

It's not "emoting", i'ts social interaction on a level that doesnb't exist currently in EVE.
That is never a bad thing in an RPG, it provides more immersion; for a lot of people.

Most peopel are role playing in EVE, unintentionally, and without realizing it.

Even our Dear Leader is playing a role in EVE.
I never say, "I play industry in EVE", I do always refer to myself as "an industrialist" though.
Natsett Amuinn
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#776 - 2013-01-13 17:00:55 UTC
Ghazu wrote:

Was just concerned about that bolded part. Meaningful wis yes, emoting lol no.

Sarcasm is a difficult beast.

Perhaps I should have put "emote" in parenthesis?

Or did we suddenly forget that I've made like a half dozen posts in here saying that I want MORE than emoting, I want MEANINGFUL.

Why in the world would I suddenly do a 180 and ask for nothing more than an extension of our one room cell?


If one iteration gave me the ability to walk around a fully realized station, enter a bar and gamble, and then the next iteration allowed me to shoot the guy I was playing cards with, I would be fine with that.

There's nothing wrong with baby steps, as long as the baby steps keep coming.
That is CCP's development philosophy isn't it? Iterate, iterate, iterate.
But with WiS, they just stopped.


I haven't been waiting a year or two for this, I've been waiting 6 or 7.
Arduemont
Rotten Legion
#777 - 2013-01-13 17:01:42 UTC
Ghazu wrote:

Was just concerned about that bolded part. Meaningful wis yes, emoting lol no.


Yea, except you weren't replying to them.

"In the age of information, ignorance is a choice." www.stateofwar.co.nf

Scatim Helicon
State War Academy
Caldari State
#778 - 2013-01-13 17:50:12 UTC
Sura Sadiva wrote:
Point is just: WiS IS along EvE's own path. Always been. It's a strategic feauture in EvE core design and DNA almost since the game release; as often happens has been implemented poorly and badly and need iterations.

What is not in EvE's path is having this core feauture released as something totally separated in respect of the main gameplay, with no chance to interact/integegrate with it and restricted by a stupid item mall.

Then, yes, an iteration/redesign of WiS as gameplay interacting and integrating with EvE main gameplay is challenging; but it's just the ability to deal with this kind of challenges rthat made EvE a great game surviving so long.

WiS will be a development along Eve's own path when it contains some gameplay that ties into the wider universe, whether that be exploring abandoned station wrecks for rare materials, or sneaking around in a hostile POS to hack the cyno jammer offline, or whatever else can be thought of.

'Social environments' and other such gameplay vacuums aren't a development to progress Eve Online, its an attempt to clone Second Life. The Incarna vision of monocle buying and a single-player room to walk up and down in isn't a development towards anything at all except the destruction of CCP's mostly positive reputation up to that point.

Arduemont wrote:
Scatim Helicon wrote:

Your argument is basically "I don't really like Eve any more and I want to play a game other than Eve, but without having to log into a game that isn't Eve."

I'm sure someone has created a space station themed social environment for Second Life that you could walk around in and emote to your heart's content, why do you argue that CCP needs to spend millions of dollars and months of development time playing catchup to Linden Lab when they could be developing Eve along its own path?


And your argument would imply you don't want anything new in Eve at all. If you follow your logic then anything that anyone wants in the game shouldn't be there because they could just play another game to get it. You could say exactly the same for any new FiS content that people ask for. Want new POSes that you can build from scratch to do exactly what you need them to do, and be customisable and individual? Go play mine-craft, you can build stuff in much more detail there.

That's stupid. Eve doesn't need the POS revamp because there's a playerbase that wants to build Minecraft structures in isolation, it needs the POS revamp because POSs and the activities carried out involving them tie in to huge swathes of the wider Eve universe and the current system is unfit for purpose. If the only reason to re-do POSs was so players could build personalised Minecraft structures that served no further purpose it would be a pointless waste of dev time, much like developing WiS just to make Second Life In Space with no gameplay included would be a pointless waste of dev time.

Quote:
Don't get me wrong, I want CCP to work on meaningful WiS content, with impact on the FiS word that matches most of the other content. But that doesn't exclude the idea of people actually being able to walk around in relatively peaceful environments.

The gameplay content comes first, it has to. If, once CCP have implemented some actual meaningful gameplay to WiS they can use that foundation to give us social environments as well without blowing a massive amount of extra resources in the process, then I'm fine with that and I'm sure most other players would feel the same. In all likelihood much of the work on WiS gameplay will be re-usable fairly painlessly.

What isn't going to fly is if implementing it becomes a massive undertaking and CCP say "sorry guys, we're implementing social environments this time round so the lowsec revamp (or whatever) is going to have to wait another six months".

Every time you post a WiS thread, Hilmar strangles a kitten.

Ghazu
#779 - 2013-01-13 17:53:55 UTC
See that's the problem, prioritization. I don't like this baby steps approach, just look at how many years it took them to redo FW.
Basically wis must be meaningful to exist at all. So meaningless at first then another 5 years of babysteping towards some meaningful gameplay, is not acceptable.

http://www.minerbumping.com/ lol what the christ https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=2299984#post2299984

Natsett Amuinn
Caldari Provisions
Caldari State
#780 - 2013-01-13 17:55:20 UTC
Just to clarify.

Emoting to me is not /wave or /dance.

To me it means being able to move around and interact with the enviroment. Like being able to sit my character in a chair, at a table, and interact with something like a tablet.

I consider emoting to be everything that allows me to make my character look like they're doing something.

I don't think it's fair to call that "meaningless". It's a reason why a not so meaningless number of people play RPG's to begin with.



It's funny.
If you go to the MMORPG.com forums and read threats discussing "what a sandbox is" you'll see the same thing mentioned a lot.

Sandboxes don't have "quests", it should be all player created content. "Quests" are themepark and not a part of "real" sandboxes. Sandboxes revolve around people interacting with one another, and have tools to do that, they should have an RP focus. It's a very vocal point I see made quite often.

However, in EVE, that's like blasphemy. Avatar based social interaction, "emoting", is the devil.