These forums have been archived and are now read-only.

The new forums are live and can be found at https://forums.eveonline.com/

Science & Industry

 
  • Topic is locked indefinitely.
 

Moon Mining: Suicide or ISK faucet?

Author
Albertus Albainn
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#1 - 2013-01-05 01:10:40 UTC  |  Edited by: Albertus Albainn
I've spent the last couple hours pouring over how to establish a moon mining POS. I'm a relatively new player, I fart around in my Mackinaw and make a nice little bit of ISK for myself, but I want to engage in some of the more complex industry gameplay on offer in EVE.

I've read over how to mine moons: One must acquire a control tower, moon harvester, silos, etc, as well having sufficient standing with the sovereign faction that presides over the system . Simple enough. I can also use my Mackinaw to mine ice to help with fuelling the thing, and run an Iteron V for hauling to and from the POS back to my hisec base of operations three jumps away.

But here's my concern: This can only occur in 0.3 space and below. How is it even possible to warp into such a low security system without having the station occupants immediately undock to ruin your day? I PvP in 0.4 space frequently, it takes all of 3 minutes to end up in a fight -- I can't imagine how it's even possible to warp in, scan the moon, transport the gear, set it up, turn it on, all without drawing attention. And once it's set up, it seems like it would be destroyed in a couple days anyway once some gang happens upon it and decides to use it for target practice. I've also read that dominant alliances in the EVE universe kind of run an unwritten monopoly over moons, so if I were to find a decent moon, I feel that my POS would be vaporised even quicker. It all just seems like a dead end unless I'm part of some megacorporation.

Am I being too pessimistic? Is this how it's actually done? I'm in a reasonably well-developed alliance but this was a pet idea that myself and a friend who joined up last week want to undertake. Can a two-man mini-corporation successfully set up and maintain a moon mining POS without having it all blown to pieces and wasting our time? I'm setting aside about 600M isk to start this up... Should I spend it elsewhere?

Thanks all.
o7
Rengerel en Distel
#2 - 2013-01-05 01:40:50 UTC
Albertus Albainn wrote:
I've spent the last couple hours pouring over how to establish a moon mining POS. I'm a relatively new player, I fart around in my Mackinaw and make a nice little bit of ISK for myself, but I want to engage in some of the more complex industry gameplay on offer in EVE.

I've read over how to mine moons: One must acquire a control tower, moon harvester, silos, etc, as well having sufficient standing with the sovereign faction that presides over the system . Simple enough. I can also use my Mackinaw to mine ice to help with fuelling the thing, and run an Iteron V for hauling to and from the POS back to my hisec base of operations three jumps away.

But here's my concern: This can only occur in 0.3 space and below. How is it even possible to warp into such a low security system without having the station occupants immediately undock to ruin your day? I PvP in 0.4 space frequently, it takes all of 3 minutes to end up in a fight -- I can't imagine how it's even possible to warp in, scan the moon, transport the gear, set it up, turn it on, all without drawing attention. And once it's set up, it seems like it would be destroyed in a couple days anyway once some gang happens upon it and decides to use it for target practice. I've also read that dominant alliances in the EVE universe kind of run an unwritten monopoly over moons, so if I were to find a decent moon, I feel that my POS would be vaporised even quicker. It all just seems like a dead end unless I'm part of some megacorporation.

Am I being too pessimistic? Is this how it's actually done? I'm in a reasonably well-developed alliance but this was a pet idea that myself and a friend who joined up last week want to undertake. Can a two-man mini-corporation successfully set up and maintain a moon mining POS without having it all blown to pieces and wasting our time? I'm setting aside about 600M isk to start this up... Should I spend it elsewhere?

Thanks all.
o7


1) You'd never find a moon that was worth it for people to fight you over it. The good ones are already taken.
2) Roaming gangs don't blow up POS for the heck of it, as you have to come back after the reinforcement timer.
3) You can get the stuff into your system yourself, or pay someone else to do it. You set up during a quiet time, hopefully with someone else there keeping an eye out.
4) I really don't know if a 2 man corp can make enough from moon mining to make it worth it. "Worth it" is pretty subjective.

With the increase in shiptoasting, the Report timer needs to be shortened.

La Nariz
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#3 - 2013-01-05 03:01:53 UTC
It's not an isk faucet it does not directly inject isk into the economy. Materials faucet, yes it is this.

This post was loving crafted by a member of the Official GoonWaffe recruitment team. Improve the forums, support this idea: https://forums.eveonline.com/default.aspx?g=posts&find=unread&t=345133

Lord Battlestar
CALIMA COLLABORATIVE
Atrox Urbanis Respublique Abundatia
#4 - 2013-01-05 03:13:51 UTC
If you have lots of friends in the area to help defend your tower it may be worth it, otherwise you might want to try another complicated industry as the locals will eventually come and bust up your operation. Sometimes you can find free moons, but most of the time they are already taken, so you would have to find someone to help you take the control tower down. Most of the time it isn't worth the isk on lower end moons unless you can react them. So in the end it isn't that big of an isk maker unless you got a profitable moon.

I once podded myself by blowing a huge fart.

Spectre Wraith
Darwin Inc.
#5 - 2013-01-05 04:08:53 UTC  |  Edited by: Spectre Wraith
All the moons worth mining are taken (or will be taken when someone scans the moon you're on). And genreally speaking, unless you can adequately setup + maintain as well as defend said pos, expect it to be bashed "for the luls". You're either mining a moon and making a profit (and will likely have the moon taken soon) or you're mining a moon while hemorhaging isk on the pos fuel.

Seriously, if you have to ask others if it's worth doing, you shouldn't be doing it. That pretty much goes for the majority of things in Eve, imho.

Dear lord, please help me deal with the insufferable....

Jason McCoy
Deep Core Mining Inc.
Caldari State
#6 - 2013-01-05 05:56:20 UTC
I run 10 poses ALONE.

7 do simple reactions from materials out of the moons
3 do complex reactions with the simple reactions already completed

The rest goes to the market.

Profit margins are well worth it. Issues problems or what nots? Havent seen one yet.
Dedaf
United Brothers Of Eve
#7 - 2013-01-05 06:31:59 UTC
As most of the other people have written already, you wont find any moons in and around empire that will make profit from just moon mining, the price of the fuel is too high. However running complex reactions is profitable and mining even the cheapest moon material will still improve your profit. And if you set it up right, then one single Caldari tower can do the entire process from moon mining to complex material.
You need to attend the tower each day thought, but if thats the business you are in, then its no big deal.

Try out my POS production tool here, to help you to see which moon material to mine for and see which complex material is most profitable at this moment.

Killing a L tower is no fun i tell you! and not something anyone do just for the fun, so if your tower is on a moon with low end moon material then id say you are fairly safe.

Good luck
Dedaf

Want to know what is best to mine or build at which cost? then try out Dedaf's Industrial Tool http://dedafsindustrialtool.blogspot.dk/

Zoltan Lazar
#8 - 2013-01-05 09:42:22 UTC
Any moon worth mining is being mined on. If you want a pos to make isk, use it to research and produce in highsec. Moons of any sort require an alliance behind them.
RubyPorto
RubysRhymes
#9 - 2013-01-06 03:06:45 UTC  |  Edited by: RubyPorto
Reaction Farms > Extraction Farms as far as personal moon goo income goes. It also circumvents the issue of good moons.

But to really be worthwhile, you're gonna want to have a JF.



Mortimer Civeri wrote:
If you set it up right, it is an ISK faucet, that makes you want to commit suicide.


Really can't emphasize that enough. Even when all your POSes are in one system.

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths." -Abrazzar "the risk of having your day ruined by other people is the cornerstone with which EVE was built" -CCP Solomon

Mortimer Civeri
Aliastra
Gallente Federation
#10 - 2013-01-06 03:14:25 UTC
If you set it up right, it is an ISK faucet, that makes you want to commit suicide.

"I don't know which is worse, ...that everyone has his price, or that the price is always so low." Calvin

Maximilien Noibzo
Viziam
Amarr Empire
#11 - 2013-01-07 13:22:08 UTC
Lots of moons are available in NPC nullsec. Not the best moons, but still some ISK to be made.
If you want to be serious, you will need several towers, a lot of investment (several billions) and a jump freighter to haul "safely" fuel and reacted products. So 'im not sure it's what you wanted to do :D
Solotta Erquilenne
#12 - 2013-01-07 15:03:53 UTC
Albertus Albainn wrote:

But here's my concern: This can only occur in 0.3 space and below. How is it even possible to warp into such a low security system without having the station occupants immediately undock to ruin your day? I PvP in 0.4 space frequently, it takes all of 3 minutes to end up in a fight -- I can't imagine how it's even possible to warp in, scan the moon, transport the gear, set it up, turn it on, all without drawing attention.


Cloaky hauler, but preferably a blockade runner. Load it up with tower and the first cycle of fuel. Go when there's not much activity or people are asleep or near downtime. People don't chill at empty moons for fun, waiting for a viator to uncloak and anchor a tower. All it takes is 2 seconds to launch the tower and set it up. As soon as it starts you can recloak, the tower can't be stolen or stopped, and it has full hitpoints. Once its anchored you have to return to drop some fuel in and online it, but this again only needs a few seconds. Worst case scenario, the locals spot a new tower without a new forcefield on d-scan, and they find your tower before you can start onlining it. Chances are they won't immediately start trying to blow up your tower with battleships/dreads. However, if its an organized pirate corp, its a system where they hang out, and they spot you before you can online it, I wouldn't be surprised if a recon camps the tower to pop you when you put fuel in it, since they'll be able to see your corp name on the tower and you in local, but unless they have a whole gang you'll be able to put the fuel in and hit the 'on' button. After that, they won't be able to stop a blockade runner from getting to the pos to manage it, since you can warp directly into the shields.

One question I have is, how much volume in terms of m3 is required per week for a single reaction tower? as in, 1 week of fuel and 1 week of reaction reagents? That seems like a pretty key figure to know. Its no question that for a large system of reaction towers one would need a jumpfreighter, just wondering how much workit might be possible to do 1-3 towers with only haulers.
Toku Jiang
Jiang Laboratories and Discovery
#13 - 2013-01-07 15:35:27 UTC
It can be done, it can be profitable with reactions, but be prepared to put in the hours. Unless your an every day, several hours a day, player I wouldn't waste my time on it.

If you have the time, then get into a cloak transport ship. I found it was the best way to move around and stay hidden with POS modules, fuel, etc. Also look for a low sec system that is a mission hub/research hub. I know it sounds crazy because there are lots of people in there, but the upshot is that most of those people are too busy to notice your POS and even if they do they don't care about it as they are always looking over their shoulder or looking for quick GF's. It's not to say someone won't decide to nuke your POS for fun, but that can happen anywhere.
Haedonism Bot
People for the Ethical Treatment of Rogue Drones
#14 - 2013-01-07 16:27:26 UTC
You will obviously want to pick a quiet system in lowsex or null to do this. You say that you are used to getting fights within 3 minutes in lowsec, but obviously you must be PvPing in Amemake if that is the case. Most of lowsec is dead empty most of the time. There is always a risk that somebody might take down your POSes, but if they do so it will be because they want those moons for themselves, or because they are desperate to provoke a fight. Nobody takes down a POS for lols. Because it isn't fun, it is just a grind.

www.everevolutionaryfront.blogspot.com

Vote Sabriz Adoudel and Tora Bushido for CSMX. Keep the Evil in EVE!

Tazarak theDeceiver
United Mining and Hauling Inc
The Initiative.
#15 - 2013-01-07 16:52:30 UTC
You do not need to extract a single component to make isk with a complex reactor. Buying all the ingedients still yields profits.

Let ne echo some of the above. I run sonething like 12 towers and PI as much as I can across 6 toons. If it wasnt profitable I'd be considered insane. Some reactions fill a silo every day so it's like watching an infant.
Ronix Aideron
Zymurgy Corp.
#16 - 2013-01-07 19:27:28 UTC
This might be a little off topic but a really inexpensive POS is a customs office for PI. If you can get someone to take out the Interbus station. For ~100 million you can have tax free PI to increase your margins.

Start the day off slow and taper off from there.

http://eveboard.com/pilot/Ronix_Aideron

Akira Menoko
Silnare
#17 - 2013-01-08 21:47:44 UTC
Albertus Albainn wrote:

having sufficient standing with the sovereign faction that presides over the system


This is actually not a problem since your POS will have to be in lowsec, where you don't need faction standings or starbase charters to anchor and run the POS.

Albertus Albainn wrote:

But here's my concern: This can only occur in 0.3 space and below. How is it even possible to warp into such a low security system without having the station occupants immediately undock to ruin your day? I PvP in 0.4 space frequently, it takes all of 3 minutes to end up in a fight -- I can't imagine how it's even possible to warp in, scan the moon, transport the gear, set it up, turn it on, all without drawing attention.


Scanning the moons can be accomplished with a covert ops which, when used properly in lowsec, is extremely difficult to catch and kill. Just make sure that if you launch a survey probe at a moon with a tower that you recloak before the tower locks on to you and shoots you.

Albertus Albainn wrote:

And once it's set up, it seems like it would be destroyed in a couple days anyway once some gang happens upon it and decides to use it for target practice. I've also read that dominant alliances in the EVE universe kind of run an unwritten monopoly over moons, so if I were to find a decent moon, I feel that my POS would be vaporised even quicker. It all just seems like a dead end unless I'm part of some megacorporation.


As people have said before, it is extremely unlikely to be shot at "for the lulz." And if you did happen across a high value vacant moon, then you can count on it being shot up soon if word about it ever gets out. For any of those good moons you definitely need to be a part of a large corporation/alliance capable of fielding a fleet to take and defend that moon. Generally speaking, moons are what large groups fight over.

Low value moons, however, are not likely to get shot up because they aren't worth much or they are so plentiful there are vacant ones to take. Of course these are not very valuable, so it may not be worth your time unless it's part of a profitable reaction, alchemy, or other scheme you have to make isk.

Albertus Albainn wrote:

Am I being too pessimistic? Is this how it's actually done? I'm in a reasonably well-developed alliance but this was a pet idea that myself and a friend who joined up last week want to undertake. Can a two-man mini-corporation successfully set up and maintain a moon mining POS without having it all blown to pieces and wasting our time? I'm setting aside about 600M isk to start this up... Should I spend it elsewhere?


From the management standpoint it's certainly possible for a couple people to setup and run several moons. From a defense standpoint, they won't be able to stop a group who wants to take them. But if the moons are common or low value, then you may not have to for a few months or ever.

Before you set anything up make sure you know how much all of your costs are (usually on a monthly basis), how much you can sell the products for, and what your profit margin is based on this. Don't be one of those people who sell a month's worth of product for 250 million isk, but spend 300-400 million isk to keep the tower running.
Akira Menoko
Silnare
#18 - 2013-01-08 21:51:03 UTC
RubyPorto wrote:

Mortimer Civeri wrote:
If you set it up right, it is an ISK faucet, that makes you want to commit suicide.


Really can't emphasize that enough. Even when all your POSes are in one system.


This is oh so very true.
RubyPorto
RubysRhymes
#19 - 2013-01-08 23:22:04 UTC
Akira Menoko wrote:
Scanning the moons can be accomplished with a covert ops which, when used properly in lowsec, is extremely difficult to catch and kill. Just make sure that if you launch a survey probe at a moon with a tower that you recloak before the tower locks on to you and shoots you.


Prowler > Covops.

But as bad as running a POS farm is, Moon scanning is worse. Which is one of the several reasons why reaction farming is better than extraction if you're not an alliance.

"It's easy to speak for the silent majority. They rarely object to what you put into their mouths." -Abrazzar "the risk of having your day ruined by other people is the cornerstone with which EVE was built" -CCP Solomon

Tauranon
Weeesearch
CAStabouts
#20 - 2013-01-08 23:27:55 UTC
Ran a moon solo for 6 months with a blockade runner. Wouldn't do it again even though there was no shiploss in the process.

JF in my mind is only justified for extracting billionish profits per month, which means several low value moons clustered around a safe station so that a t1 hauler can do the consolidation of loads and fueling. One imagines those just don't really exist unless you are a combat organisation tha I had to take a moon 5 jumps off a station last time as a solo, and can't imagine the state of the universe is better these days with alchemy changes.